Lysis by RNK-16 cytotoxic lymphocyte granules. Rate assays and conditions to study control of cytolysis

Hydrolysis of tumor cell lipids after CTL-mediated death

Contributions of lipases to CTL function have been debated, including if T cell lipases damage target cells. Expression of the lipase pancreatic lipase-related protein 2 (PLRP2) was previously found in IL-4 cultured lymphocyte cell lines but absent from IL-2 cultured lymphocytes. Here, we evaluated IL-2 and IL-4 induced CTLs for hydrolysis of target cell lipids and killing. Using anti-CD3 redirected lysis of [(3)H]-oleic acid-labeled P815 tumor cells, we detected the release of the radioactive fatty acid (FA). When PLRP2(+/+) and PLRP2(-/-) CTLs were compared, there was more killing by the PLRP2(+/+) CTLs. However, [(3)H]-oleic acid release was similar per dead P815, suggesting that lipid hydrolysis was produced by the dead P815s rather than by PLRP2. The FA release and death were completely dependent on perforin and also occurred when P815s were killed by perforin-containing T cell granule extracts that lacked lipase activity. Death by the cytotoxic granules extracts was unaffected by the addition of lipases. A lipase inhibitor, tetrahydrolipstatin, blocked FA release without affecting CTL-mediated cytotoxicity. Also, CTL-mediated death caused as much FA release as death by disruption of cells by freeze-thawing. The released oleic acid may be sufficient to promote secondary apoptotic responses after CTL-induced trauma.

Regulation of perforin lysis: implications for protein disulfide isomerase proteins

Perforin, a membrane-permeabilizing protein, is important to T cell cytotoxic action. Perforin has potential to damage the T cell in the endoplasmic reticulum (ER), is sequestered in granules, and later is exocytosed to kill cells. In the ER and after exocytosis, calcium and pH favor perforin activity. We found a novel perforin inhibitor associated with cytotoxic T cell granules and termed it Cytotoxic Regulatory Protein 2 (CxRP2). CxRP2 blocked lysis by granule extracts, recombinant perforin and T cells. Its effects lasted for hours. CxRP2 was calcium stable and refractory to inhibitors of granzyme and cathepsin proteases. Through mass spectrometric analysis of active 50-100 kDa proteins, we identified CxRP2 candidates. Protein disulfide isomerase A3 was the strongest candidate but was unavailable for testing; however, protein disulfide isomerase A1 had CxRP2 activity. Our results indicate that protein disulfide isomerases, in the ER or elsewhere, may protect T cells from their own perforin.

NK cells in gamma-interferon-deficient mice suppress lung innate immunity against Mycoplasma spp

The purpose of this study was to examine the 100-fold difference in mycoplasma levels in lungs of gamma interferon knockout (IFN-gamma(-/-)) mice compared to those seen with wild-type BALB/c mice at 3 days postinfection. NK cells secreted IFN-gamma; however, their cytotoxic granule extracts failed to kill mycoplasma. We found a conundrum: the clearance of organisms was as effective in NK-depleted IFN-gamma(-/-) animals as in wild-type mice (with both IFN-gamma and NK cells). NK(+) IFN-gamma(-/-) animals had high mycoplasma burdens, but, after NK-like cell depletion, mycoplasma numbers were controlled. Essentially, IFN-gamma was important in animals with NK-like cells and unimportant in animals without NK cells, suggesting that IFN-gamma counters deleterious effects of NK-like cells. Impairment of innate immunity in IFN-gamma(-/-) mice was not due to NK-like cell killing of macrophages. The increased levels of inflammatory cytokines and neutrophils in lung fluids of NK(+) IFN-gamma(-/-) mice were reduced after NK cell depletion. In summary, in the murine model that resembles chronic human disease, innate immunity to mycoplasma requires IFN-gamma when there are NK-like cells and the positive effects of IFN-gamma counteract negative effects of NK-like cells. When imbalanced, NK-like cells promote disease. Thus, it was not the lack of IFN-gamma but the presence of a previously unrecognized NK-like cell-suppressive activity that contributed to the higher mycoplasma numbers. It appears that pulmonary NK cells may contribute to the immunosuppressive environment of the lung, but when needed, these dampening effects can be counterbalanced by IFN-gamma. Furthermore, there may be instances where perturbation of this regulatory balance contributes to the susceptibility to and severity of disease.

