Thromboembolic risk and late survival after mitral valve replacement with the St. Jude Medical valve

A Quarter Century Experience with Mitral Valve Replacement

Between January 1967 and August 1994 Starr-Edwards (Baxter Healthcare Corporation, Santa Ana, CA, USA) ball valve prostheses (model 6120) were implanted in 1129 patients whose ages ranged from 9 to 65 years (mean 29.5 ± 11.08 years). One hundred and ninety-three patients had a concomitant tricuspid valve repair and 36 underwent closure of an atrial septal defect. A closed mitral valvotomy had been carried out previously in 15%. The hospital (30-day) mortality rate was 10.9% (123/1129), which declined to 6.9% (32/461) in the last decade. The patients were administered warfarin to counter thrombogenesis and were regularly monitored with prothrombin time values. Over the last 10 years, aspirin was used as the sole anticoagulant in a cohort of 63 patients. Follow-up was achieved in 87% of cases; the follow-up period ranged from 1 to 25 years with a total follow-up of 8579.69 patient-years. Late death occurred in 132 patients. Anticoagulant-related hemorrhage occurred at a rate of 0.31 per 100 patient-years. Prosthetic valve endocarditis occurred at a linearized rate of 0.05 per 100 patient-years. The incidence of thromboembolic events was 0.5 per 100 patient-years. There was no incidence of structural valve dysfunction or prosthetic valve thrombosis. Forty young women subsequently delivered 47 healthy children. The long-term overall survival rate was 76.1% ± 3.17% at 20 years and 70.4% ± 4.31% at 25 years. These results confirm the long-term durability and superior thromboresistance of the Starr-Edwards ball valve. We conclude that this prosthesis is the device of choice for patients undergoing mitral valve replacement in Third World countries.

Choice of echocardiography method for postoperative evaluation of mitral valve replacement with a mechanical prosthesis

OBJECT

The French Cardiology Society (SFC) systematically recommends (Class I) transesophageal echocardiography (TEE) after any mitral valve replacement with a mechanical prosthesis (MMVR). Taking into account the increasing workload of echocardiography laboratories, our attitude was to propose that only post-operative transthoracic echocardiography (TTE) is performed. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the possible risks of this simplified procedure.

METHODS

We performed a precise analysis of one full year of practice of MMVR with exhaustive follow-up for the first 2 years concentrating on thromboembolic complications.

RESULTS

From January to December 2003, 84 MMVRs (46 after rheumatic fever, 22 degenerative disease, 11 infective endocarditis (IE) and 5 ischemia) were conducted in 45 women and 39 men of average age 61 years. Early mortality (<30 days) concerned 5 patients (5.9%). A control TTE to determine normal prosthetic function was performed 7+/-2 days after surgery and this revealed 2 cases of nonobstructive thrombosis which were treated medically, 3 cases of paraprosthetic regurgitation, and 1 vegetation due to underlying IE. Actuarial survival was 90.5% at 1 year and 83.3% at 2 years. After a mean follow-up of 179.3 patient-years, 5 patients were reoperated (5.9%): 1 for IE, 1 for paravalvular regurgitation, 1 for mitral valve insufficiency with haemolysis, and 2 for obstructive prosthetic valve thromboses. In addition there were 2 cases of prosthetic valve thrombosis, 8 ischemic strokes (2 ministrokes, 6 sequelar strokes), and 1 peripheral embolism. The global thromboembolic complication rate was therefore 6.1 per 100 patient-years (n=11). There were 4 hemorrhagic events, i.e. a rate of 2.2 events per 100 patient-years. 63% of the 1193 INR conducted were within the target range (3-4.5), 26% were below 3 and 11% were greater than 4.5. 35% of patients with thromboembolic complications had an INR<3.

CONCLUSION

Morbidity and mortality during the first 2 years after MMVR were relatively high but equivalent to the values of comparable series in the literature. These complications would not have been reduced by a more precise screening based on early TEE. Despite the increasingly litigious nature of the doctor-patient relationship, it would probably be excessive to oppose that this guideline was not followed in a dispute; in particular as it is difficult to apply this measure as echocardiography departments are overworked.

The optimal intensity of vitamin K antagonists in patients with mechanical heart valves: a meta-analysis

OBJECTIVES

The purpose of this study was to compare two different intensities of vitamin K antagonists (VKA) among patients with mechanical heart valves using meta-analytic techniques.

