Unequal activation by estrogen of individual Xenopus vitellogenin genes during development

Autoregulation and crossregulation of nuclear receptor genes

Whereas crossregulation of nuclear receptors has been known for some time, recently several examples of autoregulation have been described, especially during development and specific gene expression. In this review, I discuss both these phenomena, based on some studies from our laboratory on amphibian metamorphosis and egg protein gene expression. These include autoinduction of estrogen receptor (ER) accompanying egg protein gene expression in adult and larval Xenopus; autoinduction of thyroid hormone receptor (TR) during metamorphosis and in adult Xenopus; crossregulation by triiodothyronine (T(3)) and dexamethasone of autoinduction of ER; and inhibition by PRL of autoinduction and crossinduction of TR and ER genes. A dual receptor threshold model to explain the interplay between T(3), estrogen and PRL is presented and its significance to the general question of nuclear receptor autoregulation and crossregulation during development is also discussed.

Interplay between thyroid hormone and estrogen in modulating expression of their receptor and vitellogenin genes during Xenopus metamorphosis

Many postembryonic developmental processes are regulated by an intricate interplay among hormones and growth factors. Thyroid hormone (TH) and estrogen are well known to be individually and obligatorily required for the initiation and progression of amphibian metamorphosis and vitellogenesis. However, whether or not a possible interplay between these two hormones would affect these two developmental processes is not known. Here we report on how triiodothyronine (T3) enhances the precocious activation of vitellogenin (Vit) genes by estradiol (E2) in Xenopus tadpoles during metamorphosis. Using a combination of filter hybridization, RNase protection assay and in situ hybridization, we first show that very low doses (10(-9) M) of exogenous T3 will autoinduce thyroid hormone receptor (TR) mRNA in several tissues of premetamorphic tadpoles. The same treatment enhances and accelerates the precocious activation of the silent vitellogenin genes by E2 at metamorphic climax (stages 60-64) but not before mid-metamorphosis (stages 56-58). This developmental stage dependency may be explained by our finding that, under the same experimental conditions, T3 fails to alter the autoinduction of ER mRNA at mid-metamorphosis but strongly potentiates it at metamorphic climax. Thus a developmental stage specific interplay between thyroid hormone and estrogen determines the kinetics and extent of activation of vitellogenin and estrogen receptor genes during Xenopus postembryonic development.

Thyroid hormone potentiates estrogen activation of vitellogenin genes and autoinduction of estrogen receptor in adult Xenopus hepatocytes

Although the important role of thyroid hormones in regulating metamorphosis of amphibian larvae is well known, it has not been clearly established if thyroid hormones have any function in the activities of adult amphibian tissues. We now describe a strong effect of 3,3',5-triiodothyronine (T3) on adult Xenopus liver cells. Low doses of T3 rapidly (within 6-12 h) potentiate the activation of vitellogenin (Vit) genes by estradiol-17 beta (E2) in primary cultures of adult male and female Xenopus hepatocytes. This effect is developmentally regulated and is first manifested during metamorphic climax. In an attempt to explain this potentiation, we find that T3 also upregulates thyroid hormone receptor beta, but not alpha, transcripts and rapidly enhances the autoinduction of estrogen receptor (ER) mRNA in adult Xenopus hepatocytes. In transient transfection of the Xenopus cell line XTC-2 with an estrogen response element--chloramphenicol transacetylase (ERE-CAT) construct T3 was found to potentiate the transcription by E2 from the transfected ERE, thus suggesting that it enhances the accumulation of functional ER. We conclude that T3 can function in adult amphibian tissues, and discuss the significance of thyroid hormone potentiation of responses to estrogen in reproductive processes.

