Tet repressor-tet operator contacts probed by operator DNA-modification interference studies

Biochemical identification of base and phosphate contacts between Fis and a high-affinity DNA binding site

Fis (factor for inversion stimulation) is a nucleoid-associated protein in Escherichia coli and other bacteria that stimulates certain site-specific DNA recombination events, alters DNA topology, and serves as a global gene regulator. DNA binding is central to the functions of Fis and involves a helix-turn-helix DNA binding motif located in the carboxy-terminal region. Specific DNA binding is observed at a number of sites exhibiting poorly related sequences. Such interactions require four critical base pairs positioned -7, -3, +3, and +7 nucleotides relative to the central nucleotide of a 15-bp core-binding site. To further understand how Fis interacts with DNA, we identified the positions of 14 DNA phosphates (based on ethylation interference assays) that are required for Fis binding. These are the 5' phosphates of the nucleotides at positions -8, -7, -6, +1, +2, +3, and +4 relative to the central nucleotide on both DNA strands. Another five phosphates located in the flanking regions from positions +10 through +14 can serve as additional contact sites. Using a combination of biochemical approaches and various mutant Fis proteins, we probed possible interactions between several key Fis residues and DNA bases or phosphates within a high-affinity binding site. We provide evidence in support of interactions between the R85 Fis residue and a highly conserved guanine at position -7 and between T87 and the critical base pairs at -3 and +3. In addition, we present evidence in support of interactions between N84 and the phosphate 5' to the base at +4, between R89 and the -7 phosphate, between T87 and the +3 and +4 phosphates, and between K90 and the +3 phosphate. This work provides functional evidence for some of the most critical interactions between Fis and DNA required for a high binding affinity and demonstrates the large contribution made by numerous phosphates to the stability of the Fis-DNA complex.

Tetracycline repressor, tetR, rather than the tetR-mammalian cell transcription factor fusion derivatives, regulates inducible gene expression in mammalian cells

This article describes the first (to our knowledge) tetracycline-inducible regulatory system that demonstrates that the tetracycline repressor (tetR) alone, rather than tetR-mammalian cell transcription factor fusion derivatives, can function as a potent trans-modulator to regulate gene expression in mammalian cells. With proper positioning of tetracycline operators downstream of the TATA element and of human epidermal growth factor (hEGF) as a reporter, we show that gene expression from the tetracycline operator-bearing hCMV major immediate-early enhancer-promoter (pcmvtetO) can be regulated by tetR over three orders of magnitude in response to tetracycline when (1) the reporter was cotransfected with tetR-expressing plasmid in transient expression assays, and (2) the reporter unit was stably integrated into the chromosome of a tetR-expressing cell line. This level of tetR-mediated inducible gene regulation is significantly higher than that of other repression-based mammalian cell transcription switch systems. In an in vivo porcine wound model, close to 60-fold tetR-mediated regulatory effects were detected and it was reversed when tetracycline was administered. Collectively, this study provides a direct implementation of this tetracycline-inducible regulatory switch for controlling gene expression in vitro, in vivo, and in gene therapy.

Combinations of the alpha-helix-turn-alpha-helix motif of TetR with respective residues from LacI or 434Cro: DNA recognition, inducer binding, and urea-dependent denaturation

