Protein synthetic ability of Escherichia coli valine transfer RNA with pseudouridine, ribothymidine, and other uridine-derived residues replaced by 5-fluorouridine

Synthetase recognition determinants of E. coli valine transfer RNA

We have studied the interactions between Escherichia coli tRNAVal and valyl-tRNA synthetase (ValRS) by enzymatic footprinting with nuclease S1 and ribonuclease V1, and by analysis of the aminoacylation kinetics of mutant tRNAVal transcripts. Valyl-tRNA synthetase specifically protects the anticodon loop, the 3' side of the stacked T-stem/acceptor-stem helix, and the 5' side of the anticodon stem of tRNAVal against cleavage by double- and single-strand-specific nucleases. Increased nuclease susceptibility at the ends of the anticodon- and T-stems in the tRNAVal.ValRS complex is indicative of enzyme-induced conformational changes in the tRNA. The most important synthetase recognition determinants are the middle and 3' anticodon nucleotides (A35 and C36, respectively); G20, in the variable pocket, and G45, in the tRNA central core, are minor recognition elements. The discriminator base, position 73, and the anticodon stem also are recognized by ValRS. Replacing wild-type A73 with G73 reduces the aminoacylation efficiency more than 40-fold. However, the C73 and U73 mutants remain good substrates for ValRS, suggesting that guanosine at position 73 acts as a negative determinant. The amino acid acceptor arm of tRNAVal contains no other synthetase recognition nucleotides, but regular A-type RNA helix geometry in the acceptor stem is essential [Liu, M., et al. (1997) Nucleic Acids Res. 25, 4883-4890]. In the anticodon stem, converting the U29:A41 base pair to C29:G41 reduces the aminoacylation efficiency 50-fold. This is apparently due to the rigidity of the anticodon stem caused by the presence of five consecutive C:G base pairs, since the A29:U41 mutant is readily aminoacylated. Identity switch experiments provide additional evidence for a role of the anticodon stem in synthetase recognition. The valine recognition determinants, A35, C36, A73, G20, G45, and a regular A-RNA acceptor helix are insufficient to transform E. coli tRNAPhe into an effective valine acceptor. Replacing the anticodon stem of tRNAPhe with that of tRNAVal, however, converts the tRNA into a good substrate for ValRS. These experiments confirm G45 as a minor ValRS recognition element.

Role of acceptor stem conformation in tRNAVal recognition by its cognate synthetase

Although the anticodon is the primary element in Escherichia coli tRNAValfor recognition by valyl-tRNA synthetase (ValRS), nucleotides in the acceptor stem and other parts of the tRNA modulate recognition. Study of the steady state aminoacylation kinetics of acceptor stem mutants of E.coli tRNAValdemonstrates that replacing any base pair in the acceptor helix with another Watson-Crick base pair has little effect on aminoacylation efficiency. The absence of essential recognition nucleotides in the acceptor helix was confirmed by converting E.coli tRNAAlaand yeast tRNAPhe, whose acceptor stem sequences differ significantly from that of tRNAVal, to efficient valine acceptors. This transformation requires, in addition to a valine anticodon, replacement of the G:U base pair in the acceptor stem of these tRNAs. Mutational analysis of tRNAValverifies that G:U base pairs in the acceptor helix act as negative determinants of synthetase recognition. Insertion of G:U in place of the conserved U4:A69 in tRNAValreduces the efficiency of aminoacylation, due largely to an increase in K m. A smaller but significant decline in aminoacylation efficiency occurs when G:U is located at position 3:70; lesser effects are observed for G:U at other positions in the acceptor helix. The negative effects of G:U base pairs are strongly correlated with changes in helix structure in the vicinity of position 4:69 as monitored by19F NMR spectroscopy of 5-fluorouracil-substituted tRNAVal. This suggests that maintaining regular A-type RNA helix geometry in the acceptor stem is important for proper recognition of tRNAValby valyl-tRNA synthetase.19F NMR also shows that formation of the tRNAVal-valyl-tRNA synthetase complex does not disrupt the first base pair in the acceptor stem, a result different from that reported for the tRNAGln-glutaminyl-tRNA synthetase complex.

