Impact of Clinically Relevant Elliptical Deformations on the Damage Patterns of Sagging and Stretched Leaflets in a Bioprosthetic Heart Valve

Regulatory science promotes the translation of transcatheter tricuspid valve repair/replacement devices

For patients with symptomatic and severe tricuspid regurgitation but inoperable with open surgery, transcatheter tricuspid valve intervention (TTVI) is a procedure of great clinical value. TTVI products include repair and replacement devices. TTVI products are one of the hotspots of investigation now, with different innovative biomaterials and structural designs in trials to satisfy divergent indications and reduce complications. With the emerging biomaterials, the technical difficulty of structural design will be greatly reduced, spurring further product innovation and development. The innovativeness and complexity of TTVI products have brought challenges to academia, industry, and regulatory agencies. Regulatory science provides a bridge to address these difficulties and challenges. This perspective article introduces the latest development of the TTVI products. With traditional methods, regulatory agencies face challenges in evaluating the safety and efficacy of TTVr/TTVR devices given the uncertainty of clinical use and the diversity of innovative structural design. This perspective article analyzes the regulatory challenges and discusses regulatory science that can be developed to assess the safety, efficacy, quality and performance of such products: including new approaches for innovative devices, pre-review path, computer modeling and simulation, accelerated wear testing methods for transcatheter heart valves and evidence-based research. This article reveals for the first time how to apply regulatory science systematically to TTVI products, which is of great relevance to their development and translation.

Long-term function of a novel autologous transcatheter pulmonary heart valve implant in an adult animal model

BACKGROUND

Current heart valve implants entail major disadvantages in the treatment for younger patients or those with congenital heart defects.

AIM

Evaluation of novel transcatheter pulmonary valve implant made from autologous pericardium with natural crosslinking agent in an in vitro setup and in vivo animal model METHODS: Valves were tested in a pulse duplicator according to ISO-standard 5840. For in vivo studies computer tomography was performed to measure sheep's native pulmonary valve dimensions. Pericardium was harvested by thoracotomy, personalized implants were manufactured and deployed in pulmonary valve position of the same sheep. Every 3 months implant functionality was evaluated by intracardiac echocardiography, intracardiac pressure measurements and cardiac magnetic resonance imaging (cMRI). Implants were explanted for macroscopic and histological examination.

RESULTS

In vitro experiments showed compliance with regulatory requirements in terms of valve opening and insufficiency. Five sheep successfully received an autologous valve implant. Two animals had to be euthanized due to trauma sustained in the stable. Long-term valve function was excellent in three out of four animals with median implant cMRI regurgitation fraction of 9% (n = 4) at 3 months, 8% (n = 3) at 6, 8% (n = 3) at 9, 12% (n = 3) at 13, 8% (n = 2) at 17% and 8% (n = 2) at 20.5 months after implantation. Despite good adherence to neighboring tissue and endothelization, histological assessment revealed some signs of degeneration.

CONCLUSION

Transcatheter pulmonary valve implants showed promising function for up to 20.5 months encouraging research to further improve this approach.

Surgically implanted aortic valve bioprostheses deform after implantation: insights from computed tomography

OBJECTIVE

Little is known about the prevalence and degree of deformation of surgically implanted aortic biological valve prostheses (bio-sAVRs). We assessed bio-sAVR deformation using multidetector-row computed tomography (MDCT).

METHODS

Three imaging databases were searched for patients with MDCT performed after bio-sAVR implantation. Minimal and maximal valve ring diameters were obtained in systole and/or diastole, depending on the acquired cardiac phase(s). The eccentricity index (EI) was calculated as a measure of deformation as (1 - (minimal diameter/maximal diameter)) × 100%. EI of < 5% was considered none or trivial deformation, 5-10% mild deformation, and > 10% non-circular. Indications for MDCT and implanted valve type were retrieved.

RESULTS

One hundred fifty-two scans of bio-sAVRs were included. One hundred seventeen measurements were performed in systole and 35 in diastole. None or trivial deformation (EI < 5%) was seen in 67/152 (44%) of patients. Mild deformation (EI 5-10%) was seen in 59/152 (39%) and non-circularity was found in 26/152 (17%) of cases. Overall, median EI was 5.5% (IQR 3.4-7.8). In 77 patients, both systolic and diastolic measurements were performed from the same scan. For these scans, the median EI was 6.5% (IQR 3.4-10.2) in systole and 5.1% (IQR3.1-7.6) in diastole, with a significant difference between both groups (p = 0.006).

CONCLUSIONS

Surgically implanted aortic biological valve prostheses show mild deformation in 39% of cases and were considered non-circular in 17% of studied valves.

KEY POINTS

• Deformation of surgically implanted aortic valve bioprostheses (bio-sAVRs) can be adequately assessed using MDCT. • Bio-sAVRs show at least mild deformation (eccentricity index > 5%) in 56% of studied cases and were considered non-circular (eccentricity index > 10%) in 17% of studied valves. • The higher deformity rate found in bio-sAVRs with (suspected) valve pathology could suggest that geometric deformity may play a role in leaflet malformation and thrombus formation similar to that of transcatheter heart valves.

A Computational Study on Deformed Bioprosthetic Valve Geometries: Clinically Relevant Valve Performance Metrics

Transcatheter aortic valves (TAV) are symmetrically designed, but they are often not deployed inside cylindrical conduits with circular cross-sectional areas. Many TAV patients have heavily calcified aortic valves, which often result in deformed prosthesis geometries after deployment. We investigated the effects of deformed valve annulus configurations on a surgical bioprosthetic valve as a model for TAV. We studied valve leaflet motions, stresses and strains, and analog hydrodynamic measures (using geometric methods), via finite element (FE) modeling. Two categories of annular deformations were created to approximate clinical observations: (1) noncircular annulus with valve area conserved, and (2) under-expansion (reduced area) compared to circular annulus. We found that under-expansion had more impact on increasing stenosis (with geometric orifice area metrics) than noncircularity, and that noncircularity had more impact on increasing regurgitation (with regurgitation orifice area metrics) than under-expansion. We found durability predictors (stress/strain) to be the highest in the commissure regions of noncircular configurations such as EllipMajor (noncircular and under-expansion areas). Other clinically relevant performance aspects such as leaflet kinematics and coaptation were also investigated with the noncircular configurations. This study provides a framework for choosing the most challenging TAV deformations for acute and long-term valve performance in the design and testing phase of device development.