Shear strength of laboratory-processed composite resins bonded to a silane-coated nickel-chromium-beryllium alloy

The Post-endodontic Adhesive Interface: Theoretical Perspectives and Potential Flaws

INTRODUCTION

The aim of this review was to analyze the potential of successful bonds of endodontic posts to radicular dentin as well as the limitations of the post-endodontic adhesive interface.

METHODS

The MEDLINE/PubMed and Web of Science electronic databases were searched. The search was augmented by a manual search of the pertinent bibliographies.

RESULTS

The post-endodontic adhesive interface finds application in the endodontic cohesive units. Many techniques and materials exist to improve the bond between endodontic posts and resin-based materials as well as between resin-based materials and radicular dentin. Different techniques used for the adhesion of metallic and fiber-reinforced posts are discussed and critically analyzed.

CONCLUSIONS

Although adhesive cementation of endodontic posts is popular, a long-term predictable bond may be compromised because of procedures related to the endodontic treatment and/or the adhesive cementation procedures. Microleakage and degradation phenomena may further jeopardize the post-endodontic adhesive interface.

Bonding durability between acrylic resin adhesives and titanium with surface preparations

The purpose of the present study was to evaluate the efficacy of pretreatment on the bonding durability between titanium casting and two acrylic adhesives. Cast titanium disk specimens treated with four polymer-metal bonding systems as follow: 1) air-abraded with 50-70 μm alumina, 2) 1)+Alloy Primer, 3) 1)+M.L. Primer and 4) tribochemical silica/silane coating system (Rocatec System). The specimens were bonded with M bond or Super-bond C&B adhesive. The shear bond strengths were determined before and after thermocycling (20,000 cycles). The surface characteristics after polishing, and for the 1) and 4) preparations were determined. The bond strengths for all combinations significantly decreased after thermocycling. The combination of Super-bond C&B adhesive and 2) led to significantly higher bond strength than the other preparations after thermocycling. The maximum height of the profile parameters for the polishing group was lower than other preparations.

Evaluation of two dual-functional primers and a tribochemical surface modification system applied to the bonding of an indirect composite resin to metals

We evaluated the effects of two dual-functional primers and a tribochemical surface modification system on the bond strength between an indirect composite resin and gold alloy or titanium. Disk specimens (diameter, 10 mm; thickness, 2.5 mm) were cast from type 4 gold alloy and commercially pure titanium. The specimens were wetground to a final surface finish using 600-grit silicone carbide paper. The specimens were then air-dried and treated using the following four bonding systems: (1) air-abrasion with 50-70 mum alumina, (2) system 1 + alloy primer, (3) system 1 + metal link primer, and (4) tribochemical silica/silane coating (Rocatec). A light-polymerizing indirect composite resin (Ceramage) was applied to each metal specimen and polymerized according to the manufacturer's specifications. Shear bond strengths (MPa) were determined both before and after thermocycling (4 degrees C and 60 degrees C for 1 min each for 20 000 cycles). The values were compared using analysis of variance, post hoc Scheffe tests, and Mann-Whitney U tests (alpha = 0.05). The strengths decreased after thermocycling for all combinations. For both gold alloy and titanium, the bond strength with air-abrasion only was statistically lower than that with the other three modification methods after thermocycling. Titanium exhibited a significantly higher value (13.4 MPa) than gold alloy (10.5 MPa) with the air. abrasion and alloy primer system. Treatment with the tribochemical system or air abrasion followed by treatment with dual-functional priming agents was found to be effective for enhancement of the bonding between the indirect composite and gold alloy or titanium.

Shear bond strength of three veneering resins to a Ni-Cr alloy using two bonding procedures

Composite veneering materials are used as alternatives to porcelain in fixed prosthodontics. Mechanical retention of the resin on the metal framework has been associated with the formation of gaps at the resin/alloy interface, and failure of the restoration. Several chemical bonding systems have been introduced to promote resin adhesion. The purpose of the present study was to evaluate the shear bond strength of three photocured composites (Artglass, Solidex & Signum+) to a Ni-Cr alloy.72 wax disks covered with 150-mum diameter beads were cast and divided in two equal groups. In the first group, Metal Photo Primer was applied on the casting surface, while the Siloc system was used in the second. Each group was divided in three subgroups of 12 samples, in which the three composites were photocured. Half of the specimens of each subgroup were subjected to 1000 and 5000 thermal cycles (5 and 55 degrees C) respectively. All specimens were tested in shear in a universal testing machine. The Siloc-Solidex group showed the highest bond strength (17.3 +/- 3.7 MPa). No statistically significant difference was found between specimens treated with Metal Photo Primer or Siloc. Thermocycling did not significantly affect the bond strength values. Solidex showed an adhesive failure mode for both alloy surface treatments, while Artglass and Signum+ exhibited combination failures. Conclusively, the appropriate alloy surface treatment - resin combination can significantly improve the resin-alloy shear bond strength. Specifically, Solidex resin exhibited significantly higher bond values compared with Artglass and Signum+, for both surface treatments and thermocycling procedures.

