International Commission for Protection Against Environmental Mutagens and Carcinogens. Working paper no. 5. Impact of the molecular spectrum of mutational lesions on estimates of germinal gene-mutation rates

Unique amino acid signatures that are evolutionarily conserved distinguish simple-type, epidermal and hair keratins

Keratins (Ks) consist of central α-helical rod domains that are flanked by non-α-helical head and tail domains. The cellular abundance of keratins, coupled with their selective cell expression patterns, suggests that they diversified to fulfill tissue-specific functions although the primary structure differences between them have not been comprehensively compared. We analyzed keratin sequences from many species: K1, K2, K5, K9, K10, K14 were studied as representatives of epidermal keratins, and compared with K7, K8, K18, K19, K20 and K31, K35, K81, K85, K86, which represent simple-type (single-layered or glandular) epithelial and hair keratins, respectively. We show that keratin domains have striking differences in their amino acids. There are many cysteines in hair keratins but only a small number in epidermal keratins and rare or none in simple-type keratins. The heads and/or tails of epidermal keratins are glycine and phenylalanine rich but alanine poor, whereas parallel domains of hair keratins are abundant in prolines, and those of simple-type epithelial keratins are enriched in acidic and/or basic residues. The observed differences between simple-type, epidermal and hair keratins are highly conserved throughout evolution. Cysteines and histidines, which are infrequent keratin amino acids, are involved in de novo mutations that are markedly overrepresented in keratins. Hence, keratins have evolutionarily conserved and domain-selectively enriched amino acids including glycine and phenylalanine (epidermal), cysteine and proline (hair), and basic and acidic (simple-type epithelial), which reflect unique functions related to structural flexibility, rigidity and solubility, respectively. Our findings also support the importance of human keratin 'mutation hotspot' residues and their wild-type counterparts.

Modifiers of mutation-selection balance: general approach and the evolution of mutation rates

A general approach is developed to estimate secondary selection at a modifier locus that influences some feature of a population under mutation-selection balance. The approach is based on the assumption that the properties of all available genotypes at this locus are similar. Then mutation-selection balance and weak associations between genotype distributions at selectable loci and the modifier locus are established rapidly. In contrast, changes of frequencies of the modifier genotypes are slow, and lead to only slow and small changes of the other features of the population. Thus, while these changes occur, the population remains in a state of quasi-equilibrium, where the mutation-selection balance and the associations between the selectable loci and the modifier locus are almost invariant. Selection at the modifier locus can be estimated by calculating quasiequilibrium values of these associations. This approach is developed for the situation where distributions of the number of mutations per genome within the individuals with a given modifier genotype are close to Gaussian. The results are used to study the evolution of the mutation rate. Because beneficial mutations are ignored, secondary selection at the modifier locus always diminishes the mutation rate. The coefficient of selection against an allele which increases the mutation rate by υ is approximately υδ2/[U(2−ρ)] = υŝ, where υ is the genomic deleterious mutation rate, δ is the selection differential of the number of mutations per individual in units of the standard deviation of the distribution of this number in the population, ρ is the ratio of variances of the number of mutations after and before selection, and ŝ is the selection coefficient against a mutant allele in the quasiequilibrium population. However, the decline of the mutation rate can be counterbalanced by the cost of fidelity, which can lead to an evolutionary equilibrium mutation rate.

Molecular nature of 11 spontaneous de novo mutations in Drosophila melanogaster

To investigate the molecular nature and rate of spontaneous mutation in Drosophila melanogaster, we screened 887,000 individuals for de novo recessive loss-of-function mutations at eight loci that affect eye color. In total, 28 mutants were found in 16 independent events (13 singletons and three clusters). The molecular nature of the 13 events was analyzed. Coding exons of the locus were affected by insertions or deletions >100 nucleotides long (6 events), short frameshift insertions or deletions (4 events), and replacement nucleotide substitutions (1 event). In the case of 2 mutant alleles, coding regions were not affected. Because approximately 70% of spontaneous de novo loss-of-function mutations in Homo sapiens are due to nucleotide substitutions within coding regions, insertions and deletions appear to play a much larger role in spontaneous mutation in D. melanogaster than in H. sapiens. If so, the per nucleotide mutation rate in D. melanogaster may be lower than in H. sapiens, even if their per locus mutation rates are similar.

