Induction of DNA synthesis in amphibian erythroid nuclei in Rana eggs following conditioning in meiotic oocytes

Origin and progress of nuclear transfer in nonmammalian animals

This chapter traces the origin and progress of nuclear transfer that later became the paradigm for cloning animals. Classic studies in cytology, embryology, or genetics spanning more than five centuries that led to nuclear transfers in unicellular animals and to those in oocytes of insects, fish and amphibians are reviewed. The impetus for the development of successful nuclear transfers in amphibian oocytes in 1952 was to determine whether or not differentiated somatic cell nuclei are developmentally equivalent to zygote nuclei. Experiments in amphibians demonstrated several important results: (1) specialized somatic cell nuclei are extensively multipotent; (2) fertile adult amphibians can be cloned from embryonic and larval nuclei; (3) serial cloning expands the number of clones; (4) transplanting nuclei into oocyte cytoplasm induces reprogramming of their gene function; and (5) amphibian cloning became the model for cloning mammals. Subsequent studies in mice, a more technically favorable species, revealed that specialized cell nuclei are equivalent to zygote nuclei.

Mitotic Remodeling of the Replicon and Chromosome Structure

Animal cloning by nuclear-transfer experiments frequently fails due to the inability of transplanted nuclei to support normal embryonic development. We show here that the formation of mitotic chromosomes in the egg context is crucial for adapting differentiated nuclei for early development. Differentiated erythrocyte nuclei replicate inefficiently in Xenopus eggs but do so as rapidly as sperm nuclei if a prior single mitosis is permitted. This mitotic remodeling involves a topoisomerase II-dependent shortening of chromatin loop domains and an increased recruitment of replication initiation factors onto chromatin, leading to a short interorigin spacing characteristic of early developmental stages. It also occurs within each early embryonic cell cycle and dominantly regulates initiation of DNA replication for the subsequent S phase. These results indicate that mitotic conditioning is crucial to reset the chromatin structure of differentiated adult donor cells for embryonic DNA replication and suggest that it is an important step in nuclear cloning.

Behavior of M-phase synchronized blastomeres after nuclear transfer in cattle

M-phase synchronized bovine blastomeres were used to study the effect of nuclear-cytoplasmic synchronization on the developmental potential after nuclear transfer (NT). The capacity of nocodazole and benomyl to reversibly synchronize blastomeres from embryos in M-phase was evaluated. Nocodazole reversibly arrested bovine embryos at the studied stages and induced high rates of M-phases in morulae and compact morulae. In contrast, benomyl was less efficient than nocodazole to synchronize in M-phase. After transfer of an M-phase blastomere, premature chromatin condensation was the prevalent finding 1 hr post-fusion (hpf). Condensed chromosomes non-arranged in the equatorial plate (1-3 hpf) that acquired an organized structure over time (3-7 hpf) were subsequently observed. Anaphase-telophase structures were predominantly recorded at 4-9 hpf. About 50% of the embryos activated at both 3-4 and 6-7 hpf extruded a polar body-like structure 5 hr after activation, but this was not observed in embryos activated immediately after fusion. A significantly lower activation rate was observed for oocytes activated 3-4 hpf compared to those activated 6-7 hpf. However, the ability to undergo first cleavage was significantly lower in the latter group. Reconstructed embryos activated immediately after fusion showed no difference in the rate of activation compared to those activated 6-7 hpf, although the cleavage rate was higher. DNA synthesis was observed at a significantly higher rate in embryos activated both immediately and 3-4 hpf that did not extrude a PB-like structure than in those activated 3-4 hpf that extruded a polar body-like structure. Under the conditions tested M-phase donor cells cannot be properly remodeled after NT in cattle to trigger normal embryonic development. Our observations of chromatin structures together with DNA synthesis suggest that the failure in the development may be due to improper chromatin remodeling of mitotic nuclei after NT, which may result in chromosomal abnormalities incompatible with normal embryo development.