Four newly located pseudouridylate residues in Escherichia coli 23S ribosomal RNA are all at the peptidyltransferase center: analysis by the application of a new sequencing technique

A new technique has been developed for the facile location of pseudouridylate (psi) residues in any RNA molecule. The method uses two known modification procedures which in combination uniquely identify U residues which have been converted into psi. The first procedure involves reaction of all U-like and G-like residues with N-cyclohexyl-N'-beta-(4-methylmorpholinium)ethylcarbodiimide p-tosylate (CMC), followed by alkaline removal of all CMC groups except those linked to the N3 of psi. This stops reverse transcription, resulting in a gel band which identifies the U residue. The second procedure is uridine-specific hydrazinolysis which cleaves the RNA chain at all U residues and produces a gel band upon reverse transcription. psi residues, being resistant to hydrazinolysis, are not cleaved and do not stop reverse transcription. This leads to the absence of a band at psi residues. The combined method can also distinguish psi from 5-methyluridine, 4-thiouridine, uridine-5-oxyacetic acid, and 2-thio-5-methylaminomethyluridine as shown by treating rRNA and tRNA species known to contain these modified bases at defined sites. By this procedure, four new sites for psi in Escherichia coli 23S RNA were discovered, and one was disproven. The four new sites are at positions 2457, 2504, 2580, and 2605. The erroneous site is at position 2555. These four new psi residues, which are all in or within 2-3 residues of the peptidyltransferase ring, are thus in a position to play a functional and/or structural role at the peptidyltransferase center.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Fluorine-19 nuclear magnetic resonance as a probe of the solution structure of mutants of 5-fluorouracil-substituted Escherichia coli valine tRNA

In order to utilize 19F nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) to probe the solution structure of Escherichia coli tRNAVal labeled by incorporation of 5-fluorouracil, we have assigned its 19F spectrum. We describe here assignments made by examining the spectra of a series of tRNAVal mutants with nucleotide substitutions for individual 5-fluorouracil residues. The result of base replacements on the structure and function of the tRNA are also characterized. Mutants were prepared by oligonucleotide-directed mutagenesis of a cloned tRNAVal gene, and the tRNAs transcribed in vitro by bacteriophage T7 RNA polymerase. By identifying the missing peak in the 19F NMR spectrum of each tRNA variant we were able to assign resonances from fluorouracil residues in loop and stem regions of the tRNA. As a result of the assignment of FU33, FU34 and FU29, temperature-dependent spectral shifts could be attributed to changes in anticodon loop and stem conformation. Observation of a magnesium ion-dependent splitting of the resonance assigned to FU64 suggested that the T-arm of tRNAVal can exist in two conformations in slow exchange on the NMR time scale. Replacement of most 5-fluorouracil residues in loops and stems had little effect on the structure of tRNAVal; few shifts in the 19F NMR spectrum of the mutant tRNAs were noted. However, replacing the FU29.A41 base-pair in the anticodon stem with C29.G41 induced conformational changes in the anticodon loop as well as in the P-10 loop. Effects of nucleotide substitution on aminoacylation were determined by comparing the Vmax and Km values of tRNAVal mutants with those of the wild-type tRNA. Nucleotide substitution at the 3' end of the anticodon (position 36) reduced the aminoacylation efficiency (Vmax/Km) of tRNAVal by three orders of magnitude. Base replacement at the 5' end of the anticodon (position 34) had only a small negative effect on the aminoacylation efficiency. Substitution of the FU29.A41 base-pair increased the Km value 20-fold, while Vmax remained almost unchanged. The FU4.A69 base-pair in the acceptor stem, could readily be replaced with little effect on the aminoacylation efficiency of E. coli tRNAVal, indicating that this base-pair is not an identity element of the tRNA, as suggested by others.

