Correlation between the logarithm of capacity factors for aromatic compounds in micellar electrokinetic chromatography and their octanol-water partition coefficients

Determining binding of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons to CTABr micelles using semi-equilibrium dialysis techniques

Micellar enhanced ultrafiltration (MEUF) has been shown to be an effective removal technique for a variety of trace contaminants in wastewater, especially for water soluble low molecular weight organic contaminants. In MEUF, contaminants first partition into surfactant micelles prior to removal by ultrafiltration, where the contaminants are below the molecular weight cut-off of the ultrafiltration membrane but the micelles are above the cut-off. Binding constants of selected Polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) such as naphthalene, phenanthrene, pyrene and fluorene have been determined in order to examine the removal efficiency of MEUF for PAHs with Cetyltrimethylammonium bromide (CTABr) using a semi equilibrium dialysis method. PAHs show strong binding with CTABr because of hydrophobic interactions. Our results enabled us to develop a relationship between binding constant (log K_B) and log K_OW for neutral compounds, which will be useful for predicting MEUF performance for PAHs removal from waste water. The range of our reported binding constant values are from 2.61 to 5.07.

Modeling of anti-Langmuirian peaks in micellar electrokinetic chromatography: Benzene and naphthalene

Peaks of benzene (bz) and naphthalene (np) having diffuse fronts and steep rears under overload conditions were studied quantitatively in MEKC with SDS surfactant. The retardation factors of these compounds, solubilized at microM to mM concentrations by either 10, 30, or 50 mM SDS, were determined by vacancy MEKC and frontal analysis MEKC. Isotherm coordinates were calculated from the retardation factors, and the equation for the concave upward anti-Langmuir isotherm was fit to them. Peak profiles were computed with the MacCormack algorithm from the isotherm fits and a simplified continuity equation appropriate to MEKC. These profiles were compared to ones generated in normal MEKC from samples of bz and np solubilized at muM to mM concentrations by either 10, 30, or 50 mM SDS. In all cases, the anti-Langmuir isotherm described the asymmetry of experimental peaks. For bz in 30 and 50 mM SDS and np in 10 and 50 mM SDS, good to excellent agreement was found between the experimental and predicted profiles. For bz in 10 mM SDS, the experimental profiles were more broadened than the predicted ones, although their asymmetries agreed. For np in 30 mM SDS, the experimental isotherm predicted greater peak asymmetry than was observed, and the correct anti-Langmuir isotherm for all sample concentrations and field strengths was calculated from the most asymmetrical peak by the inverse method. The relative decrease of zone velocity with increasing analyte concentration was calculated from the isotherm parameters, electrokinetic mobilities, retardation factors, surfactant concentrations, and CMC. The simplification of the continuity equation was justified.

Micellar proportion: a parameter to compare the hydrophobicity of the pseudostationary phases or that of the analytes in micellar electrokinetic chromatography

Micellar proportion, t(prop,mic) = t(mic)/t(m), a quantity expressing how much time is spent by the analyte in the micellar phase related to its whole migration time (t(m)) has been introduced by utilizing the micellar phase residence time (t(mic)). The t(prop,mic) values have been determined for analytes of different chemical structures (alkyl benzene and alkyl phenone homologous series, alcohols, strongly hydrophobic peptides) studied by micellar elektrokinetic chromatography (MEKC) using various cationic and anionic pseudostationary phases. A good linear correlation was obtained between t(prop,mic) and the calculated hydrophobicity (CLOGP) of the analytes for all pseudostationary phases (CLOGP = A.logt(prop,mic) + B). Considering a given pseudostationary phase, t(prop,mic) as a relative quantity is a suitable parameter to characterize and compare experimentally the behavior of the various analytes in MEKC. Applying a set of probe molecules with known hydrophobicity, the CLOGP(50) value (showing the value of hydrophobicity of a virtual molecule spending exactly 50% of its migration time in the pseudostationary phase) has been calculated for each pseudostationary phase applied here. This experimentally determinable numerical value (characterizing the pseudostationary phase) can be utilized to compare the hydrophobicity and hence retention ability of the pseudostationary phases. The t(prop,mic) value was found to be applicable to compare the methylene selectivity of the different pseudostationary phases as well: logt(prop,mic) = A.Z + B, where Z is the number of carbon atoms of the alkyl chain in the alkyl benzene homologous series.

