Incorporation of GDP-tubulin during elongation of microtubules in vitro

Stable GDP-tubulin islands rescue dynamic microtubules

Microtubules are dynamic polymers that interconvert between phases of growth and shrinkage, yet they provide structural stability to cells. Growth involves hydrolysis of GTP-tubulin to GDP-tubulin, which releases energy that is stored within the microtubule lattice and destabilizes it; a GTP cap at microtubule ends is thought to prevent GDP subunits from rapidly dissociating and causing catastrophe. Here, using in vitro reconstitution assays, we show that GDP-tubulin, usually considered inactive, can itself assemble into microtubules, preferentially at the minus end, and promote persistent growth. GDP-tubulin-assembled microtubules are highly stable, displaying no detectable spontaneous shrinkage. Strikingly, islands of GDP-tubulin within dynamic microtubules stop shrinkage events and promote rescues. Microtubules thus possess an intrinsic capacity for stability, independent of accessory proteins. This finding provides novel mechanisms to explain microtubule dynamics.

Role of GTP hydrolysis in microtubule polymerization: evidence for a coupled hydrolysis mechanism

The relationship between GTP hydrolysis and microtubule assembly has been investigated by using a rapid filtration method. Microtubules assembled from phosphocellulose-purified tubulin, double-labeled with [gamma-32P]- and [3H]GTP, were trapped and washed free of unbound nucleotide on glass fiber filters. The transient accumulation of microtubule-bound GTP predicted by uncoupled GTP hydrolysis models [Carlier & Pantaloni (1981) Biochemistry 20, 1918-1924; Carlier et al. (1987) Biochemistry 26, 4428-4437] during the rapid assembly of microtubules was not detectable under our experimental conditions. By calculating hypothetical time courses for the transient accumulation of microtubule-bound GTP, we demonstrate that microtubule-bound GTP would have been detectable even if the first-order rate constant for GTP hydrolysis were 4-5 times greater than the pseudo-first-order rate constant for tubulin subunit addition to microtubules. In a similar manner, we demonstrate that if GTP hydrolysis were uncoupled from microtubule assembly but were limited to the interface between GTP subunits and GDP subunits (uncoupled vectorial hydrolysis), then microtubule-bound GTP would have been detectable if GTP hydrolysis became uncoupled from microtubule assembly at less than 50 microM free tubulin, 5 times the steady-state tubulin concentration of our experimental conditions. In addition, during rapid microtubule assembly, we have not detected any microtubule-bound Pi, which has been proposed to form a stabilizing cap at the ends of microtubules [Carlier et al. (1988) Biochemistry 27, 3555-3559]. Also, several conditions that could be expected to increase the degree of potential uncoupling between GTP hydrolysis and microtubule assembly were examined, and no evidence of uncoupling was found. Our results are consistent with models that propose cooperative mechanisms that limit GTP hydrolysis to the terminal ring of tubulin subunits [e.g., O'Brien et al. (1987) Biochemistry 26, 4148-4156]. The results are also consistent with the hypothesis that a slow conformational change in tubulin subunits after GTP hydrolysis and Pi release occurs that results in destabilized microtubule ends when such subunits become exposed at the ends.

Formation and stability of vincristine-tubulin complex in kidney cytosols. Role of GTP and GTP hydrolysis

