Renal transplantation for patients with type I and type II membranoproliferative glomerulonephritis: serial complement and nephritic factor measurements and the problem of recurrence of disease

Clinical course and outcome after kidney transplantation in patients with C3 glomerulonephritis due to CFHR5 nephropathy

BACKGROUND

Complement factor H-related protein 5 (CFHR5) nephropathy is an inherited renal disease characterized by microscopic and synpharyngitic macroscopic haematuria, C3 glomerulonephritis and renal failure. It is caused by an internal duplication of exons 2-3 within the CFHR5 gene resulting in dysregulation of the alternative complement pathway. The clinical characteristics and outcomes of transplanted patients with this rare familial nephropathy remain unknown.

METHODS

This is a retrospective case series study of 17 kidney transplant patients with the established founder mutation, followed-up over a span of 30 years.

RESULTS

The mean (±SD) age of patients at the time of the study and at transplantation was 58.6 ± 9.9 and 46.7 ± 8.8 years, respectively. The 10- and 15-year patient survival rates were 100 and 77.8%, respectively. Proteinuria was present in 33.3% and microscopic haematuria in 58.3% of patients with a functional graft. Serum complement levels were normal in all. 'Confirmed' and 'likely' recurrence of CFHR5 nephropathy were 16.6 and 52.9%, respectively; however, 76.5% of patients had a functional graft after a median of 120 months post-transplantation. Total recurrence was not associated with graft loss (P = 0.171), but was associated with the presence of microscopic haematuria (P = 0.001) and proteinuria (P = 0.018). Graft loss was associated with the presence of proteinuria (P = 0.025).

CONCLUSIONS

We describe for the first time the clinical characteristics and outcome of patients with CFHR5 nephropathy post-transplantation. Despite the recurrence of CFHR5 nephropathy, we provide evidence for a long-term favourable outcome and support the continued provision of kidney transplantation as a renal replacement option in patients with CFHR5 nephropathy.

Recurrence of primary glomerulonephritis: Review of the current evidence

In view of the availability of new immunosuppression strategies, the recurrence of allograft glomerulonephritis (GN) are reported to be increasing with time post transplantation. Recent advances in understanding the pathogenesis of the GN recurrent disease provided a better chance to develop new strategies to deal with the GN recurrence. Recurrent GN diseases manifest with a variable course, stubborn behavior, and poor response to therapy. Some types of GN lead to rapid decline of kidney function resulting in a frustrating return to maintenance dialysis. This subgroup of aggressive diseases actually requires intensive efforts to ascertain their pathogenesis so that strategy could be implemented for better allograft survival. Epidemiology of native glomerulonephritis as the cause of end-stage renal failure and subsequent recurrence of individual glomerulonephritis after renal transplantation was evaluated using data from various registries, and pathogenesis of individual glomerulonephritis is discussed. The following review is aimed to define current protocols of the recurrent primary glomerulonephritis therapy.

Recurrence of membranoproliferative glomerulonephritis type II in renal allografts: The North American Pediatric Renal Transplant Cooperative Study experience

Membranoproliferative glomerulonephritis type II (MPGN II) is an uncommon form of complement-dependent acquired renal disease. Although it has been recognized since the 1970s that MPGN II recurs almost universally in renal transplants, data regarding the long-term consequences of disease recurrence are limited. Therefore, a retrospective comparative analysis of 75 patients with MPGN II contained in the North American Pediatric Renal Transplant Cooperative Study transplantation database was performed. Five-year graft survival for patients with MPGN II was significantly worse (50.0 +/- 7.5%) compared with the database as a whole (74.3 +/- 0.6%; P < 0.001). Living related donor organs had a significantly better 5-yr survival (65.9 +/- 10.7%) compared with cadaveric donor organs (34.1 +/- 9.8%; P = 0.004). The primary cause of graft failure in 11 (14.7%) patients was recurrent disease. Supplemental surveys were obtained on 29 (38%) of 75 patients. Analysis of these data indicated that recurrent disease occurred in 12 (67%) of the 18 patients with posttransplantation biopsies. Although there was no correlation between pretransplantation presentation, pre- or posttransplantation C3 levels, and either disease recurrence or graft failure, there was a strong association between heavy proteinuria and disease recurrence. The presence of glomerular crescents in allograft biopsies had a significant negative correlation with graft survival. At last follow-up, patients with recurrent disease had significantly higher serum creatinine and qualitatively more proteinuria than patients without biopsy-proven disease. These data indicate that recurrent MPGN II has a significant negative impact on renal allograft function and survival.

