The effect of the temperature and duration of sample storage on the measurement of lymphocyte subpopulations from HIV-1-positive and control subjects

Impact of blood storage and sample handling on quality of high dimensional flow cytometric data in multicenter clinical research

Obtaining reliable and reproducible high quality data in multicenter clinical research settings requires design of optimal standard operating procedures. While the need for standardization in sample processing and data analysis is well-recognized, the impact of sample handling in the pre-analytical phase remains underestimated. We evaluated the impact of sample storage time (≈transport time) and temperature, type of anticoagulant, and limited blood volume on reproducibility of flow cytometric studies. EDTA and Na-Heparin samples processed with the EuroFlow bulk lysis protocol, stained and stored at 4 °C showed fairly stable expression of cell surface markers and distribution of the major leukocyte populations for up to 72 h. Additional sample fixation (1% PFA, Fix & Perm) did not have any beneficial effects. Blood samples stored for <24 h at room temperature before processing and staining seemed suitable for reliable immunophenotyping, although losses in absolute cell numbers were observed. The major losses were observed in myeloid cells and monocytes, while lymphocytes seemed less affected. Expression of cell surface markers and population distribution were more stable in Na-Heparin blood than in EDTA blood. However, storage of Na-Heparin samples was associated with faster decrease in leukocyte counts over time. Whole blood fixation strategies (Cyto-Chex, TransFix) improved long-term population distribution, but were detrimental for expression of cellular markers. The main conclusions from this study on healthy donor blood samples were successfully confirmed in EDTA clinical (patient) blood samples with different time delays until processing. Finally, we recognized the need for adjustments in bulk lysis in case of insufficient blood volumes. Despite clear overall conclusions, individual markers and cell populations had different preferred conditions. Therefore, specific guidelines for sample handling should always be adjusted to the clinical application and the main target leukocyte population.

Analytical performance of an automated volumetric flow cytometer for quantitation of T, B and natural killer lymphocytes

BACKGROUND

Quantitation of lymphocyte subsets (B cells, T cells, CD4 and CD8 T cells and NK cells) classically relies on quantitation of lymphocytes and immunophenotyping by flow cytometry. AQUIOS CL (Beckman Coulter) is a fully automated system that performs an onboard volumetric cell count, automatically processes the sample (staining, lysing and fixation) and analyzes the results. We compared AQUIOS CL to a dual-platform analysis and evaluated analytical performance.

METHODS

We evaluated precision, sample stability, inter-sample carryover, linearity and interpanel consistency. AQUIOS CL was compared to a dual-platform method (Sysmex XE-5000 and BD FACSCanto-II). A total of 113 patient samples were included: 45 from posttransplant patients, 44 from children and 24 random routine samples. The degree of automation was scored through the need of manual revisions triggered by AQUIOS CL run notifications and run flags.

RESULTS

Intrarun and interrun variability was <9.1% with dedicated control material and <32.1% with patient samples. Relative values of lymphocyte subsets could be determined up to 48 h after venipuncture when the sample was kept at room temperature. There was no carryover and good linearity. Interpanel consistency was 3.3% for relative values and 9.4% for absolute values. Method comparison showed good analytical correlation between AQUIOS CL and a dual-platform method. Thirty-five percent of the samples triggered a run notification. In 74% of these samples, the results could be accepted without intervention, so in 26% of all samples, an unnecessary notification was generated.

CONCLUSIONS

AQUIOS CL allows for reliable fully automated immunophenotyping of lymphocyte subset quantitation. Gating algorithms could be further improved.

