Evidence for endonucleolytic attack in decay of lac messenger RNA in Escherichia coli

Strategy revealing phenotypic differences among synthetic oscillator designs

Considerable progress has been made in identifying and characterizing the component parts of genetic oscillators, which play central roles in all organisms. Nonlinear interaction among components is sufficiently complex that mathematical models are required to elucidate their elusive integrated behavior. Although natural and synthetic oscillators exhibit common architectures, there are numerous differences that are poorly understood. Utilizing synthetic biology to uncover basic principles of simpler circuits is a way to advance understanding of natural circadian clocks and rhythms. Following this strategy, we address the following questions: What are the implications of different architectures and molecular modes of transcriptional control for the phenotypic repertoire of genetic oscillators? Are there designs that are more realizable or robust? We compare synthetic oscillators involving one of three architectures and various combinations of the two modes of transcriptional control using a methodology that provides three innovations: a rigorous definition of phenotype, a procedure for deconstructing complex systems into qualitatively distinct phenotypes, and a graphical representation for illuminating the relationship between genotype, environment, and the qualitatively distinct phenotypes of a system. These methods provide a global perspective on the behavioral repertoire, facilitate comparisons of alternatives, and assist the rational design of synthetic gene circuitry. In particular, the results of their application here reveal distinctive phenotypes for several designs that have been studied experimentally as well as a best design among the alternatives that has yet to be constructed and tested.

Evolution of a genome-encoded bias in amino acid biosynthetic pathways is a potential indicator of amino acid dynamics in the environment

Overcoming the stress of starvation is one of an organism’s most challenging phenotypic responses. Those organisms that frequently survive the challenge, by virtue of their fitness, will have evolved genomes that are shaped by their specific environments. Understanding this genotype–environment–phenotype relationship at a deep level will require quantitative predictive models of the complex molecular systems that link these aspects of an organism’s existence. Here, we treat one of the most fundamental molecular systems, protein synthesis, and the amino acid biosynthetic pathways involved in the stringent response to starvation. These systems face an inherent logical dilemma: Building an amino acid biosynthetic pathway to synthesize its product—the cognate amino acid of the pathway—may require that very amino acid when it is no longer available. To study this potential “catch-22,” we have created a generic model of amino acid biosynthesis in response to sudden starvation. Our mathematical analysis and computational results indicate that there are two distinctly different outcomes: Partial recovery to a new steady state, or full system failure. Moreover, the cell’s fate is dictated by the cognate bias, the number of cognate amino acids in the corresponding biosynthetic pathway relative to the average number of that amino acid in the proteome. We test these implications by analyzing the proteomes of over 1,800 sequenced microbes, which reveals statistically significant evidence of low cognate bias, a genetic trait that would avoid the biosynthetic quandary. Furthermore, these results suggest that the pattern of cognate bias, which is readily derived by genome sequencing, may provide evolutionary clues to an organism’s natural environment.

Post-transcriptional control of gene expression: bacterial mRNA degradation

Many biological processes cannot be fully understood without detailed knowledge of RNA metabolism. The continuous breakdown and resynthesis of prokaryotic mRNA permit rapid production of new kinds of proteins. In this way, mRNA levels can regulate protein synthesis and cellular growth. Analysing mRNA degradation in prokaryotes has been particularly difficult because most mRNA undergo rapid exponential decay. Prokaryotic mRNAs differ in their susceptibility to degradation by endonucleases and exonucleases, possibly because of variation in their sequencing and structure. In spite of numerous studies, details of mRNA degradation are still largely unknown. This review highlights those aspects of mRNA metabolism which seem most influential in the regulation of gene expression.

Phenotypic deconstruction of gene circuitry

It remains a challenge to obtain a global perspective on the behavioral repertoire of complex nonlinear gene circuits. In this paper, we describe a method for deconstructing complex systems into nonlinear sub-systems, based on mathematically defined phenotypes, which are then represented within a system design space that allows the repertoire of qualitatively distinct phenotypes of the complex system to be identified, enumerated, and analyzed. This method efficiently characterizes large regions of system design space and quickly generates alternative hypotheses for experimental testing. We describe the motivation and strategy in general terms, illustrate its use with a detailed example involving a two-gene circuit with a rich repertoire of dynamic behavior, and discuss experimental means of navigating the system design space.

