Physical mapping of Qbeta replicase binding sites on Qbeta RNA

Contribution of silent mutations to thermal adaptation of RNA bacteriophage Qβ

Changes in protein function and other biological properties, such as RNA structure, are crucial for adaptation of organisms to novel or inhibitory environments. To investigate how mutations that do not alter amino acid sequence may be positively selected, we performed a thermal adaptation experiment using the single-stranded RNA bacteriophage Qβ in which the culture temperature was increased from 37.2°C to 41.2°C and finally to an inhibitory temperature of 43.6°C in a stepwise manner in three independent lines. Whole-genome analysis revealed 31 mutations, including 14 mutations that did not result in amino acid sequence alterations, in this thermal adaptation. Eight of the 31 mutations were observed in all three lines. Reconstruction and fitness analyses of Qβ strains containing only mutations observed in all three lines indicated that five mutations that did not result in amino acid sequence changes but increased the amplification ratio appeared in the course of adaptation to growth at 41.2°C. Moreover, these mutations provided a suitable genetic background for subsequent mutations, altering the fitness contribution from deleterious to beneficial. These results clearly showed that mutations that do not alter the amino acid sequence play important roles in adaptation of this single-stranded RNA virus to elevated temperature.

IMPORTANCE

Recent studies using whole-genome analysis technology suggested the importance of mutations that do not alter the amino acid sequence for adaptation of organisms to novel environmental conditions. It is necessary to investigate how these mutations may be positively selected and to determine to what degree such mutations that do not alter amino acid sequences contribute to adaptive evolution. Here, we report the roles of these silent mutations in thermal adaptation of RNA bacteriophage Qβ based on experimental evolution during which Qβ showed adaptation to growth at an inhibitory temperature. Intriguingly, four synonymous mutations and one mutation in the untranslated region that spread widely in the Qβ population during the adaptation process at moderately high temperature provided a suitable genetic background to alter the fitness contribution of subsequent mutations from deleterious to beneficial at a higher temperature.

The three faces of riboviral spontaneous mutation: spectrum, mode of genome replication, and mutation rate

Riboviruses (RNA viruses without DNA replication intermediates) are the most abundant pathogens infecting animals and plants. Only a few riboviral infections can be controlled with antiviral drugs, mainly because of the rapid appearance of resistance mutations. Little reliable information is available concerning i) kinds and relative frequencies of mutations (the mutational spectrum), ii) mode of genome replication and mutation accumulation, and iii) rates of spontaneous mutation. To illuminate these issues, we developed a model in vivo system based on phage Qß infecting its natural host, Escherichia coli. The Qß RT gene encoding the Read-Through protein was used as a mutation reporter. To reduce uncertainties in mutation frequencies due to selection, the experimental Qß populations were established after a single cycle of infection and selection against RT⁻ mutants during phage growth was ameliorated by plasmid-based RT complementation in trans. The dynamics of Qß genome replication were confirmed to reflect the linear process of iterative copying (the stamping-machine mode). A total of 32 RT mutants were detected among 7,517 Qß isolates. Sequencing analysis of 45 RT mutations revealed a spectrum dominated by 39 transitions, plus 4 transversions and 2 indels. A clear template•primer mismatch bias was observed: A•C>C•A>U•G>G•U> transversion mismatches. The average mutation rate per base replication was ≈9.1×10⁻⁶ for base substitutions and ≈2.3×10⁻⁷ for indels. The estimated mutation rate per genome replication, μ_g, was ≈0.04 (or, per phage generation, ≈0.08), although secondary RT mutations arose during the growth of some RT mutants at a rate about 7-fold higher, signaling the possible impact of transitory bouts of hypermutation. These results are contrasted with those previously reported for other riboviruses to depict the current state of the art in riboviral mutagenesis.

