Heart rate adjustment of ST-segment depression for reduction of false positive electrocardiographic responses to exercise in asymptomatic men screened for coronary artery disease

Diagnostic value of the recovery time-course of st slope on exercise ECG in discriminating false-from true-positive ST-segment depressions

BACKGROUND

Using the exercise ECG for diagnosing coronary artery disease (CAD) is hampered by the occurrence of false-positive (FP) ST-segment depression. Because it is known that the recovery ST-T time-course in CAD differs from that in FP subjects, the ST slope may help discriminate FP from true-positive (TP) results.

METHODS AND RESULTS

Treadmill digitized ECG from patients with significant ST-segment depressions and normal resting ECG were analyzed in 134 patients with CAD on angiography (>50% narrowing) and reversible perfusion defects (TP group), and 64 subjects with normal perfusion (FP group) on exercise single photon emission computed tomography. The ST slope between the J-point and J(80) was measured every minute up to 6-min postexercise. The ST slope was significantly higher in FP than in TP at peak exercise, and at postexercise 1-, 2- and 3-min (p<0.01, all). Thereafter, it gradually increased in TP, while monotonically decreasing in FP. Its decrease from 3- to 6-min could correctly diagnose 88% of FP subjects, whereas it was found in only 19% of TP patients (total accuracy 83%).

CONCLUSIONS

The ST slope change from early to late recovery is a simple yet reliable marker for discriminating FP from TP ST-segment responses in subjects with a normal resting ECG.

A new coronary artery disease index of treadmill exercise electrocardiograms based on the step-up diagnostic method

Treadmill exercise electrocardiography (ECG) is one of the most common noninvasive methods for detecting ischemic heart disease. However, this method has problems due to false-positive and false-negative results in a significant number of patients. The aim of this study was to determine whether the diagnostic accuracy of treadmill exercise ECG for detecting significant coronary stenosis can be improved by employing a step-up diagnostic method using multiple diagnostic indicators. We studied 273 consecutive patients (mean age, 56 +/- 9 years; 190 men and 83 women) without a history of myocardial infarction who underwent treadmill exercise ECG and coronary angiography for ischemic chest pain. Of these, 146 patients had no significant coronary stenosis, 61 had single-vessel disease, 56 had multivessel disease, and 10 patients had left main truncus disease. A multivariate logistic regression analysis was used to select 3 treadmill exercise electrocardiographic parameters that were independent predictors of the presence or absence of significant coronary stenosis: exercise-induced maximum ST-segment depression, QT dispersion immediately after exercise, and Athens QRS score. Significant coronary stenosis was diagnosed with a sensitivity of 84% and a specificity of 90% when a step-up diagnostic method using these 3 indicators was employed. These results were better than those obtained for each indicator alone (exercise-induced maximum ST-segment depression: sensitivity, 66%, and specificity, 73%; QT dispersion immediately after exercise [> or =60 ms positive]: sensitivity, 76%, and specificity, 86%; and Athens QRS score [< or =5 mm positive]: sensitivity, 72%, and specificity, 72%). We conclude that this step-up diagnostic method, using multiple diagnostic indicators, is a clinically useful predictor of the presence or absence of significant coronary stenosis.

Heart rate adjustment of exercise-induced ST-segment depression identifies men who benefit from a risk factor reduction program

BACKGROUND

Whether subjects identified as being at increased risk of coronary heart disease (CHD) death by heart rate adjustment of exercise-induced ST-segment depression will benefit from therapy aimed at reducing risk factors has not been examined.

METHODS AND RESULTS

Exercise ECGs were performed in 11,880 men from the Usual Care (UC) and Special Intervention (SI) groups of the Multiple Risk Factor Intervention Trial. UC men were referred to customary sources of care in the community; SI men received counseling on smoking cessation and dietary reduction of cholesterol, and stepped-care therapy for hypertension. An abnormal ST-segment response to exercise was defined according to standard criteria as > or = 100 microV of additional horizontal or downsloping ST-segment depression and by an ST-segment/heart rate (ST/HR) index >1.60 microV/bpm. After 7 years of follow-up, CHD mortality was significantly lower in SI than UC men with an abnormal ST/HR index (2.4%, 19/786 versus 5.3%, 39/729, P=.005) but was comparable in SI and UC men with a normal ST/HR index (1.6%, 84/5154 versus 1.3%, 70/5211, P=NS). Risk reduction in SI men with an abnormal ST/HR index was independent of age and other cardiac risk factors. In contrast, there was no significant difference in CHD death rate between the smaller groups of SI and UC men with an abnormal test by standard criteria (3.6%, 7/192 versus 2.7%, 5/186, P=NS).