CD3-positive B cells: a storage-dependent phenomenon

The majority of clinical studies requires extensive management of human specimen including e.g. overnight shipping of blood samples in order to convey the samples in a central laboratory or to simultaneously analyze large numbers of patients. Storage of blood samples for periods of time before in vitro/ex vivo testing is known to influence the antigen expression on the surface of lymphocytes. In this context, the present results show for the first time that the T cell antigen CD3 can be substantially detected on the surface of human B cells after ex vivo storage and that the degree of this phenomenon critically depends on temperature and duration after blood withdrawal. The appearance of CD3 on the B cell surface seems to be a result of contact-dependent antigen exchange between T and B lymphocytes and is not attributed to endogenous production by B cells. Since cellular subsets are often classified by phenotypic analyses, our results indicate that ex vivo cellular classification in peripheral blood might result in misleading interpretations. Therefore, in order to obtain results reflecting the in vivo situation, it is suggested to minimize times of ex vivo blood storage after isolation of PBMC. Moreover, to enable reproducibility of results between different research groups and multicenter studies, we would emphasize the necessity to specify and standardize the storage conditions, which might be the basis of particular findings.

Modifications in flow cytometric estimation of t cell subsets and b cells in peripheral blood to reduce the cost of investigation

The development of monoclonal antibodies combined with flow cytometry has revolutionized the analysis of lymphocyte subsets. These newer methods using the Q-prep leucocyte preparation system require only 1-2 ml of blood as compared to 10 ml required traditionally. One of the main impediments in the use of this superior technology in Indian laboratories has been the high cost of reagents. This study evaluated methods to reduce the cost of assays. In the first experiment from 26 healthy subjects, 2ml venous blood samples in EDTA (ethylenediamine tetra-acetate) were obtained. Each sample was divided into two equal portions, one portion was stained using diluted monoclonal antibody, whereas the other portion was stained using standard concentrations of antibodies. In the second experiment, blood samples from 12 subjects were again divided into 2 portions; one portion of each pair was processed using commercial Q-prep reagents while the other portion was processed using our own reagents. In the first experiment, which evaluated use of a diluted antibody against the standard recommended concentrations, a 5-tube panel that estimated CD3, CD4, CD8, CD20 was used. In the second experiment CD3, CD4 and CD8 were estimated. The total cost per sample for a 5-panel estimation was however reduced from $39.11 to $1.10.Given the proven advantages of using a whole blood stain-lyse method for T cell subset estimations, its use should be encouraged in developing country settings. With the suggested methods the whole blood Q-prep could be performed at appreciably reduced costs, without loss in precision.

Enumeration of lymphocyte subsets using flow cytometry: Effect of storage before and after staining in a developing country setting

Lymphocyte subset estimations by flow cytometry in population-based studies require transportation of samples from the field site to the laboratory. As samples arrive late in the day they have to wait overnight before being processed. The effect of two possible approaches, sample storage for 24 h before staining and immediate staining with analysis after 24 h and 48 h were evaluated. Two sets of experiments were performed with EDTA (ethylenediamine tetra-acetate) anticoagulated peripheral blood. In the first experiment, after collection, each sample was divided into two portions. One portion was stained at the time of blood collection and the other 24 h later after keeping it at room temperature (38-45°C). In the second experiment, blood samples were stained within 1-2 h. Each sample was analyzed immediately upon completion of staining process and subsequently after 24 h and 48 h of storage at 4°C. Results suggest that blood collected in EDTA can be processed using whole blood lysis method, after storage at room temperature (38-45°C) for 24 h with some but not significant alteration in T-cell subsets. Storage at 4°C after staining for 24 h results in a lesser and insignificant loss of cells or alteration of T-cell subsets and may be the method of choice.

