Treating thyroid nodules by radiofrequency: is the delivered energy correlated with the volume reduction rate? A pilot study

The Influence of Impedance on the Efficacy of Radiofrequency Ablation for Benign Thyroid Nodules

OBJECTIVE

Radiofrequency ablation (RFA) uses the heat generated by a high-frequency alternating electric current, and according to Ohm's and Joule's law, the delivered current is inversely proportional to the circuit impedance. The primary objective of this study was to investigate whether tissue impedance during radiofrequency ablation (RFA) for benign thyroid nodules is related to the degree of volume reduction.

METHODS

This observational study included consecutive patients treated with RFA for benign thyroid nodules from February 2020 to August 2023. Technical effectiveness was defined as a volume reduction percentage (VRP) >75% at 6 months after the treatment. Multivariate logistic regression analyses were performed to identify the potential role of clinical factors and changes in tissue impedance on technique effectiveness.

RESULTS

Totally 72 patients were included with 73 benign thyroid nodules. Maximal impedance peaks reached <18 times, and mean procedural impedance ≤300 Ω were significantly associated with a volume decrease of >75% at bivariate analysis. These cutoff points were exploratory, as no existing literature suggests these variables are related to the degree of volume reduction. After adjusting for age, volume, and composition, significant associations were found for mean electrical impedance in the multivariate analysis (OR = 4.86 [confidence interval [CI] 1.29-18.26], p = 0.019). The energy adjusted by volume (delivered energy) was not associated with a VRP >75% (p = 0.7746).

CONCLUSIONS

This study suggests that a mean procedural impedance

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

3 Laryngoscope, 134:5231-5238, 2024.

Collapse

Key Words

• benign thyroid nodule
• impedance
• minimally invasive techniques
• radiofrequency ablation
• thermal ablation

Collapse

MESH Headings

• Humans
• Thyroid Nodule/surgery
• Female
• Electric Impedance
• Male
• Radiofrequency Ablation/methods
• Middle Aged
• Treatment Outcome
• Adult
• Aged

Collapse

Grants Collapse

Affiliation(s)

Juan Pablo Dueñas Division of Endocrine Surgery, Integral Endocrine Surgery Clinic, Medellin, Colombia
Nathalia Buitrago-Gómez Department of Endocrinology, Universidad Pontificia Bolivariana, Medellin, Colombia
José Hugo Arias-Botero Medicine, CES University, Medellín, Colombia
Gregory Randolph Otolaryngology Head and Neck Surgery, Claire and John Bertucci Endowed Chair in Thyroid Surgical Oncology, Harvard Medical School, Chief Thyroid/Parathyroid Endocrine Surgical Division, Dept Otolaryngology Head and Neck Surgery, Massachusetts Eye and Ear Infirmary, Member Endocrine Surgical Service, Massachusetts General Hospital, President American Academy of Otolaryngology Head and Neck Surgery 2016-17, American Head and Neck Society, Administration Division Chair, International Thyroid Oncology Group (ITOG) President, American College of Surgeons Otolaryngology Governor, Boston, Massachusetts, U.S.A
Marika Russell Division of Thyroid and Parathyroid Endocrine Surgery, Department of Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery, Massachusetts Eye and Ear Infirmary, Harvard Medical School, Boston, Massachusetts, U.S.A
Amr Abdelhamid Ahmed Division of Thyroid and Parathyroid Endocrine Surgery, Department of Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery, Massachusetts Eye and Ear Infirmary, Harvard Medical School, Boston, Massachusetts, U.S.A
Roberto Valcavi Division of Endocrinology, The Endocrine & Thyroid Clinic (ETC), Reggio Emilia, Italy
Carlos Simón Duque Head and Neck Surgeon, Intermedica, Medellin, Colombia
Ralph P Tufano FPG Thyroid and Parathyroid Center, Sarasota Memorial Health Care System, Sarasota, Florida, U.S.A

Collapse

Analysis and prediction of ablation zone absorption in papillary thyroid microcarcinoma undergoing microwave ablation

PURPOSE

This study aims to investigate the factors that influence the absorption of the ablation zone in patients with papillary thyroid microcarcinoma (PTMC) following microwave ablation (MWA) and construct a nomogram for predicting the absorption of the ablation zone.

METHODS

Data from 150 patients with 187 PTMCs who received MWA between April 2020 and April 2023 were analyzed. PTMCs were randomly divided into training and validation sets in a 7:3 ratio. Univariable and multivariable analyses of Cox regression were utilized to identify the independent variables associated with the absorption of the ablation zone in PTMC post-MWA, and a nomogram was established. The discrimination and calibration performance of the nomogram was assessed using the time-dependent receiver operating characteristic curves and calibration curves.

