Parameters for evaluation of viability assays: accuracy, precision, specificity, sensitivity, and standardization

Statistical simplex centroid experimental design for evaluation of pectin, modified chitosan and modified starch as encapsulating agents on the development of vitamin E-loaded microparticles by spray-drying

Vitamin E encapsulation into biopolymer-based microparticles, obtained by spray-drying technology, was proposed to improve the encapsulation efficiency and the controlled release of fat-soluble vitamin. Binary and ternary blends of pectin, modified chitosan and modified starch, modified starch + modified chitosan, modified starch + pectin, modified chitosan + pectin and modified starch + modified chitosan + pectin ((0.33, 0.33, 0.33), (0.70, 0.15, 0.15), (0.15, 0.70, 0.15) and (0.15, 0.15, 0.70)) were proposed to produce and evaluate different carrier-based delivery systems. Vitamin E-loaded microparticles and empty microparticles were created with a product yield between 9 and 49 %. The mean diameter among all microparticles varied between 3.74 ± 0.02 and 421 ± 21 μm (differential volume distribution). Oval, spherical or irregular microparticles, with a variable morphology from a smooth to a high rough surface structure, with concavities, were produced. All vitamin E-loaded microparticles exhibited an encapsulation efficiency higher than 70 %. The slower vitamin E controlled release was observed from microparticles composed by modified chitosan (>36 h), while the faster release was achieved from microparticles individually composed by pectin (39 min). In general, the Fickian diffusion is the main release mechanism involved in the microparticles produced with modified chitosan, other formulations combine also other mechanisms such as swelling.

Utility of cell viability assays for use with ex vivo vocal fold epithelial tissue

OBJECTIVES/HYPOTHESIS

Ex vivo models are routinely used to investigate the barrier function of the vocal fold epithelium. However, there are limited reports on assays that can be used to investigate the effect of clinically relevant challenges on vocal fold epithelial tissue viability. Our objective was to determine the utility of two assays routinely used in cell culture-a cellular metabolic activity assay and a cell membrane integrity assay-to investigate the viability of ex vivo porcine vocal fold epithelium.

STUDY DESIGN

Prospective, ex vivo animal study.

METHODS

Porcine vocal folds were exposed to acrolein, hydrochloric acid, or hydrogen peroxide challenge. An untreated, sham challenge was included as a control. Assays including metabolic activity, cell membrane integrity, and histology were used to determine whether challenges reduced epithelial viability as compared to sham.

RESULTS

Cell membrane integrity and metabolic activity assays detected reductions in viability following hydrochloric acid and hydrogen peroxide challenges but not acrolein challenge as compared to sham. No challenge produced significant changes in epithelial appearance as evidenced by light microscopy.

CONCLUSIONS

Metabolic activity and cell membrane integrity assays are valuable tools that can be used to evaluate the viability of ex vivo vocal fold epithelial tissue following clinically relevant challenges. As viability is reduced, the ability of epithelial tissue to maintain its barrier function is compromised. Accurate assessment of viability may provide us clues into understanding mechanisms underlying vocal fold epithelial injury and disease.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

NA Laryngoscope, 125:E180-E185, 2015.

Analysis of the metabolic deterioration of ex vivo skin from ischemic necrosis through the imaging of intracellular NAD(P)H by multiphoton tomography and fluorescence lifetime imaging microscopy

Ex vivo human skin has been used extensively for cosmeceutical and drug delivery studies, transplantable skin allografts, or skin flaps. However, it has a half-life of a few days due to ischemic necrosis. Traditional methods of assessing viability can be time-consuming and provide limited metabolic information. Using multiphoton tomography and fluorescence lifetime imaging (MPT-FLIM) we assess ischemic necrosis of ex vivo skin by NAD(P)H autofluorescence intensity and fluorescence lifetime. Ex vivo skin is stored in the presence and absence of nutrient media (Dulbecco Modified Eagle Medium) at -20, 4, and 37 degrees C and room temperature over a 7-day time course to establish different rates of metabolic deterioration. At higher temperatures we observe a decrease in NAD(P)H autofluorescence, higher image noise, and a significant increase in the average fluorescence lifetime (tau(m)) from approximately 1000 to 2000 ps. Additionally, significant distortions in NAD(P)H fluorescence lifetime histograms correspond to the reduction in autofluorescence. Skin kept at 4 degrees C, with or without media, showed the least change. Our findings suggest that MPT-FLIM enables useful noninvasive optical biopsies to monitor the metabolic state and deterioration of human skin for research and clinical purposes.