19F NMR of 5-fluorouracil-substituted transfer RNA transcribed in vitro: resonance assignment of fluorouracil-guanine base pairs

5-Fluorouracil is readily incorporated into active tRNA(Val) transcribed in vitro from a recombinant phagemid containing a synthetic E. coli tRNA(Val) gene. This tRNA has the expected sequence and a secondary and tertiary structure resembling that of native 5-fluorouracil-substituted tRNA(Val), as judged by 19F NMR spectroscopy. To assign resonances in the 19F spectrum, mutant phagemids were constructed having base changes in the tRNA gene. Replacement of fluorouracil in the T-stem with cytosine, converting a FU-G to a C-G base pair, results in the loss of one downfield peak in the 19F NMR spectrum of the mutant tRNA(Val). The spectra of other mutant tRNAs having guanine for adenine substitutions that convert FU-A to FU-G base pairs all have one resonance shifted 4.5 to 5 ppm downfield. These results allow assignment of several 19F resonances and demonstrate that the chemical shift of the 19F signal from base-paired 5-fluorouracil differs considerably between Watson-Crick and wobble geometry.

19F nuclear magnetic resonance as a probe of anticodon structure in 5-fluorouracil-substituted Escherichia coli transfer RNA

The use of 19F nuclear magnetic resonance (n.m.r.) spectroscopy as a probe of anticodon structure has been extended by investigating the effects of tetranucleotide binding to 5-fluorouracil-substituted Escherichia coli tRNA(Val)1 (anticodon FAC). 19F n.m.r. spectra were obtained in the absence and presence of different concentrations of oligonucleotides having the sequence GpUpApX (X = A,G,C,U), which contain the valine codon GpUpA. Structural changes in the tRNA were monitored via the 5-fluorouracil residues located at positions 33 and 34 in the anticodon loop, as well as in all other loops and stems of the molecule. Binding of GpUpApA, which is complementary to the anticodon and the 5'-adjacent FUra 33, shifts two resonances in the 19F spectrum. One, peak H (3.90 p.p.m.), is also shifted by GpUpA and was previously assigned to FUra 34 at the wobble position of the anticodon. The effects of GpUpApA differ from those of GpUpA in that the tetranucleotide induces the downfield shift of a second resonance, peak F (4.5 p.p.m.), in the 19F spectrum of 19F-labeled tRNA(Val)1. Evidence that the codon-containing oligonucleotides bind to the anticodon was obtained from shifts in the methyl proton spectrum of the 6-methyladenosine residue adjacent to the anticodon and from cleavage of the tRNA at the anticodon by RNase H after binding dGpTpApA, a deoxy analog of the ribonucleotide codon. The association constant for the binding of GpUpApA to fluorinated tRNA(Val)1, obtained by Scatchard analysis of the n.m.r. results, is in good agreement with values obtained by other methods. On the basis of these results, we assign peak F in the 19F n.m.r. spectrum of 19F-labeled tRNA(Val)1 to FUra 33. This assignment and the previous assignment of peak H to FUra 34 are supported by the observation that the intensities of peaks F and H in the 19F spectrum of fluorinated tRNA(Val)1 are specifically decreased after partial hydrolysis with nucleass S1 under conditions leading to cleavage in the anticodon loop. The downfield shift of peak F occurs only with adenosine in the 3'-position of the tetranucleotide; binding of GpUpApG, GpUpApC, or GpUpApU results only in the upfield shift of peak H. The possibility is discussed that this base-specific interaction between the 3'-terminal adenosine and the 5-fluorouracil residue at position 33 involves a 5'-stacked conformation of the anticodon loop. Evidence also is presented for a temperature-dependent conformational change in the anticodon loop below the melting temperature of the tRNA.

