Chloroplast thylakoid membrane proteins having buried amine buffering groups

Distinguishing between luminal and localized proton buffering pools in thylakoid membranes

The dual gradient energy coupling hypothesis posits that chloroplast thylakoid membranes are energized for ATP formation by either a delocalized or a localized proton gradient geometry. Localized energy coupling is characterized by sequestered domains with a buffering capacity of approximately 150 nmol H(+) mg(-1) chlorophyll (Chl). A total of 30 to 40 nmol mg(-1) Chl of the total sequestered domain buffering capacity is contributed by lysines with anomolously low pK(a)s, which can be covalently derivatized with acetic anhydride. We report that in thylakoid membranes treated with acetic anhydride, luminal acidification by a photosystem I (duraquinol [DQH(2)] to methyl viologen [MV]) proton pumping partial reaction was nearly completely inhibited, as measured by three separate assays, yet surprisingly, H(+) accumulation still occurred to the significant level of more than 100 nmol H(+) mg Chl(-1), presumably into the sequestered domains. The treatment did not increase the observed rate constant of dark H(+) efflux, nor was electron transport significantly inhibited. These data provide support for the existence of a sequestered proton translocating pathway linking the redox reaction H(+) ion sources with the CF(0) H(+) channel. The sequestered, low-pK(a) Lys groups appear to have a role in the H(+) diffusion process and chemically modifying them blocks the putative H(+) relay system.

Evidence that the intrinsic membrane protein LHCII in thylakoids is necessary for maintaining localized delta mu H+ energy coupling

This work tested the hypothesis that thylakoid localized proton-binding domains, suggested to be involved in localized delta mu H(+)-driven ATP formation, are maintained with the involvement of several membrane proteins, including the LHCII (Laszlo, J.A., Baker, G.M., and Dilley, R.A. (1984) Biochim. Biophys. Acta 764, 160-169), which comprises about 50% of the total thylakoid protein. The concept we have in mind is that several membrane proteins cooperate to shield a localized proton diffusion pathway from direct contact with the lumen, thus providing a physical barrier to H+ equilibration between the sequestered domains and the lumen. A barely mutant, chlorina f2, that lacks Chl b and does not accumulate some of the LHCII proteins, was tested for its capacity to carry out localized-proton gradient-dependent ATP formation. Two previously developed assays permit clear discrimination between localized and delocalized delta mu H+ gradient-driven ATP formation. Those assays include the effect of a permeable buffer, pyridine, on the number of single-turnover flashes needed to reach the energetic threshold for ATP formation and the more recently developed assay for lumen pH using 8-hydroxy-1,3,6-pyrene trisulfonic acid as a lumenally loaded pH-sensitive fluorescent probe. By those two criteria, the wild-type barley thylakoids revealed either a localized or a delocalized energy coupling mode under low- or high-salt storage conditions, respectively. Addition of Ca++ to the high-salt storage medium caused those thylakoids to maintain a localized energy-coupling response, as previously observed for pea thylakoids.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Chloroplast thylakoid proteins associated with sequestered proton-buffering domains. Plastocyanin contributes buffering groups to localized proton domains

Thylakoid membrane proteins are organized so as to shield 30-50 nmol H+ (mg Chl)-1 from freely equilibrating with either the external or the lumen aqueous phases. Amine groups provide binding sites for this metastable buffering array and can be quantitatively measured by acetylation using [3H]acetic anhydride. The principle of the assay is that a metastable acidic domain will have relatively less of the reactive neutral form of the amine compared to the amount present after addition of an uncoupler. The extent of the acetylation reaction is strongly influenced by whether the lumen pH comes to complete equilibrium with the external pH prior to adding the acetic anhydride. Determination of the lumen pH by [14C]methylamine distribution after the standard 3 or 5 min equilibration in pH 8.6 buffer indicated that the lumen may have been 0.2 to 0.3 pH more acidic than the external phase. This effect was taken into account by determining the pH dependence, in the pH 8.2-8.6 range, of acetylation of the membrane proteins studied, and the labeling data were conservatively corrected for this possible contribution. Experiments were carried out to identify the thylakoid proteins that contribute such metastable domain amine groups, using the above conservative correction. Surprisingly, plastocyanin contributes buried amine groups, but cytochrome f did not give evidence for such a contribution, if the conservative correction in the labeling was applied. If the correction was too conservative, cytochrome f may contribute amines to the sequestered domains. The new methodology verified earlier results suggesting that three Tris-releasable photosystem II-associated proteins also contribute significantly to the sequestered amine-buffering array.

