Challenges in the management of patients with maple syrup urine disease diagnosed by newborn screening in a developing country

Treatment Outcomes for Maple Syrup Urine Disease Detected by Newborn Screening

OBJECTIVE

Maple syrup urine disease (MSUD), a life-threatening metabolic disorder, is included in newborn screening (NBS) programs worldwide. The study aims to evaluate the impact of NBS on the long-term outcome of MSUD patients.

METHODS

We performed a prospective, national, multicenter, observational study.

RESULTS

In the studied NBS cohort (N = 33; 22 classic MSUD [cMSUD], 11 variant MSUD [vMSUD]; median age at last visit 10.4 years), 32 (97%) patients survived, 58% of them had normal cognitive functions (median IQ 87). Initial peak leucine increased linearly with age in cMSUD (median: 1712 µmol/L), but not in vMSUD. Global IQ correlated inversely with the initial peak leucine concentration (P = .04; β = -0.0081) and the frequency of decompensations (P = .02; β = -9.133). A cluster analysis identified 2 subgroups differing in their long-term metabolic control (median leucine concentration: 162 vs 278 µmol/L; P < .001). In cMSUD, lower leucine concentrations were associated with a higher IQ (95.5 vs 80; P = .008). Liver transplantation (median age 5.8 years) was not associated with better cognitive outcome. NBS is highly sensitive for cMSUD, but vMSUD might be missed (N = 2 missed by NBS).

CONCLUSIONS

NBS and the early start of treatment improve survival and long-term outcome in individuals with cMSUD. Disease severity is an important modifier of outcome; however, the time to NBS report and the quality of long-term metabolic control had an independent impact on cognitive outcome, highlighting the importance of an early diagnosis and the quality of treatment.

The oral phenotype and dental management in patients with maple syrup urine disease; case report and scoping review

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES

The literature about oral manifestations and dental management in maple syrup urine disease (MSUD) is sparse. The aim of this report is to present a new case of MSUD with special emphasis on oral findings and to review the relevant literature.

METHOD

A case report of a 4-year-old boy with MSUD was described according to the CARE guidelines for describing case reports. Scoping review of relevant literature was performed, according to the PRISMA-ScR guidelines, by searching PubMed, Medline, Embase, and the grey literature for articles describing dental management and/or oral manifestations in MSUD.

RESULTS

The initial search identified 219 articles, but only 4 met the inclusion criteria. Rampant caries and plaque induced gingivitis were the main oro-dental findings in MSUD. Other oral findings included enamel hypoplasia, skeletal abnormalities, and abnormal oral behaviors. Disease-related factors appeared to play a major role in the development of the observed oral phenotype.

CONCLUSION

Oral health in MSUD seems to be influenced by the reliance on semi-synthetic diet and associated neurocognitive complications. Tailored oral health promotional interventions should be included in the multidisciplinary management of patients with MSUD.

Newborn screening of maple syrup urine disease and the effect of early diagnosis

BACKGROUND

Maple syrup urine disease (MSUD) is a rare disease for which newborn screening (NBS) is feasible but not universally applied in China. We shared our experiences with MSUD NBS.

METHODS

Tandem mass spectrometry-based NBS for MSUD was implemented in January 2003, and diagnostic methods included urine organic acid analysis via gas chromatography-mass spectrometry and genetic analysis.

RESULTS

Six MSUD patients were identified from 1.3 million newborns, yielding an incidence of 1:219,472, in Shanghai, China. The areas under the curve (AUCs) of total leucine (Xle), Xle/phenylalanine ratio, and Xle/alanine ratio were all 1.000. Some amino acid and acylcarnitine concentrations were markedly low in MSUD patients. 47 MSUD patients identified here and in other centers were investigated, which included 14 patients identified by NBS and 33 patients diagnosed clinically. Forty-four patients were subclassified into classic (n = 29), intermediate (n = 11) and intermittent (n = 4) subtypes. Due to earlier diagnosis and treatment, screened classic patients showed a higher survival rate (62.5%, 5/8) than clinically diagnosed classic patients (5.2%, 1/19). Overall, 56.8% (25/44) of MSUD patients and 77.8% (21/27) of classic patients carried variants in the BCKDHB gene. Among 61 identified genetic variants, 16 novel variants were identified.

CONCLUSION

MSUD NBS in Shanghai, China, enabled earlier detection and increased survivorship in the screened population.

Leucine tolerance in children with MSUD is not correlated with plasma leucine levels at diagnosis

OBJECTIVES

Maple syrup urine disease (MSUD) is an inborn metabolic disease. The nutritional treatment with restricted intake of branched chain amino acids and prevention of leucine toxicity are crucially important for a favorable outcome. The aim of this study is to analyze the relation of blood leucine levels at diagnosis with future leucine tolerances, to determine whether any prediction about the future leucine tolerances or plasma leucine levels is possible by evaluating blood leucine levels at diagnosis.