BACKGROUND

Patients with mechanical heart valves are at increased risk for valve thrombosis and systemic embolism, which can be reduced by VKA. The range of optimal intensity of VKA is still a matter of debate.

METHODS

A computerized search in the PubMed database was made for relevant articles. A meta-analysis was performed of all eligible studies with data on the incidences of thromboembolic and bleeding complications in patients with mechanical heart valve prostheses during different intensities of VKA therapy. The studies were classified into low-intensity VKA therapy (mean target international normalized ratio [INR] of 3.0 or lower) or high-intensity VKA therapy (mean target INR above 3.0).

RESULTS

Thirty-five eligible studies were identified, including in total 23,145 patients, who were studied for 108,792 patient-years. For patients with an aortic valve, high intensity resulted in a lower incidence of thromboembolic events (risk ratio [RR] = 0.73, p < 0.0001); however, the incidence of bleeding was increased (RR = 1.23, p < 0.0001). In the mitral valve group, the incidence rate for thromboembolism was lower in the high-intensity group (RR = 0.74, p < 0.0001), without a significantly increased bleeding incidence (RR = 1.08, p = 0.0524). The total number of thromboembolic and bleeding events was decreased in the high-intensity group compared with low-intensity VKA therapy for both aortic and mitral valve prostheses (RR = 0.94 [p = 0.0067] and 0.84 [p < 0.0001]), respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

This meta-analysis shows that both aortic and mitral valves will benefit from a treatment strategy with a target INR higher than 3.0.

Evaluating the etiology of mechanical valve obstruction: use of clinical parameters, fluoroscopy, and echocardiography

Prosthetic valve obstruction is a life-threatening complication most commonly caused by thrombus, pannus, or both. We report a St. Jude tricuspid valve obstruction, initially treated with thrombolytic therapy, found to be caused by pannus on pathologic examination. Clinical evaluation and diagnostic evaluation with fluoroscopy and echocardiography in distinguishing pannus from thrombus are reviewed.

Fifteen-Year Experience with Shanghai Disc Valve Prosthesis

Between 1983 and 1998, 168 Shanghai prosthetic heart valves were implanted in 122 patients (57 males, 65 females) aged 14 to 57 years (mean, 34 years). There were 69 mitral, 7 aortic, and 46 double valve replacements. Early mortality in each group was 8.7%, 14.3%, and 6.5%, respectively. Mean follow-up was 7.9 years (87.5% complete). There were 7 late deaths (5.7%); 2 in the mitral group, 5 in the double valve group. Five late deaths were considered valve-related. The 5-year actuarial survival rates were 96.8% for mitral, 100% for aortic, and 88% for double valve replacement. Preoperatively, 77.9% of patients were in New York Heart Association functional class III or IV, whereas postoperatively, 90.2% were in class I or II. No structural failure was observed. There were 3 cases of systemic and cerebral embolism, and 2 cases of valve thrombosis in patients who had ceased taking anticoagulants. Hemorrhage was the most frequent complication; 1 of 6 events was fatal. The very affordable Shanghai valve provided good hemodynamic performance with low thrombogenicity in patients receiving anticoagulants.

Early and long-term (one-year) effects of the association of aspirin and oral anticoagulant on thrombi and morbidity after replacement of the mitral valve with the St. Jude medical prosthesis: a clinical and transesophageal echocardiographic study

OBJECTIVES

The aim of the study was to test the value of low dose aspirin associated with standard oral anticoagulants (OAC) after mechanical mitral valve replacement (MMRV) to reduce strands, thrombi and thromboembolic events.

BACKGROUND

Strands and thrombi are thought to increase the risk of embolic events after MMVR, particularly in the immediate postoperative period.

METHODS

Two hundred twenty-nine patients were prospectively recruited: 109 patients (group A+) were randomly assigned to aspirin (200 mg per day) with OAC and 120 patients (group A-) to OAC alone (international normalized ratio 2.5 to 3.5). All patients were subjected to multiplane transesophageal echocardiography at nine days and five months and were followed up for one year.