CONCLUSIONS

An abnormal ST/HR index identifies men in whom therapy aimed at reducing CHD risk factors reduces the risk of CHD death by 61%. These findings support the application of heart rate adjustment of ST depression for screening of asymptomatic subjects at increased risk of CHD to identify those who will benefit most from risk factor-reduction programs.

Prognostic value of heart rate adjustment of exercise-induced ST segment depression in the multiple risk factor intervention trial

OBJECTIVES

We sought to assess the effect of heart rate adjustment of ST segment depression on risk stratification for the prediction of death from coronary artery disease.

BACKGROUND

Standard analysis of the ST segment response to exercise based on a fixed magnitude of horizontal or downsloping ST segment depression has demonstrated only limited diagnostic sensitivity for the detection of coronary artery disease and has variable test performance in predicting coronary artery disease mortality. Heart rate adjustment of the magnitude of ST segment depression has been proposed as an alternative approach to increase the diagnostic and prognostic accuracy of the exercise electrocardiogram (ECG).

METHODS

Exercise ECGs were performed in 5,940 men from the Usual Care Group of the Multiple Risk Factor Intervention Trial at entry into the study. An abnormal ST segment response to exercise was defined according to standard criteria as > or = 100 micro V of additional horizontal or downsloping ST segment depression at peak exercise. The ST segment/heart rate index was calculated by dividing the change in ST segment depression from rest to peak exercise by the exercise-induced change in heart rate. An abnormal ST segment/heart rate index was defined as >1.60 micro V/beats per min.

RESULTS

After a mean follow-up of 7 years there were 109 coronary artery disease deaths. Using a Cox proportional hazards model, a positive exercise ECG by standard criteria was not predictive of coronary mortality (age-adjusted relative risk [RR] 1.5, 95% confidence interval [CI] 0.6 to 3.6, p = 0.39). In contrast, an abnormal ST segment/heart rate index significantly increased the risk of death from coronary artery disease (age-adjusted RR 4.1, 95% CI 2.7 to 6.0, p < 0.0001). Excess risk of death was confined to the highest quintile of ST segment/heart rate index values, and within this quintile, risk was directly related to the magnitude of test abnormality. After multivariate adjustment for age, diastolic blood pressure, serum cholesterol and cigarettes smoked per day, the ST segment/heart rate index remained a significant independent predictor of coronary death (RR 3.6, 95% CI 2.4 to 5.4, p < 0.001).

CONCLUSIONS

Simple heart rate adjustment of the magnitude of ST segment depression improves the prediction of death from coronary artery disease in relatively high risk, asymptomatic men. These findings strongly support the use of heart rate-adjusted indexes of ST segment depression to improve the predictive value of the exercise ECG.

Asymptomatic coronary artery disease detection: update 1996. A screening protocol using 16-lead high-resolution ECG, ultrafast CT, exercise testing, and radionuclear imaging

The authors have proposed a new four-step screening algorithm to detect asymptomatic coronary artery disease (CAD) in flight school candidates, cadets, and rated flyers of the Unites States Air Force (USAF). In step 1, the USAF Armstrong Laboratory (USAF/AL) risk profile and improved 16-lead high-resolution electrocardiogram/vectorcardiogram will be recorded at baseline. On routine follow-up evaluations, quantitative serial comparisons will be performed by the method of Kornreich. In step 2, beginning with flight school candidates and cadets, all three groups will be studied by the ultrafast computed tomograph (CT) protocol. Those candidates positive for coronary calcium will be studied by coronary angiography and ventriculography, and their eligibility for continued rated flight status will be determined by present criteria. In step 3, those candidates negative for coronary calcium by ultrafast CT will then be screened by the newly defined and improved high-sensitivity treadmill exercise test criteria. In step 4, candidates with a positive treadmill exercise test result, or who are also found in the upper quintile of the USAF/AL risk profile, wild also have exercise nuclear wall motion studies and perfusion scans. If these are abnormal and suggestive of myocardial ischemia, this subset will also be studied by heart catheterization and coronary angiography, and their eligibility for continued rated flight status will be determined by present criteria. The incidence of coronary calcium/no calcium for each degree of stenosis in the 6,000 flyers in each quintile was used to develop the following projections: (1) that more than 3 of 4 rated flyers with unsuspected CAD, and (2) more than 9 of 10 with severe flow-limiting CAD can be identified by these upgraded screening procedures. Evidence is herein presented that these enhancements will result in a major (5-8-fold) increase in case finding of this disease. Based on the estimate of four lost high-performance aircrafts per year from sudden incapacitation of the pilot due to CAD, when this four-step screen is fully operational, it can be expected to reduce the $80 million annual losses to the United States government from CAD by 85%, a savings of $68 million per year.

