The role of oxygen in determining initial radiosensitivity and post-radiation recovery in the successive stages of Drosophila spermatogenesis

DNA damage and repair in somatic and germ cells in vivo

Alkylation-induced germ cell mutagenesis in the mouse versus Drosophila is compared based on data from forward mutation assays (specific-locus tests in the mouse and in Drosophila and multiple-locus assays in the latter species) but not including assays for structural chromosome aberrations. To facilitate comparisons between mouse and Drosophila, forward mutation test results have been grouped into three categories. Representatives of the first category are MMS (methyl methanesulfonate) and EO (ethylene oxide), alkylating agents with a high s value which predominantly react with ring nitrogens in DNA. ENU (N-ethyl-N-nitrosourea), MNU (N-methyl-N-nitrosourea), PRC (procarbazine), DEN (N-nitrosodiethylamine), and DMN (N-nitrosodimethylamine) belong to the second category. These agents have in common a considerable ability for modification at oxygens in DNA. Cross-linking agents (melphalan, chlorambucil, hexamethylphosphoramide) form the third category. The most unexpected, but encouraging outcome of this study is the identification of common features for three vastly different experimental indicators of genotoxicity: hereditary damage in Drosophila males, genetic damage in male mice, and tumors (TD50 estimates) in rodents. Based on the above three category classification scheme the following tentative conclusions are drawn. Monofunctional agents belonging to category 1, typified by MMS and EO, display genotoxic effects in male germ cell stages that have passed meiotic division. This phenomenon seems to be the consequence of a repair deficiency during spermiogenesis for a period of 3-4 days in Drosophila and 14 days in the mouse. We suggest that the reason for the high resistance of premeiotic stages, and the generally high TD50 estimates observed for this class in rodents, is the efficient error-free repair of N-alkylation damage. If we accept this hypothesis, then the increased carcinogenic potential in rodents, seen when comparing category 2 (ENU-type mutagens) to category 1 (MMS-type mutagens), along with the ability of category 2 genotoxins to induce genetic damage in premeiotic stages, must presumably be due to their enhanced ability for alkylations at oxygens in DNA; it is this property that actually distinguishes the two groups from each other. In contrast to category 1, examination of class 2 genotoxins (ENU and DEN) in premeiotic cells of Drosophila gave no indication for a significant role of germinal selection, and also removal by DNA repair was less dramatic compared to MMS. Thus category 2 mutagens are expected to display activity in a wide range of both post- and premeiotic germ cell stages. A number of these agents have been demonstrated to be among the most potent carcinogens in rodents.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

Studies on mutagen-sensitive strains of Drosophila melanogaster, VIII. Further data on differences between Canton-S and ebony strains with respect to maternal effects for the X-ray induction of autosomal translocations and ring-X chromosome losses in mature spermatozoa

The influence of the maternal genotype (Canton-S, proficient in the repair of X-ray-induced chromosome breaks and ebony, less proficient in this regard) on the recovery of X-ray-induced autosomal (II-III) translocations and ring-X chromosome losses in mature spermatozoa was studied. In the first series of experiments, males carrying appropriate markers on their second and third chromosomes were irradiated and mated to Canton-S or ebony females and the frequencies of II-III translocations were determined. In the second series of experiments, males carrying ring-X chromosomes were irradiated in N2 or in O2, mated to Canton-S or ebony females and the frequencies of XO males were determined; additionally, under similar gas-treatment and radiation conditions, the pattern of egg-mortality was also assessed. The data on translocations show that the yields are higher with ebony than with Canton-S females; these and earlier results on dominant lethals and sex-linked recessive lethals support the interpretation that the maternal repair system in the ebony strain is less proficient and more error-prone than that of the Canton-S strain. Those on the losses of ring-X chromosomes demonstrate that (i) the absolute yields of XO males are lower with ebony than with Canton-S females irrespective of whether the parental males are irradiated in N2 or in O2; (ii) the exposure-frequency relationships are all linear, but the slopes are higher when the males are irradiated in O2 and are consistent with an oxygen-enhancement-ratio of about 1.5 and (iii) the relationships between the logarithm of egg-survival and XO male frequency are also linear, but the slopes for the O2 groups are lower than those for the N2 groups (slope ratios of 0.86-0.87). The finding that at given survival levels, the XO frequencies are lower in the O2 than in the N2 groups of both the Canton-S and ebony series viewed in the context of the mechanisms that have been postulated to explain the loss of ring-X chromosomes in irradiated mature spermatozoa permits the following interpretation for the observed results: (i) a higher proportion of potential XO zygotes is lost through dominant lethality in the O2 groups than in the N2 ones presumably because the chromosome breaks induced in O2 are qualitatively different in the sense that they have a higher probability to undergo reunions relative to restitution, compared with breaks induced under anoxia and (ii) this leads to lower than expected oxygen-enhancement ratios (i.e., expected on the basis of published data on sex-linked recessive lethals, another kind of genetic damage which shows a linear exposure-frequency relationship.

