Messenger RNA stability in Dictyostelium discoideum: does poly(A) have a regulatory role?

Tales of Detailed Poly(A) Tails

Poly(A) tails are non-templated additions of adenosines at the 3' ends of most eukaryotic mRNAs. In the nucleus, these RNAs are co-transcriptionally cleaved at a poly(A) site and then polyadenylated before being exported to the cytoplasm. In the cytoplasm, poly(A) tails play pivotal roles in the translation and stability of the mRNA. One challenge in studying poly(A) tails is that they are difficult to sequence and accurately measure. However, recent advances in sequencing technology, computational algorithms, and other assays have enabled a more detailed look at poly(A) tail length genome-wide throughout many developmental stages and organisms. With the help of these advances, our understanding of poly(A) tail length has evolved over the past 5 years with the recognition that highly expressed genes can have short poly(A) tails and the elucidation of the seemingly contradictory roles for poly(A)-binding protein (PABP) in facilitating both protection and deadenylation.

Short poly(A) tails are a conserved feature of highly expressed genes

Poly(A) tails are important elements in mRNA translation and stability. However, recent genome-wide studies concluded that poly(A) tail length was generally not associated with translational efficiency in non-embryonic cells. To investigate if poly(A) tail size might be coupled to gene expression in an intact organism, we used an adapted TAIL-seq protocol to measure poly(A) tails in Caenorhabditis elegans. Surprisingly, we found that well-expressed transcripts contain relatively short, well-defined tails. This attribute appears dependent on translational efficiency, as transcripts enriched for optimal codons and ribosome association had the shortest tail sizes, while non-coding RNAs retained long tails. Across eukaryotes, short tails were a feature of abundant and well-translated mRNAs. Although this seems to contradict the dogma that deadenylation induces translational inhibition and mRNA decay, it instead suggests that well-expressed mRNAs accumulate with pruned tails that accommodate a minimal number of poly(A) binding proteins, which may be ideal for protective and translational functions.

Brain non-adenylated mRNAs

Most eukaryotic messenger RNA (mRNA) species contain a 3'-poly(A) tract. The histone mRNAs are a notable exception although a subclass of histone-encoding mRNAs is polyadenylated. A class of mRNAs lacking a poly(A) tail would be expected to be less stable than poly(A)+ mRNAs and might, like the histones, have a half-life that varied in response to changes in the intracellular milieu. Brain mRNA exhibits an unusually high degree of sequence complexity; studies published ten years ago suggested that a large component of this complexity might be present in a poly(A)- mRNA population that was expressed postnatally. The question of the existence of a complex class of poly(A)- brain mRNAs is particularly tantalizing in light of the heterogeneity of brain cells and the possibility that the stability of these poly(A)- mRNAs might vary with changes in synaptic function, changing hormonal stimulation or with other modulations of neuronal function. The mRNA complexity analyses, although intriguing, did not prove the existence of the complex class of poly(A)- brain mRNAs. The observed mRNA complexity could have resulted from a variety of artifacts, discussed in more detail below. Several attempts have been made to clone members of this class of mRNA. This search for specific poly(A)- brain mRNAs has met with only limited success. Changes in mRNA polyadenylation state do occur in brain in response to specific physiologic stimuli; however, both the role of polyadenylation and de-adenylation in specific neuronal activities and the existence and significance of poly(A)- mRNAs in brain remain unclear.

High-performance affinity chromatography of messenger RNA

A 50-mer of thymidylic acid, (dT)50, was coupled to silica inside prepacked columns using the N-hydroxysuccinimide chemistry. The resulting (dT)50-silica columns were used to resolve oligomers of adenylic acid, (dA)19-24, and to separate poly(A) mRNA (messenger RNA) from Saccharomyces. Oligomers which differed in length by a single nucleotide base were readily resolved. Using either (dT)50- or (dT)18-silica, poly(A) mRNA could be purified in as little as 8 min. The poly(A) mRNA isolated appeared to be full length and could be used directly for T4 RNA ligase and RNAse A and T1 enzymatic reactions. The (dT)50-silica column was used to fractionate total poly(A) mRNA by tail length. While the separation was primarily due to poly(A) tail length, most fractions appeared to contain multiple tail lengths. Whether this represents an intrinsic feature of the RNA or a limitation of the method is discussed. These studies show that polynucleotides in the kilobase size range can be separated rapidly and with good resolution on DNA-silica.

