Hemigastrectomy and truncal vagotomy in the treatment of duodenal ulcer. With a summary of related secretory data emphasizing preoperative basal acidity and postoperative basal-insulin achlorhydria

ODC, Módena JLP, Mente ED, Sankarankutty AK. DUODENOPLASTIA ASSOCIADA À VAGOTOMIA GÁSTRICA PROXIMAL NO TRATAMENTO DAS ÚLCERAS DUODENAIS ESTENOSANTES

A vagotomia gástrica proximal firmou-se como o procedimento de escolha no tratamento cirúrgico eletivo das úlceras duodenais crônicas, por ser a operação mais segura quanto à morbidade e mortalidade. Sua aplicação tem sido estendida às complicações da úlcera duodenal, mediante operação complementar que visa solucionar a complicação. Com o objetivo de avaliar a vagotomia gástrica proximal no tratamento das úlceras duodenais estenosantes os resultados clínicos de uma série consecutiva de 80 pacientes submetidos à vagotomia gástrica proximal e duodenoplastia (VGP + Dp) foram comparativos aos de uma série de 106 pacientes submetidos à vagotomia gástrica seletiva e antrectomia (VGS + A); os pacientes foram avaliados 2 a 16 anos após a cirurgia. As séries foram homogêneas quanto ao sexo e à idade. Cinco diferentes tipos de duodenoplastia foram realizados, de acordo com as características anatômicas do duodeno estenosado No grupo da VGS + A a reconstrução do trânsito alimentar foi gastroduodenal em 46 pacientes e gastrojejunal nos 60 pacientes restantes. O índice de mortalidade operatória foi de 1,2% com VGP + Dp e de 1,9% com VGS + A. Controle endoscópico pós-operatório demonstrou patência da luz duodenal e piloro conservado nos pacientes submetidos à duodenoplastia. A recorrência ulcerosa ocorreu em 5% após VGP + Dp e em 1,9% após VGS + A. Conclui-se que: 1. a duodenoplastia resolve a estenose duodenal sem dano do esfíncter pilórico, mantendo as vantagens da vagotomia gástrica proximal sem operação complementar de drenagem do estômago. 2 Na avaliação clínica global os melhores resultados foram obtidos com a vagotomia gástrica proximal. 3. A vagotomia gástrica proximal associada à duodenoplastia é uma boa opção de tratamento da úlcera duodenal estenosante.

A seven-year follow-up of proximal gastric vagotomy. Clinical results

During a 7-year period proximal gastric vagotomy (PGV) was performed in 565 patients. Of these, 210 patients with duodenal ulcer and 14 with dyspepsia without demonstrable ulcer at the time of operation were followed for 5--7 years. Sixty-six percent are symptom-free (Visick I), 23% have no complaints when they take certain dietary measures (Visick II), 3% are improved but still have periods of dyspepsia (Visick III), and 8% are failures because of recurrent ulcer (Visick IV). There were 4 duodenal, 3 pyloric, 5 prepyloric, and 7 lesser-curve gastric recurrences. There were one operative death (0.2%) and one major complication (0.2%). The side effects after PGV are mild, infrequent, and seldom of any significance to the patients. Diarrhoea and dumping are virtually eliminated. Body weight was stable during the whole period of study, and blood chemistry did not disclose any deficiency in haemoglobin, serum iron, or vitamin B12 which might be attributed to PGV. It is concluded that 5--7 years after proximal gastric vagotomy for duodenal ulcer there is a 10% recurrence rate, but the low risk of death and of severe complications and the lack of significant side effects more than outweight the high recurrence rate.

Surgery for duodenal ulcer. A study relating indications to the results of surgery

The present study correlates the indications for operation in 215 patients with duodenal ulcer disease with the results of operative management. The majority of patients had conservative surgery utilizing truncal vagotomy and pyloroplasty or gastrojejunostomy. None of the 194 patients operated on electively died and four patients died after emergency operations, for an overall operative mortality in the entire series of 1.8 per cent. The incidence of recurrent ulcer symptoms in all patients was 10 per cent. We could demonstrate only a modest correlation between indications for operation and long-term results of conservative surgical management; the indication for surgery, whether that of chronic (intractability, stenosis) or more acute (hemorrhage, perforation) ulcer disease is only moderately reliable as a predictor of long-term results. In this series of patients, those with obstructing duodenal ulcers (pyloric stenosis) had the best long-term results after conservative surgical management.

Changing trends in the surgical treatment of duodenal ulcer

On the basis of fully or partly controlled clinical trials the long term results of several standard operations for duodenal ulcer have been compared--subtotal gastrectomy, truncal vagotomy and antrectomy, truncal vagotomy and gastro-enterostomy, truncal vagotomy and pyloroplasty, selective vagotomy and pyloroplasty and proximal gastric vagotomy without drainage. Few statistically significant differences emerge but the following observations seems to be justified: (a) Subtotal gastrectomy and vagotomy and antrectomy probably offer better protection against recurrent ulceration than any of the other operations examined, but the greater intrinsic operative risks of these two resection procedures is emphasized. (b) Disturbances of alimentary function occur to a variable extent after all operations but appear to be least troublesome after proximal gastric vagotomy without drainage. In particular this operation is followed by a negligible incidence of diarrhoea compared with truncal vagotomy procedures. (c) On overall (Visick) grading the two resection operations and proximal gastric vagotomy without drainage do better than truncal vagotomy with drainage, proximal gastric vagotomy being specially notable for the relatively small proportion of patients in category 3 after its use. Surgical strategy in the choice of elevtive operation for duodenal ulcer is discussed.