Evaluation of the database on mutant frequencies and DNA sequence alterations of vermilion mutations induced in germ cells of Drosophila shows the importance of a neutral mutation detection system

The vermilion gene in Drosophila has extensively been used for the molecular analysis of mutations induced by chemicals in germ cells in vivo. The gene is located on the X-chromosome and is a useful target for the study of mutagenesis since all types of mutations are generated. We have critically evaluated this system with respect to sensitivity for mutation induction and selectivity for different types of mutations, using a database of more than 600 vermilion mutants induced in postmeiotic male germ cells by 18 mutagens. From most of these mutants the mutation has been analysed. These data showed 336 base substitutions, 96 intra-locus DNA rearrangements and 78 multi-locus deletions (MLD). Mutants containing a MLD were either heterozygous sterile or homozygous and hemizygous lethal. The distribution of both basepair (bp) changes and intra-locus rearrangements over the coding region of the vermilion gene was uniform with no preferences concerning 5' or 3' regions, certain exons, splice sites, specific amino acid changes or nonsense mutations. Possible hotspots for base substitutions seem to be related to the type of DNA damage rather than to the vermilion system. Gene mutations other than bp changes were examined on sequence characteristics flanking the deletion breakpoints. Induction frequencies of vermilion mosaic mutants were, in general, higher than those of vermilion complete mutants, suggesting that persistent lesions are the main contributors to the molecular spectra. Comparison of induction frequencies of vermilion mutants and sex-linked recessive lethal (SLRL) mutants for the 18 mutagens showed that the sensitivity of the vermilion gene against a mutagenic insult is representative for genes located on the X-chromosome. The effect of nucleotide excision repair (NER) on the formation of SLRL mutants correlated with an increase of transversions in the vermilion spectra under NER deficient conditions. Furthermore, the clastogenic potency of the mutagens, i.e., the efficiency to induce chromosomal-losses vs. SLRL forward mutations, shows a positive correlation with the percentage of DNA deletions in the molecular spectra of vermilion mutants.

Significance of the perigametic interval as a major source of spontaneous mutations that result in mosaics

An earlier analysis showed that a significant percentage of spontaneous specific-locus mutations in mice are recovered as mosaics and that the spontaneous mutation rate per cell cycle is probably higher for those mutations that produce mosaics than for those that produce whole-body mutants. The finding that the average germline composition of the mosaics was approximately 50% supported the suggestion that single-strand DNA alterations during the perigametic interval constitute the major source of spontaneous mosaics. Here, alternative origins of 50% germline mosaicism are examined. Supporting the earlier hypothesis is the finding that spontaneous mutations that are recovered as clusters constitute a different array of types from those giving rise to singletons, and the evidence from interspecies comparisons that a unique component of the life cycle, probably meiosis, makes a major contribution to spontaneous mutations. Biological factors associated with the perigametic interval were examined in an effort to suggest explanations for the observations that 1) the spontaneous mutation rate in that interval is high relative to that characterizing any mitotic cell cycle, 2) the types of mutations appear to be different from those arising during mitotic divisions, and 3) the spontaneous mutation rate for males is higher than that for females. It is concluded that the higher yield from the perigametic interval is consistent with what is known about methylation status in development of both sexes and with repair capacity in the male germline. For both parameters, differences between the sexes during their respective perigametic intervals may be at least partly responsible for the fact that the spontaneous mutation rate of mammalian females is lower than that of males.

