Proton conductance of the thylakoid membrane: modulation by light

Rethinking the existence of a steady-state Δψ component of the proton motive force across plant thylakoid membranes

Light-driven photosynthetic electron transport is coupled to the movement of protons from the chloroplast stroma to the thylakoid lumen. The resulting proton motive force that is generated is used to drive the conformational rotation of the transmembrane thylakoid ATPase enzyme which converts ADP (adenosine diphosphate) and Pi (inorganic phosphate) into ATP (adenosine triphosphate), the energy currency of the plant cell required for carbon fixation and other metabolic processes. According to Mitchell's chemiosmotic hypothesis, the proton motive force can be parsed into the transmembrane proton gradient (ΔpH) and the electric field gradient (Δψ), which are thermodynamically equivalent. In chloroplasts, the proton motive force has been suggested to be split almost equally between Δψ and ΔpH (Kramer et al., Photosynth Res 60:151-163, 1999). One of the central pieces of evidence for this theory is the existence of a steady-state electrochromic shift (ECS) absorption signal detected ~515 nm in plant leaves during illumination. The interpretation of this signal is complicated, however, by a heavily overlapping absorption change ~535 nm associated with the formation of photoprotective energy dissipation (qE) during illumination. In this study, we present new evidence that dissects the overlapping contributions of the ECS and qE-related absorption changes in wild-type Arabidopsis leaves using specific inhibitors of the ΔpH (nigericin) and Δψ (valinomycin) and separately using leaves of the Arabidopsis lut2npq1 mutant that lacks qE. In both cases, our data show that no steady-state ECS signal persists in the light longer than ~60 s. The consequences of our observations for the suggesting parsing of steady-state thylakoid proton motive force between (ΔpH) and the electric field gradient (Δψ) are discussed.

Light-induced proton slip and proton leak at the thylakoid membrane

A treatment of leaves of Spinacia oleracea L. with light or with the thiol reagent dithiothreitol in the dark led to partly uncoupled thylakoids. After induction in intact leaves, the partial uncoupling was irreversible at the level of isolated thylakoids. We distinguish between uncoupling by proton slip, which means a decrease of the H+/e(-) -ratio due to less efficient proton pumping, and proton leak as defined by enhanced kinetics of proton efflux. Proton slip and proton leak made about equal contributions to the total uncoupling. The enhanced proton efflux kinetics corresponded to reduction of subunit CF1-gamma of the ATP synthase as shown by fluorescence labeling of thylakoid proteins with the sulfhydryl probe 5-iodoacetamido fluorescein. The maximum value of the fraction of reduced CF1-gamma was only 36%, which indicates that in vivo the reduction of CF1-gamma could be limited by fast reoxidation and/or restricted accessibility of CF1-gamma to thioredoxin. Measurements of the ratio ATP/2e indicated that only the uncoupling related to less efficient proton pumping led to a decrease in the ATP yield.

The significance of molecular slips in transport systems

The advantage of precision in biological processes is obvious; however, in many cases, deviations from the faithful mechanisms occur. Here, we discuss how in-built operating imperfections in transport systems can actually benefit a cell.

Proton slip of the chloroplast ATPase: its nucleotide dependence, energetic threshold, and relation to an alternating site mechanism of catalysis

The F-ATPase of chloroplasts couples proton flow to ATP synthesis, but is leaky to protons in the absence of nucleotides. This "proton slip" can be blocked by small concentrations of ADP or by inhibitors of the channel portion, CF0. We studied charge flow through the ATPase by flash spectrophotometry and analyzed the inhibition of proton slip by nucleotides, phosphate/arsenate, and insufficient proton motive force. The following inhibition constants (at given background concentrations) were observed: ADP, 0.2 microM (0.5 mM P(i)); ADP, 13.4 microM (no P(i)); P(i), 43 microM (1 microM ADP); GDP, 2.5 microM (0.5 mM P(i)); ATP, 2 microM. ADP and P(i) mutually lowered their respective inhibition constants. Phosphate could be replaced by arsenate. Proton slip occurred only if the proton motive force exceeded a certain threshold, similar to that for ATP synthesis. The inhibition of proton slip by ADP and GDP qualified the respective nucleotide binding sites as belonging to the subset of two (or three) potentially catalytic sites out of the total of six. We interpreted the ADP-induced transition between different conduction states of the ATPase from "slipping" to "closed" to "coupled" as a consequence of the alternating site mechanism of catalysis. Whereas the proton translocator idles in the absence of nucleotides, the high-affinity binding of the first ADP/P(i) couple to one site clutches proton flow to some (conformational) change that can only be executed after the binding of another ADP/P(i) couple to a second site. From there on these sites alternate in the catalytic cycle. An entropic machine is presented which likewise models proton slip, unisite, and multisite ATP synthesis and hydrolysis.