Heart rate adjustment of ST segment depression and performance of the exercise electrocardiogram: a critical evaluation

Analysis of the rate-related change in exercise-induced ST segment depression using the exercise ST segment/heart rate slope and ST segment/heart rate index can improve the accuracy of the exercise electrocardiogram (ECG) for the identification of patients with coronary artery disease, recognition of patients with anatomically or functionally severe coronary obstruction and detection of patients at increased risk for future coronary events. These methods provide a more physiologic approach to analysis of the ST segment response to exercise by adjusting the apparent severity of ischemia for the corresponding increase in myocardial oxygen demand, which in turn can be linearly related to increasing heart rate. Solid-angle theory provides a model for the linear relation of ST segment depression to heart rate during exercise and a framework for understanding the relation of the ST segment/heart rate slope to the presence and extent of coronary artery disease. False positive and false negative test results of the heart rate-adjusted methods are well known in selected populations and require further clarification. Application of these methods is also highly dependent on the type of exercise protocol, number of ECG leads examined, timing of ST segment measurement relative to the J point and accuracy and precision of ST segment measurement. These methodologic details have been an important limitation to test application when traditional protocols and measurement procedures are required. When applied with attention to required details, the heart rate-adjusted methods can improve the usefulness of the exercise ECG in a range of clinically relevant populations.

Solid-angle theory and heart rate adjustment of ST-segment depression for the identification and quantification of coronary artery disease

Determinants of the ST-segment response to exercise can be mathematically modeled by solid-angle theory, and heart rate adjustment of the magnitude of exercise-induced ST-segment depression can remodel the solid-angle relationship to provide a theoretic and practical basis for application of heart rate-adjusted indexes of ST depression in exercise electrocardiography. Solid-angle theory indicates that the magnitude of ST depression recorded at a surface electrode (epsilon) can be described as the product of spatial and nonspatial determinants: epsilon = (omega/4 pi).(delta Vm).K (equation 1), where omega is the solid angle subtending the boundary of the ischemic territory, delta Vm is the difference in transmembrane voltage between the ischemic and adjacent nonischemic regions, and K is a term correcting for differences in intracellular and extracellular conductivity and changes in end-plate conductance. As a consequence, the magnitude of ST depression recorded by a surface electrode will be proportional both to the area of ischemic territory subtended by the recording electrode, which reflects the solid angle, and to the local transmembrane potential difference, which in turn reflects the electric consequences of the metabolic severity of ischemia at the level of the myocardial cell. It follows from equation 1 that the amplitude of ST depression can accurately reflect the area of ischemic boundary only when the severity of ischemia is constant or otherwise controlled, and differences in ST depression will only reflect varying areas of underlying ischemia when similar severity of ischemia is present. During exercise the severity of ischemia is directly proportional to changes in myocardial oxygen demand and coronary blood flow, which in turn are directly related to increasing heart rate (delta HR). Because the change in transmembrane voltage across the ischemic boundary is linearly proportional to delta HR, delta Vm/delta HR remains constant as ischemia develops. Dividing the solid-angle relationship in equation 1 by delta HR and making the appropriate substitution for a constant delta Vm/delta HR then indicates that epsilon/delta HR = (omega/4 pi).(c . K) [equation 2], where c is the new constant. Under conditions where changes in conductance are proportional or small, this simplified relationship reduces to delta ST/delta HR = c'.omega [equation 3], where delta ST reflects the magnitude of ST depression recorded by the surface electrode, delta HR the change in heart rate during developing ischemia, and c' the resulting empiric constant.

