Enhanced detection of ubiquitin isopeptides using reductive methylation

Site-specific proteomic strategies to identify ubiquitin and SUMO modifications: Challenges and opportunities

Ubiquitin and SUMO modify thousands of substrates to regulate most cellular processes. System-wide identification of ubiquitin and SUMO substrates provides global understanding of their cellular functions. In this review, we discuss the biological importance of site-specific modifications by ubiquitin and SUMO regulating the DNA damage response, protein quality control and cell cycle progression. Furthermore we discuss the machinery responsible for these modifications and methods to purify and identify ubiquitin and SUMO modified sites by mass spectrometry. We provide a framework to aid in the selection of appropriate purification, digestion and acquisition strategies suited to answer different biological questions. We highlight opportunities in the field for employing innovative technologies, as well as discuss challenges and long-standing questions in the field that are difficult to address with the currently available tools, emphasizing the need for further innovation.

A Combined Chemical Derivatization/Mass Spectrometric Method for the Enhanced Detection and Relative Quantification of Protein Ubiquitination

Mass spectrometry (MS) is a sensitive analytical technique with wide application across the sciences including for the detection of peptides and proteins in biological analysis. Ubiquitinated (Ub) proteins are typically analyzed by proteolytic digestion and subsequent chromatographic separation followed by MS detection of the resulting isopeptides. Here we describe a novel method which enables enhanced detection of this important posttranslational modification (PTM) by use of a simple chemical labeling strategy prior to Data-Independent Acquisition (DIA) using a SWATH-based acquisition approach on a suitable Quadrupole-Time-Of-Flight (Q-TOF) mass spectrometer.

Exploring the Rampant Expansion of Ubiquitin Proteomics

The ubiquitin proteasome system can arguably affect all cellular proteins with few exceptions. In addition to regulating many pathways such as cell cycle progression, inflammation, gene expression, DNA repair, and vesicle trafficking-to just name a few-ubiquitination can occur to any nascent or newly translated protein that misfolds. In the past years, substantial progress has been achieved in advancing our global understanding of the ubiquitinome-the ensemble of ubiquitinated proteins within a cell-using mass spectrometry-based proteomics. Notably, over 50,000 conjugation sites have now been reported. In this review, we discuss recent proteomics methods used to expand our knowledge of the ubiquitin proteasome system through the identification of ubiquitination sites, poly-ubiquitin chain types, and E3 ubiquitin ligase substrates.

Stable isotope dimethyl labelling for quantitative proteomics and beyond

Stable-isotope reductive dimethylation, a cost-effective, simple, robust, reliable and easy-to- multiplex labelling method, is widely applied to quantitative proteomics using liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry. This review focuses on biological applications of stable-isotope dimethyl labelling for a large-scale comparative analysis of protein expression and post-translational modifications based on its unique properties of the labelling chemistry. Some other applications of the labelling method for sample preparation and mass spectrometry-based protein identification and characterization are also summarized.This article is part of the themed issue 'Quantitative mass spectrometry'.

Proteomic techniques to probe the ubiquitin landscape

Protein ubiquitination is a powerful modulator of cellular functions. Classically linked to the degradation of proteins, it also plays a role in intracellular localization, DNA damage response, vesicle fusion events, and the immune and transcriptional responses. Ubiquitin is versatile and can code for several distinct signals, either by adding a single ubiquitin or forming a chain of ubiquitins on the target protein. The enzymatic cascade associated with the cellular process determines the nature of the modification. Numerous efforts have been made for the identification of ubiquitin acceptor sites in the target proteins using genetic, biochemical or MS-based proteomic methods, such as affinity-based enrichment of ubiquitinated proteins, and antibody-based enrichment of modified peptides. Modern instrumentation enables quantitative MS strategies to identify and characterize hundreds of ubiquitin substrates in a single analysis making it the dominant method for ubiquitin site detection. Characterization of the interubiquitin connectivity in ubiquitin polymers has also moved into focus, with the field of targeted proteomics techniques proving invaluable for identifying and quantifying linkage types found in such polyubiquitin chains. This review seeks to provide an overview of the many MS-based proteomics techniques available for exploring this dynamic field.