Long-term cyclophosphamide treatment for recurrent type I membranoproliferative glomerulonephritis after transplantation

The incidence of recurrent type I membranoproliferative glomerulonephritis (MPGN) after renal transplant is approximately 30%, and the rate of graft loss due to recurrent MPGN type I is higher than 50%. The treatment of this disease has not been defined. We report a case of recurrent MPGN type diagnosed 4 months after a cadaveric renal transplantation. The patient was treated with cyclophosphamide and was able to maintain her graft function. Cyclophosphamide was interrupted three times during the course. Each time her renal function deteriorated and her serum albumin decreased. The patient currently has a functional renal graft 3 years after transplantation while receiving low-dose therapy with cyclophosphamide. We suggest treating recurrent type I MPGN with cyclophosphamide while continuing the calcineurin inhibitor and prednisone.

Recurrence of type I membranoproliferative glomerulonephritis after renal transplantation: analysis of the incidence, risk factors, and impact on graft survival

BACKGROUND

The information in the medical literature on the incidence of recurrence of type I membranoproliferative glomerulonephritis (MPGN) after renal transplantation and its impact on graft survival is limited because most data are derived from case reports or from studies involving a small number of patients.

METHODS

We analyzed the data from our transplant center. Among 1097 adult patients receiving their first allograft between 1977 and 1994, we identified 32 patients with type I MPGN.

RESULTS

A recurrence was detected in 9 of the 27 recipients of a first cadaveric graft (33%). The cumulative incidence reached 48% at 4 years after transplantation when patients with graft failure from other causes were censored. All patients with recurrent MPGN had clinically significant proteinuria (>1 g/24 hr) that was first observed at a median time of 20 months (range, 1.5-42 months) after transplantation. Graft survival was significantly worse in patients with recurrence as compared with patients without recurrence. Mean duration of graft survival after the diagnosis of recurrence was 40 months. We could not detect any clinical characteristics of patients or donors that were associated with recurrent disease. However, an increased risk of recurrence was observed in patients with the HLA haplotype B8DR3. Four patients received an HLA-identical graft from a living related donor. Recurrence occurred in three patients (75%), with ensuing graft loss in two. The only patient with a haploidentical living related graft did not have a recurrence. Five patients with a recurrence in the first graft received a second transplant. Recurrence was observed in four of these patients (80%).

CONCLUSIONS

Type I MPGN recurred after renal transplantation in half of the patients. The incidence may be even higher in recipients of an identical living related donor graft and in patients receiving a second transplant after having experienced a recurrence in their first graft. Recurrence of type I MPGN has a detrimental effect on graft survival.

The primary glomerulopathies

Disorders of glomerular structure and function are encountered frequently in clinical medicine. Many arise as part of a well-defined multisystem or multi-organ disease process, while in others the clinical and laboratory manifestations are consequent to the sole or predominant involvement of glomeruli. The latter are known as the primary glomerulopathies. These disorders can evoke a variety of clinical syndromes, including acute glomerulonephritis, rapidly progressive glomerulo-nephritis, nephrotic syndrome, "symptomless" hematuria and/or proteinuria, and chronic glomerulonephritis. The identification of underlying morphology, through the application of renal biopsy techniques, can provide useful information for both prognosis and treatment. Pathogenic mechanisms involved in the primary glomerulopathies are varied, but immunologic perturbations underlie many disease entities. This article describes the clinical features, pathology, natural history, and treatment of the main categories of primary glomerulonephritis, with emphasis on recent developments and practical aspects of diagnosis and management.

Recurrence of disease following renal transplantation

The diagnosis of recurrent renal disease after transplantation is dependent on an accurate and complete diagnosis of the initial cause of renal failure and a similar determination of the cause of graft failure. To be classified as recurrent, the disease in the renal graft must be identical to that seen in the native kidneys. Recurrence of disease accounts for less than 2% of all graft failures, but the overall incidence of recurrent disease is probably 5 to 10 times more common. The most frequent cause of recurrent disease is glomerulonephritis, which was first recognized to recur soon after renal transplantation was introduced. It was then recognized that a variety of metabolic disorders would recur, but it has taken 25 years of experience for a clear picture to emerge of recurrence in most conditions. No initial cause of renal failure poses a contraindication to at least one attempt at transplantation, although with Fabry's disease and oxalosis, a special assessment of the risks for the individual recipient is warranted. In some patients, experience has shown the need for a delay in the commitment to transplantation (eg, in those with anti-glomerular basement membrane [GBM] antibody glomerulonephritis or Henoch Schonlein purpura), the need for the choice of a particular immunosuppressive regimen (eg, in hemolytic uremic syndrome [HUS]), the need for avoidance of primary nonfunction (eg, in oxalosis), and the desirability of avoiding live kidney donation (eg, in heterozygote donors in Fabry's disease, high-risk recipients with focal glomerulosclerosis, and in recipients with HUS). Probably all types of glomerulonephritis recur, but with great variation in frequency and severity. In some forms of glomerulonephritis, recurrence may be frequent and definite on histopathological criteria but may only have a minor clinical expression (eg, dense deposit disease, anti-GBM antibody glomerulonephritis, IgA nephropathy), but in others, recurrence is less predictable yet it is clearly associated with premature graft failure (eg, focal glomerulosclerosis, membranous nephropathy). A common theme emerging is that where the initial glomerulonephritis is aggressive and causes kidney failure over a short time, recurrence is more likely, and when present, it will lead to graft failure with an increased frequency. Clinical manifestations, the frequency of recurrence, and the prognosis of the graft are now identified for most conditions. Unexpected observations have included the rarity of recurrent systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE), the immediate return of heavy proteinuria in focal glomerulosclerosis, and the predictable return of dense deposit disease.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