Resting state respiration of mitochondria: reappraisal of the role of passive ion fluxes

Rat liver mitochondria respiring under resting state conditions in the presence of oligomycin were rapidly blocked with cyanide and the dissipation of the membrane potential, measured with a tetraphenylphosphonium-sensitive electrode, was followed over time. The plot of the rate of membrane potential dissipation versus the actual value of the membrane potential was nonlinear and identical to the plot of resting state respiration (titrated with small amounts of a respiratory inhibitor) versus the membrane potential. The relationship between the respiratory chain activity and the proton-motive force in mitochondria oxidizing succinate with either oxygen or ferricyanide as electron acceptors was also found to be identical. These results are interpreted as an indication that the passive permeability of the inner mitochondrial membrane toward ions is far more significant in maintaining resting state respiration than is the molecular slippage of the pumps in the respiratory chain. These results also confirm the non-ohmic characteristics of the inner mitochondrial membrane.

Slip and leak in mitochondrial oxidative phosphorylation

During oxidative phosphorylation by mammalian mitochondria part of the free energy stored in reduced substrates is dissipated and energy is released as heat. Here I review the mechanisms and the physiological significance of this phenomenon.

Anomalous uncoupling of photophosphorylation by palmitic acid and by gramicidin D

Palmitic acid and gramicidin D at low concentrations uncouple photophosphorylation in a mechanism that is inconsistent with classical uncoupling in the following properties: (1) delta pH, H+ uptake, or the transmembrane electric potential is not inhibited. (2) O2 evolution is stimulated under nonphosphorylating conditions but slightly inhibited in the presence of adenosine 5'-diphosphate + inorganic phosphate (Pi). (3) Light-triggered adenosine 5'-triphosphate (ATP)-Pi exchange is hardly affected, and ATPase activity is only slightly stimulated. (4) ATP-induced delta pH formation is selectively inhibited. This characteristic uncoupling is observed only when the native coupling sites of the electron transport system are used for energization such as for methylviologen-coupled phosphorylation. With pyocyanine, which creates an artificial coupling site, 1000-fold higher gramicidin D and higher palmitic acid concentrations are required for inhibition, and the inhibition is accompanied by a decrease in delta pH. Moreover, comparison between photosystem 1 and photosystem 2 electron transport and the effects of membrane unstacking suggest that low gramicidin D preferentially inhibits photosystem 2, while palmitic acid inhibits more effectively photosystem 1 coupling sites. The inhibitory capacity of fatty acids significantly drops when the chain length is reduced below 16 hydrocarbons or upon introduction of a single double bond in the hydrocarbon chain. It is suggested that palmitic acid and gramicidin D interfere with a direct H+ transfer between specific electron transport and the ATP synthase complexes, which provides an alternative coupling mechanism in parallel with bulk to bulk delta microH+. The sites of inhibition seem to be located in chloroplast ATP synthase, photosystem 2, and the cytochrome b6f complexes.