Vincristine-tubulin complex formed in the 100,000 g fraction of mouse kidney dissociated rapidly at 37 degrees in the absence of guanosine-5'-triphosphate (GTP). In the presence of 2 mM GTP, there was a substantial (2.8-fold) increase in complex stability; NaF (100 mM) but not beta-glycerophosphate (1 mM) also reduced the rate of dissociation. Further, complex was stabilized by other ribonucleoside-5'-triphosphates (but not their respective 5'-monophosphates), and a nonhydrolyzable analogue of GTP. Stability of the VCR-tubulin complex formed in cytosol from kidney and separated from unbound VCR and GTP by gel filtration was influenced by the concentration of GTP. These results appear not to be a consequence of denaturation of tubulin during incubation, as VCR binding activity remained constant under experimental conditions both in the presence and after the removal of GTP. Further, the rate of formation of the VCR-tubulin complex in kidney was also influenced by the concentration of GTP and was increased by the addition of NaF. In the absence of added GTP, virtually no complex was isolated. ATP, CTP, or ITP has little effect on complex formation, suggesting that the effect may be GTP specific. These data suggest that the destabilizing activity in cytosols prepared from mouse kidney, and the failure to form a stable VCR-tubulin complex in kidney, are in part the consequence of rapid hydrolysis of GTP by a pyrophosphohydrolase. Direct measurement of the hydrolysis of GTP showed that the activity in kidney (9.26 nmol/min/mg protein) was 9.3-fold greater than in tumor extracts.

Dynamic properties of microtubules at steady state of polymerisation

Microtubules of tubulin dimer, polymerised in vitro to steady-state are shown to incorporate tubulin rapidly and extensively. The method involves adding [3H]-GTP to microtubules at steady state, and analysing for non-exchangeable [3H]-GDP in the presence of a GTP regenerating system. The rate and extent of this exchange process is dependent on the length distribution of the microtubules, and is notably faster with sheared microtubules. We simulate all these features of the exchange kinetics, together with the length redistributions occurring at steady state of polymerisation, using a simple model based on a limited number of kinetic parameters deriving from the measurements of microtubule dynamics by Horio and Hotani. The observed exchange kinetics thus provide a direct experimental criterion of 'dynamic instability' of microtubules at steady state of polymerisation.

On the relationship between nucleotide hydrolysis and microtubule assembly: studies with a GTP-regenerating system

The assembly of pure tubulin dimer has been studied in two buffer systems (containing low and high glycerol/Mg), using a regeneration system protocol to assess the amount of GDP-tubulin in the assembling polymer. For both assembly systems studied, the GDP content is effectively stoichiometric with tubulin throughout assembly. This indicates a high degree of coupling between assembly and GTP-hydrolysis, giving a hydrolysis rate at least 10-fold faster than previously deduced. The steady state GTP hydrolysis rate is quantitatively consistent with this finding. We conclude that the extent of any GTP-tubulin cap is below the detectable limit, both during elongation and at steady state.

Tubulin-nucleotide interactions. Effects of removal of exchangeable guanine nucleotide on protein conformation and microtubule assembly

The removal of tightly bound GDP from the exchangeable nucleotide-binding site of tubulin has been performed with alkaline phosphatase under conditions which essentially retain the assembly properties of the protein. When microtubule protein is treated with alkaline phosphatase, nucleotide is selectively removed from tubulin dimer rather than from MAP (microtubule-associated protein)-containing oligomeric species. Tubulin devoid of E-site (the exchangeable nucleotide-binding site of the tubulin dimer) nucleotide shows enhanced proteolytic susceptibility of the beta-subunit to thermolysin and decreased protein stability, consistent with nucleotide removal causing changes in protein tertiary structure. Pyrophosphate ion (3 mM) is able to promote formation of normal microtubules in the complete absence of GTP by incubation at 37 degrees C either with nucleotide-depleted microtubule protein or with nucleotide-depleted tubulin dimer to which MAPs have been added. The resulting microtubules contain up to 80% of tubulin lacking E-site nucleotide. In addition to its effects on nucleation, pyrophosphate competes weakly with GDP bound at the E-site. It is deduced that binding of pyrophosphate at a vacant E-site can promote microtubule assembly. The minimum structural requirement for ligands to induce tubulin assembly apparently involves charge neutralization at the E-site by bidentate ligation, which stabilizes protein domains in a favourable orientation for promoting the supramolecular protein-protein interactions involved in microtubule formation.

