Vanadate-stimulated NADH oxidation by xanthine oxidase: an intrinsic property

Chemical, biochemical, and biological behaviors of vanadate and its oligomers

Vanadate is widely used as an inhibitor of protein tyrosine phosphatases (PTPase) and is routinely applied in cell lysis buffers or immunoprecipitations of phosphotyrosyl proteins. Additionally, vanadate has been extensively studied for its antidiabetic and anticancer effects. In most studies, orthovanadate or metavanadate was used as the starting compound, whereas these "vanadate" solutions may contain more or less oligomerized species. Whether and how different species of vanadium compounds formed in the biological media exert specific biological effect is still a mystery. In the present commentary, we focus on the chemical, biochemical, and biological behaviors of vanadate. On the basis of species formation of vanadate in chemical and biological systems, we compared the biological effects and working mechanism of monovanadate with that of its oligomers, especially the decamer. We propose that different oligomers may exert a specific biological effect, which depends on their structures and the context of the cell types, by different modes of action.

Decavanadate interacts with microsomal NADH oxidation system and enhances cytochrome c reduction

Oxidation of NADH with accompanying oxygen consumption (NADH:O(2) = 1:1) was observed in the combined presence of metavanadate (MV), decavanadate (DV) and microsomes. Oxygen consumption was negligible in the absence of MV, but NADH was oxidized and DV was reduced to a form of vanadyl-V(IV), colored blue like vanadyl sulfate but differed from it in having a 23-fold higher absorbance at 700 nm. DV can interact with the NADH oxidation system of microsomes as an electron acceptor, in addition to the known ferricyanide and cytochrome c. DV enhances rate of cytochrome c reduction significantly at microM concentrations. These studies indicate potential of DV as a redox intermediate.

Some radical queries

A little over 500 years ago, Vasco da Gama arrived on the west coast of India after the first direct sea voyage from Portugal with the intention of developing trade in spices, particularly in black pepper. Portugese took the merchandise, and much more; they ended up colonizing Goa. In 1999 delegates from all over the world came to this fabulous Goa for a symposium on antioxidants, some of which are natural products found in spices. Some views and queries on the interaction of antioxidants and radicals are presented.

NADH-dependent decavanadate reductase, an alternative activity of NADP-specific isocitrate dehydrogenase protein

The well known NADP-specific isocitrate dehydrogenase (IDH) obtained from pig heart was found to oxidize NADH with accompanying consumption of oxygen (NADH:O(2)=1:1) in presence of polyvanadate. This activity of the soluble IDH-protein has the following features common with the previously described membrane-enzymes: heat-sensitive, active only with NADH but not NADPH, increased rates in acidic pH, dependence on concentrations of the enzyme, NADH, decavanadate and metavanadate (the two constituents of polyvanadate), and sensitivity to SOD and EDTA. Utilizing NADH as the electron source the IDH protein was able to reduce decavanadate but not metavanadate. This reduced form of vanadyl (V(IV)) was similar in its eight-band electron spin resonance spectrum to vanadyl sulfate but had a 20-fold higher absorbance at its 700 nm peak. This decavanadate reductase activity of the protein was sensitive to heat and was not inhibited by SOD and EDTA. The IDH protein has the additional enzymic activity of NADH-dependent decavanadate reductase and is an example of "one protein--many functions".

A novel phenomenon of burst of oxygen uptake during decavanadate-dependent oxidation of NADH

Oxidation of NADH by decavanadate, a polymeric form vanadate with a cage-like structure, in presence of rat liver microsomes followed a biphasic pattern. An initial slow phase involved a small rate of oxygen uptake and reduction of 3 of the 10 vanadium atoms. This was followed by a second rapid phase in which the rates of NADH oxidation and oxygen uptake increased several-fold with a stoichiometry of NADH: O2 of 1:1. The burst of NADH oxidation and oxygen uptake which occurs in phosphate, but not in Tris buffer, was prevented by SOD, catalase, histidine, EDTA, MnCl2 and CuSO4, but not by the hydroxyl radical quenchers, ethanol, methanol, formate and mannitol. The burst reaction is of a novel type that requires the polymeric structure of decavanadate for reduction of vanadium which, in presence of traces of H2O2, provides a reactive intermediate that promotes transfer of electrons from NADH to oxygen.

Characterization of oxygen free radicals generated during vanadate-stimulated NADH oxidation

The oxidation of NADH and accompanying reduction of oxygen to H2O2 stimulated by polyvanadate was markedly inhibited by SOD and cytochrome c. The presence of decavanadate, the polymeric form, is necessary for obtaining the microsomal enzyme-catalyzed activity. The accompanying activity of reduction of cytochrome c was found to be SOD-insensitive and therefore does not represent superoxide formation. The reduction of cytochrome c by vanadyl sulfate was also SOD-insensitive. In the presence of H2O2, all the forms of vanadate were able to oxidize reduced cytochrome c, which was sensitive to mannitol, tris and also catalase, indicating H2O2-dependent generation of hydroxyl radicals. Using ESR and spin trapping technique only hydroxyl radicals, but not superoxide anion radicals, were detected during polyvanadate-dependent NADH oxidation.