The relationship between light-induced increases in the H+ conductivity of thylakoid membranes and activity of the coupling factor

In the absence of a transmembrane electric field, about 15 saturating single-turnover flashes are required for chloroplast thylakoid membranes to accumulate the 80 mmol H+ X mol chlorophyll-1 that are necessary to form a delta pH sufficiently large to initiate net ATP synthesis. Lowering the number of turnovers of proton-producing redox components by decreasing the flash intensity increased the number of flashes required for the onset of ATP formation. Thus, regardless of the intensity, the accumulation of the same number of hydrogen ions was needed for phosphorylation to begin. Since the size of the threshold input was constant over a very wide range of proton accumulation rates, it follows that there were no significant proton leakages during the filling of the pool to its threshold level. However, non-productive leaks were initiated once phosphorylation began since progressively lower phosphorylation efficiencies were observed at lower and lower flash intensities. It is difficult to explain this observation except in terms of competing, non-phosphorylating hydrogen ion fluxes only when the threshold accumulation had been reached. We observed an increase in the permeability of thylakoid membrane to hydrogen ions that correlated with indications of coupling factor activity: the onset of ATP synthesis, the release of tightly bound ADP and, in dithiothreitol treated membranes, the initiation of ATPase activity. Our data support the notion that the dependence of coupling factor activation and deactivation on the delta pH accounts for the substantial changes in the ion conductivity that occur in thylakoid membranes.

Intrinsic and artifactual pH buffering in chloroplast thylakoids

After an increase in pH of the suspension medium, a pH gradient across the membrane of chloroplast thylakoids stored at pH greater than or equal to 6.5 is often maintained for several minutes. The intrinsic hydrogen ion buffering capacity of the thylakoid membranes between pH 6.5 and 8.5 is about 40 neq/mg chlorophyll, but can be artificially inflated by penetration of the external buffer into the thylakoid vesicle. A delta pH imposed across the thylakoid membrane by an acid/base transition cannot be estimated accurately by the fluorescent probe 9-aminoacridine, especially with osmotically shrunken thylakoids in which 9-aminoacridine appears to become bound or adsorbed to the membrane. This interaction may be related to the existence of the previously demonstrated special pool of slowly equilibrating, "sequestered" protons.

Changes in permeability to protons and other cations at high proton motive force in rat liver mitochondria

We have confirmed that the respiration rate of rat liver mitochondria can be substantially inhibited with only a small drop in proton motive force. We have directly measured the passive proton permeability as a function of delta psi by using K+ diffusion potentials and have shown that there is a large increase in proton permeability at high delta psi. This can quantitatively account for the inhibitor titrations of respiration. delta psi and delta pH were shown to have roughly equal effects on the relatively high respiration rate in static head. The permeabilities to K+, tetramethylammonium+ and choline+ were shown to increase greatly at high delta psi, in a similar way to proton permeability, indicating a similar mechanism of entry.

Homeostasis of the protonmotive force in phosphorylating mitochondria

The relationship between the respiration rate and the magnitude of the electrochemical proton potential (delta mu H+) in rat liver mitochondria was investigated. (1) Under the active-state conditions, the action of inhibitors of either phosphorylation (oligomycin) or respiration (rotenone, malonate) on the respiration and delta mu H+ was measured. Both inhibitors diminished the respiration, whereas rotenone resulted in a decrease of delta mu H+, and oligomycin produced an increase of this potential. The effect of the inhibitors was much more pronounced on the respiration rate than on delta mu H+; for example, the excess of oligomycin produced a 90% inhibition of the respiration while delta mu H+ was changed only by 9%. (2) Under the resting-state conditions, small concentrations of the uncoupler stimulated the respiration while changing delta mu H+ to a relatively small extent. The uncoupler concentrations which doubled and tripled the respiration rate produced only 5 and 9% decrease of delta mu H+, respectively. (3) The present results enabled us to propose a model describing the interrelationship between respiration and delta mu H+.

Changes in membrane ionic conductance, but not changes in slip, can account for the non-linear dependence of the electrochemical proton gradient upon the electron-transport rate in chromatophores

Decrease in the rate of cyclic electron transport (JE) measured from the absorbance changes associated with reaction centre bacteriochlorophyll led to a less than proportionate decrease in the membrane potential (delta psi) measured by electrochromism. In principle this result can be explained either by a delta psi-dependent slip in the H+/e- coupling ratio (nE) or by a delta psi-dependent change in the membrane ionic conductance. Simultaneous measurement of the membrane ionic current (JDIS) did not reveal any significant changes in the H+/e- ratio (JDIS/JE) and showed that conductance changes (JDIS/delta psi) account quantitatively for the curved dependence of delta psi on JE. Simultaneous recordings of JDIS and the extravesicular pH from cresol-red absorbance changes, suggest that protons are the main current-carrying species across the chromatophore membrane at high values of delta psi in the presence and absence of Fo-ATPase inhibitor. At reduced delta psi the flux of other ions outweighs the hydrogen ion current.