Population selection and performance of the exercise ECG for the identification of coronary artery disease

To quantify the effect of population selection on the performance of exercise ECG criteria for the detection of coronary artery disease, the exercise ECGs of 212 clinically normal nonvolunteer subjects, 31 patients with no significant coronary disease at angiography, 153 patients with clinically stable angina, and 184 patients with catheterization-proved coronary disease were examined. Test specificity was examined separately in clinically normal subjects and in patients with angiographically normal coronary arteries, and test sensitivity was determined separately in patients with stable angina and those with catheterization-proved disease. Definition and selection of normal and abnormal study populations had marked effects on test performance. Standard ECG criteria, a simple ST depression magnitude partition of 150 microV, an ST segment/heart rate (ST/HR) index partition of 1.60 microV/beat/min, and an ST/HR slope partition of 2.40 microV/beat/min, identified coronary disease with comparably high specificities (94% to 97%) in clinically normal subjects, but with significantly lower specificities (68% to 77%, p = 0.002 to 0.0001) in patients with angiographically normal coronary arteries. Although sensitivity was significantly lower in patients with stable angina than in patients with catheterization-proved coronary disease for standard criteria (54% vs 70%, p = 0.004) and for the ST/HR index (88% vs 95%, p = 0.04), there was no significant difference in the poor sensitivity of the simple ST depression magnitude criteria (51% vs 58%) or in the high sensitivity of the ST/HR slope (93% vs 96%) in these abnormal patient groups.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Value and limitations of heart rate-adjusted ST segment depression criteria for the identification of anatomically severe coronary obstruction: test performance in relation to method of rate correction, definition of extent of disease, and beta-blockade

Performance of the linear regression-based ST/HR (heart rate) slope, the simple ST/HR index, and ST segment depression alone for the identification of anatomically severe coronary obstruction was examined in relation to the definition of the extent of disease and the presence or absence of beta-blockade during treadmill exercise using the Cornell protocol in 172 catheterized patients. Whether severe disease was defined by three-vessel obstruction, by Gensini scores partitioned at 35 or at 48, or by Duke jeopardy scores exceeding 6, the 83% to 100% sensitivities of an ST/HR slope criterion of 6.0 microV/beat/min were each significantly higher than the corresponding 65% to 80% sensitivities of 150 microV of ST segment depression closely matched specificities. The ST/HR slope was significantly more sensitive than a simple ST/HR index criterion of 3.4 microV/beat/min for detection of high Gensini scores, but despite consistently intermediate performance trends, in no case did sensitivity of the simple ST/HR index criterion significantly exceed that of ST depression alone. Each method performed better and with comparable sensitivity in patients not receiving beta-blockers. In contrast, the 82% to 100% sensitivities of the ST/HR slope for identification of severe disease were significantly higher than the 63% to 77% sensitivities of ST depression in patients taking beta-blocking drugs; however, simple heart rate adjustment using the ST/HR index had intermediate performance that in no case was significantly more sensitive than ST segment depression alone.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Accuracy of ST/heart rate index in the diagnosis of coronary artery disease

The accuracy of ST/heart rate (ST HR) index was evaluated in patients presenting for exercise electrocardiography with suspected coronary disease. In all, 420 patients (235 men and 185 women) with normal electrocardiograms at rest underwent exercise testing, followed within 3 months by coronary angiography. The sensitivity and specificity for standard ST criteria (greater than or equal to 1 mm horizontal or downsloping depression) were 48% (78 of 162) and 81% (208 of 258), respectively. An ST HR-index threshold of 1.86 microV/beta/min had the exact same specificity with a sensitivity of 44% (71 of 162; p = not significant). Consideration of greater than or equal to 1.5 mm upsloping depression had no significant impact on the aforementioned results. Using multivariate logistic regression analysis, age, sex, symptoms, cigarette smoking, diabetes mellitus, qualitative ST slope, rate-pressure product, METs achieved and exercise angina were evaluated with and without ST HR index and ST depression. According to this analysis, age, sex, symptoms and ST slope were good predictors of presence or absence of disease. Neither ST HR index nor ST depression had significance in the multivariate analysis. However, when a separate analysis was performed in men and women, the 2 quantitative ST variables showed significance in men, but not in women. Comparisons of discriminative accuracy using receiver-operating characteristic curves demonstrated differences between men and women, but no difference between ST HR index and ST depression. Therefore, concerning questions of coronary disease diagnosis, consideration of ST HR index was not better than standard ST criteria, and added nothing to multivariate analysis of other available variables.