RESULTS

At 12 months post-MWA, a 53% proportion of complete disappearance of the ablation zone was observed. Energy delivered per milliliter of volume measured in contrast-enhanced ultrasound (CEUS) mode immediately post-MWA (Edv) and the CEUS margin at 1-month post-WMA were identified as independently correlated with the ablation zone absorption post-MWA (P = 0.001, P < 0.001 respectively). A nomogram incorporating these two factors was constructed. The areas under the receiver operating characteristic curve were all above 0.78 in the training and validation sets.

CONCLUSION

Edv and the CEUS margin at 1-month post-MWA were found to be significantly associated with complete absorption of the ablation zone in PTMC patients following MWA. The established nomogram can assist practitioners in formulating more appropriate ablation strategies and provide a clinical basis for explaining the recovery status to patients.

Adjustable-tip needles versus fixed-tip needles in radiofrequency ablation of symptomatic benign thyroid nodules: a single-center Italian experience

PURPOSE

In this retrospective, observational study we aim to compare the outcomes of the RFA treatment of benign thyroid nodules, carried out respectively with the standard fixed-needle approach (FTN) and the adjustable-tip needle technique (ATN), considered a more tailored, quicker and easier technical approach.

METHODS

We enrolled 36 patients who underwent RFA treatment of symptomatic, benign, thyroid nodule, 18 with the ATN and 18 with the FTN approach, respectively. Data about absolute volume reduction, volume reduction rate (VRR) and success rate (defined as VRR ≥ 50%), after 1, 3 and 6 months of follow-up were compared.

RESULTS

Our study suggested no substantial difference between the approaches, up to 6 months of follow-up, both in terms of absolute reduction (p = 0.27) and VRR (p = 0.14). These results were confirmed when the success rates, both in terms of 50%-reduction (p = 0.12) and absolute reduction (p = 0.42), was considered. Only at the 6-month evaluation, the FTN procedure showed a better success rate, yet without statistical significance (88.9% vs. 61.1%, p = 0.12). No difference emerged both in terms of patients' satisfaction and safety.

CONCLUSION

Our small experience suggested no substantial difference between ATN and FTN, in terms of outcomes. On the other hand, ATN was considered to be more straightforward and could consequently allow for a shorter operator learning curve.

Model-Optimizing Radiofrequency Parameters of 3D Finite Element Analysis for Ablation of Benign Thyroid Nodules

Radiofrequency (RF) ablation represents an efficient strategy to reduce the volume of thyroid nodules. In this study, a finite element model was developed with the aim of optimizing RF parameters, e.g., input power and treatment duration, in order to achieve the target volume reduction rate (VRR) for a thyroid nodule. RF ablation is modelled as a coupled electro-thermal problem wherein the electric field is applied to induce tissue heating. The electric problem is solved with the Laplace equation, the temperature distribution is estimated with the Pennes bioheat equation, and the thermal damage is evaluated using the Arrhenius equation. The optimization model is applied to RF electrode with different active tip lengths in the interval from 5 mm to 40 mm at the 5 mm step. For each case, we also explored the influence of tumour blood perfusion rate on RF ablation outcomes. The model highlights that longer active tips are more efficient as they require lesser power and shorter treatment time to reach the target VRR. Moreover, this condition is characterized by a reduced transversal ablation zone. In addition, a higher blood perfusion increases the heat dispersion, requiring a different combination of RF power and time treatment to achieve the target VRR. The model may contribute to an improvement in patient-specific RF ablation treatment.

Can Thyroid Nodules be Managed with Radiofrequency Ablation?

Radiofrequency ablation (RFA) is an established and growing minimally-invasive technique with an impressive safety profile used to manage thyroid nodules. Beyond shorter operative and recovery times, the main advantages of RFA include the lack of an incisional scar as well as maximizing the potential for maintenance of normal thyroid function. RFA can significantly reduce nodular volume, achieving rates of 60% to 95% in a breadth of thyroid disease, including benign nodules, primary carcinomas, and recurrent malignancies. Thorough patient counselling is imperative for RFA candidates, including a discussant of complications, nodule regrowth, and the potential for a subsequent ablation session.

Analysis and prediction of regrowth in benign thyroid nodules undergoing radiofrequency ablation: a retrospective study with a 5-year follow-up

OBJECTIVES

To evaluate the 5-year follow-up results of radiofrequency ablation (RFA) for benign thyroid nodules (BTNs), and construct pre- and postablation nomogram models to predict regrowth in BTNs undergoing RFA.

