Isolation and structural analysis of the Escherichia coli trp leader paused transcription complex

Bacteroides expand the functional versatility of a universal transcription factor and transcribed DNA to program capsule diversity

Human gut Bacteroides species encode numerous (eight or more) tightly regulated capsular polysaccharides (CPS). Specialized paralogs of the universal transcription elongation factor NusG, called UpxY (Y), and an anti-Y UpxZ (Z) are encoded by the first two genes of each CPS operon. The Y-Z regulators combine with promoter inversions to limit CPS transcription to a single operon in most cells. Y enhances transcript elongation whereas Z inhibits noncognate Ys. How Y distinguishes among cognate CPS operons and how Z inhibits only noncognate Ys are unknown. Using in-vivo nascent-RNA sequencing and promoter-less in vitro transcription (PIVoT), we establish that Y recognizes a paused RNA polymerase via sequences in both the exposed non-template DNA and the upstream duplex DNA. Y association is aided by novel 'pause-then-escape' nascent RNA hairpins. Z binds non-cognate Ys to directly inhibit Y association. This Y-Z hierarchical regulatory program allows Bacteroides to create CPS subpopulations for optimal fitness.

Investigating the role of RNA structures in transcriptional pausing using in vitro assays and in silico analyses

Transcriptional pausing occurs across the bacterial genome but the importance of this mechanism is still poorly understood. Only few pauses were observed during the previous decades, leaving an important gap in understanding transcription mechanisms. Using the well-known Escherichia coli hisL and trpL pause sites as models, we describe here the relation of pause sites with upstream RNA structures suspected to stabilize pausing. We find that the transcription factor NusA influences the pause half-life at leuL, pheL and thrL pause sites. Using a mutagenesis approach, we observe that transcriptional pausing is affected in all tested pause sites, suggesting that the upstream RNA sequence is important for transcriptional pausing. Compensatory mutations assessing the presence of RNA hairpins did not yield clear conclusions, indicating that complex RNA structures or transcriptional features may be playing a role in pausing. Moreover, using a bioinformatic approach, we explored the relation between a DNA consensus sequence important for pausing and putative hairpins among thousands of pause sites in E. coli. We identified 2125 sites presenting hairpin-dependent transcriptional pausing without consensus sequence, suggesting that this mechanism is widespread across E. coli. This study paves the way to understand the role of RNA structures in transcriptional pausing.

New discoveries linking transcription to DNA repair and damage tolerance pathways

In Escherichia coli, the transcription elongation factor NusA is associated with all elongating RNA polymerases where it functions in transcription termination and antitermination. Here, we review our recent results implicating NusA in the recruitment of DNA repair and damage tolerance mechanisms to sites of stalled transcription complexes.

RNA transcript 3'-proximal sequence affects translocation bias of RNA polymerase

Translocation of RNA polymerase on DNA is thought to involve oscillations between pretranslocated and posttranslocated states that are rectified by nucleotide addition or pyrophosphorolysis. The pretranslocated register is also a precursor to transcriptional pause states that mediate regulation of transcript elongation. However, the determinants of bias between the pretranslocated and posttranslocated states are incompletely understood. To investigate translocation bias in multisubunit RNA polymerases, we measured rates of pyrophosphorolysis, which occurs in the pretranslocated register, in minimal elongation complexes containing T. thermophilus or E. coli RNA polymerase. Our results suggest that the identity of RNA:DNA nucleotides in the active site are strong determinants of susceptibility to pyrophosphorolysis, and thus translocation bias, with the 3' RNA nucleotide favoring the pretranslocated state in the order U > C > A > G. The preference of 3' U vs G for the pretranslocated register appeared to be universal among both bacterial and eukaryotic RNA polymerases and was confirmed by exonuclease III footprinting of defined elongation complexes. However, the relationship of pyrophosphate concentration to the rate of pyrophosphorolysis of 3' U-containing versus 3' G-containing elongation complexes did not match predictions of a simple mechanism in which 3'-RNA seqeunce affects only translocation bias and pyrophosphate (PPi) binds only to the pretranslocated state.

Roles for the transcription elongation factor NusA in both DNA repair and damage tolerance pathways in Escherichia coli

We report observations suggesting that the transcription elongation factor NusA promotes a previously unrecognized class of transcription-coupled repair (TCR) in addition to its previously proposed role in recruiting translesion synthesis (TLS) DNA polymerases to gaps encountered during transcription. Earlier, we reported that NusA physically and genetically interacts with the TLS DNA polymerase DinB (DNA pol IV). We find that Escherichia coli nusA11(ts) mutant strains, at the permissive temperature, are highly sensitive to nitrofurazone (NFZ) and 4-nitroquinolone-1-oxide but not to UV radiation. Gene expression profiling suggests that this sensitivity is unlikely to be due to an indirect effect on gene expression affecting a known DNA repair or damage tolerance pathway. We demonstrate that an N(2)-furfuryl-dG (N(2)-f-dG) lesion, a structural analog of the principal lesion generated by NFZ, blocks transcription by E. coli RNA polymerase (RNAP) when present in the transcribed strand, but not when present in the nontranscribed strand. Our genetic analysis suggests that NusA participates in a nucleotide excision repair (NER)-dependent process to promote NFZ resistance. We provide evidence that transcription plays a role in the repair of NFZ-induced lesions through the isolation of RNAP mutants that display altered ability to survive NFZ exposure. We propose that NusA participates in an alternative class of TCR involved in the identification and removal of a class of lesion, such as the N(2)-f-dG lesion, which are accurately and efficiently bypassed by DinB in addition to recruiting DinB for TLS at gaps encountered by RNAP.

The NusA N-terminal domain is necessary and sufficient for enhancement of transcriptional pausing via interaction with the RNA exit channel of RNA polymerase

NusA is a core, multidomain regulator of transcript elongation in bacteria and archaea. Bacterial NusA interacts with elongating complexes and the nascent RNA transcript in ways that stimulate pausing and termination but that can be switched to antipausing and antitermination by other accessory proteins. This regulatory complexity of NusA likely depends on its multidomain structure, but it remains unclear which NusA domains possess which regulatory activity and how they interact with elongating RNA polymerase. We used a series of truncated NusA proteins to measure the effect of the NusA domains on transcriptional pausing and termination. We find that the N-terminal domain (NTD) of NusA is necessary and sufficient for enhancement of transcriptional pausing and that the other NusA domains contribute to NusA binding to elongating complexes. Stimulation of intrinsic termination requires higher concentrations of NusA and involves both the NTD and other NusA domains. Using a tethered chemical protease in addition to protein-RNA cross-linking, we show that the NusA NTD contacts the RNA exit channel of RNA polymerase. Finally, we report evidence that the NusA NTD recognizes duplex RNA in the RNA exit channel.