METHODS

The study group consisted of 45 MSUD patients. Leucine levels at diagnosis were compared with age at diagnosis, leucine tolerances, maximum leucine levels/ages, and average blood leucine levels.

RESULTS

The mean plasma leucine level at diagnosis was 2,355.47 ± 1,251.7 μmol/L (ref: 55-164 μmol/L). The median age at diagnosis was 17 days. Leucine tolerances per kg body weight declined until the age of 8 years and stabilized subsequently. The average age of maximum leucine level during follow-up was 3.14 ± 1.92 years, and the mean maximum lifetime plasma leucine level on follow-up was 1,452.13 ± 621.38 μmol/L. The leucine levels at diagnosis did not have any significant relationship with lifetime leucine tolerances, maximum plasma leucine levels or mean plasma leucine levels.

CONCLUSIONS

The plasma leucine levels at diagnosis did not have a predictive value for later leucine tolerances or plasma leucine levels. The maximum lifetime leucine level is likely to happen within the first 3 years of life, underlining the importance of good metabolic control and compliance to dietary treatment at early ages.

Alternative sources of valine and isoleucine for prompt reduction of plasma leucine in maple syrup urine disease patients: A case series

In maple syrup urine disease (MSUD), leucine (Leu) accumulation, and its metabolites cause brain toxicity, and at diagnosis rapid plasma Leu reduction is essential. Valine (Val) and isoleucine (Iso) supplements are necessary to promote anabolism and enable prompt reduction of plasma Leu. Val/Iso supplements are unavailable in Iran, so an alternative source was necessary. An emergency protocol was developed using an unconventional source of Val and Iso to prompt reduction of high plasma Leu levels during an acute metabolic crisis to prevent brain encephalopathy and neurological sequelae. Five children with classical MSUD were referred aged 1-25 months, with a prolonged high plasma Leu of more than 1500 μmol/L and acute symptoms (irritability, poor feeding, and hypotonia). Initially, breast milk/regular infant formula was stopped. Val and Iso were given in calculated amounts from a Leu-free formula containing Iso/Val (Xleu Maxamaid, Nutricia Ltd.) to promote anabolism. It was prescribed for a controlled and limited time with a branched chain amino acid (BCAA) free formula. Frequent amino acid monitoring was conducted. Natural protein was re-added after normalizing plasma Leu. Plasma Leu declined by a median (range) of 1677 (1501-1852) μmol/L within 3-4 days of intervention. The median follow-up time was 24 months (range: 14-32) and patients showed improvement in motor and cognitive skills after normalizing plasma Leu (75-200 μmol/L). Most had improvement in their head circumference (n = 4). Due to the unavailability of individual Val/Iso supplements, a Leu-free formula rapidly lowered plasma Leu concentrations during acute crisis, to prevent cerebral edema and brain damage in MSUD.

Maple syrup urine disease: Clinical outcomes, metabolic control, and genotypes in a screened population after four decades of newborn bloodspot screening in the Republic of Ireland

Since 1972, 18 patients (10 females/8 males) have been detected by newborn bloodspot screening (NBS) with neonatal-onset maple syrup urine disease (MSUD) in Ireland. Patients were stratified into three clusters according to clinical outcome at the time of data collection, including developmental, clinical, and IQ data. A fourth cluster comprised of two early childhood deaths; a third patient died as an adult. We present neuroimaging and electroencephalography together with clinical and biochemical data. Incidence of MSUD (1972-2018) was 1 in 147 975. Overall good clinical outcomes were achieved with 15/18 patients alive and with essentially normal functioning (with only the lowest performing cluster lying beyond a single SD on their full scale intelligence quotient). Molecular genetic analysis revealed genotypes hitherto not reported, including a possible digenic inheritance state for the BCKDHA and DBT genes in one family. Treatment has been based on early implementation of emergency treatment, diet, close monitoring, and even dialysis in the setting of acute metabolic decompensation. A plasma leucine ≥400 μmol/L (outside therapeutic range) was more frequently observed in infancy or during adolescence, possibly due to infections, hormonal changes, or noncompliance. Children require careful management during metabolic decompensations in early childhood, and this represented a key risk period in our cohort. A high level of metabolic control can be achieved through diet with early implementation of a "sick day" regime and, in some cases, dialysis as a rescue therapy. The Irish cohort, despite largely classical phenotypes, achieved good outcomes in the NBS era, underlining the importance of early diagnosis and skilled multidisciplinary team management.

