Partitioning of electrostatic and conformational contributions in the redox reactions of modified cytochromes c

Antihypertensive effect of mitochondria-targeted proxyl nitroxides

Superoxide (O2-•) has been implicated in the pathogenesis of many human diseases including hypertension. Mitochondria-targeted superoxide scavenger mitoTEMPO reduces blood pressure; however, the structure–functional relationships in antihypertensive effect of mitochondria-targeted nitroxides remain unclear. The nitroxides are known to undergo bioreduction into hydroxylamine derivatives which reacts with O2-• with much lower rate. The nitroxides of pyrrolidine series (proxyls) are much more resistant to bioreduction compared to TEMPOL derivatives suggesting that mitochondria-targeted proxyls can be effective antioxidants with antihypertensive activity. In this work we have designed and studied two new pyrrolidine mitochondria targeted nitroxides: 3-[2-(triphenyphosphonio)acetamido]- and 3-[2-(triphenyphosphonio) acetamidomethyl]-2,2,5,5-tetramethylpyrrolidine-1-oxyl (mCP2) and (mCP1). These new mitochondria targeted nitroxides have 3- to 7-fold lower rate constants of the reaction with O2-• compared with mitoTEMPO; however, the cellular bioreduction of mCP1 and mCP2 was 3- and 2-fold slower. As a consequence incubation with cells afforded much higher intracellular concentration of mCP1 and mCP2 nitroxides compared to mitoTEMPO nitroxide. This has compensated for the difference in the rate of O2-• scavenging and all nitroxides similarly protected mitochondrial respiration in H₂O₂ treated endothelial cells. Treatment of hypertensive mice with mCP1 and mCP2 (1.4 mg/kg/day) after onset of angiotensin II-induced hypertension significantly reduced blood pressure to 133±5 mmHg and 129±6 mmHg compared to 163±5 mmHg in mice infused with angiotensin II alone. mCP1 and mCP2 reduced vascular O2-• and prevented decrease of endothelial nitric oxide production. These data indicate that resistance to bioreduction play significant role in antioxidant activity of nitroxides. Studies of nitroxide analogs such as mCP1 and mCP2 may help in optimization of chemical structure of mitochondria-targeted nitroxides for improved efficacy and pharmacokinetics of these drugs in treatment of hypertension and many other conditions including atherosclerosis, diabetes and degenerative neurological disorders in which mitochondrial oxidative stress seems to play a role.

•

Nitroxides bioreduction into hydroxylamine can reduce their antioxidant properties.

•

Mitochondria-targeted proxyls are more resistant to bioreduction vs mitoTEMPO.

•

Intracellular concentration of mCP1 and mCP2 nitroxides is higher vs mitoTEMPO.

•

mCP1 and mCP2 diminished vascular superoxide and reduced hypertension.

Synthetic and natural polyanions induce cytochrome c release from mitochondria in vitro and in situ

A synthetic polyanion composed of styrene, maleic anhydride, and methacrylic acid (molar ratio 56:37:7) significantly inhibited the respiration of isolated rat liver mitochondria in a time-dependent fashion that correlated with 1) collapse of the mitochondrial membrane potential and 2) high amplitude mitochondrial swelling. The process is apparently Ca(2+) dependent. Since it is blocked by cyclosporin A, the process is ascribed to induction of the mitochondrial permeability transition. In mitoplasts, i.e., mitochondria lacking their outer membranes, the polyanion rapidly blocked respiration. After incubation of rat liver mitochondria with the polyanion, cytochrome c was released into the incubation medium. In solution, the polyanion modified by conjugation with fluorescein formed a complex with cytochrome c. Addition of the polyanion to cytochrome c-loaded phosphatidylcholine/cardiolipin liposomes induced the release of the protein from liposomal membrane evidently due to coordinated interplay of Coulomb and hydrophobic interactions of the polymer with cytochrome c. We conclude that binding of the polyanion to cytochrome c renders it inactive in the respiratory chain due to exclusion from its native binding sites. Apparently, the polyanion interacts with cytochrome c in mitochondria and releases it to the medium through breakage of the outer membrane as a result of severe swelling. Similar properties were demonstrated for the natural polyanion, tobacco mosaic virus RNA. An electron microscopy study confirmed that both polyanions caused mitochondrial swelling. Exposure of cerebellar astroglial cells in culture to the synthetic polyanion resulted in cell death, which was associated with nuclear fragmentation.