Viral disease is a subject of major concern in public health. Diseases produced by riboviruses (RNA viruses sensu stricto) represent a special urgency, because these viruses display an exceptional capability to generate resistance mutations against antiviral drugs. Unfortunately, little is known about the rate and nature of spontaneous mutation in riboviruses. Thus, characterization of their mutation process may be helpful in the development of improved ways to counteract riboviral diseases. In this study, we investigated the mutation process in vivo of a model ribovirus, the bacteriophage Qß, focusing on three key aspects: i) the kinds and relative frequencies of mutations, ii) the mode of genome replication, and iii) the rate of spontaneous mutation. Our results, combined with other information about riboviral mutagenesis, depict a ribovirus mutation spectrum largely dominated by transitions, a predominantly linear mode of genome replication, and a mutation rate per genome replication on the order of 0.04 for bacteriophages and plant viruses but perhaps an order of magnitude higher for mammalian riboviruses.

Visualization of the reconstituted FRGY2-mRNA complexes by electron microscopy

Xenopus oocytes store large quantities of translationally dormant mRNA in the cytoplasm as storage messenger ribonucleoprotein particles (mRNPs). The Y-box proteins, mRNP3 and FRGY2/mRNP4, are major RNA binding components of maternal storage mRNPs in oocytes. In this study, we show that the FRGY2 proteins form complexes with mRNA, which leads to mRNA stabilization and translational repression. Visualization of the FRGY2-mRNA complexes by electron microscopy reveals that FRGY2 packages mRNA into a compact RNP. Our results are consistent with a model that the Y-box proteins function in packaging of mRNAs to store them stably for a long time in the oocyte cytoplasm.

A branched stem-loop structure in the M-site of bacteriophage Qbeta RNA is important for template recognition by Qbeta replicase holoenzyme

An internal site on bacteriophage Qbeta RNA, the M-site (map position 2545 to 2867), was recently shown by us to be required for the efficient initiation of minus strand synthesis by Qbeta replicase. In a more detailed mutational analysis, we show here that the essential elements within the M-site consist of two successive stem-loop structures followed by a bulge loop of unpaired purines, located at nucleotides 2696 to 2754 on the tip of a long, imperfectly base-paired stalk. Mutational changes affecting the sequences of paired or unpaired nucleotides in this segment reduced the template efficiency only mildly. The only severe effects were observed when one of the helical stems or the unpaired bulge was completely deleted or substantially shortened. We conclude that the three-dimensional backbone arrangement of these three elements constitutes the feature recognized by replicase. The role of the long stalk remains undetermined, because mutations that either stabilized or disrupted its base-pairing barely affected template activity, and even deletion of a major portion of one of its strands did not cause complete inactivation. Earlier evidence had implicated protein S1 (the alpha subunit of replicase) as the mediator of the M-site interaction. The lack of an active M-site on the Qbeta RNA template has the same quantitative and qualitative effects on template recognition as the absence of the S1 protein from replicase in the presence of wild-type RNA. We therefore believe that the M-site interaction explains most of the role of S1 protein in the replication of Qbeta RNA by replicase.

Probing RNA-protein interactions using pyrene-labeled oligodeoxynucleotides: Qbeta replicase efficiently binds small RNAs by recognizing pyrimidine residues

Binding of small RNAs by the RNA-dependent RNA polymerase of coliphage Qbeta was studied utilizing a fluorometric assay. A DNA oligonucleotide probe of sequence 5'-d(TTTTTCC) was 5'-end-labeled with pyrene. In this construct, the proximal thymine residues efficiently quench the fluorophore emission in solution. Upon stoichiometric binding of one probe per polymerase molecule, the pyrene steady-state fluorescence increases by two orders of magnitude, the fluorescence anisotropy increases, and a long fluorescence lifetime component of 140 ns appears. With addition of replicable RNA, steady-state fluorescence decreases in a concentration dependent manner and the long lifetime component is lost. This observation most likely reflects displacement of the pyrene-labeled probe from the proposed nucleic acid binding site II of Qbeta replicase. The effect was utilized to access binding affinities of different RNAs to this site in a reverse titration assay format. In 10 mM sodium phosphate (pH 7.0), 100 mM NaCl, at 16 degrees C, equilibrium dissociation constants for different template midi- and minivariant RNAs were calculated to be in the nanomolar range. In general, the minus and plus strands, concomitantly synthesized by Qbeta replicase during replication, exhibited discriminative affinities, while their hybrid bound less efficiently than either of the single strands. Different non-replicable tRNAs also bound to the polymerase with comparable dissociation constants. By titration with DNA homo-oligonucleotides it was shown that the probed site on Qbeta replicase does not require a 2' hydroxyl group for binding nucleic acids, but recognizes pyrimidine residues. Its interaction with thymine is lost in an A.T base-pair, while that with cytosine is retained after Watson-Crick base-pairing. These findings can explain the affinities of RNA-Qbeta replicase interactions reported here and in earlier investigations. The sensitivity of the described fluorometric assay allows detection of RNA amplification by Qbeta replicase in real-time.