Transcriptional profiling of tissue plasticity: role of shifts in gene expression and technical limitations

Reprogramming of gene expression has been recognized as a main instructive modality for the adjustments of tissues to various kinds of stress. The recent application of gene expression profiling has provided a powerful tool to elucidate the molecular pathways underlying such tissue remodeling. However, the biological interpretations of expression profiling results critically depend on normalization of transcript signals to mRNA standards before statistical evaluation. A hypothesis is proposed whereby the “fluctuating nature” of gene expression represents an inherent limitation of the test system used to quantify RNA levels. Misinterpretation of gene expression data occurs when RNA quantities are normalized to a subset of mRNAs that are subject to strong regulation. The contention of contradictory biological outcomes using different RNA-normalization schemes is demonstrated in two models of skeletal muscle plasticity with data from custom-designed microarrays and biochemical and ultrastructural evidence for correspondingly altered RNA content and nucleolar activity. The prevalence of these biological constraints is underlined by a literature survey in different models of tissue plasticity with emphasis on the unique malleability of skeletal muscle. Finally, recommendations on the optimal experimental layout are given to control biological and technical variability in microarray and RT-PCR studies. It is proposed to approach normalization of transcript signals by measuring total RNA and DNA content per sample weight and by correcting for concurrently estimated endogenous standards such as major ribosomal RNAs and spiked RNA and DNA species. This allows for later conversion to diverse tissue-relevant references and should improve the physiological interpretations of phenotypic plasticity.

Regeneration of cryoresistance of in vitro rumen ciliate cultures

The purpose of this study was to investigate factors affecting mechanical- and cryo-resistance of the rumen ciliates Entodinium caudatum (E.c.), Entodinium furca monolobum (E.f.m.), Entodinium simplex (E.s.), Diplodinium denticulatum (two clones, D.d.01 and D.d.02), Diploplastron affine (D.a.) and Epidinium ecaudatum forma caudatum (E.e.c.) after long-term in vitro cultivation. Following prolonged in vitro cultivation (more than six months), the ciliates were very sensitive to both centrifugation and 5% (v/v) dimethylsulphoxide, with motility decreased to: 39 and 23% for E.c., 66 and 32% for E.f.m., 46 and 27% for D.d. 01, 64 and 41% for D.a., and 44 and 28% for E.e.c., respectively. Thus, cryopreservation was unsuccessful. The effect of supplementing the ciliate growth medium with rumen fluid, glycine-betaine, proline, myo-inositol, linoleic acid, Sel-Plex or insulin, together with the effect of the source of rumen fluid on ciliate resistance to centrifugation, dimethylsulphoxide and freezing was also tested. The omission of rumen fluid from the growth medium resulted in the loss of cryoresistance after one-month cultivation. Supplementing the growth environment with a combination of glycine-betaine, proline, linoleic acid, Sel-Plex, insulin plus improved quality rumen fluid significantly enhanced survival of the ciliates after the freezing-thawing procedure (from 1 to 33% survival in un-supplemented vs. supplemented for E.c., P<0.01; 4-40% E.f.m., P<0.01; 0-17% D.d., P<0.05; 5-7% D.a. and 4-36% E.e.c., P<0.01).

