Promiscuous or heterogeneous muscarinic receptors in rat atria? II. Antagonism of responses to carbachol by pirenzepine

The assessment of antagonist potency under conditions of transient response kinetics

The muscarinic acetylcholine receptor antagonists, atropine and pirenzepine, produced an apparent insurmountable antagonism of muscarinic M(1) receptor-mediated intracellular Ca(2+) mobilization in Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells when tested against the agonists carbachol or xanomeline. Each antagonist caused a dextral shift of the agonist concentration-response curves with depression of the maximum response that was incomplete (i.e., saturated) and which varied with the pairs of agonist and antagonist. Equilibrium competition binding assays found no deviation from simple, reversible competitive behavior for either antagonist. The relative rates of dissociation of unlabeled atropine and pirenzepine were also assessed in radioligand kinetic studies and it was found that atropine dissociated from the receptor approximately 8-fold slower than pirenzepine. Numerical dynamic simulations suggested that the insurmountability of antagonism observed in the present study was probably a kinetic artifact related to the measurement of transient responses to a non-equilibrated agonist in the presence of a slowly dissociating antagonist. Importantly, the patterns of antagonism observed included a saturable depression of agonist maximal response, a mode of antagonism that is incompatible with the previously described phenomenon of hemi-equilibrium states. Monte Carlo simulations indicated that reasonable, semi-quantitative estimates of antagonist potency could be determined by a minor modification of standard methods, where equieffective agonist concentrations, rather than EC(50) values, are compared in the absence and presence of antagonist. Application of the latter approach to the functional data yielded estimates of antagonist potency that were in excellent agreement with those derived from the equilibrium binding assays, thus indicating that the present method can be useful for quantifying antagonist potency under non-equilibrium conditions.

Muscarinic M3 receptors mediate contractions in rabbit, endothelium-denuded aorta in vitro

1. Muscarinic receptors mediating contraction of rabbit endothelium-denuded aorta have been characterized functionally, in vitro, using a range of antagonists (atropine, pirenzepine, methoctramine, himbacine, 4-diphenyl-acetoxy-N-methyl piperidine methiodide (4-DAMP) and para-fluoro-hexahydro-siladifenidol (p-F-HHSiD). 2. The non-selective muscarinic agonist, (+)cis-dioxolane, induced concentration-dependent contractions of endothelium-denuded aortic rings. The potency (EC50) of (+)cis-dioxolane was 1.0 +/- 0.4 microM and the maximal increase in isometric tension was 944 +/- 98 mg (mean +/- SEM, n = 25). The concentration-effect curves to (+)cis-dioxolane were shifted to the right in the presence of antagonists, in a concentration-dependent manner. The following affinities (-log KB) were calculated; atropine, 9.4; pirenzepine, 6.6; methoctramine, 5.9; himbacine, 7.1; 4-DAMP, 9.2; and p-F-HHSiD, 7.7. 3. It is concluded that muscarinic M3 receptors mediate contractions of endothelium-denuded aorta. The low potency of (+)cis-dioxolane, when compared to its potency in other M3 receptor assays, suggests that the efficiency of receptor coupling, associated with contraction of this tissue, is poor.

Analysis of muscarinic cholinoceptors mediating phosphoinositide hydrolysis in guinea pig cardiac muscle

The muscarinic receptor mediating stimulation of PI hydrolysis in guinea pig atria and ventricles has been studied. The non-selective muscarinic agonist (+)-cis-dioxolane elicited this response, concentration-dependently, with a potency indicative of a low receptor reserve. The potency of a novel, M2-selective agonist, L-660,863 (-log EC50 = 6.3, atria; 6.0, ventricles) was observed to be lower than its apparent affinity (-log KA = 7.6) for M2 receptors, indicating an action probably mediated by a population distinct from that producing negative inotropy in the same tissue. The inhibition of the response to (+)-cis-dioxolane by several muscarinic antagonists (atropine, pirenzepine, AF-DX 116, methoctramine, HHSiD and pFHHSiD) generated an affinity profile for this receptor also dissimilar to that described for the receptor mediating the classical cardiac 'M2' response. Although no other muscarinic receptor mRNA has been detected in this tissue, these data suggest the presence of a second population of muscarinic sites, which may signify an M2 receptor diversity.

Biphasic dose-response curves to arecoline in rat atria-mediation by a single promiscuous receptor or two receptor subtypes?

Arecoline produces a biphasic response in rat left atria, i.e., a depression of basal inotropy at low doses and a positive inotropic effect at higher doses. These present studies were designed to determine whether it can be shown that the two separate responses to arecoline are mediated by two distinct cell surface muscarinic receptors. The antagonists scopolamine, 4-DAMP and AF-DX 116 produced apparent simple competitive antagonism of the negative responses to arecoline. Schild analysis was used to measure the equilibrium dissociation constant of the antagonist-receptor complex for antagonism of this response to arecoline by these antagonists. In atria from rats treated with pertussis toxin, the negative inotropy to arecoline was abolished and only the positive inotropic effects were observed. The antagonism of the positive inotropic response to arecoline by these antagonists was studied separately in atria from rats treated with pertussis toxin by the Schild technique. The pKB estimates made from the Schild regressions indicated no evidence to suggest that the two responses to arecoline (negative and positive inotropy) were mediated by two separate receptors in rat left atria. These data are discussed in terms of a single muscarinic receptor in this tissue mediating these two responses by interaction with two G-proteins in the same cell membrane. These data also are discussed in terms of the use of agonist potency ratios for the classification of receptors.