Lymphocyte subsets in peripheral blood of dogs--a flow cytometric study

Slight differences in the results of papers describing lymphocyte subsets distribution in the peripheral blood of healthy dogs may be explained by differences in monoclonal antibody clones and sources, breed and age of animals examined, methods of sample treatment, or methods of result analysis. In this paper, we described the effect of sample processing and of sample storage as well as the effect of age, breed, and gender of dogs on lymphocyte subset distribution. No significant differences were found between samples processed following a whole-blood lysis method and samples processed after density gradient separation. Furthermore, no significant differences were found between samples processed within 2h after collection and those stored at 4 degrees C for 12-16 h before processing. Age-related changes were evident in lymphocyte subset distribution in the peripheral blood of 38 Beagles divided according to their age into the six groups: (1) 5-6 days; (2) 2 months; (3) 6 months; (4) 1-2 years; (5) 3-5 years; and (6) >5 years. The percentage of B-lymphocytes (CD21-like positive cells) in the peripheral blood of newborn pups was 39.5+/-5.7 and decreased with advancing age. The percentage of CD8+ lymphocytes was 7.7+/-3.4 after birth and increased with advancing age. No age-related changes were observed in the percentages of CD4+ lymphocytes. The CD4+:CD8+ ratio decreased with advancing age. No significant age-related change was observed for lymphocytes bearing the gammadelta-TCR. Some breed differences were evident. Adult (1-5-year-old) Beagles, German Shepherds, Dalmatians, and Dachshunds were examined. The percentages of lymphocytes were higher in Beagles and Dachshunds than in Dalmatians and German Shepherds. The highest and the lowest absolute lymphocyte counts were found in Beagles and German Shepherds, respectively. As a consequence, German Shepherds showed the lowest absolute counts of the individual lymphocyte subpopulations and the widest neutrophil:lymphocyte ratio. Dalmatians showed the lowest percentage of CD3+ cells, the highest percentage of CD21+ cells, and the lowest CD4+:CD8+ ratio. German Shepherds showed the lowest percentage of CD21+ cells and the highest CD4+:CD8+ ratio. Females in Beagles and Dachshuns had nonsignificantly higher percentages of total lymphocytes, CD3+, CD4+, and nonsignificantly lower percentages of CD21+ lymphocytes. We concluded that there are age-, breed-, and perhaps also gender-related differences in lymphocyte subset distribution in the peripheral blood of dogs. Therefore, there is need to use appropriate control group in the experimental protocols. Among-breed differences could explain, at least partly, breed predisposition for some diseases.

Circulating CD8+ T cells in polymyalgia rheumatica and giant cell arteritis: a review

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE

During the last few years, there have been several studies on T cell subsets in polymyalgia rheumatica (PMR) and giant cell arteritis (GCA), with conflicting results. Whereas some authors have found normal values of circulating CD8+ T cells, others have found a decreased number. Furthermore, in some studies, the level of CD8+ cells was found to be related to disease activity, and it has been proposed that a decrease of CD8+ T cells be used as a diagnostic criterion for PMR. The purpose of our study was to determine the value of assessing T cell subsets in PMR and GCA.

METHODS

T lymphocyte subsets were determined by flow cytometry using a whole blood lysis technique in the following groups: 28 PMR and 6 GCA patients before corticosteroid treatment, 20 PMR and 12 GCA patients in clinical remission with steroid treatment, 55 PMR patients in remission without steroid treatment, 17 rheumatoid arthritis (RA) patients before treatment, and 18 age-matched controls with noninflammatory conditions. Total white cell, lymphocyte, and platelet counts, hemoglobin, C-reactive protein (CRP), and erythrocyte sedimentation rate (ESR) were measured by routine techniques. Comparisons were made by the Student's t-test and the Mann-Whitney test. A MEDLINE database search for studies published between 1983 and 1997 was performed.

RESULTS

Compared with noninflammatory controls, CD8+ T cells were not reduced before steroid treatment in patients with active PMR/GCA in proportion (P =.7) or absolute numbers (P =.1). Patients with active disease had significantly lower hemoglobin levels and higher platelet counts, CRP, and ESR than noninflammatory controls (P <.05). When compared with active RA, CD8+ T cells were not reduced in patients with active PMR in proportion (P =.5) or absolute numbers (P =.2). Between these two groups, RA patients were significantly younger (P =.003) and had lower ESR values (P =.003). We did not find significant differences between patients with active PMR/GCA and those in remission with steroid therapy, except for the lower hemoglobin levels and higher platelet count, CRP, and ESR in the active disease group (P <.05). The same results were found when patients with active disease were compared with PMR in remission and no longer on steroid therapy, the only significant differences were those parameters reflecting the acute phase response (hemoglobin levels, platelet count, CRP and ESR).