mRNA poly(A) tail, a 3' enhancer of translational initiation

To evaluate the hypothesis that the 3' poly(A) tract of mRNA plays a role in translational initiation, we constructed derivatives of pSP65 which direct the in vitro synthesis of mRNAs with different poly(A) tail lengths and compared, in reticulocyte extracts, the relative efficiencies with which such mRNAs were translated, degraded, recruited into polysomes, and assembled into messenger ribonucleoproteins or intermediates in the translational initiation pathway. Relative to mRNAs which were polyadenylated, we found that nonpolyadenylated [poly(A)-]mRNAs had a reduced translational capacity which was not due to an increase in their decay rates, but was attributable to a reduction in their efficiency of recruitment into polysomes. The defect in poly(A)- mRNAs affected a late step in translational initiation, was distinct from the phenotype associated with cap-deficient mRNAs, and resulted in a reduced ability to form 80S initiation complexes. Moreover, poly(A) added in trans inhibited translation from capped polyadenylated mRNAs but stimulated translation from capped poly(A)- mRNAs. We suggest that the presence of a 3' poly(A) tail may facilitate the binding of an initiation factor or ribosomal subunit at the mRNA 5' end.

mRNA poly(A) tail, a 3' enhancer of translational initiation

To evaluate the hypothesis that the 3' poly(A) tract of mRNA plays a role in translational initiation, we constructed derivatives of pSP65 which direct the in vitro synthesis of mRNAs with different poly(A) tail lengths and compared, in reticulocyte extracts, the relative efficiencies with which such mRNAs were translated, degraded, recruited into polysomes, and assembled into messenger ribonucleoproteins or intermediates in the translational initiation pathway. Relative to mRNAs which were polyadenylated, we found that nonpolyadenylated [poly(A)-]mRNAs had a reduced translational capacity which was not due to an increase in their decay rates, but was attributable to a reduction in their efficiency of recruitment into polysomes. The defect in poly(A)- mRNAs affected a late step in translational initiation, was distinct from the phenotype associated with cap-deficient mRNAs, and resulted in a reduced ability to form 80S initiation complexes. Moreover, poly(A) added in trans inhibited translation from capped polyadenylated mRNAs but stimulated translation from capped poly(A)- mRNAs. We suggest that the presence of a 3' poly(A) tail may facilitate the binding of an initiation factor or ribosomal subunit at the mRNA 5' end.

Identification and comparison of stable and unstable mRNAs in Saccharomyces cerevisiae

We developed a procedure to measure mRNA decay rates in the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae and applied it to the determination of half-lives for 20 mRNAs encoded by well-characterized genes. The procedure utilizes Northern (RNA) or dot blotting to quantitate the levels of individual mRNAs after thermal inactivation of RNA polymerase II in an rpb1-1 temperature-sensitive mutant. We compared the results of this procedure with results obtained by two other procedures (approach to steady-state labeling and inhibition of transcription with Thiolutin) and also evaluated whether heat shock alter mRNA decay rates. We found that there are no significant differences in the mRNA decay rates measured in heat-shocked and non-heat-shocked cells and that, for most mRNAs, different procedures yield comparable relative decay rates. Of the 20 mRNAs studied, 11, including those encoded by HIS3, STE2, STE3, and MAT alpha 1, were unstable (t1/2 less than 7 min) and 4, including those encoded by ACT1 and PGK1, were stable (t1/2 greater than 25 min). We have begun to assess the basis and significance of such differences in the decay rates of these two classes of mRNA. Our results indicate that (i) stable and unstable mRNAs do not differ significantly in their poly(A) metabolism; (ii) deadenylation does not destabilize stable mRNAs; (iii) there is no correlation between mRNA decay rate and mRNA size; (iv) the degradation of both stable and unstable mRNAs depends on concomitant translational elongation; and (v) the percentage of rare codons present in most unstable mRNAs is significantly higher than in stable mRNAs.

Identification and comparison of stable and unstable mRNAs in Saccharomyces cerevisiae

We developed a procedure to measure mRNA decay rates in the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae and applied it to the determination of half-lives for 20 mRNAs encoded by well-characterized genes. The procedure utilizes Northern (RNA) or dot blotting to quantitate the levels of individual mRNAs after thermal inactivation of RNA polymerase II in an rpb1-1 temperature-sensitive mutant. We compared the results of this procedure with results obtained by two other procedures (approach to steady-state labeling and inhibition of transcription with Thiolutin) and also evaluated whether heat shock alter mRNA decay rates. We found that there are no significant differences in the mRNA decay rates measured in heat-shocked and non-heat-shocked cells and that, for most mRNAs, different procedures yield comparable relative decay rates. Of the 20 mRNAs studied, 11, including those encoded by HIS3, STE2, STE3, and MAT alpha 1, were unstable (t1/2 less than 7 min) and 4, including those encoded by ACT1 and PGK1, were stable (t1/2 greater than 25 min). We have begun to assess the basis and significance of such differences in the decay rates of these two classes of mRNA. Our results indicate that (i) stable and unstable mRNAs do not differ significantly in their poly(A) metabolism; (ii) deadenylation does not destabilize stable mRNAs; (iii) there is no correlation between mRNA decay rate and mRNA size; (iv) the degradation of both stable and unstable mRNAs depends on concomitant translational elongation; and (v) the percentage of rare codons present in most unstable mRNAs is significantly higher than in stable mRNAs.