Dynamics and bistability in a reduced model of the lac operon

It is known that the lac operon regulatory pathway is capable of showing bistable behavior. This is an important complex feature, arising from the nonlinearity of the involved mechanisms, which is essential to understand the dynamic behavior of this molecular regulatory system. To find which of the mechanisms involved in the regulation of the lac operon is the origin of bistability, we take a previously published model which accounts for the dynamics of mRNA, lactose, allolactose, permease and beta-galactosidase involvement and simplify it by ignoring permease dynamics (assuming a constant permease concentration). To test the behavior of the reduced model, three existing sets of data on beta-galactosidase levels as a function of time are simulated and we obtain a reasonable agreement between the data and the model predictions. The steady states of the reduced model were numerically and analytically analyzed and it was shown that it may indeed display bistability, depending on the extracellular lactose concentration and growth rate.

Polarity Effects in the Lactose Operon of Escherichia coli

An intergenic RNA segment between lacY and lacA of the lactose operon in Escherichia coli is cleaved by RNase P, an endoribonuclease. The cleavage of the intergenic RNA was ten times less efficient than cleavage of a tRNA precursor in vitro. Fragments of the RNase P cleavage product are detectable in vivo in the wild-type strain but not in a mutant strain at the restrictive temperature. The cleavage product that contains lacA in the wild-type strain was quickly degraded. When this intergenic segment was cloned upstream of a reporter gene, the expression of the reporter gene was also inhibited substantially in wild-type E.coli, but not in a temperature sensitive mutant strain in RNase P at the restrictive temperature. These results support data regarding the natural polarity between lacZ versus lacA, the downstream gene.

Feedback regulation in the lactose operon: a mathematical modeling study and comparison with experimental data

A mathematical model for the regulation of induction in the lac operon in Escherichia coli is presented. This model takes into account the dynamics of the permease facilitating the internalization of external lactose; internal lactose; beta-galactosidase, which is involved in the conversion of lactose to allolactose, glucose and galactose; the allolactose interactions with the lac repressor; and mRNA. The final model consists of five nonlinear differential delay equations with delays due to the transcription and translation process. We have paid particular attention to the estimation of the parameters in the model. We have tested our model against two sets of beta-galactosidase activity versus time data, as well as a set of data on beta-galactosidase activity during periodic phosphate feeding. In all three cases we find excellent agreement between the data and the model predictions. Analytical and numerical studies also indicate that for physiologically realistic values of the external lactose and the bacterial growth rate, a regime exists where there may be bistable steady-state behavior, and that this corresponds to a cusp bifurcation in the model dynamics.

In the absence of translation, RNase E can bypass 5' mRNA stabilizers in Escherichia coli

In Bacilli, ribosomes or 30 S ribosomal subunits that are stalled or bound on mRNAs can stabilize downstream regions, hence the view that the degradation machinery scans mRNAs from their 5' end. In E. coli, several mRNAs can also be stabilized by secondary structures involving their 5' end. To test whether a bound 30 S subunit can act as a 5' stabilizer in E. coli, we compare here the stabilities of two untranslated variants of the lacZ mRNA, the decay of which is controlled by RNase E. In the first variant, a 35 nt region including the Ribosome Binding Site (RBS) is deleted, whereas in the second it is replaced by an 11 nt-long Shine-Dalgarno (SD) sequence lacking an associated start codon. In the latter variant, an 80 nt fragment encompassing the SD and extending up to the mRNA 5' end was stable in vivo (t1/2>one hour), reflecting 30 S binding. Yet, the full-length message was not more stable than when the SD was absent, although two small decay intermediates retaining the 5' end appear somewhat stabilized. A third variant was constructed in which the RBS is replaced by an insert which can fold back onto the lac leader, creating a putative hairpin involving the mRNA 5' end. The fragment corresponding to this hairpin was stable but, again, the full-length message was not stabilized. Thus, the untranslated lacZ mRNA cannot be protected against RNase E by 5' stabilizers, suggesting that mRNA scanning is not an obligate feature of RNase E-controlled degradation. Altogether, these results suggest important differences in mRNA degradation between E. coli and B. subtilis. In addition, we show that mRNA regions involved in stable hairpins or Shine-Dalgarno pairings can be metabolically stable in E. coli.

