Chromatin reconstitution on small DNA rings. I

An analytical method to connect open curves for modeling protein-bound DNA minicircles

We introduce an analytical method to generate the pathway of a closed protein-bound DNA minicircle. We develop an analytical equation to connect two open curves smoothly and use the derived expressions to join the ends of two helical pathways and form models of nucleosome-decorated DNA minicircles. We find that the simplest smooth connector which satisfies the boundary conditions at the end points and the length requirement for such connections to be a quartic function on the xy-plane and linear along the z-direction. This is a general method which can be used to connect any two open curves with well defined mathematical definitions as well as pairs of discrete systems found experimentally. We used this method to describe the configurations of torsionally relaxed, 360-base pair DNA rings with two evenly-spaced, ideal nucleosomes. We considered superhelical nucleosomal pathways with different levels of DNA wrapping and allowed for different inter-nucleosome orientations. We completed the DNA circles with the smooth connectors and studied the associated bending and electrostatic energies for different configurations in the absence and presence of salt. The predicted stable states bear close resemblance to reconstituted minicircles observed under low and high salt conditions.

Small extrachromosomal circular DNAs, microDNA, produce short regulatory RNAs that suppress gene expression independent of canonical promoters

Interest in extrachromosomal circular DNA (eccDNA) molecules has increased recently because of their widespread presence in normal cells across every species ranging from yeast to humans, their increased levels in cancer cells and their overlap with oncogenic and drug-resistant genes. However, the majority of eccDNA (microDNA) in mammalian tissues and cell lines are too small to carry protein coding genes. We have tested functional capabilities of microDNA by creating artificial microDNA molecules mimicking known microDNA sequences and have discovered that they express functional small regulatory RNA including microRNA and novel si-like RNA. MicroDNA are transcribed in vitro and in vivo independent of a canonical promoter sequence. MicroDNA that carry miRNA genes form transcripts that are processed by the endogenous RNA-interference pathway into mature miRNA molecules, which repress a luciferase reporter gene as well as endogenous mRNA targets of the miRNA. Further, microDNA that contain sequences of exons repress the endogenous gene from which the microDNA were derived through the formation of novel si-like RNA. We also show that endogenous microDNA associate with RNA polymerases subunits, POLR2H and POLR3F. Together, these results suggest that microDNA may modulate gene expression through the production of both known and novel regulatory small RNA.

Small DNA circles as probes of DNA topology

Small DNA circles can occur in Nature, for example as protein-constrained loops, and can be synthesized by a number of methods. Such small circles provide tractable systems for the study of the structure, thermodynamics and molecular dynamics of closed-circular DNA. In the present article, we review the occurrence and synthesis of small DNA circles, and examine their utility in studying the properties of DNA and DNA–protein interactions. In particular, we highlight the analysis of small circles using atomistic simulations.

Structural plasticity of single chromatin fibers revealed by torsional manipulation

Magnetic tweezers were used to study the mechanical response under torsion of single nucleosome arrays reconstituted on tandem repeats of 5S positioning sequences. Regular arrays are extremely resilient and can reversibly accommodate a large amount of supercoiling without much change in length. This behavior is quantitatively described by a molecular model of the chromatin three-dimensional architecture. In this model, we assume the existence of a dynamic equilibrium between three conformations of the nucleosome, corresponding to different crossing statuses of the entry/exit DNAs (positive, null or negative, respectively). Torsional strain displaces that equilibrium, leading to an extensive reorganization of the fiber's architecture. The model explains a number of long-standing topological questions regarding DNA in chromatin and may provide the basis to better understand the dynamic binding of chromatin-associated proteins.Note: In the supplementary information initially published online to accompany this article, Supplementary Figure 2 was mistakenly replaced by Supplementary Equation 2. The error has been corrected online.

DNA-loop formation on nucleosomes shown by in situ scanning force microscopy of supercoiled DNA

The flexibility of the chromatin structure, necessary for the processing of the genomic DNA, is controlled by a number of factors where flexibility and mobility of the nucleosomes is essential. Here, the influence of DNA supercoiling on the structure of single nucleosomes is investigated. Circular supercoiled plasmid DNA sub-saturated with histones was visualized by scanning force microscopy (SFM) in aqueous solution. SFM-imaging compared with topological analysis indicates instability of nucleosomes when the salt concentration is raised from 10 mM to 100 mM NaCl. Nucleosomes were observed after the deposition to the used scanning surface, i.e. mica coated with polylysine. On the images, the nucleosomes appear with a high probability in end-loops near the apices of the superhelices. In 100 mM NaCl but not in 10 mM NaCl, a significant number of complexes present the nucleosomes on superhelical crossings mainly located adjacent to an end-loop. The morphology of these structures and statistical analysis suggest that DNA loops were formed on the histone octamers, where the loop size distribution shows a pronounced peak at 50 nm. Recently, the formation and diffusion of loops on octamers has been discussed as a mechanism of translocations of nucleosomes along DNA. The presented data likely confirm the occurrence of loops, which may be stabilized by supercoiling. Analysis of the structure of regular nucleosomes not located on crossings indicates that reducing the salt concentration leads to more conformations, where DNA is partially unwrapped from the distal ends of the octamer.

Nucleosome conformational flexibility and implications for chromatin dynamics

The active role of chromatin in the regulation of gene activity seems to imply a conformational flexibility of the basic chromatin structural unit, the nucleosome. This review is devoted to our recent results pertaining to this subject, using an original approach based on the topology of single particles reconstituted on DNA minicircles, combined with their theoretical simulation. Three types of chromatin particles have been studied so far: a subnucleosome, that is, the (H3-H4)(2) histone tetramer-containing particle, now known as the tetrasome; the nucleosome; and the linker histone H5/H1-bearing nucleosome (the chromatosome). All the particles were found to exist in two to three conformational states, which differ by their topological and mechanical properties. Our approach unveiled the molecular mechanisms of nucleosome conformational dynamics and will help to understand its functional relevance. A most surprising conclusion of the work was perhaps that DNA overall flexibility increases considerably upon particle formation, which might indeed be a requirement of genome function.