Electric charge distribution in proteins and ionic strength dependence of reaction rate

The ionic strength dependence of the reaction rate between protein and dichloride anion radical has been investigated by flash photolysis of aqueous chloride-containing lysozyme, ribonuclease A, or insulin. The rate constant for the reaction of lysozyme or ribonuclease A with dichloride anion radicals decreases with increasing ionic strength, while it increases for insulin. The dependence was found to obey an equation derived from the theory of Debye and Hückel or the equation of Wherland and Gray for lysozyme within experimental errors. For ribonuclease A, however, it deviates largely from these equations. In the case of insulin a moderate deviation was observed. The different behavior in the ionic strength dependence is discussed in terms of the electric charge distribution in the protein molecules.

Some electron-transfer reactions involving carbodi-imide-modified cytochrome c

The reaction kinetics of native and carbodi-imide-modified tuna and horse heart cytochromes c with both a strong (dithionite) and a relatively weak (ascorbate) reducing agent were studied over a wide range of conditions. In their reactions with dithionite both the native and modified cytochromes exhibit single exponential time courses. The effects of dithionite concentration and ionic strength on the rate of the reduction are complex and can best be explained in terms of the model proposed by Lambeth & Palmer [(1973) J. Biol. Chem. 248, 6095-6103]. According to this model, at low ionic strength the native proteins are reduced almost exclusively by S2O4(2-) whereas the modified proteins showed reactivity towards both S2O4(2-) and SO2.-. These findings are interpreted in terms of the different charge characteristics of the carbodi-imide-modified proteins relative to the native proteins. The findings that the modified proteins react with ascorbate in a biphasic manner are explained as arising from ascorbate binding to a reducible form of the protein, before electron transfer, with an equilibrium between the ascorbate-reducible form of the protein and a non-reducible form. Estimates were obtained for both the ascorbate equilibrium binding constant and the rate constant for the internal electron transfer for both the native and modified horse and tuna proteins. The effect of pH on the reactions indicates that the active reductant in all cases is ascorbate2-. The studies of ascorbate reactivity yield important information concerning the proposed correlation between ascorbate reducibility and the presence of a 695 nm-absorption band, and the study of dithionite reactivity illustrates the effect of protein charge and solution ionic strength on the relative contributions made by the species SO2.- and S2O4(2-) to the reduction of ferricytochrome c.

Kinetics of electron transfer between mitochondrial cytochrome c and iron hexacyanides

The reduction of horse and Candida krusei cytochromes c by ferrocyanide has been studied by 1H NMR spectroscopy and the reaction found to involve a precursor complex of ferrocyanide bound to ferricytochrome c (pH* 7.4, 2H2O, I = 0.12, and 25 degrees C). The electron transfer rate constants for the reduction of the two ferricytochromes by associated ferrocyanide were found to be the same at 780 +/- 80 sec-1 but the association constants for binding of ferrocyanide to ferricytochrome c were significantly different: horse, 90 +/- 20 M-1 and Candida, 285 +/- 30 M-1. The different association constants partly accounts for the previously observed reactivity difference between horse and Candida cytochromes c. Comparison of the NMR data with data obtained by other kinetic methods has allowed the electron transfer rate constant for the oxidation of ferrocytochrome c by associated ferricyanide to be determined. This was found to be 4.6 +/- 1 X 10(4) sec-1.