Lethal double-stranded RNA processing activity of ribonuclease III in the absence of suhB protein of Escherichia coli

The suhB gene of Escherichia coli has been defined by its mutant allele that suppresses other mutants in secY, rpoH, dnaB, and era. The suhB mutant by itself is cold sensitive, and is shown to have defects in protein synthesis. Starting with the suhB cold-sensitive mutant, cold-resistant suppressors were isolated. These suppressors mapped to the gene rnc encoding RNase III (a double-strand RNA-processing enzyme), and restored normal protein synthesis to the suhB mutants. Two known rnc mutations, rnc70 or rnc105, both defective in RNA cleavage activity, similarly restored growth of suhB. These rnc mutations did not alter the level of suhB expression. These results suggest that wild-type RNase III exerts a lethal effect on E coli upon depletion of SuhB at low temperatures. One explanation is to assume that the double-strand RNA-processing activity of RNase III itself is potentially lethal to E coli and the normal function of SuhB modulates the lethal action of RNase III.

Control of mRNA processing and decay in prokaryotes

Post-transcriptional mechanisms operate in regulation of gene expression in bacteria, the amount of a given gene product being also dependent on the inactivation rate of its own message. Moreover, segmental differences in mRNA stability of polycistronic transcripts may be responsible for differential expression of genes clustered in operons. Given the absence of 5' to 3' exoribonucleolytic activities in prokaryotes, both endoribonucleases and 3' to 5' exoribonucleases are involved in chemical decay of mRNA. As the 3' to 5' exoribonucleolytic activities are readily blocked by stem-loop structures which are usual at the 3' ends of bacterial messages, the rate of decay is primarily determined by the rate of the first endonucleolytic cleavage within the transcripts, after which the resulting mRNA intermediates are degraded by the 3' to 5' exoribonucleases. Consequently, the stability of a given transcript is determined by the accessibility of suitable target sites to endonucleolytic activities. A considerable number of bacterial messages decay with a net 5' to 3' directionality. Two different alternative models have been proposed to explain such a finding, the first invoking the presence of functional coupling between degradation and the movement of the ribosomes along the transcripts, the second one implying the existence of a 5' to 3' processive '5' binding nuclease'. The different systems by which these two current models of mRNA decay have been tested will be presented with particular emphasis on polycistronic transcripts.

Synthesis and degradation of the mRNA of the Tn21 mer operon

The mercury resistance locus encoded by Tn21 on the monocopy IncFII plasmid R100 (merTn21) consists of a metal-responsive activator/repressor, merR, which controls initiation of a polycistronic message that includes genes for the uptake (merTPC) and reduction (merA) of Hg2+ and merD, which may also play a minor regulatory role. Comparison of the relative abundance of the 5' and 3' ends of the merTPCAD transcript revealed a strong transcriptional gradient in the operon, consistent with previous observations of lower relative abundance of the more promoter-distal gene products. In vivo mRNA degradation rates varied only slightly for the different genes: however, the rates of mRNA synthesis varied considerably from the beginning to the end of the operon. Specifically, mRNA corresponding to the promoter-proximal genes, merTPC, achieved a maximum in vivo synthesis rate between 60 and 120 seconds after induction; this rate was maintained for approximately ten minutes. In contrast, the synthesis rates of mRNA corresponding to the promoter-distal genes merA and merD, were initially fivefold lower than the rates of the promoter-proximal genes for the first five minutes after induction, and then rose gradually to approximately 50% of the merTPC synthesis rates. These data suggested that early after induction only 20% of the transcripts initiating at merT proceed beyond merC. At later times after induction approximately 50% of the transcripts proceed beyond merC. Nuclease end mapping did not reveal any discrete termination events in the merPCA region, thus, premature termination may occur at many sites.

Characterization of cat messenger RNA decay suggests that turnover occurs by endonucleolytic cleavage in a 3' to 5' direction

Turnover of the chloramphenicol acetyltransferase (cat) messenger RNA in Escherichia coli was investigated by analysis of cellular mRNA decay intermediates and the transcript sequence. Analysis of the sequence has revealed the presence of a repetitive extragenic palindromic (REP) element at the 3' end of the transcript as well as several 5'-UUAU-3' sequences, two elements which have roles in modulating turnover of other E. coli mRNAs. For cat mRNA, however, removal of the REP sequence has no effect on the half-life of the transcript, indicating that the REP sequence does not stabilize the upstream region of this message. Results from mapping of the mRNA decay products by several techniques suggest that the message is instead subject to endonucleolytic attack at five sites 5' of the REP element. The sequence UUAU is present at three of these five sites. It also appears that the cat mRNA is sequentially cleaved in a 3' to 5' direction during turnover of this mRNA in vivo. A model for cat mRNA turnover is discussed.