Studies on mutagen-sensitive strains of Drosophila melanogaster. IV. Modification of genetic damage induced by X-irradiation of spermatozoa and spermatids in N2 or O2 by mei-9a, mei-41D5 and mus(1)101D1

The influence of defects in DNA repair processes on X-ray-induced genetic damage in post-meiotic male germ cell stages of Drosophila melanogaster was studied using the 'maternal effects approach'. Basc males were irradiated in N2, air or O2 either as 48-h-old pupae (to sample spermatids) or as 3-4-day-old adults (to sample mature spermatozoa) and mated to females of 3 repair-deficient strains (mei-9a: excision-repair-deficient; mei-41D5: post-replication-repair-deficient; mus(1)101D1: post-replication-repair-deficient and impaired in DNA synthesis). Simultaneous controls involving mating of males to repair-proficient females (mei+) were run. The frequencies of sex-linked recessive lethals and of autosomal translocations were determined following standard genetic procedures. The responses elicited in the different crosses with repair-deficient females were compared with those in mei+ crosses. The main findings are the following: with mei-9 females, the frequencies of recessive lethals are higher after irradiation of spermatids in N2, but not after irradiation in air of O2 (relative to those in the mei+ crosses); this result is different from that obtained in earlier work with spermatozoa, in which cell stage, higher yields of recessive lethals were obtained after irradiation of males in either N2 or air; in the mei-9 crosses, there are no significant differences in response (relative to mei+) after irradiation of either spermatozoa or spermatids in O2; the translocation frequencies in the mei-9 crosses are similar to those in the mei+ crosses, irrespective of the treated germ cell stage or the irradiation atmosphere; irradiation of either spermatozoa or spermatids in N2, air or O2 does not result in any differential recovery of recessive lethals in the mei-41 relative to mei+ crosses; irradiation of spermatids in N2 and of spermatozoa in air leads to a higher recovery of translocations in the mei-41 crosses; and after irradiation of spermatids or spermatozoa in any of the gaseous atmospheres, the frequencies of recessive lethals and of translocations are lower in the mus-101 crosses. The differences in responses (between cell stages, in different gaseous atmospheres and with different repair-deficient females) are explained on the basis of both qualitative and quantitative differences in the composition of the initial lesions and the extent to which their repair may be affected by the defects present in the different repair-deficient females. Several discrepancies between expectations based on biochemical results and the genetic results are pointed out.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

Studies on mutagen-sensitive strains of Drosophila melanogaster. VII. Effects of repair deficiency in males on X-ray-induced sex-linked recessive lethals in spermatozoa

The response of mature spermatozoa to the X-ray induction (500 R and 3000 R) of sex-linked recessive lethals was studied in Drosophila melanogaster males known to be deficient in excision- or post-replication repair of UV damage in somatic cells. The results show that the induced frequencies of recessive lethals in the excision-repair-deficient males (mei-9a and mei-9L1) are similar to those in the appropriate repair-proficient males (mei+ and Berlin-K). However, in the post-replication-repair-deficient males (w mus(1)101D1), these frequencies are significantly lower than in the comparable repair-proficient males (w) after 500 R, but not after 3000 R.