We constructed 10 different variants of TetR by substituting all or some of the residues in the alpha-helix-turn-alpha-helix (HTH) operator binding motif with the respective amino acids from LacI or 434Cro. The variants were soluble, negative transdominant over tetR in vivo, and as active as wild-type TetR in tetracycline binding in vitro. The urea-induced denaturation of the 10 variants occurs in single reversible transitions, which are centered around 4.3 M urea. Denaturation is concentration-dependent, supporting a simple two-state mechanism in which the folded dimeric protein is in equilibrium with unfolded monomers. An analysis according to the two-state model yields a Gibbs free energy of stabilization (at 0 M urea, 25 degrees C) of about 75 kJ/mol, typical for dimeric proteins of this size. Even a deletion of 24 residues from the reading head decreased the stability by only 2.7 kJ/mol. These results suggest that the DNA reading head of Tet repressor is a thermodynamically independent domain and that the thermodynamic stability of the Tet repressor dimer is determined by the association of the dimerization domains of the individual monomers. Variants containing replacements in the first alpha-helix of HTH did not show any DNA binding activity whatsoever. We attribute this to the alteration of the two N-terminal residues in this alpha-helix. TetR variants were active in nonspecific DNA binding, when either all or only the solvent-exposed residues in the recognition alpha-helix of HTH were exchanged to the respective LacI sequence. Replacement of the same residues by the respective amino acids from 434Cro yielded hybrid proteins that specifically recognize tetO in vitro. Taken together, these results establish that the similarity of operator recognition between 434Cro and TetR is greater than between TetR and LacI and confirm that prediction of the recognized DNA sequence is not obvious from the sequence of the respective HTH or recognition alpha-helix.

Critical base pairs and amino acid residues for protein-DNA interaction between the TyrR protein and tyrP operator of Escherichia coli

In Escherichia coli K-12, the repression of tyrP requires the binding of the TyrR protein to the operator in the presence of coeffectors, tyrosine and ATP. This operator contains two 22-bp palindromic sequences which are termed TyrR boxes. Methylation, uracil, and ethylation interference experiments were used to identify the important sites in the TyrR boxes that make contacts with the TyrR protein. Methylation interference studies demonstrated that guanines at positions +8, -5, and -8 of the strong TyrR box and positions +8, -4, and -8 of the weak box are close to the TyrR protein. Uracil interference revealed that strong van der Waals contacts are made by the thymines at position -7 and +5 of the top strands of both strong and weak boxes and that weaker contacts are made by the thymines at positions +7 (strong box) and -5 and +7 (weak box) of the bottom strand. In addition, ethylation interference suggested that the phosphate backbone contacts are located at the end and central regions of the palindrome. These findings are supported by our results derived from studies of symmetrical mutations of the tyrP strong box. Overall, the results confirm the critical importance of the invariant (G x C)(C x G)8 base pairs for TyrR recognition and also indicate that interactions with (T x A)(A x T)7 are of major importance. In contrast, mutations in other positions result in weaker effects on the binding affinity of TyrR protein, indicating that these positions play a lesser role in TyrR protein recognition. Alanine scanning of both helices of the putative helix-turn-helix DNA-binding motif of TyrR protein has identified those amino acids whose side chains play an essential role in protein structure and DNA binding.

DNA distortion and base flipping by the EcoRV DNA methyltransferase. A study using interference at dA and T bases and modified deoxynucleosides

The EcoRV DNA methyltransferase introduces a CH3 group at the 6-amino position of the first dA in the duplex sequence d(GATATC). It has previously been reported that the methylase contacts the four phosphates (pNpNpGpA) at, and preceding, the 5'-end of the recognition sequence as well as the single dG in this sequence (Szczelkun, M. D., Jones, H., and Connolly, B. A. (1995) Biochemistry 34, 10734-10743). To study the possible role of the dA and T bases within the ATAT sequence, interference studies have been carried out using diethylpyrocarbonate and osmium tetroxide. The methylase bound very strongly to hemimethylated oligonucleotides modified at the second AT, of the ATAT sequence, in the unmethylated strand of the duplex. This probably arises because these modifications facilitate DNA distortion that follows the binding of the nucleic acid to the protein. Oligonucleotides containing modified bases at both the target dA base and its complementary T were used to determine whether this dA methylase flips out its target base in a similar manner to that observed for dC DNA methylases. In binary EcoRV methylase-DNA complexes, analogues that weakened the base pair caused an increase in affinity between the protein and the nucleic acid. In contrast, in ternary EcoRV methylase-DNA-sinefungin (an analogue of the natural co-factor, S-adenosyl-L-methionine (AdoMet)) complexes, only small differences in affinity were observed between the normal dA-T base pair and the analogues. These results are almost identical to those seen with DNA dC methylases (Klimasauskas, S., and Roberts R. J. (1995) Nucleic Acid Res. 23, 1388-1395; Yang, S. A., Jiang-Cheng, S., Zingg, J. M., Mi, S., and Jones, P. A. (1995) Nucleic Acids Res. 23, 1380-1387) and support a base-flipping mechanism for DNA dA methylases.