Inhibition of adenylate cyclase by polyadenylate

The effects of ribo- and deoxyribonucleic acids on the activity of detergent-dispersed adenylate cyclases from rat and bovine brain were examined. Mn2+ (10 mM)-activated adenylate cyclase was inhibited by micromolar concentrations of poly(A) (IC50 congruent to 0.45 microM). This inhibition was directly due to poly(A) and was not mediated by: (a) protein contamination of the poly(A) preparation, (b) metal chelation, (c) formation of an acid-soluble inhibitor of adenylate cyclase, (d) effects on the specific activity of [alpha-32P]ATP, (e) competition with MnATP for binding to adenylate cyclase, or (f) diversion of substrate to an alternate polymerase reaction. Inhibition of adenylate cyclase by poly(A) was on the enzyme's catalytic unit, as purified preparations of the enzyme from bovine brain were inhibited by poly(A). This inhibition by poly(A) was not likely mediated via the enzyme's "P"-site, through which activated forms of the enzyme are selectively inhibited by specific adenosine phosphates. In contrast with inhibition by the "P"-site agonist 3' AMP, inhibition of adenylate cyclase by poly(A) was slow in onset and was not reversible by dilution and showed a different metal-dependence. Inhibition of adenylate cyclase was relatively specific for poly(A) as poly(U) caused less than 50% inhibition and deoxyribonucleic acids had no effect. The potency and specificity of the inhibition of adenylate cyclase by poly(A) imply a biochemically interesting interaction that is possibly also of physiological significance.

Accelerated poly(A) loss on alpha-tubulin mRNAs during protein synthesis inhibition in Chlamydomonas

Detachment of flagella in Chlamydomonas reinhardii stimulates a rapid accumulation of tubulin mRNAs. The induced tubulin mRNAs are normally rapidly degraded following flagellar regeneration, but inhibition of protein synthesis with cycloheximide prevents their degradation. alpha-Tubulin poly(A) tail lengths were measured during normal accumulation and degradation, and in cycloheximide-treated cells. To measure alpha-tubulin mRNA poly(A) chain lengths with high resolution, specific 3' fragments of alpha 1- and alpha 2-tubulin mRNAs, generated by RNase H digestion of mRNA-oligonucleotide hybrids, were sized by Northern analysis. Both alpha-tubulin mRNAs have a newly synthesized poly(A) chain of about 110 adenylate residues. The poly(A) tails shorten with time, and show an average length of 40 to 60 adenylate residues by 90 minutes after deflagellation, at which time induced alpha-tubulin mRNA is being rapidly degraded. Poly(A) loss is significantly accelerated in cycloheximide-treated cells, and this loss is not attributible simply to the longer time the stabilized molecules spend in the cytoplasm. A large fraction of alpha-tubulin mRNA accumulates as mRNA with very short poly(A) tails (less than 10 residues) in the presence of cycloheximide, indicating that deadenylated alpha-tubulin mRNAs can be stable in vivo, at least in the absence of protein synthesis. The rate and extent of poly(A) loss in cycloheximide are greater for alpha 2-tubulin mRNA than for alpha 1-tubulin mRNA. This difference cannot be attributed to differential ribosome loading. This finding is interesting in that the two mRNAs are very similar in sequence with the exception of their 3' untranslated regions.

The poly(A)-poly(A)-binding protein complex is a major determinant of mRNA stability in vitro

Using an in vitro mRNA decay system, we investigated how poly(A) and its associated poly(A)-binding protein (PABP) affect mRNA stability. Cell extracts used in the decay reactions were depleted of functional PABP either by adding excess poly(A) competitor or by passing the extracts over a poly(A)-Sepharose column. Polyadenylated mRNAs for beta-globin, chloramphenicol acetyltransferase, and simian virus 40 virion proteins were degraded 3 to 10 times faster in reactions lacking PABP than in those containing excess PABP. The addition of purified Saccharomyces cerevisiae or human cytoplasmic PABP to PABP-depleted reactions stabilized the polyadenylated mRNAs. In contrast, the decay rates of nonpolyadenylated mRNAs were unaffected by PABP, indicating that both the poly(A) and its binding protein were required for maintaining mRNA stability. A nonspecific single-stranded binding protein from Escherichia coli did not restore stability to polyadenylated mRNA, and the stabilizing effect of PABP was inhibited by anti-PABP antibody. The poly(A) tract was the first mRNA segment to be degraded in PABP-depleted reactions, confirming that the poly(A)-PABP complex was protecting the 3' region from nucleolytic attack. These results indicate that an important function of poly(A), in conjunction with its binding protein, is to protect polyadenylated mRNAs from indiscriminate destruction by cellular nucleases. A model is proposed to explain how the stability of an mRNA could be affected by the stability of its poly(A)-PABP complex.