RESULTS

At nine days and five months, there was a high and comparable incidence of strands in the two groups (group A+: 44%, 58%; group A-: 49%, 63%). However, the incidence of nonobstructive periprosthetic valve thrombi was significantly lower in group A+ at 9 days: 5% versus 13%, p = 0.03. Total thromboembolic events were reduced in group A+ (9% vs. 25%, p = 0.004) although there was an increased incidence of gastrointestinal hemorrhage (7% vs. 0%). Overall mortality was 9% in group A+ and 4% in group A-. Valve-related events were similar in both groups. Early thrombi, but not strands, were associated with higher morbidity, especially thromboembolic events (30% vs. 13%, p = 0.003).

CONCLUSIONS

One year after MMVR, the association of aspirin with OAC reduced thrombi and thromboembolic events, but not morbidity, due to an increase in hemorrhagic complications.

Left atrial appendage: structure, function, and role in thromboembolism

The left atrial appendage (LAA) is derived from the left wall of the primary atrium, which forms during the fourth week of embryonic development. It has developmental, ultrastructural, and physiological characteristics distinct from the left atrium proper. The LAA lies within the confines of the pericardium in close relation to the free wall of the left ventricle and thus its emptying and filling may be significantly affected by left ventricular function. The physiological properties and anatomical relations of the LAA render it ideally suited to function as a decompression chamber during left ventricular systole and during other periods when left atrial pressure is high. These properties include the position of the LAA high in the body of the left atrium; the increased distensibility of the LAA compared with the left atrium proper; the high concentration of atrial natriuretic factor (ANF) granules contained within the LAA; and the neuronal configuration of the LAA. Thrombus has a predilection to form in the LAA in patients with atrial fibrillation, mitral valve disease, and other conditions. The pathogenesis has not been fully elucidated; however, relative stasis which occurs in the appendage owing to its shape and the trabeculations within it is thought to play a major role. Obliteration or amputation of the LAA may help to reduce the risk of thromboembolism, but this may result in undesirable physiological sequelae such as reduced atrial compliance and a reduced capacity for ANF secretion in response to pressure and volume overload.

Bileaflet mechanical prostheses performance in mitral position

OBJECTIVE

The experience with the Carbomedics (CM) and the St. Jude Medical (SJM) bileaflet mechanical prostheses was evaluated to determine thromboembolic and hemorrhagic complications and predictive risk factors.

METHODS

From 1989 to 1994, a total of 625 patients had mitral valve replacement (CM, 240; SJM, 385); 32.5% (203), concomitant procedures and 32.8% (205), previous cardiac surgery, primarily valve replacement procedures.

RESULTS

The pre-operative variables did not distinguish the populations, except for previous surgery CM 37.9% and SJM 29.6% (P < 0.05). The pre-operative variables (type of prostheses, cardiac rhythm, coronary artery bypass, NYHA III/IV, advancing age, gender, urgency status and previous surgery) were not predictive of overall thromboembolism (TE), major TE, minor TE, prosthesis thrombosis and hemorrhage (P not significant; P = NS). The linearized rate of total TE events for overall MVR was 5.0%/patient-year (CM 4.4; SJM 5.4). The < or = 30 day major crude rate was 0.44%, while the > 30 day late major event rate was 2.0%/patient-year. Of the total TE events 91% of < or = 30 days and 75%, > 30 days had an INR < 2.5 at or immediately prior to the event. The thrombosis rate (included in TE events) was 0.63%/patient-year (ten events, four managed successfully with thrombolysis, five successfully with reoperation, and one fatality identified at autopsy). The freedom, at 5 years, from major/fatal TE, thrombosis and hemorrhage from anticoagulation was 88.2%, and 89.5% exclusive of early events.

CONCLUSIONS

This non-randomized prospective observational evaluation of the CarboMedics and St. Jude Medical prostheses has not revealed any differentiation in performance of the prostheses. The study serves as a single institution experience with the potential for future comparative evaluation.