Stimulation of NADH oxidation by xanthine oxidase and polyvanadate in presence of some dehydrogenases and flavin compounds

The rates of NADH oxidation in presence of xanthine oxidase increase to a small and variable extent on addition of high concentrations of lactate dehydrogenase and other dehydrogenases. This heat stable activity is similar to polyvanadate-stimulation with respect to pH profile and SOD sensitivity. Isocitric dehydrogenase (NADP-specific) showed heat labile, SOD-sensitive polyvanadate-stimulated NADH oxidation activity. Polyvanadate-stimulated SOD-sensitive NADH oxidation was also found to occur with riboflavin, FMN and FAD in presence of a non-specific protein, BSA, suggesting that some flavoproteins may possess this activity.

Oxidation of NADH by vanadium: kinetics, effects of ligands and role of H2O2 or O2

The mechanism of oxidation of NADH by either vanadium(V) or vanadium(IV) was examined in the presence of reducing agents, complexing agents, and hydrogen peroxide. Reducing agents that stimulate the oxidation of NADH by V(V) include: a variety of cysteine analogues, glutathione, beta-mercaptoethanol, dithiothreitol, and ascorbate. Complexing agents which stimulate NADH oxidation by V(V) include cystine, glutathione disulfide, and dehydroascorbate. Vanadium(IV)-dependent systems which oxidize NADH include combinations of V(IV) with cysteine or air alone. Combination of either V(V) or V(IV) with hydrogen peroxide leads to NADH oxidation. Based on kinetic analysis and the use of the diagnostic inhibitors--superoxide dismutase, catalase, albumin, mannitol, ethanol, and anaerobic conditions--we have assigned two major mechanisms of NADH oxidation. One is the previously reported mechanism which involves V(V)-superoxide as the NADH oxidant. This reaction is inhibited by superoxide dismutase and anaerobic conditions but not by catalase or ethanol. This reaction is observed for V(V) in the presence of reducing agents and complexing agents. The second reaction mechanism operates when V(IV) comes in contact with hydrogen peroxide and involves V(III)-superoxide as the NADH oxidant. This reaction is inhibited by catalase (if unligated hydrogen peroxide is an intermediate) and superoxide dismutase but not anaerobic conditions or ethanol. This mechanism is observed for reactions of V(IV) with air or hydrogen peroxide.

Vanadate-induced toxicity towards isolated perfused rat livers: the role of lipid peroxidation

The toxic potential of sodium orthovanadate towards isolated perfused rat livers was investigated at a dose of 2 mmol/l. In livers from fasted rats, vanadate led to a release of cytosolic (glutamate-pyruvate-transaminase (GPT) and lactate dehydrogenase (LDH] and mitochondrial (glutamate dehydrogenase (GLDH] enzymes, an accumulation of calcium in the liver, a marked depletion of hepatic glutathione and an enhanced release of it into the perfusate, as well as an augmented formation and release of thiobarbituric acid-reactive material by the liver. Furthermore, a marked inhibition of oxygen consumption was observed. Vanadate-induced vasoconstriction resulted in a progressive decrease in perfusate flow rate. Control experiments with similarly reduced flow rates led to a comparable reduction in oxygen consumption. GPT and LDH release and hepatic glutathione depletion were also evident, though to a lesser extent than in the presence of vanadate, but no increase in GLDH release, in tissue calcium content or TBA-reactive material in the liver or the perfusate were observed. Thus, indirect toxic effects due to a reduced flow rate contribute only partly to vanadate hepatotoxicity and do not affect mitochondrial integrity. Omission of calcium from the perfusate did not prevent hepatotoxic responses to vanadate, although less calcium was present in the treated livers than in the control organs, indicating that calcium influx is not involved in vanadate-induced hepatotoxicity in the intact organ, in contrast to isolated hepatocytes. Feeding the animals, resulting in an activation of anaerobic energy conservation reactions, strongly attenuated vanadate hepatotoxicity indicating that the energetic status of the liver is the main target of vanadate. Superoxide dismutase did not affect the hepatotoxic responses of livers from fasted rats towards vanadate, while allopurinol and deferrioxamine inhibited lipid peroxidation and hepatotoxicity due to vanadate. The strong correlation between induction of lipid peroxidation and hepatotoxicity and the inhibition of both processes in parallel by antioxidants are suggestive of a causative role for lipid peroxidation in vanadate-induced hepatotoxicity.

