Conformation mobility within the structure of muscular parvalbumins. An NMR study of the aromatic resonances of phenylalanine residues

Christopher Dobson, 1949-2019: Mentor, Friend, Scientist Extraordinaire

It is impossible to do justice in one review article to a researcher of the stature of Christopher Dobson. His career spanned almost five decades, resulting in more than 870 publications and a legacy that will continue to influence the lives of many for decades to come. In this review, I have attempted to capture Chris's major contributions: his early work, dedicated to understanding protein-folding mechanisms; his collaborative work with physicists to understand the process of protein aggregation; and finally, his later career in which he developed strategies to prevent misfolding. However, it is not only this body of work but also the man himself who inspired an entire generation of scientists through his patience, ability to mentor, and innate generosity. These qualities remain a hallmark of the way in which he conducted his research-research that will leave a lasting imprint on science.

Crystal structure of the EF-hand parvalbumin at atomic resolution (0.91 A) and at low temperature (100 K). Evidence for conformational multistates within the hydrophobic core

Several crystal structures of parvalbumin (Parv), a typical EF-hand protein, have been reported so far for different species with the best resolution achieving 1.5 A. Using a crystal grown under microgravity conditions, cryotechniques (100 K), and synchrotron radiation, it has now been possible to determine the crystal structure of the fully Ca2+-loaded form of pike (component pI 4.10) Parv.Ca2 at atomic resolution (0.91 A). The availability of such a high quality structure offers the opportunity to contribute to the definition of the validation tools useful for the refinement of protein crystal structures determined to lower resolution. Besides a better definition of most of the elements in the protein three-dimensional structure than in previous studies, the high accuracy thus achieved allows the detection of well-defined alternate conformations, which are observed for 16 residues out of 107 in total. Among them, six occupy an internal position within the hydrophobic core and converge toward two small buried cavities with a total volume of about 60 A3. There is no indication of any water molecule present in these cavities. It is probable that at temperatures of physiological conditions there is a dynamic interconversion between these alternate conformations in an energy-barrier dependent manner. Such motions for which the amplitudes are provided by the present study will be associated with a time-dependent remodeling of the void internal space as part of a slow dynamics regime (millisecond timescales) of the parvalbumin molecule. The relevance of such internal dynamics to function is discussed.

Hydration-coupled dynamics in proteins studied by neutron scattering and NMR: the case of the typical EF-hand calcium-binding parvalbumin

The influence of hydration on the internal dynamics of a typical EF-hand calciprotein, parvalbumin, was investigated by incoherent quasi-elastic neutron scattering (IQNS) and solid-state 13C-NMR spectroscopy using the powdered protein at different hydration levels. Both approaches establish an increase in protein dynamics upon progressive hydration above a threshold that only corresponds to partial coverage of the protein surface by the water molecules. Selective motions are apparent by NMR in the 10-ns time scale at the level of the polar lysyl side chains (externally located), as well as of more internally located side chains (from Ala and Ile), whereas IQNS monitors diffusive motions of hydrogen atoms in the protein at time scales up to 20 ps. Hydration-induced dynamics at the level of the abundant lysyl residues mainly involve the ammonium extremity of the side chain, as shown by NMR. The combined results suggest that peripheral water-protein interactions influence the protein dynamics in a global manner. There is a progressive induction of mobility at increasing hydration from the periphery toward the protein interior. This study gives a microscopic view of the structural and dynamic events following the hydration of a globular protein.

Conformational dynamics and enzyme activity

Conformational flexibility and structural fluctuations play an important role in enzyme activity. A great variety of internal motions ranging over different time scales and of different amplitudes are involved in the catalytic cycle. These different types of motions and their functional consequences are considered in the light of experimental data and theoretical analyses. The conformational changes upon substrate binding, and particularly the hinge-bending motion which occurs in enzymes made of two domains, are analyzed from several well documented examples. The conformational events accompanying the different steps of the catalytic cycle are discussed. The last section concerns the motions involved in the allosteric transition which regulates the enzyme activity.

Nuclear-magnetic-resonance studies of ferrocytochrome c. pH and temperature dependence

The pH dependence and the temperature dependence of the nuclear magnetic resonance spectrum of horse ferrocytochrome c are described. This protein is very stable; it maintains an ordered structure over the pH range 4 to 12 at 25 degrees C and over the temperature range 4 degrees C to 97 degrees C at pH 7.0. The dynamic characteristics of the conformation of ferrocytochrome c were investigated. Particular emphasis was laid on the aromatic resonances and resonances of methyl groups shifted far upfield. Tyr-48 and Phe-46 were found to be relatively immobile whilst a region of the protein close to Ile-57 was found to be relatively flexible.

Structure and evolution of calcium-modulated proteins

This review suggests that the intracellular functions of calcium are best understood in terms of calcium's functioning as a second messenger. Further, when functioning as a second messenger, calcium completes its mission not by transferring charge nor by binding to lipid but by binding to specific targets, calcium-modulated proteins. This concept is broadly interpreted to include proteins involved in calcium transport. There is strong evidence that many, if not all, of these calcium-modulated proteins are homologs. Their structures and properties are contrasted to those of extracellular calcium-binding proteins which are not homologous to one another or to the intracellular calcium-modulated proteins. Finally, this line of thought leads to a suggestion of the evolutionary reason for the choice of calcium as the sole inorganic second messenger.

Calcium and magnesium binding by parvalbumin. A proton magnetic resonance spectral study

Proton magnetic resonance spectroscopy has been used to monitor the kinetics and nature of the conformational transitions induced by binding of calcium and magnesium to carp parvalbumin. Rate constants have been determined for the exchange between the cation dependent conformational states of the protein in solution. These data enable a description of the kinetics and mechanism controlling the calcium flux in vivo during contraction.

Side-chain mobility and the calculation of tyrosyl circular dichroism of proteins. Implications of a test with insulin and des-B1-phenylalanine insulin

Previous calculations using crystal structure coordinates (Strickland and Mercola [1976], Biochemistry. 15: 3857) have predicted that about 40 percent of the calculated tyrosyl circular dichroism of hexameric insulin is due to one of the four tyrosine residues: viz. the A14-tyrosine interacting with the nearby B1-phenylalanine ring group. We have tested this prediction by measuring the tyrosyl circular dichroism of an isomorphous analogue of insulin, des-B1-phenylalanine-insulin. Contrary to expectation, the resulting circular dichroism was the same as that of insulin. It is concluded that the B1-phenylalanine residue does not in fact make a large contribution to the circular dichroism of A14-tyrosine. This result is probably due to the thermal motion of the B1 and A14 ring groups not taken into account by the calculations. An example of the effects of thermal motion on the calculated circular dichroism is given and improvements that do take into account thermal motion are discussed.