The Union Carbide catalyst (Cp2Cr + SiO2), studied by solid-state NMR

Assigning 1H chemical shifts in paramagnetic mono- and bimetallic surface sites using DFT: a case study on the Union Carbide polymerization catalyst

The Union Carbide (UC) ethylene polymerization catalyst, based on silica-supported chromocene, is one of the first industrial catalysts prepared by surface organometallic chemistry, though the structure of the surface sites remains elusive. Recently, our group reported that monomeric and dimeric Cr(ii) sites, as well as Cr(iii) hydride sites, are present and that their proportion varies as a function of the Cr loading. While ¹H chemical shifts extracted from solid-state ¹H NMR spectra should be diagnostic of the structure of such surface sites, unpaired electrons centered on Cr atoms induce large paramagnetic ¹H shifts that complicate their NMR analysis. Here, we implement a cost-efficient DFT methodology to calculate ¹H chemical shifts for antiferromagnetically coupled metal dimeric sites using a Boltzmann-averaged Fermi contact term over the population of the different spin states. This method allowed us to assign the ¹H chemical shifts observed for the industrial-like UC catalyst. The presence of monomeric and dimeric Cr(ii) sites, as well as a dimeric Cr(iii)-hydride sites, was confirmed and their structure was clarified.

Creating Solid Solutions of Metallocenes: Migration of Nickelocene into the Ferrocene Crystal Lattice in the Absence of a Solvent

Ferrocene and nickelocene do not react with each other in solution; however, the large impact of the paramagnetic component on the ferrocene 1H NMR signal linewidth and relaxation times has been quantified. Co-crystallization of ferrocene and nickelocene at any ratio from a solvent can be explained with both pure substances crystallizing in the same space group P21/n. As a new phenomenon, when a ferrocene single crystal is exposed to polycrystalline nickelocene in the absence of a solvent, the nickelocene migrates into the ferrocene crystal lattice and a mixed crystal is formed that retains its macroscopic shape. This process has been proven visually by cutting the single crystal. Mixing polycrystalline ferrocene with polycrystalline nickelocene at different molar ratios with a mortar and pestle leads to crystalline solid solutions with the corresponding molar ratios of both components. This migration of one organometallic component into an existing crystal lattice of another at ambient temperature in the absence of a solvent has not been described previously. Paramagnetic 1H solid-state NMR spectroscopy of static and rotating samples of dry ferrocene/nickelocene mixtures at varying ratios is used to prove and quantify the mixing of both metallocenes at the molecular level. A single-crystal X-ray structure of a 50/50 mixed crystal corroborates the NMR results that nickelocene and ferrocene are randomly distributed in the lattice and that the space group P21/n is retained. All ferrocene molecules in the mixed crystal lattice show a broadening of their 1H wideline signals and residual magic-angle spinning (MAS) lines at ambient temperature. The broadening of the ferrocene signals correlates with the nickelocene content. 1H T1 relaxation time measurements for the signals of ferrocene in samples with different amounts of nickelocene corroborate the assumption that the signal broadening is due to paramagnetic dipole-dipole relaxation of ferrocene molecules in the vicinity of nickelocene. Spatially separated ferrocene and nickelocene powders in one rotor show the solid-state NMR characteristics of the individual polycrystalline metallocenes. The described formation of solid solutions of metallocenes in the absence of a solvent will open new pathways to homogeneously mixed nanoparticles with desired metal ratios and dual-atom catalysts.

Molecular Dynamics and Surface Interactions of Nickelocene Adsorbed on Silica: A Paramagnetic Solid-State NMR Study

When grinding nickelocene with silica in the absence of a solvent at room temperature, it adsorbs on the surface within the pores. This has also been demonstrated visually by adsorbing green nickelocene in the pores of a large colorless silica gel specimen. While this dry adsorption and translational mobility of nickelocene within the pores is proven visually, the site-to-site mobility of the nickelocene molecules and their orientation toward the surface are not yet understood. In this contribution, mesoporous silica is used as the support material for a systematic solid-state NMR study of these issues. Paramagnetic ¹H VT solid-state NMR and T₁ relaxation times have been powerful tools for studying the dynamics of nickelocene on the silica surface. Herewith, the mobility of the surface-adsorbed nickelocene molecules in the pores could be quantified on the molecular scale. According to the obtained data, the nickelocene molecules move like a liquid on the surface. Isotropically moving molecules exchange places rapidly with surface-attached molecular states of nickelocene in a sample with submonolayer surface coverage. This finding is corroborated by a macroscopic visualization experiment. The states of the surface-attached horizontally oriented nickelocene molecules that are prevalent at temperatures below 200 K have been quantified. The temperature dependencies of the rate k in coordinates of ln(k) versus 1/T and ln(k/T) versus 1/T form ideal straight lines that allow the determination of the kinetic parameters E_act = 5.5 kcal/mol, A = 1.1 × 10¹⁰, ΔH^‡ = 5.0 kcal/mol, and ΔS^‡ = -15 eu. Investigating a sample with equal amounts of nickelocene and ferrocene in a submonolayer amount of 80% overall surface coverage shows that the different metallocenes mix on the molecular level on the silica surface.