Linker histone-dependent organization and dynamics of nucleosome entry/exit DNAs

A DNA sequence-dependent nucleosome structural and dynamic polymorphism was recently uncovered through topoisomerase I relaxation of mononucleosomes on two homologous approximately 350-370 bp DNA minicircle series, one originating from pBR322, the other from the 5S nucleosome positioning sequence. Whereas both pBR and 5S nucleosomes had access to the closed, negatively crossed conformation, only the pBR nucleosome had access to the positively crossed conformation. Simulation suggested this discrepancy was the result of a reorientation of entry/exit DNAs, itself proposed to be the consequence of specific DNA untwistings occurring in pBR nucleosome where H2B N-terminal tails pass between the two gyres. The present work investigates the behavior of the same two nucleosomes after binding of linker histone H5, its globular domain, GH5, and engineered H5 C-tail deletion mutants. Nucleosome access to the open uncrossed conformation was suppressed and, more surprisingly, the ability of 5S nucleosome to positively cross was largely restored. This, together with the paradoxical observation of a less extensive crossing in the negative conformation with GH5 than without, favored an asymmetrical location of the globular domain in interaction with the central gyre and only entry (or exit) DNA, and raised the possibility of the domain physical rotation as a mechanism assisting nucleosome fluctuation from one conformation to the other. Moreover, both negative and positive conformations showed a high degree of loop conformational flexibility in the presence of the full-length H5 C-tail, which the simulation suggested to reflect the unique feature of the resulting stem to bring entry/exit DNAs in contact and parallel. The results point to the stem being a fundamental structural motif directing chromatin higher order folding, as well as a major player in its dynamics.

The carboxyl-terminal region common to lamins A and C contains a DNA binding domain

Lamins A and C are intermediate filament proteins which polymerize into the nucleus to form the nuclear lamina network. The lamina is apposed to the inner nuclear membrane and functions in tethering chromatin to the nuclear envelope and in maintaining nuclear shape. We have recently characterized a globular domain that adopts an immunoglobulin fold in the carboxyl-terminal tail common to lamins A and C. Using an electrophoretic mobility shift assay (EMSA), we show that a peptide containing this domain interacts in vitro with DNA after dimerization through a disulfide bond, but does not interact with the core particle or the dinucleosome. The covalent dimer binds a 30-40 bp DNA fragment with a micromolar affinity and no sequence specificity. Using nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) and an EMSA, we observed that two peptide regions participate in the DNA binding: the unstructured amino-terminal part containing the nuclear localization signal and a large positively charged region centered around amino acid R482 at the surface of the immunoglobulin-like domain. Mutations R482Q and -W, which are responsible for Dunnigan-type partial lipodystrophy, lower the affinity of the peptide for DNA. We conclude that the carboxyl-terminal end of lamins A and C binds DNA and suggest that alterations in lamin-DNA interactions may play a role in the pathophysiology of some lamin-linked diseases.

SWI/SNF chromatin remodeling requires changes in DNA topology

ySWI/SNF complex belongs to a family of enzymes that use the energy of ATP hydrolysis to remodel chromatin structure. Here we examine the role of DNA topology in the mechanism of ySWI/SNF remodeling. We find that the ability of ySWI/SNF to enhance accessibility of nucleosomal DNA is nearly eliminated when DNA topology is constrained in small circular nucleosomal arrays and that this inhibition can be alleviated by topoisomerases. Furthermore, we demonstrate that remodeling of these substrates does not require dramatic histone octamer movements or displacement. Our results suggest a model in which ySWI/SNF remodels nucleosomes by using the energy of ATP hydrolysis to drive local changes in DNA twist.

Inner nuclear membrane protein LBR preferentially interacts with DNA secondary structures and nucleosomal linker

The lamin B receptor (LBR) is an integral protein of inner nuclear membrane whose nucleoplasmic amino-terminal domain contributes to the attachment of the membrane to chromatin. Here we analyzed the interactions of a recombinant GST protein containing the amino-terminal domain of the protein with in vitro reconstituted nucleosomes and short DNA fragments. Data show that the LBR amino-terminal domain (AT) binds linker DNA but does not interact with the nucleosome core. Titration and competition studies revealed that the interaction between LBR AT and DNA is saturable, of high affinity (K(D) approximately 4 nM), independent of DNA sequence, and enhanced by DNA curvature and supercoiling. In this respect, LBR amino-terminal domain binding to nucleosomes is similar to that of histone H1 and non histone proteins HMG1/2 which both bind preferentially to linker DNA and present a significant affinity for DNA secondary structures.