Differential gene expression from the Escherichia coli atp operon mediated by segmental differences in mRNA stability

The atp operon of Escherichia coli directs synthesis rates of protein subunits that are well matched to the requirements of assembly of the membrane-bound H(+)-ATPase (alpha 3 beta 3 gamma 1 delta 1 epsilon 1a1b2c10-15). Segmental differences in mRNA stability are shown to contribute to the differential control of atp gene expression. The first two genes of the operon, atpl and atpB, are rapidly inactivated at the mRNA level. The remaining seven genes are more stable. It has previously been established that the translational efficiencies of the atp genes vary greatly. Thus differential expression from this operon is achieved via post-transcriptional control exerted at two levels. Neither enhancement of translational efficiency nor insertion of repetitive extragenic palindromic (REP) sequences into the atplB intercistronic region stabilized atpl. We discuss the implications of these results in terms of the pathway of mRNA degradation and of the role of mRNA stability in the control of gene expression.

Intermediates in the degradation of mRNA from the lactose operon of Escherichia coli

We have analyzed the processing of mRNA from the lac operon in an Escherichia coli strain carrying the lac on a multicopy plasmid. Messenger RNA was analyzed by hybridization and nuclease protection of pulse-labeled RNA and precursor-product relationships were determined by quantitating radioactivity in primary and processed transcripts at various times after induction of the lac promoter or inhibition of transcription with rifampicin. Our results support the existence of two types of processed transcripts with endpoints in the lacZ-lacY intercistronic region. One of these carries lacZ sequences and has a 3' endpoint about 30 bases downstream of this gene. The other carries lacY sequences and has a 5' end in the translation termination region of the lacZ gene. Finally, we have found evidence that transcription is continued at least 268 bases beyond the last gene (lacA) and that this 3' non-translated region is shortened by post-transcriptional processing.

Purification and characterization of ribonuclease M and mRNA degradation in Escherichia coli

A previously unreported endoribonuclease has been identified in Escherichia coli, which has a preference for hydrolysis of pyrimidine-adenosine (Pyd-Ado) bonds in RNA. It was purified about 7000-fold to give a single band after SDS/polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis; the eluted protein gave the same RNase specificity. The sizes of the native and denatured enzymes agreed suggesting that the enzyme exists as a monomer of approximately 26 kDa. It is called RNase M. The only other reported broadly specific endoribonuclease in E. coli is RNase I, a periplasmic enzyme. Based on differences in charge, heat stability and substrate specificity, it was clear that RNase M is not RNase I. The specificity of RNase M was remarkably similar to that of pancreatic RNase A even though the two enzymes differ in charge characteristics and size. Earlier studies had shown that mRNA from the lactose operon of E. coli is hydrolyzed in vivo primarily between Pyd-Ado bonds [Cannistraro et al. (1986) J. Mol. Biol. 192, 257-274] We propose that this major RNase activity accounts for these cleavages observed in vivo and that it is the endonuclease for mRNA degradation in E. coli.

Mechanisms of mRNA decay in bacteria: a perspective

Messenger RNA decay plays an important role in prokaryotic gene expression. The disparate stabilities of bacterial messages in vivo are a consequence of their differential susceptibility to degradation by cellular endoribonucleases and 3' -exoribonucleases, which in turn results from differences in mRNA sequence and structure. RNase II and polynucleotide phosphorylase, the major bacterial exonucleases involved in mRNA turnover, rapidly degrade single-stranded RNA from the 3' end, but are impeded by 3' stem-loop structures. At present, the identify and substrate specificity of the endonucleases that control mRNA decay rates are relatively poorly defined. Ribosomes and antisense RNA also can influence the stability of transcripts with which they associate. Differences in mRNA stability can contribute to differential expression of genes within polycistronic operons and to modulation of gene expression in response to changes in bacterial growth conditions.

Site-specific endonucleolytic cleavages and the regulation of stability of E. coli ompA mRNA

The stability of ompA mRNA is growth-rate dependent. We show that the 5' noncoding region of this mRNA provides a target for site-specific endonucleases. The rate of degradation of ompA mRNA parallels the rate of these endonucleolytic cleavages, implying that endonucleolytic rather than exonucleolytic attack is the initial step in ompA mRNA degradation. Thus the 5' noncoding region appears to be a determinant of mRNA stability, and endonucleolytic cleavages in the 5' noncoding region may well regulate expression of the ompA gene.