Autoinduction of nuclear receptor genes and its significance

Although downregulation of receptors by their respective hormonal ligands is a well-studied phenomenon, relatively less is known about autoupregulation of receptors. However, an increasing number of observations of the latter process are now being reported. Here, we discuss the phenomenon of autoinduction of nuclear receptors of the steroid/thyroid hormone gene family, and its significance in the context of the developmental and gene regulatory function of the ligands. Much of this review is illustrated by recent work from our laboratory on the autoregulation of Xenopus estrogen (ER) and thyroid hormone (TR) receptors and their transcripts, accompanying or anticipating vitellogenesis and metamorphosis, respectively. The activation by estrogen (E2) of the silent vitellogenin genes and the induction of FOSP-1 genes in primary cultures of hepatocytes from male Xenopus and oviduct cells, respectively, are tightly coupled to a substantial upregulation of ER protein and its transcript. The developmental competence to activate vitellogenin in response to E2 was found to be acquired during late metamorphosis. Since the latter process is obligatorily controlled by thyroid hormones (TH), we extended our studies to the developmental and hormonal regulation of Xenopus TR genes. Although very low levels of TR alpha and beta mRNAs are detectable in embryos and early larvae, there is a large increase in the accumulation of both transcripts before the onset of metamorphosis (stage 54 tadpoles), by which time the larval thyroid gland has first begun to secrete TH. Filter and in situ hybridization revealed that the two transcripts were differentially regulated and were not equally distributed in all regions or tissues of the tadpole. Their concentration peaks at metamorphic climax and drops to low levels in froglets and adult Xenopus. Exogenous TH given to pre-metamorphic tadpoles is known to induce metamorphosis precociously. Administration of triiodothyronine (T3) to early tadpoles (stages 50/52) caused a rapid upregulation of TR alpha and beta mRNAs which was particularly marked for the beta transcript (20- to 50-fold increase in steady-state levels). This autoinduction, which is the earliest response to T3, is mimicked to variable degrees in some Xenopus cell lines. In XTC-2 cells, in which the in vivo process is fully reproduced, it was possible to show with cycloheximide that the increase in TR mRNA requires protein synthesis. It was also possible to show by transfection of XTC-2 cells with a reporter-promoter construct of Xenopus albumin gene, which is a target for T3, that the extra TR mRNA increases functional receptor in the cell. Although the role of TH is well-known in metamorphosis, we found that TR is also autoinduced in primary culture of adult male Xenopus hepatocytes. The significance of this finding lies in the fact that T3 potentiates the autoinduction of ER and the de novo activation of vitellogenin genes by E2. Prolactin (PRL) is known to exert a "juvenilizing" action by preventing the induction of amphibian metamorphosis by TH. It is therefore highly significant that PRL prevented both the autoinduction of TR alpha and beta mRNAs in whole tadpoles and organ cultures and the activation of TR target genes, such as those encoding albumin and 63 kDa adult-type keratin. Although how PRL exerts its antimetamorphic effect is not known, these findings lead us to propose a dual threshold model for the autoinduction of TR, whereby the autoinduction of TR genes requires a very low level of TR and TH to rapidly augment the amount of functional TR. This higher amount of receptor would be required to achieve a higher threshold to activate "downstream" or target genes which specify the adult phenotype at the end of metamorphosis. Finally, a survey of recent literature shows that the phenomenon of autoinduction is not restricted to Xenopus ER and TR but is more widespread among members of the nuclear receptor family.

Xenopus transcription factors: key molecules in the developmental regulation of differential gene expression

Images

Vitellogenin gene expression in male rainbow trout (Salmo gairdneri)

Estrogen has a marked effect on the expression of vitellogenin, the egg yolk precursor protein in the liver of egg-laying vertebrates. cDNA clones specific for trout vitellogenin mRNA have been used to study the expression of the vitellogenin genes in rainbow trout (Salmo gairdneri). The steady-state levels of vitellogenin mRNA in the liver of male rainbow trout were measured during primary and secondary stimulation with estradiol. The kinetics of induction in trout appear to be very similar to those seen in Xenopus and chicken in that a lag of approximately 2 days is observed in the accumulation of serum vitellogenin during primary induction. This lag is not observed during the secondary stimulation. The primary induction of vitellogenin mRNA in trout liver, using a single injection of estradiol (3 mg/kg body wt) results in a short-lived rise, reaching a maximum level of 260 ppm total RNA on Day 2. Using silastic implants of estradiol to induce a primary response produces a large increase in the steady-state level of vitellogenin mRNA which reaches a maximum of 2750 ppm total RNA on Day 10. During secondary stimulation, using silastic tubing the maximum level reached was 1200 ppm of the total RNA on Day 7, approximately half the level seen in the primary induction using the silastic implants. The difference in these two levels is due to an increase in the steady-state levels of rRNA, which appear to increase between Days 10 and 21 after the primary stimulation. These results demonstrate that the induction of vitellogenesis in the trout by estradiol involves changes in the steady-state levels of a number of different mRNA and rRNA sequences and resembles that seen in Xenopus and chicken.