Quantitative reduction of methyl tetrazolium by fresh vein homograft biopsies in vitro is an index of viability

OBJECTIVE

The color density of the methyl tetrazolium (MTT) test is proportional to mitochondrial enzyme activity thus reflecting cellular viability. The aim was to evaluate the MTT test as a viability assay for vein homograft studies.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Fresh intact vein samples were harvested during multi-organ procurement. The reliability of the MTT assay was tested by a fluorescent dye combination (1 microg/ml propidium iodide PI and 4 microM/ml SYTO-16 stains). The enzyme kinetics of the reaction was also investigated. The optimal reagent concentration, biopsy size and incubation period were established.

RESULTS

There was a linear relationship between the vein homograft's weight and the pigment production activity. A nonspecific reaction (8.6%) was observed in negative controls. The MTT cleavage up to 0.1% (w/v) follows the Michaelis kinetics. The Michaelis constant (2,805 +/- 130 microM), the maximal velocity (196 +/- 2.2 x 10(-5 )microM s(-1)) and the velocity constant (6.98 +/- 0.2 x 10(-7) s(-1)) was calculated. The viability assessed by fluorescent dyes simultaneously visualized the live/dead cell ratio, which can be calculated by image analysis software.

CONCLUSION

The use of MTT in colorimetric assays offers high sensitivity. The assay is simple, inexpensive, and reproducible in vein homograft studies.

Evaluation of donor skin viability: fresh and cryopreserved skin using tetrazolioum salt assay

Cell viability assessment in allograft skin is an essential step to ensure a supply of good quality allograft skin for clinical repair of wounds. It is widely recognised that 'take' of allografts is strongly influenced grafted by tissue viability. The aim of this study was to set-up storage protocols that maintain high viability of the allograft after harvest, treatment and storage. In this study, the viability of post-mortem allografts (n=350) harvested from 35 different donors, was investigated using the MTT salt assay. The conditions of preparation and storage of the allograft included: 1. Fresh skin samples (about 12, 30, and 60h after harvesting). 2. The same specimens (stored at 4 and 37 degrees C) tested for at least 1 month. 3. Samples after cryopreservation and thawing. 4. Thawed specimens tested daily for at least 6 days. Parallel histomorphological analysis performed, under each of these conditions, showed a correlation between changes in structure and changes in viability as measured by the MTT quantitative assay. The viability index (VI) of skin is expressed as the ratio between the optical density (O.D.) produced in the MTT assay by the skin sample and its weight in grams. The percentage viability index is the ratio of the VI of the fresh sample (considered as 100% viability) and the value of specimens from the same harvest batch after storage or cryopreservation. The results indicated that samples tested within 12-30h from harvesting have an average viability index of about 75 with little variation. Samples tested within 60h have an average viability index of 40, showing a viability decrease of about 50%. A protocol to treat skin within a maximum of 30h was, therefore, set-up. The data suggested that skin stored at 37 degrees C, undergoes a viability increase during the first 2 days after harvesting. However, the viability under these conditions then decreased very quickly. After 6 days of preservation at this temperature the samples were no longer viable (PVI = 0). The tissue structure started to become damaged after 3 days. On the other hand, skin stored at 4 degrees C, showed a very slow viability decrease. After 15 days, viability was still almost 25% of the fresh sample. The tissue architecture showed no signs of damage under these conditions until day 7 from harvesting. MTT analysis was performed on the specimens cryopreserved with DMSO at 10%. These measurements were compared to viability assessment of the same fresh skin samples (considered as 100%) that were analysed within 30h from harvesting. The average PVI of thawed skin was 54% of the fresh sample. This result demonstrates that the viability of cryopreserved skin is comparable to the viability of fresh skin stored at 4 degrees C for 4 days. The PVI of thawed skin samples decreased dramatically within 24h, and had reached 0% within 6 days.

