Anion binding to the chloride pump, halorhodopsin, and its implications for the transport mechanism

Effect of a bound anion on the structure and dynamics of halorhodopsin from Natronomonas pharaonis

Active ion transport across membranes is vital to maintaining the electrochemical gradients of ions in cells and is mediated by transmembrane proteins. Halorhodopsin (HR) functions as a light-driven inward pump for chloride ions. The protein contains all-trans-retinal bound to a specific lysine residue through a protonated Schiff base. Interaction between the bound chloride ion and the protonated Schiff base is crucial for ion transport because chloride ion movement is driven by the flipping of the protonated Schiff base upon photoisomerization. However, it remains unknown how this interaction evolves in the HR photocycle. Here, we addressed the effect of the bound anion on the structure and dynamics of HR from Natronomonas pharaonis in the early stage of the photocycle. Comparison of the chloride-bound, formate-bound, and anion-depleted forms provided insights into the interaction between the bound anion and the chromophore/protein moiety. In the unphotolyzed state, the bound anion affects the π-conjugation of the polyene chain and the hydrogen bond of the protonated Schiff base of the retinal chromophore. Picosecond time scale measurements showed that the band intensities of the W16 and W18 modes of the tryptophan residues decreased instantaneously upon photoexcitation of the formate-bound form. In contrast, these intensity decreases were delayed for the chloride-bound and anion-depleted forms. These observations suggest the stronger interactions of the bound formate ion with the retinal chromophore and the chromophore pocket. On the nanosecond to microsecond timescales, we found that the interaction between the protonated Schiff base and the bound ion is broken upon formation of the K intermediate and is recovered following translocation of the bound anion toward the protonated Schiff base in the L intermediate. Our results demonstrate that the hydrogen-bonding ability of the bound anion plays an essential role in the ion transport of light-driven anion pumps.

Stopped-flow analysis on anion binding to blue-form halorhodopsin from Natronobacterium pharaonis: comparison with the anion-uptake process during the photocycle

Pharaonis halorhodopsin (phR), the light-driven chloride ion pump from Natronobacterium pharaonis with C-terminal histidine tag, was expressed in Escherichia coli cells. The protein was solubilized with 0.1% n-dodecyl beta-D-maltopyranoside and purified with a nickel column. Removal of Cl- from the medium yields blue phR (phR(blue)) that has lost Cl- near the chromophore. Addition of Cl- converts phR(blue) to a red-shifted Cl--bound form (phR(Cl)). Circular dichroic spectra of phR(blue) and phR(Cl) exhibited a bilobe in the visual region, indicating specific oligomerization of the phR monomers. The order of anion concentration which induced a shift from phR(blue) to phR(X) was Br- < Cl- < NO3- < N3-, which was the same as in the case of phR purified from N. pharaonis membranes. Chloride binding kinetics was measured by time-resolved absorption changes with stopped-flow rapid mixing. Rates of Cl- binding consisted of fast and slow components, and the amplitude of the fast component was about 90% of the total changes. The rate constant of the fast component at 100 mM NaCl at 25 degrees C was 260 s(-1) with an apparent activation energy of 35 kJ/mol. These values are in good agreement with the process of Cl- uptake in the photocycle (O --> hR' reaction) reported previously [Váró et al. (1995) Biochemistry 34, 14500-14507]. In addition, the Cl- concentration dependence on both rates was similar to each other. These observations suggest that the O-intermediate is similar to phR(blue) and that Cl- uptake during the photocycle may be ruled by a passive process.