Nucleosome dynamics V. Ethidium bromide versus histone tails in modulating ethidium bromide-driven tetrasome chiral transition. A fluorescence study of tetrasomes on DNA minicircles

Protein and DNA contributions in the chiral transition of DNA minicircle-reconstituted tetrasomes (the particles made of DNA wrapped around the histone (H3-H4)(2) tetramer) to a right-handed conformation have been investigated in a recent article from this laboratory. As the evidence for a protein contribution, a sterical hindrance introduced at the H3/H3 interface of the two constituent H3-H4 dimers by oxidation of H3 cysteine 110 blocked the tetramer in a half-left-handed or semi-right-handed conformation, depending on the SH-reagent used. The DNA contributed at the level of the dyad region, which appeared to act through its sequence-dependent deformability in modulating both the loop threshold positive constraint required to trigger the transition, and the tetrasome lateral opening. This opening, which electron microscopic visualizations directly showed to be associated with the transition, is expected to help remove the clash between the entering and exiting DNAs. In this work, the transition mechanism was further investigated by applying a positive constraint in the loop through ethidium bromide (EtBr) intercalation. This technique, including the determination of binding isotherms, has first been used with mononucleosomes on DNA minicircles, and has revealed that these particles could tolerate large positive supercoilings without disruption, owing to the loop ability to cross positively in a histone tail-dependent manner. The transition of 359 bp tetrasomes was found to go to completion in lower salt (10 mM), but not in higher salt (100 mM), whereas the transition of 256 bp tetrasomes was already hindered in lower salt. Histone acetylation relieved that lower salt hindrance but enhanced the higher salt hindrances. These data again pointed to the DNA in the dyad region as a regulator of the transition. The block was indeed expected to originate from a local EtBr intercalation in that DNA, which opposed its overtwisting during the transition. The occurrence of the block, or its relief, then depended on the outcome of the competition between the tails and EtBr for binding to that region, that is, on whether the tails could prevent EtBr intercalation before the ongoing transition hampered both bindings. Destabilization of the tails in the course of the transition is documented in an accompanying article through a relaxation study of a 351-366 bp tetrasome series.

Nucleosome dynamics. Protein and DNA contributions in the chiral transition of the tetrasome, the histone (H3-H4)2 tetramer-DNA particle

Our laboratory has previously reported the chiral transition of DNA minicircle-reconstituted tetrasomes (the particles made of DNA wrapped around the histone (H3-H4)2tetramer). This transition was induced by DNA positive torsional constraint, generated either by initial supercoiling of the loop or by its thermal fluctuations during topoisomerase relaxation. Taking into account the wrapping of the DNA around the histones into less than a turn, and its negative crossing at the entry-exit, the transition was proposed to involve a 360 degrees rotation of the loop around the particle dyad axis, and the formation of a positive crossing. The tetramer horseshoe-shaped conformation within the octamer further suggested that this process could be mediated by a reorientation of the two sector-like H3-H4 dimers about their H3/H3 interface, which would switch the overall handedness of the proteinaceous superhelix from left to right-handed. We now provide additional evidence for such a contribution of the protein by showing, through gel electrophoresis, topoisomerase relaxation and electron microscopy, that a sterical hindrance at the H3/H3 interface, introduced by covalent linking of bulky adducts through thiol oxidation of H3 cysteine 110, interferes with the transition. Such interference varies, depending on the particular SH-reagent used; but the most remarkable effect was obtained with 5, 5'-dithiobis (2-nitrobenzoic acid) (DTNB), which displaces the preferred conformation of the tetrasomes from left-handed to semi-right-handed, and at the same time preserves a significant degree of chiral flexibility. DNA contribution was evidenced by a specific fractionation of circular tetrasomes in gel electrophoresis which, together with a different positioning of control and DTNB tetrasomes on linear DNA, pointed to an interdependence between tetrasome conformation and positions. Moreover, linear tetrasomes fluctuate between crossed and uncrossed conformations in a salt-dependent equilibrium which appears to vary with their positions on the DNA. These data suggest a modulatable role of the DNA around the dyad in the transition, depending primarily on its sequence-dependent deformability. This role is played at both levels of H3-H4 dimer reorientation and lateral opening, a mechanism by which the particle may relieve the clash between its entering and exiting DNAs. These properties make the tetrasome an attractive potential intermediate in nucleosome dynamics in vivo, in particular duringX transcriptional activation and elongation.

Isolation and characterization of a protein with high affinity for DNA: the glutamine synthetase of Thermus thermophilus 111

In a search of proteins from the thermophilic bacterium Thermus thermophilus 111 with a high affinity for DNA, the selected protein from this screening appears to be the glutamine synthetase (GS). The purified product gives one band in SDS-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (53,700 Da). The N-terminal 32 residues have been identified and present an homology of 80% with the glutamine synthetase of Bacillus subtilis and 76% with that of Thermotoga maritima. The protein displays the characteristic dodecameric structure of the eubacteria glutamine synthetase. From a detailed study of the interaction of this protein with DNA by dark-field electron microscopy and agarose gel electrophoresis, it is concluded that double-stranded DNA wraps the protein by a full turn of 150 bp length. An even number of GS molecules bound to a closed relaxed plasmid DNA does not alter its null topology. By using an inverted dimer DNA fragment, which contains twice a curved kinetoplast DNA insert in its central part, it is shown that DNA curvature rules the order in which GS binds to the DNA. DNA ends are also sites of high affinity for the GS. Supercoiling does not favor the binding of GS to the DNA with the exception of the apices that are by essence bent regions. By saturating a DNA molecule with GS one obtains a novel characteristic scalloped configuration in which the DNA undulates from one GS to the next. The DNA is condensed at least three times in these structures. By increasing the ratio of GS to DNA in solution the resulting material migrates as discrete bands relative to the free DNA in an agarose gel. By gel retardation and EM statistical distribution analysis of GS within the complexes, an average affinity constant of 10(7) M-1 was obtained. The potential implications of this novel interaction of the glutamine synthetase with DNA for the regulation of its own gene are briefly discussed.