The application of targeted mass spectrometry-based strategies to the detection and localization of post-translational modifications

This review describes some of the more interesting and imaginative ways in which mass spectrometry has been utilized to study a number of important post-translational modifications over the past two decades; from circa 1990 to 2013. A diverse range of modifications is covered, including citrullination, sulfation, hydroxylation and sumoylation. A summary of the biological role of each modification described, along with some brief mechanistic detail, is also included. Emphasis has been placed on strategies specifically aimed at detecting target modifications, as opposed to more serendipitous modification discovery approaches, which rely upon straightforward product ion scanning methods. The authors have intentionally excluded from this review both phosphorylation and glycosylation since these major modifications have been extensively reviewed elsewhere.

Review of methods to assign the nuclear magnetic resonance peaks of reductively methylated proteins

Reductive methylation of lysyl side-chain amines has been a successful tool in the advancement of high-resolution structural biology. The utility of this method has continuously gained ground as a protein chemical modification, first as a tool to aid protein crystallization and later as a probe in protein nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy. As an isotope-labeling strategy for NMR studies, reductive methylation has contributed to the study of protein-protein interactions and global conformational changes. Although more detailed structural studies using this labeling strategy are possible, the hurdle of assigning the NMR peaks to the corresponding reductively methylated amine hinders its use. In this review, we discuss and compare strategies used to assign the NMR peaks of reductively methylated protein amines.

Mass spectral enhanced detection of Ubls using SWATH acquisition: MEDUSA--simultaneous quantification of SUMO and ubiquitin-derived isopeptides

Protein modification by ubiquitination and SUMOylation occur throughout the cell and are responsible for numerous cellular functions such as apoptosis, DNA replication and repair, and gene transcription. Current methods for the identification of such modifications using mass spectrometry predominantly rely upon tryptic isopeptide tag generation followed by database searching with in vitro genetic mutation of SUMO routinely required. We have recently described a novel approach to ubiquitin and SUMO modification detection based upon the diagnostic a' and b' ions released from the isopeptide tags upon collision-induced dissociation of reductively methylated Ubl isopeptides (RUbI) using formaldehyde. Here, we significantly extend those studies by combining data-independent acquisition (DIA) with alternative labeling reagents to improve diagnostic ion coverage and enable relative quantification of modified peptides from both MS and MS/MS signals. Model synthetic ubiquitin and SUMO-derived isopeptides were labeled with mTRAQ reagents (Δ0, Δ4, and Δ8) and subjected to LC-MS/MS with SWATH acquisition. Novel diagnostic ions were generated upon CID, which facilitated the selective detection of these modified peptides. Simultaneous MS-based and MS/MS-based relative quantification was demonstrated for both Ub and SUMO-derived isopeptides across three channels in a background of mTRAQ-labeled Escherichia coli digest.

Chemically facilitating the generation of diagnostic ions from SUMO(2/3) remnant isopeptides

RATIONALE

Mapping sites of wild-type SUMO modification is a challenging endeavour. Here we postulate that a combination of chemical derivatistation and collision-induced dissociation (CID) could be used to generate SUMO remnant diagnostic ions to aid both detection of these isopeptides and increase the analytical value of the product ion spectra required to characterize the nature and position of modification.

METHODS

SUMO(2/3)ylated proteins were digested with trypsin to generate isopeptides bearing TGG and QTGG isotags. The resulting digests were then dimethyl labelled followed by liquid chromatography/tandem mass spectrometry (LC/MS/MS) utilising CID in a data-dependent acquisition on a QSTAR XL. Product ion spectra were interrogated for the presence of iso-N-terminal fragment ions in addition to backbone sequence ions. The ability to diagnostically detect these isopeptides was tested by generation of co-XICs of the iso-N-terminal fragments in a semi-complex background.

RESULTS

Dimethyl labelling facilitated the robust detection of a1', b2' & b3' (TGG isotag) and a1', b2' & b4' (QTGG isotag) ions. The abundance of both N-terminal and iso-N-terminal fragment ions, supported by dimethyl labelling, facilitated the generation of information-rich product ion spectra of these isopeptides to aid confident site assignment. Moreover, the diagnostic nature of the combined XICs of the iso-N-terminal fragments supported detection of the isopeptide signals from a semi-complex background.

CONCLUSIONS

A combination of dimethyl labelling and CID does indeed lead to the generation of SUMO remnant isopeptide product ion spectra which are more analytically rich. This enables an improvement in characterization of both the isotag and backbone sequences and the site of modification. The diagnostic value of iso-N-terminal fragment ions allows for post-acquisition XIC interrogation to detect putative isopeptides of interest.