Effect of rate-limiting elongation on bacteriophage MS2 RNA-directed protein synthesis in extracts of Escherichia coli

The mitochondrial myopathy, encephalopathy, lactic acidosis, and stroke-like episode syndrome-associated human mitochondrial tRNALeu(UUR) mutation causes aminoacylation deficiency and concomitant reduced association of mRNA with ribosomes

The pathogenetic mechanism of the mitochondrial tRNA(Leu(UUR)) A3243G transition associated with the mitochondrial myopathy, encephalopathy, lactic acidosis, and stroke-like episodes (MELAS) syndrome has been investigated in transmitochondrial cell lines constructed by transfer of mutant mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA)-carrying mitochondria from three genetically unrelated MELAS patients or of isogenic wild-type mtDNA-carrying organelles into human mtDNA-less cells. An in vivo footprinting analysis of the mtDNA segment within the tRNA(Leu(UUR)) gene that binds the transcription termination factor failed to reveal any difference in occupancy of sites or qualitative interaction with the protein between mutant and wild-type mtDNAs. Cell lines nearly homoplasmic for the mutation exhibited a strong (70-75%) reduction in the level of aminoacylated tRNA(Leu(UUR)) and a decrease in mitochondrial protein synthesis rate. The latter, however, did not show any significant correlation between synthesis defect of the individual polypeptides and number or proportion of UUR codons in their mRNAs, suggesting that another step, other than elongation, may be affected. Sedimentation analysis in sucrose gradient showed a reduction in size of the mitochondrial polysomes, while the distribution of the two rRNA components and of the mRNAs revealed decreased association of mRNA with ribosomes and, in the most affected cell line, pronounced degradation of the mRNA associated with slowly sedimenting structures. Therefore, several lines of evidence indicate that the protein synthesis defect in A3243G MELAS mutation-carrying cells is mainly due to a reduced association of mRNA with ribosomes, possibly as a consequence of the tRNA(Leu(UUR)) aminoacylation defect.

Probing the function of conserved RNA structures in the 30S subunit of Escherichia coli ribosomes

Ribosomes play an active role in protein biosynthesis. Ribosomal RNA conformation in ribosomal subunits, intramolecular interactions between different rRNA sequences within the confinement of the particles, and intermolecular interactions are presumed necessary to support efficient and accurate protein synthesis. Here we report an analysis of the disposition of 16S rRNA conserved zones centered about positions 525, 1400, and 1500 in 30S subunits. Complementary oligodeoxyribonucleotides in conjunction with nuclease S1 digestion were used to do this. All of the sequences examined in 30S subunits are accessible to DNA probes of 9 to 12 nucleotide residues in length. However, the kinetic characteristics of the respective DNA interactions with 30S particles vary significantly. In addition to the investigation of normal 30S particles, a four base deletion within the 1400 region of 16S rRNA was analyzed. The deletion was made by using synthetic DNAs to target the deletion site for RNase H digestion. The direct in vitro procedure for manipulating rRNA conserves nucleotide modifications. The alteration causes a significant change in the disposition of 16S rRNA in 30S subunits, suggesting a reduction in the freedom of movement of the altered zone in the particle. In a factor-dependent in vitro protein synthesis system primed with MS2 mRNA and altered 30S subunits, there was a 50% decrease in phage coat protein synthesis. The reduction could be due to a decrease in the rate of translation or premature termination of translation. We present evidence here, based on isotopic studies, which supports the latter possibility.

Uncharged tRNA, protein synthesis, and the bacterial stringent response

Uncharged tRNA has been shown in vivo to have an active role both in the stringent response, and in modulating the rate of translational elongation. Both of these effects appear to be mediated by codon-anticodon interactions on the ribosome. Although the involvement of uncharged tRNA in the stringent response was expected from in vitro experiments, it has only recently been confirmed in vivo. Inhibition of translation by cognate uncharged tRNA was not expected, and a model is proposed in which excess uncharged tRNA competes with charged tRNA (in ternary complex) for the 30S component of the ribosomal A site. When uncharged tRNA is in sufficient excess over charged tRNA, interaction of uncharged tRNA with the 50S component of the A site occurs as well, leading to a stringent response. The cell has a continuum of responses to decreasing aminoacyl-tRNA levels: in moderately limited conditions, the proportion of uncharged tRNA increases, and the translation rate is slowed; under more severe limitations, uncharged tRNA provokes a stringent response, with pleiotropic consequences for the cell.

