Current Educational Practices for Major Neurocognitive Disorders in Psychiatry: a Scoping Review

Clinical Care of Patients with Neurocognitive Disorders: A Qualitative Study of the Psychiatric Residency Training Experience

OBJECTIVE

Few data describe how general psychiatry residencies prepare trainees to care for individuals with neurocognitive disorders (NCDs), despite increasing recognition of the need for psychiatrists to provide care for the growing numbers of patients with NCD. This study aims to identify training needs and approaches, as the resident experience is one important perspective that can be added to others, such as milestones developed by expert educators.

METHODS

The authors conducted three focus groups of third- and fourth-year general adult psychiatry residency trainees from three different training programs in May and June of 2021. Focus groups consisted of three to eight unique participants per group. Qualitative data analysis techniques derived in grounded theory were utilized to identify themes.

RESULTS

Four main themes emerged from the focus groups: unique challenges of NCD care, intrinsic rewards of working with families, perceived gaps in educational experiences, and limited comfort in future practice.

CONCLUSIONS

Participants expressed that aspects of NCD care were fundamentally different than care for other mental health conditions encountered in psychiatry residency. They found the progressive nature of the disease to be particularly challenging, and they also expressed challenges with clinical interviews and establishing rapport with individuals with NCDs. However, working with families was especially rewarding. Regardless of training program, participants expressed a need for additional longitudinal and diversified training opportunities to prepare them for future practice in this area.

Geriatric Psychiatry Across the Spectrum: Medical Student, Resident, and Fellow Education

The older adult population in the United States is poised to reach 83.7 million by 2050, and up to 20% will suffer from cognitive and mental illnesses. We do not have the workforce available to meet this need; therefore, general psychiatrists will care for many older psychiatric patients. Enhancing learning opportunities during general medical education and residency could improve the knowledge of general psychiatrists and encourage recruitment into geriatric psychiatry. This article outlines geriatric psychiatry education in medical school, residency, and geriatric psychiatry fellowship with suggestions for recruitment into the field, along with recommendations for enhanced learning for general psychiatrists.

Evidence-oriented teaching of geriatric psychiatry: a narrative literature synthesis and pilot evaluation of a clerkship seminar

INTRODUCTION

The field of geriatric psychiatry has in recent decades developed into an independent discipline, incorporating elements of psychiatry, neurology and internal medicine. In view of demographic changes, this field is becoming increasingly relevant for primary care and undergraduate medical training. So far, however, there is little educational guidance for instructional design of geriatric psychiatry in undergraduate medical education.

PROJECT DESCRIPTION

A narrative literature review of medical education studies in the field of geriatric psychiatry was conducted. Student evaluations of a geriatric psychiatry clerkship seminar were analyzed, followed by a target group analysis. Results informed the iterative development of new clerkship seminar content and structure. This was implemented and evaluated over several academic cycles. Learning material was made available via the open-source learning management system "ILIAS".

RESULTS

A total of 29 medical education articles were identified and evaluated. The previous seminar in geriatric psychiatry at our university hospital was rated below average (Likert item overall rating of 4.3/6 compared to other seminars with an average overall rating of 5.2, p<0.001). An evidence-oriented revision of the content and instructional design was implemented. Activation of learners, self-reference effect, and audience questioning were used during the lecture. Additionally, two geriatric psychiatry case scenarios were adapted for discussion. We saw continuous improvement of student evaluations of the revised course, reaching a rating improvement of 5.3 out of 6 (p<0.01, U=135.5 Cohen's d=1.28).

CONCLUSION

A systematic approach was used to develop a geriatric psychiatry clerkship seminar, based on medical education evidence, for undergraduate medical students, resulting in better student evaluations. The teaching materials can be adapted for local implementation at other teaching hospitals. Future studies should also explore effects regarding higher learning outcomes.

Psychiatry Resident Education in Neurocognitive Disorders: a National Survey of Program Directors in Psychiatry

OBJECTIVE

As major neurocognitive disorders increase, little research has examined how psychiatry residents are prepared to provide neurocognitive care to patients.

METHODS

A national survey was sent to program directors of general psychiatry in the USA and Canada, including questions about satisfaction, attitudes, and graduation expectations for training in major neurocognitive disorders. The authors examined descriptive statistics and a series of chi-squared analyses by training setting, residency type, and presence of subspecialty fellowships. The authors also collected free text responses about perceived needs for enhancing training.

RESULTS

Program directors agreed that the scope of general psychiatry includes the evaluation of cognitive disorders (78.8%) and the treatment of cognitive symptoms (77.5%) and behavioral/psychological symptoms (78.8%). Required clinical rotations were the preferred method of teaching (63.7%), but didactics were most used (93.8%). The most frequently used clinical teaching setting was geriatric psychiatry (61.3%) and didactics were most frequently taught by geriatric psychiatrists (75.0%). Fifty-six percent were satisfied or very satisfied with their clinical training and 66.3% with their didactics. There were no significant differences in satisfaction or attitudes when compared by training setting, residency type, or presence of subspecialty fellowships. Additional trained faculty were most frequently listed as a need for improving clinical and didactic training.

CONCLUSIONS

Psychiatry program directors view major neurocognitive disorders as part of the scope of psychiatric practice. The majority of training is provided within psychiatry rotations, especially geriatric psychiatry. Program directors reported several unmet needs for optimal training, particularly related to clinical training services.