Promotion and inhibition of catalytic cooperativity of the Ca2+-dependent ATPase activity of spinach chloroplast coupling factor 1 (CF1)

Molecular evolution of the modulator of chloroplast ATP synthase: origin of the conformational change dependent regulation

Chloroplast ATP synthase synthesizes ATP by utilizing a proton gradient as an energy supply, which is generated by photosynthetic electron transport. The activity of the chloroplast ATP synthase is regulated in several specific ways to avoid futile hydrolysis of ATP under various physiological conditions. Several regulatory signals such as Delta mu H(+), tight binding of ADP and its release, thiol modulation, and inhibition by the intrinsic inhibitory subunit epsilon are sensed by this complex. In this review, we describe the function of two regulatory subunits, gamma and epsilon, of ATP synthase based on their possible conformational changes and discuss the evolutionary origin of these regulation systems.

Molecular devices of chloroplast F(1)-ATP synthase for the regulation

In chloroplasts, synthesis of ATP is energetically coupled with the utilization of a proton gradient formed by photosynthetic electron transport. The involved enzyme, the chloroplast ATP synthase, can potentially hydrolyze ATP when the magnitude of the transmembrane electrochemical potential difference of protons (Delta(micro)H(+)) is small, e.g. at low light intensity or in the dark. To prevent this wasteful consumption of ATP, the activity of chloroplast ATP synthase is regulated as the occasion may demand. As regulation systems Delta(micro)H(+) activation, thiol modulation, tight binding of ADP and the role of the intrinsic inhibitory subunit epsilon is well documented. In this article, we discuss recent progress in understanding of the regulation system of the chloroplast ATP synthase at the molecular level.

Important subunit interactions in the chloroplast ATP synthase

General structural features of the chloroplast ATP synthase are summarized highlighting differences between the chloroplast enzyme and other ATP synthases. Much of the review is focused on the important interactions between the epsilon and gamma subunits of the chloroplast coupling factor 1 (CF(1)) which are involved in regulating the ATP hydrolytic activity of the enzyme and also in transferring energy from the membrane segment, chloroplast coupling factor 0 (CF(0)), to the catalytic sites on CF(1). A simple model is presented which summarizes properties of three known states of activation of the membrane-bound form of CF(1). The three states can be explained in terms of three different bound conformational states of the epsilon subunit. One of the three states, the fully active state, is only found in the membrane-bound form of CF(1). The lack of this state in the isolated form of CF(1), together with the confirmed presence of permanent asymmetry among the alpha, beta and gamma subunits of isolated CF(1), indicate that ATP hydrolysis by isolated CF(1) may involve only two of the three potential catalytic sites on the enzyme. Thus isolated CF(1) may be different from other F(1) enzymes in that it only operates on 'two cylinders' whereby the gamma subunit does not rotate through a full 360 degrees during the catalytic cycle. On the membrane in the presence of a light-induced proton gradient the enzyme assumes a conformation which may involve all three catalytic sites and a full 360 degrees rotation of gamma during catalysis.

Cooperativity between the enzymatic sites of F1-ATPase revisited by the use of HPLC methods

The fundamental question of the cooperativity between the enzymatic sites of F1-ATPase is examined in the light of new measurements of the enzymatic rate of ATP hydrolysis by CF1, the enzyme isolated from spinach chloroplasts. The experimental data, obtained with a chromatographic method, fit a model that involves two kinds of independent enzymatic sites working with metal-free ATP, with no need of cooperativity between the sites. Binding measurements between ADP or ATP and CF1 by the chromatographic method of Hummel and Dreyer (1962) also support this conclusion. The present data and interpretation are in agreement with those reported recently (Reynafarje and Pedersen, 1996) which show that the first order rate constant of ATP hydrolysis by MF1, the analogous enzyme from mitochondria, is virtually constant under experimental conditions involving either unisite or multisite hydrolysis of ATP. The present data and interpretation are discussed together with those reported previously, in particular with regard to the methods that were used to support the commonly accepted opposite viewpoint.

The formation or the reduction of a disulfide bridge on the gamma subunit of chloroplast ATP synthase affects the inhibitory effect of the epsilon subunit

