Anatomical and physiological localization of prelabeled grafts in rat hippocampus

Clinical prospects for neural grafting therapy for hippocampal lesions and epilepsy

OBJECTIVE

Hippocampal lesions and epilepsy may be potential clinical targets for neural grafting. We hypothesized that neural grafting could be a restorative therapy either acutely, adding unformed neural elements, or chronically, treating postlesioning epilepsy. The goal of this review was to assess the clinical reality of this hypothesis of neural grafting and to determine the problems that remain to be resolved before grafting can be applied clinically.

METHODS

We quantitatively defined graft integration within the host, on a cellular basis, by directly assessing survival of the transplanted neurons, graft cell dispersion and migration, neuronal differentiation and development, and establishment of appropriate local and long-distance synaptic connectivity.

RESULTS

Embryonic hippocampal suspension grafts demonstrate excellent survival rates (20-80%). Embryonic axons exhibit extensive, appropriate, local and long-distance connectivity, can facilitate reconstruction of excitatory and inhibitory cortical circuitry, and can prevent the formation of aberrant circuitry. Immature neural stem cells demonstrate lesser degrees of integration, likely because of a paucity of positional cues in the lesioned brain for the differentiation of stem cells into region-specific neuronal phenotypes. Labeled grafted cells may be selectively and noninvasively removed from the host with triggerable stealth toxins, for the late treatment of unanticipated graft problems.

CONCLUSION

Neural grafting with appropriate embryonic neurons may provide significant clinical benefits. However, embryonic cell availability is severely limited, and alternative sources of cells, such as stem cells, require significant additional research into the induction and maintenance of neuronal commitment and the ability of the cells to form functional synaptic connections in vivo.

Persistent neuronal labeling by retrograde fluorescent tracers: a comparison between Fast Blue, Fluoro-Gold and various dextran conjugates

The permanence of retrograde neuronal labeling by the fluorescent tracers Fast Blue, Fluoro-Gold, Mini-Ruby, Fluoro-Ruby and Fluoro-Emerald was investigated in adult rat spinal motorneurons at 1, 4, 12 and 24 weeks after tracer application to a transected muscle nerve. After 1 week, the largest number of retrogradely labeled motoneurons was found with Mini-Ruby, Fluoro-Gold and Fluoro-Ruby, while Fluoro-Emerald yielded a smaller number of labeled cells. With increasing survival time, all of these tracers exhibited a marked decrease in the number of labeled neurons. Fast Blue also produced very efficient staining after 1 week and, in addition, the number of Fast Blue-labeled cells remained constant over the entire time period studied. Also in embryonic spinal cord tissue exposed to Fast Blue. the label persisted for at least 6 months after transplantation into adult spinal cord. Double-labeling experiments combining Fast Blue with Fluoro-Gold, Mini-Ruby, Fluoro-Ruby or Fluoro-Emerald showed that all these substances were non-toxic and that the time-related decrease in the number of neurons labeled by the latter tracers was due to degradation or leakage of the dyes. Thus, Fast Blue would be the tracer of choice for motoneuronal labeling in long-term experiments, whereas the usage of the other tracers should be restricted to experiments of limited duration.