RNA-binding specificity of E. coli NusA

The RNA sequences boxA, boxB and boxC constitute the nut regions of phage λ. They nucleate the formation of a termination-resistant RNA polymerase complex on the λ chromosome. The complex includes E. coli proteins NusA, NusB, NusG and NusE, and the λ N protein. A complex that includes the Nus proteins and other factors forms at the rrn leader. Whereas RNA-binding by NusB and NusE has been described in quantitative terms, the interaction of NusA with these RNA sequences is less defined. Isotropic as well as anisotropic fluorescence equilibrium titrations show that NusA binds only the nut spacer sequence between boxA and boxB. Thus, nutR boxA5-spacer, nutR boxA16-spacer and nutR boxA69-spacer retain NusA binding, whereas a spacer mutation eliminates complex formation. The affinity of NusA for nutL is 50% higher than for nutR. In contrast, rrn boxA, which includes an additional U residue, binds NusA in the absence of spacer. The K_d values obtained for rrn boxA and rrn boxA-spacer are 19-fold and 8-fold lower, respectively, than those for nutR boxA-spacer. These differences may explain why λ requires an additional protein, λ N, to suppress termination. Knowledge of the different affinities now describes the assembly of the anti-termination complex in quantitative terms.

Mechanism of sequence-specific pausing of bacterial RNA polymerase

Sequence-specific pausing of multisubunit RNA polymerases (RNAPs) represents a rate-limiting step during transcription elongation. Pausing occurs on average every 100 bases of DNA. Several models have been proposed to explain pausing, including backtracking of the ternary elongation complex, delay of translocation of the enzyme along DNA, or a conformational change in the active site preventing formation of the phosphodiester bond. Here, we performed biochemical characterization of previously-reported pauses of Escherichia coli RNAP and found that they are not associated with backtracking or a translocation delay. Instead, the paused complex contains the 3' end of the transcript in the active center and is capable of binding the next cognate NTP. However, bond formation occurs much slower in the paused complex compared with its fully-active counterpart. The pausing is dramatically decreased by a substitution of the base encoding the next incoming NTP and the base encoding the 3' end of the nascent RNA, suggesting that (mis)-alignment of the 3' end of the RNA and the incoming NTP in the active site is crucial for pausing. These pause sites are conserved between E. coli and Thermus thermophilus RNAPs, but are not recognized by Saccharomyces cerevisiae RNAP II, indicating that prokaryotic RNAPs might be more sensitive to the changes in the alignment of the nascent transcript and the substrate NTP in the active site.

In vivo dynamics of intracistronic transcriptional polarity

Transcriptional polarity occurs in Escherichia coli when cryptic Rho-dependent transcription terminators become activated as a consequence of reduced translation. Increased spacing between RNA polymerase and the leading ribosome allows the transcription termination factor Rho to bind to mRNA, migrate to the RNA polymerase, and induce termination. Transcriptional polarity results in decreased synthesis of inefficiently translated mRNAs and, therefore, in decreased expression not only of downstream genes in the same operon (intercistronic polarity) but also of the cistron in which termination occurs (intracistronic polarity). To quantitatively measure the effect of different levels of translation on intracistronic transcription termination, the polarity-prone lacZ reporter gene was fused to a range of mutated ribosome binding sites, repressed to different degrees by local RNA structure. The results show that polarity gradually increases with decreasing frequency of translational initiation, as expected. Closer analysis, with the help of a newly developed kinetic model, reveals that efficient intracistronic termination requires very low translational initiation frequencies. This finding is unexpected because Rho is a relatively small protein that binds rapidly to its RNA target, but it appears to be true also for other examples of transcriptional polarity reported in the literature. The conclusion must be that polarity is more complex than just an increased exposure of the Rho binding site as the spacing between the polymerase and the leading ribosome becomes larger. Biological consequences and possible mechanisms are discussed.

Transcriptional modulator NusA interacts with translesion DNA polymerases in Escherichia coli

NusA, a modulator of RNA polymerase, interacts with the DNA polymerase DinB. An increased level of expression of dinB or umuDC suppresses the temperature sensitivity of the nusA11 strain, requiring the catalytic activities of these proteins. We propose that NusA recruits translesion DNA synthesis (TLS) polymerases to RNA polymerases stalled at gaps, coupling TLS to transcription.

A Central Role of the RNA Polymerase Trigger Loop in Active-Site Rearrangement during Transcriptional Pausing

Transcriptional pausing by RNA polymerase is an underlying event in the regulation of transcript elongation, yet the physical changes in the transcribing complex that create the initially paused conformation remain poorly understood. We report that this nonbacktracked elemental pause results from an active-site rearrangement whose signature includes a trigger-loop conformation positioned near the RNA 3' nucleotide and a conformation of betaDloopII that allows fraying of the RNA 3' nucleotide away from the DNA template. During nucleotide addition, trigger-loop movements or folding appears to assist NTP-stimulated translocation and to be crucial for catalysis. At a pause, the trigger loop directly contributes to the paused conformation, apparently by restriction of its movement or folding, whereas a previously postulated unfolding of the bridge helix does not. This trigger-loop-centric model can explain many properties of transcriptional pausing.

Role of E.coli NusA in phage HK022 Nun-mediated transcription termination

The 109 amino acid residue Nun protein expressed from prophage HK022 excludes superinfecting phage lambda by arresting transcription on the lambda chromosome near the lambdanut sites. In vitro, the Nun N terminus binds to nascent lambdanutRNA, whereas the C terminus interacts with RNA polymerase and DNA template. Escherichia coli host factors, NusA, NusB, NusE (S10), and NusG, stimulate Nun-arrest. NusA binds the Nun C terminus and enhances formation of the Nun-nutRNA complex. Because of these in vitro activities of NusA, and since a nusA mutation (nusAE136K) blocked Nun in vivo, we assumed that NusA was required for Nun activity. However, using a nusAts strain, we find that NusA is required for termination at nutR but not at nutL. Furthermore, nusAE136K is dominant to nusA(+) for Nun-arrest, both in vitro and in vivo. NusAE136K shows increased affinity for Nun and, unlike NusA(+), can readily be recovered in a ternary complex with Nun and nutRNA. We propose NusAE136K suppresses Nun-arrest when it is a component of the transcription elongation complex, perhaps, in part, by blocking interactions between the Nun C terminus and RNA polymerase and DNA. We also find that in contrast to Nun-arrest, antitermination by lambda N requires NusA.