Hydroxyl radicals is not a significant intermediate in the vanadate-stimulated oxidation of NAD(P)H by O2

The vanadate-stimulated oxidation of NADH by an enzymatic flux of O2- is inhibited by superoxide dismutase, but not by catalase. Keller et al. (1989, Free Radical Biol. Med. 6, 15-22) observed inhibition by catalase presumably because they used a commercial preparation contaminated with superoxide dismutase. Their proposal, that H2O2 and hydroxyl radical play significant roles in vanadate-stimulation of NAD(P)H oxidation, may be discounted on the basis of these and of previously reported results.

Vanadate-dependent NAD(P)H oxidation by microsomal enzymes

Vanadate-dependent NAD(P)H oxidation, catalyzed by rat liver microsomes and microsomal NADPH-cytochrome P450 reductase (P450 reductase) and NADH-cytochrome b5 reductase (b5 reductase), was investigated. These enzymes and intact microsomes catalyzed NAD(P)H oxidation in the presence of either ortho- or polyvanadate. Antibody to P450 reductase inhibited orthovanadate-dependent NADPH oxidation catalyzed by either purified P450 reductase or rat liver microsomes and had no effect on the rates of NADH oxidation catalyzed by b5 reductase. NADPH-cytochrome P450 reductase catalyzed orthovanadate-dependent NADPH oxidation five times faster than NADH-cytochrome b5 reductase catalyzed NADH oxidation. Orthovanadate-dependent oxidation of either NADPH or NADH, catalyzed by purified reductases or rat liver microsomes, occurred in an anaerobic system, which indicated that superoxide is not an obligate intermediate in this process. Superoxide dismutase (SOD) inhibited orthovanadate, but not polyvanadate-mediated, enzyme-dependent NAD(P)H oxidation. SOD also inhibited when pyridine nucleotide oxidation was conducted anaerobically, suggesting that SOD inhibits vanadate-dependent NAD(P)H oxidation by a mechanism independent of scavenging of O2-.

Effects of vanadate on the oxidation of NADH by xanthine oxidase

Vanadate (V(V)) stimulates the oxidation of NADH by xanthine oxidase and superoxide dismutase eliminates the effect of V(V). Paraquat stimulates both the oxidation of NADH by xanthine oxidase and the V(V) enhancement of that oxidation. Xanthine, which is a better substrate for xanthine oxidase than is NADH, causes a V(V)-dependent co-oxidation of NADH which is transient and eliminated by SOD. Urate inhibits the V(V)-stimulated oxidation of NADH by xanthine oxidase or by Rose Bengal plus light. Measurement of rates of both O2- production and V(V)-stimulated NADH oxidation showed that many molecules of NADH were oxidized per O2-. These chain lengths were an inverse function of overall reaction rate. Minimum chain lengths, calculated on the basis of 100% univalent reduction of O2 to O2-, were smaller than measured average chain lengths by a factor of five. All of these results are in accord with the view that V(V) does not directly affect the activity of the enzyme, but rather catalyzes the free radical chain oxidation of NADH by O2-. It was further shown that phosphate was not involved and that the active form of V(V) was orthovanadate, rather than decavanadate.

Vanadate-stimulated oxidation of NAD(P)H

Vanadate stimulates the oxidation of NAD(P)H by biological membranes because such membranes contain NAD(P)H oxidases which are capable of reducing dioxygen to O2- and because vanadate catalyzes the oxidation of NAD(P)H by O2-, by a free radical chain mechanism. Dihydropyridines, such as reduced nicotinamide mononucleotide (NMNH), which are not substrates for membrane-associated NAD(P)H oxidases, are not oxidized by membranes plus vanadate unless NAD(P)H is present to serve as a source of O2-. When [NMNH] greatly exceeds [NAD(P)H], in such reaction mixtures, one can observe the oxidation of many molecules of NMNH per NAD(P)H consumed. This reflects the chain length of the free radical chain mechanism. We have discussed the mechanism and significance of this process and have tried to clarify the pertinent but confusing literature.

Occurrence of lipid peroxidation in brain microsomes in the presence of NADH and vanadate

Oxidation of NADH by rat brain microsomes was stimulated severalfold on addition of vanadate. During the reaction, vanadate was reduced, oxygen was consumed, and H2O2 was generated with a stoichiometry of 1:1 for NADH/O2, as in the case of other membranes. Extra oxygen was found to be consumed over that needed for H2O2 generation specifically when brain microsomes were used. This appears to be due to the peroxidation of lipids known to be accompanied by a large consumption of oxygen. Occurrence of lipid peroxidation in brain microsomes in the presence of NADH and vanadate has been demonstrated. This activity was obtained specifically with the polymeric form of vanadate and with NADH, and was inhibited by the divalent cations Cu2+, Mn2+, and Ca2+, by dihydroxyphenolic compounds, and by hemin in a concentration-dependent fashion. In the presence of a small concentration of vanadate, addition of an increasing concentration of Fe2+ gave increasing lipid peroxidation. After undergoing lipid peroxidation in the presence of NADH and vanadate, the binding of quinuclidinyl benzylate, a muscarinic antagonist, to brain membranes was decreased.