Nucleosome dynamics. II. High flexibility of nucleosome entering and exiting DNAs to positive crossing. An ethidium bromide fluorescence study of mononucleosomes on DNA minicircles

H2A-H2B exchange with the intranuclear histone pool upon chromatin transcription in vivo is generally viewed as being triggered by the DNA positive supercoiling wave pushed by the elongating polymerase. This notion was tested here by investigating a potential release of H2A-H2B by ethidium bromide-induced positive supercoiling in the loop of mononucleosomes reconstituted on DNA minicircles. The results of gel electrophoresis, fluorescence titration and electron microscopy showed that such a positive supercoiling was not able to release H2A-H2B, nor to unfold the nucleosome to any detectable extent. The reason appeared to be the ease with which the loop could undergo a positive crossing, a surprising observation in view of the DNA left-handed wrapping around the octamer. Moreover, the influence of histone acetylation suggested that such loop flexibility to positive crossing is mediated by histone N-terminal tails which, by interacting with entering and exiting DNAs, reduce their electrostatic repulsion. These conclusions are confirmed and extended in the accompanying article through relaxation with topoisomerase I.

Nucleosome dynamics. III. Histone tail-dependent fluctuation of nucleosomes between open and closed DNA conformations. Implications for chromatin dynamics and the linking number paradox. A relaxation study of mononucleosomes on DNA minicircles

The mean linking number (<Lk>) of the topoisomer equilibrium distribution obtained upon relaxation of DNA minicircles with topoisomerase I did not increase linearly, but rather in a step wise fashion, with DNA size between 351 and 366 bp. As a consequence, the corresponding linking number difference (<DeltaLk>) did not remain equal to 0, but rather oscillated between +/-0.3 with the periodicity of the double helix. This oscillation, not observed with plasmid-size DNA, is an expected consequence of the stiffness of short DNA. When minicircles were reconstituted with a nucleosome, the associated <DeltaLkn> oscillated between approximately -1.4 +/-0. 2. This oscillation appears to result from the combined effects of DNA stiffness, and nucleosome ability to thermally fluctuate between three distinct DNA conformational states. Two of these states, a closed approximately 1.75-turn DNA conformation with negatively crossed entering and exiting DNAs, and an open approximately 1.4-turn conformation with uncrossed DNAs, are well known, whereas the third state, with a closed DNA conformation and DNAs tending to cross positively rather than negatively, is less familiar. Access to both closed "negative" and "positive" states appears to be mediated by histone N-terminal tails, as shown by specific alterations to the <DeltaLkn> oscillation caused by histone acetylation and phosphate ions, a potent tail destabilizator. These results extend previous observations of ethidium bromide fluorescence titration in the accompanying article, which have pointed to an histone tail-dependent flexibility of entering and exiting DNAs to positive crossing. They also show that DNA wrapping around the histones occurred without twist alteration compared to the DNA free in solution, and reveal an intriguing new facet of the "linking-number-paradox" problem: the possibility for linkers in chromatin to adopt different crossing status within an overall dynamic equilibrium which may be regulated by histone acetylation.

Modeling chain folding in protein-constrained circular DNA

An efficient method for sampling equilibrium configurations of DNA chains binding one or more DNA-bending proteins is presented. The technique is applied to obtain the tertiary structures of minimal bending energy for a selection of dinucleosomal minichromosomes that differ in degree of protein-DNA interaction, protein spacing along the DNA chain contour, and ring size. The protein-bound portions of the DNA chains are represented by tight, left-handed supercoils of fixed geometry. The protein-free regions are modeled individually as elastic rods. For each random spatial arrangement of the two nucleosomes assumed during a stochastic search for the global minimum, the paths of the flexible connecting DNA segments are determined through a numerical solution of the equations of equilibrium for torsionally relaxed elastic rods. The minimal energy forms reveal how protein binding and spacing and plasmid size differentially affect folding and offer new insights into experimental minichromosome systems.

A topological approach to nucleosome structure and dynamics: the linking number paradox and other issues

The linking number paradox of DNA in chromatin (two negative crossings around the octamer, associated with a unit linking number reduction), which is 21 years old this year, has come of age. After stirring much debate in the past, the initially hypothetical explanation of the paradox by DNA overtwisting on the nucleosome surface is now presented as a hard fact in recent textbooks. The first part of this article presents a historical perspective of the problem and details the numerous attempts to measure DNA local periodicity, which in one remarkable example sowed the seeds for the discovery of DNA bending. The second part is devoted to the DNA minicircle system, which has been developed in the author's laboratory as an alternative to the local-periodicity-measurement approach. It offers a simple proposal: a unit linking number reduction associated with a single crossing. This conclusion is contrasted with the latest high-resolution crystallographic data of the nucleosome in the third part of the article, and the fourth part examines the available evidence supporting an extension of these results to nucleosomes in chromatin. The last part addresses another basic question pertaining to nucleosome dynamics, the conformational flexibility of the histone tetramer.

The elastic rod model for DNA and its application to the tertiary structure of DNA minicircles in mononucleosomes

Explicit solutions to the equations of equilibrium in the theory of the elastic rod model for DNA are employed to develop a procedure for finding the configuration that minimizes the elastic energy of a minicircle in a mononucleosome with specified values of the minicircle size N in base pairs, the extent w of wrapping of DNA about the histone core particle, the helical repeat h(0)b of the bound DNA, and the linking number Lk of the minicircle. The procedure permits a determination of the set Y(N, w, h(0)b) of integral values of Lk for which the minimum energy configuration does not involve self-contact, and graphs of writhe versus w are presented for such values of Lk. For the range of N of interest here, 330 < N < 370, the set Y(N, w, h(0)b) is of primary importance: when Lk is not in Y(N, w, h(0)b), the configurations compatible with Lk have elastic energies high enough to preclude the occurrence of an observable concentration of topoisomer Lk in an equilibrium distribution of topoisomers. Equilibrium distributions of Lk, calculated by setting differences in the free energy of the extranucleosomal loop equal to differences in equilibrium elastic energy, are found to be very close to Gaussian when computed under the assumption that w is fixed, but far from Gaussian when it is assumed that w fluctuates between two values. The theoretical results given suggest a method by which one may calculate DNA-histone binding energies from measured equilibrium distributions of Lk.