CONCLUSIONS

This study does not confirm the previous findings that the proportion or number of circulating CD8+ T cells are reduced in patients with active PMR/GCA. The utility of the determination of CD8+ T cells for diagnostic and prognostic purpose should be evaluated in a large multicenter study.

Higher proportion of CD8+ T cells in the blood in healthy adults from Ethiopia and Bangladesh compared with Sweden

The phenotypic composition of peripheral blood lymphocytes in 45 healthy adults (15 each from Bangladesh, Ethiopia and Sweden) was analysed as an indicator of the influence of environment and/or ethnic background on the human immune response. The possible interference of technical factors was minimized by highly standardized handling of samples and by use of a similar simultaneous 3-colour flow cytometry analysis technique for all samples. The percentage of CD4+ cells was lower, and the percentage of CD8+ cells was higher, in Bangladeshi and Ethiopian subjects than in those from Sweden. A higher percentage of CD57+/CD8+ T cells was also found in these 2 groups than in Swedish subjects. The percentage of gamma delta T cells was higher in Bangladeshi subjects and a difference in T cell receptor V beta expression was also noted between Bangladeshi and Swedish subjects. The data suggest that environmental or genetic factors are important bias factors to be considered in immunophenotyping studies. Possibly differences in the pattern or level of microbial challenge, as well as nutritional factors, may lead to different adaptive changes in the immune response. The potential influence of such immune adaptation on the response to vaccination or pharmaceutical therapy may be important in the development of new strategies of medical intervention in different geographical regions or ethnic groups.

The effect of storage on immunophenotyping of sheep peripheral blood lymphocytes by flow cytometry

We have shown that when a whole blood method of cell staining is used for flow cytometric analysis of sheep lymphocytes (i.e. red cell lysis after addition of antibody), staining may be delayed for up to 48 h after blood collection without significant effect on expression of CD4, CD5, CD8 or B cell markers. If cells were stained immediately after blood collection, using the same whole blood method, and then fixed with paraformaldehyde, cell samples could be stored for 24 h without change in marker expression. However, by 7 days there was a significant decrease in the percentage of cells expressing CD8, T19 and B cell markers. Cryopreservation prior to staining was found to markedly affect the expression of all cell surface markers investigated. These results indicate that storage of sheep blood prior to flow cytometric analysis is feasible but may affect the results obtained. Thus is it important to standardise the handling of samples, especially when comparative studies are being undertaken.

Technical influences on immunophenotyping by flow cytometry. The effect of time and temperature of storage on the viability of lymphocyte subsets

The typing of lymphocyte subsets may be influenced by a variety of technical influences including the duration and temperature of sample storage and the method used for staining samples. We have extended a previous study examining the effect of storage conditions on the baseline values of a number of lymphocyte subsets. EDTA-anticoagulated samples from 13 HIV-1-positive and 15 healthy laboratory controls were analyzed for a number of lymphocyte subsets (CD3+, CD4+/CD3+, and CD8+/CD3+ T cells and CD19+ B cells) (whole blood lysis method, Becton-Dickinson FACScan flow cytometer and reagents) at 0, 24, 48, 72, and 96 h after storage at 4 degrees C, 17 degrees C or 21 degrees C. During storage at both 4 degrees C and 21 degrees C, there were significant changes in baseline values of the majority of lymphocyte subsets and some of these were related to the HIV status of the donor. The optimum temperature for storage in our system appeared to be around 17 degrees C in both our study groups. We have also used propidium iodide in order to discriminate between viable and non-viable cells during flow cytometry of lymphocytes from eight HIV-1-positive and five control subjects. The results show that for both HIV-positive and control samples stored at 4 degrees C, and for control subjects at 21 degrees C, the changes in baseline values of lymphocyte subsets observed were not due to selective loss of particular subsets arising from cell death during storage. However, there was substantial loss of cells from all three subsets in HIV-positive subjects during storage at 21 degrees C, with loss of CD8+ and CD3+ T cells being more significant than loss of CD4+ T cells.