Identifying coronary artery disease in women by heart rate adjustment of ST-segment depression and improved performance of linear regression over simple averaging method with comparison to standard criteria

Performance of exercise electrocardiography for the detection of coronary artery disease (CAD) in women has been limited by relatively poor sensitivity and specificity of standard test criteria. Recent studies suggest that diagnostic methods incorporating heart rate (HR) adjustment of ST-segment depression during exercise may improve the accuracy of exercise testing in women, but the relative performance of different rate-adjusted methods for this purpose is unknown. To assess the effect of gender on relative test performance of the ST-segment/HR (ST/HR) slope, the simple ST/HR index, the HR-recovery loop, and standard ST-depression criteria for the identification of CAD, the exercise electrocardiograms of 254 patients with known or suspected CAD (67 women and 187 men) and of 150 clinically normal subjects (29 women and 121 men) were analyzed. Specificity of each method was comparable in men and women: ST/HR slope 98% (118 of 121) vs 97% (28 of 29), ST/HR index 97% (117 of 121) vs 97% (28 of 29), and HR-recovery loop 96% (116 of 121) vs 93% (27 of 29). In contrast, although there was no difference in sensitivity of the ST/HR slope (95% [177 of 187] vs 93% [62 of 67]; p = not significant [NS]) or HR-recovery loop (90% [168 of 187] vs 87% [58 of 67]; p = NS) between men and women, the ST/HR index was less sensitive for CAD in women than in men (82% [55 of 67] vs 93% [173 of 187]; p less than 0.05).(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Exercise-induced ST depression and ST/heart rate index to predict triple-vessel or left main coronary disease: a multicenter analysis

The aim of this investigation was to determine the difference in accuracy between two frequently published noninvasive indicators of severity of coronary artery disease (exercise-induced ST segment depression and heart rate-adjusted ST depression [ST/HR index]). The study was designed as a survey of consecutive patients undergoing exercise electrocardiography and coronary angiography. There were a total of 2,270 patients without prior myocardial infarction or cardiac valvular disease referred for angiography from eight institutions in three countries; 401 of these patients had triple-vessel or left main coronary artery disease. The sensitivities of ST depression and ST/HR index in detecting triple-vessel or left main coronary artery disease were, respectively, 75% and 78% (p = 0.08) at cut point values where their specificities were equal (64%). This small increase in the accuracy of the ST/HR index was evident only at peak exercise heart rates below the median value of 132 beats/min, where the sensitivities of ST depression and ST/HR index were 73% and 76% (p = 0.03), respectively, at cut point values corresponding to a specificity of 60%. These results were consistent at all eight participating institutions. The increase in accuracy achieved by dividing exercise-induced ST depression by heart rate is small and confined exclusively to a low exercise heart rate. This lack of superiority cannot be generalized to all methods of heart rate adjustment.

Heart rate adjustment of the time-voltage ST segment integral: identification of coronary disease and relation to standard and heart rate-adjusted ST segment depression criteria

To assess the effect of heart rate adjustment of the magnitude of the ST integral (ST-HR integral) on exercise test performance, the exercise electrocardiogram (ECG) of 50 clinically normal subjects and 100 patients with known or suspected coronary artery disease was analyzed. At matched specificity of 96% with standard ECG criteria (greater than or equal to 0.1 mV of additional horizontal or downsloping ST segment depression), an unadjusted ST integral partition of 16 microV-s identified coronary disease in the 100 patients with known or suspected disease with a sensitivity of only 41%, a value significantly lower than the 59% sensitivity of standard ECG criteria (p less than 0.01) and the 65% sensitivity of an ST depression partition of 130 microV (p less than 0.001). However, test performance of the ST integral was greatly improved by simple heart rate adjustment: at a matched specificity of 96%, an ST-HR integral partition of 0.154 microV-s/beat per min identified coronary disease in the 100 patients with a sensitivity of 90%, a value significantly greater than the 59% sensitivity of standard criteria and 65% sensitivity of ST depression criteria (each p less than 0.001) and similar to the 91% sensitivity of the ST-HR index and 93% sensitivity of the ST-HR slope (each p = NS). Comparison of receiver-operating characteristic curves confirmed the superior overall test performance of the ST-HR integral relative to the ST integral and ST segment depression, and demonstrated improved performance that was comparable with that of the ST-HR index and the ST-HR slope.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

A lesson from the controversy about heart rate adjustment of ST segment depression

To summarize the literature review, the heart rate adjustment appears to be able to perfectly discriminate patients with different numbers of diseased coronary vessels in one center, to increase the diagnostic accuracy of three-vessel or left main disease in eight centers, and unable to improve accuracy in seven centers. To explain those differences, several methodological and statistical biases have been considered. However, a recent report regarding the application of the method in eight centers and a meticulous literature review could not explain the superior performance in some laboratories.

