Protein transport in intact, purified pea etioplasts

Developmental regulation of protein import into plastids

The plastid proteome changes according to developmental stages. Accruing evidence shows that, in addition to transcriptional and translational controls, preprotein import into plastids is also part of the process regulating plastid proteomes. Different preproteins have distinct preferences for plastids of different tissues. Preproteins are also divided into at least three age-selective groups based on their import preference for chloroplasts of different ages. Both tissue and age selectivity are determined by the transit peptide of each preprotein, and a transit-peptide motif for older-chloroplast preference has been identified. Future challenges lie in identifying other motifs for tissue and age selectivity, as well as in identifying the receptor components that decipher these motifs. Developmental regulation also suggests that caution should be exercised when comparing protein import data generated with plastids isolated from different tissues or with chloroplasts isolated from plants of different ages.

Transit peptide design and plastid import regulation

Import of most nuclear encoded proteins into plastids is directed by an N-terminal transit peptide. Early studies suggested that transit peptides are interchangeable between precursor proteins. However, emerging evidence shows that different transit peptides contain different motifs specifying their preference for certain plastid types or ages. In this opinion article, we propose a 'multi-selection and multi-order' (M&M) model for transit peptide design, describing each transit peptide as an assembly of motifs for interacting with selected translocon components. These interactions determine the preference of the precursor for a particular plastid type or age. Furthermore, the order of the motifs varies among transit peptides, explaining why no consensus sequences have been identified through linear sequence comparison of all transit peptides as one group.

Plastid targeting strategies for cyanophycin synthetase to achieve high-level polymer accumulation in Nicotiana tabacum

The production of biodegradable polymers in transgenic plants is an important challenge in plant biotechnology; nevertheless, it is often accompanied by reduced plant fitness. In order to decrease the phenotypic abnormalities caused by cytosolic production of the biodegradable polymer cyanophycin, and to increase polymer accumulation, four translocation pathway signal sequences for import into chloroplasts were individually fused to the coding region of the cyanophycin synthetase gene (cphA(Te)) of Thermosynechococcus elongatus BP-1, resulting in the constructs pRieske-cphA(Te), pCP24-cphA(Te), pFNR-cphA(Te) and pPsbY-cphA(Te). These constructs were expressed in Nicotiana tabacum var. Petit Havana SRI under the control of the constitutive cauliflower mosaic virus (CaMV) 35S promoter. Three of the four constructs led to polymer production. However, only the construct pPsbY-cphA(Te) led to cyanophycin accumulation exclusively in chloroplasts. In plants transformed with the pCP24-cphA(Te) and pFNR-cphA(Te) constructs, water-soluble and water-insoluble forms of cyanophycin were only located in the cytoplasm, which resulted in phenotypic changes similar to those observed in plants transformed with constructs lacking a targeting sequence. The plants transformed with pPsbY-cphA(Te) produced predominantly the water-insoluble form of cyanophycin. The polymer accumulated to up to 1.7% of dry matter in primary (T(0)) transformants. Specific T(2) plants produced 6.8% of dry weight as cyanophycin, which is more than five-fold higher than the previously published value. Although all lines tested were fertile, the progeny of the highest cyanophycin-producing line showed reduced seed production compared with control plants.

Chloroplast protein translocon components atToc159 and atToc33 are not essential for chloroplast biogenesis in guard cells and root cells

Protein import into chloroplasts is mediated by a protein import apparatus located in the chloroplast envelope. Previous results indicate that there may be multiple import complexes in Arabidopsis. To gain further insight into the nature of this multiplicity, we analyzed the Arabidopsis ppi1 and ppi2 mutants, which are null mutants of the atToc33 and atToc159 translocon proteins, respectively. In the ppi2 mutant, in contrast to the extremely defective plastids in mesophyll cells, chloroplasts in guard cells still contained starch granules and thylakoid membranes. The morphology of root plastids in both mutants was similar to that in wild type. After prolonged light treatments, root plastids of both mutants and the wild type differentiated into chloroplasts. Enzymatic assays indicated that the activity of a plastid enzyme was reduced only in leaves but not in roots. These results indicated that both the ppi1 and ppi2 mutants had functional root and guard cell plastids. Therefore, we propose that import complexes are cell type specific rather than substrate or plastid specific.

