Predictions of the somatic mutation and mortalization theories of cellular ageing are contrary to experimental observations

Modelling the molecular mechanisms of aging

The aging process is driven at the cellular level by random molecular damage that slowly accumulates with age. Although cells possess mechanisms to repair or remove damage, they are not 100% efficient and their efficiency declines with age. There are many molecular mechanisms involved and exogenous factors such as stress also contribute to the aging process. The complexity of the aging process has stimulated the use of computational modelling in order to increase our understanding of the system, test hypotheses and make testable predictions. As many different mechanisms are involved, a wide range of models have been developed. This paper gives an overview of the types of models that have been developed, the range of tools used, modelling standards and discusses many specific examples of models that have been grouped according to the main mechanisms that they address. We conclude by discussing the opportunities and challenges for future modelling in this field.

The szilard hypothesis on the nature of aging revisited

This year marks the 50th anniversary of a nearly forgotten hypothesis on aging by Leo Szilard, best known for his pioneering work in nuclear physics, his participation in the Manhattan Project during World War II, his opposition to the nuclear arms race in the postwar era, and his pioneering ideas in biology. Given a specific set of assumptions, Szilard hypothesized that the major reason for the phenomenon of aging was aging hits, e.g., by ionizing radiation, to the gene-bearing chromosomes and presented a mathematical target-hit model enabling the calculation of the average and maximum life span of a species, as well as the influence of increased exposure to DNA-damaging factors on life expectancy. While many new findings have cast doubt on the specific features of the model, this was the first serious effort to posit accumulated genetic damage as a cause of senescence. Here, we review Szilard's assumptions in the light of current knowledge on aging and reassess his mathematical model in an attempt to reach a conclusion on the relevance of Szilard's aging hypothesis today.

Sparse plating increases the heterogeneity of proliferative potential of fibroblasts

High heterogeneity of proliferative potential in the cultures of diploid human fibroblasts was reported in many studies. It was generally believed that the heterogeneity of proliferative potential of human fibroblasts reflects the unevenness of their senescence. However we show here that immortalized (telomerized) human fibroblasts obey the same rule. Up to 50% of these cells rapidly ceased to proliferate when plated at low density in contrast to usual conditions of mass culture where at least 98% of these cells keep on proliferating. Initially, we proposed that the appearance of non-dividing or slow-dividing cells in low-density cell culture experiments could be caused by cell damage due to the experimental setup. Indeed, lowering of oxygen level and addition of conditioned medium improved colony formation, but there were a large number of non-proliferating cells (13-20%). When we sparsely plated cells on a feeder layer of cells of certain density, the portion of non-proliferating cells decreased to 2%, i.e. became the same as in mass culture. Thus, the heterogeneity of proliferative potential is partially a result of the adverse effect of low cell density.

Somatic mutations and ageing in silico

Considerable evidence points to an accumulation of somatic mutations in older cells and organisms but the causal role of mutations in the ageing process is still unclear. In addition to demonstrating that mutations accumulate, it is important to address the question of whether they do so at a sufficient rate and with a dynamic profile that is consistent with them playing a causative role. We describe the development of in silico models that can be used to explore the role of somatic mutations in ageing and which form a part of a growing effort to build predictive mathematical and computer models that can help unravel the complexity of the functional genomics of ageing. Our models address, in particular, how mutations affect populations of dividing cells like human fibroblasts, in which the challenge to the somatic mutation theory is greatest, since selection at the cellular level will tend to suppress the accumulation of mutations.

Twenty years of ageing research at the Mill Hill laboratories

Research on ageing was carried out in the Genetics Division laboratories, Mill Hill, London, from 1970 to 1990, resulting in more than 100 publications. The work centred around the in vitro ageing of human diploid fibroblasts, but there was also research on transformed cells, rat and mouse tissues, human lymphocytes, chick cells, mice and a microbial model system. The major conclusion from all this research, together with a broad overview of the whole field of gerontology, is that ageing has multiple causes, and that adult animals become senescent through the eventual failure of several important maintenance mechanisms.