Acute mechanical valve thrombosis of the St. Jude medical prosthesis

From 1986 to 1996, 2585 patients underwent valve replacement with the St. Jude medical prosthesis. Sixty experienced mechanical valve thrombosis. Seventeen of 60 patients (28.3%) had isolated aortic valve replacements, 33 had isolated mitral valve replacements (55%), and 10 had double valve replacements (16.7%) (aortic and mitral valve replacement). All patients who underwent reoperation for mechanical valve thrombosis were functional Class III or IV. Against medical advice, systemic anticoagulation with warfarin sodium had been discontinued or used only intermittently. Thus, anticoagulant activity was not adequate. The diagnosis of thrombosis was made by clinical examination, laboratory findings, and echocardiography and cineradiography. Of the 60 patients, 9 patients died early after surgery or before discharge. Most of the deaths were attributed to low cardiac output. The overall hospital mortality was 15%. The overall 10-year actuarial survival rate was 82.8+/-1.6%. In our study, reoperation for thrombosed mechanical prosthesis was not an independent parameter determining mortality. Age was the only statistically important hospital mortality predictor. Of this group, 90% suffered mechanical valve obstruction within the first 5 years after operation. These results suggest that valve re-replacement appears to be a suitable surgical treatment for thrombosis of mechanical prosthetic valves, especially in the young. In these patients subsequent anticoagulation management is necessary.

Evaluation of the Sorin bicarbon bileaflet valve in 488 patients (519 prostheses)

The Sorin bicarbon bileaflet prosthesis was introduced in 1990. To evaluate the clinical performance of this prosthesis, we reviewed 519 prostheses that were implanted in 488 patients (275 men, 213 women; mean age 59 years; SD 10.8, range 19 to 88) from 1993 to 1997. Preoperatively, 82% of patients were in New York Heart Association (NYHA) functional class III or IV. There were 263 aortic valve replacements (AVRs) (54%), 194 mitral valve replacements (MVRs) (40%), and 31 AVRs and MVRs (both) (6%). Concomitant procedures were performed in 82 patients (17%). Follow-up was complete in 471 (97%) with a total cumulative follow-up of 866 patient-years. The 30-day mortality for patients with AVR was 5.7% (95% confidence interval [CI] 2.9 to 8.5), MVR 17.5% (CI 9.9 to 19.7), and both 19% (CI 7.6 to 51.1), with no early valve-related deaths. Patient survival at 55 months was 76% (SE 2.27%), with patients with AVR being 90%, MVR 63%, and both 61%. This was influenced by the following: (1) valve position, which was higher for MVR (p = 0.0001); (2) poor NYHA functional class (p = 0.0006); (3) reoperation (p = 0.02); and (4) age >70 years (p = 0.0001). Valve-related complications (expressed as percentage per patient year and number of events) were major thromboembolism at 0.9% per year (8), with AVR rates being 1.2% per year (6) and MVR 0.7% per year (2); major hemorrhage at 2.3% per year (20) with AVR rates being 2.4% per year (12) and MVR 2.5% per year (7); bacterial endocarditis at 0.2% per year (2); and nonstructural dysfunction rate of 0.7% per year (6). The reoperation rate was 0.9% per year (8) with AVR being 0.6% per year (3) and MVR 1.7% per year (5). At 55 months, actuarial freedom from major thromboembolism was 97% (SE 1.1%) with AVR being 96% and MVR 98%; major hemorrhage 89% (SE 3.1%) with AVR being 88.6% and MVR 91%; structural valve dysfunction 100% (SE 0.0%); and reoperation 97.1% (SE 1.10%) with AVR being 98.5% and MVR 94.6%. At follow-up, 88% of survivors were in NYHA class I or II. In this series, hospital mortality and overall survival in patients were influenced by the patients' clinical characteristics. There were no early valve-related deaths. Valve-related complications were similar to previously reported series with no episode of structural failure. Our experience with the Sorin bicarbon bileaflet prosthesis suggests that it has a satisfactory clinical performance, with low complication rates.

Thrombosis of mitral valve prosthesis presenting as abdominal pain

A 67-year-old woman presented with abdominal pain, anemia, and leukocytosis. Five years previously, the patient had undergone mitral valve replacement with a St. Jude bileaflet mechanical prosthesis. After her admission, echocardiography confirmed an immobile leaflet of the prosthetic valve. At urgent surgery, thrombosis and pannus, obstructing the disc, were found, and the mechanical valve was replaced with a bioprosthesis. The incidence of mitral valve thrombosis is low, ranging from 0.1% to 5.7% per patient per year. Patients who receive inadequate anticoagulation, particularly with valve prostheses in the mitral position, have an increased risk for thrombus or pannus formation. Presentation varies, from symptoms of congestive heart failure or systemic embolization, to fever or no symptoms. New or worsening symptoms in a patient with a prosthetic heart valve should raise concerns about prosthetic dysfunction. Aggressive investigation and, if indicated, urgent or emergency surgery for treatment can be lifesaving.