Mobility of individual 5-fluorouridine residues in 5-fluorouracil-substituted Escherichia coli valine transfer RNA. A 19F nuclear magnetic resonance relaxation study

19F nuclear magnetic resonance (n.m.r.) relaxation parameters of 5-fluorouracil-substituted Escherichia coli tRNA(Val)1 were measured and used to characterize the internal mobility of individual 5-fluorouridine (FUrd) residues in terms of several models of molecular motion. Measured relaxation parameters include the spin-lattice (T1) relaxation time at 282 MHz, the 19F(1H) NOE at 282 MHz, and the spin-spin (T2) relaxation time, estimated from linewidth data at 338 MHz, 282 MHz and 84 MHz. Dipolar and chemical shift anisotropy contributions to the 19F relaxation parameters were determined from the field-dependence of T2. The results demonstrate a large chemical shift anisotropy contribution to the 19F linewidths at 282 and 338 MHz. Analysis of chemical shift anisotropy relaxation data shows that, relative to overall tumbling of the macromolecule, negligible torsional motion occurs about the glycosidic bond of FUrd residues in 19F-labeled tRNA(Val)1, consistent with the maintenance of base-base hydrogen-bond and/or stacking interactions at all fluorouracil residues in the molecule. The dipolar relaxation data are analyzed by using the "two-state jump" and "diffusion in a cone" formalisms. Motional amplitudes (theta) are interpreted as being due to pseudorotational fluctuations within the ribose ring of the fluorinated nucleoside. These amplitudes range from approximately 30 degrees to 60 degrees, assuming a correlation time (tau i,2) of 1.6 ns. By using available 19F n.m.r. assignment data for the 14 FUrd residues in 5-fluorouracil-substituted tRNA(Val)1, these motional amplitudes can be correlated directly with the environmental domain of the residue. Residues located in tertiary and helical structural domains show markedly less motion (theta approximately equal to 30 to 35 degrees) than residues located in loops (theta approximately equal to 45 to 60 degrees). A correlation between residue mobility and solvent exposure is also demonstrated. The amplitudes of internal motion for specific residues agree quite well with those derived from X-ray diffraction and molecular dynamics data for yeast tRNA(Phe).

Fluorine-19 nuclear magnetic resonance study of codon-anticodon interaction in 5-fluorouracil-substituted E. coli transfer RNAs

Codon-anticodon interaction was investigated in fully active 5-fluorouracil-substituted E. coli tRNAVal1 (anticodon FAC) by 19F NMR spectroscopy. Binding of the codon GpUpA results in the upfield shift of a 19F resonance at 3.9 ppm in the central region of the 19F NMR spectrum, whereas trinucleotides not complementary to the anticodon have no effect. The same 19F resonance shifts upfield upon formation of an anticodon-anticodon dimer between the 19F-labeled tRNA and E. coli tRNATyr2 (anticodon QUA). These results permit assignment of the peak at 3.9 ppm to the 5-fluorouracil at position 34 in the anticodon of fluorouracil-substituted tRNAVal1. The methionine codon ApUpG also causes a sequence-specific upfield shift of a peak in the central part of the 19F NMR spectrum of fluorinated E. coli tRNAMetm. However, ApUpG has no effect on the 19F spectrum of 19F-labeled E. coli tRNAMetf, indicating possible conformational differences between the anticodon loop of initiator and chain-elongating methionine tRNAs. 19F NMR experiments detect no binding of CpGpApA to the complementary FpFpCpG (replaces Tp psi pCpG) in the T-loop of 5-fluorouracil-substituted tRNAVal1, in the presence or absence of codon, suggesting that the tertiary interactions between the T- and D-loops are not disrupted by codon-anticodon interactions.