We have studied the change of the catalytic activity of chimeric complexes that were formed by chloroplast coupling factor 1 (CF1) -gamma, alpha and beta subunits of thermophilic bacterial F1 after formation or reduction of the disulfide bridge of different gamma subunits modified by oligonucleotide-directed mutagenesis techniques. For this purpose, three mutant gamma subunits were produced: gamma Delta194-230, here 37 amino acids from Pro-194 to Ile-230 are deleted, gammaC199A, Cys-199 is changed to Ala, and gamma Delta200-204, amino acids from Asp-200 to Lys-204 are deleted. All of the chimeric subunit complexes produced from each of these mutant CF1-gamma subunits and alpha and beta subunits from thermophilic bacterial F1 lost the sensitivity against thiol reagents when compared with the complex containing wild-type CF1-gamma. The pH optimum (pH 8.5-9.0) and the concentration of methanol to stimulate ATPase activities were not affected by these mutations. These indicate that the introduction of the mutations did not change the main features of ATPase activity of the chimeric complex. However, the interaction between gamma subunit and epsilon subunit was strongly influenced by the type of gamma subunit itself. Although the ATPase activity of the chimeric complex that contained gamma Delta200-204 or gammaC199A was inhibited by the addition of recombinant epsilon subunit from CF1 similarly to complexes containing the reduced wild-type gamma subunit, the recombinant epsilon subunit did not inhibit the ATPase of the complex, which contained the oxidized form of gamma subunit. Therefore the affinity of the epsilon subunit to the gamma subunit may be dependent on the state of the gamma subunit or the epsilon subunit may bind to the oxidized form of gamma subunit in a mode that does not inhibit the activity. The ATPase activity of the complex that contains gamma Delta194-230 was not efficiently inhibited by epsilon subunit. These results show that the formation or reduction of the disulfide bond on the gamma subunit may induce a conformational change in the region that directly affects the interaction of this subunit with the adjacent epsilon subunit.

Unisite ATP hydrolysis by soluble Rhodospirillum rubrum F1-ATPase is accelerated by Ca2+

At saturating concentrations of ATP, soluble F1 from the Rhodospirillum rubrum (RF1) exhibits a higher rate of hydrolysis with Ca2+ than with Mg2+. The mechanisms involved in the expression of a higher catalytic activity with Ca2+ were explored by measuring the ATPase activity of RF1 at substiochiometric concentrations of ATP (unisite conditions). At a ratio of 0.25 [gamma-32P]ATP per RF1, the enzyme exhibited a 50 times higher hydrolytic rate with Ca2+ than with Mg2+. The rate of [gamma-32P]ATP binding to RF1 was in the same range with the two divalent metal ions. Centrifugation-filtration of RF1 exposed to substoichiometric [gamma-32P]ATP concentrations and Mg2+ through Sephadex columns yielded an enzyme that contained [gamma-32P]ATP and [32P]phosphate in a stoichiometry that was close to one. In the presence of Ca2+, the eluted enzyme did not contain [gamma-32P]ATP nor [32P]phosphate. This indicated that the rate of product release was faster with Ca2+ than with Mg2+. It was also observed that the ratio of multisite to unisite hydrolysis rates was of similar magnitude with both divalent cations. This suggests that they do not affect differently the cooperative mechanisms that may exist between catalytic sites. In consequence, the higher ATPase activity of RF1 in presence of Ca2+ strongly suggests that the retention time of products is decreased in the presence of this cation. Copyright 1998 Elsevier Science B.V.

Molecular aspects of activation mechanisms of CF₁

The Ca²( +) -dependent ATPase activity of spinach chloroplast coupling factor 1 (CF₁) is activated by treatment with dithiothreitol (DDT). If excess of this reagent is eliminated by gel filtration, an Eadie-Hofstee biphasic plot is obtained. These results are consistent with the existence of two active forms of the enzyme governed by the redox state. We have observed that SDS-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis pattern is affected by the pretreatment of the samples under those two different conditions. Spontaneous activation of the samples, due to a limited proteolytic process, has also been detected. In this case the electrophoretic pattern was also affected. The protease implied in this process could be a cystein protease co-isolated with CF₁. These observations suggest that limited proteolysis, as well as redox-induced changes, are involved in the physiological regulation of the enzyme.

Control of mitochondrial ATP synthesis in the heart

Images

Catalytic properties of β subunit isolated from chloroplast coupling factor 1

The chloroplast coupling factor (CF1) was dissociated into subunits by the freezing-thawing procedure in the presence of 0.5 M NaBr and the β subunit was purified by ion-exchange chromatography on a DEAE-cellulose column. The β subunit did not catalyze ATP hydrolysis either in the presence or in the absence of reagents known to activate Mg(2+)-dependent ATPase activity of CF1. However, it manifested appreciable adenylate kinase-like and ATP-ADP γ-phosphate exchange activities. The adenylate kinase-like activity only slightly depended on Mg(2+) ions. Ethanol, and especially diadenosine pentaphosphate, inhibited the reaction effectively. In contrast, the ATP-ADP exchange activity was Mg(2+)-dependent. Ethanol and diadenosine pentaphosphate were poor inhibitors. Sulfite, the CF1-ATPase activator, and quercetin, its inhibitor, had a minor effect on catalytic activity of the β subunit.