Nucleosome structural transition during chromatin unfolding is caused by conformational changes in nucleosomal DNA

We have recently reported that certain core histone-DNA contacts are altered in nucleosomes during chromatin unfolding (Usachenko, S. I., Gavin I. M., and Bavykin, S. G. (1996) J. Biol. Chem. 271, 3831-3836). In this work, we demonstrate that these alterations are caused by a conformational change in the nucleosomal DNA. Using zero-length protein-DNA cross-linking, we have mapped histone-DNA contacts in isolated core particles at ionic conditions affecting DNA stiffness, which may change the nucleosomal DNA conformation. We found that the alterations in histone-DNA contacts induced by an increase in DNA stiffness in isolated core particles are identical to those observed in nucleosomes during chromatin unfolding. The change in the pattern of micrococcal nuclease digestion of linker histone-depleted chromatin at ionic conditions affecting chromatin compaction also suggests that the stretching of the linker DNA may alter the nucleosomal DNA conformation, resulting in a structural transition in the nucleosome which may play a role in rendering the nucleosome competent for transcription and/or replication.

Interaction of Bacillus subtilis purine repressor with DNA

A purine repressor (PurR) mediates adenine nucleotide-dependent regulation of transcription initiation of the Bacillus subtilis pur operon. This repressor has been purified for the first time, and binding to control site DNA was characterized. PurR binds in vitro to four operons. Apparent Kd values for binding were 7 nM for the pur operon, 8 nM for purA, 13 nM for purR, and 44 nM for the pyr operon. In each case, DNase I footprints exhibited a pattern of protected and hypersensitive sites that extended over more than 60 bp. A GAAC-N24-GTTC sequence in the pur operon was necessary but not sufficient for the PurR-DNA interaction. However, this motif, which is conserved in the four binding sites, was not required for binding of PurR to purA. Thus, the common DNA recognition element for binding of PurR to the four operons is not known. Multiple PurR-pur operon DNA complexes having a binding stoichiometry that was either approximately two or six repressor molecules per DNA fragment were detected. The results of a torsional constraint experiment suggest that control site DNA forms one right-handed turn around PurR.

Modeling protein-induced configurational changes in DNA minicircles

A method is offered for obtaining minimum energy configurations of DNA minicircles constrained by one or more DNA-binding proteins. The minicircles are modeled as elastic rods, while the presence of bound protein is implied by rigidly fixing portions of these chains. The configurations of the geometrically constrained circular rods are sampled stochastically and optimized according to a simple elastic energy model of nicked DNA. The shapes of the minimum energy structures identified after a simulated annealing process are analyzed in terms of relative protein orientation and writhing number. The procedure is applied to minicircles 500 base pairs in length, bound to two evenly spaced DNA-wrapping proteins. The presence of histone octamers is suggested by rigidly fixing the two protein-bound portions of each minicircle as small superhelices similar in dimension to nucleosomal DNA. The folded minimum energy forms of sample chains with different degrees of protein wrapping are noteworthy in themselves in that they offer a new resolution to the well-known minichromosome linking number paradox and point to future minicircle simulations of possible import.

Interaction of the histone (H3-H4)2 tetramer of the nucleosome with positively supercoiled DNA minicircles: Potential flipping of the protein from a left- to a right-handed superhelical form

We have studied the ability of the histone (H3-H4)2 tetramer, the central part of the nucleosome of eukaryotic chromatin, to form particles on DNA minicircles of negative and positive superhelicities, and the effect of relaxing these particles with topoisomerase I. The results show that even modest positive torsional stress from the DNA, and in particular that generated by DNA thermal fluctuations, can trigger a major, reversible change in the conformation of the particle. Neither a large excess of naked DNA, nor a crosslink between the two H3s prevented the transition from one form to the other. This suggested that during the transition, the histones neither dissociated from the DNA nor were even significantly reshuffled. Moreover, the particles reconstituted on negatively and positively supercoiled minicircles look similar under electron microscopy. These data agree best with a transition involving a switch of the wrapped DNA from a left- to a right-handed superhelix. It is further proposed, based on the left-handed overall superhelical conformation of the tetramer within the octamer [Arents, G., Burlingame, R. W., Wang, B. C., Love, W. E. & Moudrianakis, E. N. (1991) Proc. Natl.Acad. Sci. USA 88, 10148-10152] that this change in DNA topology is mediated by a similar change in the topology of the tetramer itself, which may occur through a rotation (or a localized deformation) of the two H3-H4 dimers about their H3-H3 interface. Potential implications of this model for nucleosome dynamics in vivo are discussed.

Preferential binding of the archaebacterial histone-like MC1 protein to negatively supercoiled DNA minicircles

The interaction of the archaebacterial MC1 protein with 207 bp negatively supercoiled DNA minicircles has been examined by gel retardation assays and compared to that observed with the relaxed DNA minicircle. MC1 binding induces a drastic DNA conformational change of each minicircle, leading to an increase of the electrophoretic mobility of the DNA. A slight increase in salt concentration enhances the amount of bound MC1, and high NaCl concentrations are required to dissociate the complexes. Furthermore, the salt effect on binding depends on the supercoiling state of the DNA. The dissociation rates decrease with increasing linking difference of the minicircles relative to their relaxed configuration to reach a maximum at -2 turns. In addition, differences between the topoisomers are also observed in terms of stoichiometry of the strongest complexes. So with the -2 topoisomer the complex with two MC1 molecules is the most stable, while with the -1 and -3 topoisomers, the strongest ones are those with one MC1 molecule per DNA ring.