[Bonding agent influence on shear bond strength of titanium/polyglass interface]

There is little information regarding bond strengths of polyglass to metal alloys. This study evaluated the influence of bonding system on shear bond strength of a composite resin (Artglass/Heraeus Kulzer) to cast titanium (Ti). Twenty metallic structures (4mm in diameter, 5mm thick) of titanium grade I were cast shaped and abraded with 250mm aluminum oxide and separated into two groups. For each group was applied one bonding system (Siloc or Retention Flow) before opaque and dentin polymer superposition. This procedure was managed using teflon matrices. They were manipulated and polymerized according to the manufacturer's recommendations. The samples were stored in distilled water for 24 hours at 37º and thermocycled (5º and 55ºC/500 cycles). Shear bond strength tests were performed by using an Instron Universal testing machine at a crosshead speed of 5mm/min. Results were analyzed statistically with one-way ANOVA (a=0,5) and they indicated that the Retention Flow system was statistically better than Siloc (20.74 MPa and 11.65 MPa , respectively). It was possible to conclude that the bonding agent influenced the adhesion between polymer and cast titanium.

Shear bond strength of aesthetic materials bonded to Ni-Cr alloy

OBJECTIVES

This study was undertaken to evaluate the shear bond strength of four materials used as aesthetic material bonded to Ni-Cr alloy.

METHODS

Sixty-eight alloy discs were prepared and divided equally into four groups, and received four treatments for veneering: conventional feldspathic porcelain (Noritake EX-3) and three light-cured prosthodontic composite resins (Artglass, Solidex and Targis). The aesthetic materials were applied after metal structure conditioning in accordance with the manufacturers' recommendations. The specimens were stored in distilled water at 37 degrees C for 7 days. A universal testing machine was used to measure the shear bond strength of the specimens at a cross head speed of 0.5 mm/min. Fractured specimens were examined by using both optical and scanning electron microscope.

RESULTS

The analysis of variance and Tukey's test showed that the strongest mean shear bond was obtained with Noritake EX-3 (mean shear bond strength 42.90+/-7.82 MPa). For composites, the highest mean shear bond strength was observed for Targis (12.30+/-1.57 MPa); followed by Solidex (11.94+/-1.04 MPa) and Artglass (10.04+/-0.75 MPa). Optical analysis of the fractured surfaces indicated that for Targis and Noritake EX-3 all failures were a mixture of both cohesive and adhesive patterns. As for Artglass and Solidex, the fractures were mainly adhesive in nature.

CONCLUSIONS

The Solidex system was equivalent to the Targis system in bond strength and exhibited greater strength than the Artglass system. The porcelain fused-to-metal showed considerably higher shear bond strength than the three metal-resin bonding techniques.

Shear bond strength of techniques for bonding esthetic veneers to metal

STATEMENT OF PROBLEM

New composites with improved qualities have been introduced to the dental profession as alternatives to porcelain. There is concern about the strength and reliability of new metal-resin bonding systems when these composites are used as esthetic veneers over metal frameworks.

PURPOSE

This in vitro study compared the shear bond strength of 2 metal-resin bonding techniques with the bond strength of conventional porcelain fused-to-metal (PFM). Effects of water storage and thermocycling were also evaluated.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Ninety disks, cast in a medium gold, high noble PFM alloy, were divided equally into 6 groups, and received 3 treatments for veneering: conventional feldspathic porcelain on 1 group, and a composite (Artglass) bonded to the metal, using 2 metal-resin bonding techniques. Specimens were tested in shear, half of them after a 24-hour dry storage at room temperature and the rest after 10-day storage in normal saline solution at 37 degrees C and thermocycling. Fractured specimens were evaluated under x10 magnification to determine the nature of failure. Statistical analysis was performed with 2-factor analysis of variance (ANOVA).

RESULTS

Mean shear bond strength values before and after wet storage and thermocycling were 29.66 and 22.91 MPa for the PFM group; 21.43 and 17.92 MPa for the Siloc group; and 19.34 and 15.64 for the etched group, respectively. The PFM group exhibited significantly higher bond strength values compared with the other 2 groups (P<.001). All groups showed a significant decrease in bond strength values after wet storage and thermocycling (P<.001).

CONCLUSION

Wet storage and thermocycling caused a significant decrease in shear bond strength of all specimens. Shear bond strength of conventional feldspathic PFM was significantly higher than that of the 2 metal-resin bonding techniques tested. The 2 latter techniques did not reveal any statistically significant differences.

Resin to metal bond strengths using two commercial systems

STATEMENT OF PROBLEM

A secure bond between resin and an alloy framework is necessary for clinical success in removable prosthodontics.

PURPOSE

This study compared the shear bond strength of composite to composite to metal with two commercially available chemical bonding systems: a silicoating system (Silicoater) and a nitrogenous heterocycle-acrylonitrile system (Kevloc).