Perforin lytic activity is controlled by calreticulin

The components within cytotoxic lymphocyte granules are responsible for a significant fraction of T and NK cell-mediated death. Perforin is stored in these granules together with calreticulin. Calreticulin has long been recognized as a chaperone protein of the endoplasmic reticulum (ER) and is the only resident ER protein to be found in the cytotoxic granules. Here we implicate a role for calreticulin in killing and report that it controls osmotic lysis mediated by purified perforin. Calreticulin, at a concentration of 2.2 x 10-7 M, completely blocked perforin-mediated lysis. Inhibition was stable and held over 5 h. Recombinant calreticulin, at a concentration of 8. 8 x 10-7 M, also blocked lysis, indicating the inhibition was due to calreticulin and not a copurifying protein in the native calreticulin preparations. Using calreticulin domain fragments (expressed as GST fusion proteins), we found inhibitory activity in the high-capacity calcium-binding C-domain, which does not bind perforin. The N- or P-domains, which can bind perforin, were unable to block lysis. The inhibition of lysis was independent of granzyme inactivation or the ability of calreticulin to sequester calcium. Our data indicate that calreticulin regulation of perforin-mediated lysis probably occurs without direct interaction with perforin. We propose a novel model in which calreticulin stabilizes membranes to prevent polyperforin pore formation.

Computational models in immunological methods: an historical review

The utilization of computational models in immunology dates from the birth of the science. From the description of antibody-antigen binding to the structural models of receptors, models are utilized to bring fundamental understandings of the processes together with laboratory measurements to uncover implications of these data. In this review, an historical view of the role of computational models in the immunology laboratory is presented, and short mathematical descriptions are given of fundamental assays. In addition, the range of current uses of models is explored -- especially as seen through papers which have appeared in the Journal of Immunological Methods from volume 1 (1971/1972) to volume 208 (1997). Each paper which introduced a new mathematical, statistical, or computer simulation model, or introduced an enhancement to an instrument through a model in those volumes is cited and the type of computational model noted.

Perforin-enhancing protein, a low molecular weight protein of cytotoxic lymphocyte granules, enhances perforin lysis

Perforin is a 68 kD protein found in the granules of cytotoxic lymphocytes and is used by lymphocytes to form lethal pores in the membranes of the cells they kill. We and others have found that when perforin is purified, its lytic activity is markedly reduced. ELISAs indicated that our final recovery of perforin protein was excellent. We decided to determine if depletion of other granule proteins contributed to the loss of lytic activity. We isolated perforin to the point where lytic activity was diminished and added back granule proteins that had no lytic activity or detectable (antigenic) perforin. Perforin was isolated by Cu2+-immobilized metal affinity chromatography (IMAC) followed by phenyl-Superose hydrophobic interaction chromatography (HIC). Its lytic activity was enhanced by a low molecular weight (<15 kD) protein, perforin enhancing protein (PEPr). We have isolated PEPr by two methods, HIC and MonoQ. Nonlytic PEPr restored perforin to close to its original lytic activity. A protein similar if not identical to PEPr was also detectable as an 125I-labeled protein associated with lytic perforin. We propose that PEPr acts in conjunction with perforin to form lethal pores and suggest that PEPr may be the rat equivalent of the human cytotoxic lymphocyte protein, granulysin.

Fractionation of perforin and granzymes by immobilized metal affinity chromatography (IMAC)