METHODS

According to the occurrence of regrowth, BTNs were divided into two subgroups, the regrowth group and the nonregrowth group, and the variables were compared between these two subgroups. Then, univariate and multivariate Cox regression analyzes were utilized to filter the independent prognostic factors of regrowth, which then were introduced into the pre- and postablation prognostic nomograms, respectively. The discrimination powers and prediction performances of the nomograms were appraised by receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curves and calibration charts.

RESULTS

The 5-year mean volume reduction rate was 88.80%, with a complication rate of 0.35% (7/200). Within 5 years of follow-up, the regrowth rate was 19% (38/200). Pre- and postablation prognostic nomograms were established to predict the probability of nonregrowth at 1, 3, and 5 years after RFA. The preablation nomogram included initial volume, perinodular vascularity, and high enhancement ring. The postablation nomogram incorporated total volume, perinodular vascularity, and energy applied per volume. The area under the ROC curves and concordance index values of these models were all above 0.7, indicating that the prognostic nomograms achieved satisfactory discrimination powers and prediction performances.

CONCLUSION

RFA for BTNs has long-term efficacy and safety under the influence of key techniques. The pre- and postablation nomograms constructed in the present study might facilitate clinical decision-making before RFA and for the follow-up management after RFA.

KEY POINTS

• Perinodular vascularity, rather than intranodular vascularity was an independent predictor of regrowth, both before and after the RFA procedure. • A high enhancement ring on preablation contrast-enhanced ultrasound was an independent predictor of regrowth. • Pre- and postablation nomograms might facilitate clinical decision-making before RFA and follow-up management after RFA.

Choice in Ablative Therapies for Thyroid Nodules

Ultrasound-guided ablation procedures have been growing in popularity and offer many advantages compared with traditional surgery for thyroid nodules. Many technologies are available, with thermal ablative techniques being the most popular currently though other nonthermal techniques, such as cryoablation and electroporation, are gaining interest. The objective of the present review is to provide an overview of each of the currently available ablative therapies and their applications in various clinical indications.

Immunocytochemistry Profile of Benign Thyroid Nodules Not Responding to Thermal Ablation: A Retrospective Study

Purpose

Thermal ablations (TA) are gaining ground as alternative options to conventional therapies for symptomatic benign thyroid nodules. Little is known about the impact of nodule biology on the outcomes of TA. The aim of our study was to evaluate the baseline immunocytochemistry profile of thyroid nodules that were poorly responsive to TA in order to identify potential predictors of the treatment response.

Methods

From a cohort of 406 patients with benign thyroid nodules treated with TA and followed for 5 years, we retrospectively selected two groups of patients: NONRESPONDERS (patients who did not respond to TA and were later surgically treated) and RESPONDERS (patients who responded to TA). The fine-needle aspiration cytology (FNAC) slides obtained before TA were stained for Galectin-3, HBME-1, CK-19, and Ki-67.

Results

Benign nodules of NONRESPONDERS (n = 19) did not express CK-19 (p = 0.03), as compared to RESPONDERS (n = 26). We combined the absence of CK-19 and the presence of Ki-67 to obtain a composite biomarker of resistance to TA, which discriminated between likelihood of retreatment and no retreatment with an AUC of 0.68 (95%CI: 0.55-0.81) and a sensitivity, specificity, PPV, and NPV of 29%, 91%, 71%, and 64%, respectively.

Conclusion

In benign thyroid nodules, the absence of CK-19 was associated with resistance to TA, while the presence of CK-19 was predictive of response to TA. If confirmed, this finding could provide rapid and inexpensive information about the potential outcome of TA on benign thyroid nodules. In addition, as CK-19 can be expressed in adenomatous hyperplasia, it could be speculated that these nodules, rather than follicular adenomas, might be better candidates for TA.

Efficacy and safety of radiofrequency ablation for calcified benign thyroid nodules: results of over 5 years' follow-up

Purpose

To evaluate the efficacy and safety of radiofrequency ablation (RFA) for treating calcified benign thyroid nodules (CBTNs).

Methods

Fifty-two patients with 52 CBTNs who underwent RFA in our hospital were included in this retrospective study. According to the size of calcifications, CBTNs were divided into two groups: the punctate echogenic foci (PEF) group and macrocalcification group. Moreover, the macrocalcification group was further subdivided into two groups, the strong group and the weak group, based on their morphologic characteristics. After the RFA procedure, routine ultrasound (US) and clinical evaluation were performed at 1, 3, 6 and 12 months postoperatively and every 12 months thereafter.

