Overlapping direct repeats stimulate deletions in specially designed derivatives of plasmid pBR325 in Escherichia coli

Genetic assays for measuring rates of (CAG).(CTG) repeat instability in Escherichia coli

Genetic selection assays were developed to measure rates of deletion of one or more (CAG).(CTG) repeats, or an entire repeat tract, in Escherichia coli. In-frame insertions of >or=25 repeats in the chloramphenicol acetyltransferase (CAT) gene of pBR325 resulted in a chloramphenicol-sensitive (Cm(s)) phenotype. When (CAG)25 comprised the leading template strand, deletion of one or more repeats resulted in a chloramphenicol resistant (Cm(r)) phenotype at a rate of 4 x 10(-2) revertants per cell per generation. The mutation rates for plasmids containing (CAG)43 or (CAG)79 decreased significantly. When (CTG)n comprised the leading template strand the Cm(r) mutation rates were 100-1000 lower than for the opposite orientation. As an initial application of this assay, the effects of mutations influencing mismatch repair and recombination were examined. The methyl directed mismatch repair system increased repeat stability only when (CTG)n comprised the leading template strand. Replication errors made with the opposite repeat orientation were apparently not recognized. For the (CAG)n leading strand orientation, mutation rates were reduced as much as 3000-fold in a recA- strain. In a second assay, out-of-frame mutation inserts underwent complete deletion at rates ranging from about 5 x 10(-9) to 1 x 10(-7) per cell per generation. These assays allow careful quantitation of triplet repeat instability in E. coli and provide a way to examine the effects of mutations in replication, repair, and recombination on repeat instability.

Stationary phase deletions in Escherichia coli. II. Mutations which stimulate stationary phase deletions in plasmid pMC874

Deletions in the plasmid pMC874 take place in resting cells incubating on McConkey's or minimal lactose agar and are time rather than generation dependent. These deletions join the km(r) promoter to a promoterless lac operon giving rise to Lac(+) papillae on McConkey's lactose agar, and can occur in the absence of sequence homologies such as direct or inverted repeats. Using this as a selective screen we isolated 31 mutants designated dli (for deletion increase), which enhanced to different extents the frequency of this unusual class of deletions. Six of these were characterized by phenotypic tests and their ability to stimulate other deletion events such as the excision of Tn10 from various chromosomal sites and the loss of cloned fragments between two EcoR1 sites in the gene for chloramphenicol resistance (cat) of plasmid pBR325. Two of them showed contrasting phenotypes and were studied further: one (dli1) stimulated Lac(+) deletions in pMC874 in resting cells but not Tn10 excision from chromosomal locations in log phase cells, and the other one (dli2) did exactly the reverse, i.e. it enhanced Tn10 excision but not Lac(+) deletion incidence. Mapping and complementation tests showed that dli1 is a null mutation in recC and was renamed recC2251. This is strong evidence that resting phase deletions in pMC874 are stimulated by the absence of a functional RecBCD enzyme. The dli2 mutation was identified by mapping and phenotypic tests as a mutation in uvrD, the gene for helicase II, and it was tentatively designated uvrD(-)dli2. These results show that (1) pMC874 is an excellent system to select mutants for genetic functions involved in the generation of resting phase deletions, and (2) there are at least two major deletion pathways in E. coli, one active in resting and the other in actively dividing cells.

Stationary phase deletions in Escherichia coli. I--Evidence for a new deletion pathway

Deletions in the plasmid pMC874 join the promoter of the km(r) (kanamycin resistance) gene coding for the enzyme aminoglycoside 3'-phosphotransferase to a promoterless lac operon downstream giving a phenotypic change from Lac(-)-->Lac(+). They differ from most deletions studied in Escherichia coli, which occur in actively dividing cells, in several important respects, as follows. (1) They occur in "resting" cells incubating on McConkey's or minimal lactose agar and increase in number gradually over a period of 1-2 weeks. Thus, like "adaptive" mutations, they are time rather than generation dependent. (2) They are extremely rare events (frequency 1x10(-11)-5x10(-11)) in wild type cells, but their frequency is increased between 1 and 2 orders of magnitude by null recC(-) mutations. In these respects they differ from "adaptive" mutations which are equally frequent in recC(+) and recC(-) cells. (3) Their frequency is not increased by mutations which stimulate log phase deletions. (4) Based on a computer search for homologies and sequencing of one deletion, it appears that they differ from log phase deletions in that they can occur in the absence of major terminal homologies (direct repeats) or intervening homologies (inverted repeats) which could stabilize a transient secondary structure and determine the deletion endpoints. Thus, they are not explained by the misaligned mutagenesis model. In conclusion, resting phase deletions occur through a totally different pathway from deletions in actively dividing cells and probably originate from unrepaired double strand breaks.