Isolation of chicken vitellogenin I and III cDNAs and the developmental regulation of five estrogen-responsive genes in the embryonic liver

The isolation of cDNA clones that code for portions of the two minor chicken vitellogenin (VTG) genes (VTGI and VTGIII) is reported. These clones represent unique sequences that are expressed exclusively in the livers of estrogenized birds. In the liver of the egg-laying hen, the levels of RNAs encoding VTGI, VTGII, and VTGIII are approximately 11,000, 30,000, and 3,000 molecules per cell, respectively. We have used the newly isolated clones, as well as the yolk protein cDNAs previously available [VTGII, apolipoprotein II (apoVLDLII), and apolipoprotein B], as probes to examine several aspects of the regulation of these genes by estradiol. First, we demonstrate that the capacity of each gene to respond to estradiol is acquired between 8 and 13 days in ovo. The response of four of these genes to estradiol is diminished during late fetal development, but the responsiveness is recovered within a week after hatching. Second, we demonstrate that these genes display distinct kinetic response profiles following the addition of estradiol. Third, as has been described previously for the VTGII and apoVLDLII genes, we demonstrate that a single injection of estradiol effects a long-term reprogramming event (hepatic memory) that allows a faster onset of the rapid accumulation of both VTGI and VTGIII RNAs following a subsequent rechallenge by estradiol. Collectively, these three sets of data suggest molecular parameters that may contribute to both the coordinate and noncoordinate regulation of this set of genes by estradiol.

Vitellogenin mRNA in locust fat body: coordinate induction of two genes by a juvenile hormone analog

Levels of vitellogenin (Vg) mRNA in Locusta migratoria fat body were determined as indicators of gene expression induced by the juvenile hormone analog methoprene. After injection of methoprene into juvenile hormone-deprived locusts, excised fat bodies were cultured with [3H]leucine for immunochemical assay of Vg synthesis, and RNA was assayed for Vg mRNA content by hybridization with probes from the previously cloned locust Vg genes A and B. In general, the rise in Vg mRNA paralleled the rise in Vg synthesis. During the primary response to methoprene (in female locusts in which the corpora allata had been destroyed immediately after emergence), Vg mRNA was first detected after 18-24 hr and accumulated rapidly between 36 and 48 hr. The secondary response (in locusts allatectomized during vitellogenesis and kept until Vg disappeared) was accelerated, as Vg mRNA was detectable at 12 hr and titers rose steeply after 18 hr. When Vg synthesis was prematurely induced by injection of methoprene into fifth-stage female larvae, the kinetics of mRNA accumulation were similar to those of primary stimulation in the adult. After allatectomy of vitellogenic females, fat body Vg mRNA decayed with a half-life of about 24 hr, roughly paralleling the decline in Vg synthesis. Assays with the two Vg probes showed coordinate accumulation of gene A and gene B messages under all conditions tested: during primary and secondary stimulation in adult females and in the low-level response obtained by treating male larvae with methoprene.

Reduced stability of RNA coding for yolk polypeptide 3 in Drosophila melanogaster ovary

In Drosophila three yolk polypeptides (YP1, YP2 and YP3) are synthesized at two sites in the adult female: in the fat body tissue, from which they are transported via the haemolymph to the ovary, and in the ovarian follicle cells which surround the developing oocytes. All three yolk polypeptides are synthesized at equal levels in the fat body. In this paper we show that the steady-state level of YP3 RNA is significantly reduced in the ovary in comparison with the fat body, and that none of the yolk protein genes is amplified either in the fat body or the follicle cells. In order to determine the basis of the reduced level of YP3 RNA in the ovary, which could result from a lower rate of transcription or through a decreased stability of the RNA, we have devised an in vivo method of determining relative rates of gene transcription. In both the fat body and the ovary all three yolk proteins are transcribed at similar rates. Thus we infer that YP3 RNA is destabilised in the ovary, accounting for the reduction in its steady-state level.

Identification of the vitellogenin proteins in the newt Pleurodeles waltl (urodele amphibian)

Vitellogenin derived from the blood of estrogen-treated Pleurodeles waltl was identified by immunochemical and electrophoretic analyses, using an antiserum against plasma vitellogenin isolated by dimethylformamide precipitation. Pleurodeles vitellogenin migrates as four bands on native PAGE, designated alpha-, beta-, gamma- and delta- VTG, with apparent mol. wts of 250,000, 270,000, 280,000 and 520,000 respectively. In the plasma, from estrogen-treated males like from ovariectomized estrogen-treated females, an additional band (mu-VTG) was found by native PAGE, never observed in estrogen-treated female plasma. It has a mol. wt of about 380,000 and shows complete immunological cross-reactivity with the vitellogenin antiserum. At least two polypeptides, termed VTG-I and VTG-II (mol. wt = 180,000 and 210,000) were identified by SDS-PAGE. Rocket immunoelectrophoresis displays three distinct precipitate lines indicating major immunological differences between the plasma vitellogenins.