The relationship between the rate of respiration and the protonmotive force. The role of proton conductivity

It is shown by titrating a suspension of rat liver mitochondria with either ADP or an uncoupler that a specific rate of respiration may not have a unique associated value of the protonmotive force. Alternatively, a specific protonmotive force may not be associated with a unique rate of respiration. It seems that the rate of respiration and the protonmotive force are more sensitive to the agents used for the titrations than to each other. Such observations are not easily explained by the chemiosmotic hypothesis. It is, however, possible provided that the proton conductivities, i.e. the rates of dissipation of the protonmotive force, are considered to be different for each of the agents used to titrate the rate of respiration at the same protonmotive force, or vice versa.

Molecular slipping in redox and ATPase H+ pumps

The titration of the mitochondrial ATPase H+ pump with oligomycin has been compared with the titration of the redox H+ pump with antimycin. In both cases there is extensive inhibition of the pumps without significant depression of delta muH. The two pumps exhibit 'nonohmic' behavior in different ranges of delta muH. This discrepancy favors the hypothesis of nontightly coupled or 'slipping' H+ pumps with respect to that of a steep dependence of the membrane 'leak' conductance for H+ on delta muH.

The effects of partial uncoupling upon the kinetics of ATP synthesis by vesicles from Paracoccus denitrificans and by bovine heart submitochondrial particles. Implications for the mechanism of the proton-translocating ATP synthase

1. Reduction in the magnitude of the respiration-dependent protonmotive force (proton electrochemical gradient in mV) of vesicles from Paracoccus denitrificans, and of submitochondrial particles, has been found to be paralleled small increases in S50% values for both ADP and Pi. For example, reduction of the protonmotive force of P. denitrificans vesicles from 145 mV to 110 mV was accompanied by an increase of S50% (ADP) from 8 microM to 18 microM, and an increase of S50% (Pi) from 0.33 mM to 1.4 mM. This result was obtained with partial uncoupling quantities of both carbonyl-cyanide p-trifluoromethoxyphenylhydrazone and of the synergistic combination of nigericin plus valinomycin in the presence of K+. In view of the similar effects of these two different methods of uncoupling it is concluded that the changes in S50% were a consequence of the diminished protonmotive force acting on the ATP synthase rather than of a secondary, direct interaction of the uncouplers with the enzyme. Changes in S50% rather than Km are described because under several sets of conditions double-reciprocal plots were nonlinear. 2. For equivalent attenuations in the rate of ATP synthesis by submitochondrial particles, 2,4-dinitrophenol caused much larger increases in S50% (ATP) than did carbonylcyanide p-trifluoromethoxyphenylhydrazone. Therefore it is concluded that the effect of 2,4-dinitrophenol was primarily a consequence of its previously recognized direct interaction with the F1 segment of the mitochondrial ATPase. The concentration range of 2,4-dinitrophenol that raised S50% (ADP) is similar to that which weakens the binding of ADP to a particular type of site on the purified F1 sector of ATP synthase. This correlation is consistent with such a site having a catalytic role during ATP synthesis. 3. A titration of the rate of ATP synthesis by vesicles of P. denitrificans with increasing quantities of carbonylcyanide p-trifluoromethoxyphenylhydrazone showed that the initial titres of the uncoupler caused large decreases in the rate of ATP synthesis for relatively small attenuations in the protonmotive force. Thus the initial 20 mV drop in the protonmotive force was accompanied by a reduction of more than 65% in the rate of ATP synthesis. Over the lowest range of values of protonmotive force that drove detectable rates of ATP synthesis however, the dependence of the rate was a less steep function of the protonmotive force. A plot of the logarithm of the rate of ATP synthesis against protonmotive force reveals a biphasic relationship. There does not appear to be a 'threshold' value of the protonmotive force below which ATP synthesis is blocked by kinetic factors. 4. The relationships of the protonmotive force with S50% values and with the rate of ATP synthesis (at near saturating concentrations of ADP and Pi) are discussed in relation to possible mechanisms for the coupling of proton translocation to ATP synthesis.