Implications of a developmental-stage-dependent thylakoid-bound protease in the stabilization of the light-harvesting pigment-protein complex serving photosystem II during thylakoid biogenesis in red kidney bean

Intact etioplasts of bean (Phaseolus vulgaris) plants exhibit proteolytic activity against the exogenously added apoprotein of the light-harvesting pigment-protein complex serving photosystem II (LHCII) that increases as etiolation is prolonged. The activity increases in the membrane fraction but not in the stroma, where it remains low and constant and is mainly directed against LHCII and protochlorophyllide oxidoreductase. The thylakoid proteolytic activity, which is low in etioplasts of 6-d-old etiolated plants, increases in plants pretreated with a pulse of light or exposed to intermittent-light (ImL) cycles, but decreases during prolonged exposure to continuous light, coincident with chlorophyll (Chl) accumulation. To distinguish between the control of Chl and/or development on proteolytic activity, we used plants exposed to ImL cycles of varying dark-phase durations. In ImL plants exposed to an equal number of ImL cycles with short or long dark intervals (i.e. equal Chl accumulation but different developmental stage) proteolytic activity increased with the duration of the dark phase. In plants exposed to ImL for equal durations to such light-dark cycles (i.e. different Chl accumulation but same developmental stage) the proteolytic activity was similar. These results suggest that the protease, which is free to act under limited Chl accumulation, is dependent on the developmental stage of the chloroplast, and give a clue as to why plants in ImL with short dark intervals contain LHCII, whereas those with long dark intervals possess only photosystem-unit cores and lack LHCII.

Transit peptides play a major role in the preferential import of proteins into leucoplasts and chloroplasts

The in vitro import characteristics of six different precursors of plastid proteins were assessed to determine differences in the protein import pathways of leucoplasts and chloroplasts. Five of these precursor proteins are destined to different subchloroplast sites, and one is a leucoplast stromal precursor protein. The results indicate that some of these precursors can be imported equally into both plastid types and others preferentially into one type of plastid versus the other. The ability of plastids to import different proteins correlates with the in vivo steady state levels of these proteins. Additional differences were also observed in the intraorganellar portion of the translocation pathway for two thylakoidal proteins. The differences in import characteristics were found to be predominantly governed by information in the transit peptides, since attachment of the various transit peptides to different plastid and foreign proteins demonstrated that the import behavior of the proteins is transferable with the transit sequence. These results indicate that the import mechanisms of leucoplasts and chloroplasts are sufficiently different such that the plastids respond differently to the information present in the transit peptides.

A plastid enzyme arrested in the step of precursor translocation in vivo

The key enzyme of chlorophyll biosynthesis in higher plants, NADPH:protochlorophyllide (Pchlide) oxidoreductase (POR, EC 1.3.1.33), accumulates in its precursor form (pPORA) in barley. pPORA is bound to the chloroplasts and is able to interact with the enzyme's substrate, Pchlide, at both the cytosolic as well as the stromal side of the plastid envelope. The interaction with intraplastidic Pchlide, formed in ATP-containing chloroplasts upon feeding with -aminolevulinic acid, drives vectorial translocation of pPORA across the plastid envelope membranes. In contrast, exogenously applied Pchlide causes the release of the envelope-bound precursor protein to the cytosol. Both processes compete with each other if intra- and extraplastidic Pchlide are applied simultaneously. A cytosolic heat shock cognate protein of Mr 70,000 present in wheat germ and barley leaf protein extracts appears to prevent the release of the pPORA to the cytosol in vivo, however.

Thylakoid-bound proteolytic activity against LHC II apoprotein in bean

Triton X-100 solubilized thylakoids, isolated from Phaseolus vulgaris chloroplasts, degrade endogenous or exogenously added LHC II. The degradation, as monitored by immunodetection of the remaining LHC II after incubation at 37°C, is activated by Mg(++) and inhibited by pCMB, EDTA, PMSF and benzamidine; the activity under high light conditions parallels chlorophyll photooxidation. The thylakoid-bound proteolytic activity is under phytochrome control. Etiolated plants pretreated by a white light pulse, and kept in the dark thereafter, show enhanced proteolytic activity, which follows rhythmical oscillations. On the other hand, chloramphenicol pretreatment of etiolated plants, prior to their transfer to continuous light, reduces the proteolytic activity against LHC II. The results suggest that the degradation involves a serine type protease, which depends on SH group(s), coded by the plastid genome; the protease action on LHC II is regulated by Mg(++), phytochrome, the biological clock and chlorophyll accumulation in the thylakoid. The stroma lamellar fraction, separated from French press disrupted chloroplasts, exhibits higher activity towards exogenous LHC II than the grana fraction. The stroma of intact chloroplasts exhibits also high proteolytic activity, which is drastically reduced when the lysis medium is supplemented with cations. This suggests that the protease is bound mainly on stroma lamellae and peripheral granal membranes, its association to the membranes being possibly under cation control.

Subcellular location and expression level of a chimeric protein consisting of the maize waxy transit peptide and the beta-glucuronidase of Escherichia coli in transgenic potato plants

The transit peptide of the maize waxy protein (a nuclear-encoded amyloplast protein of the maize endosperm) was studied with respect to its role in subcellular protein targeting in transgenic potato plants. TP30, a chimeric precursor protein consisting of the waxy transit peptide and an additional 34 amino acids of the mature waxy protein fused to the beta-glucuronidase of Escherichia coli, was expressed in potato plants under the control of the 35S promoter of cauliflower mosaic virus. This fusion protein is imported not only into amyloplasts, the natural target organelles in the maize plant, but also into chloroplasts. In contrast, Gus, the beta-glucuronidase alone, which was also expressed in parallel experiments in transgenic potato plants is always found in the cytosol of the plant cells. As a consequence of the different subcellular locations of TP30 and Gus, we observed differences in the expression rates of the respective proteins in leaf cells, resulting in higher steady state levels of TP30 compared to Gus. In tuber cells, no correlation between intracellular location and expression of the proteins was found.

