Prediction of subclinical perhexiline neuropathy in a patient with inborn error of debrisoquine hydroxylation

Can pharmacogenetics help rescue drugs withdrawn from the market?

Observations over the later half of the last century have suggested that genetic factors may be the prime determinant of drug response, at least for some drugs. Retrospectively gathered data have provided further support to the notion that genotype-based prescribing will improve the overall efficacy rates and minimize adverse drug reactions (ADRs), making personalized medicine a reality. During the last 16 years, 38 drugs have been withdrawn from major markets due to safety concerns. Inevitably, a question arises as to whether it might be possible to 'rescue' some of these drugs by promoting genotype-based prescribing. However, ironically pharmacogenetics has not perceptibly improved the risk/benefit of a large number of genetically susceptible drugs that are already in wide clinical use and are associated with serious ADRs. Drug-induced hepatotoxicity and QT interval prolongation (with or without torsade de pointes) account for 24 (63%) of these 38 drug withdrawals. In terms of the number of drugs implicated, both these toxicities are on the increase. Many others have had to be withdrawn due to their inappropriate use. This paper discusses the criteria that a drug would need to fulfill, and summarizes the likely regulatory requirements, before its pharmacogenetic rescue can be considered to be realistic. One drug that fulfils these criteria is perhexiline (withdrawn worldwide in 1988) and is discussed in some detail. For the majority of these 38 drugs there are, at present, no candidates for genetic traits to which the toxicity that led to their withdrawal may be linked. For a few other drugs where a potential candidate for a genetic trait might explain the toxicity of concern, the majority of patients who experienced the index toxicity had easily managed nongenetic risk factors. It may be possible to rescue these drugs simply by careful attention to their dose, interaction potential and prescribing patterns, but without the need for any pharmacogenetic test. In addition, the pharmacogenetic rescue of drugs might not be as effective as anticipated as hardly any pharmacogenetic test is known to have the required test efficiency to promote individualized therapy. Multiple pathways of drug elimination, contribution to toxicity by metabolites as well as the parent drug, gene-gene interactions, multiple mechanisms of toxicity and inadequate characterization of phenotype account for this lack of highly predictive tests. The clinical use of tests that lack the required efficiency carries the risks of over- or under-dosing some patients, denying the drug to others and decreasing physician vigilance of patients. Above all, at present, prescribing physicians lack an adequate understanding of pharmacogenetics and its limitations. It is also questionable whether their prescribing will comply with the requirements for pretreatment pharmacogenetic tests to make pharmacogenetic rescue a realistic goal.

Polymorphic hydroxylation of perhexiline in vitro

AIMS

The aims of this study were to examine the in vitro enzyme kinetics and CYP isoform selectivity of perhexiline monohydroxylation using human liver microsomes.

METHODS

Conversion of rac-perhexiline to monohydroxyperhexiline by human liver microsomes was assessed using a high-performance liquid chromatography assay with precolumn derivatization to measure the formation rate of the product. Isoform selective inhibitors were used to define the CYP isoform profile of perhexiline monohydroxylation.

RESULTS

The rate of perhexiline monohydroxylation with microsomes from 20 livers varied 50-fold. The activity in 18 phenotypic perhexiline extensive metabolizer (PEM) livers varied about five-fold. The apparent Km was 3.3 +/- 1.5 micro m, the Vmax was 9.1 +/- 3.1 pmol min-1 mg-1 microsomal protein and the in vitro intrinsic clearance (Vmax/Km) was 2.9 +/- 0.5 micro l min-1 mg-1 microsomal protein in the extensive metabolizer livers. The corresponding values in the poor metabolizer livers were: apparent Km 124 +/- 141 micro m; Vmax 1.4 +/- 0.6 pmol min-1 mg-1 microsomal protein; and intrinsic clearance 0.026 micro l min-1 mg-1 microsomal protein. Quinidine almost completely inhibited perhexiline monohydroxylation activity, but inhibitors selective for other CYP isoforms had little effect.

CONCLUSIONS

Perhexiline monohydroxylation is almost exclusively catalysed by CYP2D6 with activities being about 100-fold lower in CYP2D6 poor metabolizers than in extensive metabolizers. The in vitro data predict the in vivo saturable metabolism and pharmacogenetics of perhexiline.

Antiarrhythmic drugs and polyneuropathy. The Collaborative Group for the Study of Polyneuropathy

A total of 151 patients on chronic treatment with amiodarone and other antiarrhythmic drugs were subjected to standard clinical and electrophysiological investigation to assess the prevalence and specificity of polyneuropathy. Twenty two untreated patients with cardiac disorders and 246 normal subjects served as controls. Abnormal electrophysiological findings supporting the diagnosis of polyneuropathy were present in 38 subjects (25%) given antiarrhythmic drugs, with even distribution among drugs, and four untreated patients (18%). Concurrent clinical abnormalities were present in five treated patients (one each with amiodarone, propafenone, and flecainide, and two with multiple drugs). Therefore, electrophysiological abnormalities are a common, although non-specific, feature in patients taking antiarrhythmic drugs. Amiodarone users do not seem at higher risk of polyneuropathy than subjects treated with other drugs or even untreated patients with cardiac disorders.

Clinical significance of genetic influences on cardiovascular drug metabolism

Inherited differences in metabolism may be responsible for individual variability in the efficacy of drugs and the occurrence of adverse drug reactions. Among the cardiovascular drugs reported to exhibit genetic polymorphism are debrisoquine, sparteine, some beta-adrenoceptor antagonists, flecainide, encainide, propafenone, nifedipine, procainamide, and hydralazine. The implications of genetic differences in the metabolism of these drugs for cardiovascular therapeutics is the subject of this review.

The genetic polymorphism of debrisoquine/sparteine metabolism--clinical aspects

It has been established that the metabolism of more than twenty drugs, including antiarrhythmics, beta-adrenoceptor antagonists, antidepressants, opiates and neuroleptics is catalyzed by cytochrome P-450dbl. The activity of this P-450 isozyme is under genetic rather than environmental control. This article discusses the therapeutic implications for each of the classes of drugs affected by this genetic polymorphism in drug metabolism. Not only are the problems associated with poor metabolizers who are unable to metabolize the compounds discussed, but it is also emphasized that it is difficult to attain therapeutic plasma concentrations for some drugs in high activity extensive metabolizers.