Results

The mean follow-up time was 68.98 ± 7.68 months (60–87 months), and the 5-year mean volume reduction rate (VRR) after RFA was 92.95%, with a complication rate of 0.6% (3/52). The mean initial volume of the macrocalcification group was significantly larger than that of the PEF group (9.94 ± 24.60 ml vs. 0.23 ± 0.22 ml, respectively; P = 0.011). Thus, their VRRs were not comparable between the two groups. However, baseline characteristics did not show statistically significant differences between the strong and weak macrocalcification subgroups. The VRRs of the strong subgroup were significantly lower than those of the weak subgroup at the 3-year, 4-year, and 5-year follow-ups.

Conclusion

RFA was effective and safe for treating CBTNs. Strong macrocalcification was related to the VRR of CBTNs after the RFA procedure.

Safety and Efficacy of Single-Session Radiofrequency Ablation Treatment for Benign Non-toxic Multinodular Goiter

BACKGROUND

Radiofrequency ablation (RFA) is an effective treatment for benign thyroid nodules. However, it remains unclear if ablating multiple nodules in single-session offers comparable safety and efficacy to ablating single nodule. Our study compared early complication rate and 6-month nodule shrinkage between multiple-nodules ablation and single-nodule ablation by RFA.

METHODS

Among the 174 eligible patients undergoing RFA of one or more benign thyroid nodules, 85 (48.8%) had single-nodule ablation (group I) while 89 (51.1%) had two or three nodules ablation (group II). The 6-month nodule shrinkage of each nodule (by volume reduction ratio) (VRR) was calculated by (Baseline volume - volume at 6-month)/(Baseline volume)*100 and compared between two groups. To determine independent predictors for VRR, a multivariate analysis was done by logistic regression analysis.

RESULTS

Patients in group II reported significantly higher pain scores during and 2-h after treatment than group I (42.31 vs. 29.66, p = 0.029 and 38.21 vs. 26.18, p = 0.037, respectively). Two vocal cord paresis occurred in each group. 3- and 6-month VRR of the largest nodule were comparable between two groups (67.39% vs. 63.89%, p = 0.248 and 77.29% vs. 73.38%, p = 0.182). Similar 3- and 6-month VRR were observed for 2 and 3 largest nodules in group II. In multivariate analysis, total energy given per nodule volume (OR = 1.007, 95% CI = 1.001-1.012, p = 0.036) was the only independent predictor for 6-month VRR.

CONCLUSION

In the presence of multinodular goiter, ablating two or more nodules by RFA within one session appears to offer a comparable level of safety and efficacy to ablating single nodule.

Efficacy on radiofrequency ablation according to the types of benign thyroid nodules

Percutaneous radiofrequency ablation (RFA) has been recommended as minimally invasive treatment for patients with symptomatic benign thyroid nodules (BTNs) because of the large number of clinical applications. This retrospective observational study sought to evaluate the clinical outcomes of RFA for BTNs. From 2014 to 2019, a sample size of 1289 patients treated by RFA were 262 ones with solid nodules and 1027 ones with cystic-solid nodule, respectively. The efficacy including the nodule maximal diameter reduction ratio (MDRR), the volume reduction ratio (VRR) and the cosmetic scores reduction ratio (CSRR). The results of the nodule MDRR and VRR in the cystic-solid nodule group were significantly better than those in the solid nodule group at the 3rd and 6th month, and the CSRR in the two groups showed statistically significant difference at the 3rd month. In a word, RFA is an effective method for symptomatic benign solid or cystic-solid nodules. The achieved MDRR and VRR in the cystic-solid nodule group were significantly better than those in the solid nodule group at the 3rd and 6th month.

A study on the efficacy of microwave ablation for benign thyroid nodules and related influencing factors

OBJECTIVES

To explore the efficacy of microwave ablation (MWA) in the treatment of benign thyroid nodules, and analyze related influencing factors.

METHODS

The clinical and ultrasound data of 115 patients with 115 benign thyroid nodules treated with MWA were retrospectively analyzed. The volume of nodules at 1, 3, 6, and 12 months after the procedure was obtained, and the volume reduction rate (VRR) at each time point was calculated. With VRR > 90% as the criterion for nodule cure, binary logistic regression was employed to screen the factors that affect the efficacy.

RESULTS

① At 1, 3, 6, and 12 months after the procedure, the volume of nodules continued to decrease, the VRR gradually increased, and the differences at each time point were statistically significant (p < 0.05). A total of 29 (25.21%) nodules disappeared completely at 12 months after the procedure; ② Multivariate stepwise logistic regression showed that there was a statistically significant difference for the internal component of nodules, enhancement mode, and immediate volume after the procedure in determining the ablation efficacy (p < 0.05); ③ The ROC curve was plotted for predicting the efficacy of MWA, with the results showing that the AUC, sensitivity, specificity, and accuracy were 0.82, 67.50, 88.00, 79.10%, respectively; ④ 11 cases (9.56%) had side effects, 10 cases (8.70%) had minor complications, and three cases (2.61%) had major complications.