Differential mRNA stability controls relative gene expression within a polycistronic operon

In this paper we demonstrate a role for mRNA stability in controlling relative gene expression within a polycistronic operon. The polycistronic malEFG operon of E. coli contains two REP sequences (highly conserved inverted repeats) within the malE-malF intercistronic region. Deletion of these REP sequences from the chromosomal operon not only destabilizes upstream malE mRNA, but also results in a 9-fold reduction in the synthesis of MalE protein. A single REP sequence seems to be as efficient as the two normally found in this intergenic region at stabilizing translationally active upstream mRNA. The widespread occurrence of REP sequences and other sequences that could potentially stabilize upstream mRNA suggests that this mechanism of control of gene expression may be rather common.

The mRNA for an inducible chloramphenicol acetyltransferase gene is cleaved into discrete fragments in Bacillus subtilis

cat-86 is a promoter-deficient plasmid gene that encodes chloramphenicol acetyltransferase (CAT). Insertion of a promoter at a site 144 base pairs 5' to the cat-86 coding sequence activates transcription of the gene and allows cat-86 to specify chloramphenicol-inducible CAT activity in Bacillus subtilis. Induction of cat-86 by chloramphenicol has been shown to result from a regulatory event that activates translation of cat-86 mRNA that is present in cells before the addition of inducer (E. J. Duvall and P. S. Lovett, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 83:3939-3943, 1986). In the present study we show an unusual property of cat-86 mRNA. Full-length cat-86 transcripts, consisting of 920 nucleotides (nt), are cleaved in B. subtilis to yield two predominant fragmentation products: an 810-nt species that lacks sequences present at the 5' end of the 920-nt species and a 720-nt species that lacks sequences present at the 3' end of the 920-nt species. A third fragmentation product consisting of 620 nt may result from the cleavage of a single 920-nt transcript at both the 5' and 3' ends. The sequences which are missing from the 720- and 620-nt species suggest that these transcripts cannot be translated into functional CAT. The 810-nt species lacks sequences from the 5' regulatory region, and it is not yet certain whether or not translation of this species can be induced by chloramphenicol. The ratio of 920-nt molecules/720-nt molecules in rifampin-treated cells is increased when the cells are grown in chloramphenicol. Therefore, induction may partially stabilize full-length cat-86 transcripts against inactivation by a novel processing-like system.

Induced mRNA stability in Bacillus subtilis

We have investigated the induced stability of mRNA encoded by the ermC gene in Bacillus subtilis. Induction of ermC gene expression by erythromycin is known to occur at the translational level. We show that this induction is accompanied by an increase in ermC mRNA half-life from about 2 min to about 40 min. Induced stabilization of ermC mRNA occurs independently of induced translation. The regulatory sequences required for stability are promoter-proximal and can confer induced stability on large mRNAs having diverse 3' ends. Translation of the ermC leader peptide and ribosome-stalling in the leader peptide sequence are necessary for induced stabilization.

Deletion of a repetitive extragenic palindromic (REP) sequence downstream from the structural gene of Escherichia coli glutamate dehydrogenase affects the stability of its mRNA

A deletion that removes one repetitive extragenic palindromic sequence downstream of the structural gene of Escherichia coli glutamate dehydrogenase, reduces twofold the half-life of gdhA mRNA.

Specific endonucleolytic cleavage sites for decay of Escherichia coli mRNA

The polycistronic lac mRNA of Escherichia coli contains three messages. The rate of degradation of the second (lacY) message was observed to be equal to that of the third (lacA), and each decayed twice as fast as did the first (lacZ). Specific 5'- and 3'-ended lacY mRNA molecules could be recovered from cells; most likely, they are generated from endonucleolytic cleavages that are a part of the degradative process. They were observed by S1 nuclease mapping, and the exact 5'- and 3'-end oligonucleotides of many of them were identified by direct sequencing. Almost all of the molecules started with a 5' adenosine that would be preceded by a pyrimidine. The specificity was further restricted by neighboring nucleotides, and analysis of the data suggested that 5'-U-U decreases-A-U- is especially vulnerable. Also, computer analyses predicted the most stable secondary structures of selected segments of the mRNA and suggested that cleavages may only occur in regions of single strandedness. A model of mRNA degradation is proposed based on these observations and earlier ones. There is no unique target on a message for the initial inactivating attack: any region free of ribosomes is vulnerable, but for statistical reasons the initial attack of most molecules is near the ribosome-loading site. With no further ribosome loading, the newly unprotected 5' ends are "chopped off" at one of the next preferred target sites almost as fast as the last ribosomes moves down the mRNA.