Characterization of the fluorodihydrouracil substituent in 5-fluorouracil-containing Escherichia coli transfer RNA

The fluorodihydrouridine derivative previously detected in one of two isoaccepting forms of FUra-substituted Escherichia coli tRNAMetf has been further characterized. This substituent is responsible for the 19F resonance observed 15 ppm upfield from free FUra (= 0 ppm) in the high resolution 19F-NMR spectra of FUra-substituted tRNA purified by chromatography on DEAE-cellulose, at pH 8.9, to remove normal tRNA. Similar highfield 19F signals have now been observed in the spectra of two other purified fluorinated E. coli tRNAs, tRNAMetm and tRNAVal1, as well as in unfractionated tRNA, indicating the widespread occurrence of the constituent. Comparison with 19F spectrum of the model compound 5'-deoxy-5-fluoro-5,6-dihydrouridine (dH56FUrd) (delta FUra = -31.4 ppm; JHF = 48 Hz) indicates that the substituent does not contain an intact fluorodihydrouridine ring. dH56FUrd is considerably more alkali labile than 5,6-dihydrouridine (H56Urd). At pH 8.9, where H56Urd is stable, dH56FUrd is degraded to a derivative, presumably a fluoroureidopropionic acid, with a 19F resonance at - 15.7 ppm that nearly coincides with the upfield peak in the spectrum of pH 8.9-treated tRNA. The 19F-NMR spectrum of fluorinated tRNA, not exposed to pH 8.9, exhibits two peaks 31 and 32 ppm upfield of FUra, in place of the 19F signal at - 15 ppm. Hydrolysis of this tRNA with RNAase T2 produces a sharp doublet 33 ppm upfield (JHF = 45 Hz). Similarities of the 19F chemical shift and coupling constant to those of dH56FUrd, allows assignment of the peak at -33 ppm to an intact fluorodihydrouridine residue in the tRNA. Our results demonstrate that FUra residues incorporated into E. coli tRNA at sites normally occupied by dihydrouridine can be recognized by tRNA-modifying enzymes and reduced to fluorodihydrouridine. This substituent is labile at moderately alkaline pH values and undergoes ring-opening during purification of the tRNA.

On the role of ribosylthymine in prokaryotic tRNA function

tRNAPhe and tRNALys were isolated from an Escherichia coli K12 mutant deficient in ribosylthymine (rT) and from the wild-type strain. The sequence G-rT-psi-C which is common to loop IV of practically all tRNAs used in the elongation cycle of protein synthesis reads G-U-psi-C in the tRNAs of the mutant strain. The purified tRNAs were compared in various steps of protein biosynthesis. The poly(U)-dependent poly(Phe) synthesis performed with purified Phe-tRNAPhe and purified elongation factors showed no dependence on the presence or absence of ribosylthymine in the respective tRNAs. In contrast, the corresponding poly(A)-dependent poly(Lys) synthesis was markedly increased when Lys-tRNALys lacking rT was used. The analysis of individual functional steps of the poly(A)-dependent elongation cycle demonstrated that the absence of rT reduced the binding to the A-site and improved the translocation reaction, whereas the formation of the ternary complex EF-Tu . GTP . aa-tRNA as well as both tRNA binding to the P-site and the peptidyltransferase reaction remained unaffected. The presence of U in place of rT in tRNA increases the misincorporation of leucine in an optimized poly(U)/poly(Phe) system from about 3 in 10 000 to 3 in 1000. Our results are in agreement with the view that rT is involved in tRNA binding to the A-site in contrast to the P-site, and suggested that the presence of rT in tRNA improves the fidelity of the decoding process at the A-site of the ribosome.