Evidence for two mechanisms of palindrome-stimulated deletion in Escherichia coli: single-strand annealing and replication slipped mispairing

Spontaneous deletion mutations often occur at short direct repeats that flank inverted repeat sequences. Inverted repeats may initiate genetic rearrangements by formation of hairpin secondary structures that block DNA polymerases or are processed by structure-specific endonucleases. We have investigated the ability of inverted repeat sequences to stimulate deletion of flanking direct repeats in Escherichia coli. Propensity for cruciform extrusion in duplex DNA correlated with stimulation of flanking deletion, which was partially sbcD dependent. We propose two mechanisms for palindrome-stimulated deletion, SbcCD dependent and SbcCD independent. The SbcCD-dependent mechanism is initiated by SbcCD cleavage of cruciforms in duplex DNA followed by RecA-independent single-strand annealing at the flanking direct repeats, generating a deletion. Analysis of deletion endpoints is consistent with this model. We propose that the SbcCD-independent pathway involves replication slipped mispairing, evoked from stalling at hairpin structures formed on the single-stranded lagging-strand template. The skew of SbcCD-independent deletion endpoints with respect to the direction of replication supports this hypothesis. Surprisingly, even in the absence of palindromes, SbcD affected the location of deletion endpoints, suggesting that SbcCD-mediated strand processing may also accompany deletion unassociated with secondary structures.

DNA-directed mutations. Leading and lagging strand specificity

The fidelity of replication has evolved to reproduce B-form DNA accurately, while allowing a low frequency of mutation. The fidelity of replication can be compromised, however, by defined order sequence DNA (dosDNA) that can adopt unusual or non B-DNA conformations. These alternative DNA conformations, including hairpins, cruciforms, triplex DNAs, and slipped-strand structures, may affect enzyme-template interactions that potentially lead to mutations. To analyze the effect of dosDNA elements on spontaneous mutagenesis, various mutational inserts containing inverted repeats or direct repeats were cloned in a plasmid containing a unidirectional origin of replication and a selectable marker for the mutation. This system allows for analysis of mutational events that are specific for the leading or lagging strands during DNA replication in Escherichia coli. Deletions between direct repeats, involving misalignment stabilized by DNA secondary structure, occurred preferentially on the lagging strand. Intermolecular strand switch events, correcting quasipalindromes to perfect inverted repeats, occurred preferentially during replication of the leading strand.

Primer-template misalignments during leading strand DNA synthesis account for the most frequent spontaneous mutations in a quasipalindromic region in Escherichia coli

Spontaneous mutant sequences which differ from the starting DNA sequence by the specific correction of quasipalindromic to perfect palindromic sequence are hallmarks of mutagenesis mediated by misalignments directed by palindromic complementarity. The mutant sequences are specifically predicted by templated, but ectopic, DNA polymerization on a misaligned DNA substrate. In a previous study, we characterized a spontaneous frameshift hotspot near a 17 bp quasipalindromic DNA sequence within the mutant chloramphenicol acetyl transferase (CAT) gene of plasmid pJT7. A one base-pair insertion hotspot, ectopically templated by misalignment mediated by palindromic complementarity, was shown to occur more frequently during synthesis of the leading than the lagging DNA strand. Here we analyze the misalignment mechanisms that can account for the DNA sequences of 123 additional spontaneous frameshift mutations (22 distinct genotypes) occurring in the same quasipalindromic DNA region in plasmids pJT7 and p7TJ (a pJT7 derivative with the CAT gene in the inverse orientation). Approximately 80% of the small frameshift mutants in each plasmid are predicted by palindromic misalignments of the leading strand. Smaller numbers of mutations are consistent with other DNA misalignments, including those predicted by simple slippage of the nascent DNA strand on its template. The results show that remarkable changes in the mutation spectra of a reporter gene may not be revealed by measurements of mutation frequency.

Stability of an inverted repeat in a human fibrosarcoma cell

Deletions and rearrangements of DNA sequences within the genome of human cells result in mutations associated with human disease. We have developed a selection system involving a neo gene containing a DNA sequence inserted into the NcoI site that can be used to quantitatively assay deletion of this sequence from the chromosome. The spontaneous deletion from the neo gene of a 122 bp inverted repeat occurred at a rate of 2.1 x 10(-8) to <3.1 x 10(-9) revertants/cell/generation in three different cell lines. Deletion of the 122 bp inverted repeat occurred between 6 bp flanking direct repeats. Spontaneous deletion of a 122 bp non-palindromic DNA sequence flanked by direct repeats was not observed, indicating a rate of deletion of <3.1 x 10(-9) revertants/cell/generation. This result demonstrates that a 122 bp inverted repeat can exhibit a low level of instability in some locations in the chromosome of a human cell line.

