It's not all in the numbers

Prediction of appropriate ICD therapy in patients with ischemic heart failure

BACKGROUND

Previous studies show inconsistent results on the role of innervation imaging (with I-123-mIBG) and perfusion imaging in predicting appropriate ICD therapy (aICDth). These studies included patients with both dilated and ischemic cardiomyopathy. This study compared the ability of 123I-mIBG imaging along with perfusion imaging (using thallium-199) to predict aICDth in patients with ischemic heart failure (IHF) in relation to indication for ICD implantation (primary vs. secondary prevention of sudden cardiac death (SCD)).

METHODS

mIBG/thallium SPECT imaging were performed before ICD implantation in 80 patients with IHF: 49 candidates for primary and 31 for secondary SCD prevention.

RESULTS

During a mean follow-up of 18 months, the imaging results could not predict patients with appropriate ICD therapy among patients with ICD implants for primary SCD prevention. While in the secondary SCD prevention group, those who received a ICDth had significantly larger summed scores of regional perfusion and innervation impairment, but not higher heart-to-mediastinal mIBG ratio. The best results to predict aICDth were using mIBG summed score (cut-off point > 34%, sensitivity 72%, specificity 100%, AUC 0.909, P < 0.0001).

CONCLUSION

The prognostic value of innervation and perfusion imaging in patients with IHF differ based on indication for ICD implantation (primary vs. secondary prevention of SCD).

Quality and utility of [123I]I-metaiodobenzylguanidine cardiac SPECT imaging in nondiabetic postinfarction heart failure patients qualified for implantable cardioverter defibrillator

OBJECTIVE

Impaired cardiac adrenergic activity has been demonstrated in heart failure (HF) and in diabetes mellitus (DM). [123I]I-metaiodobenzylguanidine (MIBG) enables assessment of the cardiac adrenergic nervous system. Tomographic imaging of the heart is expected to be superior to planar imaging. This study aimed to determine the quality and utility of MIBG SPECT in the assessment of cardiac innervation in postinfarction HF patients without DM, qualified for implantable cardioverter defibrillator (ICD) in primary prevention of sudden cardiac death.

METHODS

Consecutive patients receiving an ICD on the basis of contemporary guidelines were prospectively included. Planar MIBG studies were followed by SPECT. The essential analysis was based on visual assessment of the quality of SPECT images ("high", "low" or "unacceptable"). The variables used in the further analysis were late summed defect score for SPECT images and heart-to-mediastinum rate for planar images. MIBG images were assessed independently by two experienced readers.

RESULTS

Fifty postinfarction nondiabetic HF subjects were enrolled. In 13 patients (26%), the assessment of SPECT studies was impossible. In addition, in 13 of 37 patients who underwent semiquantitative SPECT evaluation, the assessment was equivocal. Altogether, in 26/50 patients (52%, 95% confidence interval 38-65%), the quality of SPECT images was unacceptable or low and was limited by low MIBG cardiac uptake and by comparatively high, interfering MIBG uptake in the neighboring structures (primarily, in the lungs).

CONCLUSIONS

The utility of MIBG SPECT imaging, at least with conventional imaging protocols, in the qualification of postinfarction HF patients for ICD, is limited. In approximately half of the postinfarction HF patients, SPECT assessment of cardiac innervation can be impossible or equivocal, even without additional damage from diabetic cardiac neuropathy. The criteria predisposing the patient to good-quality MIBG SPECT are: high values of LVEF from the range characterizing the patients qualified to ICD (i.e., close to 35%) and left lung uptake intensity in planar images comparable to or lower than heart uptake.

Current Clinical Applications and Next Steps for Cardiac Innervation Imaging

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Autonomic innervation is crucial for regulating cardiac function. Sympathetic innervation imaging with ¹²³I-mIBG and analogous PET tracers assesses disease in ways that differ from customary methods. This review describes practical use in various clinical scenarios, discusses recent guidelines, presents new data confirming risk stratification power, describes an ongoing prospective study, and looks forward to wider use in patient management.

RECENT FINDINGS

ASNC ¹²³I-mIBG guidelines are available, expanding on European guidelines. ADMIRE-HF patient follow-up increased to 2 years in ADMIRE HFX, demonstrating independent mortality risk reclassification. ADMIRE-HF findings were substantiated in a Japanese consortium study and in the PAREPET ¹¹C-HED PET study. Exciting potential uses of adrenergic imaging are management of LVADs and VT ablation. CZT cameras provide advantages, but derived parameters differ from Anger camera values. Independent risk stratification utility of adrenergic imaging with ¹²³I-mIBG and PET tracers is continuously being confirmed. An ongoing prospective randomized study promises to establish patient management utility. There is potential for wider use and improved images with newer cameras and PET.