CONCLUSION

MWA is safe and effective in the treatment of benign thyroid nodules. The internal component of nodules, enhancement mode, and immediate volume after the procedure are independent factors that affect the efficacy of ablation.

Nomogram prediction for the involution of the ablation zone after radiofrequency ablation treatment in patients with low-risk papillary thyroid carcinoma

OBJECTIVES

To construct a prognostic nomogram to predict the involution of the ablation zone for patients with low-risk papillary thyroid carcinoma (PTC) who underwent radiofrequency ablation (RFA) treatment.

METHODS

Data from 204 patients with low-risk PTC without extrathyroidal extension or cervical lymph node or distant metastasis who underwent RFA treatment were collected from January 2018 to January 2019. Clinicopathological and imaging characteristics were analyzed. The prognostic factors associated with the involution of the ablation zone within 12 months after RFA were identified by logistic analysis, and the nomogram was established. Calibration curve and decision curve analysis were used to evaluate the nomogram performance.

RESULTS

Of the 204 patients included in this study, the ablation zone in 78 (38%) patients did not completely disappear in the 12 months after RFA. Four variables, including sex (odds ratio [OR], 3.303; 95% confidence interval [CI], 1.418-8.418; p = 0.008), age (OR, 1.045; 95% CI, 1.012-1.081; p = 0.009), calcification size (OR, 1.666; 95% CI, 1.041-2.701; p = 0.035), and RFA energy (OR, 2.902; 95% CI, 1.333-6.683; p = 0.009), were found to be closely associated with ablation zone non-disappearance at 12 months after RFA by multivariate analysis. A nomogram model was constructed, and its accuracy was well validated (C-index = 0.787).

CONCLUSIONS

This study constructed and validated a risk model that could accurately predict the involution of the ablation zone after RFA for patients with PTC. This could provide clinicians with useful resource to guide patient counseling regarding tumor prognosis after RFA.

Conspicuousness and recurrence related factors of ultrasound-guided microwave ablation in the treatment of benign thyroid nodules

Objective

Microwave ablation (MWA) is a minimally invasive technique for the treatment of benign thyroid nodules. The purpose of this study was to evaluate efficacy and safety of ultrasound-guided MWA in the treatment of benign thyroid nodules, and to find out the recurrence related factors, so as to provide reference for future clinical work.

Methods

This study retrospectively analyzed the patients who received ultrasound-guided MWA for benign thyroid nodules in our hospital from October 2018 to March 2020. A total of 214 patients were included in the study. We assessed thyroid volume changes (represented by volume reduction ratio VRR), the energy per 1 mL reduction in nodular volume (represented by energy volume ratio ΔE), the serum levels of free triiodide thyroid hormone (FT3), free thyroxine (FT4), thyrotropin (TSH) and complications after MWA treatment.

Results

There were a total of 306 nodules in 214 patients, including 183 (85.51%) females and 31 (14.49%) males. The median diameter and volume of the nodule were 33 mm and 8.01 mL. The VRR at 1 month, 3 months, 6 months and 12 months were 40.79%, 60.37%, 74.59% and 85.60%, respectively. In addition, MWA had a better ablation effect for small nodules (initial volume ≤ 10 mL). In recurrent studies, we found that ΔE was an independent risk factor for benign thyroid nodules (P < 0.05).

Conclusions

Ultrasound-guided MWA is effective and safe in the treatment of benign thyroid nodules. In addition, it has little damage to surrounding tissues and no effect on thyroid function. Especially, the nodules with smaller initial volume, the treatment is better. On the other hand, the energy per 1 mL reduction ΔE in nodular volume may be associated with nodular recurrence, which requires further follow-up for longer periods. At this stage, we consider that ultrasound-guided MWA can be used as one of the main clinical treatment methods for benign thyroid nodules.

Current Status and Challenges of US-Guided Radiofrequency Ablation of Thyroid Nodules in the Long Term: A Systematic Review

BACKGROUND

US-guided minimally-invasive techniques, such as radiofrequency ablation (RFA) have emerged as an alternative treatment for benign and malignant thyroid nodules. This systematic review aims to provide an overview on the long-term outcomes of US-guided RFA in patients with benign and malignant thyroid nodules.

METHODS

We systematically searched PubMed/MEDLINE, EMBASE, and Scopus to identify articles reporting the outcomes of thyroid RFA after a follow-up of at least 3 years.