Union carbide polymerization catalysts: from uncovering active site structures to designing molecularly-defined analogs

The Union Carbide (UC) ethylene polymerization catalysts, based on chromocene dispersed on silica, show distinct features from the Phillips catalysts, but share the same heated debate regarding the structure of their active sites. Based on a combination of IR, EPR spectroscopies, labeling experiments, and DFT modeling, we identified monomeric surface-supported Cr(iii) hydrides, ( Created by potrace 1.16, written by Peter Selinger 2001-2019 ]]> SiO)Cr(Cp)–H, as the active sites of the UC catalyst. These sites are formed in the presence of grafted and adsorbed chromocene as well as residual surface OH groups, only possible at high Cr loading, and involve a C–H activation of the Cp ring. These Cr-hydrides initiate polymerization, yielding Cr(iii) alkyl species that insert ethylene through a Cossee–Arlman-type mechanism, as evidenced by spectroscopic studies. These insights inspired the design of a well-defined analog, CpCr(CH(SiMe₃)₂)₂ grafted on partially dehydroxylated silica, that shows similar spectroscopic and polymer structure to the UC catalyst, further supporting the proposed active site structure.

A combined SOMC and DFT studies on the Union Carbide catalyst enable to propose that Cr(iii)-H, formed at high-loading, are active in ethylene polymerization. We therefore design a well-defined supported CpCr(iii)-R ethylene polymerization catalyst.

Disentangling different modes of mobility for triphenylphosphine oxide adsorbed on alumina

Triphenylphosphine oxide (TPPO, 1) has been adsorbed on neutral alumina by dry grinding of the components in the absence of a solvent. The adsorption proves translational mobility of 1 on the surface of alumina. Different surface coverages from a densely packed monolayer (99% coverage) to a dilute sub-monolayer (25%) have been produced. The samples have been studied by diverse multinuclear ¹H, ¹³C, and ³¹P variable temperature solid-state nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) techniques. The interactions of 1 with the surface are determined by hydrogen bonding of the P=O group to OH groups on the surface. The ³¹P solid-state NMR spectra prove that even at low temperatures, the molecules of 1 are highly mobile on the surface. Using T₁ and T₂ relaxation time analyses of the ³¹P resonance in the solid state at variable temperatures allowed the identification and quantification of two different modes of mobility. Besides the translational mobility that consists of jumps from one hydrogen-bonding OH site on the surface to an adjacent one, a rotational movement around the axis defined by the P=O group of 1 occurs.

Structures and Dynamics of Secondary and Tertiary Alkylphosphine Oxides Adsorbed on Silica

The three secondary phosphine oxides [CH₂ =CH(CH₂ )₄ ]₂ HPO (1), [CH₂ =CH(CH₂ )₅ ]₂ HPO (2), and [CH₂ =CH(CH₂ )₆ ]₂ HPO (3), and two diphosphine dioxides, {[CH₂ =CH(CH₂ )₆ ]₂ PO(CH₂ )₇ }₂ (4) and {[CH₂ =CH(CH₂ )₆ ]₂ PO(CH₂ )₄ }₂ (5), incorporating long methylene chains, are described. The single crystal X-ray structures of 1, 2, and 5 have been determined. The phosphine oxides 3, 4, and 5 have been adsorbed on silica in submonolayer quantities to give 3 a-5 a. The ¹ H, ¹³ C, and ³¹ P solid-state NMR spectra of polycrystalline 3-5 have been analyzed and compared with those of 3 a-5 a. The changes of the solid-state NMR characteristics upon adsorption and the surface mobilities of the phosphine oxides are discussed.

Single-atom active sites on metal-organic frameworks

Single-site heterogeneous catalysis has been recently accepted as a novel branch of heterogeneous catalysis. Catalysts with single-atom active sites (SAHCs) allow the design and fine-tuning of the active moiety, and can potentially combine the advantages of heterogeneous and homogeneous catalysis. This study illustrates how porous metal-organic frameworks (MOFs) can be synthesized with homogeneous distribution of SAHCs. The catalytic potential of MIXMOFs is shown. A short overview of catalysis with mesoporous silica materials is described to demonstrate their importance in SAHC.

Solid-State 93Nb and 13C NMR Investigations of Half-Sandwich Niobium(I) and Niobium(V) Cyclopentadienyl Complexes

Solid-state 93Nb and 13C NMR experiments, in combination with theoretical calculations of NMR tensors, and single-crystal and powder X-ray diffraction experiments, are applied for the comprehensive characterization of structure and dynamics in a series of organometallic niobium complexes. Half-sandwich niobium metallocenes of the forms Cp'Nb(I)(CO)4 and CpNb(V)Cl4 are investigated, where Cp = C5H5- and Cp' = C5H4R- with R = COMe, CO2Me, CO2Et, and COCH2Ph. Anisotropic quadrupolar and chemical shielding (CS) parameters are extracted from 93Nb MAS and static NMR spectra for seven different complexes. It is demonstrated that 93Nb NMR parameters are sensitive to changes in temperature and Cp' ring substitution in the Cp'Nb(I)(CO)4 complexes. There are dramatic differences in the 93Nb quadrupolar coupling constants (C(Q)) between the Nb(I) and Nb(V) complexes, with C(Q) between 1.0 and 12.0 MHz for Cp'Nb(CO)4 and C(Q) = 54.5 MHz for CpNbCl4. The quadrupolar Carr-Purcell Meiboom-Gill (QCPMG) pulse sequence is applied to rapidly acquire, in a piecewise fashion, a high signal-to-noise ultra-wide-line 93Nb NMR spectrum of CpNbCl4, which has a breadth of ca. 400 kHz. Solid-state 93Nb and 13C NMR spectra and powder XRD data are used to identify a new metallocene adduct coordinated at the axial position of the metal site by a THF molecule: CpNb(V)Cl4.THF. 13C MAS and CP/MAS NMR experiments are used to assess the purity of samples, as well as for measuring carbon CS tensors and the rare instance of one-bond 93Nb, 13C J-coupling, 1J(93Nb,13C). Theoretically calculated CS and electric field gradient (EFG) tensors are utilized to determine relationships between tensor orientations, the principal components, and molecular structures.