Neuropathic urinary incontinence in pediatric patients: management with artificial sphincter

Chapitre C-2 E - Chirurgie prothétique de l’incontinence urinaire d’effort par insuffisance sphinctérienne neurologique

Neurogenic sphincter incompetence, in the absence of detrusor dysfunction, results in stress urinary incontinence. Management is exclusively surgical. The available artificial sphincters ensure continence, provided intermittent self-catheterization is performed when necessary for neurogenic bladder. Artificial urinary sphincter is the reference treatment, historically and based on published cohort studies. However, it is associated with a higher morbidity in this population than in the non-neurological population. Although the surgical implantation technique is not modified in females as a result of the neurological disorder it is modified in males, as periprostatic implantation may be necessary, requiring specific training in this technique and rigorous patient selection. Other more recent prosthetic treatments are being developed, but are still at the stage of evaluation: periurethral fascia sling, periurethral injections and periurethral balloon implantation. These techniques eliminate the need to manipulate a pump to open the sphincter for self-catheterization. They appear to be promising, but their long-term results are unknown. In conclusion, operative indications for SUI due to neurogenic sphincter incompetence must be based on a multidisciplinary diagnostic assessment and explicit patient information.

Long-term results of artificial urinary sphincters in children are independent of age at implantation

PURPOSE

The long-term success and efficacy of the artificial urinary sphincter for the management of neurogenic incontinence have been well documented. We evaluated if long-term results were affected by patient age at the time of sphincter placement.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A retrospective review of the medical records of patients who underwent artificial urinary sphincter placement and had minimum of 10 years of followup was conducted. All patients with an intact sphincter were interviewed to assess current results. Patients were stratified into groups 1 and 2 if the sphincter was implanted before or after age 11 years, respectively, and the results were compared statistically.

RESULTS

An artificial urinary sphincter was placed in 45 children at Children's Hospital of Michigan between October 1978 and August 1986, and medical records and followup were available for 32. Mean followup was 15.4 years. Of the 21 group 1 patients 12 (57%) have an intact sphincter after 26 revisions, and all are dry and 9 (75%) require intermittent catheterization. Of the 11 group 2 patients 7 (64%) have an intact sphincter, and 6 (86%) are dry, 3 (43%) perform intermittent catheterization and 6 required 8 revisions. There was no statistically significant difference in the number of artificial urinary sphincter removals, continence, revision rate, bladder augmentations, complications or upper tract changes.

CONCLUSIONS

The artificial urinary sphincter is a successful and durable option for the surgical management of neurogenic incontinence. The long-term results appear independent of patient age at the time of sphincter placement.

Placement of artificial urinary sphincter in children and simultaneous gastrocystoplasty

PURPOSE

Previous studies have described placement of an artificial urinary sphincter and simultaneous augmentation cystoplasty with a segment of bowel. Conclusions from these studies indicated that infection rates were higher and a staged approach should be undertaken. Others have suggested that concurrent urinary reconstruction with stomach and sphincter placement can be performed safely. Results comparing infection rates of simultaneous sphincter placement and gastrocystoplasty versus staged sphincter placement and augmentation cystoplasty using a segment of ileum or stomach versus sphincter placement alone in a pediatric population have not been previously described to our knowledge. We reviewed these various groups of patients to determine if the difference in infectious complications were clinically and statistically significant.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A retrospective review of medical records from 1986 to 1999 identified 28 pediatric patients (age 18 years or less) who had undergone placement of an AS800dagger artificial urinary sphincter. Data points were collected focusing on etiology of the neurogenic bladder, age at time of surgery, types of surgery performed, length of followup and complication rates.

RESULTS

Complete data were available for 27 of the 28 patients. Neurogenic bladder was secondary to myelomeningocele in 25 cases, transverse myelitis in 1 and spinal cord injury in 2. Mean patient age at surgery was 12.7 years (range 6.1 to 18.2) and mean followup was 4.3 years (range 1 month to 13 years). Simultaneous gastrocystoplasty was performed in 7 cases (group 1), staged sphincter placement followed by augmentation cystoplasty with a segment of ileum or stomach was done in 8 (group 2) and 12 did not require bladder augmentation (group 3). Urethral device erosion requiring explantation was the most common complication, occurring in 3 patients in group 1 and 2 in group 3 (p = 0.101). Mean time to erosion was 22.1 months (range 2 to 46.4). Previous surgery (bladder neck or hernia repair) was a common factor in each group with complications. Urine cultures and culture of the explanted device were positive in 2 patients in group 1.

CONCLUSIONS

Simultaneous placement of artificial urinary sphincter at the time of gastrocystoplasty can be performed in carefully selected patients, although those undergoing staged procedures did well without complications. Prior bladder neck surgery seems to be a significant risk for infection. A staged approach to lower urinary tract reconstruction would be more advantageous due to the absence of infection and erosion in those undergoing staged sphincter placement and augmentation cystoplasty.

Long-term results of artificial urinary sphincters in children are independent of age at implantation

PURPOSE

The long-term success and efficacy of the artificial urinary sphincter for the management of neurogenic incontinence have been well documented. We evaluated if long-term results were affected by patient age at the time of sphincter placement.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A retrospective review of the medical records of patients who underwent artificial urinary sphincter placement and had minimum of 10 years of followup was conducted. All patients with an intact sphincter were interviewed to assess current results. Patients were stratified into groups 1 and 2 if the sphincter was implanted before or after age 11 years, respectively, and the results were compared statistically.