The poly(A)-poly(A)-binding protein complex is a major determinant of mRNA stability in vitro

Using an in vitro mRNA decay system, we investigated how poly(A) and its associated poly(A)-binding protein (PABP) affect mRNA stability. Cell extracts used in the decay reactions were depleted of functional PABP either by adding excess poly(A) competitor or by passing the extracts over a poly(A)-Sepharose column. Polyadenylated mRNAs for beta-globin, chloramphenicol acetyltransferase, and simian virus 40 virion proteins were degraded 3 to 10 times faster in reactions lacking PABP than in those containing excess PABP. The addition of purified Saccharomyces cerevisiae or human cytoplasmic PABP to PABP-depleted reactions stabilized the polyadenylated mRNAs. In contrast, the decay rates of nonpolyadenylated mRNAs were unaffected by PABP, indicating that both the poly(A) and its binding protein were required for maintaining mRNA stability. A nonspecific single-stranded binding protein from Escherichia coli did not restore stability to polyadenylated mRNA, and the stabilizing effect of PABP was inhibited by anti-PABP antibody. The poly(A) tract was the first mRNA segment to be degraded in PABP-depleted reactions, confirming that the poly(A)-PABP complex was protecting the 3' region from nucleolytic attack. These results indicate that an important function of poly(A), in conjunction with its binding protein, is to protect polyadenylated mRNAs from indiscriminate destruction by cellular nucleases. A model is proposed to explain how the stability of an mRNA could be affected by the stability of its poly(A)-PABP complex.

mRNA decay rates in late-developing Dictyostelium discoideum cells are heterogeneous, and cyclic AMP does not act directly to stabilize cell-type-specific mRNAs

We reevaluated the use of 32PO4 pulse-chases for analyzing mRNA decay rates in late-developing Dictyostelium cells. We found that completely effective PO4 chases could not be obtained in developing cells and that, as a consequence, the decay rates exhibited by some mRNAs were influenced by the rates at which they were transcribed. In developing cells disaggregated in the presence of cyclic AMP, the poly(A)+ mRNA population turned over with an apparent half-life of 4 h, individual mRNA decay rates were heterogeneous, and some prestalk and prespore mRNAs appeared to decay with biphasic kinetics. In cells disaggregated in the absence of cyclic AMP, all prestalk and prespore mRNAs decayed with biphasic kinetics. During the first 1 to 1.5 h after disaggregation in the absence of cyclic AMP, the cell-type-specific mRNAs were selectively degraded, decaying with half-lives of 20 to 30 min; thereafter, the residual prestalk and prespore mRNA molecules decayed at rates that were similar to those measured in the presence of cyclic AMP. This short-term labilization of cell-type-specific mRNAs was observed even for those species not requiring cyclic AMP for their accumulation in developing cells. The observation that cell-type specific mRNAs can decay at similar rates in disaggregated cells with or without cyclic AMP indicates that this compound does not act directly to stabilize prestalk and prespore mRNAs during development and that its primary role in the maintenance of cyclic-AMP-dependent mRNAs is likely to be transcriptional.

mRNA decay rates in late-developing Dictyostelium discoideum cells are heterogeneous, and cyclic AMP does not act directly to stabilize cell-type-specific mRNAs

We reevaluated the use of 32PO4 pulse-chases for analyzing mRNA decay rates in late-developing Dictyostelium cells. We found that completely effective PO4 chases could not be obtained in developing cells and that, as a consequence, the decay rates exhibited by some mRNAs were influenced by the rates at which they were transcribed. In developing cells disaggregated in the presence of cyclic AMP, the poly(A)+ mRNA population turned over with an apparent half-life of 4 h, individual mRNA decay rates were heterogeneous, and some prestalk and prespore mRNAs appeared to decay with biphasic kinetics. In cells disaggregated in the absence of cyclic AMP, all prestalk and prespore mRNAs decayed with biphasic kinetics. During the first 1 to 1.5 h after disaggregation in the absence of cyclic AMP, the cell-type-specific mRNAs were selectively degraded, decaying with half-lives of 20 to 30 min; thereafter, the residual prestalk and prespore mRNA molecules decayed at rates that were similar to those measured in the presence of cyclic AMP. This short-term labilization of cell-type-specific mRNAs was observed even for those species not requiring cyclic AMP for their accumulation in developing cells. The observation that cell-type specific mRNAs can decay at similar rates in disaggregated cells with or without cyclic AMP indicates that this compound does not act directly to stabilize prestalk and prespore mRNAs during development and that its primary role in the maintenance of cyclic-AMP-dependent mRNAs is likely to be transcriptional.