DNA replication in quiescent cell nuclei: regulation by the nuclear envelope and chromatin structure

Quiescent nuclei from differentiated somatic cells can reacquire pluripotence, the capacity to replicate, and reinitiate a program of differentiation after transplantation into amphibian eggs. The replication of quiescent nuclei is recapitulated in extracts derived from activated Xenopus eggs; therefore, we have exploited this cell-free system to explore the mechanisms that regulate initiation of replication in nuclei from terminally differentiated Xenopus erythrocytes. We find that these nuclei lack many, if not all, pre-replication complex (pre-RC) proteins. Pre-RC proteins from the extract form a stable association with the chromatin of permeable nuclei, which replicate in this system, but not with the chromatin of intact nuclei, which do not replicate, even though these proteins cross an intact nuclear envelope. During extract incubation, the linker histones H1 and H1(0) are removed from erythrocyte chromatin by nucleoplasmin. We show that H1 removal facilitates the replication of permeable nuclei by increasing the frequency of initiation most likely by promoting the assembly of pre-RCs on chromatin. These data indicate that initiation in erythrocyte nuclei requires the acquisition of pre-RC proteins from egg extract and that pre-RC assembly requires the loss of nuclear envelope integrity and is facilitated by the removal of linker histone H1 from chromatin.

Karyoplast-cytoplast volume ratio in bovine nuclear transfer embryos: effect on developmental potential

To evaluate the effect of karyoplast-cytoplast ratio on the development of nuclear transfer embryos, karyoplasts from day 4, day 5, and day 6 embryos were transferred to oocytes enucleated with different volumes of cytoplasm: Type 1, removal of a small volume of cytoplasm equivalent to the first polar body, Type 2, removal of a volume of cytoplasm approximately equal to the volume of the respective karyoplast, and Type 3, removal of half of the oocyte volume. In addition, the effect of experimental reduction of karyoplast cytoplasm was investigated in day 4 and day 5 karyoplasts. Intact day 4 karyoplasts fused to Type 3 cytoplasts did not support development to blastocysts, whereas these karyoplasts yielded blastocysts in combination with Type 1 (7%) and Type 2 cytoplasts (12%). After experimental reduction of cytoplasmic volume in day 4 karyoplasts, blastocysts (10%) were also obtained after fusion with Type 3 cytoplasts, probably due to reduction of cytoplasmic chimerism. With day 5 karyoplasts, blastocyst rate was higher in combination with Type 2 (34%) than with Type 1 (19%) and Type 3 cytoplasts (16%; P < 0.05). The use of day 6 intact karyoplasts resulted in a significantly (P < 0.05) higher proportion of blastocysts when fused with Type 2 (38%) or Type 1 cytoplasts (34%) than with Type 3 cytoplasts (16%). These results suggest that enucleation of oocytes with a volume similar to that of the respective karyoplast creates better conditions for cell cycle interactions with all types of karyoplasts than enucleation with minimal or large volume of cytoplasm.

Reactivation of DNA replication in nuclei from terminally differentiated cells: nuclear membrane permeabilization is required for initiation in Xenopus egg extract

We have used Xenopus egg extract to investigate the requirements for reactivation of DNA replication in nuclei isolated from terminally differentiated chicken erythrocytes. Previous work has shown that reactivation of erythrocyte nuclei in egg extract is accompanied by chromatin decondensation, nuclear envelope reformation, and the accumulation of egg lamin, LIII. However, in those studies, erythrocyte nuclei were prepared by methods that were not designed to maintain the selective permeability of the nuclear membrane, and as such, it is not clear if loss of nuclear membrane integrity played a role in the reactivation process. Therefore, the purpose of this study was to determine if changes in nuclear membrane permeability are required for reactivation of erythrocyte nuclei in egg extract. Nuclei with intact nuclear membranes were prepared from erythrocytes with streptolysin O and permeable nuclei by treatment of intact nuclei with the detergent Nonidet-P40. Like permeable nuclei, most intact nuclei decondensed, imported nuclear protein, and accumulated lamin LIII from the extract. However, unlike permeable nuclei, which replicated extensively in the extract, few intact nuclei initiated replication under the same conditions. These data demonstrate that permeabilization of the nuclear membrane is required for reactivation of DNA replication in terminally differentiated erythrocyte nuclei by egg extract and suggest that loss of nuclear membrane integrity may be a general requirement for replication of quiescent cell nuclei by this system.

