Translation of fragmented viral RNA in vitro: initiation at multiple sites

Structural studies of the eIF4E-VPg complex reveal a direct competition for capped RNA: Implications for translation

Viruses have transformed our understanding of mammalian RNA processing, including facilitating the discovery of the methyl-7-guanosine (m⁷G) cap on the 5' end of RNAs. The m⁷G cap is required for RNAs to bind the eukaryotic translation initiation factor eIF4E and associate with the translation machinery across plant and animal kingdoms. The potyvirus-derived viral genome-linked protein (VPg) is covalently bound to the 5' end of viral genomic RNA (gRNA) and associates with host eIF4E for successful infection. Divergent models to explain these observations proposed either an unknown mode of eIF4E engagement or a competition of VPg for the m⁷G cap-binding site. To dissect these possibilities, we resolved the structure of VPg, revealing a previously unknown 3-dimensional (3D) fold, and characterized the VPg-eIF4E complex using NMR and biophysical techniques. VPg directly bound the cap-binding site of eIF4E and competed for m⁷G cap analog binding. In human cells, VPg inhibited eIF4E-dependent RNA export, translation, and oncogenic transformation. Moreover, VPg formed trimeric complexes with eIF4E-eIF4G, eIF4E bound VPg-luciferase RNA conjugates, and these VPg-RNA conjugates were templates for translation. Informatic analyses revealed structural similarities between VPg and the human kinesin EG5. Consistently, EG5 directly bound eIF4E in a similar manner to VPg, demonstrating that this form of engagement is relevant beyond potyviruses. In all, we revealed an unprecedented modality for control and engagement of eIF4E and show that VPg-RNA conjugates functionally engage eIF4E. As such, potyvirus VPg provides a unique model system to interrogate eIF4E.

Expression of Middle-Component RNA of Cowpea Mosaic Virus: In Vitro Generation of a Precursor to Both Capsid Proteins by a Bottom-Component RNA-Encoded Protease from Infected Cells

The expression of the middle-component (M) RNA of cowpea mosaic virus was studied by means of in vitro translation. In both the wheat germ extract and the rabbit reticulocyte lysate, M RNA was translated into two overlapping polypeptides of 95 and 105 kilodaltons. Incubation of these polypeptides with 30,000 x g supernatant fractions from cowpea mesophyll protoplasts inoculated with complete virus or with separate bottom (B) components alone resulted in extensive processing, yielding polypeptides of 60, 58, 48, and 47 kilodaltons. Similar proteolytic activity was found associated with the in vitro translation products from the bottom-component RNA, demonstrating that the protease present in infected cells is encoded by B RNA. Using antisera raised against the separate capsid proteins VP23 and VP37, it was shown that the 60-kilodalton cleavage product is the precursor to both capsid proteins. Cleavage of nascent 95- and 105- kilodalton polypeptides by the in vivo protease demonstrated that this capsid protein precursor is located C terminally within both polypeptides and that the synthesis of these two overlapping polypeptides is the result of two initiation sites on middle-component RNA. In addition, a second virus-induced proteolytic activity, capable of releasing VP23 from the 95- and 105-kilodalton polypeptides, was detected in leaves of infected plants, but not in infected mesophyll protoplasts. A model for the expression of the middle-component RNA is presented.

Lucerne transient streak virus RNA and its translation in rabbit reticulocyte lysate and wheat germ extract