Determinants of mRNA stability in Dictyostelium discoideum amoebae: differences in poly(A) tail length, ribosome loading, and mRNA size cannot account for the heterogeneity of mRNA decay rates

As an approach to understanding the structures and mechanisms which determine mRNA decay rates, we have cloned and begun to characterize cDNAs which encode mRNAs representative of the stability extremes in the poly(A)+ RNA population of Dictyostelium discoideum amoebae. The cDNA clones were identified in a screening procedure which was based on the occurrence of poly(A) shortening during mRNA aging. mRNA half-lives were determined by hybridization of poly(A)+ RNA, isolated from cells labeled in a 32PO4 pulse-chase, to dots of excess cloned DNA. Individual mRNAs decayed with unique first-order decay rates ranging from 0.9 to 9.6 h, indicating that the complex decay kinetics of total poly(A)+ RNA in D. discoideum amoebae reflect the sum of the decay rates of individual mRNAs. Using specific probes derived from these cDNA clones, we have compared the sizes, extents of ribosome loading, and poly(A) tail lengths of stable, moderately stable, and unstable mRNAs. We found (i) no correlation between mRNA size and decay rate; (ii) no significant difference in the number of ribosomes per unit length of stable versus unstable mRNAs, and (iii) a general inverse relationship between mRNA decay rates and poly(A) tail lengths. Collectively, these observations indicate that mRNA decay in D. discoideum amoebae cannot be explained in terms of random nucleolytic events. The possibility that specific 3'-structural determinants can confer mRNA instability is suggested by a comparison of the labeling and turnover kinetics of different actin mRNAs. A correlation was observed between the steady-state percentage of a given mRNA found in polysomes and its degree of instability; i.e., unstable mRNAs were more efficiently recruited into polysomes than stable mRNAs. Since stable mRNAs are, on average, "older" than unstable mRNAs, this correlation may reflect a translational role for mRNA modifications that change in a time-dependent manner. Our previous studies have demonstrated both a time-dependent shortening and a possible translational role for the 3' poly(A) tracts of mRNA. We suggest, therefore, that the observed differences in the translational efficiency of stable and unstable mRNAs may, in part, be attributable to differences in steady-state poly(A) tail lengths.

Determinants of mRNA stability in Dictyostelium discoideum amoebae: differences in poly(A) tail length, ribosome loading, and mRNA size cannot account for the heterogeneity of mRNA decay rates

As an approach to understanding the structures and mechanisms which determine mRNA decay rates, we have cloned and begun to characterize cDNAs which encode mRNAs representative of the stability extremes in the poly(A)+ RNA population of Dictyostelium discoideum amoebae. The cDNA clones were identified in a screening procedure which was based on the occurrence of poly(A) shortening during mRNA aging. mRNA half-lives were determined by hybridization of poly(A)+ RNA, isolated from cells labeled in a 32PO4 pulse-chase, to dots of excess cloned DNA. Individual mRNAs decayed with unique first-order decay rates ranging from 0.9 to 9.6 h, indicating that the complex decay kinetics of total poly(A)+ RNA in D. discoideum amoebae reflect the sum of the decay rates of individual mRNAs. Using specific probes derived from these cDNA clones, we have compared the sizes, extents of ribosome loading, and poly(A) tail lengths of stable, moderately stable, and unstable mRNAs. We found (i) no correlation between mRNA size and decay rate; (ii) no significant difference in the number of ribosomes per unit length of stable versus unstable mRNAs, and (iii) a general inverse relationship between mRNA decay rates and poly(A) tail lengths. Collectively, these observations indicate that mRNA decay in D. discoideum amoebae cannot be explained in terms of random nucleolytic events. The possibility that specific 3'-structural determinants can confer mRNA instability is suggested by a comparison of the labeling and turnover kinetics of different actin mRNAs. A correlation was observed between the steady-state percentage of a given mRNA found in polysomes and its degree of instability; i.e., unstable mRNAs were more efficiently recruited into polysomes than stable mRNAs. Since stable mRNAs are, on average, "older" than unstable mRNAs, this correlation may reflect a translational role for mRNA modifications that change in a time-dependent manner. Our previous studies have demonstrated both a time-dependent shortening and a possible translational role for the 3' poly(A) tracts of mRNA. We suggest, therefore, that the observed differences in the translational efficiency of stable and unstable mRNAs may, in part, be attributable to differences in steady-state poly(A) tail lengths.