Pulse radiolysis kinetics of the reaction of hydrated electrons with ferric-, ferrous-, protoporphyrin IX- and apo-myoglobin

The kinetics of the reaction of hydrated electron (e-aq) with ferric-, ferrous-, metal-free protoporphyrin IX-and apo-myoglobin have been studied by pulse radiolysis so that a direct kinetic measure of the relative reactivities of the heme and the protein part of myoglobin can be made. The second-order association rate constant with ferric Mb is about 3-times that for ApoMb, while ferric Mb, ferrous Mb and protoporphyrin IX-Mb all react at about the same rate, indicating that it is mainly the porphyrin that is the electron-attracting site. The magnitude of the rate constants (8-25 nM-1 X S-1) indicates that the encounter of e-aq with the protein is almost certainly diffusion-controlled. The initial encounter is probably followed by electron migration along parallel paths to the heme and most likely several of the 12 histidine residues. The heme competes very effectively (approx. 70%) with these other sites. The kinetically measured reduction yield of heme is consistent with that found spectrally, indicating that a histidine radical on the protein does not effectively transfer an electron intramolecularly to the heme. The spectral changes found upon the completion of the fast reaction (approx. 40 microseconds) for protoporphyrin IX-Mb and ferrous Mb are consistent with the formation of a porphyrin anion radical. For ApoMb the spectral changes are consistent with the formation of a histidine free radical.

The oxidation-reduction kinetics of the reaction of cytochrome c1 with non-physiological redox agents

The kinetics of the oxidation-reduction reactions of cytochrome c1 with ascorbate, ferricyanide, triphenanthrolinecobalt(III) and N,N,N',N'-tetramethyl-p-phenylenediamine (TMPD) have been examined using the stopped-flow technique. The reduction of ferricytochrome c1 by ascorbic acid is investigated as a function of pH. It is shown that at neutral and alkaline pH the reduction of the protein is mainly performed by the doubly deprotonated form of ascorbate. From the ionic-strength-dependence studies of the reactions of cytochrome c1 with ascorbate, ferricyanide and triphenanthrolinecobalt(III), it is demonstrated that the reactions rate is governed by electrostatic interactions. The second-order rate constants for the reaction of cytochrome c1 with ascorbate, ferricyanide, TMPD and triphenanthrolinecobalt(III) are 1.4 . 10(4), 3.2 . 10(3), 3.8 . 10(4) and 1.3 . 10(8) M-1 . s-1 (pH 7.9, I = 0, 10 degrees C), respectively. Application of the Debye-Hückel theory to the data of the ionic-strength-dependence studies of these redox reactions of cytochrome c1 yielded for ferrocytochrome c1 and ferricytochrome c1 a net charge of --5 and --4, respectively. The latter value is close to that of --3 for the oxidized enzyme, calculated from the amino acid sequence of the protein. This implies that not a local charge on the surface of the protein, but the overall net charge of cytochrome c1 governs the reaction rate with small redox molecules.

A quantitative test for superoxide radicals produced in biological systems

The preparation and properties of a partially succinoylated cytochrome c, suited for the detection of superoxide anion radicals in liver microsomes, is reported. By succinoylation of 45% of the primary amino groups of horse heart cytochrome c the activity towards solubilized NADPH--cytochrome P-450 reductase was diminished by 99% compared with native cytochrome c. The capacities of cytochrome b5 and cytochrome c oxidase to reduce the succinoylated ferricytochrome c and oxidize succinoylated ferrocytochrome c respectively were decreased to a similar extent. However, the bimolecular rate constant for the reduction of the partially succinoylated ferricytochrome c by O2-. was estimated to be one-tenth of the value for the reaction of O2-. with native ferricytochrome c a pH 7.7. On this basis the quantification of O2-. generated by NADPH-supplemented liver microsomes became possible. The initial rates of succinoylated ferricytochrome c reduction determined at various finite concentrations of the cytochrome c derivative can be extrapolated to obtain true rates of O2-. generation in a homogeneous system. The problems encountered in the quantitative determination of O2-. produced in biological membranes, e.g. microsomes, are discussed.