A stochastic model of cell replicative senescence based on telomere shortening, oxidative stress, and somatic mutations in nuclear and mitochondrial DNA

Human diploid fibroblast cells can divide for only a limited number of times in vitro, a phenomenon known as replicative senescence or the Hayflick limit. Variability in doubling potential is observed within a clone of cells, and between two sister cells arising from a single mitotic division. This strongly suggests that the process by which cells become senescent is intrinsically stochastic. Among the various biochemical mechanisms that have been proposed to explain replicative senescence, particular interest has been focussed on the role of telomere reduction. In the absence of telomerase--an enzyme switched off in normal diploid fibro-blasts-cells lose telomeric DNA at each cell division. According to the telomere hypothesis of cell senescence, cells eventually reach a critically short telomere length and cell cycle arrest follows. In support of this concept, forced expression of telomerase in normal fibroblasts appears to prevent cell senescence. Nevertheless, the telomere hypothesis in its basic form has some difficulty in explaining the marked stochastic variations seen in the replicative lifespans of individual cells within a culture, and there is strong empirical and theoretical support for the concept that other kinds of damage may contribute to cellular ageing. We describe a stochastic network model of cell senescence in which a primary role is played by telomere reduction but in which other mechanisms (oxidative stress linked particularly to mitochondrial damage, and nuclear somatic mutations) also contribute. The model gives simulation results that are in good agreement with published data on intra-clonal variability in cell doubling potential and permits an analysis of how the various elements of the stochastic network interact. Such integrative models may aid in developing new experimental approaches aimed at unravelling the intrinsic complexity of the mechanisms contributing to human cell ageing.

Ageing: definitions, mechanisms and the magnitude of the problem

All multi-cellular organisms undergo change with time. Conception heralds the onset of growth and development, leading to reproductive competence and propagation of the species. With time, organisms age, leading to death as a final end-point. Whilst our knowledge and definitions of growth and reproduction are firmly established, the concept of ageing remains less well understood. One of the reasons for the lack of a singular definition of ageing is that it can be considered in many different ways, according to social, behavioural, physiological, morphological, cellular and molecular changes. Research has led to a number of theories being proposed that may explain the ageing process. In this chapter, we will review some of these theories and address some of the following fundamental questions: What is ageing? How can ageing be measured? When does ageing begin? When is an organism defined as old?

21st Century: Review: Ageing and medicine

Throughout the world, populations are ageing. The response of the health services needs to be based on a knowledge of the nature of human ageing and the principles of rational health care for older people. Ageing comes about from interactions between intrinsic (genetic) and extrinsic (environment and lifestyle) factors. Health care has to be responsive to the general needs of older people, but also to recognize the heterogeneity produced by different rates and patterns of individual ageing. There are now real possibilities of improving the course of human ageing through modulation of both intrinsic and extrinsic processes. There is also a need to adapt social institutions to what is a permanent change in demography.

Network theory of aging

Evolution theory indicates that investment in mechanisms of somatic maintenance and repair is likely to be limited, suggesting that aging may result from the accumulation of unrepaired somatic defects. An important corollary of this hypothesis is that multiple mechanisms of aging operate in parallel. We describe a recently developed "network theory of aging" that integrates the contributions of defective mitochondria, aberrant proteins, and free radicals in the aging process and that includes the protective effects of antioxidant enzymes and proteolytic scavengers. Possibilities for further extension of the theory and its role in prediction and simulation of experimental results are discussed.

Age-related changes in expression and activity of DNA polymerase alpha: some effects of dietary restriction

DNA polymerase alpha (pol alpha) purified from human diploid fibroblasts (HDF) and from livers of C57BL/6N mice showed age-related decreases in: (1) mRNA levels; (2) the amount of enzyme isolated per cell; and (3) enzyme activity (HDF); as well as: a) the amount of enzyme isolated; b) the specific activity; and c) the enzyme fidelity (liver). Hepatic pol alpha from dietary restricted (DR) mice exhibited less of a decline in specific activity and copied synthetic DNA templates with relatively higher fidelity than did enzymes from animals fed ad libitum (AL). Pol alpha from fetal-derived HDF exhibited increased expression compared with aged donor-derived HDF, with both fetal and old cell pol alpha in normal cells being expressed at lower levels than in their transformed cell corollaries. Treatment of human pol alpha from aged donor-derived HDF with a pol alpha accessory protein isolated from log phase murine cells resulted in increased pol alpha binding of DNA and increased pol alpha activity. However, highly active pol alpha isolated from fetal-derived or transformed HDF, or from transformed murine cells, showed little or no activity enhancement in the presence of accessory protein. These data indicate that, as a function of increased age, there is a decrease in pol alpha expression and specific activity in HDF, as well as decreases in specific activity and fidelity of pol alpha in essentially amitotic murine hepatic tissues. Dietary restriction impedes the age-related declines in both activity and fidelity of hepatic pol alpha in mice. The data further indicate that transformation of slowly dividing HDF is associated with increased expression of pol alpha, but suggest that increased expression alone is not sufficient to explain the difference in polymerase activity levels between parental and transformed HDF. Lastly, the data suggest that interaction of pol alpha with an essential accessory protein may be altered as a function of age, an alteration that appears to be correlated with the decline in pol alpha DNA binding and specific activity.