Separation methods for estimating octanol-water partition coefficients

Separation methods for the indirect estimation of the octanol-water partition coefficient (logP) are reviewed with an emphasis on high throughput methods with a wide application range. The solvation parameter model is used to identify suitable separation systems for estimating logP in an efficient manner that negates the need for empirical trial and error experiments. With a few exceptions, systems based on reversed-phase chromatography employing chemically bonded phases are shown to be unsuitable for estimating logP for compounds of diverse structure. This is because the fundamental properties responsible for chromatographic retention tend to be different to those responsible for partition between octanol and water, especially the contribution from hydrogen bonding interactions. On the other hand, retention in several micellar and microemulsion electrokinetic chromatography systems is shown to be highly correlated with the octanol-water partition coefficient. These systems are suitable for the rapid, high throughput determination of logP for neutral, weakly acidic, and weakly basic compounds. For compounds with a permanent charge, electrophoretic migration and electrostatic interactions with the stationary phase results in inaccurate estimation of partition coefficients. The experimental determination of solute descriptors offers an alternative approach for estimating logP, and other biopartitioning properties. A distinct advantage of this approach is that once the solute descriptors are known, solute properties can be estimated for any distribution or transport system for which a solvation parameter model has been established.

Column selection for liquid chromatographic estimation of the kw′ hydrophobicity parameter

Newer reversed-phase column technologies that incorporate polar groups either by an endcapping procedure or by embedding them into the stationary phase ligand have been receiving much attention in the literature for their robustness when highly aqueous conditions are used. We investigated their ability to accurately determine the chromatographic hydrophobicity value log k'w. The non-linear deviations of retention data as mobile phase conditions approach zero percent modifier are a large source of error when extrapolating to log k'w values using the linear solvent strength model. Here, we compare a conventional reversed-phase stationary phase with others that have incorporated either polar embedded or polar endcapped phases, along with a hybrid-based particle derivatized with a polar embedded ligand. Our results show that polar endcapped phases perform very similarly to the conventional phase and do not show any improved ability for determining log k'w, but polar embedded phases have reduced curvature in the data, and therefore result in less error in extrapolation. We also investigated the solubility parameter model and the [ET(30)] model for their extrapolation efficiency, and have concluded that the [ET(30)] model shows the least error when extrapolating the data.

Comparison of measured and calculated lipophilicity of substituted aurones and related compounds

A molecule library containing 55 aurone- and thioaurone-type structures has been designed and synthesised. Reversed phase high performance liquid chromatographic (RP-HPLC) method has been developed to separate these compounds and to characterise their lipophilicity by experimental method (k'). The experimental lipophilicity data have been compared with the computer calculated lipophilicity parameters (CLOGPs) of the same molecules. In general, good correlations between the measured and calculated lipophilicities have been found with the exception of structure isomers and compounds capable for hydrogen bonding. The chromatographic method was suitable to separate the structure (ortho and para) isomers of aurone and thioaurones and was sensitive enough to differentiate their lipophilicities. Our findings suggest the usefulness of the chromatographic method in fast characterisation of the lipophilicity of structurally closely related molecules.