Flexing and folding double helical DNA

DNA base sequence, once thought to be interesting only as a carrier of the genetic blueprint, is now recognized as playing a structural role in modulating the biological activity of genes. Primary sequences of nucleic acid bases describe real three-dimensional structures with properties reflecting those structures. Moreover, the structures are base sequence dependent with individual residues adopting characteristic spatial forms. As a consequence, the double helix can fold into tertiary arrangements, although the deformation is much more gradual and spread over a larger molecular scale than in proteins. As part of an effort to understand how local structural irregularities are translated at the macromolecular level in DNA and recognized by proteins, a series of calculations probing the structure and properties of the double helix have been performed. By combining several computational techniques, complementary information as well as a series of built-in checks and balances for assessing the significance of the findings are obtained. The known sequence dependent bending, twisting, and translation of simple dimeric fragments have been incorporated into computer models of long open DNAs of varying length and chemical composition as well as in closed double helical circles and loops. The extent to which the double helix can be forced to bend and twist is monitored with newly parameterized base sequence dependent elastic energy potentials based on the observed configurations of adjacent base pairs in the B-DNA crystallographic literature.

Effects of DNA topology in the interaction with histone octamers and DNA topoisomerase I

Several simple proteins and complex protein systems exist which do not recognize a defined sequence but--rather--a specific DNA conformation. We describe experiments and principles for two of these systems: nucleosomes and eukaryotic DNA topoisomerase I. Evidences are summarized that describe the effects of negative DNA supercoiling on nucleosome formation and the influence of DNA intrinsic curvature on their localization. The function of the DNA rotational information in nucleosome positioning and in the selection of multiple alternative positions on the same helical phase are described. This function suggests a novel genetic regulatory mechanism, based on nucleosome mobility and on the correlation between in vitro and in vivo positions. We observe that the same rules that determine the in vitro localization apply to the in vivo nucleosome positioning, as determined by a technique that relies on the use of nystatin and on the import of active enzymes in living yeast cells. The sensitivity of DNA topoisomerase I to the topological condition of the DNA substrate is reviewed and discussed taking into account recent experiments that describe the effect of the DNA tridimensional context on the reaction. These topics are discussed in the following order: (i) Proteins that look for a consensus DNA conformation; (ii) Nucleosomes; (iii) Negative supercoiling and nucleosomes; (iv) DNA curvature/bending and nucleosomes; (v) Multiple positioning; (vi) Multiple nucleosomes offer a contribution to the solution of the linking number paradox; (vii) Rotational versus translational information; (viii) A regulatory mechanism; (ix) DNA topoisomerase I; (x) DNA topoisomerase I and DNA supercoiling: a regulation by topological feedback; (xi) DNA topoisomerase I and DNA curvature; (xii) The in-and-out problem in the accessibility of DNA information; (xiii) The integrating function of the free energy of supercoiling.

Chromatin reconstitution on small DNA rings. V. DNA thermal flexibility of single nucleosomes

The thermal flexibility of DNA minicircles reconstituted with single nucleosomes was measured relative to the naked minicircles. The measurement used a new method based on the electrophoretic properties of these molecules, whose mobility strongly depended on the DNA writhe, either of the whole minicircle, when naked, or of the extranucleosomal loop, when reconstituted. The experiment was as follows. The DNA length was first increased by one base-pair (bp), and the correlative shift in mobility resulting from the altered DNA writhe was recorded. Second, the gel temperature was increased so that the former mobility was restored. Under these conditions, the untwisting of the thermally flexible DNA due to the temperature shift exactly compensates for the increase in the DNA mean twist number resulting from the one bp addition. The relative thermal flexibility was then calculated as the ratio between the increases in temperature measured for the naked and the reconstituted DNAs, respectively. The figure, 0.69 (+/- 0.07), was used to derive the length of DNA in interaction with the histones, 109 (+/- 25) bp. Such length was in good agreement with the mean value of 115 bp we have previously obtained from the distribution of the angles between DNAs at the entrance and exit of similar nucleosomes measured from high resolution electron microscopy. This consistency further reinforces our previous conclusion that minicircle-reconstituted nucleosomes, with 1.3(109/83) to 1.4(115/83) turns of superhelical DNA, show no crossing of entering and exiting DNAs when the loop is in its most probable configuration, and therefore, that these nucleosomes behave topologically as "single-turn" particles. The present data are also within the range of values, 50 to 100 bp of thermally rigid DNA per nucleosome, obtained by others for yeast plasmid chromatin, suggesting that the "single-turn" particle notion may be extended to this particular case of naturally-occurring H1-free chromatin. However, these data are quite different from the 230 bp figure derived from thermal measurements of reconstituted H1-free minichromosomes. It is proposed that nucleosome interactions occurring in this chromatin, but not in yeast chromatin, may be partly responsible for the discrepancy.