Effect of high KCl concentrations on membrane-localized metastable proton buffering domains in thylakoids

Recent work showed that chloroplast thylakoid membranes stored in 100 mM KCl-containing media have delocalized energy coupling consistent with a rapid equilibration of the proton gradient between the proton-producing redox steps and the lumen bulk phase (Beard and Dilley 1986). Thylakoids stored in low salt media showed localized energy coupling. A related thylakoid membrane property is the occurrence of sequestered, metastable, acidic domains, associated with pK a ≈7.5 amine groups. For low salt-stored membranes the domain protons appear to be in the direct (localized) diffusion pathway of protons involved in energizing ATP formation, whereas in thylakoids stored in high KCl, domain protons equilibrated with the lumen during the development of the ATP energization threshold (Theg et al. 1988). This work tested whether the 100 mM KCl storage treatment did or did not cause the dissipation of the metastable acidic domain protons in the dark, storage period. By three criteria, it was found that the 100 mM KCl storage treatment had only a slight tendency to dissipate the acidic domain protons into alkaline media under dark conditions. Storage in KCl does not cause the dissipation of the acidic domains in the dark, but allows domain protons to equilibrate with the lumen after the redox system begins turning over, but before the ATP energization threshold ΔpH is reached. These results must be considered in models of how the thylakoid structure can accommodate metastable acidic domains and how such domain protons diffuse to the CF0-CF1 complexes in energy coupling.

Interaction of photosystem I-derived protons with the water-splitting enzyme complex. Evidence for localized domains

The induction of millisecond delayed fluorescence mediated by PS I-dependent proton pumping has been used as an indicator of the time course with which those protons equilibrate with sites on the oxygen-evolving enzyme complex (Bowes, J. M., and Crofts, A. R. (1978). Z. Naturforsch. 33C, 271-275). We found that the induction curves were retarded by a reversible exposure of non-energized thylakoids to low concentrations of the uncoupler, desaspidin, at alkaline, but not at neutral, pH. The induction curves were not retarded by increasing the buffering capacity of the thylakoid lumen with Tricine, and were inhibited by the energy transfer inhibitors, dicyclohexylcarbodiimide (DCCD) and triphenyltin chloride (TPT). These data suggest that the catalytic site of the water-splitting complex is located in proton-sequestering membrane domains, rather than at the lumen-exposed inner membrane surface, protons released during PS I-mediated electron transport might equilibrate with protonatable sites on the oxygen-evolving complex without passing through the lumen, and those protons may travel over specific conducting pathways which can be blocked by DCCD and TPT.

Models of localized energy coupling

It is proven that any model of localized protonmotive energy coupling that relies upon properties of a homogeneous surface phase must, when operated in the steady state, lead to bulk phase electrochemical potentials for protons that are as large as those required by the delocalized chemiosmotic theory. To obtain models consistent with experiments supporting localized energy coupling requires some kind of surface heterogeneity for the proton conducting pathways. Two general classes of heterogeneous surface models are mentioned. One class involves phase-separated lipid domains. The second class involves hydrogen-bonded chains in proteins that traverse the membrane laterally.

Correlation between membrane-localized protons and flash-driven ATP formation in chloroplast thylakoids

Flash-driven ATP formation by spinach chloroplast thylakoids, using the luciferin luminescence assay to detect ATP formed in single turnover flashes, was studied under conditions where a membrane protein amine buffering pool was either protonated or deprotonated before the beginning of the flash trains. The flash number for the onset of ATP formation was delayed by about 10 flashes (from 15 to about 25) when the amine pool was deprotonated as compared to the protonated state. The delay was substantially reversed again by reprotonating the pool upon application of 20-30 single-turnover flashes and 8 min of dark before addition of ADP, Pi, and the luciferin system. In the case of deprotonation by desaspidin, the uncoupler was removed by binding to BSA before the reprotonating flashes were given. Reprotonation was carried out before addition of ADP and Pi, to avoid a possible interference by the ATP-ase, which can energize the system by pumping protons. The reprotonated state, as indicated by an onset lag of about 15 flashes rather than 25 for the deprotonated state, was stable in the dark over extended dark times. The number of protons released by 10 flashes is approximately 30 nmol H+ (mg chl)-1, an amount similar to the size of the reversibly protonated amine group buffering pool. The data are consistent with the hypothesis that the amine buffering groups must be in the protonated state before any protons proceed to the coupling complex and energize ATP formation. Other work has suggested that the amine buffering pool is sequestered within membrane proteins rather than being exposed directly to the inner aqueous bulk phase. Therefore, it is possible that the sequestered amine group array may provide localized association-dissociation sites for proton movement to the coupling complex.