Outcome analysis of 245 CarboMedics and St. Jude valves implanted at the same institution

BACKGROUND

Thromboembolism and valve-related death are major complications associated with prosthetic valve implants, but it is difficult to evaluate the relative incidence of these complications based on studies in which the implantation of only one valve is reported from any given institution. We therefore report the outcome of patients implanted at our institution during the same time period with either the recently released CarboMedics (CM) or the St. Jude Medical (SJ) valve prostheses.

METHODS

Between October 1994 and January 1996, 245 consecutive patients received either SJ (116 patients) or CM (129 patients) valves at our institution. Follow up of these patients was 99.6% complete, for a total of 318.5 cumulative patient-years (median follow-up, 1.4 years).

RESULTS

The 30-day mortality rates for SJ and CM implants were 3.4% and 3.1%, respectively. Actuarial survival and freedom from valve related mortality rates at 1.5 years for SJ and CM valves were 94%+/-2% versus 86%+/-3% (p = 0.03) and 100% versus 94%+/-2% (p = 0.005), respectively. There was no structural valve failure for either implant, but there were five thrombosed valves in the CM group and none in the SJ group (p = 0.04). All thrombosed valves were mitral (four mitral valve replacement, one aortic and mitral valve replacement). Two of the thrombosed valves were successfully explanted, whereas the three remaining patients died. Freedom from a thromboembolic event in the mitral position at 1.5 years, including thrombosed valves was 97%+/-3% and 83%+/-5% for SJ and CM valves, respectively (p = 0.04).

CONCLUSIONS

The results of this study suggest that further evaluation of thromboembolic outcomes after CM compared with SJ valve implantation is warranted.

Coronary embolism following aortic and mitral valve replacement: successful management with abciximab and urokinase

We report a case of coronary embolism in a 63-year-old woman with St. Jude aortic and mitral valve replacements who presented with acute myocardial infarction. Urgent catheterization revealed a saddle embolus in the proximal part of the circumflex and ramus arteries and another embolus in a diagonal branch. After employing angioplasty for the totally occluding diagonal embolus, a combined regimen of intracoronary urokinase and intravenous abciximab was successful in achieving complete resolution of the emboli.

Valve repair versus replacement for mitral insufficiency: when is a mechanical valve still indicated?

OBJECTIVES

Although many advantages of mitral valve reconstruction have been demonstrated, whether specific subgroups of patients exist in whom mechanical valve replacement offers advantages over mitral reconstruction remains undetermined.

METHODS

This study examined the late results of mitral valve surgery in patients with mitral insufficiency who received either a St. Jude Medical valve (n = 514) or a mitral valve reconstruction with ring annuloplasty (n = 725) between 1980 and 1996.

RESULTS

Overall operative mortality was 7.2% in the patients receiving a St. Jude Medical mitral valve and 5.4% in those undergoing mitral valve reconstruction (no significant difference); isolated mortality was 2.5% in the St. Jude Medical group and 2.2% in the valve reconstruction group (no significant difference). The follow-up interval was more than 5 years for 340 patients with a mean of 39.8 months (98.5% complete). Overall 8-year freedom from late cardiac death, reoperation, and all valve-related complications was 72.8% for the St. Jude Medical group and 64.8% for valve reconstruction group (no significant difference). For patients with isolated, nonrheumatic mitral valve disease, 8-year freedom from late cardiac death and reoperation was better in the mitral valve reconstruction group (88.3%) than in the St. Jude Medical valve group (86.0%; p = 0.05). Furthermore, Cox proportional hazards regression revealed that mitral valve reconstruction was independently associated with a lesser incidence of late cardiac death (p = 0.04), irrespective of preoperative New York Heart Association class. However, the St. Jude Medical valve offered better 8-year freedom from late cardiac death, reoperation, and all valve-related complications than did mitral valve reconstruction in patients with multiple valve disease (77.0% vs 45.3%; p < 0.01).

CONCLUSIONS

Therefore, mitral valve reconstruction appears to be the procedure of choice for isolated, nonrheumatic disease, whereas insertion of a St. Jude Medical valve should be preferred for patients with multiple valve disease.