The Vi element. A transposon-like repeated DNA sequence interspersed in the vitellogenin locus of Xenopus laevis

A repeated DNA element in Xenopus laevis is described that is present in about 7500 copies dispersed throughout the genome. It was first identified in the 5' flanking region of one vitellogenin gene and was therefore named the Vi element. Seven copies are present within the vitellogenin gene region, three of them within introns of the genes A1, A2 and B2, and the other four copies in the gene flanking regions. Four of these copies have been sequenced. The Vi element is bounded by a well-conserved 13 base-pair inverted repeat; in addition, it is flanked by a three base-pair direct repeat that appears to be site-specific. The length of these four copies varies from 112 to 469 base-pairs; however, sequence homology between the different copies is very high. Their structural characteristics suggest that length heterogeneity may have arisen by either unequal recombinations, deletions or tandem duplications. Altogether, the characteristics and properties of the Vi element indicate that it might represent a mobile genetic element. One of the four copies sequenced is inserted close (position -535) to the transcription initiation site of the vitellogenin gene B2 in a region otherwise showing considerable homology with the closely related gene B1. Nevertheless, the presence of the Vi element does not seem to influence significantly the estrogen-controlled expression of gene B2. In addition, three alleles of this gene created by length polymorphism in intron 3 and in the Vi element inserted near the transcription initiation site are described.

Inhibition by estradiol of binding and mitogenic effect of epidermal growth factor in primary cultures of Xenopus hepatocytes

We demonstrate here the presence of two classes of EGF (epidermal growth factor) binding sites in primary cultures of male Xenopus liver parenchymal cells. One of these corresponds to the high-affinity receptor described in other tissues and species, and which exhibits the property of autophosphorylation. The number of EGF receptors decreased sharply in freshly prepared cultures but recovered to maximum levels within 24 h thereafter. Addition of EGF and insulin to the hepatocyte cultures enhanced the rate of DNA synthesis as measured by the incorporation of [3H]thymidine. Estrogen abolished this increase, reducing the incorporation to that seen with hydroxyurea. At the same time, the addition of estradiol reduced the number or activity of EGF receptors in a dose-dependent manner. The latter paralleled the activation of transcription of vitellogenin genes in Xenopus hepatocytes so that a high rate of DNA synthesis is unnecessary for or incompatible with the activation of the steroid hormone-induced vitellogenin genes.

Deinduction of transcription of Xenopus 74-kDa albumin genes and destabilization of mRNA by estrogen in vivo and in hepatocyte cultures

The goal of this study is to explain the molecular basis of the marked deinduction of Xenopus albumin synthesis and secretion accompanying the activation of vitellogenin genes by estrogen. We have characterized by restriction analysis, DNA sequencing and hybrid-selected translation of mRNA, a cloned cDNA specifying the two 74-kDa albumins which constitute the predominant circulating form of albumin in Xenopus laevis. Using this recombinant DNA plasmid as a hybridization probe, we have determined the steady-state levels of albumin mRNA, the rate of transcription of the two 74-kDa albumin genes and the stability of the mRNA in male and female Xenopus hepatocytes in vivo and in primary cell cultures following estrogen treatment. In both whole liver and cultured hepatocytes estradiol caused a rapid drop in the steady-state levels of 74-kDa albumin mRNAs, which was reversed spontaneously in the continued presence of the hormone. The concentration of albumin mRNA was substantially higher in male than in female hepatocytes, the hormonal effect being more marked in male than in female hepatocytes. The decrease in steady-state levels of mRNA was anticipated in male hepatocytes by a 70% inhibition of rate of transcription of albumin genes within 2 h of exposure to estradiol, as measured by run-off transcription in liver nuclei isolated from animals treated in vivo or by determining the absolute transcription rate in cell cultures. In the latter the diminished transcription rate returned to normal within 12 h in the continued presence of the hormone. Estradiol caused a threefold destabilization of albumin mRNA in both male and female hepatocyte cultures to t 1/2 = 3 h and 2 h respectively. The combined effects on rate of or transcription and mRNA stability largely explain the changes in the steady-state levels of mRNA caused by hormone administration. Comparison of the kinetics of transcription rates of vitellogenin and albumin genes in vivo and in vitro reveals a striking reciprocity in the selective activation of the inducible genes and deinduction of the constitutively expressed genes at the early stages of response of Xenopus hepatocytes to estrogen.