Genomic potential of erythroid and leukocytic cells of Rana pipiens analyzed by nuclear transfer into diplotene and maturing oocytes

In order to determine whether differentiated somatic cells maintain genetic totipotency, nuclear transplantations from several differentiated somatic cell types into eggs and oocytes were performed previously in Rana pipiens and Xenopus laevis. The formation of postneurula embryos and tadpoles under the direction of the test nuclei demonstrated their genetic multipotency. In addition, Rana erythrocyte nuclei transplanted to oocytes directed more extensive tadpole development than those injected into eggs. We have extended our studies of the genomic potential of differentiated somatic nuclei from the peripheral blood of Rana pipiens. First, we show that the developmental potential of erythrocyte nuclei injected into oocytes at first meiotic metaphase was greater than those injected into diplotene oocytes. Second, we demonstrate that erythroblast and leukocyte nuclei transplanted to oocytes at first meiotic metaphase promoted more advanced tadpole development than those previously injected into Xenopus eggs. Third, erythrocyte nuclei were more successful in promoting advanced tadpole development compared with erythroblast and leukocyte nuclei. The results show that differentiated somatic nuclei transferred to the cytoplasm of oocytes at first meiotic metaphase display enhanced genomic and developmental potential over those transplanted to diplotene oocytes and eggs, at least for the three nuclear cell types tested from the peripheral blood.

Genomic potential in mammals

Embryos of amphibians, fish, sheep, cattle, swine and rabbits have been multiplied by nuclear transfer. Successful nuclear transfer in these species has been accomplished by transfer of a blastomere from a late stage embryo into an enucleated oocyte or egg with large scale multiplication achieved by serial repetition of the procedure using blastomeres from nuclear transfer embryos. This allows the production of clonal lines, which when appropriately selected for performance in a given trait, can be reproduced to capture in the offspring expression of both additive and nonadditive inheritance. The efficiency of producing offspring from nuclear transfer is low in mammals in both frequency of morula or blastocyst produced and maintenance of pregnancy after embryo transfer. In domestic animals the largest number of offspring from one embryo has been eight calves. Embryos as late as the 64-cell stage in cattle and 120-cell blastocyst in sheep have been used successfully as donors of blastomeres. Recloning has also been done in cattle. Potentially, nuclear transfer provides a mechanism for multiplication and production testing of clonal lines, a method for rapid genetic improvement and a means for rapid propagation of a selected genotype.

Genomic multipotentiality of differentiated somatic cells

Nuclear transplantations from several differentiated somatic cell types into amphibian oocytes and eggs revealed that their genome contains the genes required for the development of prefeeding tadpoles. In addition, erythrocyte nuclei directed the formation of feeding tadpoles (independent organisms) that advanced to larval stages with hind limb buds. Thus, the genome of several differentiated somatic cell types can undergo widespread activation and specify a multiplicity of cell types. Although evidence for the genetic totipotency of differentiated somatic cells is lacking, we speculate that the genetic totipotency of at least some differentiated somatic cell types still remains a tenable hypothesis.

The genome of frog erythrocytes displays centuplicate replications

Seven nuclear lines derived from erythrocyte nuclei of Rana pipiens were produced by serial nuclear transplantation into oocytes and eggs. Even at the termination of the experiments, embryos and tadpoles developed in the eighth transplant generations. Thus, there was no evidence that the mitotic progeny of the erythrocyte nuclei lost their ability to replicate their genomes and continue cell cycling. We conclude that the genome of noncycling and terminally differentiated erythrocytes maintains its potential for widespread replication and extensive reversal of gene function in excess of a hundred (centuplicate) cell cycles.

Activation of dormant genes in specialized cells

In several experimental systems the genomic capacity in specialized cells can be assessed by examining the activation of dormant genes. Since some of these specialized cells can be induced to change cell phenotype, all cell specializations do not necessarily involve irreversible genetic changes.

Effects of Ca2+ ions on the formation of metaphase chromosomes and sperm pronuclei in cell-free preparations from unactivated Rana pipiens eggs

Nuclei transplanted into unactivated amphibian eggs are known to condense into metaphase chromosomes whereas those transplanted into activated eggs decondense and enlarge. We have made cell-free cytoplasmic preparations from Rana pipiens eggs which can induce demembranated Xenopus laevis sperm to undergo changes similar to those seen in intact eggs. Sperm chromatin which is incubated for 3 hr in unactivated egg preparations made using a buffer containing 3 mM EGTA is induced to form metaphase chromosomes. However, decondensed interphase nuclei are formed when chromatin is incubated in unactivated egg preparations made without EGTA as well as in activated egg preparations. When Ca2+ ions are added to unactivated egg preparations made with EGTA, the preparations lose the ability to induce metaphase chromosome formation and become capable of decondensing sperm chromatin. Once the ability to decondense chromatin has developed, either in unactivated or activated egg preparations, it cannot be suppressed by the addition of EGTA. However, decondensation of sperm chromatin in activated egg preparations can be suppressed by the addition of unactivated egg preparations made with EGTA. In this case, the incubated sperm chromatin is induced to form metaphase chromosomes. These results may indicate that the chromosome condensation activity of unactivated egg cytoplasm can be sustained in cell-free preparations when Ca2+ ion levels are kept low, but when Ca2+ ion levels increase this activity is lost and replaced by a new activity which can decondense chromatin. Since this change in cytoplasmic activities is comparable to that occurring in the intact egg following fertilization, these results suggest that Ca2+ ions play a crucial role during activation in altering the cytoplasmic activities which control nuclear behavior.