Deletion during recombination in bacteriophage T7

The ligase gene of bacteriophage T7 was interrupted with inserts made from synthetic DNA. A pair of inserts were designed so that each insert contained one copy of an identical 17 bp sequence (repeat) positioned such that intermolecular recombination between the 17 bp homologies on separate genomes could delete enough of the insert to produce a functional ligase gene. The frequency of deletion by intermolecular recombination was compared to deletion frequency when repeated copies of the identical 17 bp sequence were present on the same genome separated by 39 bp. When the 17 bp homologous sequences were on different genomes the formation of ligase positive phage was about 7% to 13% of the deletion frequency measured with both repeats on the same genome. A second set of inserts contained the same 17 bp sequence present in the first pair of inserts. The sequence of this second set of inserts was such that when both 17 bp repeats were present on the same genome there was no separation between the repeats. With the second set of inserts (no separation) deletion by intermolecular recombination was about two orders of magnitude higher than what was measured with the first set of inserts where 39 bp of nonhomologous sequence intervened between the 17 bp repeats and the normal T7 genome. These data are interpreted to suggest that in T7 misalignment between repeated sequences during intermolecular recombination may play a role in deletion mutagenesis.

Deletion between direct repeats in T7 DNA stimulated by double-strand breaks

An in vitro system based on extracts of Escherichia coli infected with bacteriophage T7 was used to study genetic deletions between directly repeated sequences. The frequency of deletion was highest under conditions in which the DNA was actively replicating. Deletion frequency increased markedly with the length of the direct repeat both in vitro and in vivo. When a T7 gene was interrupted by 93 bp of nonsense sequence flanked by 20-bp direct repeats, the region between the repeats was deleted in about 1 out of every 1,600 genomes during each round of replication. Very similar values were found for deletion frequency in vivo and in vitro. The deletion frequency was essentially unaffected by a recA mutation in the host. When a double-strand break was placed between the repeats, repair of this strand break was often accompanied by the deletion of the DNA between the direct repeats, suggesting that break rejoining could contribute to deletion during in vitro DNA replication.

Deletion between direct repeats in bacteriophage T7 gene 1.2

Deletion mutagenesis in bacteriophage T7 was studied with an insertion-reversion assay involving phage containing inserts of foreign DNA that form 10-bp direct repeats. The precise deletion of the insert restores the function of the non-essential gene and is easily assayed by growth on selection strains of E. coli. Similar inserts with unique direct repeats were placed in either gene 1.2 (dGTPase Inhibitor) or gene 1.3 (DNA ligase). The deletion rates of the inserts were quantified with Luria and Delbrück fluctuation tests. Deletion rates were similar for inserts in both genes indicating that the rates of deletion were not unique to either specific site, or the sequence of the direct repeats. Deletion was independent of functional T7 ligase at 37 degrees C, while an increase in the rate of deletion was noted in some ligase-deficient phage at 43 degrees C. The effect of E. coli DNA Polymerase I on deletion rate was tested and found to decrease deletion rate 60% with the polA1 mutation and 90% with the polA546ex mutation.

Double-strand breaks in plasmid DNA and the induction of deletions

Double-strand breaks (dsbs) have been produced in plasmid DNA by various restriction endonucleases and the survival and the deletion mutation incidence have been measured in E. coli. The deletion formation is known to depend upon the occurrence of short direct repeats within the DNA molecule. In order to study the role of these repeats we constructed plasmid molecules with repeats of various lengths or with a 10-base pair repeat at different distances from each other. Furthermore the influence of the location and the structure of the dsb was studied. Repair and deletion frequencies of the linearized plasmids were measured after transformation of E. coli. The yield of the specific deletion mutation (the one which occurs between the introduced repeats) increases nearly linearly with the square of the length of the repeat, while the yield of the correctly repaired DNA and the yield of all other deletion mutants remained constant. The slope of the linear increase of the yield of the specific deletion depends on the location and the structure of the dsb. The yield of the specific deletion mutation decreases with increasing distance between the repeats. A proposal for the rate-determining step of the deletion formation is made.