Effects of aging and dietary restriction on DNA polymerases: gene expression, enzyme fidelity, and DNA excision repair

Hepatic DNA polymerases isolated from young and old C57BL/6N mice fed ad libitum or calorically restricted differed in chromatographic characteristics, binding affinity for DNA template-primer, specific activity, and fidelity of synthesis. DNA polymerase alpha total and specific activity declined slightly, while the nucleotide misincorporation frequency increased dramatically, with increased age of the donor animals. A positive correlation was observed between polymerase alpha specific activity and the affinity of enzyme binding to activated DNA template-primer. Both the age-associated decline in enzyme activity and the decrease in fidelity of synthesis were modified by dietary restriction, with higher specific activity levels and lower misincorporation frequencies for DNA polymerases from dietarily restricted animals compared with ad libitum animals of all ages. Fidelity of both DNA polymerase alpha and beta increased following treatment with the phosphoinositide hydrolysis product inositol-1,4-bisphosphate. The data suggest that dietary restriction could play an important role in decreasing the age-associated decline in function of physiological systems sensitive to decreased or defective DNA synthesis.

DNA methylation and cellular ageing

Methylated cytosine (m5C) in DNA appears to be an important modulator of the expression of some genes. There are several lines of evidence that gradual loss of m5C is relevant to in vitro cellular ageing: m5C loss occurs during cell culture; m5C loss is detectable at an early stage of culture; m5C loss appears to be related to cell division not just duration in culture; the rate of m5C loss appears to be related to in vitro lifespan of the cell strain in question; and the total loss of m5C during an in vitro lifespan is significant by comparison with induced-changes in m5C levels which effect cell growth, or cause cell-death in culture. Progressive loss of m5C in dividing cells may thus produce the multi-step cell division "clock" which underlies the Hayflick phenomenon.

A re-examination of the effects of ionizing radiation on lifespan and transformation of human diploid fibroblasts

Human diploid fibroblasts, strain MRC-5, were sequentially irradiated with 60Co gamma rays at intervals during their in vitro lifespan. The results indicate that 3 or 6 doses of 1 Gy can increase lifespan, and the same was true for cells treated with 3 doses of 3 Gy. Higher doses (5 x 3 Gy) did reduce growth potential, suggesting either that mid-late passage cells become more sensitive to radiation, or that doses beyond a given threshold reduce population lifespan by multiple cellular hits. The life extension induced by gamma rays might be due to an induced hypermethylation of DNA. Alternatively, oxygen radicals produced by irradiation might trigger an adaptive stress response which would remove damaged macromolecules and thereby increase the cells' growth potential. Whichever explanation is correct, the results show that the human fibroblast system is not appropriate for the study of the well known effect of ionizing radiation in shortening the lifespan of experimental animals. Contrary to earlier published results, populations of cells treated with cumulative doses of 15 Gy or 18 Gy and held for nearly 3 months after they had reached senescence (Phase III), produced no foci of transformed cells.

Effect of dietary restriction on the fidelity of DNA polymerases in aging mice

DNA polymerases purified from hepatic tissues of C57BL/6 mice showed an age-related decrease in both specific activity and fidelity of the various enzyme forms. Polymerases from dietary restricted mice exhibited less of a decline in specific activity and copied synthetic DNA templates with relatively higher fidelity than did enzymes from animals fed ad libitum. Polymerases treated with inositol-1,4-bisphosphate [I(1,4)P2] showed varying levels of increased activity, with fidelity increases up to 3-fold. These data indicate that aging is associated with decreases in both specific activity and fidelity of DNA polymerases isolated from a nondividing tissue, and that dietary restriction impedes the age-related decline in both specific activity and fidelity of these polymerases. The data further indicate that DNA polymerases may interact with phosphoinositide hydrolysis products resulting in increased specific activity and fidelity of the enzymes. Phosphoinositide interactions with polymerases could constitute an important mechanism moderating the age-related decrease in function and accuracy of DNA polymerases.