Direct incorporation of guanosine 5'-diphosphate into microtubules without guanosine 5'-triphosphate hydrolysis

Using highly purified calf brain tubulin bearing [8-14C]guanosine 5'-diphosphate (GDP) in the exchangeable nucleotide site and heat-treated microtubule-associated proteins (both components containing negligible amounts of nucleoside diphosphate kinase and nonspecific phosphatase activities), we have found that a significant proportion of exchangeable-site GDP in microtubules can be incorporated directly during guanosine 5'-triphosphate (GTP) dependent polymerization of tubulin, without an initial exchange of GDP for GTP and subsequent GTP hydrolysis during assembly. The precise amount of GDP incorporated directly into microtubules is highly dependent on specific reaction conditions, being favored by high tubulin concentrations, low GTP and Mg2+ concentrations, and exogenous GDP in the reaction mixture. Minimum effects were observed with changes in reaction pH or temperature, changes in concentration of microtubule-associated proteins, alteration of the sulfonate buffer, or the presence of a calcium chelator in the reaction mixture. Under conditions most favorable for direct GDP incorporation, about one-third of the GDP in microtubules is incorporated directly (without GTP hydrolysis) and two-thirds is incorporated hydrolytically (as a consequence of GTP hydrolysis). Direct incorporation of GDP occurs in a constant proportion throughout elongation, and the amount of direct incorporation probably reflects the rapid equilibration of GDP and GTP at the exchangeable site that occurs before the onset of assembly.

Control of nucleation in microtubule self-assembly

The inhibition of the rate and amplitude of assembly of microtubule protein at low GTP concentration is shown by measurement of microtubule length distributions to be due to the suppression of microtubule nucleation. This inhibitory effect is enhanced by GDP added before assembly, but can be overcome by a number of molecules such as pyrophosphate or ADP. The selective inhibition of nucleation by GDP in vitro, which occurs in addition to inhibition of elongation, could provide a mechanism for the control of spontaneous microtubule nucleation in vivo.

Inhibition of microtubule elongation by GDP

GDP reduces both the rate and amplitude of GTP-induced assembly of microtubules from tubulin dimer or from microtubule protein, and promotes disassembly from microtubules at the steady state. One interpretation postulates that added GDP modifies microtubule ENDS so that tubulin-GTP, the species involved in steady state elongation of microtubules, cannot bind to a microtubule END containing tubulin-GDP. This concept has been used in subsequent models of assembly which treat the 'dynamic instability' of microtubules. We question this interpretation on the basis of the published experimental data and the results reported here. Using a relatively simple model for microtubule assembly, we show by numerical simulation that the quantitative effects of GDP on the rate and amplitude of microtubule assembly and inhibition of steady state GTPase activity are well accounted for by the nucleotide exchange equilibrium of tubulin-GDP and tubulin-GTP. We therefore conclude that the effect of added GDP on elongation of MAP-containing microtubules and on steady state GTPase activity does not indicate modification of the activity of microtubule ENDs but depends on the tubulin-GTP/tubulin-GDP equilibrium. Additional evidence argues that microtubule ENDS containing GDP can indeed accept elongation by tubulin-GTP.

Assembly of microtubules from nucleotide-depleted tubulin

In vitro assembly of microtubules from tubulin is considered to have an absolute requirement for added GTP (or a non-hydrolysable GTP-analogue) involving binding at the E(exchangeable)-site located on the beta-subunit of the tubulin dimer. By contrast, GDP inhibits assembly. Nucleotide hydrolysis has been implicated in the dynamic properties of microtubules, treadmilling and mechanical coupling. Here we demonstrate that assembly is not necessarily dependent on the presence of GTP at the E-site; microtubules can be formed efficiently in the absence of GTP in the presence of pyrophosphate. These microtubules, which have normal morphology and lability at cold temperatures, contain N(non-exchangeable)-site GTP and a significant proportion of E-site GDP. This demonstrates the possibility of direct incorporation of GDP-containing tubulin dimer during assembly which probably derives from microtubule-associated protein (MAP)-containing oligomers. This finding has important implications for the mechanism of microtubule elongation. The effects of pyrophosphate suggest that charge neutralization by the bidentate ligand is an essential step in promoting microtubule assembly, and that this interaction involves only a minimal conformational change in the protein.