Optimization of delivery of foreign DNA into higher-plant chloroplasts

We report here an efficient and highly reproducible delivery system, using an improved biolistic transformation device, that facilitates transient expression of beta-glucuronidase (GUS) in chloroplasts of cultured tobacco suspension cells. Cultured tobacco cells collected on filter papers were bombarded with tungsten particles coated with pUC118 or pBI101.3 (negative controls), pBI505 (positive nuclear control) or a chloroplast expression vector (pHD203-GUS), and were assayed for GUS activity. No GUS activity was detected in cells bombarded with pUC118 or pBI101.3. Cells bombarded with pBI505 showed high levels of expression with blue color being distributed evenly throughout the whole cytosol of the transformants. pHD203-GUS was expressed exclusively in chloroplasts. We base this conclusion on: i) the procaryotic nature of the promoter used in the chloroplast expression vector; ii) delayed GUS staining; iii) localization of blue color within subcellular compartments corresponding to plastids in both shape and size; and iv) confirmation of organelle-specific expression of pHD203-GUS using PEG-mediated protoplast transformation. Chloroplast transformation efficiencies increased dramatically (about 200-fold) using an improved helium-driven biolistic device, as compared to the more commonly used gun powder charge-driven device. Using GUS as a reporter gene and the improved biolistic device, optimal bombardment conditions were established, consistently producing several hundred transient chloroplast transformants per Petri plate. Chloroplast transformation efficiency was found to be increased further (20-fold) with supplemental osmoticum (0.55 M sorbitol and 0.55 M mannitol) in the bombardment and incubation medium. This system provides a highly effective mechanism for introducing and expressing plasmid DNA within higher-plant chloroplasts, and the fact that GUS functions as an effective marker gene now makes many genetic studies possible which were not possible before.

Transient foreign gene expression in chloroplasts of cultured tobacco cells after biolistic delivery of chloroplast vectors

Expression of chloramphenicol acetyltransferase (cat) by suitable vectors in chloroplasts of cultured tobacco cells, delivered by high-velocity microprojectiles, is reported here. Several chloroplast expression vectors containing bacterial cat genes, placed under the control of either psbA promoter region from pea (pHD series) or rbcL promoter region from maize (pAC series) have been used in this study. In addition, chloroplast expression vectors containing replicon fragments from pea, tobacco, or maize chloroplast DNA have also been tested for efficiency and duration of cat expression in chloroplasts of tobacco cells. Cultured NT1 tobacco cells collected on filter papers were bombarded with tungsten particles coated with pUC118 (negative control), 35S-CAT (nuclear expression vector), pHD312 (repliconless chloroplast expression vector), and pHD407, pACp18, and pACp19 (chloroplast expression vectors with replicon). Sonic extracts of cells bombarded with pUC118 showed no detectable cat activity in the autoradiograms. Nuclear expression of cat reached two-thirds of the maximal 48 hr after bombardment and the maximal at 72 hr. Cells bombarded with chloroplast expression vectors showed a low level of expression until 48 hr of incubation. A dramatic increase in the expression of cat was observed 24 hr after the addition of fresh medium to cultured cells in samples bombarded with pHD407; the repliconless vector pHD312 showed about 50% of this maximal activity. The expression of nuclear cat and the repliconless chloroplast vector decreased after 72 hr, but a high level of chloroplast cat expression was maintained in cells bombarded with pHD407. Organelle-specific expression of cat in appropriate compartments was checked by introducing various plasmid constructions into tobacco protoplasts by electroporation. Although the nuclear expression vector 35S-CAT showed expression of cat, no activity was observed with any chloroplast vectors.

Recent developments in chloroplast protein transport

Most proteins located in chloroplasts are encoded by nuclear genes, synthesized in the cytoplasm, and transported into the organelle. The study of protein uptake by chloroplasts has greatly expanded over the past few years. The increased activity in this field is due, in part, to the application of recombinant DNA methodology to the analysis of protein translocation. Added interest has also been gained by the realization that the transport mechanisms that mediate protein uptake by chloroplasts, mitochondria and the endoplasmic reticulum display certain characteristics in common. These include amino terminal sequences that target proteins to particular organelles, a transport process that is mechanistically independent from the events of translation, and an ATP-requiring transport step that is thought to involve partial unfolding of the protein to be translocated. In this review we examine recent studies on the binding of precursors to the chloroplast surface, the energy-dependent uptake of proteins into the stroma, and the targeting of proteins to the thylakoid lumen. These aspects of protein transport into chloroplasts are discussed in the context of recent studies on protein uptake by mitochondria.