Two abundant, encapsidated RNAs of lucerne transient streak virus (LTSV) are the 1.5 x 10(6) molecular weight (Mr) linear RNA-1 and both circular (RNA-2) and linear (RNA-3) forms of a 0.15 x 10(6) Mr viroid-like RNA. Two additional discrete minor RNAs, Mr 0.35 x 10(6) and 0.07 x 10(6), and a heterogeneous mixture of RNAs in the Mr range 0.05 to 1.0 x 10(6) are reported. Principal polypeptides translated from unfractionated LTSV RNA in rabbit reticulocyte lysate were of Mr 105,000 (p105), 78,000 (p78), and 33,000 (p33), the last not easily detected after translation in wheat germ extracts. All apparently are encoded in RNA-1. However, p33, which was precipitated by antibody of LTSV particles and presumably is the major capsid protein, was more readily translated from a smaller, most likely the Mr 0.35 x 10(6), RNA. Partial proteolysis and other tests indicate that p105 has a carboxyl terminal extension of p78 amino acid sequences and that neither shares sequences with p33. No translation products were attributed to RNA-2, RNA-3 or the Mr 0.07 x 10(6) RNA.

Translation of tobacco rattle virus RNAs in vitro: four proteins from three RNAs

RNAs from the Lisse and PRN strains of tobacco rattle virus were translated in nuclease-treated reticulocyte lysates. With both strains, RNA-1 coded for two proteins of MW 170,000 and 120,000. Addition of 1-2 mM Mg2+ increased the yield of the larger product, apparently by facilitating readthrough of a leaky termination codon at the end of the region coding for the smaller protein. Experiments with yeast suppressor tRNA indicate that this is not a UAG or UAA codon. RNA-2 coded for a protein of the same size as coat protein. A product of MW 30,000 was coded by a third RNA (RNA-3) which in the case of PRN TRV had a molecular weight of 550,000 and could be separated from RNA-2 by gel electrophoresis. Translation of all three RNAs was inhibited by m7GTP. However, RNA-1 also directed a low level of m7GTP-resistant synthesis of a 30,000-dalton protein which appeared to be identical to the RNA-3 product, and it is suggested that RNA-3 corresponds to the 3' end of RNA-1. Thus the strategies of synthesis of the non-coat proteins of tobacco rattle and tobacco mosaic viruses appear to be similar.

Lessons (not) learned from mistakes about translation

Some popular ideas about translational regulation in eukaryotes have been recognized recently as mistakes. One example is the rejection of a long-standing idea about involvement of S6 kinase in translation of ribosomal proteins. Unfortunately, new proposals about how S6 kinase might regulate translation are based on evidence that is no better than the old. Recent findings have also forced rejection of some popular ideas about the function of sequences at the 3' end of viral mRNAs and rejection of some ideas about internal ribosome entry sequences (IRESs). One long-held belief was that tissue-specific translation via an IRES underlies the neurotropism of poliovirus and the attenuation of Sabin vaccine strains. Older experiments that appeared to support this belief and recent experiments that refute it are discussed. The hypothesis that dyskeratosis congenita is caused by a defect in IRES-mediated translation is probably another mistaken idea. The supporting evidence, such as it is, comes from a mouse model of the disease and is contradicted by studies carried out with cells from affected patients. The growing use of IRESs as tools to study other questions about translation is discussed and lamented. The inefficient function of IRESs (if they are IRESs) promotes misunderstandings. I explain again why it is not valid to invoke a special mechanism of initiation based on the finding that edeine (at very low concentrations) does not inhibit the translation of a putative IRES from cricket paralysis virus. I explain why new assays, devised to rule out splicing in tests with dicistronic vectors, are not valid and why experiments with IRESs are not a good way to investigate the mechanism whereby microRNAs inhibit translation.

Regulation of translation via mRNA structure in prokaryotes and eukaryotes

The mechanism of initiation of translation differs between prokaryotes and eukaryotes, and the strategies used for regulation differ accordingly. Translation in prokaryotes is usually regulated by blocking access to the initiation site. This is accomplished via base-paired structures (within the mRNA itself, or between the mRNA and a small trans-acting RNA) or via mRNA-binding proteins. Classic examples of each mechanism are described. The polycistronic structure of mRNAs is an important aspect of translational control in prokaryotes, but polycistronic mRNAs are not usable (and usually not produced) in eukaryotes. Four structural elements in eukaryotic mRNAs are important for regulating translation: (i) the m7G cap; (ii) sequences flanking the AUG start codon; (iii) the position of the AUG codon relative to the 5' end of the mRNA; and (iv) secondary structure within the mRNA leader sequence. The scanning model provides a framework for understanding these effects. The scanning mechanism also explains how small open reading frames near the 5' end of the mRNA can down-regulate translation. This constraint is sometimes abrogated by changing the structure of the mRNA, sometimes with clinical consequences. Examples are described. Some mistaken ideas about regulation of translation that have found their way into textbooks are pointed out and corrected.