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Fifty-two nickel-chromium cubes were cast and composite resin was bonded to the alloy surfaces according to manufacturer's directions. After storage at 35 degrees C for 15 days, and thermocycling at 5 degrees C and 55 degrees C for 1200 cycles, the bonds were fractured in shear on a universal testing machine.

RESULTS

Mean bond strength for the silicoated sample was 10.93 MPa and for the heterocycle-acrylnitrate system 11.44 MPa. An unpaired t test revealed no difference between the groups (p = 0.60). Visual inspection of the fracture surfaces revealed that failure was adhesive at the resin-to-metal surface in almost all the specimens.

Bond strengths of resin-to-metal bonding systems

STATEMENT OF PROBLEM

Resinous materials for the veneers of fixed prostheses commonly require mechanical retention on metal substructures because there is no chemical adhesion. However, mechanical retention does not restrict creation of a marginal gap at the resin-metal interface, which can cause discoloration or detachment of resinous material. The development of a chemical resin-to-metal bonding could resolve this problem and also reduce the need for mechanical retention (pearls, wires) on metal frameworks.

PURPOSE

This study evaluated six current methods with the use of various storage conditions to predict clinical efficacy.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Six resin-to-metal bonding systems were tested: Silicoater, Silicoater MD, Rocatec, OVS, Sebond, and Spectra-Link. All specimens were examined in bending tests after 24 hours of dry storage (category A), after 24 hours of water storage and thermocycling (category B), and after 2 months of water storage and thermocycling (category C). Tensional tests were completed for all bonding systems after dry storage, and microscopic examination (optical and SEM) was performed for all specimens.

RESULTS AND CONCLUSIONS

This study indicated that certain systems can provide stable bonding of resin to metal substructures despite prolonged wet storage and intensive thermocycling. These systems can also be used clinically without retentive configurations on metal frameworks, resulting in better esthetics. Some bonding systems revealed progressive weakening of bond strengths, so research is needed to verify their clinical efficacy.

A comparison of two silicoating techniques

PURPOSE

A major challenge of composite-coated metal restorations is creating a strong bond between the two materials. This study was conducted to compare the bond strengths between composite and metal alloys using two silicoating treatments; the Silicoater Classic and the Silicoater MD (Kulzer Inc, Irvine, CA).

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The Classic uses a pyrolytically applied silica glass and the MD process is an oven sintering of a metal oxide silicate layer. Two types of specimens of three different alloys were cast (Deva4: 51Au38Pd, G-Cast: 50Au32Ag12Cu [Degussa Corp. South Plainfield, NJ]; Ticonium: 70Ni15Cr [CMP Industries, Inc, Albany NY]). The specimens were silicoated with either the Classic or the MD process and opaque resin and composite (Dentacolor, Kulzer Inc) were bonded to each surface. A total of five control and 10 thermocycled (5,040 cycles 0 degree C to 67 degrees C; dwell time, 1 minute) specimens were fabricated for each alloy and specimen type. Two bond strength tests were used; a three-point flexure test and a shear bond strength test. Data were analyzed using a multivariate analysis of variance (MANOVA) and a Tukey's multiple comparison test.

RESULTS

The standard deviations of the shear bond strength values ranged from +/- 2.30 to +/- 17.82.kg; thus, there was no significant difference in these results. Bond strength ratios were calculated from the flexure strength data. After thermocycling, the Silicoater MD produced significantly higher (P < 0.05) bond strength ratio values compared with the Silicoater Classic for Deva-4 (MD, 9.6 +/- 1.5 v Classic, 4.7 +/- 0.9) and G-Cast (MD, 11.6 +/- 1.2 v Classic, 3.9 +/- 0.5) but lower values for Ticonium (MD, 4.5 +/- 0.4 v Classic, 6.9 +/- 0.9).

CONCLUSION

The Silicoater MD produced higher bond strength ratio values with noble alloys, and the Silicoater Classic produced higher bond strength ratio results when base metal alloys were used, suggesting a possible correlation between the effectiveness of the coating processes and the compositions of the alloys. These findings suggest that, for optimum results, selection of the type of silicoating process should be based on the components of the alloy.

Effect of heat-curing cycle and gypsum contamination on the bond strengths of composite bonded to a silane-treated alloy

Silane-coated alloy specimens bonded to composite resin were tested for shear bond strengths and compared with an identical specimen group exposed to gypsum invested heat-processing conditions. The results indicate that the bond of composite resin to silane-coated alloy is not impaired by investing, boil-out, cleaning, packing, and curing during the process of securing artificial teeth to a partial denture framework. In a second part of this study, the alloy specimens were silane-coated and exposed to the gypsum invested heat-processing procedure before the composite resin was bonded to them. In addition, the specimens were exposed to one of three different cleaning agents (ethyl acetate, ethyl alcohol, and soap and water). Results in the second part of the study indicate that ethyl acetate is an effective cleaning agent to use when a silane-coated alloy surface previously exposed to gypsum processing is to be bonded to composite resin.