Structure of a Mycobacterium tuberculosis NusA-RNA complex

NusA is a key regulator of bacterial transcriptional elongation, pausing, termination and antitermination, yet relatively little is known about the molecular basis of its activity in these fundamental processes. In Mycobacterium tuberculosis, NusA has been shown to bind with high affinity and specificity to BoxB-BoxA-BoxC antitermination sequences within the leader region of the single ribosomal RNA (rRNA) operon. We have determined high-resolution X-ray structures of a complex of NusA with two short oligo-ribonucleotides derived from the BoxC stem-loop motif and have characterised the interaction of NusA with a variety of RNAs derived from the antitermination region. These structures reveal the RNA bound in an extended conformation to a large interacting surface on both KH domains. Combining structural data with observed spectral and calorimetric changes, we now show that NusA binding destabilises secondary structure within rRNA antitermination sequences and propose a model where NusA functions as a chaperone for nascently forming RNA structures.

A quantitative description of the binding states and in vitro function of antitermination protein N of bacteriophage lambda

The N protein of bacteriophage lambda activates transcription of genes that lie downstream of termination sequences by suppressing transcription termination. N binds to specific (boxB) and non-specific sites on the transcript RNA and contacts RNA polymerase via cis-RNA looping, resulting in "antitermination" of transcription. To find the effect of N-boxB binding on antitermination, we quantitatively relate binding measurements made in isolation to in vitro antitermination activity. We measure binding of N to boxB RNA, non-specific single-stranded RNA, and non-specific double-stranded DNA fluorimetrically, and use an equilibrium model to describe quantitatively the binding of N to nucleic acids of Escherichia coli transcription elongation complexes. We then test the model by comparison with in vitro N antitermination activity measured in reactions containing these same elongation complexes. We find that binding of N protein to the nucleic acid components of transcription elongation complexes can quantitatively predict antitermination activity, suggesting that antitermination in vitro is determined by a nucleic acid binding equilibrium with one molecule of N protein per RNA transcript being sufficient for antitermination. Elongation complexes contain numerous overlapping non-specific RNA and DNA-binding sites for N; the large number of sites compensates for the low N binding affinity, so multiple N proteins are expected to bind to elongation complexes. The occupancy/activity of these proteins is described by a binomial distribution of proteins on transcripts containing multiple non-specific sites. The contribution of specific (boxB) binding to activity also depends on this distribution. Specificity is not measured accurately by measurements made in the presence and in the absence of boxB. We find that antitermination is inhibited by non-productive binding of N to non-specific sites on template DNA, and that NusA protein covers RNA sites on the transcript, limiting N access and activity. The activity and specificity of regulatory proteins that loop from high-affinity binding sites are likely modulated by multiple non-specific binding events; in vivo activity may also be regulated by the modulation of non-specific binding.

Structural basis for the interaction of Escherichia coli NusA with protein N of phage lambda

The C terminus of transcription factor NusA from Escherichia coli comprises two repeat units, which bind during antitermination to protein N from phage lambda. To delineate the structural basis of the NusA-lambdaN interaction, we attempted to crystallize the NusA C-terminal repeats in complex with a lambdaN peptide (residues 34-47). The two NusA domains became proteolytically separated during crystallization, and crystals contained two copies of the first repeat unit in contact with a single lambdaN fragment. The NusA modules employ identical regions to contact the peptide but approach the ligand from opposite sides. In contrast to the alpha-helical conformation of the lambdaN N terminus in complex with boxB RNA, residues 34-40 of lambdaN remain extended upon interaction with NusA. Mutational analyses indicated that only one of the observed NusA-lambdaN interaction modes is biologically significant, supporting an equimolar ratio of NusA and lambdaN in antitermination complexes. Solution studies indicated that additional interactions are fostered by the second NusA repeat unit, consistent with known compensatory mutations in NusA and lambdaN. Contrary to the RNA polymerase alpha subunit, lambdaN binding does not stimulate RNA interaction of NusA. The results demonstrate that lambdaN serves as a scaffold to closely oppose NusA and the mRNA in antitermination complexes.

RNA stem-loop enhanced expression of previously non-expressible genes

The key step in bacterial translation is formation of the pre-initiation complex. This requires initial contacts between mRNA, fMet-tRNA and the 30S subunit of the ribosome, steps that limit the initiation of translation. Here we report a method for improving translational initiation, which allows expression of several previously non-expressible genes. This method has potential applications in heterologous protein synthesis and high-throughput expression systems. We introduced a synthetic RNA stem-loop (stem length, 7 bp; DeltaG(0) = -9.9 kcal/mol) in front of various gene sequences. In each case, the stem-loop was inserted 15 nt downstream from the start codon. Insertion of the stem-loop allowed in vitro expression of five previously non-expressible genes and enhanced the expression of all other genes investigated. Analysis of the RNA structure proved that the stem-loop was formed in vitro, and demonstrated that stabilization of the ribosome binding site is due to stem-loop introduction. By theoretical RNA structure analysis we showed that the inserted RNA stem-loop suppresses long-range interactions between the translation initiation domain and gene-specific mRNA sequences. Thus the inserted RNA stem-loop supports the formation of a separate translational initiation domain, which is more accessible to ribosome binding.

Crystal structure of NusA from Thermotoga maritima and functional implication of the N-terminal domain

We report the crystal structure of N-utilizing substance A protein (NusA) from Thermotoga maritima (TmNusA), a protein involved in transcriptional pausing, termination, and antitermination. TmNusA has an elongated rod-shaped structure consisting of an N-terminal domain (NTD, residues 1-132) and three RNA binding domains (RBD). The NTD consists of two subdomains, the globular head and the helical body domains, that comprise a unique three-dimensional structure that may be important for interacting with RNA polymerase. The globular head domain possesses a high content of negatively charged residues that may interact with the positively charged flaplike domain of RNA polymerase. The helical body domain is composed of a three-helix bundle that forms a hydrophobic core with the aid of two neighboring beta-strands. This domain shows structural similarity with one of the helical domains of sigma(70) factor from Escherichia coli. One side of the molecular surface shows positive electrostatic potential suitable for nonspecific RNA interaction. The RBD is composed of one S1 domain and two K-homology (KH) domains forming an elongated RNA binding surface. Structural comparison between TmNusA and Mycobacterium tuberculosis NusA reveals a possible hinge motion between NTD and RBD. In addition, a functional implication of the NTD in its interaction with RNA polymerase is discussed.