Development and utilization of the rat lymphocyte hprt mutation assay

Much of the recent progress in the field of genetic toxicology has come from an increased understanding of the molecular and cellular biology of the mammalian organism. Most prominent has been the ability to detect and quantify somatic mutation and relate the nature of the mutation to the specific type of chemical damage. Building upon the foundation of the human lymphocyte hypoxanthine guanine phosphoribosyl transferase (hprt) system, and later, the mouse hprt system, methods for the detection and quantification of hprt mutations in rat lymphocytes were developed. These methods are described in this report as is the ongoing validation of the assay. Additionally, the characterization of the recovered mutants and a comparison of the mutation spectrum in the rat lymphocyte system to the spectrum in cancer genes, such as H-ras and p53, and the spectrum in transgenic systems, such as lacI, are included. The development of the rat lymphocyte hprt system and validation of the assay at the molecular level, provide an effective and reliable measure of genetic damage in an in vivo system which is readily comparable to measurement of genetic damage in the human.

The natural somatic mutation frequency and human carcinogenesis

Much recent attention has been paid to the important role of the DNA mismatch repair system in controlling the accumulation of somatic mutations in human tissues and the association of mismatch repair deficiency with carcinogenesis. In the absence of an intact mismatch repair system, cells accumulate mutations at a rate some 1000 times faster than normal cells, and this mutator phenotype is easily measured by the detection of the formation of new variant alleles at microsatellite loci. However, the mismatch repair system is not 100% efficient, even when intact, and the pattern of microsatellite alterations in a wide variety of tumors is consistent with these being due to clonal amplification from tissues that are genetically heterogeneous at microsatellite loci rather than mismatch repair deficiency in the tumor itself. On this basis, it can be estimated that the mutation frequency of microsatellites in normal human tissues is approximately 10(-2) per locus per cell. Similarly, a frequency of mutation at minisatellite loci in normal tissues of around 10(-1) per locus per cell can be estimated. Such elevated levels of mutation are consistent with a recent study of the frequency of HPRT mutation in human kidneys that demonstrated these to be frequent (average 2.5 x 10(-4) in individuals of 70 years or more) and exponentially related to age. Taken as a whole, the data suggest that somatic mutation in human epithelial cells may be some 10-fold higher than in peripheral blood lymphocytes and that the underlying rate of spontaneous mutation is sufficient to account for a large proportion of human carcinogenesis without the need to evoke either stepwise alteration to a mutator phenotype of clonal expansion at all the mutation steps in carcinogenesis. The exponential increase in mutation frequency with age is predictable on the basis that the mutation rate is controlled at the level of repair and that mutation in genes that affect the efficiency of these processes will gradually increase the underlying rate. In addition, the age relatedness of mutation frequency strongly supports the concept that mutation is cell division dependent and that cellular proliferation per se is an important risk factor for cancer. Comparison of somatic mutations with those in the human germline mutation suggests common mechanistic origins and that the high levels of somatic mutation that occur are a direct reflection of the germline mutation rate selected over evolutionary time. Thus, the somatic accumulation of mutations can be seen as a natural process within the human body and cancer a normal part of the human life cycle. This point of view may explain why it has been so difficult to significantly reduce cancer incidence and suggests that, for this to be achieved, the means of altering the natural somatic mutation rate needs to be identified.

