Comparison of the retentive properties of two hollow-tube post systems to those of a solid post design

3D FEA of Hollow and Solid Design Zirconia Dental Dowels

PURPOSE

The aim of this study was to evaluate the stress distribution of hollow and solid design zirconia dowels.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Finite element analysis (FEA) was used to investigate the influence of different dowel designs on the stress distribution of zirconia dowels. The coronal diameter of the dowel was 2.2 mm, the apical diameter was 1.8 mm, and the length was 15 mm. The diameter of the hollow space was 1.2 mm. Occlusal forces (both parallel and oblique) of 100 N were applied from the wider edge of the dowels simulating loads acting on the incisor during clenching and incising. The results were expressed in terms of von Mises criteria.

RESULTS

FEA revealed differences in stress distribution. During parallel load, the maximum tensile stress of the hollow design (89.40 MPa) was greater than the solid design (43.30 MPa). During oblique load, the maximum tensile stress of the hollow design (1437.90 MPa) was greater than the solid design (917.96 MPa). The maximum deformation was observed in the coronal part of the dowel in both designs under the two load directions.

CONCLUSIONS

FEA results showed that the hollow design zirconia dowels presented higher tensile stress.

In vitro comparison of fracture strength of experimental hollow and solid design zirconia dowels

PURPOSE

The aim of this study was to evaluate the fracture strength of experimental hollow and solid design zirconia dowels.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Three types of dowels (fiber-reinforced composite [FRC], hollow design, and solid design zirconia dowels) were tested in the study (n = 10). A three-point bending method was conducted, and a load was applied until fracture. The values were recorded as Newtons (N) and then converted to megapascals (MPa) according to the diameter of the dowels. Statistical analyses were performed using one-way ANOVA and Tukey HSD tests. The significance was set at p < 0.05.

RESULTS

The mean fracture strength of the hollow design zirconia dowels was significantly higher (960.72 MPa) than solid zirconia dowels (741.78 MPa) and FRC dowels (687.64 MPa) (p < 0.05).

CONCLUSIONS

The hollow design zirconia dowel seems to have sufficient fracture strength for anterior restorations. This design may be beneficial to access the apical region when retreatment is necessary, without any dowel-removing procedure.

Torsional resistance of crowns cemented to composite cores involving three stainless steel endodontic post designs

STATEMENT OF PROBLEM

There are no studies analyzing the effects of a crown in relationship to torsional resistance for a titanium-reinforced core material supported by a post.

PURPOSE

This study investigated the effects of post design on the torsional resistance of a crown supported by a titanium-reinforced composite core material (Ti-Core) and 3 endodontic posts (AccessPost, Flexi-Post, and ParaPost).

MATERIAL AND METHOD

Three groups of 10 specimens per group were studied. A total of 30 recently extracted human single-rooted (incisors) teeth with their crowns removed were used. Post holes preparations were created according to manufacturer's instructions. All posts were cemented using Flexi-Flow with titanium cement. Scotchbond Multi-Purpose bonding system was used as the bonding system for all groups. All cores were fabricated with Ti-Core with titanium core material with hard copper bands as the matrix. The Ti-Core core material was allowed to set for 1 hour. Metal crowns were fabricated and cemented with zinc phosphate cement. Specimens were placed in a special jig and a clockwise torsional force was applied. Torsional force was measured on a Lebow 1102-200 torque transducer and recorded on a Hewlett Packard 7015B X-Y recorder in inch x ounce. A 1-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) was used to test for statistical significance (P < .001).

RESULTS

The torsional values (inch x ounce) were AccessPost 77.2 +/- 30.3, Flexi-Post 162.2 +/- 51.2, and ParaPost 60.9 +/- 28.4. SNK and Scheffé comparison tests revealed that the Flexi-Post group had significantly greater resistance to torque loading than the AccessPost and ParaPost groups, which were statistically similar to each other.

CONCLUSION

Post design has an effect on torsional resistance of a crown supported by titanium-reinforced core build-up and post. The threaded split-shank design of the Flexi-Post dowel offers significantly greater resistance to torsional loading than the passive posts studied.

Effects of three bonding systems on the torsional resistance of titanium-reinforced composite cores supported by two post designs

STATEMENT OF PROBLEM

There are no studies that have investigated the effects of bonding agents on the resistance to torque of a composite core supported by a prefabricated post.

PURPOSE

This study investigated the ability of bonding agents to resist rational forces applied to titanium-reinforced composite cores supported by 2 post designs.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Two post designs (AccessPost and ParaPost dowels) with titanium-reinforced core material and 4 bonding conditions (AllBond-2, ScotchBond Multi-Purpose, Tenure A&B, and without a bonding agent) were studied. A total of 80 specimens in 8 experimental groups were prepared and subjected to clockwise torsional forces until failure.

RESULTS

Torsional values ranged from 53.31 in. x oz (ParaPost/ScotchBond Multi-Purpose) to 72.31 in. x oz (AccessPost/ScotchBond Multi-Purpose). Two-way of analysis of variance failed to demonstrate a significant difference among posts or type of bonding system.