Tetracycline analogs affecting binding to Tn10-Encoded Tet repressor trigger the same mechanism of induction

We examined the influence of substituents in tetracycline (tc) analogs modified at positions 2 and 4-9 and anhydrotetracycline (atc) on induction of the Tn10-encoded Tet repressor (TetR) by a quantitative in vitro induction assay. The equilibrium association constants of the modified tc to TetR were independently determined to distinguish effects on binding from those on induction. We found a correlation between the binding affinity and induction of TetR for most tc analogs. While a substitution at position 5 revealed only minor effects, changes at position 6 increased binding and induction efficiencies up to 20-fold. A chlorine at position 7 or 8 enhanced binding and induction about 4- and 9-fold, respectively. Substituents at position 9 decreased binding up to 5-fold. Epimerization of the dimethylamino function at position 4 in 4-epi-tc resulted in about 300-fold-reduced binding and 80-fold-reduced induction. Substitution of this grouping by hydrogen in 4-de(dimethylamino)-tc resulted in no binding and no induction. The respective atc analog failed to induce as well, although binding was still observed. The dimethylamino function may, thus, play a role in triggering the conformational change of TetR necessary for induction. Substitution of the 2-carboxamido by a nitrilo function did not influence binding and induction efficiencies. Atc showed about 30-fold increased binding and induction, being the most effective inducer tested in this study. The equilibrium association constants of most TetR-[Mg-tc]+ and TetR-([Mg-tc]+)2 analog complexes with tet operator are decreased about 10(2)- and 10(8)-fold, respectively, as compared to those of free TetR. This suggests that these tc analogs share the same molecular mechanism of TetR induction.

Characterization of non-inducible Tet repressor mutants suggests conformational changes necessary for induction

Non-inducible tetracycline repressor (TetR) mutants were grouped in three structurally distinct classes. We quantitated in vivo operator binding, inducibility, and in vitro tetracycline binding of mutants from each class. Mutation of residues close to tetracycline (class 1) leads to reduced affinity for the drug. Mutation of residues located at the connection of the DNA-reading head with the protein core (class 2) and at the dimerization interface (class 3) bind inducer with the same affinity as wild-type TetR. These mutations interfere with the induced, but not the operator-binding conformation of TetR. The affinity of some class 1 mutants for tetracycline is less affected than their inducibility, suggesting that the mutated residues are important for triggering those conformational changes necessary for induction.

Interactions of the site-specific recombinases XerC and XerD with the recombination site dif

The Xer site-specific recombination system of Escherichia coli is involved in the stable inheritance of circular replicons. Multimeric replicons, produced by homologous recombination, are converted to monomers by the action of two related recombinases XerC and XerD. Site-specific recombination at a locus, dif, within the chromosomal replication terminus region is thought to convert dimeric chromosomes to monomers, which can then be segregated prior to cell division. The recombinases XerC and XerD bind cooperatively to dif, where they catalyse recombination. Chemical modification of specific bases and the phosphate-sugar backbone within dif was used to investigate the requirements for binding of the recombinases. Site-directed mutagenesis was then used to alter bases implicated in recombinase binding. Characterization of these mutants by in vitro recombinase binding and in vivo recombination, has demonstrated that the cooperative interactions between XerC and XerD can partially overcome DNA alterations that should interfere with specific recombinase-dif interactions.

Structure of the Tet repressor-tetracycline complex and regulation of antibiotic resistance

The most frequently occurring resistance of Gram-negative bacteria against tetracyclines is triggered by drug recognition of the Tet repressor. This causes dissociation of the repressor-operator DNA complex and enables expression of the resistance protein TetA, which is responsible for active efflux of tetracycline. The 2.5 angstrom resolution crystal structure of the homodimeric Tet repressor complexed with tetracycline-magnesium reveals detailed drug recognition. The orientation of the operator-binding helix-turn-helix motifs of the repressor is inverted in comparison with other DNA binding proteins. The repressor-drug complex is unable to interact with DNA because the separation of the DNA binding motifs is 5 angstroms wider than usually observed.