Effect of ST segment measurement point on performance of standard and heart rate-adjusted ST segment criteria for the identification of coronary artery disease

BACKGROUND

Recent reports critical of the performance of heart rate-adjusted indexes of ST depression during exercise electrocardiography have used J-point rather than ST segment measurements. However, no standard exists for the optimal time after the J-point at which to measure ST segment deviation.

METHODS AND RESULTS

To assess the effect of ST segment measurement position on performance of standard exercise electrocardiographic criteria, the delta ST segment/heart rate (delta ST/HR) index, and the ST segment/heart rate (ST/HR) slope for the detection of coronary artery disease, the exercise electrocardiograms of 50 clinically normal subjects and 80 patients with known or likely coronary disease were analyzed using ST depression measured at both the J-point and at 60 msec after the J-point (J + 60). A positive exercise electrocardiogram by standard criteria, defined as 0.1 mV or more of additional horizontal or downsloping ST depression at end exercise, had a specificity of 96% when ST depression was measured at either the J-point or J + 60. There was no difference in sensitivity of standard electrocardiographic criteria at J + 60 and J point (both 59%, p = NS). However, at matched specificity of 96%, the delta ST/HR index and ST/HR slope calculated using ST depression at J + 60 were significantly more sensitive (90% and 93%) than when calculated using J-point depression (64% and 61%, each p less than 0.001). Comparison of areas under respective receiver operating characteristic curves confirmed the superior performance of J + 60 as opposed to J-point measurements for both the delta ST/HR index (0.98 versus 0.89, p = 0.006) and the ST/HR slope (0.96 versus 0.87, p = 0.007) and also demonstrated modestly improved overall test performance for standard electrocardiographic criteria using J + 60 measurements (0.88 versus 0.82, p = 0.001).

CONCLUSIONS

Use of J-point measurements significantly degrades performance of heart rate-adjusted indexes of ST depression but has less effect on standard criteria.

Heart rate adjustment of exercise-induced ST segment depression. Improved risk stratification in the Framingham Offspring Study

BACKGROUND

Simple heart rate adjustment of ST segment depression during exercise (delta ST/HR index) and the pattern of ST depression as a function of heart rate during exercise and recovery (the rate-recovery loop) have been shown to improve the ability of the exercise electrocardiogram to detect the presence of coronary heart disease (CHD), but the performance of these methods for the prediction of future coronary events remains to be examined.

METHODS AND RESULTS

We compared the delta ST/HR index and the rate-recovery loop with standard electrocardiographic criteria for prediction of CHD events in 3,168 asymptomatic men and women in the Framingham Offspring Study who underwent treadmill exercise electrocardiography and who, at entry, were free of clinical and electrocardiographic evidence of CHD. After a mean follow-up of 4.3 years, there were 65 new CHD events: four sudden deaths, 24 new myocardial infarctions, and 37 incident cases of angina pectoris. When a Cox proportional hazards model with adjustment for age and sex was used, a positive exercise electrocardiogram by standard criteria (greater than or equal to 0.1 mV horizontal or downsloping ST segment depression) was not predictive of new CHD events (chi 2 = 0.40, p = 0.52). In contrast, stratification according to the presence or absence of a positive delta ST/HR index (greater than or equal to 1.6 microV/beat/min) and a positive (counterclockwise) rate-recovery loop was associated with CHD event risk (chi 2 = 9.45, p less than 0.01) and separated subjects into three groups with varying risks of coronary events: high risk, when both tests were positive (relative risk 3.6; 95% confidence interval, 2.4-5.4); intermediate risk, when either the delta ST/HR index or the rate-recovery loop was positive (relative risk, 1.9; 95% confidence interval, 1.3-2.8); and low risk, when both tests were negative. After multivariate adjustment for age, sex, smoking, total cholesterol level, fasting glucose level, diastolic blood pressure, and electrocardiographic evidence of left ventricular hypertrophy, the combined delta ST/HR index and rate-recovery loop criteria remained predictive of coronary events (chi 2 = 5.45, p = 0.02).