Regulation of mRNA stability and the poly(A) problem in Dictyostelium discoideum

This paper reviews our studies of three aspects of post-transcriptional regulation in Dictyostelium discoideum: 1) the determinants of mRNA stability in vegetative amoebae; 2) the effects of disaggregation and cyclic AMP on the decay rates of cell-type-specific mRNAs in late developing cells; and 3) the cytoplasmic function of the 3' poly(A) tracts present on most mRNAs. We find that: 1) mRNA stability in vegetative amoebae is not dependent on mRNA size, ribosome loading, or poly(A) tract length, but may be determined by specific 3'-untranslated sequences within a given mRNA; 2) mRNA decay rates in late developing cells are heterogeneous, and cyclic AMP does not act directly to stabilize cell-type-specific mRNAs; and 3) poly(A) is most likely involved in the initiation of protein synthesis via an interaction with cytoplasmic poly(A)-binding proteins.

Contribution of polyadenylate sequences to the translational efficiency of globin messenger RNAs

mRNAs from reticulocyte polysomes were fractionated by chromatography on poly(U)-Sepharose and thermal elution. The molar ratio of alpha- to beta-globin mRNA was found to be 2:1 and 1:1 respectively in short- and long-poly(A) size classes. Translational analyses indicated that the globin mRNAs containing long poly(A) tracts (with a mean length of about 70 nucleotides) directed protein synthesis with higher rates than did mRNA containing short poly(A) tracts (15-35 nucleotides). Experiments performed with sub-saturating mRNA concentrations showed that the digestion with RNAase H induced a decrease in the translational capacity of both globin mRNAs and an increase in the alpha- to beta-globin synthesis ratio. No correlation was observed between the size of the poly(A) tail in mRNA and the optimal K+ requirement for translation.

A direct evidence for the involvement of poly(A) in protein synthesis

A radioactive polyadenylated globin mRNA was translated in either rabbit reticulocyte lysate or wheat germ extract under various conditions. When globin mRNA was translated, globin synthesis was directly proportional to the rate of loss in A units from the poly(A) tail. On the other hand, when globin poly(A) mRNA was incubated under non-translated conditions, no loss of A units was detected. The presence of ribonuclease inhibitor in the reaction mixture did not alter either the rate of globin synthesis or the loss in A units from the poly(A) tail. The present data suggests a correlation between protein synthesis and loss in A units from the poly(A) tail.

H4 histone messenger RNA decay in cell-free extracts initiates at or near the 3' terminus and proceeds 3' to 5'

The relative decay of four human messenger RNAs, gamma globin, delta globin, c-myc and H4 histone, were compared in a cell-free system. Under appropriate conditions, they are degraded in vitro in approximately the same relative order as in vivo: histone faster than c-myc and delta globin faster than gamma globin. Degradation of polysome-associated H4 histone mRNA and of deproteinized histone mRNA begins at or near the 3' terminus. At least a portion of the mRNA then continues to be degraded in a 3' to 5' direction. Discrete 3'-terminal degradation hold-up points are observed, suggesting that 3' to 5' degradation occurs non-uniformly. Cycloheximide and puromycin inhibit protein synthesis but do not affect the rate or directionality of histone mRNA decay in vitro. We conclude that the rate-limiting step in H4 histone mRNA decay occurs at or near the 3' terminus and that at least a portion of the mRNA molecule is subsequently degraded 3' to 5', probably via a processive exonuclease.

A gene expressed in undifferentiated vegetative Dictyostelium is repressed by developmental pulses of cAMP and reinduced during dedifferentiation

We describe the gene M4-1, whose unique pattern of developmental expression will allow us to study the molecular mechanisms controlling expression in undifferentiated cells in addition to repression in response to cAMP during development and reinduction during dedifferentiation. M4-1 is a Dictyostelium gene expressed in the undifferentiated cell. We have shown that M4-1 continues to be expressed very early during the developmental cycle but is repressed at a later stage of development, at a time coincident with the establishment of oscillations in the cAMP pool. Studies on the expression of the M4-1 gene in shaking culture, under conditions that mimic early development, have established that pulsatile stimulation of cells with cAMP is sufficient to repress M4-1 expression. Consistent with this, cells that are exposed to high levels of cAMP are unable to respond normally to cAMP oscillations and continue to express M4-1 at vegetative levels. These data indicate that low-level oscillations of cAMP are required for the repression of M4-1 expression rather than the continuous high levels of cAMP responsible for the regulation of a different class of Dictyostelium genes. We suggest that cAMP may mediate developmental expression of the Dictyostelium genome by different mechanisms. We also show that cell-cell interaction, a developmental event that occurs subsequent to the cAMP pulse, does not normally influence the regulation of M4-1. Finally, we have shown that when cAMP-pulsed cells are induced to dedifferentiate, M4-1 RNA sequences rapidly reappear in nuclei and cytoplasm, suggesting that regulation of M4-1 expression is primarily mediated at the level of transcription.