Potassium salts influence the fidelity of mRNA translation initiation in rabbit reticulocyte lysates: unique features of encephalomyocarditis virus RNA translation

It is widely assumed that in vitro translation of mRNA is more efficient in the presence of potassium acetate rather than KCl, that the optimum concentration of potassium acetate is higher than for KCl, and that uncapped RNAs exhibit a lower optimum salt concentration than capped mRNAs. When these assumptions were examined using several different mRNA species in four batches of rabbit reticulocyte lysate, some notable exceptions were found. The translation of encephalomyocarditis virus (EMCV) RNA exhibited a salt optimum unusually high for an uncapped mRNA, and was very much more efficient and accurate with KCl rather than potassium acetate. It was also unique in being strongly activated by low concentrations (5-10 mM) KSCN in the presence of 90 mM potassium acetate. For the translation of other uncapped RNAs (poliovirus RNA, cowpea mosaic virus (CPMV) M RNA and bacteriophage MS2 RNA) amino acid incorporation at the optimum potassium acetate level was significantly greater than could be achieved using KCl. However, KCl was found to be restrictive and potassium acetate permissive for the synthesis of abnormal products thought to arise from initiation at incorrect sites, with the result that KCl gave a product pattern closer to that observed in vivo. In the particular case of the reticulocyte lysate system, accurate translation therefore requires the use of KCl rather than potassium acetate, but the choice of salt was found to be less critical in cell-free extracts from HeLa or L-cells.

The scanning model for translation: an update

The small (40S) subunit of eukaryotic ribosomes is believed to bind initially at the capped 5'-end of messenger RNA and then migrate, stopping at the first AUG codon in a favorable context for initiating translation. The first-AUG rule is not absolute, but there are rules for breaking the rule. Some anomalous observations that seemed to contradict the scanning mechanism now appear to be artifacts. A few genuine anomalies remain unexplained.

Sequence and organization of barley yellow dwarf virus genomic RNA

The nucleotide sequence of the genomic RNA of barley yellow dwarf virus, PAV serotype was determined, except for the 5'-terminal base, and its genome organization deduced. The 5,677 nucleotide genome contains five large open reading frames (ORFs). The genes for the coat protein (1) and the putative viral RNA-dependent RNA polymerase were identified. The latter shows a striking degree of similarity to that of carnation mottle virus (CarMV). By comparison with corona- and retrovirus RNAs, it is proposed that a translational frameshift is involved in expression of the polymerase. An ORF encoding an Mr 49,797 protein (50K ORF) may be translated by in-frame readthrough of the coat protein stop codon. The coat protein, an overlapping 17K ORF, and a 3'6.7K ORF are likely to be expressed via subgenomic mRNAs.

Both VP2 and VP3 are synthesized from each of the alternative spliced late 19S RNA species of simian virus 40

