Comparison of exercise test responses before and after either percutaneous transluminal coronary angioplasty or coronary artery bypass grafting

Prognostic value of exercise thallium-201 imaging performed within 2 years of coronary artery bypass graft surgery

OBJECTIVES

We sought to determine the prognostic capabilities of exercise thallium (Tl)-201 tomographic imaging performed relatively early (within 2 years) after coronary artery bypass graft surgery (CABG).

BACKGROUND

Exercise testing is commonly performed after CABG, but few data exist demonstrating its prognostic value in this setting.

METHODS

Four hundred eleven patients were followed up for a median duration of 5.8 years. Eleven prospectively chosen clinical, exercise and Tl-201 variables were tested for their associations with outcome end points by means of proportional hazards regression models.

RESULTS

During follow-up there were 60 deaths from any cause, 53 initial cardiac deaths or nonfatal myocardial infarctions (MIs) and 22 late (>3 months after the Tl-201 study) revascularization procedures. The number of abnormal Tl-201 segments on the postexercise image was the only variable in the multivariate analyses to show a significant association with all three outcome end points: chi-square 7.3, p = 0.007 for overall mortality; chi-square 8.1, p = 0.004 for cardiac death or MI; chi-square 7.8, p = 0.005 for any cardiac event. Other independent predictors of outcome were exercise duration (chi-square 10.7, p = 0.001) and age (chi-square 3.9, p = 0.049) for overall mortality and exercise angina score (chi-square 8.7, p = 0.003) for cardiac death or MI. The 5-year survival rate free of cardiac death or MI was 93% for patients without angina and a normal image or small postexercise perfusion defect versus 71% for patients with angina and a medium or large defect.

CONCLUSIONS

Exercise Tl-201 imaging performed within 2 years of CABG can stratify patients into low and high risk subgroups.

Suitability and durability of multiple internal thoracic artery coronary artery bypasses

OBJECTIVE

The authors evaluate operative and extended outcomes of coronary artery bypass surgery using the bilateral internal thoracic arteries (ITAs) as bypass grafts. The authors conclude that the procedure is viable and of long-term benefit to most patients.

SUMMARY BACKGROUND DATA

Multiple ITA grafting was met with early enthusiasm by the surgical profession, but skepticism and controversy arose with reports of increased operative morbidity, insufficient graft blood flow, a high incidence of failure of the right ITA, and uncertainty about durability and long-term benefits.

METHODS

To assess the actual incidence and impact of these complications and long-term results, the authors prospectively studied 500 consecutive patients with multiple ITA bypasses, constituting the closely observed and carefully documented experience of one surgeon over an 11-year period.

RESULTS

Operative mortality in the series of 500 patients was 1.8%, perioperative myocardial infarction (new Q wave) rate was 0.6%, and deep sternal wound infection occurred in 1%. Six patients (1.2%) had strokes, and nine patients (1.8%) were returned to the operating room to control bleeding. One hundred ninety-eight patients who had abnormal stress test results before surgery were retested within 3 months of surgery. Ninety-four percent of these were normal, 3% were nondiagnostic, and 3% were abnormal. After a mean follow-up of 7.1 years (mode, 7.2 years), 87.5% of patients in the sample were alive, and 93.2% of this group have experienced continuing good clinical results (New York Heart Association class I or II). Eighty-nine patients who underwent an angiogram had 90.8% patency rates of ITA bypasses and 84.5% patency of vein grafts. Only two patients required repeat operations.

CONCLUSIONS

The operative results did not support the contention that the coronary artery bypass using ITA procedure produces higher than acceptable mortality and morbidity rates. Multiple ITA bypasses can be performed without excessive morbidity, with low reoperation rates and long-term outcomes that should encourage skeptics to reconsider the procedure's clinical value.

Clinical assessment following coronary revascularization

There remains a need to establish adequate protocols for investigating the short- and long-term follow-up of revascularization procedures. For coronary angioplasty the most reliable basis for decision-making in managing patients is the symptomatology of the patient. For bypass surgery a protocol should be established to evaluate patients late, at 5 to 10 years following bypass surgery, in particular those with saphenous vein grafting, as graft and patient survival begins to fall after this period. Investigation after this may be too late for many patients who may already have several occluded grafts and poor left ventricular function, two of the most important prognostic factors post bypass surgery. The improvement and refinement of non-invasive investigations has led to a better understanding of the value and limitations of many of these tests, but it is particularly important that the limitations of many investigation are fully appreciated when they are used to influence clinical decisions. In this regard, a study comparing and integrating the predictive value of the persistence or return to symptoms, a positive non-invasive test, and a positive invasive test would surely prove invaluable.

The effect of complete and incomplete revascularization on exercise variables in patients undergoing coronary angioplasty

To investigate the effects of complete and incomplete revascularization on the response to exercise, 25 patients underwent symptom-limited exercise testing with continuous assessment of gas exchange a mean of 5 +/- 4 days prior to and 18 +/- 12 days following percutaneous transluminal coronary angioplasty. All antianginal medications were discontinued for testing. Revascularization was considered complete if all stenoses were reduced to less than 50% diameter (13 patients), and incomplete if one or more stenoses remained (12 patients). Consistent improvements in ST-segment depression were observed after angioplasty at matched submaximal exercise levels (mean range 0.5-0.8 mm; p less than 0.05), and were accompanied by a reduction in angina. Significant increases in heart rate and systolic blood pressure were observed at peak exercise following angioplasty in both groups. Gas exchange variables were significantly improved at maximal exercise, with a similar increase in oxygen uptake observed in both groups following angioplasty (mean increase 3.3-3.7 ml/kg/min; p less than 0.01). Thus, incomplete revascularization following coronary angioplasty resulted in hemodynamic, electrocardiographic, symptomatic, and gas exchange responses to exercise that were comparable to complete revascularization.