Replacement of pseudouridine in transfer RNA by 5-fluorouridine does not affect the ability to stimulate the synthesis of guanosine 5'-triphosphate 3'-diphosphate

The requirement for ribothymidine and pseudouridine in the TpsiCG loop of tRNA for its activity in the ribosome and tRNA-stimulated synthesis of guanosine 5'-triphosphate 3'-diphosphate (pppGpp) by stringent factor has been tested by the use of a purified tRNAPhe (883 pmol of phenylalanine incorporated/A260 unit) in which 92% of the pseudouridine, 98% of the ribothymidine, 98% of the dihydrouridine, and 88% of the uridines were substituted by 5-fluorouridine. This tRNA was quantitatively as active as control tRNA in inducing pppGpp synthesis. With loose-couple ribosomes, the concentration of tRNA needed to give half-maximal reaction was 0.07 micrometer for both normal and fluorouridine-substituted tRNA, with vacant tight-couple ribosomes it was 0.05 micrometer, and with tight couples carrying poly(Phe)-tRNA at the P site the value was 0.02 micrometer. These results show that at the level of intact tRNA there is no special requirement for modified bases in the TpsiCG loop of tRNA in the synthesis of pppGpp.

Increasing content of poly A(+) mRNA of serum-stimulated cells in the absence of ribosome synthesis

When 3T6 cells undergo a serum-induced transition from resting to growing state, the number of ribosomes and the amounts of mRNA increase as the cells prepare for DNA synthesis. We have examined the effect of preventing ribosome synthesis during this transition. When resting cells are stimulated to grow in the presence of 5-fluorouridine, mRNA accumulates normally during the first eight hours, though new ribosome formation is completely blocked by the drug. At later times, mRNA continues to accumulate, but at a reduced rate. The ratio of poly A(+) mRNA to rRNA increases from the value characteristic of resting 3T6 (1.8%) to that of growing 3T6 (2.7%) by five hours, and continues to increase to abnormally high values after this time. Although labelling of tRNA is not affected after brief exposure of cells to fluorouridine, the drug prevents the later accumulation of tRNA that ordinarily occurs following serum stimulation of resting cells. This failure of accumulation is not the result of increased lability of fluorinated tRNA, but is probably due to failure of the transcription rate of pre-tRNA to increase. It is possible that this effect might be due to a regulatory system coupling tRNA content to ribosome content. In cultures stimulated with serum in the presence of fluorouridine the rate of protein synthesis increases with poly A(+) mRNA content during the first eight hours; it then fails to increase further, possibly because ribosomes become rate-limiting.

Photoaffinity labeling of the ribosomal A site with S-(p-azidophenacyl)valyl-tRNA

S-(p-Azidophenacyl)valyl-tRNA, an analog of valyl-tRNA which has a photoaffinity label attached to its 4-thiouridine residue, was bound to the ribosomal A site at 10 mM Mg2+. Binding was stimulated 25-fold by the presence of elongation factor EFTu. Photoactivation of the p-azidophenacyl group by irradiation resulted in covalent linking of 6% of the noncovalently bound tRNA to the ribosomes. Covalent linking was dependent on the simultaneous presence of ribosomes, poly(U2,G),EFTu.GTP, required irradiation, and did not occur when S-(phenacyl)valyl-tRNA, a nonphotolyzable analog, replaced S-(p-azidophenacyl)valyl-tRNA. The attached tRNA was distributed approximately equally between both the 30S and 50S subunits. At the 30S subunit, 30% of the tRNA was bound to protein while 70% was linked to 16S RNA. At the 50S subunit, however, negligible binding to the 23S RNA was observed. More than 90% of the tRNA was attached to low molecular weight material according to sodium dodecyl sulfate-sucrose gradient analysis, and more than 87% of this fraction consisted of tRNA-protein complexes as assayed by phenol solubility and electrophoretic mobility before and after protease treatment. These results, in conjunction with our previous report (I. Schwartz and J Ofengand (1974), Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 71, 3951) which showed that covalent linking of this same tRNA derivative at the ribosomal P site resulted in attachment solely to the 16S RNA, demonstrate that 16S, but not 23S or 5S rRNA, is an important component of the tRNA binding site in the region of the 4-thiouridine residue and furthermore show that ribosomal A and P sites are topologically distinct.