Downstream DNA sequence effects on transcription elongation. Allosteric binding of nucleoside triphosphates facilitates translocation via a ratchet motion

The ability of RNA polymerase (RNAP) to adopt multiple conformations is central to transcriptional regulation. In previous work, we demonstrated that RNAP can exist in an unactivated state that catalyzes synthesis slowly and an activated state that catalyzes synthesis rapidly, with the transition from the unactivated to the activated state being induced by the templated NTP binding to an allosteric site on the RNAP. In this work, we investigate the effects of downstream DNA sequences on the kinetics of single nucleotide incorporation. We demonstrate that changing the identity of the DNA base 1 bp downstream (+2) from the site of incorporation (+1) can regulate the catalytic activity of RNAP. Combining these data with sequence and structural analyses and molecular modeling, we identify the streptolydigin-binding region (Escherichia coli beta residues 543-546), which lies across from the downstream DNA, as the putative allosteric NTP binding site. We present a structural model in which the NTP binds to the streptolydigin loop and upon pairing with the +1 DNA base in the unactivated state or the +2 DNA base in the activated state facilitates translocation via a ratchet motion. This model provides an alternative mechanism for pausing as well as a structural explanation not only for our kinetic data but also for data from elongation studies on yeast RNAP II.

Interactions of an Arg-rich region of transcription elongation protein NusA with NUT RNA: implications for the order of assembly of the lambda N antitermination complex in vivo

The E. coli NusA transcription elongation protein (NusA(Ec)), identified because of its requirement for transcription antitermination by the N protein, has an Arg-rich S1 RNA-binding domain. A complex of N and NusA with other host factors binding at NUT sites in the RNA renders RNA polymerase termination-resistant. An E. coli haploid for nusA944, having nine different codons replacing four normally found in the Arg-rich region, is defective in support of N action. Another variant, haploid for the nusAR199A allele, with a change in a highly conserved Arg codon in the S1 domain, effectively supports N-mediated antitermination. However, nusAR199A is recessive to nusA944, while nusA(Ec) is dominant to nusA944 for support of N-mediated antitermination, suggesting a competition between NusA944 and NusAR199A during complex formation. Complex formation with the variant NusA proteins was assessed by mobility gel shifts. NusAR199A, unlike NusA(Ec) and NusA944, fails to form a complex with N and NUT RNA. However, while NusAR199A, like wild-type NusA, forms an enlarged complex with NUT RNA, N, RNA polymerase, and other host proteins required for efficient N-mediated antitermination, NusA944 does not form this enlarged complex. Consistent with the in vivo results, NusA944 prevents NusAR199A but not NusA(Ec) from forming the enlarged complex. The simplest conclusion from these dominance studies is that in the formation of the complete active antitermination complex in vivo, NusA and N binding to the newly synthesized NUT RNA precedes addition of the other factors. Alternative less effective routes to the active complex that allows bypass of this preferred pathway may also exist.

The alpha subunit of E. coli RNA polymerase activates RNA binding by NusA

The Escherichia coli NusA protein modulates pausing, termination, and antitermination by associating with the transcribing RNA polymerase core enzyme. NusA can be covalently cross-linked to nascent RNA within a transcription complex, but does not bind RNA on its own. We have found that deletion of the 79 carboxy-terminal amino acids of the 495-amino-acid NusA protein allows NusA to bind RNA in gel mobility shift assays. The carboxy-terminal domain (CTD) of the alpha subunit of RNA polymerase, as well as the bacteriophage lambda N gene antiterminator protein, bind to carboxy-terminal regions of NusA and enable full-length NusA to bind RNA. Binding of NusA to RNA in the presence of alpha or N involves an amino-terminal S1 homology region that is otherwise inactive in full-length NusA. The interaction of the alpha-CTD with full-length NusA stimulates termination. N may prevent termination by inducing NusA to interact with N utilization (nut) site RNA rather than RNA near the 3' end of the nascent transcript. Sequence analysis showed that the alpha-CTD contains a modified helix-hairpin-helix motif (HhH), which is also conserved in the carboxy-terminal regions of some eubacterial NusA proteins. These HhH motifs may mediate protein-protein interactions in NusA and the alpha-CTD.

Pausing by bacterial RNA polymerase is mediated by mechanistically distinct classes of signals

Transcript elongation by RNA polymerase is discontinuous and interrupted by pauses that play key regulatory roles. We show here that two different classes of pause signals punctuate elongation. Class I pauses, discovered in enteric bacteria, depend on interaction of a nascent RNA structure with RNA polymerase to displace the 3' OH away from the catalytic center. Class II pauses, which may predominate in eukaryotes, cause RNA polymerase to slide backwards along DNA and RNA and to occlude the active site with nascent RNA. These pauses differ in their responses to antisense oligonucleotides, pyrophosphate, GreA, and general elongation factors NusA and NusG. In contrast, substitutions in RNA polymerase that increase or decrease the rate of RNA synthesis affect both pause classes similarly. We propose that both pause classes, as well as arrest and termination, arise from a common intermediate that itself binds NTP substrate weakly.

DNA melting and promoter clearance by eukaryotic RNA polymerase I

Ribosomal RNA transcription initiation requires the melting of DNA to form an open complex, formation of the first few phosphodiester bonds, commencement of RNA polymerase I movement along the DNA, clearance of the promoter, and the formation of a steady-state ternary elongation complex. We examined DNA melting and promoter clearance by using potassium permanganate, diethylpyrocarbonate and methidiumpropylEDTA.Fe(II) footprinting. In combination, these methods demonstrated: (1) TIF-IB and RNA polymerase I are the only proteins required for formation of an initial approximately 9 base-pair open promoter region. This finding contradicts earlier results using diethylpyrocarbonate alone, which suggested an RNA synthesis requirement for stable melting. (2) DNA melting is temperature-dependent, with a tm between 15 and 20 degrees C. (3) Temperature-dependency of melting, as well as stalling the polymerase at sites close to the transcription start site revealed that the melted DNA region initially opens upstream of the transcription initiation site, and enlarges in a downstream direction coordinate with initiation, eventually attaining a steady-state transcription bubble of approximately 19 base-pairs. (4) The RNA-DNA hybrid protects the template DNA from single-strand footprinting reagents. The hybrid is 9 bp in length, consistent with the longer hybrid estimated by some for the Escherichia coli polymerase and with the hybrids estimated for eukaryotic polymerases II and III.