Spontaneous mutations recovered as mosaics in the mouse specific-locus test

The specific-locus test (SLT) detects new mutants among mice heterozygous for seven recessive visible markers. Spontaneous mutations can be manifested not only as singleton whole-body mutants in controls (for which we report new data), but as mosaics-either visible (manifesting mottled coat color) in the scored generation (G2) or masked, among the wild-type parental generation (G1). Masked G1 mosaics reveal themselves by producing clusters of whole-body mutants in G2. We provide evidence that most, if not all, mosaics detected in the SLT (both radiation and control progenies) result from a single-strand spontaneous mutation subsequent to the last premeiotic mitosis and before the first postmeiotic one of a parental genome-the "perigametic interval." Such events in the genomes of the G1 and Gzero results, respectively, in visible and masked 50:50 mosaics. Per cell cycle, the spontaneous mutation rate in the perigametic interval is much higher than that in pregamete mitotic divisions. A clearly different locus spectrum further supports the hypothesis of different origin, and casts further doubt on the validity of the doubling-dose risk-estimation method. Because mosaics cannot have arisen in mitotic germ cells, and are not induced by radiation exposure in the perigametic interval, they should not be included in calculations of radiation-induced germ-line mutation rates. For per-generation calculations, inclusion of mosaics yields a spontaneous frequency 1.7 times that calculated from singletons alone for mutations contributed by males; including both sexes, the multiple is 2.2.

Clusters of identical new mutation in the evolutionary landscape

In contrast to the common assumption that each new mutant results from a unique, independent mutation event, clusters of identical premeiotic mutant alleles are common. Clusters can produce large numbers of related individuals carrying identical copies of the same new genetic change. By entering the gene pool in multiple copies at one time, clusters can influence fundamental processes of population genetics. Here we report evidence that clusters can increase the arrival and fixation probabilities and can lengthen the average time to extinction of new mutations. We also suggest it may be necessary to reconsider other fundamental elements of population genetic theory.

Spontaneous and X-ray-induced deletion mutations in a LacZ plasmid-based transgenic mouse model

Transgenic mouse mutation models carrying bacterial marker genes in bacteriophage lambda shuttle vectors have been applied to study spontaneous or induced mutations in vivo. However, due to the nature of the shuttle vector these models are insensitive to large deletions. Clastogenic agents, which predominantly induce large deletions, were therefore found to yield very low responses in these assays. Here we report the use of LacZ plasmid-based transgenic mice, allowing the detection of a broad spectrum of mutations. Treatment of mice with X-rays (5 x 50 rads) resulted in induction of up to about 5-fold higher mutation frequencies in lung, spleen and liver. Analysis of spontaneous and induced mutant LacZ genes indicated that at least 40-50% of all mutations were caused by deletions. The possibility of detecting a broad spectrum of mutations with this system suggests that the LacZ plasmid-based transgenic mouse may be the mammalian model of choice for studying spontaneous and induced mutations in vivo.

Biological basis of germline mutation: comparisons of spontaneous germline mutation rates among drosophila, mouse, and human

Spontaneous mutation rates per generation are similar among the three species considered here--Drosophila, mouse, and human--and are not related to time, as is often assumed. Spontaneous germline mutation rates per generation averaged among loci are less variable among species than they are among loci and tests and between gender. Mutation rates are highly variable over time in diverse lineages. Recent estimates of the number of germ cell divisions per generation are: for humans, 401 (30-year generation) in males and 31 in females; for mice, 62 (9-month generation) in males and 25 in females; and for Drosophila melanogaster, 35.5 (18-day generation) in males and 36.5 (25-day generation) in females. The relationships between germ cell division estimates of the two sexes in the three species closely reflect those between mutation rates in the sexes, although mutation rates per cell division vary among species. Whereas the overall rate per generation is constant among species, this consistency must be achieved by diverse mechanisms. Modifiers of mutation rates, on which selection might act, include germline characteristics that contribute disproportionately to the total mutation rates. The germline mutation rates between the sexes within a species are largely influenced by germ cell divisions per generation. Also, a large portion of the total mutations occur during the interval between the beginning of meiosis and differentiation of the soma from the germline. Significant genetic events contributing to mutations during this time may include meiosis, lack of DNA repair in sperm cells, methylation of CpG dinucleotides in mammalian sperm and early embryo, gonomeric fertilization, and rapid cleavage divisions.