CONCLUSIONS

Heart rate adjustment of ST segment depression by the delta ST/HR index and the rate-recovery loop during exercise electrocardiography can improve prediction of future coronary events in asymptomatic men and women.

Assessment of stable ischemic heart disease. Which tests are best for which patients?

An understanding of the importance of various risk factors, the pathogenesis of myocardial ischemia, and the appropriate use of various noninvasive and invasive tests is essential for management of patients with known or suspected coronary artery disease (CAD). Although coronary angiography remains the "gold standard" for diagnosis of CAD, much of the data obtained from risk factor assessment, medical history, and various noninvasive tests provides information that may be even more important than cardiac catheterization data alone for defining prognosis and directing management.

Effect of precision of ST-segment measurement on identification and quantification of coronary artery disease by the ST/HR index

To assess the effect of varying precision of ST-segment depression measurement on test performance of the ST-segment/heart rate (ST/HR) index for the identification and quantification of coronary artery disease, the exercise electrocardiograms (ECGs) of 100 clinically normal subjects and 154 patients with angiographically proved coronary disease were reviewed. The ST/HR index was calculated by dividing the maximal additional ST-segment depression at end exercise by the exercise-induced change in heart rate. ST-segment depression was measured to the nearest 10 microV (ST10) at a point 60 ms after the J point on a computerized exercise ECG system, and was subsequently rounded down to the nearest 50 microV (ST50) and the nearest 100 microV (ST100) to simulate measurements to these precisions. An ST10/HR index partition of 1.60 microV/bpm with a specificity of 95% (95/100) in normal subjects identified the presence of coronary disease with a sensitivity of 94% (144/154). Precision of ST-segment measurement significantly affected sensitivity for coronary disease. At matched specificity of 95%, an ST50/HR index partition of 1.55 microV/bpm had a sensitivity of 88% (135/154, p less than 0.01) and an ST100/HR index partition of 1.22 microV/bpm had a sensitivity of 84% (130/154, p less than 0.001) for the detection of coronary obstructions. Comparison of receiver-operating characteristic curves (ROC) confirmed the superior overall performance of the ST/HR index using ST10 measurements for the identification of coronary disease. By contrast, test performance for the identification of three-vessel coronary disease was not affected by the precision of ST-segment measurement with no significant difference in test sensitivity or areas under respective ROCs.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Clinical significance of simple heart rate-adjusted ST segment depression in supine leg exercise in the diagnosis of coronary artery disease

To evaluate the clinical significance of simple heart rate-adjusted ST segment depression (delta ST/delta HR) in the diagnosis of coronary artery disease, 42 patients with stable exertional angina underwent supine leg exercise testing and cardiac catheterization. During exercise, heart rate, a multilead electrocardiogram, and pulmonary artery wedge pressure were recorded. The sensitivity and accuracy of the delta ST/delta HR criteria (greater than or equal to 3.0 microV/beat/min) were significantly greater than the conventional analysis of ST segment depression criteria (greater than or equal to 0.2 mV) for detecting three-vessel coronary artery disease at a matched specificity of 72% (100% versus 46%, 81% versus 64%, p less than 0.01). A significant linear correlation was found between maximum pulmonary artery wedge pressure increments during exercise (delta PAWP) or Gensini score and the delta ST/delta HR (delta PAWP: r = 0.51, p less than 0.001; Gensini score: r = 0.47, p less than 0.001). There were no statistically significant differences in the delta PAWP or Gensini score between patients with three-vessel disease who had delta ST/delta HR greater than or equal to 3.0 microV/beat/min and those with one- or two-vessel disease who had delta ST/delta HR greater than or equal to 3.0 microV/beat/min (delta PAWP: 18.1 +/- 2.0 versus 21.9 +/- 3.3, p = NS; Gensini score: 68.5 +/- 6.6 versus 66.3 +/- 11.3, p = NS). These findings demonstrate that delta ST/delta HR is more useful than a conventional analysis of ST segment depression for identifying not only anatomically severe coronary artery disease but also functionally severe coronary artery disease.