Altered 3'-terminal RNA structure in phage Qbeta adapted to host factor-less Escherichia coli

The RNA phage Qbeta requires for the replication of its genome an RNA binding protein called Qbeta host factor or Hfq protein. Our previous results suggested that this protein mediates the access of replicase to the 3'-end of the Qbeta plus strand RNA. Here we report the results of an evolutionary experiment in which phage Qbeta was adapted to an Escherichia coli Q13 host strain with an inactivated host factor (hfq) gene. This strain initially produced phage at a titer approximately 10,000-fold lower than the wild-type strain and with minute plaque morphology, but after 12 growth cycles, phage titer and plaque size had evolved to levels near those of the wild-type host. RNAs isolated from adapted Qbeta mutants were efficient templates for replicase without host factor in vitro. Electron microscopy showed that mutant RNAs, in contrast to wild-type RNA, efficiently interacted with replicase at the 3'-end in the absence of host factor. The same set of four mutations in the 3'-terminal third of the genome was found in several independently evolved phage clones. One mutation disrupts the base pairing of the 3'-terminal CCCOH sequence, suggesting that the host factor stimulates activity of the wild-type RNA template by melting out its 3'-end.

Translational activation in coliphage Qbeta: on a polycistronic messenger RNA, repression of one gene can activate translation of another

We present evidence for translational activation of the Qbeta coliphage maturation cistron, mediated by the presence of Qbeta replicase. This activation does not require RNA replication, translation of a second gene, or any direct protein-RNA binding at the maturation gene initiation site. Our data support a model in which the Qbeta maturation gene remains translationally "off" by two means: (1) the thermodynamic stability of an RNA structure that greatly discourages, but does not eliminate, ribosome access at the maturation start site; and (2) the presence of the stronger, proximal coat gene ribosome binding site. Moreover, maturation gene expression is switched "on" when ribosome entry at the coat initiation site, present on the same polycistronic RNA molecule, is repressed by Qbeta replicase, thereby allowing ribosomes to compete for the weaker, upstream maturation start site.

Recognition of bacteriophage Qbeta plus strand RNA as a template by Qbeta replicase: role of RNA interactions mediated by ribosomal proteins S1 and host factor

RNA-protein interactions between bacteriophage Qbeta plus strand RNA and the components of the Qbeta replicase system were studied by deletion analysis. Internal, 5'-terminal and 3'-terminal deletions were assayed for template activity with replicase in vitro. Of the two internal binding sites previously described for replicase, we found that the S-site (map position 1247 to 1346) could be deleted without any significant effect on template activity, whereas deletion of the M-site (map position 2545 to 2867) resulted in a strong inactivation and a high salt sensitivity of the residual activity. Binding complexes of the deletion mutant RNAs with the different proteins involved in Qbeta RNA replication were analysed by electron microscopy. The formation of looped complex structures, previously reported and explained as simultaneous interactions with replicase at the S and the M-site, was abolished by deleting the S-site but, surprisingly, not by deleting the M-site. The same types of complexes observed with replicase were also formed with purified protein S1 (the alpha subunit of replicase), suggesting that these internal interactions with Qbeta RNA are mediated by the S1 protein. The Qbeta host factor, a protein required for the template activity of the Qbeta plus strand, was reported earlier to form similar complexes by binding to the S and M-sites (or adjacent sites) and in addition to the 3'-end, resulting in double-looped structures. The patterns of looped complexes observed with the deletion mutant RNAs suggest that the binding of host factor might not involve the S and M-sites themselves but adjacent downstream sites. An additional internal host factor interaction near map position 2300 was detected with several mutant RNAs. Qbeta RNA molecules with 3'-truncations formed 3'-terminal loops with similar efficiency as wild-type RNA, indicating that recognition of the 3'-end by host factor is not dependent on a specific 3'-terminal base sequence.