RESULTS

A total of 20 studies met the inclusion criteria and were included in the review. In patients with benign thyroid nodules, RFA significantly reduced nodule volume and this was generally maintained for the following 5 years. However, a small but not negligible proportion of nodules regrew and some of them required further treatments over time. In patients with malignant nodules, RFA has been used not only to treat differentiated thyroid cancer (DTC) neck recurrences, but also to treat papillary thyroid microcarcinoma (PTMC). In most patients with PTMC, RFA led to complete disappearance of the tumor. When it was compared to surgery, RFA was not inferior in terms of oncologic efficacy but it had a lower complication rate. However, RFA did not allow for final pathology, disease staging and accurate risk stratification.

CONCLUSIONS

US-guided RFA significantly reduces benign thyroid nodules and destroys most PTMC, and this is generally maintained for at least 5 years after the initial treatment. Further studies addressing the risk of regrowths in patients with benign thyroid nodules, as well as the risk of recurrence in patients with PTMC are needed.

Laser Ablation Versus Radiofrequency Ablation for Thyroid Nodules: 12-Month Results of a Randomized Trial (LARA II Study)

CONTEXT

Radiofrequency ablation (RFA) seems to achieve a significantly larger nodule volume reduction rate (VRR) than laser ablation (LA) in benign nonfunctioning thyroid nodules (BNTNs).

OBJECTIVE

To compare the efficacy and safety of both treatments at 12-month follow-up in patients with solid or predominantly solid BNTN.

METHODS

This was a single-center, 12-month, randomized, superiority, open-label, parallel-group trial conducted in an outpatient clinic. Sixty patients with a solitary BNTN or dominant nodule characterized by pressure symptoms/cosmetic problems were randomly assigned (1:1 ratio) to receive either a single session of RFA or LA. Twenty-9 patients per group completed the study. The main outcome measures were VRR and proportion of nodules with more than 50% reduction (technical success rate).

RESULTS

At 12 months, VRR was 70.9 ± 16.9% and 60.0 ± 19.0% in the RFA and LA groups, respectively (P = .024). This effect was confirmed in the linear regression model that was adjusted for age, sex, nodule baseline volume, and proportion of cellular components (RFA treatment: β = .390; P = .009). No significant between-group difference was observed in the technical success rate at 12 months after treatment. A statistically significant improvement was observed from the baseline to the 12-month follow-up for compression (RFA: 4.6 ± 2.6 and 1.3 ± 0.8, P < .001; and LA: 4.6 ± 2.1 and 1.6 ± 0.8, respectively, P < .001) and cosmetic (RFA: 3.4 ± 0.6 and 1.3 ± 0.5, P < .001; and LA: 3.4 ± 0.5 and 1.4 ± 0.6, P < .001) scores although the between-group differences were not significant.

CONCLUSION

RFA achieved a significantly larger nodule volume reduction at 12 months; however, the technical success rate was similar in the RFA and LA groups.

RFA and benign thyroid nodules: Review of the current literature

Benign thyroid nodules (BTNs) are commonly found in the general population. They are usually asymptomatic and their incidence has increased as a result of wide-spread use of ultrasound. Benign nodules are typically monitored clinically until they increase in size, resulting in compressive symptoms warranting surgery. However, although surgery is generally well-tolerated and of low-risk, it is associated with a small risk for several complications including hypothyroidism, nerve injury, hematoma, injury to other structures and wound infection. Recently, newer image-guided ablation techniques including radiofrequency ablation (RFA) have been introduced. RFA has a similar safety profile when compared to surgery and has shown promising results in challenging surgical candidates. Though several studies have been published in Asian and European countries on the efficacy of RFA, limited data is available on the North American population. The aim of the study is to review the current literature establishing the clinical outcomes and safety of RFA for benign nodules.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

V.

Determining an energy threshold for optimal volume reduction of benign thyroid nodules treated by radiofrequency ablation

OBJECTIVES

Radiofrequency ablation (RFA) is effective in reducing the volume of benign thyroid nodules. However, what parameters can influence the response to RFA is still unclear. The present study aimed to (1) investigate which ultrasound and technical parameters are potential determinants of the volumetric reduction; (2) develop a dose-response model, and (3) analyze the effects of RFA on ultrasound features.

METHODS

In this retrospective study, three institutions treated patients with benign thyroid nodules according to the same protocol. The technical parameters were power and energy. The 1-year volume reduction ratio (VRR) was the reference standard of the response. The correlations of different parameters with VRR were analyzed and the association between several parameters and a VRR above 50% studied by uni- and multivariate analyses. The probit regression estimated the probability to achieve an effective response.

RESULTS

One hundred fifteen patients were enrolled. The median power was 50 W and median total delivered energy 27,531 J. At 1-year follow-up, the median VRR was 64.0% and 87 (75.7%) nodules showed a VRR above 50%. Among all parameters, only baseline volume, total energy, and energy per volume were independently associated to a VRR > 50% (p = 0.001, p = 0.0178, p < 0.001 respectively). The probit regression analysis demonstrated that delivering 756 J/ml and 2670 J/ml gave a probability of VRR > 50% in 50% and 99% of patients, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

Considering the baseline nodular volume and delivering the adequate energy per volume allow optimizing technical and clinical success.