Differential stability of Drosophila embryonic mRNAs during subsequent larval development

The relative stabilities of specific embryonic mRNAs that persist in Drosophila melanogaster larvae were determined using an approach that combined RNA density labeling with cell-free translation. Unlike the other methods commonly used to measure the decay of individual mRNAs, the density labeling approach does not depend on the use of transcriptional inhibitors or on the measurement of precursor pool specific activities. Using this approach, we have determined that different embryonic mRNA species persist for varying periods during subsequent development, with half-lives ranging from approximately 2 to approximately 30 h. The embryonic histone mRNAs are relatively unstable; they are no longer detectable by 9 h of larval development. By 41 h of larval development, 90% of the nonhistone mRNAs assayed have decayed considerably; computerized scanning densitometry of translation products indicates that these transcripts are not decaying as members of discrete half-life classes. The persisting mRNAs that remain are very long-lived; their in vitro translation products can still be detected after 91 h of larval development. We have tentatively identified the mRNAs that encode actin, tropomyosin, and tubulin as members of this stable mRNA population. Although embryonic mRNAs do fall into these three broad classes of stability, they appear to decay with a continuum of half-lives. Because the range of half-lives is so great, mRNA stability is probably an important factor controlling mRNA abundance during Drosophila development.

Translational control during early Dictyostelium development: possible involvement of poly(A) sequences

A rapid decrease in the translational efficiency of mRNA synthesized during vegetative growth is associated with the initiation of development in Dictyostelium discoideum. In contrast, newly synthesized mRNA associates with polysomes with high efficiency. Discrimination between these two mRNA populations correlates with a rapid shortening of the poly(A) tract on the preexisting mRNA. A model is proposed in which a critical poly(A) length regulates the pattern of protein synthesis by affecting the efficiency with which mRNAs can interact with the translational machinery. The model suggests that transcriptional and translational controls can be coupled by altering the state of adenylation of the preexisting mRNA population. The model allows radical changes in the pattern of protein synthesis without wholesale destruction of preexisting mRNA.

Polyadenylated mRNA from the photosynthetic procaryote Rhodospirillum rubrum

Total cellular RNA extracted from Rhodospirillum rubrum cultured in butyrate-containing medium under strict photosynthetic conditions to the stationary phase of growth has been fractionated on an oligodeoxythymidylic acid-cellulose column into polyadenylated [poly(A)+] RNA and poly(A)- RNA fractions. The poly(A)+ fraction was 9 to 10% of the total bulk RNA isolated. Analysis of the poly(A)+ RNA on a denaturing urea-polyacrylamide gel revealed four sharp bands of RNA distributed in heterodisperse fashion between 16S and 9S. Similar fractionation of the poly(A)- RNA resulted in the separation of 23, 16, and 5S rRNAs and 4S tRNA. Poly(A)+ fragments isolated after combined digestion with pancreatic A and T1 RNases and analysis by denaturing gel electrophoresis demonstrated two major components of 80 and 100 residues. Alkaline hydrolysis of the nuclease-resistant, purified residues showed AMP-rich nucleotides. Through the use of snake venom phosphodiesterase, poly(A) tracts were placed at the 3' end of poly(A)+ RNA. Stimulation of [3H]leucine incorporation into hot trichloroacetic acid-precipitable polypeptides in a cell-free system from wheat germ primed by the poly(A)+ RNA mixture was found to be 220-fold higher than that for poly(A)- RNAs (on a unit mass basis), a finding which demonstrated that poly(A)+ RNAs in R. rubrum are mRNAs. Gel electrophoretic analysis of the translation mixture revealed numerous 3H-labeled products including a major band (Mr, 52,000). The parent protein was precipitated by antibodies to ribulose bisphosphate carboxylase-oxygenase and comprised 6.5% of the total translation products.