Long-term Outcomes of Individuals With Metabolic Diseases Identified Through Newborn Screening

BACKGROUND

Although extended newborn screening (NBS) programs have been introduced more than 20 years ago, their impact on the long-term clinical outcome of individuals with inherited metabolic diseases (IMDs) is still rarely investigated.

METHODS

We studied the clinical outcomes of individuals with IMDs identified by NBS between 1999 and 2016 in a prospective multicenter observational study.

RESULTS

In total, 306 screened individuals with IMDs (115 with phenylketonuria and 191 with other IMDs with a lifelong risk for metabolic decompensation) were followed for a median time of 6.2 years. Although the risk for metabolic decompensation was disease-specific and NBS could not prevent decompensations in every individual at risk (n = 49), the majority did not develop permanent disease-specific signs (75.9%), showed normal development (95.6%) and normal cognitive outcome (87.7%; mean IQ: 100.4), and mostly attended regular kindergarten (95.2%) and primary school (95.2%). This demonstrates that not only individuals with phenylketonuria, serving as a benchmark, but also those with lifelong risk for metabolic decompensation had a favorable long-term outcome. High NBS process quality is the prerequisite of this favorable outcome. This is supported by 28 individuals presenting with first symptoms at a median age of 3.5 days before NBS results were available, by the absence of neonatal decompensations after the report of NBS results, and by the challenge of keeping relevant process parameters at a constantly high level.

CONCLUSIONS

NBS for IMDs, although not completely preventing clinical presentations in all individuals, can be considered a highly successful program of secondary prevention.

Evaluation of 11 years of newborn screening for maple syrup urine disease in the Netherlands and a systematic review of the literature: Strategies for optimization

Maple syrup urine disease (MSUD) leads to severe neurological deterioration unless diagnosed early and treated immediately. We have evaluated the effectiveness of 11 years of MSUD newborn screening (NBS) in the Netherlands (screening >72 hours, referral if both total leucine (Xle) and valine ≥400 μmol/L blood) and have explored possibilities for improvement by combining our data with a systematic literature review and data from Collaborative Laboratory Integrated Reports (CLIR). Dutch MSUD NBS characteristics and accuracy were determined. The hypothetical referral numbers in the Dutch population of additional screening markers suggested by CLIR were calculated. In a systematic review, articles reporting NBS leucine concentrations of confirmed patients were included. Our data showed that NBS of 1 963 465 newborns identified 4 MSUD patients and led to 118 false-positive referrals (PPV 3.28%; incidence 1:491 000 newborns). In literature, leucine is the preferred NBS parameter. Total leucine (Xle) concentrations (mass-spectrometry) of 53 detected and 8 false-negative patients (sampling age within 25 hours in 3 patients) reported in literature ranged from 288 to 3376 (median 900) and 42 to 325 (median 209) μmol/L blood respectively. CLIR showed increasing Xle concentrations with sampling age and early NBS sampling and milder variant MSUD phenotypes with (nearly) normal biochemical profiles are causes of false-negative NBS results. We evaluated the effect of additional screening markers and established the Xle/phenylalanine ratio as a promising additional marker ratio for increasing the PPV, while maintaining high sensitivity in the Dutch MSUD NBS.

Branched-chain α-ketoacid dehydrogenase deficiency (maple syrup urine disease): Treatment, biomarkers, and outcomes

Over the past three decades, we studied 184 individuals with 174 different molecular variants of branched-chain α-ketoacid dehydrogenase activity, and here delineate essential clinical and biochemical aspects of the maple syrup urine disease (MSUD) phenotype. We collected data about treatment, survival, hospitalization, metabolic control, and liver transplantation from patients with classic (i.e., severe; n = 176), intermediate (n = 6) and intermittent (n = 2) forms of MSUD. A total of 13,589 amino acid profiles were used to analyze leucine tolerance, amino acid homeostasis, estimated cerebral amino acid uptake, quantitative responses to anabolic therapy, and metabolic control after liver transplantation. Standard instruments were used to measure neuropsychiatric outcomes. Despite advances in clinical care, classic MSUD remains a morbid and potentially fatal disorder. Stringent dietary therapy maintains metabolic variables within acceptable limits but is challenging to implement, fails to restore appropriate concentration relationships among circulating amino acids, and does not fully prevent cognitive and psychiatric disabilities. Liver transplantation eliminates the need for a prescription diet and safeguards patients from life-threatening metabolic crises, but is associated with predictable morbidities and does not reverse pre-existing neurological sequelae. There is a critical unmet need for safe and effective disease-modifying therapies for MSUD which can be implemented early in life. The biochemistry and physiology of MSUD and its response to liver transplantation afford key insights into the design of new therapies based on gene replacement or editing.