Are transposons a cause of ageing?

A hypothesis for ageing is proposed based on the properties of transposons. During the process of transposition, one copy of the DNA sequence generally remains at the same position while the other copy moves to another location in the genome. In this manner the DNA sequence of the transposon is effectively duplicated. With time the number of transposons increases exponentially and since in their new location they can inactivate an essential gene, they will eventually kill a cell line or organism. Thus transposons could be a cause of ageing. This hypothesis is attractive because it can explain many of the properties of senescent cells. Other processes capable of DNA self-duplication (e.g., reverse transcription) could also contribute to the increase in transposable DNA sequences.

Age-related changes in DNA polymerase alpha expression

DNA polymerase alpha isozymes differing in specific activity and affinity of binding to DNA were purified from human fibroblasts derived from donors of different ages. Fetal-derived fibroblasts expressed a single, high-activity enzyme (A2), with high affinity of binding to DNA. Adult-derived fibroblasts exhibited two forms of DNA polymerase alpha, one identical to the fetal enzyme, and a second with about tenfold less activity showing low affinity of binding to DNA (A1). The ratio of DNA polymerase A2/A1 decreased dramatically with age, from 100% A2 in fetal-derived fibroblasts to about 94% A1 in fibroblasts derived from a 66-year-old donor. The DNA binding affinity of polymerase alpha A1 from adult-derived fibroblasts increased concomitant with a significant increase in activity when the enzyme was treated with phosphatidylinositol-4-monophosphate (PIP), or with inositol-1, 4-bisphosphate (I(1,4)P2). The enzyme reverted back to a less active form, with loss of the noncovalently bound I(1,4)P2, as a function of time. When permeabilized human fibroblasts with low DNA excision repair capacity were treated with 7,8-dihydrodiol-9,10-epoxybenzo(a)-pyrene (BPDE) in the presence of 32P-ATP, phosphatidylinositol, and cycloheximide, excision repair was initiated and 32P-labeled DNA polymerase alpha was recovered in the absence of de novo protein synthesis. DNA synthesis associated with either scheduled DNA synthesis or BPDE-initiated excision repair declined as a function of increased age in human cells. The data suggest that the decline in both DNA excision repair-associated and mitogen-activated DNA synthesis may be correlated with decreased total intracellular levels of DNA polymerase and with the decline in polymerase alpha activity as a function of age, that DNA repair-associated initiation of DNA synthesis in adult-derived cells may increase with activation of a pool of low activity DNA polymerase alpha, and that DNA polymerase alpha activity increases as a function of enzyme interaction with a component of the PI phosphorylation cascade.

DNA, mutations and aging

Genetic instability is widely thought to be involved in the process of aging. Evolutionary theory suggests that aging may well result from stochastic damage to DNA. However, studies of the dynamics of accumulation of simple somatic mutations have shown that such a mechanism cannot readily account for experimental observations. A more complex mutational theory of aging is emerging which allows for interaction between mutations, for damage to epigenetic controls on gene expression, and for interaction of (epi)genetic changes with other possible molecular events contributing to aging.

The inheritance of epigenetic defects

Evidence from many sources shows that the control of gene expression in higher organisms is related to the methylation of cytosine in DNA, and that the pattern of methylation is inherited. Loss of methylation, which can result from DNA damage, will lead to heritable abnormalities in gene expression, and these may be important in oncogenesis and aging. Transformed permanent lines often lose gene activity through de novo methylation. It is proposed that epigenetic defects in germline cells due to loss of methylation can be repaired by recombination at meiosis but that some are transmitted to offspring.