Light-dependent proton efflux from chloroplast thylakoids

This work clarifies certain aspects of proton conductivity estimates in the light compared to dark conditions for spinach chloroplast thylakoid membranes. A method is presented, with kinetic analysis to justify it, that permits the separation of the proton influx and efflux rate constants, the sum of which contributes to the measured apparent first-order rate constant for proton efflux linked to basal electron transport. Proton fluxes linked to ATP formation were not dealt with. Using this technique it was shown that dicyclohexylcarbodiimide, an inhibitor of proton channel function, completely blocks a component of proton efflux in the light, as well as partially blocking the proton efflux in the dark. Antibody against purified chloroplast coupling factor (CF1) inhibits the light-dependent proton efflux, but has no effect on the dark proton efflux. Those data are consistent with there being a proton efflux pathway through the coupling factor complex, both in the light and the dark. The H+ efflux through the coupling factor was closely correlated with adenine nucleotide exchange activity. As suggested by others, such exchange activity may be an indication of conformational changes linked to the activation of the coupling factor. A plausible model is that the positive proton electrochemical potential gradient leads to an interaction between protons and the coupling factor, causing a conformational change, which leads to adenine nucleotide exchange linked to the passage of protons through the coupling complex. The nucleotide exchange activity reflects a transition from a higher to a lower binding affinity. Some of the Gibbs free energy lost in the dissipation of the proton gradient must be conserved in the transition to the lower affinity adenine nucleotide binding form of the coupling factor protein complex.

Relationship between phosphorylation potential and electrochemical H+ gradient during glycolysis in Streptococcus lactis

Assays of intracellular ATP, ADP, and inorganic phosphate allowed calculation of the phosphorylation potential (delta G'ATP/F) maintained during glycolysis by Streptococcus lactis. At the same time, the electrochemical H+ gradient (delta mu-H+/F) was evaluated by distribution methods, using radioactive tetraphenylphosphonium bromide as a probe for the membrane potential and salicylic acid as a probe for the pH gradient. Detailed comparisons were made at pH 5, when the reaction mediated by the proton-translocating ATPase (BF0F1) was likely to have been poised near equilibrium; for those conditions, the ratio delta G'ATP/delta mu-H+ was used to estimate stoichiometry for BF0F1 during ATP hydrolysis. At an external pH of 5, in the presence or absence of valinomycin, this ratio was close to 3, over a range of 370 to 510 mV (8.5 to 11.7 kcal/mol) for delta G'ATP/F and a range of 128 to 167 mV for delta mu-H+/F. Other work suggested that delta G'ATP/delta mu-H+ increased from its minimum value of 3 to 4.3 as the external pH changed from pH 5 to 7.

The influence of the ionic conductance on the relation between electron transport and proton-motive force in intact cells of Rhodopseudomonas capsulata

1. The dependence of membrane potential (delta psi) on the rate of respiration in darkened intact cell suspensions of Rhodopseudomonas capsulata was distinctly non-linear: severe inhibition of respiration with either rotenone or KCN led to only a small drop in delta psi. 2. In the presence of 0.3 microMs carbonylcyanide p-trifluoromethoxyphenylhydrazone [CF3OPhzC(CN)2] the dependence of delta psi on respiratory rate became linear. Consequently, and particularly at lower concentrations of CF3OPhzC(CN)2, there was a pronounced, synergistic depression of the respiratory delta psi with CF3OPhzC(CN)2 and either rotenone or KCN. 3. Antimycin A, at a concentration which strongly inhibited the photosynthetic electron transport chain, only slightly lowered the light-induced delta psi in anaerobic cell suspensions. Antimycin and CF3OPhzC(CN)2 synergistically lowered delta psi generated by illumination. 4. The light-induced delta psi in anaerobic cells was only about 1.5-times larger than the respiratory-induced delta psi in darkened cells. Nevertheless it required approximately 16-times more CF3OPhzC(CN)2 to collapse the photosynthetic delta psi than the respiratory delta psi. 5. These results are discussed with reference to the ionic current/delta psi relation described in [J.B. Jackson (1982) FEBS Lett. 139, 139-143]. The unifying feature is that the intrinsic conductance of the cell membrane is strongly dependent on delta psi but the conductance due to CF3OPhzC(CN)2 is independent of delta psi.