Multiple pathways of deletion formation in Escherichia coli

We are investigating the mechanisms for deletion formation through the use of mutants which alter deletion frequency together with well characterized systems for deletion detection. We report here on three mutations which were isolated for their ability to stimulate deletions in plasmid pMC874 (dli mutations). The mutation rec-2251 (formerly known as dli1) is a new allele of recBCD, a group of genes coding for the polypeptide components of the major recombination enzyme complex in E. coli; the second one, dli2 may be a new allele of uvrD, which codes for DNA helicase II; and the third one, dli3, has the phenotype of a mismatch repair mutation. Here we compare the effects of mutations in SOS-repair genes to those of the dli mutations on three different deletion events: (a) the deletion of short (60-100-bp) palindromic and non-palindromic inserts in derivatives of plasmid pBR325; (b) larger (600-800-bp) deletions in plasmid pMC874; and (c) the excision of the Tn10 transposon from chromosomal sites. Our results indicate that some form of SOS processing stimulates the loss of palindromes but not non-palindromes in plasmid pBR325 derivatives, and that RecA is necessary for UV-induced excision of Tn10 but this event is inhibited by UmuCD or its homolog MucAB. Each of the dli mutations showed unique effects on different classes of deletions. Mutation rec-2251 stimulated specifically deletions in pMC874 but had no effect on the deletion of non-palindromes in pBR325, and reduced the incidence of the other deletion events tested including loss of palindromic inserts in pBR325 as well as Tn10 excision. Mutation dli2, on the other hand, stimulated all deletions tested to varying extents, while dli3 did not affect markedly deletion formation in pBR325 plasmids but had a large stimulatory effect on both deletions in plasmid pMC874 and Tn10 excision. These results reveal that (a) some SOS-repair functions participate in deletion formation, (b) mutations selected for altering the incidence of one class of deletions may have totally different effects on other deletion events, and (c) the differences in mutant behavior may result in part from the ability of some pathways to discriminate among different deletion intermediates such as hairpins or cruciforms formed by palindromic sequences vs. transient secondary structures stabilized by direct repeats flanking non-palindromic sequences.

Participation of the SOS system in producing deletions in E. coli plasmids

The participation of the SOS response in the deletion of palindromic and non-palindromic inserts of about 66 and 100 bp cloned within the EcoR1 site of the chloramphenicol acetyl transferase (cat) gene of plasmid pBR325 was tested after introducing the derived plasmids into strains containing different combinations of lexA, recA and umuC alleles and the auxotrophic mutation trpE65. This allowed for a comparison of deletion frequency in the plasmids, measured as the reversion of chloramphenicol sensitivity to resistance (Cms-->Cmr), to point-mutation frequency measured from the reversion of trpE65 to tryptophan independence (Trp(-)-->Trp+). We found that the spontaneous deletion frequency of palindromic inserts was increased by the overproduction of activated RecA* and UmuC+ in lexA (Def) backgrounds but the deletion of the non-palindromic inserts was unaltered. Overproduction of RecA+ had no significant effect on deletion incidence but it did increase Trp(-)-->Trp+ reversions. The SOS stimulation of palindrome deletions paralleled the SOS mutator effect of certain recA and umuC alleles on Trp(-)-->Trp+ reversions, suggesting that some form of SOS processing was responsible for the observed increases. The results further suggest that the SOS effect on deletions depends on the distinction between palindromy vs. non-palindromy, rather than on the sizes or sequences of the inserts or those of the terminal homologies bracketing them.

Involvement of RecB-mediated (but not RecF-mediated) repair of DNA double-strand breaks in the γ-radiation production of long deletions in Escherichia coli

Experiments were designed to determine the association between the repair of gamma-radiation-induced DNA double-strand breaks (DSB) and the induction of 700-1000 bp long deletions (Lac(-)----Lac+), base substitutions (leuB19----Leu+), and frameshifts (trpE9777----Trp+) in Escherichia coli K-12. Over the range of 2.5-20 krad, deletions were induced with linear kinetics, as has been shown for the induction of DSB, while the induction kinetics of base substitutions and frameshifts were curvilinear. Like the repair of DSB, deletion induction showed an absolute requirement for an intact recB gene as well as a dependency on the type of preirradiation growth medium; these requirements were not seen for base substitutions or frameshifts. In addition, about 80% of the spontaneous deletions were absent in the recB21 strain. A recC1001 mutation, which confers a 'hyper-Rec' phenotype, increased the rate of gamma-radiation-induced deletions as well as the low-dose production of base substitutions and frameshifts. A recF143 mutation increased the yield of gamma-radiation-induced deletions without increasing base substitutions or frameshifts. A mutS mutation markedly enhanced the gamma-radiation induction of frameshifts, and had a slight effect on base substitutions, but did not affect the induction of deletions. Resistance to gamma-irradiation and the capacity to repair DSB (albeit at about half the normal rate) were restored to the radiosensitive recB21 strain by the addition of the sbcB21 and sbcC201 mutations. However, the radioresistant recB sbcBC strain, which is recombination proficient via the RecF pathway, was still grossly deficient in the ability to produce deletions. A model for deletion induction as a by-product of the recB-dependent (Chi-dependent) repair of gamma-radiation-induced DSB is discussed, as is the inability to detect deletions in cells that use only the recF-dependent (Chi-independent) mechanism to repair DSB.