Strong effects of 5-azacytidine on the in vitro lifespan of human diploid fibroblasts

Azacytidine (5-aza-CR) and azadeoxycytidine (5-aza-CdR) are known to inhibit the methylation of cytosine (5-mC) in DNA, and their effects on the long-term growth of human fibroblasts, strain MRC-5, have been examined. A single treatment with either analogue initially inhibits growth, but the cells recover to normal morphology, growth rate and cell density at confluence. However, a memory of the treatment is retained, since the cells' subsequent lifespan is considerably reduced in comparison with controls, and the terminal stages of growth are indistinguishable from senescent cultures of untreated cells. The effect of 5-aza-CR or 5-aza-CdR does not appear to be closely related to the concentration used, or to the length of treatment up to about half-way through the total lifespan. Sequential doses have cumulative effects on longevity. There is evidence that the pattern of 5-mC in mammalian DNA is inherited via cell division; therefore, a reduction in 5-mC induced by a pulse treatment of 5-aza-CR or 5-aza-CdR will be transmitted to all descendants. The results are consistent with independent observations that the level of 5-mC declines continually during the serial subculture of human diploid cells. The analogues would be expected to precipitate this decline and thereby advance the physiological age of the culture. The results provide support for the view that the random loss of methyl groups in DNA may eventually have deleterious consequences, such as aberrant epigenetic changes in gene expression.

Age-dependent changes in proteins of Drosophila melanogaster

Several molecular theories of aging postulate that there are age-dependent changes in gene expression and that these changes contribute to the reduction in the viability of senescent cells. High-resolution, semiautomated, quantitative two-dimensional gel electrophoresis of many soluble proteins was used to test this hypothesis in Drosophila. Two-dimensional protein gel patterns were analyzed for each of three age groups of [(35)S]methionine-labeled adult male Drosophila melanogaster, which, except for their spermatocytes, consist entirely of fixed postmitotic cells. Seven relatively abundant polypeptides expressed in middle-aged (28-day-old) flies were absent in both young(10-day-old) and old (44-day-old) flies. Quantitative analyses of an additional 100 polypeptides were carried out by computer-assisted microdensitometry of fluorograms of the gel preparations. These analyses revealed a significant age-related heterogeneity in the quantitative distribution of radiolabel in these proteins. The data indicate that the qualitative pattern of gene expression is identical in young and old flies, but that profound quantitative changes occur in the expression of proteins during the Drosophila life-span.

A quantitative analysis of the aging of human glial cells in culture

The kinetics of aging of normal human diploid brain cells in culture have been determined using the miniclone technique in which cells are cloned in the presence of a large number of other cells. The miniclone technique records the behaviour of every viable cell in the sample, not merely those cells capable of forming visible clones. This technique permits the direct measurement of the reproductive potential of individual cells growing in bulk culture and of the dispersion of the sizes of colonies generated by dividing cells. The fraction of cells that are able to divide declines smoothly and continuously from the beginning of in vitro cultures of human glial cells. There is a broad distribution of colony sizes; even at the earliest passages there are significant numbers of small colonies. With increasing age of the culture there is a shift in the distribution, so that fewer large colonies and more small colonies occur. The distribution of intermitotic times is almost identical in young and middle-aged cultures. Our data seem to exclude quite positively any description in terms of a catastrophe or any abrupt change in the population. On the contrary, the decline in reproductive potential may be described adequately either as a linear change with time, or as predicted by the mortality theory of Shall and Stein (1979), in which the single constant, gamma, describes the change in reproductive potential over the entire lifetime.

Cytogerontology since 1881: a reappraisal of August Weismann and a review of modern progress

Cytogerontology, the science of cellular ageing, originated in 1881 with the prediction by August Weismann that the somatic cells of higher animals have limited division potential. Weismann's prediction was derived by considering the role of natural selection in regulating the duration of an organism's life. For various reasons, Weismann's ideas on ageing fell into neglect following his death in 1914, and cytogerontology has only reappeared as a major research area following the demonstration by Hayflick and Moorhead in the early 1960s that diploid human fibroblasts are restricted to a finite number of divisions in vitro. In this review we give a detailed account of Weismann's theory, and we reveal that his ideas were both more extensive in their scope and more pertinent to current research than is generally recognised. We also appraise the progress which has been made over the past hundred years in investigating the causes of ageing, with particular emphasis being given to (i) the evolution of ageing, and (ii) ageing at the cellular level. We critically assess the current state of knowledge in these areas and recommend a series of points as primary targets for future research.