CONCLUSION

The use of a multistep bonding agent had no significant effect on the torsional resistance of a core supported by a passive endodontic post.

Retention of three endodontic posts cemented with five dental cements

STATEMENT OF PROBLEM

The retention of a post is believed to be a major factor in restoration survival. Therefore the cement with the greatest in vitro retention property should give the best performance for a restoration.

PURPOSE

This study compared retentive values of three posts (Flexi-Post, AccessPost, and ParaPost) cemented with five cements (Flexi-Flow, zinc phosphate, Advance, Duet, and Ketac-Cem) plus a control group that consisted of a Flexi-Post No. 2 dowel without cement.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

A total of 160 recently extracted human single-rooted teeth with crowns removed at the cementoenamel junction were divided into 16 groups of 10 samples. Post holes were prepared according to manufacturers' instructions. Posts were then cemented with one of the five cements. Each sample was placed into a specialized jig and on a tensile testing machine with crosshead speed of 0.638 cm/minute, applied until failure. A two-way analysis of variance and Newman-Keuls multiple range comparison tests were performed for all cemented groups. A one-way analysis of variance and a Student-Newman-Keuls multiple range comparison test were performed only for the groups with the Flexi-Post dowel, this included the no cement condition, with significant results if p < 0.05.

RESULTS

Flexi-Post dowel with Flexi-Flow Natural cement obtained the highest retentive value (303.91 pounds). ParaPost dowel with Duet cement exhibited the lowest retention value (21.23 pounds). The Flexi-Post dowel demonstrated higher mean retention than AccessPost or ParaPost dowels, AccessPost dowel was higher than ParaPost dowel. Flexi-Flow cement had the highest overall mean retention followed, in decreasing order, by zinc phosphate, Advance, Ketac-Cem, and Duet cements.

CONCLUSIONS

Flexi-Post dowel was the most retentive post studied with values ranging from 303.91 pounds with Flexi-Flow Natural cements to 150.93 pounds without cement. Flexi-Flow cements had a higher overall mean retention than other cements studied.

Rigidity and retention of carbon fibre versus stainless steel root canal posts

Two of the main requirements of a root canal post are that it is rigid so as to resist flexing under functional load, and that it is well retained in the root. This study compared these properties in two different 1-mm diameter root canal posts--smooth carbon fibre posts (Endopost) and serrated stainless steel posts (Parapost). Ten posts of each type were tested for rigidity in a three-point bend test. Ten posts of each type were cemented with resin cement into the roots of endodontically treated, extracted teeth. The tensile force required to remove the posts was recorded. The Paraposts proved to be significantly more rigid under load (P < 0.001) and significantly more strongly retained in the tooth roots (P < 0.005). The Parapost appears to be a mechanically superior post for the restoration of root-filled teeth with narrow diameter root canals.

Comparison of the torsional forces at failure for seven endodontic post systems

Resistance to torsional forces is critical in restoration of endodontically treated teeth. Seven post designs (Flexi-Post, Flexi-Flange, Para-Post, AccessPost, World Post, Vlock, and Dentatus posts) were cemented in roots of natural teeth with zinc phosphate and Flexi-Flow cements, which resulted in 11 different groupings that were subjected to torsional forces in a clockwise direction. In addition, clockwise and counterclockwise torque was applied to the Flexi-Post and Flexi-Flange systems cemented with zinc phosphate and Flexi-Flow cements. A total of 150 samples were prepared, and groups for this study were: group 1, Flexi-Post/zinc phosphate clockwise and counterclockwise; group 2, Flexi-Post/Flexi-Flow clockwise and counterclockwise; group 3, Flexi-Flange/zinc phosphate clockwise and counterclockwise; group 4, Flexi-Flange/Flexi-Flow clockwise and counterclockwise; group 5, Para-Post/zinc phosphate clockwise; group 6, AccessPost/zinc phosphate clockwise; group 7, AccessPost/Flexi-Flow with grooved dentin clockwise; group 8, World Post/zinc phosphate clockwise; group 9, World Post/Flexi-Flow with grooved dentin clockwise; group 10, Vlock Post/zinc phosphate clockwise; and group 11, Dentatus post/zinc phosphate clockwise. Torsional forces for the groups ranged from 17 ounce-inches (Dentatus/zinc phosphate) to 81 ounce-inches (Flexi-Post/zinc phosphate). Flexi-Post and Flexi-Flange threaded posts exhibited statistically greater resistance to torsional forces. Analyses were computed with one-way and three-way analysis of variance followed by Duncan's multiple range test. Duncan's multiple range test indicated that Flexi-Post/zinc phosphate/clockwise was similar to Flexi-Post/Flexi-Flow/clockwise and that both had significantly higher torque levels than the other treatment conditions in the clockwise direction (p 0.0001). Dentatus/zinc phosphate/clockwise had significantly lower torque levels than the other treatment conditions (p 0.031).