Halide dependence of the halorhodopsin photocycle as measured by time-resolved infrared spectra

Time-resolved Fourier transform infrared (FTIR) difference spectra of the halorhodopsin (hR) photocycle have been collected from 3 micros to 100 ms in saturating concentrations of KCl or KBr. Kinetic analysis of these data revealed two decay processes, with time constants of tau(1) approximately 150 micros and tau(2) approximately 16 ms in the presence of either halide, with tau(2) describing the return to the starting (hR) state. Comparison to previous low-temperature FTIR spectra of hR intermediates confirms that characteristic hK and hL spectral features are both present before the tau(1) decay, in a state previously defined as hK(L) (Dioumaev, A., and M. Braiman. 1997. Photochem. Photobiol. 66:755-763). However, the relative sizes of these features depend on which halide is present. In Br-, the hL features are clearly more dominant than in Cl-. Therefore, the state present before tau(1) is probably best described as an hK(L)/hL(1) equilibrium, instead of a single hK(L) state. Different halides affect the relative amounts of hK(L) and hL(1) present, i.e., Cl- produces a much more significant back-reaction from hL(1) to hK(L) than does Br-. The halide dependence of this back-reaction could therefore explain the halide selectivity of the halorhodopsin anion pump.

Protonation of lysine residues inverts cation/anion selectivity in a model channel

A dimeric alamethicin analog with lysine at position 18 in the sequence (alm-K18) was previously shown to form stable anion-selective channels in membranes at pH 7.0 [Starostin, A. V., R. Butan, V. Borisenko, D. A. James, H. Wenschuh, M. S. Sansom, and G. A. Woolley. 1999. Biochemistry. 38:6144-6150]. To probe the charge state of the conducting channel and how this might influence cation versus anion selectivity, we performed a series of single-channel selectivity measurements at different pH values. At pH 7.0 and below, only anion-selective channels were found with P(K(+))/P(Cl(-)) = 0. 25. From pH 8-10, a mixture of anion-selective, non-selective, and cation-selective channels was found. At pH > 11 only cation-selective channels were found with P(K(+))/P(Cl(-)) = 4. In contrast, native alamethicin-Q18 channels (with Gln in place of Lys at position 18) were cation-selective (P(K(+))/P(Cl(-)) = 4) at all pH values. Continuum electrostatics calculations were then carried out using an octameric model of the alm-K18 channel embedded in a low dielectric slab to simulate a membrane. Although the calculations can account for the apparent pK(a) of the channel, they fail to correctly predict the degree of selectivity. Although a switch from cation- to anion-selectivity as the channel becomes protonated is indicated, the degree of anion-selectivity is severely overestimated, suggesting that the continuum approach does not adequately represent some aspect of the electrostatics of permeation in these channels. Side-chain conformational changes upon protonation, conformational changes, and deprotonation caused by permeating cations and counterion binding by lysine residues upon protonation are considered as possible sources of the overestimation.

Charge motions during the photocycle of pharaonis halorhodopsin

Oriented gel samples were prepared from halorhodopsin-containing membranes from Natronobacterium pharaonis, and their photoelectric responses to laser flash excitation were measured at different chloride concentrations. The fast component of the current signal displayed a characteristic dependency on chloride concentration, and could be interpreted as a sum of two signals that correspond to the responses at high-chloride and no-chloride, but high-sulfate, concentration. The chloride concentration-dependent transition between the two signals followed the titration curve determined earlier from spectroscopic titration. The voltage signal was very similar to that reported by another group (Kalaidzidis, I. V., Y. L. Kalaidzidis, and A. D. Kaulen. 1998. FEBS Lett. 427:59-63). The absorption kinetics, measured at four wavelengths, fit the kinetic model we had proposed earlier. The calculated time-dependent concentrations of the intermediates were used to fit the voltage signal. Although no negative electric signal was observed at high chloride concentration, the calculated electrogenicity of the K intermediate was negative, and very similar to that of bacteriorhodopsin. The late photocycle intermediates (O, HR', and HR) had almost equal electrogenicities, explaining why no chloride-dependent time constant was identified earlier by Kalaidzidis et al. The calculated electrogenicities, and the spectroscopic information for the chloride release and uptake steps of the photocycle, suggest a mechanism for the chloride-translocation process in this pump.