Mutagenesis and human genetic disease: dominant mutation frequencies and a characterization of mutational events in mice and humans

Dominant deleterious traits are generally regarded to be the most relevant genetic endpoints when the expected increased mutational load of genetic diseases associated with exposure to mutagenic agents is considered in humans. At present, human risk estimation procedures rely on results from laboratory mammal germ-cell mutagenicity experiments as well as on data from human epidemiology and medical genetics. A comparison of the mouse and human data indicates that a small subset of loci, which when mutated result in a dominant phenotype, is contributing disproportionately to the observed mutation frequency. This is likely due to the fact that those loci with an observed high mutation frequency are inherently unstable, the function of such loci is critical, and/or the wild-type phenotype requires two copies of the normal gene (haploinsufficiency). The locus specificity of the observed spontaneous and induced mutation frequencies implies that efforts must be made to closely match those genetic endpoints screened in the mouse with the human genetic endpoints considered relevant in estimating the genetic risk after exposure to mutagenic agents. The contributions to our understanding of the organization, function, and stability of the mouse and human genomes provided by molecular biological techniques should make compliance with this restriction feasible.

Mosaicism: the embryo as a target for induction of mutations leading to cancer and genetic disease

Mosaicism, the existence of "patches" of cells with a genetic constitution that differs from that of other cells of an organism, has been observed in both germinal and somatic tissues of several species, including humans. Mutational events occurring during early embryogenesis can give rise to an organism with a significant number of cells with the mutant genotype in one or more tissues. If this event occurs in a precursor of the germ cells, the mutation can be transferred to subsequent generations. In the F1 generation, this event will usually be perceived as a de novo germinal mutation rather than a transmitted variant allele, unless significant effort is directed toward detecting the mosaicism. Similarly, mutations in oncogenes and tumor-suppressor genes in proliferating somatic cells can generate populations of cells that are at increased risk of transforming into tumor cells. The number of potential preneoplastic cells is larger when the mutagenic event occurs in early development than if it occurs in the mature adult. Experimental data confirm that treatment of the developing embryo or fetus with carcinogenic and mutagenic agents increases the cancer incidence in these animals and the frequency of mutations in the offspring of the animals that were exposed in utero. The available data are conclusive that the developing organism is at risk from exposure to mutagenic and carcinogenic agents. However, the data are insufficient to estimate the level of risk associated with exposures in utero, relative to either the background (spontaneous) level of risk or risk associated with similar exposures to the adult organism.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

International Commission for Protection Against Environmental Mutagens and Carcinogens. Working paper no. 6. Estimation of genetic risks of exposure to chemical mutagens: relevance of data on spontaneous mutations and of experience with ionizing radiation

This paper examines the impact of advances in knowledge on the molecular biology of human Mendelian diseases on the estimation of genetic risks of exposure to ionizing radiation and to chemical mutagens. More specifically, it addresses the question of whether and to what extent naturally occurring Mendelian diseases can be used as a baseline for efforts in this area. Data on the molecular nature and mechanisms of origin of spontaneous mutations underlying naturally occurring Mendelian diseases and on radiation-induced mutations in experimental systems suggest that for ionizing radiation, naturally occurring Mendelian diseases may not constitute an entirely adequate frame of reference and that current risk estimates for this class of diseases are conservative; these estimates however provide a margin of safety in formulating radiation protection guidelines. Currently available data on mechanisms and specificities of action of chemical mutagens, molecular dosimetry, repair of chemically induced adducts in the DNA, adduct-mutation relationships etc., permit the tentative conclusion that naturally occurring Mendelian diseases may provide a better baseline for genetic risk estimation for chemical mutagens than for ionizing radiation. With both ionizing radiation and chemical mutagens, the question of which Mendelian diseases are potentially inducible will become answerable in the near future when more molecular data on human genetic diseases become available. It is therefore essential that risk estimators keep abreast of advances in human genetics and integrate these into their conceptual framework. However, induced Mendelian diseases (especially the dominant ones which are of more immediate concern) are likely to represent a very small fraction of the adverse genetic effects of induced mutations. More attention therefore needs to be devoted to studies on the heterozygous effects of induced mutations.