Functional importance of regions in Escherichia coli elongation factor NusA that interact with RNA polymerase, the bacteriophage lambda N protein and RNA

The association of the essential Escherichia coli protein NusA with RNA polymerase increases pausing and the efficiency of termination at intrinsic terminators. NusA is also part of the phage lambda N protein-modified antitermination complex that functions to prevent transcriptional termination. We have investigated the structure of NusA using various deletion fragments of NusA in a variety of in vitro assays. Sequence and structural alignments have suggested that NusA has both S1 and KH homology regions that are thought to bind RNA. We show here that the portion of NusA containing the S1 and KH homology regions is important for NusA to enhance both termination and antitermination. There are two RNA polymerase-binding regions in NusA, one in the amino-terminal 137 amino acids and the other in the carboxy-terminal 264 amino acids; only the amino-terminal RNA polymerase-binding region provides a functional contact that enhances termination at an intrinsic terminator or antitermination by N. The carboxy-terminal region of NusA is also required for interaction with N and is important for the formation of an N-NusA-nut site or N-NusA-RNA polymerase-nut site complex; the instability of complexes lacking this carboxy-terminal region of NusA that binds N and RNA polymerase can be compensated for by the presence of the additional E. coli elongation factors, NusB, NusG and ribosomal protein S10.

Folding of a large ribozyme during transcription and the effect of the elongation factor NusA

We compared in vitro transcription-initiated folding of the ribozyme from Bacillus subtilis RNase P to refolding from the full-length, denatured state by monitoring the appearance of its catalytic activity. At 37 degrees C, Mg(2+)-initiated refolding of the wild type and a circularly permutate ribozyme takes minutes and is limited by a kinetic trap. Transcription by T7 RNA polymerase alters the folding pathway of both RNAs and introduces new kinetic traps. Transcription by the core Escherichia coli RNA polymerase yields the same result, in spite of its 4-fold-slower elongation rate. However, the presence of its elongation factor NusA accelerates more than 10-fold the transcription-initiated folding of the circularly, permutated ribozyme by E. coli RNA polymerase. The effect of NusA likely is caused by its enhancement of transcriptional pausing because NusA did not accelerate transcription-initiated folding using a mutant RNA polymerase that failed to pause or respond to NusA during ribozyme synthesis. We conclude that both transcription and specific pausing therein can alter RNA-folding pathways.

Escherichia coli RNA polymerase terminates transcription efficiently at rho-independent terminators on single-stranded DNA templates

Several models have been proposed for the mechanism of transcript termination by Escherichia coli RNA polymerase at rho-independent terminators. Yager and von Hippel (Yager, T. D. & von Hippel, P. H. (1991) Biochemistry 30, 1097-118) postulated that the transcription complex is stabilized by enzyme-nucleic acid interactions and the favorable free energy of a 12-bp RNA-DNA hybrid but is destabilized by the free energy required to maintain an extended transcription bubble. Termination, by their model, is viewed simply as displacement of the RNA transcript from the hybrid helix by reformation of the DNA helix. We have proposed an alternative model where the RNA transcript is stably bound to RNA polymerase primarily through interactions with two single-strand specific RNA-binding sites; termination is triggered by formation of an RNA hairpin that reduces binding of the RNA to one RNA-binding site and, ultimately, leads to its ejection from the complex. To distinguish between these models, we have tested whether E. coli RNA polymerase can terminate transcription at rho-independent terminators on single-stranded DNA. RNA polymerase cannot form a transcription bubble on these templates; thus, the Yager-von Hippel model predicts that intrinsic termination will not occur. We find that transcript elongation on single-stranded DNA templates is hindered somewhat by DNA secondary structure. However, E. coli RNA polymerase efficiently terminates and releases transcripts at several rho-independent terminators on such templates at the same positions as termination occurs on duplex DNAs. Therefore, neither the nontranscribed DNA strand nor the transcription bubble is essential for rho-independent termination by E. coli RNA polymerase.

Regulation of the elongation-termination decision at intrinsic terminators by antitermination protein N of phage lambda

The mechanisms that control N-protein-dependent antitermination in the phage lambda life cycle have counterparts in the regulatory systems of other organisms. Here we examine N-dependent antitermination at the intrinsic tR' terminator of lambda to elucidate the regulatory principles involved. The tR' terminator consists of a sequence of six base-pairs along the template at which the transcription complex is sufficiently destabilized to make RNA release possible. Within this "zone of opportunity" for termination the termination efficiency (TE) at each template position is determined by a kinetic competition between alternative reaction pathways that lead either to elongation or to termination. TE values at each position within tR' have been mapped as a function of NTP concentration, and it is shown that N protein (in the presence of NusA and a nut site; the minimal system for N-dependent antitermination) can offset increases in TE that are induced by limiting the concentrations of each of the next required NTPs. By limiting NTP concentrations or working at low temperature we show that a significant effect of N within the minimal system is to increase the rate of transcript elongation three- to fivefold at most positions along the template. Assuming that a comparable increase in elongation rate applies at template positions within the terminator, we show that an increase of this magnitude is not sufficient to account for the antitermination efficiency observed and that an approximately 100-fold stabilization of the transcription complex at intrinsic termination sites as a consequence of binding the N-containing antitermination sub-assembly must be invoked as well. A general method for partitioning TE effects in antitermination between changes in elongation rate and termination complex stability is demonstrated, based on competing free energy of activation barriers for the elongation and termination reactions. The analysis and utility of such mixed modes of transcriptional regulation are considered in general terms.