An in vitro approach to identifying specificity determinants of mutagenesis mediated by DNA misalignments

In vitro, misalignments of the newly synthesized (primer) strand during DNA polymerization lead to deletion and/or complex frameshift mutations. In vivo, similar misalignments of repeated and quasipalindromic DNA sequences are predicted to be intermediates of mutagenesis. The mutagenic misalignments are mediated by complementary pairing between the sequence at the 3'-OH end of the newly synthesized DNA strand and sequences in the template or in the newly synthesized DNA. Mutant sequences are produced when the misaligned primers act as substrates for DNA polymerization. The misalignments responsible for detected mutant sequences were compared to similar misalignments that were not implicated in mutagenesis, and all misalignment possibilities were compared to the position of pausing during polymerization by Escherichia coli polymerase I or its Klenow fragment. These comparisons revealed three characteristics of in vitro misalignment specificity. First, the termini produced by pausing are likely to be precursors to mutagenic misalignments. Second, the absence of some potential misalignments from the detected spectrum is explained well by the predicted undetectability of the mutant sequences they produce. Third, factors distinct from pausing and mutant detectability are responsible for differences in the specificity of misalignment mutagenesis mediated by E. coli DNA polymerase I and Klenow polymerase during in vitro synthesis.

The effect of the length of direct repeats and the presence of palindromes on deletion between directly repeated DNA sequences in bacteriophage T7

The frequency of genetic deletion between directly repeated DNA sequences in bacteriophage T7 was measured as a function of the length of the direct repeat. The non-essential ligase gene (gene 1.3) of bacteriophage T7 was interrupted with pieces of synthetic DNA bracketed by direct repeats of various lengths. Deletion of these 76 bp long inserts was too low to be measured when the direct repeats were less than 6 bp long. However, the frequency of deletion of inserts with longer direct repeats increased exponentially as the length of the repeats increased from 8 to 20 bp. When inverted repeats (palindromes) were designed in the midst of the insert there was essentially no increase in deletion frequency between 10 bp direct repeats. But, the same palindromic sequences increased the deletion frequency between 5 bp direct repeats by at least two orders of magnitude. Thus, in this system homology at the endpoints is a more important determinant of deletion frequency than is the presence of palindromes between the direct repeats.

RecA-dependent increased precise excision of Tn10 in Salmonella typhimurium

UV irradiation induced the precise excision of Tn10 inserted in met, trp or srl in a Salmonella typhimurium strain; mitomycin C was also found to induce the frequency of precise excision of Tn10 from srl or met. Precise excision of Tn10 was not increased by either UV or mitomycin C in a recA mutant. Similarly, a recA mutant derived from a uvrD strain showed a drastic reduction in the high spontaneous levels of precise excision of Tn10 of this strain. These results indicate that recA is involved in the increased precise excision of Tn10. In contrast to point mutations excision of Tn10 was found to be UV inducible in a top mutant.

Deletion mutagenesis independent of recombination in bacteriophage T7

Deletion between directly repeated DNA sequences in bacteriophage T7-infected Escherichia coli was examined. The phage ligase gene was interrupted by insertion of synthetic DNA designed so that the inserts were bracketed by 10-bp direct repeats. Deletion between the direct repeats eliminated the insert and restored the ability of the phage to make its own ligase. The deletion frequency of inserts of 85 bp or less was of the order of 10(-6) deletions per replication. The deletion frequency dropped sharply in the range between 85 and 94 bp and then decreased at a much lower rate over the range from 94 to 900 bp. To see whether a deletion was predominantly caused by intermolecular recombination between the leftmost direct repeat on one chromosome and the rightmost direct repeat on a distinct chromosome, genetic markers were introduced to the left and right of the insert in the ligase gene. Short deletions of 29 bp and longer deletions of approximately 350 bp were examined in this way. Phage which underwent deletion between the direct repeats had the same frequency of recombination between the left and right flanking markers as was found in controls in which no deletion events took place. These data argue against intermolecular recombination between direct repeats as a major factor in deletion in T7-infected E. coli.