Structural and dynamical studies of mixed chlorophyll/phosphatidylcholine bilayers via x-ray diffraction, absorption polarization spectroscopy and nuclear magnetic resonance

Effect of chlorophyll a on the phase behavior of hydrated monogalactosyldiacylglycerols

We have studied the effect of chlorophyll a (chl a) on the X-ray diffraction patterns and the appearance of freeze-fracture electron micrographs of aqueous dispersions of monogalactosyldiacylglycerols (MGDG), the most abundant lipid in the thylakoid membrane. In MGDG systems containing 0-18 mol% of chl a, the diffraction patterns indicate the presence of a well-ordered reverse hexagonal phase. When 30 mol% of chl a was incorporated into the MGDG, the low-angle X-ray diffraction lines of the hexagonal lattice were slightly broadened and were accompanied by additional weak lines. With higher mol percents of chl a, the low-angle lines could no longer be indexed on a hexagonal or lamellar lattice. The freeze-fracture electron micrographs of similar samples showed that the patterns characteristic of the reverse hexagonal phase of an aqueous dispersion of pure MGDG were replaced by large liposomes, the fracture pattern of which is circular. We conclude that chl a in excess of 20 mol% destabilized the orderly reverse hexagonal phase of aqueous MGDG dispersions and disturbed the long-range order of the lipid array. These results are summarized in a temperature-composition isobaric phase diagram over a temperature range of -60 degrees C to 60 degrees C.

Organization of chlorophyll a in bilayer membranes. The chlorophyll a/dimyristoylphosphatidylcholine system

In order to investigate the relative importance of the hydrophobic and headgroup interactions of chlorophyll a in phospholipid bilayers, we have carried out differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) and deuterium (2H) and phosphorus (31P) nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) experiments on the multilamellar system of chlorophyll a in dimyristoylphosphatidylcholine (DMPC). Compared to the phytol chain of chlorophyll and the previously reported distearoylphosphatidylcholine (DSPC), the acyl chains of DMPC are shorter in length by three and four carbons, respectively. A lowering in the phase-transition temperature was observed for the DMPC multilayers in the presence of chlorophyll a in the DSC thermograms and in the 31P chemical shift anisotropy measurements. These results, together with data on hydrophobic interactions as measured by 2H-NMR and on headgroup interactions as evidenced from 31P-NMR, suggest a phase diagram for the chlorophyll a/DMPC system in which phase separation readily occurs between a chlorophyll-rich compound phase and a chlorophyll-poor phospholipid phase. Compound formation appears to be important in the stabilization of chlorophyll a in bilayers with shorter chains.

Mixing of single-chain amphiphiles in two-chain lipid bilayers. 2. Characteristics of chlorophyll a and alpha-tocopherol incorporation in unilamellar phosphatidylcholine vesicles

As a step toward the elucidation of the biological significance of the isoprenic chains found ubiquitously in single-chain lipids involved in electron and energy transfer of chloroplasts and mitochondria, we undertook a comparative study of the incorporation of chlorophyll a (Chl a) and alpha-tocopherol (alpha T) in unilamellar phosphatidylcholine (PC) vesicles. We observed that while Chl alpha is added to the PC bilayers in a simple, almost linear way, the inclusion of alpha T is a sigmoid-like function characterized first by a slow variation of alpha T incorporation followed by a rather steep increase till saturation occurs at initial mol% alpha T of approx. 5%. Owing to the likeness of the isoprenic chains of Chl a and alpha T the simplest interpretation of the data is that the different mixing behaviours of the two lipids in PC vesicles are due to the special arrangement of the tetrapyrrole macrocycle and the chromanol ring in the lipid bilayers. However, no satisfactory explanation of the mechanisms involved can be given as yet. One possibility is that the inclusion of Chl a and alpha T in the membranes results from adsorption differences brought about by the extent of penetration of the molecule into the monolayers of the unilamellar vesicles.

