Problems and pitfalls in assessing human T-lymphocyte mutant frequencies

Role of glutathione S-transferase mu (GSTM1) in styrene-7,8-oxide toxicity and mutagenicity

In the human glutathione S-transferase (GST) mu gene family, homozygous deletion of GSTM1 is the null phenotype (frequency of approximately 50% in Caucasians). In the current study, GSTM1 status was determined in human cell lines using reverse transcriptase, polymerase chain reaction, and immunochemistry. Cell lines were challenged with a range of doses of styrene-7,8-oxide (SO) and then toxicity and genotoxicity were monitored. Toxicity was determined by growth in flasks and genotoxicity by cloning in microplates in the presence/absence of 6-thioguanine, to detect mutations at the hypoxanthine phosphoribosyltransferase (hprt) locus. A SO concentration-dependent decrease in survival was observed for all cell lines, with GSTM1-deficient lines being more sensitive. The IC(50)s of deficient and proficient cell lines were 0.45 and 0.55 mM SO, respectively. The difference between survival of GSTM1-deficient and -proficient cell lines approached statistical significance. The background mutation frequency of GSTM1-deficient cell lines was 2 x 10(-5), and that of GSTM1-proficient cell lines was 3 x 10(-6). GSTM1-deficient cell lines were significantly more sensitive than GSTM1-proficient cell lines to mutation induction for concentrations up to 2.5 mM SO (P < 0.001, regression analysis). These results suggest that cell lines containing metabolically competent GSTM1 are able to efficiently use GSTM1 to conjugate SO and reduce its hazard. This supports the epidemiological evidence that GSTM1 influences sensitivity to chemical carcinogenesis and subsequent risk of cancer induction.

Use of transgenic mouse models for studying somatic mutations in aging

Theories on the causes of aging, based on the accumulation of somatic mutations in tissues of an organism, were formulated decades ago, but remain insufficiently tested. Transgenic animals, equipped with integrated bacterial reporter genes that can be efficiently rescued from total genomic DNA of all tissues and organs, represent ideal tools for investigating the types and frequencies of spontaneous mutants accumulating during aging. The first of such systems, based on the transgenic integration of bacteriophage lambda shuttle vectors that contain the bacterial lacZ gene as mutational target, was constructed in our laboratory and is now routinely used. Results obtained with this and the related LacI system that are relevant for the somatic mutation theory of aging will be discussed. One conclusion is that, due to the nature of the transgene, lambda-based systems have the disadvantage that deletion type mutations are underrepresented in comparison to point mutations. To overcome those limitations, we constructed a new transgenic mouse model carrying a pUR288 plasmid shuttle vector with the lacZ reporter gene. Some preliminary data obtained with this model serve to illustrate its potential use to extensively test the somatic mutation theory of aging.

An investigation of mutation as a function of age in humans

An accumulation of mutations on their own or together with other age-related changes may contribute to aging and the development of age-related pathologies. The aim of this investigation was to assess the extent of DNA mutations as a function of age in humans. The mutant frequency (MF) at the hypoxanthine-guanine phosphoribosyl-transferase (hgprt) locus was assessed in lymphocytes isolated from male volunteers in each of three age groups (35-39, 50-54 and 65-69 years). Results show that the mean MF in the 65-69 years group was approximately twice that in the 35-39 and 50-54 years groups (4.1/10(6) cells, 1.9/10(6) cells and 1.79/10(6) cells, respectively) increasing by about 1.33% per year, after 54 years. In addition, there was an increased frequency of chromosomal aberrations in the 65-69 years group compared to the other two age groups. The results of this investigation show an increase in DNA mutations in cultured human lymphocytes with age. Factors which may influence the extent of DNA damage in human lymphocytes are discussed.