Roles of cytosol and cytoplasmic particles in nuclear envelope assembly and sperm pronuclear formation in cell-free preparations from amphibian eggs

A cell-free cytoplasmic preparation from activated Rana pipiens eggs could induce in demembranated Xenopus laevis sperm nuclei morphological changes similar to those seen during pronuclear formation in intact eggs. The condensed sperm chromatin underwent an initial rapid, but limited, dispersion. A nuclear envelope formed around the dispersed chromatin and the nuclei enlarged. The subcellular distribution of the components required for these changes was examined by separating the preparations into soluble (cytosol) and particulate fractions by centrifugation at 150,000 g for 2 h. Sperm chromatin was incubated with the cytosol or with the particulate material after it had been resuspended in either the cytosol, heat-treated (60 or 100 degrees C) cytosol or buffer. We found that the limited dispersion of chromatin occurred in each of these ooplasmic fractions, but not in the buffer alone. Nuclear envelope assembly required the presence of both untreated cytosol and particulate material. Ultrastructural examination of the sperm chromatin during incubation in the preparations showed that membrane vesicles of approximately 200 nm in diameter, found in the particulate fraction, flattened and fused together to contribute the membranous components of the nuclear envelope. The enlargement of the sperm nuclei occurred only after the nuclear envelope formed. The pronuclei formed in the cell-free preparations were able to incorporate [3H]dTTP into DNA. This incorporation was inhibited by aphidicolin, suggesting that the DNA synthesis by the pronuclei was dependent on DNA polymerase-alpha. When sperm chromatin was incubated greater than 3 h, the chromatin of the pronuclei often recondensed to form structures resembling mitotic chromosomes within the nuclear envelope. Therefore, it appeared that these ooplasmic preparations could induce, in vitro, nuclear changes resembling those seen during the first cell cycle in the zygote.

Production of genetically identical sets of mammals: cloning?

In the past few years, there has been phenomenal progress in producing genetically identical mammalian multiplets by asexual means. The simplest method is to divide embryos into two, three, or four parts, and transfer the parts to surrogate mothers for gestation to term. Another approach is to inject nuclei from totipotent embryonic cells into fertilized one-cell embryos and to remove both male and female pronuclei. When these embryos reach the blastocyst stage, nuclei from their totipotent cells can be removed and injected into one-cell embryos, thus amplifying the process ad infinitum. Subsets of these embryos can be stored in liquid nitrogen to make genetic material for additional copies available indefinitely. Some of these techniques are fairly efficacious, others are not. No reliable techniques are available for making genetic copies of nonhomozygous adult mammals (or other vertebrates) unless samples of embryonic cells were cryopreserved when the individuals were embryos. However, injection of nuclei of spermatogonia into enucleated one-cell embryos is a promising strategy. The genetic totipotency of these nuclei is obvious since they become gamete nuclei. Moreover, the birth of mice from the diploidized genetic material of a single X-bearing spermatozoan after removal of the female pronucleus from a one-cell fertilized embryo suggests that we should eventually be able to make genetic copies of adult male mammals. This approach would not work for adult females because their oogonia have all become oocytes, and the DNA configuration in oocytes is not identical to somatic cells due to meiotic crossing over.

Gene reactivation in erythrocytes: nuclear transplantation in oocytes and eggs of Rana

Adult erythrocyte nuclei of Rana, transplanted and incubated in the cytoplasm of maturing oocytes, direct matured oocytes to form swimming tadpoles. These results demonstrate that nuclei of noncycling and terminally differentiated erythrocytes contain the genes to specify tadpole development, and conditioning these nuclei in the cytoplasm of oocytes leads to a widespread reactivation of dormant genes.