A study on the mechanism of the vanadate-dependent NADH oxidation

The mechanism of the vanadate (V(V]-dependent oxidation of NADH was different in phosphate buffers and in phosphate-free media. In phosphate-free media (aqueous medium or HEPES buffer) the vanadyl (V(IV] generated by the direct V(V)-dependent oxidation of NADH formed a complex with V(V). In phosphate buffers V(IV) autoxidized instead of forming a complex with V(V). The generated superoxide radical (O2-) initiated, in turn, a high-rate free radical chain oxidation of NADH. Phosphate did not stimulate the V(V)-dependent NADH oxidation catalyzed by O2--generating systems. Monovanadate proved to be a stronger catalyzer of NADH oxidation as compared to polyvanadate.

Vanadate-stimulated NADH oxidation requires polymeric vanadate, phosphate and superoxide

NADH oxidation, catalyzed by the microsomal enzyme system is stimulated on addition of polymeric vanadate. Maximum stimulation by polymeric vanadate was obtained in the presence of phosphate buffer. The small stimulation obtained by metavanadate (500 microM) increased on acidification followed by neutralization, or on adding a trace amount of polymeric vanadate (1 microM).

Peroxidative membrane damage in human erythrocytes induced by a concerted action of iodoacetate, vanadate and ferricyanide

Human erythrocytes incubated without substrate in the presence of iodoacetate (0.2 mM), vanadate (0.5 mM) and ferricyanide (5 mM) form aqueous membrane leaks of equivalent radii of 0.5-0.8 nm leading to complete colloid-osmotic lysis within 180 min. All three components are indispensable for the effect. Inosine but not glucose markedly enhances the rate of hemolysis. These effects are due to oxidative damage, as indicated by concomitant destruction of polyunsaturated fatty acids and suppression of both effects by radical scavengers. Hemoglobin is not oxidized under these conditions. GSH and membrane SH levels remain almost normal, and no crosslinking or irreversible aggregation of membrane proteins is observed. In the absence of O2 no membrane damage can be observed. It is proposed that radical formation originates from reduction of O2 by NADPH, analogous to processes described in microsomal membranes. NADH seems not to be involved, since leak formation occurs in spite of the blockage of NADH formation by iodoacetate. Vanadate and ferricyanide are probably required to amplify the peroxidative reaction sufficiently to overcome the cellular antioxidative capacity.

Vanadate-stimulated NADH oxidation in microsomes

Addition of vanadate, stimulated oxidation of NADH by rat liver microsomes. The products were NAD+ and H2O2. High rates of this reaction were obtained in the presence of phosphate buffer and at low pH values. The yellow-orange colored polymeric form of vanadate appears to be the active species and both ortho- and meta-vanadate gave poor activities even at mM concentrations. The activity as measured by oxygen uptake was inhibited by cyanide, EDTA, mannitol, histidine, ascorbate, noradrenaline, adriamycin, cytochrome c, Mn2+, superoxide dismutase, horseradish peroxidase and catalase. Mitochondrial outer membranes possess a similar activity of vanadate-stimulated NADH oxidation. But addition of mitochondria and some of its derivative particles abolished the microsomal activity. In the absence of oxygen, disappearance of NADH measured by decrease in absorbance at 340 nm continued at nearly the same rate since vanadate served as an electron acceptor in the microsomal system. Addition of excess catalase or SOD abolished the oxygen uptake while retaining significant rates of NADH disappearance indicating that the two activities are delinked. A mechanism is proposed wherein oxygen receives the first electron from NAD radical generated by oxidation of NADH by phosphovanadate and the consequent reduced species of vanadate (Viv) gives the second electron to superoxide to reduce it H2O2. This is applicable to all membranes whereas microsomes have the additional capability of reducing vanadate.

NADH-dependent polyvanadate reduction by microsomes

NADH-dependent reduction of polyvanadate was observed by using rat liver microsomes as the enzyme source. The reduced vanadate form obtained was blue in color with a broad absorption maximum in the red region around 650 nm. Microsomes and phosphate anions were found to be essential for polyvanadate reduction. The rate and the extent of formation of blue color compound was dependent on the amount of vanadate present. Cytochrome b5 was found to be involved in this SOD-insensitive reaction. The rate of disappearance of the blue-colored compound was dependent on concentration of NADH and was found to be sensitive to SOD. Catalase and Mn2+, which inhibit oxygen consumption accompanying NADH oxidation, increased both the rate and extent of the blue color compound formed. The results suggest that vanadate acts as an electron acceptor.