Vitellogenin genes and their products in closely and distantly related species of Xenopus

Plasma vitellogenins from two closely related species of Xenopus, X. laevis and X. borealis, and a more ancient species, X. tropicalis, exhibited the same size on gel electrophoresis and were immunologically related. Partial peptide maps of 125I-labelled plasma vitellogenins, however, revealed marked differences in th structure and organisation of vitellogenin in the three Xenopus species. Northern blot hybridisation of liver RNA from oestrogen-treated males and females, probed with cloned vitellogenin cDNA, revealed the presence of mRNA of the same size in the three species of Xenopus, which was absent in untreated male liver. Cell-free translation of total liver RNA showed the presence of functional mRNA coding for vitellogenin subunit of the same size (Mr congruent to 210,000). Restriction endonuclease digestion patterns of genomic DNA from the three Xenopus species, using cloned X. laevis vitellogenin cDNA as the hybridisation probe, revealed significant differences in the organisation of these genes, which occur at a higher multiplicity in X. laevis and X. borealis than in X. tropicalis. Thus, despite a high degree of conservation of size, overall sequence and immunological identity of vitellogenin genes and their products in the three species of Xenopus, there is a substantial structural rearrangement during evolution of Xenopus within this multigene family.

Sex- and tissue-specific, but hormonally independent, demethylation at the 3'-end of Xenopus vitellogenin gene B1

We describe three HpaII-specifying sequences in 6 kbp of DNA at the 3'-end of Xenopus vitellogenin gene B1 (two within the coding sequence and one downstream) which remain methylated in all tissues of adult male Xenopus. These sites are however fully demethylated exclusively in adult Xenopus liver parenchymal cells but not in oviduct, kidney or erythrocytes. Developmental studies suggest that this tissue- and sex-specific demethylation may occur gradually after metamorphosis. The methylation of these 3'-sites is independent of transcriptional activation by oestrogen of vitellogenin genes in male or female Xenopus.

Regulation by estrogen receptor of vitellogenin gene transcription in Xenopus hepatocyte cultures

We have used primary cell cultures of hepatocytes from male or female Xenopus laevis to study the mechanisms by which estrogen induces vitellogenin gene transcription and how primary exposure to estrogen renders cells more responsive to secondary stimulation. We have characterized the estrogen receptor in hormonally naïve cells and in hepatocytes treated with estrogen under a variety of conditions. Under all conditions the receptor has a Kd congruent to 4 X 10(-10) M. Hormonally naïve male cells contain 300 binding sites whereas female cells or male cells previously exposed to estradiol exhibit 6-7-fold higher levels. In parallel cultures, the absolute rate of vitellogenin gene transcription was determined by hybridization of newly synthesized RNA pulse-labelled with [3H]uridine to cloned Xenopus vitellogenin cDNA. Naïve male cells on primary stimulation with estradiol synthesized vitellogenin mRNA at an average rate of approximately 150 moles/cell/h compared to 1200 moles/cell/h for cells previously exposed to estrogen, thus bearing a close correlation with receptor number. Furthermore, we show that the kinetics of the induced up-regulation of receptor exactly parallel those of the increase in the rate of vitellogenin gene transcription upon secondary hormonal stimulation following various periods of primary exposure to estrogen. Addition of cycloheximide to cell cultures during primary estrogen treatment abolishes both receptor up-regulation and increased rate of vitellogenin gene transcription on secondary stimulation. In addition, primary treatment with the antiestrogen tamoxifen prevents both receptor up-regulation and an enhanced rate of transcription or accumulation of vitellogenin mRNA on secondary hormonal exposure. These results demonstrate that estrogen treatment of male Xenopus hepatocytes results in the rapid up-regulation of its own receptor to female levels via new receptor synthesis, and that receptor number is rate-limiting in vitellogenin gene transcription.

Primary culture, cellular stress and differentiated function

Isolation of specialized cell types for the analysis of tissue-specific gene function often results in loss of the differentiated phenotype. Examples of this type of phenotypic change following tissue disaggregation are reviewed together with possible explanations. Close similarities between the effects of cell isolation with those of other cellular stresses such as heat or anoxia point to common biochemical mechanisms being involved. This suggests that the study of freshly isolated cells will contribute significantly to out understanding of the nature of cellular stress and its consequences for the maintenance of phenotype and induction of tissue specific gene expression.