Bioenergetics of the Archaea

In the late 1970s, on the basis of rRNA phylogeny, Archaea (archaebacteria) was identified as a distinct domain of life besides Bacteria (eubacteria) and Eucarya. Though forming a separate domain, Archaea display an enormous diversity of lifestyles and metabolic capabilities. Many archaeal species are adapted to extreme environments with respect to salinity, temperatures around the boiling point of water, and/or extremely alkaline or acidic pH. This has posed the challenge of studying the molecular and mechanistic bases on which these organisms can cope with such adverse conditions. This review considers our cumulative knowledge on archaeal mechanisms of primary energy conservation, in relationship to those of bacteria and eucarya. Although the universal principle of chemiosmotic energy conservation also holds for Archaea, distinct features have been discovered with respect to novel ion-transducing, membrane-residing protein complexes and the use of novel cofactors in bioenergetics of methanogenesis. From aerobically respiring Archaea, unusual electron-transporting supercomplexes could be isolated and functionally resolved, and a proposal on the organization of archaeal electron transport chains has been presented. The unique functions of archaeal rhodopsins as sensory systems and as proton or chloride pumps have been elucidated on the basis of recent structural information on the atomic scale. Whereas components of methanogenesis and of phototrophic energy transduction in halobacteria appear to be unique to Archaea, respiratory complexes and the ATP synthase exhibit some chimeric features with respect to their evolutionary origin. Nevertheless, archaeal ATP synthases are to be considered distinct members of this family of secondary energy transducers. A major challenge to future investigations is the development of archaeal genetic transformation systems, in order to gain access to the regulation of bioenergetic systems and to overproducers of archaeal membrane proteins as a prerequisite for their crystallization.

Bacterioopsin-triggered retinal biosynthesis is inhibited by bacteriorhodopsin formation in Halobacterium salinarium

Factors regulating retinal biosynthesis in halobacteria are not clearly understood. In halobacteria, events leading to the biosynthesis of bacteriorhodopsin have been proposed to participate in stringent regulation of retinal biosynthesis. The present study describes a novel approach of in vivo introductions of mRNA and membrane proteins via liposome fusion to test their role in cellular metabolism. Both the bacterioopsin-encoding mRNA and the liposome-encapsulated bacterioopsin (apoprotein) are independently introduced in spheroplasts of the purple membrane-negative strain Halobacterium salinarium that initially contain neither bacterioopsin nor retinal. Isoprenoid analyses of these cells indicate that the expression/presence of bacterioopsin triggers retinal biosynthesis from lycopene, and its subsequent binding to opsin generates bacteriorhodopsin. When bacteriorhodopsin and excess retinal were independently introduced into spheroplasts of purple membrane-negative cells, the introduction of bacteriorhodopsin resulted in an accumulation of lycopene, indicating an inhibition of retinal biosynthesis. These results provide direct evidence that the formation of bacterioopsin acts as a trigger for lycopene conversion to beta-carotene in retinal biosynthesis. The trigger for this event does not lie with either transcription or translation of the bop gene. It is clearly associated with the folded and the membrane-integrated state of bacterioopsin. On the other hand, the trigger signaling inhibition of retinal biosynthesis does not lie with the presence of excess retinal but with the correctly folded, retinal-bound form, bacteriorhodopsin.

Existence of two L photointermediates of halorhodopsin from Halobacterium salinarium, differing in their protein and water FTIR bands

FTIR difference spectra were recorded for the photoreactions of halorhodopsin from Halobacterium salinarium at 170 and 250 K. Obvious differences at the two temperatures were noted in neither the visible spectra nor the FTIR bands of the chromophore. However, perturbation of Asp141 is observed in the L intermediate at 250 K but not at 170 K. We named these photoproducts La (at 170 K) and Lb (at 250 K). The spectrum of Lb is distinct from that of La also in the different shifts of water O-H stretching bands, and larger changes in the bands from the protein backbone with different sensitivities to varying the halide. These results suggest that the photocycle of halorhodopsin contains two L states, La and Lb, in which the structure of protein and internal water molecules is different but chloride stays at the same site close to the Schiff base.