Influence of lecithin liposomes on chlorophyllase-catalyzed chlorophyll hydrolysis: comparison of intramembraneous and solubilized Phaeodactylum chlorophyllase

1.Chlorophyllase-catalyzed chlorophyll hydrolysis is greatly enhanced by the addition of divalent cations (Mg2+) combined with a reducing agent (dithiothreitol, ascorbate). A similar effect is obtained by the addition of lecithin. In the presence of lecithin, dithiothreitol has only slight or no influence on chlorophyll hydrolysis. Mg2+ eliminates the activating effect of lecithin. 2. In the absence of Mg2+ + dithiothreitol or of lecithin, Triton X-100 has a slight activating effect on chlorophyllase-catalyzed chlorophyll hydrolysis, but only at low concentrations (0.01--0.02%). In the presence of Mg2+ and dithiothreitol or of lecithin, Triton X-100 (greater than or equal to 0.02%) inhibits this reaction. 3. Whereas chlorophyllase combines with chlorophyll, no combination of chlorophyllase and lecithin could be detected. 4. Solubilized chlorophyllase is stabilized by its substrate, chlorophyll. Enzyme stabilization is eliminated by lecithin, whereas in the absence of chlorophyll, denaturation is somewhat increased by dithiothreitol. 5. No clear difference was found between the actions of intramembraneous and solubilized chlorophyllase. The results suggest that chlorophyllase is situated within membranes in such a way that the active group protrudes into the aqueous medium surrounding the membrane. 6. A hypothesis explaining the activating effects which Mg2+ combined with a reducing agent and lecithin have upon chlorophyllase-catalyzed chlorophyll hydrolysis is presented.

Monitoring the location profile of fluorophores in phosphatidylcholine bilayers by the use or paramagnetic quenching

Spin probes differing in the position of their paramagnetic centre are used to quench the fluorescence of pyrene derivatives and chlorophylls incorporated into dimyristoyl phosphatidylcholine membranes. Pyrene butyric acid and pyrene decanoic acid with known orientation relative to the membrane surface are investigated. The quenching efficiency of fatty acid spin probes is dependent on the position of the nitroxide radical group in the fatty acid chain. Using this short range interaction we developed a spectroscopic method to chlorophyll-containing vesicles, we were able to characterize the orientation of the porphyrin ring within the membrane. Moreover, the chlorophyll fluorescence is also quenched by a water-soluble spin label. Therefore the porphyrin ring appears to be orientated in the polar head group region of the lipid layer, but not to be protruding out into the water phase. This conclusion is confirmed by the use of pyrene derivatives. Fluorescence quenching by a water-soluble spin label within the lipid matrix is observed even in the rigid state of the membrane. Fluorescence lifetime measurements suggest the existence of two different quenching mechanisms: (1) a static quenching occurring below the lipid phase transition temperature, and (2) an additional dynamic quenching taking place in the fluid state of the lipid bilayer.

Proton magnetic relaxation studies of mixed phosphatidylcholine/fatty acid and mixed phosphatidylcholine bimolecular bilayers

High resolution proton spin-lattice relaxation times (T1), spin-spin relaxation times (T2) and resonance linewidths were measured above the gel-to-liquid crystal transition temperature (Tm), in phosphatidylcholine bilayers possessing various degrees of intramolecular motional anisotrophy at the level of various alkyl chain proton groups. The experiments were designed to test the hypothesis that coupled trans-gauche isomerizations along the chains can be responsible for the anisotropic motion of phosphatidylcholine proton groups in bilayer membranes (Horwitz, A.F., Horsley, W.J. and Klein, M.O. (1972) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S. 69,500). Systematic series of structural perturbations of the bilayer were achieved in mixed phosphatidylcholine/fatty acid and in mixed phosphatidylcholine bilayers where the degree of motional anisotrophy of the chains' proton groups was gradually reduced by progressively increasing the chain length disparity of the two components. The systematic T1 and T2 variations observed were interterpreted on the basis of the Woessner's treatment for computing the relaxation times of a spin pair reorienting randomly about an axis which, in turn, tumbles randomly (Woessner, D.E. (1962) J. Chem. Phys. 36, 1). The results confirmed in a qualitative sense the original hypothesis made by Horwitz et al. The time-averaged structural interpretations suggested by the mangetic relaxation studies are in agreement with low-angle X-ray diffraction results obtained below Tm. In addition, the T1 values evaluated at various temperatures in dipalmitoyl phosphatidylcholine vesicles incorporated with either 2H-labeled or unlabeled palmitic acid chains indicated that the average intermolecular contribution to the spin-lattice relaxation rate of the proton groups of the phosphatidylcholine chains appears comparable to the intramolecular term at temperatures moderately higher than Tm, but becomes less and less important as the temperature is further increased above the thermal transition.