Assessing the separation of neutral plant secondary metabolites by micellar electrokinetic chromatography

In this work, partition coefficients (Pwm) and solute-micelle association constants per monomer (Km/N) were measured using micellar electrokinetic chromatography in tetraborate-sodium dodecylsulfate electrolytes for 18 important plant secondary metabolites (coumarin, verbenone, camphor, eucalyptol, carvone, alpha-terpineol, linalool, jasmone, bergapten, rose oxide, geraniol, t-anethole, citronellal, citronellol, p-cymene, limonene, caryophyllene and nerol) of wide occurrence in herbal extracts and essential oils. Caryophyllene presented a retention time longer than anthracene (micelle marker) and its set of constants could not be determined accurately. Pwm and Km/N were generated by the non-linear data fitting of both partition and solute-micelle association models for the 17 solutes under consideration (caryophyllene excluded). Pwm varied from 147 (coumarin) to 13175 (limonene) while Km/N varied from 37 (coumarin) to 3721 (limonene). Under optimal conditions, the separation of the selected compounds was attempted successfully in commercialized samples of rose, anise and geranium essential oils.

Capillary electrophoresis in anti-cancer metallodrug research: advances and future challenges

An efficient and convenient separation method has been a long sought after goal for anti-cancer metallodrug developers. For many reasons, capillary electrophoresis (CE) has recently emerged as the method of choice for the separation of intact platinum metal complexes and their metabolites, assessment of drug stability, and studying the interaction of the administered and potential tumor-inhibiting metallocomplexes with biomolecules. Due to the application of gentle separation conditions and successful developments in combinations with molecule-specific detectors, CE is also growing in importance as a versatile tool for the characterization of specific metal-bioligand binding products and thereby for providing mechanism-of-action information. Recent advances in metallodrug monitoring by CE are reviewed and critically evaluated. Likewise, the current limitations of CE in the field, such as the lack of assays involving individual proteins and targeting real-world biological samples, are brought into focus. Further strategies for method's refinement in anti-cancer metallodrug research that should ultimately take place along these lines and result in the development of high-throughput screening CE systems in the near future are finally discussed.

Rapid estimation of octanol-water partition coefficients using synthesized vesicles in electrokinetic chromatography

Vesicle electrokinetic chromatography (VEKC) using vesicles synthesized from the oppositely charged surfactants cetyltrimethylammonium bromide (CTAB) and sodium octyl sulfate (SOS) and from the double-chained anionic surfactant bis(2-ethylhexyl)sodium sulfosuccinate (AOT) was applied to the indirect measurement of octanol-water partition coefficients (log Po/w). A variety of small organic molecules with varying functional groups, pesticides, and organic acids were evaluated by correlating log Po/w and the logarithm of the retention factor (log k') and comparing the calibrations. A linear solvation energy relationship (LSER) analysis was conducted to describe the retention behavior of the vesicle systems and compared to that of octanol-water partitioning. The solute hydrogen bond donating behavior is slightly different with the vesicle interactions using CTAB-SOS vesicles as compared to the octanol-water partitioning model. The AOT vesicle and octanol-water partitioning systems showed similar partitioning characteristics. VEKC provides rapid separations for determinations of log Po/w in the range of 0.5 to 5 using CTAB-SOS vesicles and 0 to 5.5 using AOT vesicles.

Relationship between lipophilicity and antitumor activity of molecule library of Mannich ketones determined by high-performance liquid chromatography, clogP calculation and cytotoxicity test

A series of Mannich ketones were synthesized in order to study the relative importance of structure and specific substitutions in relation to their lipophilicity and antitumor activity. Substitutions were carried out with morpholinyl, pirrolidinyl, piperidyl and tetrahydro-isoquinolyl groups in various positions on three different skeletons. Lipophilicity of Mannich ketones was characterised by chromatography data (log k') and by software calculated parameters (clogP). Compounds were tested on their ability to inhibit the proliferation of the A431 human adenocarcinoma cell line evaluated by MTT and apoptosis assays. The results suggest that the higher the lipophilicity values (log k' and clogP), the higher the antitumor and apoptotic activity of Mannich ketones. Determination of lipophilicity by measuring the log k' or by calculating the clogP values of the compounds may help to predict their biological activities.