Possible involvement of poly(A) in protein synthesis

The experiments of this paper have re-evaluated the possibility that poly(A) is involved in protein synthesis by testing whether purified poly(A) might competitively inhibit in vitro protein synthesis in rabbit reticulocyte extracts. We have found that poly(A) inhibits the rate of translation of many different poly(A)+ mRNAs and that comparable inhibition is not observed with other ribopolymers. Inhibition by poly(A) preferentially affects the translation of adenylated mRNAs and can be overcome by increased mRNA concentrations or by translating mRNPs instead of mRNA. The extent of inhibition is dependent on the size of the competitor poly(A) as well as on the translation activity which a lysate has for poly(A)+ RNA. In light of our results and numerous experiments in the literature, we propose that poly(A) has a function in protein synthesis and that any role in the determination of mRNA stability is indirect.

Human beta and delta globin messenger RNAs turn over at different rates

We have tested the hypothesis of Winslow & Ingram (1966) that the steady-state levels of human beta and delta globin proteins are determined, in part, by the stabilities of their respective messenger RNAs. Nucleated bone marrow cells were cultured under different RNA "chase" conditions, and samples were harvested at intervals thereafter. The quantities of beta and delta globin mRNA sequences in total RNA from these cells were measured by solution hybridization with specific 32P-labeled DNA probes. The average half-lives of beta and delta globin mRNAs are 16.5 and 4.5 hours, respectively. Both mRNAs are polyadenylated. The rapid turnover of delta globin mRNA accounts, at least in part, for the low level of delta globin mRNA in non-nucleated peripheral blood reticulocytes. The possibility that the rate of mRNA decay is determined by nucleotide sequence signals located in the 3' untranslated region is discussed.

Sequence-specific adenylations and deadenylations accompany changes in the translation of maternal messenger RNA after fertilization of Spisula oocytes

A dramatic change in the pattern of protein synthesis occurs within ten minutes after fertilization of Spisula oocytes. This change is regulated entirely at the translational level. We have used DNA clones complementary to five translationally regulated messenger RNAs to follow shifts in mRNA utilization at fertilization and to characterize alterations in mRNA structure that accompany switches in translational activity in vivo. Four of the mRNAs studied are translationally inactive in the oocyte. After fertilization two of these mRNAs are completely recruited onto polysomes, and two are partially recruited. All four of these mRNAs have very short poly(A) tracts in the oocyte; after fertilization the poly(A) tails lengthen considerably. In contrast, a fifth mRNA, that encoding alpha-tubulin mRNA, is translated very efficiently in the oocyte and is rapidly lost from polysomes after fertilization. Essentially all alpha-tubulin mRNA in the oocyte is poly(A)+ and a large portion of this mRNA undergoes complete deadenylation after fertilization. These results reveal a striking relationship between changes in adenylation and translational activity in vivo. This correlation is not perfect, however. Evidence for and against a direct role for polyadenylation in regulating these translational changes is discussed. Changes in poly(A) tails are the only alterations in mRNA sizes that we have been able to detect. This indicates that, at least for the mRNAs studied here, translational activation is not due to extensive processing of larger translationally incompetent precursors. We have also isolated several complementary DNA clones to RNAs encoded by the mitochondrial genome. Surprisingly, the poly(A) tracts of at least two of the mitochondrial RNAs also lengthen in response to fertilization.

Messenger RNA half-life in Dictyostelium discoideum

Messenger RNA half-life in vegetatively growing cells of Dictyostelium discoideum was determined using a uridine pulse-chase procedure. In these experiments, mRNA decayed in a complex fashion, and consisted of at least two major components, one with a half-life of about 50 min and a second with a half-life of about 10 hr. These results independently confirm our previous studies on the decay of mRNA extracted from actinomycin D-treated cells. Since these results were in apparent conflict with half-life determinations obtained with a combination of actinomycin D and daunomycin (J. P. Margolskee and H. F. Lodish, 1980a, Dev. Biol. 74, 37-49), we have also studied mRNA half-life in cells treated with a combination of both drugs and found that simultaneous use of both drugs leads to accelerated mRNA decay and other noticeable side effects. In light of our observations, we have suggested an alternative to conclusions drawn by others with respect to mRNA synthesis and stability in Dictyostelium development.

Nogalamycin inhibits ribonucleic acid synthesis in growing and developing cells of the slime mold Dictyostelium discoideum

Nogalamycin, an anthracycline antibiotic that intercalates into deoxyribonucleic acid, is a potent inhibitor of ribonucleic acid (RNA) synthesis in the slime mold Dictyostelium discoideum. The antibiotic inhibits RNA synthesis in growing cells and in inactivated spores, and in this way inhibits spore germination. Protein synthesis is much less inhibited. Nogalamycin inhibits ribosomal RNA, transfer RNA, and messenger RNA equally. Polysomes break down in the presence of the drug with a half-life of 220 min, and messenger RNA decays with a half-life of 290 min. The data show that nogalamycin can be employed to inhibit messenger RNA synthesis and is useful in determining messenger RNA decay rates in the slime mold.