Effects of lymphocyte subpopulations on the clonal assay of HPRT mutants: occupational exposure to cytostatic drugs

The mutagenic effect of occupational exposure to antineoplastic agents was studied in chemotherapy nurses and pharmacists using the T-lymphocyte clonal assay. A significant increase in mutant frequency was observed compared to controls. However, in the present study, cloning efficiency without selection (CEU) was significantly reduced in exposed personnel raising the possibility of an overestimation of the calculated MF. Changes in lymphocyte populations and clonal potential of T-cells were also observed following exposure. CEU was related to % CD4 cells but CE with selection (CETG) was not. Differences in clonal ability of T-cells under selective and unselective conditions coupled with differential lethal effect of antineoplastic agents on lymphocyte subsets may result in inaccurate estimation of MF.

An algorithm accounting for plating efficiency in estimating spontaneous mutation rates

An algorithm is described for calculating the probability distribution of the number of mutant colonies arising in a Luria-Delbrück fluctuation experiment subject to a plating efficiency of less than 100%. A table is constructed to facilitate the estimation of spontaneous mutation rates taking into account the plating efficiency.

An improved estimator of spontaneous mutation rates in Luria-Delbrück fluctuation experiments

In estimating the spontaneous mutation rate, mu, in cultured mammalian cells, the number of mutant cells in several parallel cultures, each a clone from a single cell, is determined. Luria and Delbrück (1943), and subsequently Lea and Coulson (1949), proposed several estimators of mu using data from such experiments. These methods of analysis were originally proposed to apply to mutants arising in microbial cultures, and some of the limitations in applying them to mammalian cell cultures have been outlined by Featherstone et al. (1987), and by Kendal and Frost (1988). For a given value of mu, the number of mutants, r, found in a culture is exceedingly variable, so that r contains very little information concerning mu. It is important, therefore, that an estimator of mu be efficient; that it not waste the limited information available in the experimental data. To this end, a new estimator is proposed which compounds the information previously utilized by the so-called P0 and median estimators. Using a spreadsheet program such as that available with MINITAB, the algorithm can be programmed in as few as 26 instructions. Tested against simulated data across a range of values of mu, the proposed compound estimator is more efficient than the currently used estimators.

Accounting for plating efficiency when estimating spontaneous mutation rates

When the spontaneous mutation rate mu in mammalian cell cultures is estimated using Luria-Delbrück fluctuation analysis, many factors contribute to the unreliability of the estimate. Some of these have been documented by Featherstone et al. (1987) and by Kendal and Frost (1988). In particular, the plating efficiencies for mammalian cells are often much less than 100%, and this can be taken into account. A derivation of a generalized P0 estimator, mg, based on the classical P0 estimator of Luria and Delbrück (1943) is offered. In an experiment involving C cultures, of which z exhibit no mutant colonies, and in which the plating efficiency is p, (0 < p < 1), the estimated mean number of mutations per culture is given by [formula: see text] The classical P0 estimator is shown to be the limiting case of mg as plating efficiency tends to 100%.

Effect of neonatal exposure to 5-bromo-2'-deoxyuridine on life span, estrus function and tumor development in rats--an argument in favor of the mutation theory of aging?

Outbred LIO rats were exposed to subcutaneous injections (3.2 mg) of a synthetic analogue of thymidine, 5-bromo-2'-deoxyuridine (BrdUrd), on days 1 and 3, or days 1, 3, 7 and 21 of postnatal life. The mean life span decreased by 31% and 38% in male and by 14% and 27% in female rats that received 2 and 4 injections of BrdUrd, respectively, in comparison to untreated controls. The opening of the vagina was delayed, whereas age-related changes in the length of the estrous cycle and in the incidence of persistent estrus and/or anestrus were observed earlier in BrdUrd-injected female rats than in untreated ones. Inhibition of compensatory ovarian hypertrophy induced by hemiovariectomy at the age of 3 months was found in females exposed neonatally to BrdUrd as compared to untreated rats, while the uterus weight increase induced by the administration of human chorionic gonadotropin was similar in both control and BrdUrd-treated infantile rats. These data suggest that exposure to BrdUrd in early life impairs pituitary gonadotropic function in female rats. It was also shown that neonatal administration of BrdUrd to rats doubles the incidence of chromosome aberrations in peripheral blood lymphocytes in comparison to controls and is followed by a dose-related increase in tumor incidence. Our observations on the decrease in mean and maximum life span, acceleration of age-related changes in reproductive system function, increase in chromosome aberration and tumor incidence and decrease in tumor latency in rats exposed to BrdUrd in early life suggest that this model could be used as a model of accelerated aging and that some of the results can be interpreted as arguments in favor of the mutation theory of aging.