Nano- and microsecond time-resolved FTIR spectroscopy of the halorhodopsin photocycle

Step-scan Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy with 50 ns time resolution was applied to the early stages of the photocycle of halorhodopsin (hR) for the temperature range 3-42 degrees C. Kinetic data analysis with global fitting revealed two distinct kinetic processes associated with relaxations of the early red-shifted photoproduct hK; these processes have time constants tau 1 approximately equal to 280 ns and tau 2 approximately equal to 360 microns at 20 degrees C. Spectral features demonstrate that the tau 1 process corresponds to a transition between two distinct bathointermediates, hKE and hKL. The vibrational difference bands associated with both tau 1 and tau 2 transitions are spread throughout the whole 1800-900 cm-1 range. However, the largest bands correspond to ethylenic C=C stretches, fingerprint C-C stretches and hydrogen out-of-plane (HOOP) wags of the retinal chromophore. The time evolution of these difference bands indicate that both the tau 1 and tau 2 decay processes involve principally a relaxation of the chromophore and its immediate environment. The decay of the intense HOOP vibrations is nearly equally divided between the tau 1 and tau 2 processes, indicating a complex chromophore relaxation from a twisted nonrelaxed conformation in the primary (hKE) bathointermediate, to a less-twisted structure in hKL, and finally to a roughly planar structure in the hypsochromically shifted hL intermediate. This conclusion is also supported by the unexpectedly large positive entropy of activation observed for the tau 1 process. The two relaxations from hKE to hL are largely analogous to corresponding relaxations (KE-->KL-->L) in the bacteriorhodopsin photocycle, except that the second step is slowed down by over 200-fold in hR.

Specific arginine and threonine residues control anion binding and transport in the light-driven chloride pump halorhodopsin

The light-driven chloride pump halorhodopsin (HR), a halobacterial retinal protein, was studied by comparing wild type with specific mutants. Changes of conserved arginine and threonine residues in the transmembrane regions could be classified in two categories: in the extracellular half of the molecule, mutations influence anion uptake and binding. R108 mutations abolish all anion effects previously attributed to two distinct binding sites and change the characteristic photochemistry. Neutral residues at position 108 completely inactivate the pump. T111 increases the affinity of this anion binding site without being essentially important. In the photochemical cycles of the mutants T111V and Q105E, a red-shifted absorbing intermediate is enriched indicating retarded anion uptake. On the cytoplasmic side, mutations do not change anion binding properties of the unphotolyzed protein, but slow down anion release thereby reducing the chloride transport activity and the photocycling rate. The lowest activity is found for T203V, while R200 mutations have weaker effects. Thus, in the symmetrically arranged pairs R108/T111 and T203/R200, threonine and arginine play different roles, reflecting high affinity anion uptake by the former and effective anion release catalyzed by the latter residues. A model for the anion transport mechanism in HR is suggested comprising the specific functions of channel-lining residues.

Anion-protein interactions during halorhodopsin pumping: halide binding at the protonated Schiff base

Halorhodopsin (hR), the light-driven chloride pump of Halobacterium halobium, has been studied by Fourier transform infrared (FTIR) spectroscopy. Direct hydrogen bonding of halide ions with the protonated Schiff base (PSB) group was detected by means of halide-dependent perturbations on this group's vibrational frequencies. FTIR difference spectra were obtained of the hR-->hL photoreaction in reconstituted membrane vesicles. Nearly identical results were obtained using either low-temperature static difference spectroscopy at 1-cm-1 resolution or a stroboscopic time-resolved technique with 5-ms temporal and 2-cm-1 spectral resolution. The frequency of the negative difference band due to the PSB C = N stretch mode in the hR state shows a dependence on the type of halide counteranion that is present, 1632 cm-1 in the presence of Cl-, 1631 cm-1 in Br-, and 1629 cm-1 in I-. The C = NH+ stretch frequency thus correlates with the strength of the hydrogen bond formed by the halide. Analogous halide-dependent shifts of the C = NH+ frequency were observed in IR spectra of model compound retinylidene PSB salts. We also observed a significant halide dependence of the visible absorption maximum of hR solubilized in lauryl maltoside detergent. From such halide perturbation effects, we conclude that there is a direct hydrogen-bonded interaction between the Schiff base group and an externally supplied halide ion in the hR state. Halide perturbation effects are also observed for PSB-group vibrations in the hL state. Thus, despite an apparent overall weakening of hydrogen-bonding interactions of the PSB with its environment after chromophore photoisomerization to form hL, the PSB remains hydrogen-bonded to the halide. The results are best explained in terms of a "one-site, two-state" model for anion binding near the chromophore in the hR state, as opposed to a previously proposed two-site model.