Multiple mechanical valve replacement surgery comparison of St. Jude Medical and CarboMedics prostheses

OBJECTIVE

The experience with the St. Jude Medical (SJM) and CarboMedics (CM) bileaflet mechanical prostheses was evaluated to determine thromboembolic and hemorrhagic complications and predictive risk factors.

METHODS

From 1989 to 1994, a total of 246 patients had multiple valve replacement (SJM, 140; CM, 106); concomitant procedures 20.3% (50) [coronary artery bypass 10.6% (26)] and 53.7% (132) previous cardiac surgery, primarily valve replacement procedures. The pre-operative variables [coronary artery disease, previous cardiovascular surgery, concomitant procedures, valve lesion (except mitral stenosis), status, atrial fibrillation, and NYHA III/IV] did not distinguish the prosthesis-type (pNS).

RESULTS

The prosthesis-type and the pre-operative variables, including atrial fibrillation, were not predictive of overall thromboembolism (TE). The linearized rate of total TE events for overall multiple replacements (MR) was 5.4%/patient-year (minor, 2.52; major 2.85); the total TE for CM and SJM was 5.4%/patient-year, respectively. The < or = 30 day major TE crude rate was 0.82%, while the > 30 day major event rate was 2.7%/patient-year. Of the total (major and minor) TE events 100% (3) of < or = 30 days and 72% (29), > 30 days had an INR < 2.5 at or immediately prior to the event. The thrombosis rate (included in total TE events) was 0.67%/patient-year (4 events, 100% INR < 2.5). Of the various TE event categories the prosthesis-types (CM and SJM) were not differentiated (pNS). The freedom, at 5 years, from major/fatal TE, thrombosis and hemorrhage from anticoagulation was 89.3 +/- 3.8% for CM and 87.9 +/- 3.7% for SJM and, 91.3 +/- 3.5% and 89.3 +/- 3.7%, respectively, (pNS) exclusive of early events.

CONCLUSIONS

The performance of the CarboMedics and St. Jude Medical prostheses in multiple valve replacement surgery in this non-randomized prospective study revealed no significant differences in performance with regard to thromboembolic and hemorrhagic complications.

Appendage obliteration to reduce stroke in cardiac surgical patients with atrial fibrillation

BACKGROUND

Left atrial appendage obliteration was historically ineffective for the prevention of postoperative stroke in patients with rheumatic atrial fibrillation who underwent operative mitral valvotomy. It is, however, a routine part of modern "curative" operations for nonrheumatic atrial fibrillation, such as the maze and corridor procedures.

METHODS

To assess the potential of left atrial appendage obliteration to prevent stroke in nonrheumatic atrial fibrillation patients, we reviewed previous reports that identified the etiology of atrial fibrillation and evaluated the presence and location of left atrial thrombus by transesophageal echocardiography, autopsy, or operation.

RESULTS

Twenty-three separate studies were reviewed, and 446 of 3,504 (13%) rheumatic atrial fibrillation patients, and 222 of 1,288 (17%) nonrheumatic atrial fibrillation patients had a documented left atrial thrombus. Anticoagulation status was variable and not controlled for. Thrombi were localized to, or were present in the left atrial appendage and extended into the left atrial cavity in 254 of 446 (57%) of patients with rheumatic atrial fibrillation. In contrast, 201 of 222 (91%) of nonrheumatic atrial fibrillation-related left atrial thrombi were isolated to, or originated in the left atrial appendage (p < 0.0001).

CONCLUSIONS

These data suggest that left atrial appendage obliteration is a strategy of potential value for stroke prophylaxis in nonrheumatic atrial fibrillation.

Results with mechanical cardiac valvular prostheses

Mechanical cardiac valvular prostheses continue to be more popular than bioprostheses for heart valve replacement operations. Five different brands of mechanical heart valves are now approved for implantation in the United States: Starr-Edwards models 1260 and 6120, Medtronic-Hall, St. Jude Medical, Omniscience, and CarboMedics. Each model of mechanical valve has certain positive and negative attributes, but none is functionally mechanically perfect. A review of the published long term results with these valves favors the Medtronic-Hall and St. Jude Medical valves. A new method of assessing the thrombogenic potential and requirement for anticoagulation of the different mechanical valves, namely the composite thromboembolism and bleeding index, is proposed. Evaluation of the new index demonstrates a modest advantage for the Medtronic-Hall valve, particularly in the aortic position.