Cytotoxic lymphocytes and natural killer cells kill their targets by releasing pore-forming granules or by Fas ligand-Fas initiated death. The granules contain the pore-forming protein perforin, proteoglycan and multiple serine proteases termed granzymes. In this paper we describe two options for isolating perforin and granzymes. Both options separate the proteins by their ability to bind to immobilized metal affinity chromatography (IMAC) columns. The first option, with Cu2+ as the metal (Cu2+-IMAC), separates both perforin and granzymes while the second, with Co2+ as the metal (Co2+-IMAC), separates only perforin. After Cu2+-IMAC perforin is > 20-fold enriched with excellent recovery of lytic activity. Only two proteins are substantial contaminants. After Cu2+-IMAC, the perforin is dilute and requires concentration before additional steps of purification. The second option, with Co2+ as the metal Co2+-IMAC), yields perforin that is concentrated in a sharp peak. The concentrated perforin is immediately suitable for further purification. The first option, with Cu2+, isolates the granzymes while the second option, Co2+-IMAC, does not. After isolation, the perforin lytic and granzyme activities are stable for weeks at 4 degrees C, an advantage to previous isolation methods for these proteins. The excellent recoveries of perforin and granzymes also indicate that these proteins are less than 4% and 15% of the total lymphocyte granule protein, respectively.

Characterization, application and potential uses of biotin-tagged inhibitors for lymphocyte serine proteases (granzymes)

Cytotoxic lymphocytes and natural killer cells are able to kill their target cells in minutes. The death of the target cell occurs after the release of cytoplasmic granules from the effector cell. These granules contain the pore-forming protein perforin and serine proteases (granzymes). To date 10 genes encoding lymphocyte granzymes have been discovered; of these only four have been purified and characterized for their substrate specificity. Several are predicted to have a common chymase, like specificity which is found in the granule extracts. Others may need to be enriched as active enzymes before they can be evaluated for substrate hydrolysis. Due to the limitations of detection by substrate hydrolysis, a more sensitive method for the detection of dilute granules was needed. We report the differing reactivities of seven biotin (Bi)-tagged isocoumarin (IC) inhibitors for Asp-ase, chymase, tryptase and Met-ase granzymes. The inhibitors contained different substituents at their no. 3 position: methoxy (OMe), ethoxy (OEt), propoxy (OPr) or 2-phenylethoxy (OEtPh) groups. The OMe group conferred general reactivity, whereas the OEtPh group conferred selective reactivity with chymase granzymes. The inhibitors that contained the longest aminocaproyl (Aca) spacers between the biotin-tag and the isocoumarin ring mediated the most stable granzyme inactivation. These inhibitors were the most effective at blocking lysis of red blood cells by the granule extracts. The inhibitors were used in protein blotting experiments where the biotin was detected with an avidin-enzyme complex. Over 10 granzymes were labelled by the inhibitor Bi-Aca-Aca-IC-OMe. The inhibitors detected granzymes when they were not readily detected by substrate hydrolysis.

Sulfonyl fluoride serine protease inhibitors inactivate RNK-16 lymphocyte granule proteases and reduce lysis by granule extracts and perforin

Cytolytic granules purified from natural killer lymphocytes (NK) contain a pore-forming protein (perforin) and a number of serine proteases. When these proteases are inhibited by serine protease-specific isocoumarin reagents the serine proteases are inactivated and the cytolytic activity of the granules is decreased. Paradoxically, it has been found that the general serine protease inhibitor phenylmethylsulfonyl fluoride (PMSF) frequently cannot block killing even though it inhibits many of the serine proteases. At the same time it has been reported that "purified" perforin alone can lyze cells. To address these inconsistencies we first compared the ability of PMSF and four new sulfonyl fluoride serine protease inhibitors to inhibit proteases and cell lysis. We determined the effects on lysis and the second order inhibition rate constants for five granule protease activities: ly-tryptase, ly-chymase, Met-ase (methionine cleaving), Ser-ase (serine cleaving) and Asp-ase (aspartic acid cleaving). One compound, 2-(Z-NH(CH2)2CONH)C6SO2F, was a potent inhibitor of Met-ase activity (k(obsd)/[I] = 162 M-1 s-1), ly-chymase activity (k(obsd)/[I] = 147 M-1 s-1), and granule-mediated as well as perforin-mediated lysis. PMSF was a poor inhibitor of granule proteases (k(obsd)/[I]'s less than 7 M-1 s-1 for four activities and no inhibition of Ser-ase); the lack of reactivity is consistent with the failure of PMSF to block granule lytic activity. We also prepared enriched perforin by anion exchange chromatography and showed that a ly-chymase and a Met-ase associated with perforin. By inhibiting these proteases we also inhibited lytic activity.