Contacts between Tet repressor and tet operator revealed by new recognition specificities of single amino acid replacement mutants

We have analyzed the DNA binding properties of Tet-repressor mutants with single amino acid residue replacements at eight positions within the alpha-helix-turn-alpha-helix DNA-binding motif. A saturation mutagenesis of Gln38, Pro39, Thr40, Tyr42, Trp43 and His44 in the second alpha-helix was performed; in addition, several substitutions of Thr27 and Arg28 in the first alpha-helix were constructed. The abilities of these mutant repressors to bind a set of 16 operator variants were determined and revealed 23 new binding specificities. All repressor mutants with DNA-binding activity were inducible by tetracycline, while mutants lacking binding activity were trans-dominant over the wild-type. All mutant proteins were present at the same intracellular steady-state concentrations as the wild-type. These results suggest the structural integrity of the mutant repressors. On the basis of the new recognition specificities, five contacts between a repressor monomer and each operator half-site and the chemical nature of these repressor-operator interactions are proposed. We suggest that Arg28 contacts guanine of the G.C base-pair at operator position 2 with two H-bonds, Gln38 binds adenine of the A.T base-pair at position 3 with two H-bonds, and the methyl group of Thr40 participates in a van der Waals' contact with cytosine of the G.C base-pair at position 6 of tet operator. A previously unrecognized type of interaction is proposed for Pro39, which inserts its side-chain between the methyl groups of the thymines of T.A and A.T base-pairs at positions 4 and 5. Computer modeling of these proposed contacts reveals that they are possible using the canonical structures of the helix-turn-helix motif and B-DNA. These contacts suggest an inverse orientation of the Tet repressor helix-turn-helix with respect to the operator center as compared with non-inducible repressor-operator complexes, and are supported by similar contacts of other repressor-operator complexes.

The Tn10-encoded Tet repressor blocks early but not late steps of assembly of the RNA polymerase II initiation complex in vivo

We have studied the effect of the Tn10-encoded Tet repressor on expression from 13 cauliflower mosaic virus (CaMV) 35S promoter derivatives that contain a tet operator sequence in various positions downstream of the TATAbox. When the operator sequence was inserted less than 33 bp away from the TATAbox (position +9 with respect to the transcription start site), the repressor interfered with transcription, whereas increasing the distance to 35 bp (position +11) abolished repression. This result indicates that initiation of transcription from the CaMV 35S promoter occurs in at least two different steps: (1) binding of transcription factors, involving sequences extending to position +9; this step can be inhibited by binding of the Tet repressor protein; and (2) initiation of transcription from this complex, which is not affected by the repressor protein. We suggest that the Tet repressor can be used to investigate whether transcription conditions in vitro truly reflect the in vivo situation.

Characterization of the interaction of plant transcription factors using a bacterial repressor protein

Transcription initiation from a eukaryotic polymerase II promoter requires a functional interaction of regulatory transcriptional activators with at least one of the basal transcription factors binding in the vicinity of the TATA box. To characterize this type of interaction in vivo, we have inserted the bacterial Tet repressor-operator complex in nine different positions between an enhancer element (as-1) and the TATA box of the cauliflower mosaic virus (CaMV) 35S RNA promoter. A direct contact between the transcriptional activator ASF-1, which binds to as-1, and the transcriptional machinery should be affected by a repressor protein bound between them, as the spacing of only 34 base pairs (bp) between as-1 and the TATA box is too short to allow looping of the DNA around the repressor. In each construct, the distance of 34 bp was kept constant, while the position of the 19-bp tet operator relative to the TATA box differed by 2 bp. Thus, the position of the Tet repressor relative to the plant transcription factors was consecutively changed by 72 degrees, which allowed us to investigate whether repression depended on the stereospecific alignment of the repressor with the transcription factors. Binding of the Tet repressor to the operator blocked transcription only when the operator was inserted less tha 5 bp from the TATA box. In all other promoter derivatives, no inhibitory effect of the repressor was observed, which suggests that ASF-1 does not directly interact with the general transcription machinery.