Thioguanine-resistant mutant frequency in T-lymphocytes from a healthy human population

Resistance to 6-thioguanine in T-lymphocytes was used to study in vivo somatic mutations in normal healthy adults. Donor age had a significant effect on mutant frequency at the hprt locus, showing an increase of 0.09/10(6) cells per year of age. No significant increase was associated with sex of donor, smoking habits, alcohol or coffee/tea intake, or X-ray exposure. The lower mutant frequency seen with contraceptive pill usage was probably due to the age difference between the groups of users and non-users.

High somatic mutation frequencies in a LacZ transgene integrated on the mouse X-chromosome

To study spontaneous and induced mutagenesis in vivo we recently constructed a series of transgenic mice harboring different numbers of bacteriophage lambda shuttle vectors, provided with a LacZ mutational target gene, integrated in their genome. The transgenic mice enabled analysis of spontaneous and induced mutation frequencies in postmitotic tissues like liver and brain. The obtained data indicated spontaneous mutation frequencies in the order of 10(-5)-10(-6). Here we report a 25-100 times higher spontaneous mutation frequency in liver and brain DNA of mice from strain 35.5, with the lambda-gt10LacZ concatemer integrated on the X-chromosome. These results indicate the presence of a mutational 'hot spot' in the mammalian somatic genome in vivo.

Somatic mutations and cellular aging: two-dimensional DNA typing of rat fibroblast clones

Aging may be explained, to some extent, as a stochastic process of macromolecular damage. The rate of such a process should then determine longevity and be genetically controlled, as can be derived from the species specificity of maximum lifespan. The genome of the somatic cell is a major candidate to study for loss of DNA sequence integrity during aging. Unfortunately, a lack of adequate techniques has thus far hampered progress in testing the aging genome for changes in its DNA sequence content. Here we discuss recently developed sophisticated technology for studying spontaneous somatic mutations in relation to aging. More specifically, we describe the use of a novel two-dimensional DNA typing technique for the analysis of fibroblast clones derived from primary cultures established from skin biopsies of rats of different ages. Preliminary data are presented indicating the occurrence of DNA sequence changes in mini- and microsatellite regions of the rat genome at an average frequency of 2.7 x 10(-3) per analyzed DNA fragment. Age-related variations in the somatic mutation frequency of these genomic regions were not observed.

Nuclear medicine patients do not have higher mutant frequencies after exposure to thallium-201

The HPRT-lymphocyte clonal assay has been used to detect mutants induced in vivo in humans. This method has previously detected a rise in mutant frequency among nuclear medicine patients following exposure to technetium-99m, at a dose corresponding in theory to 5.1 mGy. In the present study, nuclear medicine patients were sampled before and after exposure to thallium-201, corresponding to a whole-body dose of 4.2 mGy. No rise in mutant frequency was found. We suggest that a difference in the effective dose received by the patients' lymphocytes accounts for the apparent contradiction with earlier results.

DNA damage metabolism and aging

As a result of permanent exposure to low levels of various endogenous and exogenous genotoxic agents, large numbers of lesions are continuously induced in the DNA of cells of living organisms. Such lesions could lead to dysfunction of cells and tissues, and they might well be the underlying cause of the age-related reduction of homeostatic capacity and the increased incidence of cancer and other diseases of old age. The rate of damage induction as well as the persistence of the lesions depends on the activity, efficiency and reliability of a wide variety of molecular defense systems. However, a certain degree of imperfection seems to be a general characteristic of most of these defense systems and this could lead to a gradual accumulation of DNA alterations during aging. Even when the original lesions are quickly removed, they can still lead to secondary changes in the DNA, such as DNA-sequence changes and changes in gene expression. This process would be accelerated in case of the occurrence of an age-related decline in the efficiency of these molecular defense systems. This review deals with the present knowledge on the occurrence of 'spontaneous' DNA damage in aging organisms, its potential sources, the influence of preventive and processive cellular defense mechanisms and its consequences in terms of DNA-sequence changes, DNA conformational and configurational changes and changes in gene expression. In general, it can be concluded from the data discussed here that, in spite of a number of discrepancies and conflicting results, an age-related accumulation of DNA alterations occurs at all levels, e.g., chemical structure, DNA-sequence organization and gene expression.