Relationship between protein synthesis and concentrations of charged and uncharged tRNATrp in Escherichia coli

We have continuously monitored Trp-tRNA(Trp) concentrations in vivo and, in the same cultures, measured rates of protein synthesis in isogenic stringent and relaxed strains. We have also manipulated cellular charged and uncharged [tRNA(Trp)] by two means: (i) the strain used contains a Trp-tRNA synthetase mutation that increases the Km for Trp; thus, varying exogenous Trp varies cellular Trp-tRNA(Trp); and (ii) we have introduced into the mutant strain a plasmid containing the tRNA(Trp) gene behind an inducible promoter; thus, total [tRNA(Trp)] also can be varied depending on length of induction. The use of these conditions, combined with a previously characterized assay system, has allowed us to demonstrate that (i) the rate of incorporation of Trp into protein is proportional to the fraction of tRNA(Trp) that is charged; for any given total [tRNA(Trp)], this rate is also proportional to the [Trp-tRNA(Trp)]; (ii) uncharged tRNA(Trp) inhibits incorporation of Trp into protein; and (iii) rates of incorporation into protein of at least two other amino acids, Lys and Cys, are also sensitive to [Trp-tRNA(Trp)] and are inhibited by uncharged tRNA(Trp). Our results are consistent with models of translational control that postulate modulating polypeptide chain elongation efficiency by varying concentrations of specific tRNAs.

Codon contexts from weakly expressed genes reduce expression in vivo

Nucleotides that neighbor codons in Escherichia coli genes are highly non-random. Furthermore, these context biases are stronger and extend farther from the codon in weakly expressed than in highly expressed genes. We therefore suggested that codon contexts are selected to reduce gene expression levels. We now compare the expression levels of lacZ genes containing two specific coding sequences (context inserts). One context insert represents contexts seen in weakly expressed genes (low variant); the other represents contexts seen in highly expressed genes (high variant). The two variants have identical nucleotide and codon compositions, and encode the same protein. A permutation of four nucleotides, which changes eight codon:codon interfaces of 1043, comprises the only difference between the high and low context variant genes. In three different lacZ mRNAs, the low variant was expressed at a level significantly below that of the high variant. This context effect depends entirely on translation of the contexts in the correct frame; its magnitude depends in part on the placement of other features (e.g. transcriptional pauses and terminators, or perhaps other slow codons or contexts) in the mRNAs. Changing the ribosome density on the message by changing the ribosome binding site distinguishes between dropoff, interference and polarity, three fundamentally different types of models for the context effect. The expression difference between context variants is eliminated by both increases and decreases in the ribosome initiation frequency, as uniquely predicted by the polarity model. In fact, data from all constructions are accommodated by a model in which slow translation of the low context insert increases rho-dependent transcriptional termination within the test gene. The data suggest that the rates of translational initiation and elongation are poised with respect to the rate of transcriptional elongation so that all are influential in setting the expression level of wild-type lacZ. We conclude that context-induced polarity will exist in genes wherever low and reproducible gene product levels have been selected.

Accuracy of natural messenger translation: analysis of codon-anticodon recognition in a simplified cell-free system

A simplified plasmid-directed coupled system [Robakis, N., Cenatiempo, Y., Meza-Basso, L., Brot, N., & Weissbach, H. (1983) Methods Enzymol. 101, 690-706] was used to study the accuracy of natural messenger translation in vitro. In this system, protein synthesis is limited to the formation of the N-terminal di- or tripeptide of the gene product. Such a control is obtained by restricting the supply of aminoacyl-tRNAs in the assay medium to those corresponding specifically to the first two or three triplets in the mRNA coding sequence. We analyzed comparatively the interaction of 6 different codons with their cognate tRNAs and 18 noncognate tRNAs able to recognize triplets differing from the legitimate sequences by one base only. Special attention was paid to the single base errors occurring at the first and second codon positions during ribosomal selection of aminoacyl-tRNA molecules. The noncognate tRNAs were assayed either in the absence of the legitimate tRNAs or under competition conditions. They were chosen so that all the possibilities for misreading any particular base as each of the other three bases could be studied. First, it was mainly observed that translation mistakes can be equally detected in the first and second codon positions; there is no compelling evidence for a most or least accurate site. Second, pyrimidines seem to be read more accurately than purines. In particular, U cannot be read as either C or G, and C can hardly be mistaken for any other base.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Effects of post-transcriptional base modifications on the site-specific function of transfer RNA in eukaryote translation