Chromatin reconstitution on small DNA rings. IV. DNA supercoiling and nucleosome sequence preference

Nucleosome formation on inverted repeats or on some alternations of purines and pyrimidines can be inhibited in vitro by DNA supercoiling through their supercoiling-induced structural transitions to cruciforms or Z-form DNA, respectively. We report here, as a result of study of single nucleosome reconstitutions on a DNA minicircle, that a physiological level of DNA supercoiling can also enhance nucleosome sequence preference. The 357 base-pair minicircle was composed of a promoter of phage SP6 RNA polymerase joined to a 256 base-pair fragment containing a sea urchin 5 S RNA gene. Nucleosome formation on the promoter was found to be enhanced on a topoisomer with in vivo superhelix density when compared to topoisomers of lower or higher superhelical densities, to the nicked circle, or to the linear DNA. In contrast, nucleosomes at other positions appeared to be insensitive to supercoiling. This observation relied on a novel procedure for the investigation of nucleosome positioning. The reconstituted circular chromatin was first linearized using a restriction endonuclease, and the linear chromatin so obtained was electrophoresed as nucleoprotein in a polyacrylamide gel. The gel showed well-fractionated bands whose mobilities were a V-like function of nucleosome positions, with the nucleosome near the middle migrating less. This behavior is similar to that previously observed for complexes of sequence-specific DNA-bending proteins with circularly permuted DNA fragments, and presumably reflects the change in the direction of the DNA axis between the entrance and the exit of the particle. Possible mechanisms for such supercoiling-induced modulation of nucleosome formation are discussed in the light of the supercoiling-dependent susceptibility to cleavage of the naked minicircle with S1 and Bal31 nucleases; and a comparison between DNase I cleavage patterns of the modulated nucleosome and of another, non-modulated, overlapping nucleosome.

Influence of DNA topology and histone tails in nucleosome organization on pBR322 DNA

Recently, we have found that the assembly of nucleosomes reconstituted on negatively supercoiled DNA is cooperative. In the present paper the role of DNA topology and of histone tails in nucleosome assembly was explored. Reconstituted minichromosomes on relaxed DNA at different histone/DNA ratios (R) were assayed by topological analysis and electron microscopy visualization. Both methods show a linear relationship between average nucleosome number (N) and R. This suggests that in the case of relaxed DNA, cooperative internucleosomal interactions are small or absent. The influence of histone tails in nucleosome assembly was studied on minichromosomes reconstituted with trypsinized histone octamer on negatively supercoiled DNA by topological analysis. The topoisomers distribution, after trypsinization, dramatically changes, indicating that nucleosome-nucleosome interactions are remarkably decreased. These results show that, in chromatin folding, in addition to the well known role of histone H1, the interactions between histone octamer tails and DNA are also of importance.

Quantitative electron microscopic analysis of DNA-protein interactions

Electron microscopy offers a unique potentiality to visualize individual molecules. For the last 30 years it has been used to study the structure and the interactions of various biological macromolecules. The contribution of electron microscopy is important because of its capacity to demonstrate the existence of conformational structures such as kinks, bents, loops, etc., either on naked DNA, or on DNA associated with various proteins or ligands. Increasing interest was given to such observations when it was found that they provide a direct visualization of interacting molecules involved in DNA metabolism and gene regulation. Technical advances in the preparation of the specimens, their observation in the electron microscope, and the image processing by computers have allowed the shifting from qualitative to quantitative analysis, as illustrated by a few examples from our laboratory.

Structural features of a regulatory nucleosome

DNA sequences from the long terminal repeat of the mouse mammary tumor virus (MMTV-LTR) position nucleosomes both in vivo and in vitro. Here, were present chromatin reconstitution experiments showing that MMTV-LTR sequences from -236 to +204 accommodate two histone octamers in positions compatible with the in vivo data. This positioning is not influenced by the length of the DNA fragment and occurs in linear as well as in closed circular DNA molecules. MMTV-LTR DNA sequences show an intrinsic bendability that closely resembles its wrapping around the histone octamer. We propose that bendability is responsible for the observed rotational nucleosome positioning. Translational nucleosome positioning seems also to be determined by the DNA sequence. These data, along with the results from reconstitution experiments with insertion mutants, support a modular model of nucleosome phasing on MMTV-LTR, where the actual positioning of the histone octamer results from the additive effect of multiple features of the DNA sequence.

The structure of DNA in a nucleosome

We describe the application of the hydroxyl radical footprinting technique to examine the histone-DNA interactions of a nucleosome that includes part of the 5S ribosomal RNA gene of Xenopus borealis. We establish that two distinct regions of DNA with different helical periodicities exist within the nucleosome and demonstrate a change in the helical periodicity of this DNA upon nucleosome formation. In particular, we find that on average the helical periodicity of DNA in this nucleosome is 10.18 +/- 0.05 base pairs per turn. The same DNA, when bound to a calcium phosphate surface, has a periodicity of 10.49 +/- 0.05 base pairs per turn, similar to that of random sequence DNA. Modulations in minor groove width within the naked DNA detected by the hydroxyl radical are maintained and exaggerated in nucleosomal DNA. These features correlate with regions in the DNA previously suggested to be important for nucleosome positioning.

Chromatin reconstitution on small DNA rings. III. Histone H5 dependence of DNA supercoiling in the nucleosome

Mononucleosomes were reconstituted on small DNA rings in the presence of histone H5 and relaxed to an equilibrium using calf thymus topoisomerase I. DNA products, when compared to the equilibria observed with the same minicircles in the absence of histones, showed that a linking number reduction of 1.6 to 1.7 was associated with this reconstitution, in contrast with the 1.1 to 1.2 figure reported in our recent study of the H5-free nucleosome. Gel electrophoretic properties and electron microscopic visualization of the nucleosomes suggest a correlation between this increase and a further wrapping of the DNA around the histone core from less than 1.5 turns of the superhelix in the absence of H5, to close to two turns in its presence. Implications for DNA topology in chromatin are discussed.