The stability of E. coli gene transcripts is dependent on determinants localized to specific mRNA segments

To map the structural features responsible for the 5-fold difference in stability of the E. coli ompA and bla gene transcripts, we have constructed gene fusions that encode chimeric ompA/bla transcripts and a deletion that eliminates a large internal segment of bla mRNA. Shortening of bla transcripts by internal deletion or replacement of the 3' end with the corresponding segment of the ompA transcript had little effect on bla mRNA stability. However, fusion of a 5'-terminal 147 nucleotide segment of the ompA message 5' to full-length or truncated bla transcripts increased the half-life of the bla segments 3- to 5-fold. These and other findings indicate that E. coli transcripts contain discrete structural determinants of stability and instability that can influence the decay rate of linked mRNA segments derived from other genes.

The stability of bacteriophage T4 gene 32 mRNA: a 5' leader sequence that can stabilize mRNA transcripts

In T4-infected cells, the gene 32 monocistronic mRNA is very stable. To study the molecular basis for this stability, we have constructed chimeric plasmids containing the monocistronic promoter and the gene 32 translation initiation sequence fused to either most of the E. coli lac operon or only a segment of the lacZ gene, followed by the gene 32 transcription terminator. The resulting hybrid transcripts are unstable in uninfected cells. In phage-infected cells, however, the hybrid mRNAs are at least as stable as gene 32 mRNA itself. Analysis of other plasmid constructs indicates that the sequences on the gene 32 mRNA from its 5' end to slightly beyond the initiation codon suffice to stabilize these hybrids. Studies with a series of deletions of the gene 32 leader sequence suggest that an RNA sequence near the gene 32 initiation codon is involved. Various models to explain this mRNA stabilization are discussed.

The relationship between translational initiation and messenger RNA inactivation in down-shifted Escherichia coli

The parameters of protein synthesis and functional inactivation of global messenger RNA (mRNA) were examined in a Tic+ strain of Escherichia coli during the 30-min period following a shift-down from glucose-minimal to succinate-minimal medium. The rate of mRNA inactivation and the relative translational initiation frequency were both most severely depressed immediately after the shift-down and increased slowly thereafter. If glucose was restored to the medium at any time after shift-down, mRNA inactivation immediately resumed its normal (preshift) rate and the protein-forming capacity was increased. These changes in mRNA inactivation rate do not reflect an altered mRNA composition in the down-shifted cells. The relative rate of mRNA inactivation was linearly proportional to the relative translational initiation frequency over a 10-fold range of initiation frequencies. Low initiation frequencies represent increased "dwell" of the ribosomes at the initiation site before the commencement of polypeptide chain initiation. We propose that initiating ribosomes protect mRNA from an inactivating endonucleolytic cleavage at or near the ribosome binding site.

Isolating and sequencing the predominant 5'-ends of a specific mRNA in cells. I. Purification by filter hybridization

Procedures are considered for purification of a specific procaryotic RNA by successive hybridizations to DNA immobilized to nitrocellulose with special consideration of problems associated with subsequent end-labeling in the T4 polynucleotide kinase reaction. (1) Inhibitors of the kinase can be associated with the plasmid but were removed by electrophoresis of the DNA fragment through polyacrylamide. (2) Residual soluble acrylamide, contaminating the DNA and preventing its efficient retention to nitrocellulose, could be removed by DE52 chromatography. (3) Short denatured DNA required high salt (0.9 M) to bind to nitrocellulose but reannealed quickly at those salt concentrations unless applied at less than or equal to 0.3 micrograms/ml at 4 degrees C with a flow rate of 1 ml/min. (4) The kinetics of the hybrid reaction were a function of DNA length, concentration, and temperature. (5) Formamide was a more effective denaturing agent to remove hybrid RNA from the filter than either 12 M urea or 8 M guanidine-HCl, but caused significant release of DNA from the nitrocellulose as well as another potent inhibitor of the kinase reaction. The release of DNA and other kinase inhibitors was greatly reduced by eluting in boiling water.