ST changes in relation to heart rate during bicycle exercise in patients with coronary artery disease

Exercise test on cycle ergometer and coronary angiography were performed on 190 patients with chest pain. Volunteers with a normal thallium scintigraphy (n = 47) served as controls. The load started at 20 W and increased at a rate of 10 W min-1 until exhaustion or symptoms. Conventional 12-lead ECGs were recorded by means of computer before, during and after exercise. Minimum ST amplitude 60 ms after the STJ point (ST60) at end of work with a cut-off level of -1.10 mm had a sensitivity of 69% (52/75) and a specificity of 89% (37/42) when individuals with a normal resting ECG were considered. ST80 and sum of ST60 in left ventricular leads had slightly lower values of sensitivity and specificity. Changes in ST60 during exercise discriminated less well between the groups. Final heart rate during exercise (less than 148 min-1) had a sensitivity of 88% (53/60) and a specificity of 89% (42/47). The change in heart rate during exercise (less than 66 min-1) had a sensitivity of 50/60 (only patients without beta-blockers were considered). The best discrimination was obtained by defining a test score (TS) according to the linear equation TS = 2.95-0.23 x HRE-0.301 X ST60 where a positive value indicates a positive test and a negative value a negative test. Sensitivity and specificity were 21/23 (91%) and 40/42 (95%), respectively. The test score was also calculated in those patients having significant coronary disease and an abnormal resting ECG (no bundle branch block, no beta-blockers) and this yielded a sensitivity of 30/34.

Effect of baseline ST segment elevation on test performance of standard and heart rate-adjusted ST segment depression criteria

Whether the ST segment shift used to evaluate the presence and severity of myocardial ischemia should include the additional deviation due to decreasing amounts of baseline ST segment elevation was examined in 100 clinically normal subjects and in 124 patients with coronary disease. Exercise ST segment depression was calculated in two ways: as the difference between exercise and resting ST segment depression, but excluding any resting ST elevation (STdep), and as the total ST segment difference or excursion, including any baseline resting ST elevation (STdiff). These values were also used for separate calculation of the maximal ST/heart rate slope and delta ST/heart rate index in each case. Given partition values with matched specificity of 95% in clinically normal subjects, 150 microV of STdep was significantly more sensitive for coronary disease than 220 microV of STdiff (61% [76 of 124] versus 50% [62 of 124], p less than 0.005). Comparison of receiver operating characteristic curves confirmed the superior test performance of STdep for the identification of coronary disease in this population (area under the curve 0.920 versus 0.869, p = 0.0019). In contrast, detection of three-vessel coronary obstruction by standard ST segment criteria was not affected by definition of ST segment excursion. Substitution of STdiff for STdep did not change the performance of the ST/heart rate slope of the delta ST/heart rate index for either the detection of coronary disease or for the identification of three-vessel coronary obstruction.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Recovery-phase patterns of ST segment depression in the heart rate domain. Identification of coronary artery disease by the rate-recovery loop

Although the time course of ST segment depression after exercise has been related to the presence and severity of coronary artery disease, recovery-phase patterns of ST segment depression with reference to changing heart rate have not been quantified. We have found distinct recovery loop patterns of ST segment depression that distinguish subjects without coronary disease from patients with coronary artery disease when ST segment depression is examined in the heart rate domain. Continuous plots of ST segment depression and heart rate were constructed throughout treadmill exercise and recovery in 100 clinically normal subjects, in 124 patients with coronary artery disease proven by catheterization, and in 17 patients with no significant coronary disease at catheterization. Among clinically normal subjects, 95% (95 of 100) had normal (clockwise) rate-recovery loops, and 5% (five of 100) had abnormal (counterclockwise) rate-recovery loops. In these normal subjects, the resulting 95% specificity of a normal rate-recovery loop was similar to the 93% (93 of 100) specificity of standard end-exercise ST segment depression criteria. Among patients with coronary disease proven by angiography, 93% (115 of 124) had abnormal (counterclockwise) rate-recovery loops, and 7% (nine of 124) had normal rate-recovery loops. In contrast was the significantly lower 74% (92 of 124) sensitivity of standard ST segment criteria (p less than 0.001 vs. the rate-recovery loop). Specificity of a normal rate-recovery loop (71%, 12 of 17) and standard ST segment depression criteria (71%, 12 of 17) were similar in the patients with normal coronary arteries at angiography.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)