Studies on mutagen-sensitive strains of Drosophila melanogaster. VI. The effect of DNA-repair deficiencies in spermatids, spermatocytes and spermatogonia irradiated in N2 or O2

This study was aimed at ascertaining the extent to which paternal repair processes possibly deficient in mei-9a, mei-41D5 and mus-101D1 genotypes would affect the recovery of radiation-induced recessive lethals in early spermatids, spermatocytes and spermatogonia. These germ cell stages were sampled in two 2-day broods from freshly hatched males, that were irradiated as 24-h old pupae in O2, or N2 followed by N2 or O2 post-treatment. Spontaneous mutation frequencies were higher in mei-9 and mei-41 males, and thus appropriate corrections were applied to the radiation data. Only with mei-9 males a clear and consistent increase of the radiation-induced mutation frequency was observed. The effect is somewhat more pronounced in brood B, presumably representing spermatogonia, than in brood A and is observed after radiation in either O2 or N2. The paternal repair process thus differs from the maternal one in that it also responds to radiation damage induced in O2. The finding that, following irradiation under anoxia, post-treatment with O2 (versus that with N2), also lowers the mutation frequency in mei-9 males, indicates that the repair defect in mei-9 does not interfere with oxygen-dependent post-radiation repair. Thus there are two different paternal repair processes in these early stages of spermatogenesis: that is, one controlled by mei-9 and one depending on oxygen. Mei-41 and mus-101 do not appear to interfere with the paternal repair process. The frequency of translocations recovered from these stages was likewise not affected by mus-101.

Studies on mutagen-sensitive strains of Drosophila melanogaster. II. Detection of qualitative differences between genetic damage induced by X-irradiation of mature spermatozoa in oxygenated and anoxic atmospheres through the use of the repair-deficient mutant mei-9a

Muller-5 males were irradiated with X-rays in nitrogen, in air or in oxygen (followed by nitrogen or oxygen post-treatments in the nitrogen and oxygen series) and were mated to females of a repair-proficient strain (mei+) or to those of a strain known to be deficient in excision repair of UV damage (in somatic cells). The latter strain, designated as mei-9a, is also known to be sensitive, in the larval stages, to the killing effects of UV, X-rays and to a number of chemical mutagens. The frequencies of sex-linked recessive lethals and autosomal translocations induced in the spermatozoa of males were determined and compared. The frequencies of sex-linked recessive lethals in the mei-9 control groups were consistently higher than in the mei+ groups. Irradiation in air or in nitrogen led to significantly higher yields of recessive lethals when the irradiated males were mated to mei-9 females, whereas, after irradiation in oxygen, the yields were similar with both kinds of female. No significant differences in the frequencies of reciprocal translocations were observed between the mei+ and mei-9 groups after irradiation of the males in nitrogen, in air or in oxygen. Likewise, no differential effects of the contrasting post-treatments (nitrogen versus oxygen), either for recessive lethals or for translocations, could be discerned. These results are considered to support the notion that the kinds of genetic damage induced in mature spermatozoa in air or in nitrogen are qualitatively similar (at least with respect to the component(s) that lead to the production of recessive lethal mutations), but clearly different when induced in an oxygen atmosphere. The enhanced yields of recessive lethals with mei-9 females (after irradiation of the males either in air or in nitrogen) has been interpreted on the assumption that the mei-9 mutant is also deficient for the repair of X-ray-induced, recessive lethal-generating premutational lesions. Possible reasons for the lack of differences between the mei+ and mei-9 groups with respect to translocation yields and for the absence of measurable differences in response between the contrasting post-treatments (after irradiation of the males in nitrogen) are discussed.