A new method for the routine spreading of DNA in protein-free conditions

Electron microscopic studies of DNA are hampered by difficulties encountered with the spreading of DNA under protein-free conditions. The established and currently popular technique of spreading DNA on carbon membranes treated by glow discharge in an atmosphere of pentylamine is limited with regard to its reproducibility and the proper distribution of spread molecules on the surface of the membranes. A new, reliable, and highly reproducible technique using tri-L-(dimethylaminomethyl)phenol (DMP 30), a promotor factor for spreading circular DNA, linear DNA, and DNA-protein complexes, is described in this paper. Monolayers of DMP 30 are formed at the air-water interface by a microdiffusion procedure on droplets. DNA molecules that diffuse on this monolayer can easily be picked up on hydrophobic carbon membranes. This method, which is easy, reproducible, and fast, will facilitate electron microscopic studies of DNA-protein interactions.

Rat gastric mucin is synthesized and secreted exclusively as filamentous oligomers

Oligomeric gastric mucin was isolated from the fundic part of the rat stomach. Previously we have shown by biochemical analysis that this oligomeric mucin consists of disulphide-linked homo-oligomers, which contain no other covalently attached proteins [Dekker, Aelmans & Strous (1991) Biochem. J. 277, 423-427]. Electron-microscopic images of the oligomeric mucin revealed a heterogenous population of long filamentous molecules of 300-3000 nm length. After reduction and carboxymethylation the monomeric mucins displayed a length distribution with a single peak at about 279 nm. Length-distribution analysis of oligomeric molecules with length up to 1000 nm revealed three subpopulations with one, two or three times the length of the monomeric mucin. The oligomers displayed small globular domains of about 15 nm, which were equally spaced along the molecule's length. As the distance between these globular domains was similar to the monomer length, these domains most likely indicate attachment sites of the monomers. These results show that the mucin monomers attached end-to-end in the oligomer. Biosynthesis of the mucin oligomers was studied by labelling of stomach explants in vitro with [35S]methionine, [3H]galactose or [35S]sulphate and subsequent immunoprecipitation of the mucin with a specific antiserum. Analysis by electrophoresis and gel filtration revealed that the oligomerization takes place by formation of disulphide bonds between the 300 kDa mucin precursors. The mucin was exclusively synthesized and secreted as fully glycosylated oligomers, as neither precursor proteins nor monomeric mucin were detected in the culture medium. A model for the biosynthesis of rat gastric mucin is proposed in which the filamentous mucin monomers are linked end-to-end by disulphide bonds.

Secondary structure of the central region of bacteriophage MS2 RNA. Conservation and biological significance

The RNA of the Escherichia coli RNA phages is highly structured with 75% of the nucleotides estimated to take part in base-pairing. We have used enzymatic and chemical sensitivity of nucleotides, phylogenetic sequence comparison and the phenotypes of constructed mutants to develop a secondary structure model for the central region (900 nucleotides) of the group I phage MS2. The RNA folds into a number of, mostly irregular, helices and is further condensed by several long-distance interactions. There is substantial conservation of helices between the related groups I and II, attesting to the relevance of discrete RNA folding. In general, the secondary structure is thought to be needed to prevent annealing of plus and minus strand and to confer protection against RNase. Superimposed, however, are features required to regulate translation and replication. The MS2 RNA section studied here contains three translational start sites, as well as the binding sites for the coat protein and the replicase enzyme. Considering the density of helices along the RNA, it is not unexpected to find that all these sites lie in helical regions. This fact, however, does not mean that these sites are recognized as secondary structure elements by their interaction partners. This holds true only for the coat protein binding site. The other four sites function in the unfolded state and the stability of the helix in which they are contained serves to negatively control their accessibility. Mutations that stabilize helices containing ribosomal binding sites reduce their efficiency and vice versa. Comparison of homologous helices in different phage RNAs indicates that base substitutions have occurred in such a way that the thermodynamic stability of the helix is maintained. The evolution of individual helices shows several distinct size-reduction patterns. We have observed codon deletions from loop areas and shortening of hairpins by base-pair deletions from either the bottom, the middle or the top of stem structures. Evidence for the coaxial stacking of some helical segments is discussed.