The site-specific function in translation of several naturally occurring mammalian transfer RNAs has been studied in a series of investigations with some similarities to studies in other laboratories of tRNAs in suppression. Equal amounts of aminoacyl-tRNA isoacceptors with contrasting isotopes were added in pairs to reticulocyte lysates and allowed to incorporate their amino acids into rabbit globin. Rates of incorporation from unlimiting amounts of each isoacceptor into the corresponding amino-acid-containing sites were determined. The tRNAs of each isoacceptor pair differed as to post-transcriptional base modifications. The natural occurrence of these isoacceptors can be correlated with rates of cellular division, with more rapidly dividing and neoplastic cells containing hypomodified tRNA. The overall incorporation of lysine into globin from a fully modified tRNALys that decodes AAG is faster by 25 to 30% than from the corresponding hypomodified tRNALys. There is considerable scatter in values for incorporation ratios at different lysine-containing sites, with the hypomodified isoacceptor even being preferred at one site. The AAG decoding isoacceptors are capable of translating AAA although much more slowly than AAG. In translating AAA, in contrast to translating AAG, the hypomodified tRNALys isoacceptor is preferred. A Y base-deficient hypomodified tRNAPhe isoacceptor found only in some kinds of rapidly dividing tumor cells donates its phenylalanine preferentially to globin in competition with the fully modified Y-containing tRNAPhe of liver by 15 to 17%. There is a considerable range of incorporation ratios at the different phenylalanine-containing sites of the globin subunits. No correlation can be made between the isoacceptor preferred and the phenylalanine codon being translated. The incorporation of histidine from a fully modified tRNAHis-containing Q base in its anticodon, compared with that from the hypomodified counterpart isoacceptor that lacks Q base and that occurs in rapidly dividing cells, showed no difference in their ability to incorporate overall or into individual histidine-containing sites. There is little evidence that adjacent bases or codons in messenger RNA affect the tRNAs preferred in the translation of most sites. A striking pattern of tRNA preference was observed in three cases in which there are tandem codons, with the same codon appearing twice in succession.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

Effect of a 2-methylthio-N6-isopentenyladenosine deficiency on peptidyl-tRNA release in Escherichia coli

We examined the effect of miaA, a mutation conferring a deficiency in 2-methylthio-N6-isopentenyladenosine in tRNA, on patterns of peptidyl-tRNA accumulation in Escherichia coli strains deficient in peptidyl-tRNA hydrolase activity. A specific reduction in peptidyl-tRNA accumulation was seen for tRNAs which normally contain the 2-methylthio-N6-isopentenyladenosine modification. These results provide new evidence in support of the ribosome editor model, which links peptidyl-tRNA release to mistranslation events.

Quantities of individual aminoacyl-tRNA families and their turnover in Escherichia coli

The cellular content of all 20 aminoacyl-tRNA species was determined in small cultures of Escherichia coli by labeling cells with 3H-amino acids and extraction of 3H-amino acid-labeled nucleic acid by standard procedures. Of 3H-amino acid-labeled material, 25 to 90% was identified as 3H-aminoacyl-tRNA by the following criteria: sensitivity to base hydrolysis with expected kinetics; association of 3H counts released by base treatment of the 3H-amino acid-labeled nucleic acid with amino acid standards upon paper chromatography of the hydrolysate; and changes in the amount of 3H-amino acid-labeled nucleic acid recovered from cells as a function of time. Individual aminoacyl-tRNA content was determined with as few as 8 X 10(7) to 4 X 10(8) E. coli cells. Although the total number of aminoacyl-tRNA molecules per cell varied only by 10 to 20% among various strains of E. coli, some individual aminoacyl-tRNA families varied two- to threefold among strains. For a given amino acid, the number of aminoacyl-tRNA molecules per cell in E. coli strain K38 growing with a doubling time of 60 min varied from 730 (glutamyl-tRNA) to 7,910 (valyl-tRNA) with a mean value of 3,200. The total number of aminoacyl-tRNA molecules per cell (6.4 X 10(4)) in E. coli K38 was 5.5-fold higher than the number of ribosomes and was equal to 84% of the amount of elongation factor Tu molecules per cell. The ratio of aminoacyl-tRNA to synthetase for 10 amino acids varied from about 1 to 15 with a mean value of 4.7. The turnover of individual aminoacyl-tRNA families in E. coli cells was estimated to be in the range of 1.7 to 8.1 s-1 with a mean value of 3.7 s-1. An estimate of minimum in vivo molecular activity of aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases gives values of 2 to 48 s-1 for individual enzymes.