KEY POINTS

• The effectiveness of radiofrequency ablation in treating benign thyroid nodules is negatively correlated to the volume of the nodule and positively correlated to the energy delivered per volume. • When planning the treatment, the total energy to deliver can be calculated by using a simple formula: nodular volume × 2670 J.

Long-Term Outcomes of Thermal Ablation for Benign Thyroid Nodules: The Issue of Regrowth

Thermal ablation (TA) for benign thyroid nodules (BTNs) is widely accepted as an effective and safe alternative to surgery. However, studies on the long-term outcomes of TA have reported problems with nodule regrowth and symptom recurrence, which have raised the need for adequate control of regrowth. Therefore, a more complete TA with a longer-lasting treatment effect may be required. In this study, we review and discuss long-term outcomes and regrowth of BTNs following TA and evaluate factors affecting the long-term outcomes. We also discuss the management of regrowth based on long-term outcomes.

Update of Radiofrequency Ablation for Treating Benign and Malignant Thyroid Nodules. The Future Is Now

Thermal and chemical ablation are minimally invasive procedures that avoid removal of the thyroid gland and target symptomatic nodules directly. Internationally, Radiofrequency ablation (RFA) is among one of the most widely used thermal ablative techniques, and is gaining traction in North America. Surgery remains the standard of care for most thyroid cancer, and in the right clinical setting, Active Surveillance (AS) can be a reasonable option for low risk disease. Minimally invasive techniques have emerged as an alternative option for patients deemed high risk for surgery, or for those patients who wish to receive a more active treatment approach compared to AS. Herein, we review the literature on the safety and efficacy of RFA for treating benign non-functioning thyroid nodules, autonomously functioning thyroid nodules, primary small low risk thyroid cancer (namely papillary thyroid cancer) as well as recurrent thyroid cancer.

A Nomogram to Predict Regrowth After Ultrasound-Guided Radiofrequency Ablation for Benign Thyroid Nodules

OBJECTIVE

To develop and validate a nomogram to predict regrowth for patients with benign thyroid nodules undergoing radiofrequency ablation (RFA).

METHODS

A total of 200 patients with 220 benign thyroid nodules who underwent RFA were included in this respective study. After RFA, patients were followed up at 1, 3, 6, and 12 months, and every 12 months thereafter. Regrowth was defined as an increase in nodule volume 50% over the previously recorded smallest volume. A nomogram was developed based on the variables identified by multivariate logistic regression and the model performance was evaluated by discrimination(concordance index) and calibration curves.

RESULTS

The incidence of regrowth was 13.64% (30/220) after a mean follow-up period of 27.43 ± 17.99 months. Multivariate logistic regression revealed initial volume (OR = 1.047, 95%CI 1.020-1.075), vascularity (OR = 2.037, 95%CI 1.218-3.404), and location close to critical structure (OR = 4.713, 95%CI 1.817-12.223) were independent factors associated with regrowth. The prognostic nomogram incorporating these three factors achieved good calibration and discriminatory abilities with a concordance index of 0.779 (95%CI 0.686-0.872).

CONCLUSIONS

A prognostic nomogram was successfully developed to predict nodule regrowth after RFA, which might guide physician in stratifying patients and provide precise guidance for individualized treatment protocols.

Comparison of the Effectiveness of Ethanol and Radiofrequency Ablation in the Treatment of Thyroid Nodules and Their Effects on Cosmetic Scoring

PURPOSE

In this study, we aimed to retrospectively evaluate the volumes and cosmetic scores of mixed-type and spongy-type thyroid nodules treated with ethanol and radiofrequency (RF) ablation before and after treatment. In addition, the safety and efficacy of ethanol and RF ablation treatment methods were compared.

METHODS

In the radiology department, mixed-type and spongy-type benign thyroid nodules undergoing ethanol and RF ablation between February 2015 and March 2020 were evaluated retrospectively. Consequently, 50 patients who received ethanol ablation therapy and 46 patients who received RF ablation therapy were included in the study. Nodule volumes obtained in pretreatment, third-month, and sixth-month control ultrasounds were noted. Similarly, the cosmetic scores obtained pretreatment and at the sixth-month follow-up were recorded for all patients.