The late 19S RNAs of simian virus 40 consist of a family of alternatively spliced RNAs, each of which contains open reading frames corresponding to all three of the virion proteins. Two approaches were used to test the hypothesis that each alternatively spliced 19S RNA species is translated to synthesize preferentially only one of the virion proteins. First, we analyzed the synthesis of virion proteins in simian virus 40 mutant-infected monkey cells that accumulate predominantly either only one spliced 19S RNA species or only the 19S RNAs. Second, we determined the virion proteins synthesized in a rabbit reticulocyte lysate programmed with specific, in vitro-transcribed 19S RNA species. These results indicated that VP2 and VP3, but not VP1, are synthesized from all 19S RNA species. Quantitative analysis of these data indicated that individual 19S RNA species containing a translation initiation signal upstream of the VP2 AUG codon were translated in a cell extract three- to fivefold less efficiently than were 19S RNA species lacking this signal and that the precise rate of synthesis of VP2 relative to VP3 varied somewhat with the sequence of the leader region. These data are consistent with the synthesis of VP2 and VP3 occurring by a leaky scanning mechanism in which initiation of translation at a specific AUG codon is affected by both (i) the intrinsic efficiency of ribosomes recognizing the sequences surrounding the AUG codon as an initiation signal and (ii) partial interference from 5'-proximal initiation signals and their corresponding open reading frames.

Immunogold localization of the intracellular sites of structural and nonstructural tobacco mosaic virus proteins

Antibodies raised against the 126K nonstructural protein (replicase) encoded by tobacco mosaic virus (TMV) RNA or the viral coat protein have been used to localize these proteins within virus-infected tobacco leaf cells by an immunogold labeling technique. A protocol is given for low-temperature fixation to facilitate immunogold labeling. In cells of TMV-infected leaf tissue, the 126K protein immunogold label was found almost exclusively in "viroplasms" in the cytoplasm and in pockets of virus particles at the viroplasmic periphery. When utilizing the coat protein antiserum, very little labeling was seen within the viroplasms, although virus particles throughout the cytoplasm were heavily labeled. Viroplasms contained electron-dense rope-like structures embedded in a ribosome-rich matrix. In their "mature" form, viroplasms are the well-known "X body" inclusions. The rope-like structures were up to 1.2 micron long and appear twisted, undergoing several revolutions throughout their length, but were not of a constant pitch. In transverse section, they appeared to be composed of several hollow, radially segmented cylinders 21 nm in diameter, with a 9-nm hole. Antibody labeling showed them to be composed, at least in part, of the 126K protein. Clusters of virus particles at the edge of or within the viroplasms were also labeled with the 126K antiserum, in contrast to virus particles in other areas of the cell, which were not. TMV-infected tobacco mesophyll protoplasts cultured for up to 27 hr did not contain the rope-like ribbons. Instead, isolated protoplasts contained amorphous cytoplasmic areas which were labeled with 126K antibody. Since the 126K protein is most probably a constituent of the TMV RNA-replicating enzyme (replicase), its intracellular location is considered to be indicative of the site of replication of TMV RNA. Therefore these results suggest that replication occurs at the edges of the viroplasms.

Detection of genomic-length soybean mosaic virus RNA on polyribosomes of infected soybean leaves

Soybean mosaic virus (SMV)-related RNAs were examined in both polyribosomal and nonpolyribosomal fractions of systemically infected soybean leaves. Viral RNAs were detected by Northern blot hybridization analysis using two cloned SMV-cDNAs representing different regions of the viral genome as hybridization probes. Genomic length SMV-RNA (Mr of 3.3 X 10(6] was found in specific association with EDTA-sensitive polyribosomes of infected leaves, indicating that it functions as a messenger RNA in these cells. A smaller SMV-related RNA (Mr of 1.6 X 10(6] was sometimes detected in the polyribosomal fraction; however, reconstruction experiments indicate that this RNA is a breakdown product of the genomic-length RNA, generated during cell fractionation or RNA extraction. Two other SMV-related RNAs with Mr of 2.0 and 0.78 X 10(6) were sometimes detected in infected cells and were not generated from genomic SMV-RNA or intact virus particles in reconstruction experiments. However, these RNAs were exclusively associated with the EDTA-resistant, nonpolyribosomal fraction of infected cells. These data suggest that genomic-length SMV-RNA is the only viral RNA which is translated in these infected plants.