Lupus-inducing drugs alter the structure of supercoiled circular DNA domains

We analyzed the effects of procainamide (PROC), hydralazine (HYD), N-acetylprocainamide (NAPA), and L-canavanine (CAN) on circular supercoiled plasmids as models for chromosomal loop domains. The supercoil-dependent B-Z equilibrium in recombinant plasmids was used as an indicator of structural changes induced in circular DNA. Two-dimensional gel electrophoresis showed that PROC and HYD strongly inhibited supercoil-induced Z-DNA formation, whereas NAPA caused less pronounced changes in the B-Z equilibrium, and CAN had no effect. Gel retardation assays showed that the binding of a Z-DNA-specific autoimmune antibody to a Z-DNA-containing plasmid was strongly perturbed by HYD, but not influenced by CAN. Both PROC and NAPA showed moderate inhibition of antibody binding. Our results demonstrate the different potentials of these 4 drugs to interact with DNA and to alter the tertiary topology of DNA domains. It is conceivable that the in vivo capacity of PROC and HYD to induce antinuclear antibodies may be related to their ability to influence structural features in chromosomal DNA domains or nucleosomes, thus liberating antigenic structural epitopes in DNA and/or DNA-associated proteins.

Protein-induced unwinding of DNA: measurement by gel electrophoresis of complexes with DNA minicircles. Application to restriction endonuclease EcoRI, catabolite gene activator protein and lac repressor

An electrophoretic procedure for the measurement of the helix unwinding induced by a sequence-specific protein is described. The method, which was applied here to EcoR I, CAP and lac repressor, involved the migration of the complexes with positively and negatively supercoiled DNA minicircles carrying a single protein binding site. Mobility shifts of complexes relative to naked DNAs appeared to be a result of i) the unwinding; of ii) an increase in the molecular frictional coefficient, which led to a retardation; of iii) bending, in the particular case of CAP, which induced an acceleration; and of iv) looping, in the case of lac repressor, which also resulted in an acceleration. Under conditions where the migration of the naked topoisomers was V-like (topoisomer mobility showed the same linear increase with both negative and positive supercoilings; Zivanovic et al. (1986) J. Mol. Biol., 192, 645-660), the protein unwinding contribution to mobility was assumed to be identical to that experimentally observed in the case of a thermal unwinding: all negatively supercoiled topoisomers were retarded and all positively supercoiled topoisomers were accelerated to the same extent. In contrast, the mobility contribution of the frictional term, as well as those of bending and looping, appeared to vary strongly with the magnitude of the supercoiling, but only weakly with its polarity. As a consequence, these latter contributions may approximately cancel when one is measuring the difference between the shifts observed for two comigrating, negatively and positively supercoiled, topoisomers, allowing the unwinding to be calculated. While estimates obtained for EcoR I, 23 +/- 3 degrees, and CAP, about 29 degrees, were in good agreement with previous measurements using topoisomerase I, the value found for lac repressor, 13 to 16 degrees, was significantly smaller.

Linkage reduction allows reconstitution of nucleosomes on DNA microdomains

We have established an experimental system for reconstitution of an individual nucleosome on a closed DNA microdomain (operationally defined as a DNA domain of a size so small as to be unable to establish titratable superhelical turns). The microdomain (185 base-pairs (bp), composed of 128 bp encompassing the central part of the Saccharomyces cerevisiae ADH II promoter plus 57 bp of a polylinker) was obtained by ligation under conditions that produced three circularized forms characterized by different linkage numbers. These linkomers were tested for nucleosome reconstitution with S. cerevisiae histones. It was observed that only microcircles with linkage reduction (delta Lk = 1 or 2) could form a nucleosome, as defined by protection of a 145(+/- 2) bp DNA fragment from micrococcal nuclease, relaxed forms (open or closed circles) could not.

Chromatin reconstitution on small DNA rings. II. DNA supercoiling on the nucleosome

DNA supercoiling on the nucleosome was investigated by relaxing with topoisomerase I mono- and dinucleosomes reconstituted on small DNA rings. Besides 359 base-pair (bp) rings whose linking differences were integers, two additional series of rings with fractional differences, 341 and 354 bp in size, were used. Mononucleosomes reconstituted on 359 bp rings were found to relax into a single mononucleosome form. In contrast, 341 and 354 bp mononucleosomes relaxed into a mixture of two forms, corresponding to two adjacent topoisomers. The observation that the ratio between these two forms was, within each ring series, virtually independent of the initial linking number of the topoisomer used for the reconstitution suggested that each partition reflected an equilibrium. Comparison with the equilibria observed for the same rings in the absence of histones showed that the formation of a single nucleosome is associated with a linking number change of -1.1(+/-0.1) turn. Dinucleosomes, in contrast, were not relaxed to completion and do not reach equilibria. The corresponding linking number change per nucleosome was, however, estimated to be similar to the above figure, in agreement with previous data from the literature obtained with circular chromatins containing larger numbers of nucleosomes. DNA structure in mononucleosomes was subsequently investigated by means of high-resolution electron microscopy and gel electrophoresis. It was found that the above linking number reduction could be ascribed to a particle with a large open extranucleosomal DNA loop and with no more than 1.5 turns of a superhelix around the histone core. A theoretical model of a nucleosome on a small ring was constructed in which one part of the DNA was wrapped around a cylinder and the other part was free to vary both in torsion and flexion. The linking number reduction predicted was found to be most consistent with experimental data when the twist of the DNA in the superhelix was between 10.5 and 10.65 pb per turn, suggesting that wrapping on the nucleosome does not alter the twist of the DNA significantly. A lower estimate of the linking number reduction associated with a two-turn nucleosome was also derived, based on an analysis of recent data obtained upon treatment of reconstituted minichromosomes with gyrase. The value, 1.6 turns, set a lower limit of 10.44 bp per turn for the twist of nucleosomal DNA, in agreement with the above estimate.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)