The 5' ends of Escherichia coli lac mRNA

We identified the predominant 5' ends of an mRNA in Escherichia coli to the exact nucleotides. There are four such ends of lac mRNA in fully induced cells. About 70% of the molecules have the reported major in vitro end, A-A-U-U-G (at +1), which is located 38 nucleotides before the A-U-G translation start. Another 15% start with A-U-U-G at +2, and about 8% start with A-U-U-A-G at -52. A fourth class of molecules begin with either A-G, C-A-G, A-C-A-G, or a weak A-C-A-C-A-G (at +24), observed only once. The origins of this latter set (less than or equal to 10% of the total) are not known, but they could represent "ragged" ends of the mRNA when it is degraded to the beginning of the ribosome-protected region of the message. The A-U-U-A-G molecules are probably initiated from an upstream promoter whose position would coincide with the cAMP-CRP DNA binding site for the major promoter.

Evidence that the 5' end of lac mRNA starts to decay as soon as it is synthesized

By monitoring the decay of the first 16% of the beta-galactosidase message, we showed that the 5' end started to decay before the 3' end was completed and at a rate equivalent to that of the whole molecule. Thus, decay was neither from 3' to 5' nor from random internal fragmentation but rather proceeded in a net 5' to 3' direction.

Posttranscriptional modulation of bacteriophage P22 scaffolding protein gene expression

The bacteriophage P22 late operon contains 2 genes whose products are required for cell lysis and 13 genes whose products are involved in the morphogenesis of the phage particle. This operon is under the positive control of the phage gene 23 product and is thought to have a single promoter. The expression of one of these late genes, the scaffolding protein gene, is autogenously modulated independently from the remainder of the late genes. When unassembled, scaffolding protein turns down the rate of synthesis of additional scaffolding protein, and when it is assembled into phage precursor structures, it does not. Experiments presented here show (i) that the mRNA from the scaffolding protein gene is functionally threefold more stable when most of the scaffolding protein is assembled than when it is unassembled and (ii) that no new promoter near the scaffolding protein gene is activated at the high level of synthesis. These data support the model that this autogenous modulation occurs at a posttranscriptional level. We also observed that another message, that of coat protein, appears to become increasingly stable with time after phage infection.

Repetitive extragenic palindromic sequences: a major component of the bacterial genome

We describe a remarkably conserved nucleotide sequence, the many copies of which may occupy up to 1% of the genomes of E. coli and S. typhimurium. This sequence, the REP (repetitive extragenic palindromic) sequence, is about 35 nucleotides long, includes an inverted repeat, and can occur singly or in multiple adjacent copies. A possible role for the REP sequences in regulation of gene expression has been thoroughly investigated. While the REP sequences do not appear to modulate differential gene expression within an operon, they can affect the expression of both upstream and downstream genes to a small extent, probably by affecting the rate of mRNA degradation. Possible roles for the REP sequence in mRNA degradation, chromosome structure, and recombination are discussed.

Decay of mRNA in Escherichia coli: investigation of the fate of specific segments of transcripts

An assay was developed to investigate the fate of specific segments of beta-lactamase (bla) and ompA gene transcripts in Escherichia coli. DNA probes cloned in bacteriophage M13 were treated with an endonuclease capable of cleaving single-stranded DNA, the fragments produced were annealed with total cellular RNA, and the resulting RNA . DNA hybrids were subjected to S1 nuclease treatment and gel fractionation. By using this assay, direct evidence was obtained for 3'-to-5' directionality in the decay of the long-lived mRNA encoded by the ompA gene, and no preferential stability was observed for translated versus untranslated mRNA segments. In the case of bla mRNA, initial cleavage of the full-length transcript was rate limiting, and no decay intermediates were detected. No difference in degradation rate was seen for bla transcripts having variant 3' or 5' termini.

Amplification of ribonuclease II (rnb) activity in Escherichia coli K-12

A 7.1 kb HindIII-XhoI fragment of E. coli DNA which contains the structural gene for ribonuclease II (rnb) has been cloned in the recombinant plasmid pDK24. At least two constitutively expressed genes are encoded on the fragment as shown by maxicell analysis. On denaturing polyacrylamide gels RNase II appears as a single 72,000 dalton species. The approximate site of transcription initiation of the rnb gene has been mapped. Although derivatives of E. coli harboring pDK24 contained 10-fold more RNase II activity that wild type strains without the plasmid, the degradation rate of mRNA was similar in all strains tested. Strains deficient in both RNase II and polynucleotide phosphorylase appear inviable.