Analysis of in vitro and in vivo products of the TMV 30kDa open reading frame using antisera raised against a synthetic peptide

The peptide Tyr-Ser-Glu-Ala-Thr-Val-Ala-Glu-Ser-Asp-Ser-Phe (the predicted C-terminal 11 amino acids of the TMV 30kDa open reading frame plus an additional N-terminal Tyr residue) was synthesized by solid phase methods and used to raise antisera in rabbits. These antisera precipitated 4 major proteins (p30, p28, p19 and 18.5kDa) from in vitro translation products of TMV short rod RNA, but only one, of apparent M r = 30500, from TMV-infected tobacco protoplasts. This protein was made between 8 and 16 h post infection, and had [35S]Met-labelled tryptic peptides identical to those of in vitro synthesized p30.

Multiple proteins and subgenomic mRNAs may be derived from a single open reading frame on tobacco mosaic virus RNA

It has previously been shown that messenger activity for a protein of Mr = ca. 30k exists in RNA fractions extracted from particles of either native or alkali stripped U1 TMV, or from cowpea strain TMV, that are smaller than full genomic length. Analysis of sucrose gradient fractions containing this activity reveals a number of slightly smaller template activities directing synthesis of proteins between 18.5k and 29k in size. All of these messenger activities, including that for the 30k protein, respond to cap analogues in anomalous ways. Discrete RNA species that include active mRNAs for these proteins can be demonstrated in the same fractions by labelling with preparations of vaccinia capping enzyme and [alpha-32P] GTP without prior beta-elimination. Detailed analysis of three of these proteins (of Mr's ca. 30k, 29k and 23k) by peptide mapping and translation of purified vaccinia-labelled RNA demonstrates that all three are unrelated to the large early TMV proteins, but are related to each other in such a way as to form a nested set with staggered N termini and identical C termini. mRNAs of chain lengths ca. 1900 and 1500 bases direct synthesis of the 30k and 23k proteins respectively, an mRNA of about 1850 bases directs both 29k and (perhaps because of cross-contamination) 30k synthesis. Initiation codons for the 29k and 23k proteins have been mapped at positions 4960-4962 and 5191-5193 respectively on TMV RNA. Since all three encapsidated templates have similar properties we conclude that either there is a family of 30k-related proteins with unusual mRNAs, or that none of these in vitro translation products are directed by physiological templates.

The origin of multiple polypeptides of molecular weight below 110 000 encoded by tobacco mosaic virus RNA in the messenger-dependent rabbit reticulocyte lysate

Multiple polypeptides encoded by tobacco mosaic virus (TMV) RNA in the messenger-dependent rabbit reticulocyte lysate are not attributable to contaminating 3'-coterminal RNA fragments, multiple leaky termination codons or endonuclease activity opening-up legitimate or spurious internal initiation sites. Quantitative analysis of polypeptides encoded over a range of added RNA concentrations from 0.09 microgram X ml-1 to 180 micrograms X ml-1 compared with those synthesized in response to size-fractionated RNAs from a crude virus preparation, or with RNA extracted from the alkali-stable fraction of TMV suggest that apart from four legitimate virus-coded products of apparent Mr approx. 165 000, 110 000, 30 000 and 17 500 all other polypeptides arise from the overlapping 5'-proximal cistrons either by (i) site-selective endonucleolytic cleavage, (ii) sense codon misreading, or (iii) specific regions of secondary structure on TMV RNA which impede ribosome translocation.

Nucleotide sequence of tobacco mosaic virus RNA

Oligonucleotide primers have been used to generate a cDNA library covering the entire tobacco mosaic virus (TMV) RNA sequence. Analysis of these clones has enabled us to complete the viral RNA sequence and to study its variability within a viral population. The positive strand coding sequence starts 69 nucleotides from the 5' end with a reading frame for a protein of Mr 125,941 and terminates with UAG. Readthrough of this terminator would give rise to a protein of Mr 183,253. Overlapping the terminal five codons of this readthrough reading frame is a second reading frame coding for a protein of Mr 29,987. This gene terminates two nucleotides before the initiator codon of the coat protein gene. Potential signal sequences responsible for the capping and synthesis of the coat protein and Mr 29,987 protein mRNAs have been identified. Similar sequences within these reading frames may be used in the expression of sets of proteins that share COOH-terminal sequences.