Ultrastructural histochemical investigations of "dense deposit disease". Pathogenetic approach to a special type of mesangiocapillary glomerulonephritis

Dense deposit disease is characterized by the presence of intramembranous dense deposits; their constituents are unknown but immunological and biochemical studies have demonstrated that they contain no gamma-globulins or any other plasma protein. In order to clarify the nature of the dense deposits better, we investigated their most distinctive character, (marked electron-density) by means of ultrastructural histochemistry techniques using thin sections from Formaldehyde fixed, OsO4 postfixed and Epon embedded specimens collected for diagnostic electron microscopy. The dense deposits have a higher osmium affinity than the lamina densa of normal basement membranes, and the electron-density is strictly osmium-dependent suggesting the presence of a lipid component. Further data, obtained using an extraction method for lipids, seems to confirm our hypothesis.

[Recurrence of the original disease in the transplanted kidney]

Recurrence of the original disease in the transplanted kidney is observed in 5.6%-9.3% of the patients. However, the clinical significance of recurrence is often minor. Diagnosis is easy in diseases with specific renal lesions, e.g., in dense deposit disease and IgA-nephropathy, but may be difficult if such a marker is missing. Recurrence is of special clinical importance in the following conditions: Membranoproliferative GN type I (in 33%, often severe) and type II (= dense deposit disease, recurrence in 90%, often minor), focal segmental glomerulosclerosis (in 48% of patients with a rapid course (less than 3 years) and in 12% of patients with a longer duration of the original disease; often severe), membranous nephropathy (recurrence rather rare, but often serious), and primary hyperoxaluria (in 100%). Mesangial IgA deposits recur in half of the patients with IgA-nephropathy and anaphylactoid purpura, but clinical findings are often minimal. Recurrence in anti-GBM-nephritis and SLE is rare. The study of recurrence may contribute to a better understanding of many renal diseases.

Dense intramembranous deposit disease: new pathologic features

The pathologic and clinical features of 16 patients with dense intramembranous deposit disease are described. By light microscopy nine patients had membranoproliferative glomerulonephritis, five had focal segmental necrotizing glomerulonephritis with segmental epithelial crescents, four of whom also had a prominent tubulointerstitial nephritis, and two had focal segmental mesangial proliferative glomerulonephritis. The patients with membranoproliferative glomerulonephritis and one with focal segmental mesangial proliferative glomerulonephritis had easily recognizable dense intramembranous deposits by optical microscopy. The patients with focal segmental necrotizing glomerulonephritis and one with focal segmental mesangial proliferative glomerulonephritis did not have recognizable peripheral loop dense intramembranous deposits even under oil immersion. In patients with membranoproliferative glomerulonephritis ultrastructural examination revealed extensive capillary wall dense intramembranous deposits. Immunofluorescence revealed diffuse double linear staining along the capillary walls and "mesangial rings" of C3. In the patients with focal segmental necrotizing glomerulonephritis and one with focal segmental mesangial proliferative glomerulonephritis the immunofluorescence study suggested a diagnosis of dense intramembranous deposit disease because of the segmental double linear staining of the capillary walls and "mesangial rings" of C3, but the diagnosis was only established by fine structural analysis where occasional peripheral loop and prominent paramesangial basement membrane dense intramembranous deposits and mesangial nodular deposits were identified. Clinical features prior to biopsy included nephrotic syndrome in eight patients, an acute nephritic syndrome in six patients, and asymptomatic proteinuria and hematuria in two patients. Five of six patients with an acute nephritic presentation had focal segmental necrotizing glomerulonephritis. The acute renal insufficiency in these patients was transitory and appeared to be related to a prominent acute tubulointerstitial nephritis present in four of the biopsy specimens. Depressed serum C3 levels were present in patients with membranoproliferative glomerulonephritis; patients with focal segmental lesions were normocomplementemic. Because of the "atypical" light microscopic features in six of our patients, we support the suggestion that membranoproliferative glomerulonephritis, type II be replaced by the term 'dense intramembranous deposit disease' for this glomerulopathy with variable clinical and histologic features.

Status of renal transplantation. A clinical perspective

Although the survival of patients on chronic dialysis has improved in recent years, the quality and status of rehabilitation remains poor. Renal transplantation must be used to complement chronic dialysis in the management of these patients. Physicians should not be biased and commit their patients to one or the other form of long-term treatment.