Effects of incubation temperature and time after thawing on viability assessment of peripheral hematopoietic progenitor cells cryopreserved for transplantation

Three widely used viability assessments were compared: (1) membrane integrity of nucleated cells using trypan blue (TB) exclusion and a fluorometric membrane integrity assay (SYTO 13 and propidium iodide), (2) enumeration of viable CD34+ cells, and (3) clonogenic assay (granulocyte-macrophage colony-forming units, CFU-GM). Post thaw peripheral hematopoietic progenitor cells (HPC) were incubated at 0, 22, and 37 degrees C for 20-min intervals before assessment. The recovery of viable nucleated cells assessed by TB and SYTO/PI decreased significantly with time at incubation temperatures of 22 and 37 degrees C (P<0.05), and correlated with the concentration of mononuclear cells (MNC) (r=0.936, P<0.05). The decrease in recovery of viable nucleated cells was slower when thawed cells were incubated at 0 degrees C compared with 22 degrees C or 37 degrees C. The recovery, measured by absolute viable CD34+ or CFU-GM, was not affected by 2 h post thaw incubation (P>0.05) at 0, 22, and 37 degrees C (P>0.05). There were no significant differences in the measured recovery of viable CD34+ cells and CFU-GM at all incubation times (P>0.05) and temperatures (P>0.05). Both CFU-GM and absolute CD34+ cells can be used as post thaw viability assays for HPC cryopreserved for transplantation.

Storage media and temperature maintain normal anatomy of cadaveric human skin for transplantation to full-thickness skin wounds

Cadaveric human skin provides an optimal temporary cover after early excision of full-thickness burns; however, engraftment is reduced greatly by cryopreservation. Refrigerated skin is generally preferred because of its rapid revascularization, presumably caused by its greater viability. In this study, the effects of storage solutions, temperature, and the changing of the storage media on skin graft anatomy were evaluated as an indicator of graft viability. Split-thickness human skin grafts (0.012-0.015 mm) were retrieved from cadaveric donors and grafted to circumferential, full-thickness skin wounds on athymic mice. After clinical determination of engraftment 3 months after grafting, 6-mm punch biopsy samples of the human skin were harvested and separated into two groups. Biopsy samples were stored in either saline or Eagle's minimal essential medium. Media were not changed or were changed every 3 days. All groups were stored at either 4 degrees C or room temperature (RT). After 5, 10, and 21 days of storage, biopsy samples were grafted onto athymic mice for 20 days. The biopsy grafts were then collected and prepared for histologic scoring on a scale of +4 (normal anatomy) to 0 (no epithelial cells). Significant differences in histologic scores were found by the nonparametric Kruskal-Wallis test followed by Wilcoxon pairwise comparison. Skin stored in media maintained better histologic anatomy than skin in saline, suggesting better maintenance of viability. There was also better preservation of anatomy after storage at RT for 21 days with media changes every 3 days when compared to unchanged media and all conditions at 4 degrees C. These results support the hypothesis that increased availability of nutrients and increased storage temperature maintain higher viability of cadaveric human skin for transplantation to full-thickness cutaneous wounds.

Metabolic detriment in donor heart valves induced by ischemia and cryopreservation

BACKGROUND

The injury resulting from postmortem ischemia is a critical deterrent to the availability of donor valves. Using the reduction of XTT-tetrazolium salt as a marker of metabolic sequelae, we assessed the injurious effect of ischemia and the metabolic sequelae in 156 porcine semilunar leaflets.

METHODS

The leaflets were randomly allocated to noncryoprocessed (n = 72) or cryoprocessed (n = 72) groups. At each preservation temperature of 4 degrees C, 24 degrees C, or 37 degrees C, 24 leaflets each were exposed to one of four storage periods of 9, 17, 30, or 60 hours. Twelve fresh aortic leaflets served as baseline reference samples.

RESULTS

There was a progressive loss in the metabolic functioning of valve leaflet cells in both noncryopreserved and cryopreserved tissue as the storage times increased. Cryopreserved tissue showed a greater loss of function than noncryopreserved tissue did. The metabolic injury was mainly a consequence of cryoprocessing. The greatest loss in metabolic functioning occurred in the valves stored for 60 hours. The least favorable combination of variables was cryopreservation and a precryopreservation storage time of 60 hours.

CONCLUSIONS

We conclude that 30- to 60-hour delays do not have a significant metabolic effect on cardiac leaflets. Thus it may be possible to safely extend the permissible ischemic periods after organ harvest.