RESULTS

All of the patients had a single nodule, and 46 patients (47.9%) received RF ablation, and 50 patients (52.1%) received ethanol ablation. The mean volume pretreatment in nodules with RF ablation was 21.41 ml, at the third-month control was 5.68 ml, and at the sixth-month control, it was 4.12 ml (p < 0.05). In ethanol ablation therapy, the mean volume pretreatment was 20.52 ml, at the third-month control was 8.76 ml and at the sixth-month control was 6.01 ml (p < 0.05).

CONCLUSION

A minimally invasive approach is increasingly used in the treatment of benign thyroid nodules. Our study showed that RF ablation was somewhat more successful in reducing cosmetic scores in patients with biopsy-proven benign mixed-type and spongy-type thyroid nodules, and both techniques were similarly effective in volume reduction.

Five-Year Results of Radiofrequency and Laser Ablation of Benign Thyroid Nodules: A Multicenter Study from the Italian Minimally Invasive Treatments of the Thyroid Group

Background: Radiofrequency ablation (RFA) and laser ablation (LA) are effective treatments for benign thyroid nodules. Due to their relatively recent introduction into clinical practice, there are limited long-term follow-up studies. This study aimed to evaluate technique efficacy, rate of regrowth, and retreatment over 5 years after RFA or LA and to identify predictive factors of outcome. Methods: In this multicenter retrospective study, the rates of technique efficacy, regrowth, and retreatment were evaluated in 406 patients treated with either RFA or LA, and followed for 5 years after initial treatment. Propensity score matching was used to compare treatments. Cumulative incidence studies with hazard models were used to describe regrowth and retreatment trends, and to identify prognostic factors. Logistic regression models and receiver operating characteristic analyses were used for risk factors and their cutoffs. Results: RFA and LA significantly reduced benign thyroid nodule volume, and this reduction was generally maintained for 5 years. Technique efficacy (defined as a reduction ≥50% after 1 year from the treatment) was achieved in 74% of patients (85% in the RFA and 63% in the LA group). Regrowth occurred in 28% of patients (20% in the RFA and 38% in the LA group). In the majority of cases, further treatment was not required as only 18% of patients were retreated (12% in the RFA and 24% in the LA group). These data were confirmed by propensity score matching. Cumulative incidence studies showed that RFA was associated with a lower risk of regrowth and a lower risk of requiring retreatment over time. Overall, technique inefficacy and regrowth were associated with low-energy delivery. Retreatments were more frequent in young patients, in large nodules, in patients with lower volume reduction at 1 year, and in cases of low-energy delivery (optimal cutoff was 918 J/mL for RFA). Conclusions: Both thermal ablation techniques result in a clinically significant and long-lasting volume reduction of benign thyroid nodules. The risk of regrowth and needing retreatment was lower after RFA. The need for retreatment was associated with young age, large baseline volume, and treatment with low-energy delivery.

Initial Ablation Ratio Predicts Volume Reduction and Retreatment After 5 Years From Radiofrequency Ablation of Benign Thyroid Nodules

BACKGROUND

Radiofrequency ablation (RFA) has gained ground as an effective and well-tolerated technique to treat benign thyroid nodules. Most of the available studies have described the short-term outcomes of RFA, whereas there is a limited number of studies evaluating long-term issues, such as regrowth and the likelihood of retreatments. In addition, risk markers of regrowth and retreatment remain to be defined. The initial ablation ratio (IAR) is an index that measures the amount of ablation after RFA, which has been associated with technique efficacy (i.e. volume reduction >50% after 1 year from the procedure). This study aimed at evaluating i) IAR reproducibility and ii) IAR predictive value for RFA 5-year outcomes.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

This is a retrospective single center study on patients with benign thyroid nodules treated with RFA and followed for 5 years after initial treatment. IAR interobserver reproducibility was evaluated with Bland-Altman method and Lin's concordance correlation coefficient (ρc). IAR predictive value for RFA 5-year outcomes was evaluated with linear and logistic regression models, as well as with Cox models, while receiver operating characteristic (ROC) analyses were used for cut-offs.

RESULTS

We selected 78 patients with 82 benign thyroid nodules. The procedure significantly reduced nodule volume and this reduction was generally maintained over time. Technique efficacy was achieved in 92% of patients, while 23% of nodules regrew and 12% of nodules were retreated. Median IAR was 83%. Lin's concordance and Pearson's correlation coefficients suggested a good interobserver reproducibility of this index, consistent with the limits of agreement of the Bland-Altman plot. IAR was significantly associated with technique efficacy, 1- and 5-year volume reduction ratio, and with the likelihood of a retreatment, but not with nodule regrowth. ROC analyses showed that IAR cut-off was 49% for technique efficacy and 73% for retreatment.

CONCLUSIONS

Our results show for the first time that IAR is reproducible and that it predicts the volume reduction and the likelihood of a retreatment after 5 years from RFA.