Development of fetal hippocampal grafts in intact and lesioned hippocampus

Functional recovery observed in Parkinson's disease patients following grafting of fetal substantia nigra has encouraged the development of similar grafting therapy for other neurological disorders. Fetal hippocampal grafting paradigms are of considerable significance because of their potential to treat neurological disorders affecting primarily hippocampus, including temporal lobe epilepsy, cerebral ischemia, stroke, and head injury. Since many recent studies of hippocampal transplants were carried out with an aim of laying the foundation for future clinical applications, an overview of the development of fetal hippocampal transplants, and their capability for inducing functional recovery under different host conditions is timely. In this review, we will summarize recent developments in hippocampal transplants, especially the anatomical and/or functional integration of grafts within the host brain under specific host conditions, including a comparison of intact hippocampus with various types of hippocampal lesions or injury. Improvements in grafting techniques, methods for analysis of graft integration and graft function will be summarized, in addition to critical factors which enhance the survival and integration of grafted cells and alternative sources of donor cells currently being tested or considered for hippocampal transplantation. Viewed collectively, hippocampal grafting studies show that fetal hippocampal tissue/cells survive grafting, establish both afferent and efferent connections with the host brain, and are also capable of ameliorating certain learning and memory deficits in some models. However, the efficacy of intracerebral fetal hippocampal grafts varies considerably in different animal models, depending on several factors: the mode of donor tissue preparation, the method of grafting, the state of host hippocampus at the time of grafting, and the placement of grafts within the hippocampus. Functional improvement in many models appeared to be caused partially by re-establishment of damaged circuitry and partially by a trophic action of grafts. However, exact mechanisms of graft-mediated behavioral recovery remain to be clarified due to the lack of correlative analysis in the same animal between the degree of graft integration and behavioral recovery. Issues of mechanisms of action, degree of restoration of host circuitry and amelioration of host pathological conditions will need to be sorted out clearly prior to clinical use of fetal hippocampal transplants for susceptible neurological conditions.

In vitro labeling strategies for identifying primary neural tissue and a neuronal cell line after transplantation in the CNS

Potential labels for identifying embryonic raphe neurons and a clonal, neuronally differentiating, raphe-derived cell line, RN33B, in CNS transplantation studies were tested by first characterizing the labels in vitro. The labels that were tested included 4',6-diamidino-2-phenylindole hydrochloride, 1,1'-dioctadecyl-3,3,3'-tetramethylindocarbocyanine perchlorate, the Escherichia coli lacZ gene, Fast Blue, Fluoro-Gold, fluorescein-conjugated latex microspheres, fluorescein isothiocyanate-conjugated or nonconjugated Phaseolus vulgaris leucoagglutinin, methyl o-(6-amino-3'-imino-3H-xanthen-9-yl) benzoate monohydrochloride, or tetanus toxin C fragment. Subsequently, the optimal in vitro labels for embryonic raphe neurons and for RN33B cells were characterized in vivo after CNS transplantation. In vitro, 1,1'-dioctadecyl-3,3,3'-tetramethylindocarbocyanine perchlorate (DiI) optimally labeled embryonic neurons. The Escherichia coli lacZ gene optimally labeled RN33B cells. Most labels were rapidly diluted in cultures of embryonic astrocytes and proliferating RN33B cells. Some labels were toxic and were often retained in cellular debris. In vivo, DiI was visualized in transplanted, DiI-labeled raphe neurons, but not in astrocytes up to 1 mo posttransplant. DiI-labeled host cells were seen after transplantation of lysed, DiI-labeled cells. beta-Galactosidase was visualized in transplanted, Escherichia coli lacZ gene-labeled RN33B cells after 15 days in vivo. No beta-galactosidase was seen in host cells after transplantation of lysed, lacZ-labeled RN33B cells. The results demonstrate that labels for use in CNS transplantation studies should be optimized for the specific population of donor cells under study, with the initial step being characterization in vitro followed by in vivo analysis. Appropriate controls for false-positive labeling of host cells should always be assessed.

Fluorescent labeling of dissociated fetal cells for tissue culture

The ability to pre-label cells used in transplantation experiments would have the potential benefits of identification of cell type and associated processes and the analysis of graft migration in the host. We have used an in vitro tissue culture system as a model to test several fluorescent dyes for this application. Fetal rat hippocampal tissue (E17-E18) was dissociated and incubated in the presence of carboxyfluorescein ester (CFSE), rhodamine-B dextran amine (RBD), DiI, or rhodamine-labeled latex microspheres. Cells were cultured in defined medium for up to 1 month. Cells labeled with CFSE were initially bright but faded over several days. RBD labeled the soma of cells, but fluorescence intensity was lost over a period of a few weeks. Cells labeled with DiI possessed brilliant staining of neuronal processes for weeks. Latex microspheres brightly labeled the soma but not the processes of neurons; fluorescent debris and sterility were problems with this label. We conclude that CFSE and DiI have significant potential usefulness in vitro as markers of cell viability and process formation with mammalian fetal CNS cells, whereas RBD is much less permanent. Latex microspheres may be suitable for pre-labeling of cells for transplantation if purification and sterility can be enhanced over present preparations.