Determination of octanol-water partition coefficients of pesticides by microemulsion electrokinetic chromatography

Microemulsion electrokinetic chromatography (MEEKC) was evaluated as a screening tool for the indirect measurement of octanol-water partition coefficients (log Po/w) of pesticide compounds. Over 80 pesticide compounds representing a variety of structural characteristics were studied, and good correlation of log Po/w with the logarithm of the retention factor was found. The microemulsion system studied allowed the separation of compounds in the log Po/w range of -1 to 7. In addition, a smaller set of simple organic molecules that vary in structural features was evaluated and compared to the pesticide log Po/w calibration. The pesticide and simple organic molecule log Po/w calibration lines were statistically similar. This suggests that a universal set of standard compounds may be employed for the log Po/w calibration to provide measurements for a variety of compounds with good accuracy.

Separation of a group of N-phenylpyrazole derivatives by micellar electrokinetic chromatography: application to the determination of solute-micelle association constants and estimation of the hydrophobicity

Micellar electrokinetic chromatography (MEKC) was applied to the separation of a group of N-phenylpyrazole derivatives. Sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS) as micellar system and 2-(N-cyclohexylamino)ethanesulfonic acid (CHES) as separation buffer (pH 10) were employed in the absence and presence of different percentages of medium chain alcohols (n-propanol or n-butanol). The separation of multicomponent mixtures of the solutes studied enabled the rapid determination of their retention factors which, in turn, allowed the study of the separation selectivity of compounds and the determination of their solute-micelle association constants (from the linear variation of the retention factors as a function of the total surfactant concentration in the separation buffer). Separation selectivity was studied according to the elution range and number of solutes separated in all the electrolyte solutions employed (45 micellar phases). The effect of the buffer concentration (0.05, 0.08 and 0.10 M), the alcohol nature (n-propanol or n-butanol) and the alcohol percentage (1, 3 or 5%) of the values obtained for the solute-micelle association constants was also studied. The best separation (12 solutes) was performed when a 0.08 M CHES buffer, pH 10, 0.02 M SDS modified by 5% n-butanol was used. The possibilities of using MEKC for evaluating the hydrophobicity of compounds was investigated through the study of the correlation between the logarithm of the retention factors of N-phenylpyrazole derivatives and their logarithm of the octanol-water distribution coefficients estimated by high performance liquid chromatography (HPLC).

Investigation of the chiral surfactant N-dodecoxycarbonylvaline in electrokinetic chromatography: improvements in elution range and pH stability via mixed micelles and vesicles, and the hydrophobicity determination of basic pharmaceutical drugs

The chiral surfactant dodecoxycarbonylvaline (DDCV) has proven to be an effective pseudostationary phase for the separation of many enantiomeric pharmaceutical compounds. In this study the elution range and the prediction of octanol-water partitioning for the DDCV micellar system was examined. Through incorporation of DDCV in mixed micelles and unilamellar vesicles, enhancement of the elution range was observed. The mixed micelles contained a second anionic surfactant, sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS), while the vesicles were composed of DDCV and the cationic surfactant cetyltrimethylammonium bromide (CTAB). Enantioselectivity, as well as other chromatographic and electrophoretic parameters, were compared between the mixed micelles, vesicles, and DDCV micelles. The hydrophobicity of the DDCV system was also evaluated as a predictor of n-octanol-water partition coefficients for 15 beta amino alcohols. The correlation between the logarithm of the retention factor (log k) and log P(ow) for seven hydrophobic beta-blockers and eight beta-agonists were r2 = 0.964 and r2 = 0.814, respectively.

Characterization of lipophilicity scales using vectors from solvation energy descriptors

Lipophilicity scales were characterized by an approach using vectors provided from solvation energy descriptors (SED) of solutes such as an excess molar refraction, the dipolarity/polarizability, the hydrogen-bond acidity, the basicity, and the McGowan characteristic volume. The five components of the SED vector were obtained from the coefficients of the five SED terms of the linear solvation energy relationship (LSER) equation for the lipophilicity scales. The analogy between two lipophilicity scales was expressed as the angle between the two SED vectors, while the difference in the contribution of the five independent SEDs to these two lipophilicity scales was quantified by the difference of the unit vectors of the SED vectors. These approaches were applied to several lipophilicity scales measured using microemulsions, micelles, an immobilized artificial membrane column, and an octanol-water system. As a result, the quantitative classification of these scales was successfully carried out, and the difference in the scales was well characterized. In addition, this vector approach was extended to the estimation of the contribution of each constituent of the microemulsions to the lipophilicity scale. Furthermore, some biological parameters such as skin permeability and the distribution between blood and brain could be predicted by the summation of the SED vectors obtained from the chromatographic systems. These results suggest that complex biological systems can be expressed quantitatively by simple chemical models with their SED vectors.