Thermodynamics of electron transfer and its coupling to vectorial processes in biological membranes

A method is developed to express the flux of an electron transfer reaction as a function of the conjugate force, the redox potential difference, throughout the nonlinear region. The flux can be expressed by a product of the hyperbolic sine of the force, a factor ("redox-poising parameter") determined by the redox potentials of subsystem (in certain cases by local pH's and pK's of subsystems), and some constants. This is analogous to the expression of the flux of a diffusion process by the product of its force and the concentration of the diffusing species. The redox-poising parameter corresponds to the concentration term. The expression is applied to redox chains in which electron transfers are coupled to vectorial processes such as proton translocation or electric current.

Variable proton conductance of submitochondrial particles

The relationship between the rate of substrate oxidation and the protonmotive force (electrochemical proton gradient) generated by bovine heart submitochondrial particles has been examined. Unexpectedly, oxidation of succinate generated a higher protonmotive force than the oxidation of NADH, although the rate of proton translocation across the membrane was inferred to be considerably lower with succinate as substrate. The data suggest that the flow of electrons through site 1 of the respiratory chain may increase the conductance of the mitochondrial membrane for protons. Upon reduction of the rate of succinate oxidation by titration with malonate, the protonmotive force remained essentially constant until the extent of inhibition was greater than 75%. The general conclusion from this work is that a constant passive membrane conductance for protons cannot be assumed.

Structure and function of H+-ATPase

(1) Extensive studies on proton-translocating ATPase (H+-ATPase) revealed that H+-ATPase is an energy transforming device universally distributed in membranes of almost all kinds of cells. (2) Crystallization of the catalytic portion (F1) of H+-ATPase showed that F1 is a hexagonal molecule with a central hole. The diameter of F1 is about 90 A and its molecular weight is about 380,000. (3) Use of thermophilic F1 permits the complete reconstitution of F1 from its five subunits (alpha, beta, gamma, delta, epsilon) and demonstration of the gate function of the gamma delta epsilon-complex, the catalytic function of beta (supported by alpha and gamma), and the H+-translocating functions of all five subunits. (4) Studies using purified thermostable F0 showed that F0 is an H+-channel portion of H+-ATPase. The direct measurement of H+-flux through F0, sequencing of DCCD-binding protein, and isolation of F1-binding protein are described. (5) The subunit stoichiometry of F1 may be alpha 3 beta 3 gamma delta epsilon. (6) Reconstitution of stable H+-ATPase-liposomes revealed that ATP is directly synthesized by the flow of H+ driven by an electrochemical potential gradient and that H+ is translocated by ATP hydrolysis. This rules out functions for all the hypothetical components that do not belong to H+-ATPase in H+-driven ATP synthesis. The roles of conformation change and other phenomena in ATP synthesis are also discussed.

Effect of nucleotides on potential and pH changes across the thylakoid membrane of spinach chloroplasts

With appropriate preparations of spinish chloroplasts we observe three distinct effects of the nucleotides: 1. An accelaration of the dark decay of the light induced 520 nm absorbance change after ATP addition. 2. An acidification of the internal space of the thylakoids after ATP addition in darkness. 3. A dark ATPase activity which is regulated by the deltapH across the membrane. We conclude that the effect of the nucleoside triphosphates on the 520 nm signal is linked to a change of the proton conductivity of the membrane, induced by the formation of a deltapH across the membrane in consequence of the dark ATPase activity. The mode of action of the nucleoside diphosphates in the presence of inorganic phosphate on the 520 nm signal is discussed. It is proposed that the effects observed are linked to the hydrolysis of the newly formed nucleoside triphosphates.