Preferential interaction of the his pause RNA hairpin with RNA polymerase beta subunit residues 904-950 correlates with strong transcriptional pausing

RNA secondary structures (hairpins) that form as the nascent RNA emerges from RNA polymerase are important components of many signals that regulate transcription, including some pause sites, all rho-independent terminators, and some antiterminators. At the his leader pause site, a 5-bp-stem, 8-nt-loop pause RNA hairpin forms 11 nt from the RNA 3' end and stabilizes a transcription complex conformation slow to react with NTP substrate. This stabilization appears to depend at least in part on an interaction with RNA polymerase. We tested for RNA hairpin interaction with the paused polymerase by crosslinking 5-iodoUMP positioned specifically in the hairpin loop. In the paused conformation, strong and unusual crosslinking of the pause hairpin to beta904-950 replaced crosslinking to beta' and to other parts of beta that occurred in nonpaused complexes prior to hairpin formation. These changes in nascent RNA interactions may inhibit reactive alignment of the RNA 3' end in the paused complex and be related to events at rho-independent terminators.

Multiple interactions stabilize a single paused transcription intermediate in which hairpin to 3' end spacing distinguishes pause and termination pathways

Transcription is delayed in the leader regions of the Escherichia coli trp and his operons by multipartite pause signals that consist of four components: a nascent RNA structure (the pause hairpin), the 10 or 11 nt 3'-proximal region between the pause hairpin and the RNA 3' end, the bases in the active site, and approximately 14 bp of duplex DNA downstream from the pause site. Results described in the accompanying paper suggest that the his pause hairpin slows nucleotide addition via interaction with an easily disordered surface on RNA polymerase. Here we report that the four pause signal components slow nucleotide addition in a single kinetic intermediate. Formation of the paused transcription complex, in contrast, involves synergistic effects of RNA and DNA sequences that select the wild-type pause site from among several adjacent possibilities. Extending the pause hairpin with one G x C base-pair reduces pausing, apparently by interfering with pause hairpin interaction; adding a second C x G base-pair that reduces the 3'-proximal RNA to 9 nt or less (within the 7 to 9 nt characteristic of rho-independent terminators) induces transcript release. We propose that escape from the pause is governed by a rate-limiting isomerization that may require substrate NTP binding to re-establish the active site geometry, whereas transcript release and termination ensue when the hairpin interaction is weakened and isomerization to an active conformation is blocked.

Nuclease cleavage of the upstream half of the nontemplate strand DNA in an Escherichia coli transcription elongation complex causes upstream translocation and transcriptional arrest

We tested the susceptibility of nucleic acid strands in a halted transcription elongation complex to digestion by micrococcal nuclease (MN). The 16-nucleotide nascent RNA was protected within RNA polymerase. A 27-28-nucleotide template strand DNA fragment also was resistant to MN digestion. However, the upstream half of the nontemplate DNA within this region was digested rapidly by MN, suggesting that the nontemplate strand emerges from the RNA polymerase near the middle of the melted transcription bubble with the bases oriented away from the enzyme surface. MN cleavage of the exposed nontemplate DNA shifted polymerase backward, making it unable to extend the RNA chain. However, the MN-trimmed G16 complexes could be reactivated by GreB-stimulated cleavage of the nascent RNA. These results favor a model of transcriptional arrest involving upstream slippage of RNA polymerase along the RNA and DNA chains. They also suggest that the exposed segment of nontemplate DNA may directly or indirectly stabilize the lateral position of the transcription complex along the DNA.

Discontinuous movements of DNA and RNA in RNA polymerase accompany formation of a paused transcription complex

A central enigma of transcriptional regulation is how the normally efficient transcription elongation complex stops at pause and termination signals. One possibility, raised by the discovery that RNA polymerase sometimes contracts its DNA footprint, is that discontinuous movements contribute to recognizing these signals. We report that E. coli RNA polymerase responds to sequences immediately downstream and upstream from the his leader pause site by changing neither its downstream DNA contact nor its upstream RNA contact for 8 bp preceding the pause. This compressed complex isomerizes to a paused conformation by an approximately 10 bp jump of its downstream DNA contact and simultaneous extrusion of an RNA hairpin that stabilizes the paused conformation. We suggest pausing and termination could be alternative outcomes of a similar isomerization that depend on the strength of contacts to 3'-proximal RNA remaining after the jump.

Bipartite function of a small RNA hairpin in transcription antitermination in bacteriophage lambda

Transcription of downstream genes in the early operons of phage lambda requires a promoter-proximal element known as nut. This site acts in cis in the form of RNA to assemble a transcription antitermination complex which is composed of lambda N protein and at least four host factors. The nut-site RNA contains a small stem-loop structure called boxB. Here, we show that boxB RNA binds to N protein with high affinity and specificity. While N binding is confined to the 5' subdomain of the stem-loop, specific N recognition relies on both an intact stem-loop structure and two critical nucleotides in the pentamer loop. Substitutions of these nucleotides affect both N binding and antitermination. Remarkably, substitutions of other loop nucleotides also diminish antitermination in vivo, yet they have no detectable effect on N binding in vitro. These 3' loop mutants fail to support antitermination in a minimal system with RNA polymerase (RNAP), N, and the host factor NusA. Furthermore, the ability of NusA to stimulate the formation of the RNAP-boxB-N complex is diminished with these mutants. Hence, we suggest that boxB RNA performs two critical functions in antitermination. First, boxB binds to N and secures it near RNAP to enhance their interaction, presumably by increasing the local concentration of N. Second, boxB cooperates with NusA, most likely to bring N and RNAP in close contact and transform RNAP to the termination-resistant state.

NusA changes the conformation of Escherichia coli RNA polymerase at the binding site for the 3' end of the nascent RNA

A conformational change in Escherichia coli RNA polymerase induced by NusA was detected by utilizing photocrosslinking. A change in the binding site for the 3' end of the RNA occurred, and NusA increased interactions of the RNA with the beta subunit of the polymerase. NusA was not contacted by the 3' end of the RNA.

The KH domain occurs in a diverse set of RNA-binding proteins that include the antiterminator NusA and is probably involved in binding to nucleic acid

New findings are presented for the approximately 50 residue KH motif, a domain recently discovered in RNA-binding proteins. The conserved sequence is approximately 10 residues larger than previously reported. Profile searches have revealed new members of this family, including two, E. coli NusA and human GAP-associated p62 phosphoprotein, for which RNA-binding data exists. A nusA homolog was detected in the RNA polymerase gene complex of six archaebacterial species and may encode an antiterminator. All KH-containing proteins are linked with RNA and the KH motif most probably functions as a nucleic acid binding domain.