Analysis of the complete nucleotide sequence of the group IV RNA coliphage SP

We report the nucleotide sequence of the Group IV RNA bacteriophage SP. The entire sequence is 4276 nucleotides long. Four cistrons have been identified by comparison with the related Group III phage Q beta. The maturation protein contains 449 amino acids, the coat protein contains 131 amino acids, the read-through protein contains 330 amino acids and the replicase beta-subunit contains 575 amino acids. SP is 59 nucleotides longer than Q beta. We have analyzed both sequence and structural conservation between SP and Q beta and shown that the sequences for the coat and central region of the replicase are strongly conserved between the two genomes. We also show that the S and M replicase binding sites of Q beta are strongly conserved in SP. Interestingly, the base composition of SP and Q beta differ significantly from one another, and most of the differences can be accounted for by a strong preponderance of U in the third position of each codon of Q beta relative to SP. We also compare conserved hairpins associated with potential coat protein and replicase binding sites.

Autocatalytic replication of a recombinant RNA

We demonstrate that a heterologous RNA sequence can be copied in vitro by Q beta replicase when it is inserted into a naturally occurring Q beta replicase template. A recombinant RNA was constructed by inserting decaadenylic acid between nucleotides 63 and 64 of MDV-1 (+) RNA, using phage T4 RNA ligase. The insert was located away from regions of the template known to be required for the binding of the replicase and for the initiation of product strand synthesis. To minimize the disruption of template structure, we inserted the heterologous sequence into a hairpin loop on the exterior of the molecule. Q beta replicase copied this recombinant RNA in vitro, and the complementary product strands served as templates for the synthesis of additional copies of the original recombinant RNA. The reaction was therefore autocatalytic and the amount of recombinant RNA increased exponentially. A 300-fold amplification of the recombinant RNA occurred within nine minutes. Insertion of biologically significant RNAs into the MDV-1 RNA sequence should allow them to be replicated autocatalytically.

Differential binding of RNA polymerase to the pRM and pR promoters of bacteriophage lambda

Escherichia coli RNA polymerase binding to the promoters pR and pRM of bacteriophage lambda was visualized and quantitated by electron microscopy. Although the two promoters are located close together in the phage genome, their proximity to the end of an 889-bp HaeIII DNA fragment made it possible to position binary complexes within 18 bp (2%) intervals. Thus, polymerase binding to pR and pRM could be distinguished by comparing the locations of binary complexes formed with wild-type and mutant (prm-) DNA at 37 degrees and 15 degrees C. We found that at 37 degrees C, RNA polymerase bound primarily to pR, while at 15 degrees C the efficiency of binding was the same at pRM as at pR. In addition, at 15 degrees C the overall efficiency of binding was significantly reduced relative to that at 37 degrees C. When the enzyme was incubated with prm- DNA, binding to pRM was reduced at both temperatures, as expected. Reduced binding to pRM was accompanied by an increase in binding to pR, apparently as a consequence of the low enzyme-to-DNA ratios used in these experiments.

The interaction of the A and A* proteins of bacteriophage phi X174 with single-stranded and double-stranded phi X DNA in vitro

The binding of the bacteriophage phi X 174-coded A and A* proteins to single-stranded (ssDNA) and double-stranded (dsDNA ) phi X DNA was studied by electron microscopy. The interaction of the A* protein with ssDNA and dsDNA was also studied by sedimentation velocity centrifugation. It was shown that the binding of the A and A* proteins to ssDNA occurs in a non-cooperative manner and requires no or very little sequence specificity under the conditions used here. Both protein-ssDNA complexes have the same compact structure caused by intrastrand cross-linking through the interaction of protein molecules with separate parts of the ssDNA molecule. The A protein does not bind to phi X dsDNA in the absence of divalent cations. The A* protein does bind to dsDNA, although it has a strong preference for binding to ssDNA. The structure of the A* protein-dsDNA complexes is different from that of the A* protein-ssDNA complexes, as the former have a rosette-like structure caused by protein-protein interactions. High ionic strengths favour the formation of large condensed aggregates.