Efficient rescue of integrated shuttle vectors from transgenic mice: a model for studying mutations in vivo

To study gene mutations in different organs and tissues of an experimental animal, we produced transgenic mice harboring bacteriophage lambda shuttle vectors integrated in the genome in a head-to-tail arrangement. As a target for mutagenesis, the selectable bacterial lacZ gene was cloned in the vector. The integrated vectors were rescued from total genomic DNA with high efficiency by in vitro packaging and propagation of the phages in a LacZ- strain of Escherichia coli C. The background mutation frequencies in brain and liver DNA appeared to be low, as was indicated by the absence of colorless plaques among 138,816 and 168,160 phage isolated from brain and liver DNA, respectively. Treatment of adult female transgenic mice with N-ethyl-N-nitrosourea resulted in a dose-dependent increase of the frequency of mutated vectors isolated from brain DNA, up to 7.4 x 10(-5) at 250 mg of the alkylating agent per kilogram of body weight. At this dose, in liver DNA of the same mice, mutation frequencies were approximately 3 x 10(-5). DNA sequence analysis of four mutant vectors isolated from brain DNA indicated predominantly G.C----A.T transitions. These results demonstrate the value of this transgenic mouse model in studying gene mutations in vivo. In addition to its use in fundamental research, the system could be used as a sensitive, organ-specific, short-term mutagenicity assay.

4-Quinolone antibiotics: positive genotoxic screening tests despite an apparent lack of mutation induction

The effects of different 4-quinolone antibiotic derivatives (4-Qs) in a number of short-term tests commonly employed for the evaluation of genetic toxicity were studied. Incorporation of [3H]thymidine into mitogen-stimulated peripheral blood lymphocytes was strongly enhanced at a low concentration (1.56 micrograms/ml) for most of the tested 4-Qs, whereas DNA strand breakage in lymphoblastoid cells was evident only for ciprofloxacin (10 micrograms/ml and upwards), ofloxacin (80 micrograms/ml) and norfloxacin (160 micrograms/ml). Ciprofloxacin induced a significant amount of unscheduled DNA synthesis, but was found to be negative in a shuttle vector plasmid mutation test. Ciprofloxacin (80 micrograms/ml) did not inhibit enzymes involved in the early steps of pyrimidine biosynthesis. Cell growth was slightly depressed at a concentration of 20 micrograms/ml, becoming marked at 80 micrograms/ml. In conclusion, this study seeks to contribute to an improved evaluation of genotoxic screening test data, by focusing attention on the conflicting effects imposed by the 4-Qs on a battery of such tests.

Detection of 6-thioguanine resistance in human peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBL) of industrial workers and lung cancer patients

Human peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBL) were selected for 6-thioguanine (6-TG) resistance in short-term (42-h) cultures in 110 high-cancer-risk industrial workers, 131 primary lung cancer patients and 96 low-risk controls. The lymphocytes were cultured and stimulated by phytohemagglutinin (PHA). A labeling index (LI) was scored using light microscope autoradiography, based on the lymphocyte's ability to incorporate tritiated thymidine with or without selective agent 6-TG. The number of 6-TG-resistant cells increased in the high-occupational-cancer-risk group of vinyl chloride- and mixed organic industrial dust (MOID)-exposed workers as well as in the primary lung cancer patients. The results were compared with the low-occupational-cancer-risk groups and with samples taken from the 70 healthy individuals and 26 hospitalized, non-cancerous controls. In both risk-exposed groups the frequency of 6-TG-resistant lymphocytes was significantly higher (p less than 0.01) than in the controls. These results suggest that the original Strauss and Albertini (1977, 1979) method can be used to study qualitative risk assessment in carcinogen- or mutagen-exposed occupational groups.