Initiation reactions in the mRNA-dependent reticulocyte lysate

Reticulocyte lysates depleted of mRNA by digestion with micrococcal nuclease still show an unexpectedly high rate of formation of 80 S initiation complexes. Formation of these complexes is sensitive to all inhibitors of the normal protein synthesis initiation process tested. Such lysates contain high concentrations of mRNA fragments which can be utilized for initiation, with which exogenous mRNA must compete. As a consequence of this competition, mRNAs that are weak initiators may be translated poorly by this system even at low exogenous mRNA concentrations.

Post-Translational Proteolytic Cleavage of In Vitro-Synthesized Turnip Yellow Mosaic Virus RNA-Coded High-Molecular-Weight Proteins

In a reticulocyte lysate, turnip yellow mosaic virus genomic RNA directs the synthesis of two proteins with molecular weights of 150,000 (150K) and 195K. We present evidence that the larger protein is processed in vitro, after its completion, in at least three fragments. The NH 2 -terminal fragment (82K) and the COOH-terminal fragment (78K) have been well characterized by different methods. The fact that the 150K protein is not cleaved in vitro, although it contains the regions that are processed in the 195K protein, could be of fundamental biological significance for the expression of the viral genes: a single polypeptide chain could be processed in several ways, leading to different peptides with distinct biological activities.

Activation of an internal initiation site for protein synthesis during in vitro translation

The major mRNA for adenovirus 2 polypeptide pVIII sediments at 18S as assayed by in vitro translation in the messenger-dependent rabbit reticulocyte lysate system. However, a small amount of messenger activity for pVIII sediments at abut 27S, coincident with the mRNA for 100 K. Isolation and fractionation of poly(A) containing RNA following in vitro translation of 27S 100 K mRNA demonstrated the appearance of an 18S messenger activity for pVIII, which is approximately the size of the authentic mRNA for this protein. Partial degradation of 27S 100 K mRNA with alkali or ribonuclease T1 also results in activation of an 18S messenger activity for pVIII suggesting that in vitro messenger activity for pVIII associated with 27S RNA is due to degradation of 100 K mRNA during translation in the cell-free system.

Location of the initiation site for protein synthesis on foot-and-mouth disease virus RNA by in vitro translation of defined fragments of the RNA

An mRNA-dependent reticulocyte lysate has been used to translate foot-and-mouth disease virus RNA in vitro. Polypeptides P16, P20a, and P88, which have been shown to be derived from the 5' end of the RNA by pactamycin mapping experiments with infected cells, were preferentially synthesized in vitro. Removal of VPg, the small protein covalently linked to the 5' end of the genome RNA, had no effect on the translation of the RNA. The two RNA fragments (L and S) produced by specific digestion of the polycytidylic acid [poly(C)] tract with RNase H were also translated in vitro. The L fragment, consisting of RNA to the 3' side of the poly(C) tract and including the polyadenylic acid [poly(A)] tract, directed the synthesis of the same products as those made by full-length RNA. However, no small defined products were produced when the S fragment, which contains the 5' end of the RNA, was translated. These results show that the major initiation site for protein synthesis on foot-and-mouth disease virus RNA is to the 3' side of the poly(C) tract. Furthermore, the use of N-formyl [35S]methionine tRNAfMet as a label for the initiation peptides showed that the major polypeptide labeled in lysates primed with both full-length RNA and the L fragment was P16, i.e., the protein nearest the initiation site for translation as deduced from pactamycin mapping experiments. Fragments of RNA were also translated in vitro. Those containing the poly(C) tract gave products similar to those produced when full-length RNA was translated. The polypeptides synthesized when fragments containing the poly(A) tract were used, however, did not resemble those made from full-length RNA.