Kinetic studies on the reduction of cytochrome c. Reaction with dihydroxy conjugated compounds (catechols and quinols)

The kinetics of reduction of cytochrome c by catechol(s), quinol(s) and related compounds were investigated by stopped-flow spectrophotometry. Studies on the influence of pH on the rates indicate that only deprotonated forms of these compounds act as reducing agents, with the dianionic forms being the most effective. The pH-independent second-order rate constants are reported. Hammett treatment of the effects of substituents on the aromatic ring structure of the reductants show that for electron transfer to occur the charge on the deprotonated species must not be withdrawn on to the substituents. Possible sites for electron donation to cytochrome c are discussed, and the results indicate that the haem edge is a likely candidate.

Molecular interpretation of kinetic-ionic strength effects

A recent and important approach to investigating electron transfer mechanisms of redox proteins has been through kinetic-ionic strength studies. There is, however, significant controversy as to whether such studies (1) yield information regarding the charge (or location) of the electron transfer site or (2) more simply reflect the influence of net or overall protein charge on the electrostatic interactions. A critical analysis using different theoretical approaches is made of our recent work and of the bulk of the published non-physiological small molecule-protein and protein-protein kinetic ionic strength studies; it is concluded that (1) the approximated Bronsted-Debye-Huckel equation can not be used at all for protein redox reactions, (2) irrespective of the theoretical approaches discussed, such studies do not provide information regarding the charge of the electron transfer site, (3) it is the net charge of the reactants that control the electrostatic interactions, (4) both the equation derived by Wherland and Gray and the full Bronsted-Debye-Huckel equation provide reasonably good approximations of net protein charge, (5) pH changes quantitatively modulate net protein charge, and (6) thus, protein redox rates need to be electrostatically corrected if relevant interpretations of kinetic-ionic strength experiments are to be made.

Kinetic data for redox reactions of cytochrome c with Fe(CN)5X complexes and the question of association prior to electron transfer

Use of rigorous equilibration kinetics to evaluate rate constants for the Fe(CN)6 4- reduction of horse-heart cytochrome c in the oxidized form, cyt c (III), has shown that limiting kinetics do not apply with concentrations of Fe(CN)6 4- (the reactant in excess) in the range 2-10 x 10(-4) M, I = 0.10 M (NaCl). The reaction conforms to a first-order rate law in each reactant, and at 25 degrees C, pH 7.2 (Tris), it is concluded that K for association prior to electron transfer is less than 200 M-1. From previous studies at 25 degrees C, ph 7.0 (10(-1) M phosphate), I = 0.242 M (NaCl), a value K = 2.4 x 10(3) M-1 has been reported. Had such a value applied, some or all of the redox inactive complexes Mo(CN)8 4-, Co(CN)6 3-, Cr(CN)6 3-, Zr(C2O4)4 4- present in amounts 5-20 x 10(-4) M would have been expected to associate at the same site and partially block the redox process. No effect on rats was observed. With the reductants Fe(CN)5(4-NH2-py)3- and Fe(CN)5(imid)3-, reactions proceeded to greater than 90% completion and rate laws were again first order in each reactant. Rate constants (M-1 sec-1) at 25 degrees C, pH 7.2 (Tris), I = 0.10 M (NaCl), are Fe(CN)6 4- (3.5 x 10(4)), Fe(CN)5(4-NH2py)3- (6.7 x 10(5), and Fe(CN)5(imid)3- (4.2 x 10(5). Related reactions in which cyt c(II) is oxidized are also first order in each reactant, Fe(CN)6 3- (9.1 x 10(6)), Fe(CN)5(NCS)3- (1.3 x 10(6)), Fe(CN)5(4-NH2py)2- (3.8 x 10(6) at pH 9.4), and Fe(CN)5(NH3)2- (2.75 x 10(6) at ph 8). Redox inactive Co(CN)6 3- (1.0 x 10(-3) M) has no effect on the reaction of Fe(CN)6 3- which suggests that a recent interpretation for the Fe(CN)6 3- oxidation of cyt c(II), I = 0.07 M, may also require reappraisal.