Overview of capillary electrophoresis and capillary electrochromatography

This paper provides an overview on the current status of capillary electrophoresis (CE) and capillary electrochromatography (CEC). The focus is largely on the current application areas of CE where routine methods are now in place. These application areas include the analysis of DNA, clinical and forensic samples, carbohydrates, inorganic anions and metal ions, pharmaceuticals, enantiomeric species and proteins and peptides. More specific areas such the determination of physical properties, microchip CE and instrumentation developments are also covered. The application, advantages and limitations of CEC are covered. Recent review articles and textbooks are frequently cited to provide readers with a source of information regarding pioneering work and theoretical treatments.

Effect of separation conditions on chromatographic determination of hydrophobicity of acidic xenobiotics

Problems encountered in the chromatographic determination of hydrophobicity of acidic xenobiotics are discussed. First, the definition and meaning of hydrophobicity is briefly presented. Next, the methods of determination of the hydrophobicity parameter by reversed-phase high-performance liquid chromatography are described. The methods of determination of the dead volume are analyzed with regard to calculation of the thermodynamically valid retention parameters. Relationships between retention factors and pH of mobile phase which have been reported in the literature are presented. The effects of ionic strength and buffer composition on the apparent retention parameters are discussed. The reversed-phase stationary phase materials presently employed for hydrophobicity determinations are reviewed. Application of micellar electrokinetic chromatography in the determination of hydrophobicity of ionizable analytes is presented. The ability of chromatography to provide the measures of hydrophobicity of xenobiotics best modelling their biological activity is underlined.

Rapid estimation of octanol-water partition coefficients of pesticides by micellar electrokinetic chromatography

Micellar electrokinetic chromatography (MEKC) was evaluated as a new technique for the rapid estimation of octanol-water partition coefficient (logKow). Retention measurements for more than 40 reference pesticides with varied structural characteristics and hydrophobicity were carried out in two MEKC systems, based on sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS) and sodium cholate (SC), respectively. To enable an accurate determination of capacity factors in the SC-MEKC system, cypermethrin (a synthetic pyrethroid insecticide) was utilized instead of Sudan III as the SC micelle tracer, since a few highly hydrophobic pesticides were found to elute after Sudan III. The linear correlation between logarithmic capacity factor (logk') and logKow in the two systems was examined. It was found that, under the typical buffer condition (10 mM sodium phosphate with 60 mM surfactant, pH 7.0), the SDS-MEKC system provided a somewhat wider dynamic range for hydrophobicity (logKow from -1.0 to 4.5). However, the correlation of logk' with logKow was not very high when all the reference pesticides were included in one single calibration set. For the SC-MEKC system, the dynamic range for logKow was in the range of 1.0-5.5, and a good linear correlation existed between logk' and logKow, even when all reference pesticides were incorporated into a single calibration group. By comparing the regression line of the reference pesticides with that of a group of simple aromatic derivatives, it was discovered that molecular size and functionality posed a less significant effect on the measurement of logKow in the SC-MEKC system than in the SDS-MEKC system. Thus, SC-MEKC shall be the system of choice for the estimation of logKow. The typical error on logKow determination using the current MEKC technique was within 0.5 units, suggesting that MEKC can be a valuable complement to reversed phase high performance liquid chromatography (RP-HPLC) for the indirect determination of logKow. Besides maintaining all the advantages of the HPLC approach, the MEKC technique showed some unique benefits, such as better inter-column reproducibility, higher throughput, and less handling of toxic pesticides and solvents.