Regulation of a modified CaMV 35S promoter by the Tn10-encoded Tet repressor in transgenic tobacco

We have investigated the use of the Tn10-encoded tet repressor-operator system to regulate the expression of a suitably engineered cauliflower mosaic virus (CaMV) 35S promoter in transgenic tobacco plants. First, a transgenic plant was generated which constitutively synthesizes 600,000 Tet repressor monomers per cell. In a second transformation step, the beta-glucuronidase (gus) gene under the control of a modified CaMV 35S promoter, containing two tet operators, was stably integrated into the plant genome of a tetR+ plant. Expression of the gus gene is repressed 5-fold, if the operators are located flanking the TATA box, and 50- to 80-fold when both operators are positioned downstream of the TATA box. This indicates that Tet repressor-operator complexes can form on plant chromosomes and interfere with transcription. Maximal induction is achieved after 0.5 h upon application of only 0.1 mg/l tetracycline. This fast and efficient induction makes the system useful for specifically inducing expression of transferred genes at different stages of plant development.

Local supercoil-stabilized DNA structures

The DNA double helix exhibits local sequence-dependent polymorphism at the level of the single base pair and dinucleotide step. Curvature of the DNA molecule occurs in DNA regions with a specific type of nucleotide sequence periodicities. Negative supercoiling induces in vitro local nucleotide sequence-dependent DNA structures such as cruciforms, left-handed DNA, multistranded structures, etc. Techniques based on chemical probes have been proposed that make it possible to study DNA local structures in cells. Recent results suggest that the local DNA structures observed in vitro exist in the cell, but their occurrence and structural details are dependent on the DNA superhelical density in the cell and can be related to some cellular processes.

Chemical and photochemical probing of DNA complexes

An overview of the chemical and photochemical probes which over the past ten years have been used in studies of DNA/ligand complexes and of non-B-form DNA conformations is presented with emphasis on the chemical reactions of the probes with DNA and on their present 'use-profile'. The chemical probes include: dimethyl sulfate, ethyl nitroso urea, diethyl pyrocarbonate, osmium tetroxide, permanganate, aldehydes, methidiumpropyl-EDTA-Fell (MPE), phenanthroline metal complexes and EDTA/FeII. The photochemical probes that have been used include: psoralens, UVB, acridines and uranyl salts. The biological systems analysed by use of these probes are reviewed by tabulation.

Saturation mutagenesis of the Tn10-encoded tet operator O1. Identification of base-pairs involved in Tet repressor recognition

Saturation mutagenesis of Tn10-encoded tet operator O1 was performed by chemical synthesis of 30 sequence variants yielding all possible point mutations of an operator half side. Their effect on Tet repressor binding was scored by an in-vivo repressor titration system. Tet repressor affinities of selected operator mutants were further characterized in vitro by dissociation rate measurements. The O1 sequence spans 19 base-pairs. Out of these, all 18 palindromic base-pairs are involved in Tet repressor recognition. The central base-pair does not contribute to sequence-specific binding of Tet repressor. At position 1 a pyrimidine residue is sufficient for maximal affinity to the repressor. At positions 2, 3 and 4, each mutation reduces repressor binding at least tenfold. Mutations at positions 5, 6, 7, 8 and 9 result in less drastic reductions of Tet repressor binding. Differential effects of mutations at a given position are used to deduce the chemical functions contacted by Tet repressor. The T.A to A.T transversion at position 9 increases Tet repressor affinity slightly, while all other mutations decrease repressor binding. The increased affinity of the wild-type tet operator O2 compared to wild-type O1 results from the addition of two favorable transversions at positions +/- 9 and an unfavorable T.A to C.G transition at position -7. Deletion or palindromic doubling of the central base-pair of the O1 palindrome reveals that the wild-type spacing of both operator half sides is crucial for efficient Tet repressor binding.