Computer simulation of ribosome editing

A stochastic model of protein synthesis was modified by including the process of dissociating peptidyl-tRNA from ribosomes. To simulate ribosome editing, the probability of dissociation was assumed to be high if the peptidyl-tRNA was erroneous; that is, if it resulted from transfer of a peptide to an aminoacyl-tRNA that was inappropriate relative to the mRNA codon. The effects of amino acid starvation on protein synthesis were simulated both by increasing the probability of such erring at and by reducing the conditional probability of elongation at "hungry" codons, those whose correct amino acid was in short supply. These probabilities were varied systematically to simulate tryptophan limitation during synthesis of coat protein from bacteriophage MS2. Significant reduction, during starvation, in the synthesis of complete coat protein required large reductions in the probability of elongation at hungry codons but only small increases in the probability of erring. Enhanced dissociation of peptidyl-tRNA during starvation, followed rapidly by dissociation of ribosomes from mRNA, led to reductions in mean polysome size, a result that had been interpreted by others as due to some effect of starvation on the initiation of protein synthesis. Results from experiments by Goldman (1982) on the cell-free synthesis of MS2 coat protein during tryptophan starvation could be mimicked in detail by the computer simulations. A simple competition between correct and erroneous amino acids was sufficient to explain the tryptophan dependence of complete coat protein and internal peptide syntheses. Values for the Michaelis constants were derived from the computer simulations.

Control of RNA and protein synthesis by the concentration of Trp-tRNATrp in Escherichia coli infected with bacteriophage MS2

The effect of varying the concentration of Trp-tRNATrp in Escherichia coli infected with bacteriophage MS2 has been studied by varying the amount of exogenously added tryptophan (Trp) to cells bearing a mutation which results in a tryptophanyl-tRNA synthetase with a higher Km value for Trp. The phenotype of the mutant has been confirmed by measuring the level of tRNATrp which can be aminoacylated in vivo, and the mutant has also been shown to have elevated tRNATrp levels compared to wild-type. The growth of MS2 decreases continuously with decreasing Trp concentration (and hence, decreasing Trp-tRNATrp concentration). This appears to be due to reduced gene expression, since at later times in infection the amount of MS2 coat protein synthesized likewise decreases continuously with decreasing Trp concentration. However, there is little decrease in the amount of coat protein or replicase synthesized during the first few minutes after the Trp concentration shift. A continuous increase in the average polysome size distribution is seen as the Trp concentration is decreased. MS2 RNA synthesis also decreases continuously with decreasing Trp concentration, and is shut off in the absence of Trp. This does not seem to be due to ppGpp as these cells are functionally relaxed under these conditions, nor does it seem to be due to degradation of pre-existing template. Addition of chloramphenicol abolishes the effect of Trp concentration on RNA synthesis. The data are consistent with a model in which ribosomes pause at Trp codons in the absence of Trp-tRNATrp, while other ribosomes queue behind and continue to load onto the message. The reduction of RNA synthesis would then be a consequence of coupling to translation.

Human beta and delta globin messenger RNAs turn over at different rates

We have tested the hypothesis of Winslow & Ingram (1966) that the steady-state levels of human beta and delta globin proteins are determined, in part, by the stabilities of their respective messenger RNAs. Nucleated bone marrow cells were cultured under different RNA "chase" conditions, and samples were harvested at intervals thereafter. The quantities of beta and delta globin mRNA sequences in total RNA from these cells were measured by solution hybridization with specific 32P-labeled DNA probes. The average half-lives of beta and delta globin mRNAs are 16.5 and 4.5 hours, respectively. Both mRNAs are polyadenylated. The rapid turnover of delta globin mRNA accounts, at least in part, for the low level of delta globin mRNA in non-nucleated peripheral blood reticulocytes. The possibility that the rate of mRNA decay is determined by nucleotide sequence signals located in the 3' untranslated region is discussed.

DNA sequesters endogenous mRNA during preparation of crude Escherichia coli extracts for protein synthesis; use of an S60 reduces the sequestered mRNA

High backgrounds of endogenous incorporation of amino acids into protein in crude extracts of Escherichia coli are a consequence of endogenous messenger RNA. This RNA survives the preparation by virtue of protection or sequestering by endogenous DNA. Thus, DNase treatment in the crude extract leads to the elimination of this mRNA, while DNase treatment has no effect on the purified RNA. The endogenous mRNA also appears to be physically associated with DNA on CsCl gradients, and can be largely removed along with DNA by centrifugation of extracts at 60,000g. The top layer above a 60,000g centrifugation (S60) appears to be suitable for protein synthesis, and provides for lower background levels of endogenous messenger RNA.