Interrelations of bioenergetic and sensory functions of the retinal proteins

Rhodopsins are intrinsic membrane retinal-containing proteins composed of 7 hydrophobic alpha-helical transmembrane columns and hydrophilic sequences of various length connecting the helices and localized at N- and C-ends of the polypeptide. The chromophore (retinal) forms a Schiff base with a lysine residue in the middle part of the last alpha-helix. Absorption of a photon results in isomerization of retinal which gives rise to a conformational change in the protein moiety. Rhodopsins can be involved in two entirely different types of activities, i.e. ion pumping and photosensing. Recent observations concerning the pumping and sensory mechanisms allowed both these events to be explained in terms of one and the same unitary concept, which postulates the formation of a hydrophilic cleft in the hydrophobic part of the protein molecule as a crucial step in energy conservation and photosensing.

Properties and the primary structure of a new halorhodopsin from halobacterial strain mex

A new halorhodopsin-like pigment from the new halobacterial strain mex (Otomo, J., Tomoika, H. and Sasabe, H. (1992) J. Gen. Microbiol. 138, 1027-1037) was partially purified, and its amino acid sequence from helices A to G was determined using PCR technique. Two arginine residues in the A-B interhelix loop segment, a series of six amino acid residues (EMPAGH) in the B-C interhelix segment and most of the residues near the Schiff base of the retinal were found to be conserved in three halorhodopsins (halobium, pharaonis and mex). This result strongly suggests that these residues are essential for anion pumping function in halorhodopsin. The light-induced ion-pump measurements have shown that the selectivity of anion transport between chloride and nitrate in mex halorhodopsin is lower than that of halobium halorhodopsin, but higher than that of pharaonis halorhodopsin. The number of amino acid residues in the B-C interhelix loop segments is different in each halorhodopsin, and it correlates with their anion (chloride and nitrate) selectivity. These results suggest that the length of the B-C segment affects the selectivity of anion transport in halorhodopsin.

A unifying concept for ion translocation by retinal proteins

First, halorhodopsin is capable of pumping protons after illumination with green and blue light in the same direction as chloride. Second, mutated bacteriorhodopsin where the proton acceptor Asp85 and the proton donor Asp96 are replaced by Asn showed proton pump activity after illumination with blue light in the same direction as wildtype after green light illumination. These results can be explained by and are discussed in light of our new hypothesis: structural changes in either molecule lead to a change in ion affinity and accessibility for determining the vectoriality of the transport through the two proteins.

Marked effects of salt on estrogen receptor binding to DNA: biologically relevant discrimination between DNA sequences

Avidin-biotin complexed with DNA (ABCD) assays were employed to determine the binding affinity of estrogen receptor (ER) to DNA under various salt conditions. Type and concentration of salt in the reaction buffer dramatically affected the ability of the ER to discriminate between DNA sequences. Under appropriate salt conditions, ER was able to bind to the estrogen response element from the Xenopus vitellogenin A2 gene with at least 3 orders of magnitude greater affinity than a two base pair mutant sequence, and 5 orders of magnitude greater affinity than plasmid DNA. In these studies, the best discrimination was observed under conditions of salt type and concentration that more closely approximated intracellular conditions, i.e., 100-150 mM potassium salts. Analysis of the binding affinities for ER to all three types of DNA over a range of KCl concentrations indicated that the ionic interactions upon ER binding were the same for the three DNA molecules tested. Therefore, the additional stability of ER binding to target DNA sequences was contributed by nonionic interactions.