Synthesis and characterization of a new photocrosslinking CTP analog and its use in photoaffinity labeling E. coli and T7 RNA polymerases

A new photocrosslinking CTP analog that functioned as a substrate during transcription was synthesized and used to photoaffinity label E. coli and bacteriophage T7 RNA polymerases. This analog, 5-((4-azidophenacyl)thio) cytidine-5'-triphosphate (5-APAS-CTP) contains an aryl azide group approximately 10 A from the nucleotide base and specifically replaced CTP during synthesis of RNA by both polymerases. Analog was placed at the 3' end or internally within RNA. Both polymerases inefficiently incorporated two 5-APAS-CMP molecules sequentially, as was found for the related 5-APAS-UMP. Analog was placed at the 3' end of RNA in transcription complexes paused at the site of Q-modification of E. coli RNA polymerase, downstream of the lambda PR' promoter (+16), a pause that requires specific DNA sequences but no apparent RNA hairpin. Crosslinking was examined in the presence and absence of the NusA protein, which enhances the transcriptional pause at this site and is required for Q modification of the polymerase. Crosslinking of the 3' end of the RNA to NusA was not observed, consistent with our earlier results involving a NusA-enhanced pause site downstream from an RNA hairpin.

Transcription termination

Chromosomes are organized into units of expression that are bounded by sites where transcription of DNA sequences into RNA is initiated and terminated. To allow for efficient stepwise assembly of complete transcripts, the transcribing enzyme (RNA polymerase) makes a stable complex with the DNA template until it reaches the terminator. Three general mechanisms of transcription termination have been recognized: one is by a spontaneous dissociation of the RNA at a sequence segment where RNA polymerase does not maintain its usual stable interaction with the nascent chain; another involves the action of a protein (rho factor in bacteria) on the nascent RNA to mediate its dissociation; and a third involves an action triggered by a protein that binds to the DNA at a sequence that is just downstream of the termination stop point. Transcription termination is important in the regulation of gene expression both by modulating the relative levels of various genes within a single unit of expression and by controlling continuation of transcription in response to a metabolic or regulatory signal.

Structure of RNA and DNA chains in paused transcription complexes containing Escherichia coli RNA polymerase

RNA polymerases pause conspicuously at certain positions on a DNA template. At the well-studied pause sites in the attenuation control regions that precede the trp and his operons, both formation of secondary structure in the nascent transcript and the DNA sequence immediately downstream contribute to pausing. The mechanisms of these effects are unknown. We report here studies on the structure of the RNA and DNA strands in purified trp and his paused transcription complexes in comparison to ten elongation complexes halted by nucleoside triphosphate deprivation. A 14 to 22 nucleotide region of the DNA strands was accessible to modification by KMnO4 or diethylpyrocarbonate in both the paused and halted transcription complexes. However, the region in front of the nucleotide-addition site was reactive only in some halted complexes. In both types of complexes, approximately eight nucleotides on the template strand immediately preceding the 3' end were protected from modification. We also examined the sensitivity of the nascent transcript to RNase A and found that the 3'-proximal eight nucleotide region could be cleaved without complete loss of the potential for elongation. However, a model RNA:DNA hybrid designed to mimic a hybrid in the transcription complex could also be cleaved under similar conditions. Together, the results suggest that the 3'-proximal eight nucleotides of transcript may pair with the DNA template and that this structure is not disrupted by hairpin formation at a pause site. Rather, pausing may result from distinct interactions between RNA polymerase and both the pause RNA hairpin and the downstream DNA sequence.

Parameters affecting transcription termination by Escherichia coli RNA polymerase

Escherichia coli RNA polymerase can terminate transcription efficiently at rho-independent terminators in a purified transcription system in the absence of accessory factors. This process of "intrinsic termination" involves direct recognition of the terminator by the core RNA polymerase, and provides an important model system for the study of the molecular interactions involved in the switch between elongation and termination. We have analyzed the intrinsic termination efficiency (%T) of 13 rho-independent terminators, under a variety of in vitro reaction conditions. Although all of these sites share the general sequence features of typical rho-independent terminators, we find a wide range of %T (2% to 90%) for the different sites under our standard transcription conditions. While %T for a particular site is characteristic of that site, the efficiency can be altered considerably by the nature and concentration of salts in the reaction, by alteration of the concentrations of the nucleoside triphosphate substrates, or by transcription from supercoiled rather than linear templates. Surprisingly, different conditions can alter %T to a different extent for different terminators. For neutral salts such as potassium chloride or potassium glutamate, changes in the range from 0.1 to 1 M affect %T for different terminators in a distinct manner, depending on the terminator and the anion involved. At some sites, %T is greatly increased by Cl- concentrations up to 1 M, while at other sites %T is reduced or unaffected by these conditions. At some sites K+ concentrations up to 1 M give a modest increase in %T, while at other sites %T is slightly reduced under the same conditions. Thus the actual values of %T, as well as the order of terminator sites ranked according to %T, can be altered greatly according to the choice of reaction conditions. Reduction of the Mg2+ concentration below 1 mM has a dramatic and quite different effect, enhancing termination to approximately 100% for all terminators tested. Transcription of supercoiled DNA templates gives somewhat reduced %T as compared with linear DNA templates. However, the effect is no greater than twofold. Our results are not consistent with those expected for models in which %T is determined by the differential stability of DNA, RNA and hybrid duplex structures at the melted region in the transcription complex. Thus, the Cl anion does not affect the stability of nucleic acid duplexes even at 1 M concentrations, but can enhance termination tenfold. Also, the alterations of monovalent cation concentration that affect %T are not expected to have a differential effect on Tm for DNA, RNA and hybrid duplexes.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

Transcript hairpin structures are not required for RNA polymerase pausing in the gene encoding the E. coli RNase P RNA, M1 RNA

Strong pauses at nucleotides +118 and +121 relative to the transcriptional start occur during in vitro transcription of the E. coli rnpB gene encoding the catalytic M1 RNA subunit of Ribonuclease P. These pauses are immediately downstream of 2 phylogenetically conserved stem-loop structures in the RNA. In the present work, single-base changes which disrupted Watson-Crick base-pairing in the hairpins were introduced into rnpB. Transcription studies in vitro with these modified templates revealed that none of the nucleotide changes predicted to increase or decrease the stability of the first hairpin significantly affected the pause half-lives. A mutation which disrupted the second hairpin increased the pause half-life 2-fold. The data suggest that the upstream stem and loop structures in the transcript are not involved in the pausing event.

