Effect of pH on the thermoluminescence of spinach chloroplasts in the presence and absence of Photosystem II inhibitors

Pitfalls, artefacts and open questions in chlorophyll thermoluminescence of leaves or algal cells

Thermoluminescence of intact photosynthetic organisms, leaves or algal cells, raises specific problems. The constitutive S2/3Q B (-) B bands constitute major probes of the state of photosystem II in vivo. The presence of a dark-stable acidic lumen causes a temperature downshift of B bands, specially the S3 B band, providing a lumen pH indicator. This is accompanied by a broadening of the S3 B band that becomes an envelope of elementary B bands. The occasional AT, Q and C bands are briefly examined in an in vivo context. It is emphasized that freezing below the nucleation temperature is not necessary for physiological studies, but a source of artefacts, hence should be avoided. In intact photosynthetic structures, a dark-electron transfer from stroma reductants to the quinonic acceptors of photosystem II via the cyclic/chlororespiratory pathways, strongly stimulated by moderate warming, gives rise to the afterglow (AG) luminescence emission that reflects chloroplast energy status. The decomposition of complex TL signals into elementary bands is necessary to determine the maximum temperature T m and the area of each of them. A comparison of TL signals after 1 flash and 2 flashes prevents from confusing the three main bands observed in vivo, i.e. the S2 and S3 B bands and the AG band. Finally, the thermoluminescence bands arising sometimes above 50 °C are mentioned. The basic principles of (thermo)luminescence established on isolated thylakoids should not be applied directly without a careful examination of in vivo conditions.

Light emission originating from photosystem II radical pair recombination is sensitive to zeaxanthin related non-photochemical quenching (NPQ)

We have used chlorophyll fluorescence, delayed luminescence and thermoluminescence measurements to study the influence of an artificial DeltapH in the presence or absence of zeaxanthin on photosystem II reactions. Energization of the pea thylakoid membranes induced non-photochemical fluorescence quenching and an increase in the overall luminescence emission of PSII during delayed luminescence and thermoluminescence measurements. This DeltapH-induced overall luminescence increase was caused by a strongly enhanced delayed luminescence in the seconds range before sample heating. In the subsequent thermoluminescence measurements the intensity of the B-band decreased after one and increased after two or more single turnover flashes. We propose that strong membrane energization shifted the redox potential of photosystem II radical pairs to more negative values causing the high delayed luminescence. The zeaxanthin-dependent non-photochemical fluorescence quenching component, however, did not alter thermoluminescence B-bands but decreased the delayed luminescence intensity by 30%. To our knowledge this is the first report that the radiative radical pair recombination, exhibited as delayed luminescence but not thermoluminescence emission, is sensitive to the antenna located zeaxanthin related non-photochemical fluorescence quenching. Our data can be interpreted within the frame of the exciton/radical pair equilibrium model that describes photosystem II as a shallow trap and incorporates the transfer of energy from the re-excitated reaction centre to the antenna of photosystem II.

Effects of dark- and light-induced proton gradients in thylakoids on the Q and B thermoluminescence bands

Thermoluminescence experiments have been carried out to study the effect of a transmembrane proton gradient on the recombination properties of the S2 and S3 states of the oxygen evolving complex with QA (-) and QB (-), the reduced electron acceptors of Photosystem II. We first determined the properties of the S2QA (-) (Q band), S2QB (-) and S3QB (-) (B bands) recombinations in the pH range 5.5 to 9.0, using uncoupled thylakoids. The, a proton gradient was created in the dark, using the ATP-hydrolase function of ATPases, in coupled unfrozen thylakoids. A shift towards low temperature of both Q and B bands was observed to increase with the magnitude of the proton gradient measured by the fluorescence quenching of 9-aminoacridine. This downshift was larger for S3QB (-) than for S2QB (-) and it was suppressed by nigericin, but not by valinomycin. Similar results were obtained when a proton gradient was formed by photosystem I photochemistry. When Photosystem II electron transfer was induced by a flash sequence, the reduction of the plastoquinone pool also contributed to the downshift in the absence of an electron acceptor. In leaves submitted to a flash sequence above 0°C, a downshift was also observed, which was supressed by nigericin infiltration. Thus, thermoluminescence provides direct evidence on the enhancing effect of lumen acidification on the S3→S2 and S2→S1 reverse-transitions. Both reduction of the plastoquinone pool and lumen acidification induce a shift of the Q and B bands to lower temperature, with a predominance of lumen acidification in non-freezing, moderate light conditions.

Analyses of pH-induced modifications of the period four oscillation of flash-induced oxygen evolution reveal distinct structural changes of the photosystem II donor side at characteristic pH values

This study presents a thorough analysis of the reaction pattern of flash-induced oxygen evolution in spinach thylakoids as a function of pH (4.5 < or = pH < or = 9) and the redox state of tyrosine YD in polypeptide D2. Evaluation of the experimental data within the conventional Kok model [Kok, B., Forbush, B., & McGloin, M. (1970) Photochem. Photobiol. 11, 457-475] led to the following results: (1) the probability of the miss factor is strongly pH dependent (with a pronounced minimum near neutral pH) while the double hit factor is less affected; (2) a marked increase of the apparent S0 population arises at alkaline pH in dark-adapted samples where most of the YD is reduced, but this effect is absent if the percentage of PS II containing the oxidized form YDox is high; and (3) the lifetimes of S2 and S3 exhibit a characteristic pH dependence that is indicative of conformational changes of functional relevance within the water-oxidizing complex and its environment; (4) the kinetic interaction of redox states S2 and S3 with YD is characterized by a change of its behavior at a threshold pH of 6.5-7.0; and (5) at acidic pH values the extent of S2 and S3 reduction by YD decreases concomitant with the occurrence of a very fast decay kinetics. On the basis of a detailed discussion of these results and data from the literature, the water oxidase is inferred to undergo structural changes at pH values of 5-5.5 and 6.5-7.0. These transitions are almost independent of the redox state Si and modify the reaction coordinates of the water oxidase toward endogenous reductants.

Participation of the g = 1.9 and g = 1.82 EPR forms of the semiquinone-iron complex, QA-.Fe2+ of photosystem II in the generation of the Q and C thermoluminescence bands, respectively

Following illumination at 200 K, the charge recombination reactions and the origin of the thermoluminescence (TL) bands appearing at about 0 degree C (Q band) and +50 degrees C (C band) in the glow curve were investigated by comparative TL and EPR measurements in DCMU-treated photosystem II particles. Decay half-time measurements carried out at -25 degrees C and +25 degrees C, respectively, suggest that the S2 state (multi-line signal) undergoes charge recombination with the g = 1.9 form of the semiquinone-iron complex, QA-.Fe2+, resulting in the appearance of the Q band, and that the g = 1.82 form of QA-.Fe2+ back-reacts with the oxidized tyrosine, YD+ (Signal IIs), accounting for the generation of the C band.