RESULTS

An artificial urinary sphincter was placed in 45 children at Children's Hospital of Michigan between October 1978 and August 1986, and medical records and followup were available for 32. Mean followup was 15.4 years. Of the 21 group 1 patients 12 (57%) have an intact sphincter after 26 revisions, and all are dry and 9 (75%) require intermittent catheterization. Of the 11 group 2 patients 7 (64%) have an intact sphincter, and 6 (86%) are dry, 3 (43%) perform intermittent catheterization and 6 required 8 revisions. There was no statistically significant difference in the number of artificial urinary sphincter removals, continence, revision rate, bladder augmentations, complications or upper tract changes.

CONCLUSIONS

The artificial urinary sphincter is a successful and durable option for the surgical management of neurogenic incontinence. The long-term results appear independent of patient age at the time of sphincter placement.

Placement of artificial urinary sphincter in children and simultaneous gastrocystoplasty

PURPOSE

Previous studies have described placement of an artificial urinary sphincter and simultaneous augmentation cystoplasty with a segment of bowel. Conclusions from these studies indicated that infection rates were higher and a staged approach should be undertaken. Others have suggested that concurrent urinary reconstruction with stomach and sphincter placement can be performed safely. Results comparing infection rates of simultaneous sphincter placement and gastrocystoplasty versus staged sphincter placement and augmentation cystoplasty using a segment of ileum or stomach versus sphincter placement alone in a pediatric population have not been previously described to our knowledge. We reviewed these various groups of patients to determine if the difference in infectious complications were clinically and statistically significant.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A retrospective review of medical records from 1986 to 1999 identified 28 pediatric patients (age 18 years or less) who had undergone placement of an AS800dagger artificial urinary sphincter. Data points were collected focusing on etiology of the neurogenic bladder, age at time of surgery, types of surgery performed, length of followup and complication rates.

RESULTS

Complete data were available for 27 of the 28 patients. Neurogenic bladder was secondary to myelomeningocele in 25 cases, transverse myelitis in 1 and spinal cord injury in 2. Mean patient age at surgery was 12.7 years (range 6.1 to 18.2) and mean followup was 4.3 years (range 1 month to 13 years). Simultaneous gastrocystoplasty was performed in 7 cases (group 1), staged sphincter placement followed by augmentation cystoplasty with a segment of ileum or stomach was done in 8 (group 2) and 12 did not require bladder augmentation (group 3). Urethral device erosion requiring explantation was the most common complication, occurring in 3 patients in group 1 and 2 in group 3 (p = 0.101). Mean time to erosion was 22.1 months (range 2 to 46.4). Previous surgery (bladder neck or hernia repair) was a common factor in each group with complications. Urine cultures and culture of the explanted device were positive in 2 patients in group 1.

CONCLUSIONS

Simultaneous placement of artificial urinary sphincter at the time of gastrocystoplasty can be performed in carefully selected patients, although those undergoing staged procedures did well without complications. Prior bladder neck surgery seems to be a significant risk for infection. A staged approach to lower urinary tract reconstruction would be more advantageous due to the absence of infection and erosion in those undergoing staged sphincter placement and augmentation cystoplasty.

The outcome of artificial urinary sphincter placement after a mean 15-year follow-up in a paediatric population

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the long-term outcome in children who had an artificial urinary sphincter (AUS) placed, after a minimum of 10 years of follow-up.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

The medical records of patients who had an AUS placed at the Children's Hospital of Michigan were reviewed and a telephone questionnaire was then completed by all patients with an AUS currently in place.

RESULTS

Forty-seven children initially had an AUS placed between October 1978 and August 1986; medical records and follow-up were available for 32. After a mean follow-up of 15.4 years, 13 patients had had the AUS removed and 19 currently have an intact AUS. Erosion or infection was responsible for all AUS removals. Possible risk factors for AUS removal were prior AUS erosion, prior bladder neck surgery and a balloon pressure of >70 cmH2O. Eighteen of 19 patients with an intact AUS are dry and seven void volitionally. Revision was the most common reason for additional surgery, but the revision rate has decreased with the most current AS-800 model, to 0.03 revisions per patient-year. Of the 13 patients with an AS-800 model placed after 1987, nine have not required revision. Upper tract changes were mild and uncommon.

CONCLUSION

The AUS is a durable and effective surgical option in the management of neurogenic urinary incontinence, and is the only reliable technique that can preserve volitional voiding. With technical improvements to the AUS and a longer follow-up, the revision rate has decreased. Causes of AUS removal may be preventable with improvements in surgical technique and patient selection. AUS placement should be considered as a first choice for the surgical management of neurogenic sphincteric incompetence.

The development and evolution of artificial urethral sphincters

This history and evolution of mechanical devices designed to achieve urinary continence are reviewed. The following devices were studies: Foley clamp, Kaufman prosthesis, Giori, Summers and Rosen sphincters, Gruneberger and Cleveland Clinic magnetic designs, Craggs sphincter and the AMS family of sphincters (AMS 721, AMS 761, AMS 742 (A, B, C), AMS 792, AMS 800). The design of active hydraulic devices is discussed in more detail. This review analyses the problems relating to the application of pressure and the presence of foreign material around the urethra. 'Volume set' devices are universally unsuccessful and detrimental for urethral integrity as opposed to 'pressure set' hydraulic sphincters (e.g. AMS 800). The implications for the design of artificial implants are discussed.