Evidence for endonucleolytic cleavage at the 5'-proximal segment of the trp messenger RNA in Escherichia coli

The 5'-proximal trp leader RNA segment (about 5S) decays at 2 to 3 times slower rates than the distal trp mRNA sequence. This has been demonstrated by employing the deletion mutants which lack a large portion of the structural genes but retain the promoter-proximal region of the trp operon. Relative stability of the leader RNA is not merely due to the presence of an untranslatable region in the segment; the internal untranslatable segment of trp mRNA downstream from the nonsense alteration site of a double mutant trpAD28.trpE9758 decays as fast as the normal trp mRNA sequence. These results suggest that the trp mRNA is endonucleolytically cleaved to yield the small 5'-proximal leader RNA segment before the distal mRNA decays and that the leader RNA sequence is not subject to usual mode of mRNA decay in the 5' to 3' direction.

Altered mRNA metabolism in ribonuclease III-deficient strains of Escherichia coli

The metabolism of mRNA from the lactose (lac) operon of Escherichia coli has been studied in ribonuclease (RNase) III-deficient strains (rnc-105). The induction lag for beta-galactosidase from the first gene was twice as long, and enzyme synthesis was reduced 10-fold in one such mutant compared with its isogenic rnc+ sister; in the original mutant strain AB301-105, synthesis of beta-galactosidase was not even detectable, although transduction analysis revealed the presence of a normal lac operon. This defect does not reflect a loss of all lac operon activity galactoside acetyltransferase from the last gene was synthesized even in strain AB301-105 but at a rate several times lower than normal. Hybridization analyses suggested that both the frequency of transcription initiation and the time to transcribe the entire operon are normal in rnc-105 strains. The long induction lag was caused by a longer translation time. This defect led to translational polarity with reduced amounts of distal mRNA to give a population of smaller-sized lac mRNA molecules. All these pleiotropic effects seem to result from RNase III deficiency, since it was possible to select revertants to rnc+ that grew and expressed the lac operon at normal rates. However, the rnc-105 isogenic strains (but not AB301-105) also changed very easily to give a more normal rate of beta-galactosidase synthesis without regaining RNase III activity or a faster growth rate. The basis for this reversion is not known; it may represent a "phenotypic suppression" rather than result from a stable genetic change. Such suppressor effects could account for earlier reports of a noninvolvement of RNase III in mRNA metabolism in deliberately selected lac+ rnc-105 strains. The ribosomes from rnc-105 strains were as competent as ribosomes from rnc+ strains to form translation initiation complexes in vitro. However, per mass, beta-galactosidase mRNA from AB301-105 was at least three times less competent to form initiation complexes than was A19 beta-galactosidase mRNA. RNase III may be important in the normal cell to prepare lac mRNA for translation initiation. A defect at this step could account for all the observed changes in lac expression. A potential target within a secondary structure at the start of the lac mRNA is considered. Expression of many operons may be affected by RNase III activity; gal and trp operon expressions were also abnormal in RNase III- strains.

Translation and mRNA decay

Degradation of messenger RNA from the lactose operon (lac mRNA) was measured during the inhibition of protein synthesis by chloramphenicol (CM) or of translation-initiation by kasugamycin (KAS). With increasing CM concentration mRNA decay becomes slower, but there is no direct proportionality between rates of chemical decay and polypeptide synthesis. During exponential growth lac mRNA is cleaved endonucleolytically (Blundell and Kennell, 1974). At a CM concentration which completely inhibits all polypeptide synthesis this cleavage is blocked. In contrast, if only the initiation of translation is blocked by addition of KAS, the cleavage rate as well as the rate of chemical decay are increased significantly without delay. These faster rates do not result from immediate degradation of the lengthening stretch of ribosome-free proximal message, since the full-length size is present and the same discrete message sizes are generated during inhibition. These results suggest that neither ribosomes nor translation play an active role in the degradative process. Rather, targets can be protected by the proximity of a ribosome, and without nearly ribosomes the probability of cleavage becomes very high. During normal growth there is a certain probability that any message is in such a vulnerable state, and the fraction of vulnerable molecules determines the inactivation rate of that species.