Transcription by single molecules of RNA polymerase observed by light microscopy

The kinetics of transcription by Escherichia coli RNA polymerase relate directly to the regulation of transcription and to the properties of processive enzymes in general, but analysis of RNA polymerase movement along the DNA template has so far been limited to the study of populations of enzyme molecules. The ability to view nanometre-sized particles with the light microscope suggested a method of monitoring transcription by individual RNA polymerase molecules. We describe here the behaviour of 40-nm-diameter particles of colloidal gold attached to the ends of DNA molecules being transcribed by RNA polymerase immobilized on a glass surface. The tethered gold particles are released from the surface at times after addition of nucleoside triphosphates that are consistent with the kinetics of transcription by RNA polymerase in solution. Analysis of the brownian motion of the gold particles enabled us to measure the movement along the template DNA of individual polymerase molecules.

Escherichia coli sigma 70 and NusA proteins. I. Binding interactions with core RNA polymerase in solution and within the transcription complex

This paper describes the binding interactions of Escherichia coli transcription factors sigma 70 and NusA with core RNA polymerase, both free in solution and as a part of the functional transcription complex. High pressure liquid chromatography gel filtration and fluorescence techniques have been used to monitor the binding of these factors to core polymerase in solution at salt concentrations roughly comparable to the in vivo environment (250 mM-KCl, 50 mM-potassium phosphate (pH 7.5]; under these conditions all the interacting species exist separately as protein monomers. We find that sigma 70 and NusA binds competitively to core polymerase with a 1:1 binding stoichiometry in this milieu, and that NusA does not bind to the polymerase holoenzyme. Association constants of approximately 2 x 10(9) and 1 x 10(7) M-1 have been measured for the sigma 70-core polymerase interaction and for the NusA-core polymerase interaction, respectively. These findings are consistent with the original formulation of the NusA-sigma 70 cycle put forward by Greenblatt & Li, and provide the basis for a further (and preliminary) quantitative examination of these same interactions within the transcription complex. We use a number of molecular biological techniques, together with data from the literature, to estimate these binding constants in various phases of the transcription cycle. In keeping with our results in solution, we find that the effective binding affinity of sigma 70 for core polymerase within the "open" promoter-polymerase complex is at least 500-fold greater than that of NusA. As the transcription complex moves from the initiation to the elongation phase these relative binding affinities are reversed; the average association constant of NusA for the core polymerase in the elongation complex remains practically the same as in free solution (approx. 3 x 10(7) M-1), while the affinity of sigma 70 for core polymerase in this complex drops to less than 5 x 10(5) M-1. These results are used to begin to define the basic conformational states and interaction potentials of core polymerase in the various stages of the transcription cycle.

RNA-protein interactions in a Nus A-containing Escherichia coli transcription complex paused at an RNA hairpin

We have isolated Escherichia coli transcription complexes, paused in the presence and absence of Nus A, which contain RNA substituted at every UMP residue with a photocrosslinking nucleotide analog. The pause site is immediately downstream from an RNA stem-loop structure, and although pausing occurs in the absence of Nus A, it is substantially enhanced in the presence of Nus A. We have analyzed the secondary structure of this RNA and show that the analog does not interfere with the formation of the normal stem-loop structures. Additionally, the analog substrate does not alter transcriptional pausing, in the presence or absence of Nus A, indicating that Nus A recognition of the transcription complex is not affected by the presence of the crosslinking groups in the RNA. Ribonuclease digestion of the RNA in paused complexes identifies two accessible regions, two nucleotides in the loop and one near the base of the upstream side of the stem-loop. Cleavage at one loop nucleotide is enhanced by Nus A, while the nucleotide near the base of the stem-loop is partially protected. Upon irradiation of the transcription complex, Nus A is not photoaffinity labeled by the RNA, even at a high molar ration to RNA polymerase (250:1). Both the beta and beta' subunits are labeled, however, indicating that the putative stem-loop binding domain on the core polymerase involves both subunits. Because the nucleotide protected from ribonuclease by Nus A is very near two analogs, yet Nus A is not crosslinked to the RNA, it is unlikely that Nus A could be protecting this position through direct contact. Furthermore, analog is substituted at positions in both the loop and at several positions in the stem, and again, no crosslinking to Nus A is observed. We conclude that enhancement of pausing by Nus A probably does not require direct interaction with the bases in the RNA stem-loop.

Isolation and footprint analysis of the Escherichia coli thr leader paused transcription complex

The E. coli thr operon leader region contains a cluster of transcription pause sites upstream of the attenuator. In this report, we determine the exact sites of pausing and analyze the structure of the ternary complex by footprint techniques. Under synchronized transcription initiation conditions in vitro, three closely-spaced transcription pause sites were identified. These pause sites appeared downstream of the first region of dyad symmetry, which encodes an RNA hairpin in the transcript, and occurred at positions G112, G114 and A116 of the thr leader RNA. The results showed that the half-life of the thr paused complexes at G112 and G114 could be enhanced by limiting the concentration of the nucleoside triphosphate GTP in the transcription reactions. In addition, the half-life of the paused complexes was shown to increase in the presence of NusA protein. The thr leader complex that paused immediately before residues G112 and G114 of the nascent transcript was isolated and its structure was analyzed with enzymatic and chemical cleavage reagents. The footprinting studies using DNase I showed that there were approximately 35 nucleotides on both strands of the DNA that were protected by RNA polymerase from DNase I cleavage. The DNA segment protected by RNA polymerase is approximately 19 nucleotides upstream and 14 nucleotides downstream of the pause sites. The results from hydroxyl radical footprints also showed a similar pattern of protection at the transcription pause sites. However, no significant differences in the footprinting patterns were observed in the presence or absence of NusA protein.

Transcriptional antitermination in the bgl operon of E. coli is modulated by a specific RNA binding protein

Regulation of bgl operon expression in E. coli occurs by a mechanism involving antitermination of transcription at two termination sites within the operon. The bglG gene product is absolutely required for this process. Here we provide evidence that BglG is an RNA binding protein that recognizes a specific sequence located just upstream of each of the terminators. The sequence was delimited using a series of specific oligonucleotide probes. Mutational analysis of this sequence indicates that the protein requires a specific RNA secondary structure for recognition. We propose that BglG prevents transcription termination by binding to nascent RNA and blocking formation of the terminator structure.