DNA electron microscopy

In recent years DNA electron microscopy has become a tool of increasing interest in the fields of molecular genetics and molecular and cell biology. Together with the development of in vitro recombination and DNA cloning, new electron microscope techniques have been developed with the aim of studying the structural and functional organization of genetic material. The most important methods are based on nucleic acid hybridizations: DNA-DNA hybridization (heteroduplex, D-loop), RNA-DNA hybridization (R-loop), or combinations of both (R-hybrid). They allow both qualitative and quantitative analysis of gene organization, position and extension of homology regions, and characterization of transcription. The reproducibility and resolution of these methods make it possible to map a specific DNA region within 50 to 100 nucleotides. Therefore they have become a prerequisite for determining regions of interest for subsequent nucleotide sequencing. Special methods have been developed also for the analysis of protein-DNA interaction: e.g., direct visualization of specific protein-DNA complexes (enzymes, regulatory proteins), and analysis of structures with higher complexity (chromatin, transcription complexes).

Q beta replicase template specificity: different templates require different GTP concentrations for initiation

Qbeta replicase is notable for its high degree of template specificity. It has been shown to transcribe Qbeta RNA and synthetic polymers containing cytidylate. However, other natural RNAs are not transcribed unless Mn2+ ions are present. The enzyme initiates all RNA synthesis with GTP. In this report it is shown that Qbeta replicase can transcribe heterologous natural RNA species in the absence of Mn2+ if sufficient GTP is present. Each RNA tested requires a different GTP concentration for initiation. These results indicate that the site for the initiating nucleoside triphosphate on Qbeta replicase is strongly influenced by the template. It is proposed that the high degree of template specificity is a consequence of the fact that different templates induce initiation sites with varying affinities for GTP. Two lines of evidence support this idea. First, Mn2+ ions, which reduce template specificity, reduce the concentration of GTP required for initiation. Second, high ionic strength, which decreases transcription of all templates except Qbeta RNA, increases the GTP requirement. The possibility is considered that variable promoter or ribosome binding site strengths could result from a mechanism similar to that proposed here.

A relationship between DNA helix stability and recognition sites for RNA polymerase

The RNA polymerase binding sites on the DNA of (i) the aroE-trkA-spc segment of the Escherichia coli genome, (ii) transposon Tn3, (iii) plasmid ColE1, and (iv) coliphage lambda were mapped by electron microscopy, with the use of the BAC technique; these maps were compared with the maps of the early-melting regions for the same genomes. The results indicate that in all these cases the binding sites for the E. coli RNA polymerase lie preferentially in the early melting regions of DNA. These data indicate that helix stability may be an important feature of the multipartite nature of the promoter structure.

Refined molecular weights for phage, viral and ribosomal RNA

The RNAs of the Escherichia coli bacteriophages MS2 and Qbeta as well as E. coli 16S ribosomal RNA were examined under identical conditions by electron microscopy using the protein-free benzyldimethylalkylammonium chloride (BAC) spreading technique. From the contour length ratios of the RNAs and the known number of nucleotides for MS2, the chain lengths for Qbeta RNA and 16S RNA were found to be 4790 +/- 150 and 1645 +/- 55 nucleotides. Correcting for the base composition of Qbeta RNA the molecular weight of the Na salt of this RNA is (1.64 +/- 0.06) . 10(6) daltons. Since published values on the relative lengths of Qbeta RNA and several other homogeneous RNAs (E. coli 23S rRNA, E. Coli bacteriophage R17 and f2 RNAs, Pseudomonas aeruginosa phage PP7 RNA and Newcastle disease virus RNA) are available, we are able to calculate the approximate number of nucleotides for these useful standards.