Flicker detection in the albino rat following light-induced retinal damage

Rat superior colliculus encodes the transition between static and dynamic vision modes

The visual continuity illusion involves a shift in visual perception from static to dynamic vision modes when the stimuli arrive at high temporal frequency, and is critical for recognizing objects moving in the environment. However, how this illusion is encoded across the visual pathway remains poorly understood, with disparate frequency thresholds at retinal, cortical, and behavioural levels suggesting the involvement of other brain areas. Here, we employ a multimodal approach encompassing behaviour, whole-brain functional MRI, and electrophysiological measurements, for investigating the encoding of the continuity illusion in rats. Behavioural experiments report a frequency threshold of 18±2 Hz. Functional MRI reveal that superior colliculus signals transition from positive to negative at the behaviourally-driven threshold, unlike thalamic and cortical areas. Electrophysiological recordings indicate that these transitions are underpinned by neural activation/suppression. Lesions in the primary visual cortex reveal this effect to be intrinsic to the superior colliculus (under a cortical gain effect). Our findings highlight the superior colliculus' crucial involvement in encoding temporal frequency shifts, especially the change from static to dynamic vision modes.

A multimodal approach connecting cortical and behavioural responses to the visual continuity illusion

In their recently published study, Gil, Valente and Shemesh combined behaviour, functional magnetic resonance imaging, electroencephalography and causal interventions to establish and validate a cortical processing substrate underlying the transition from static to dynamic visual states in the rat. Their research highlights the superior colliculus as the primary mediator of visual temporal discrimination by showing a direct correlation between behavioural and cortically derived flicker fusion frequency thresholds. This work provides the first empirical evidence addressing the previously established disparity between behavioural and cortically derived flicker fusion frequency thresholds. It demonstrates how important convergent multimodal approaches are to mapping and validating previously disputed cortical pathways. Here, we discuss and evaluate their work, suggesting possible future applications in the field of behavioural neuroscience.

ERG and Behavioral CFF in Light-Damaged Albino Rats

The full-field ERG is useful for index rod- or cone-mediated retinal function in rodent models of retinal degeneration. However, the relationship between the ERG response amplitudes and visually guided behavior, such as flicker detection, is not well understood. A comparison of ERG to behavioral responses in a light-damage model of retinal degeneration allows us to better understand the functional implications of electrophysiological changes. Flicker-ERG and behavioral responses to flicker were used to determine critical flicker frequency (CFF) under scotopic and photopic conditions before and up to 90 d after a 10-day period of low-intensity light damage. Dark- and light-adapted ERG flash responses were significantly reduced after light damage. The a-wave was permanently reduced, while the b-wave amplitude recovered over three weeks after light damage. There was a small, but significant dip in scotopic ERG CFF. Photopic behavioral CFF was slightly lower following light damage. The recovery of the b-wave amplitude and flicker sensitivity demonstrates the plasticity of retinal circuits following photopic injury.

Unsupervised experience with temporal continuity of the visual environment is causally involved in the development of V1 complex cells

Unsupervised adaptation to the spatiotemporal statistics of visual experience is a key computational principle that has long been assumed to govern postnatal development of visual cortical tuning, including orientation selectivity of simple cells and position tolerance of complex cells in primary visual cortex (V1). Yet, causal empirical evidence supporting this hypothesis is scant. Here, we show that degrading the temporal continuity of visual experience during early postnatal life leads to a sizable reduction of the number of complex cells and to an impairment of their functional properties while fully sparing the development of simple cells. This causally implicates adaptation to the temporal structure of the visual input in the development of transformation tolerance but not of shape tuning, thus tightly constraining computational models of unsupervised cortical learning.

Divergent Solutions to Visual Problem Solving across Mammalian Species

Our understanding of the neurobiological underpinnings of learning and behavior relies on the use of invasive techniques, which necessitate the use of animal models. However, when different species learn the same task, to what degree are they actually producing the same behavior and engaging homologous neural circuitry? This question has received virtually no recent attention, even as the most powerful new methodologies for measuring and perturbing the nervous system have become increasingly dependent on the use of murine species. Here, we test humans, rats, monkeys, and an evolutionarily intermediate species, tree shrews, on a three alternative, forced choice, visual contrast discrimination task. As anticipated, learning rate, peak performance, and transfer across contrasts was lower in the rat compared to the other species. More interestingly, rats exhibited two major behavioral peculiarities: while monkeys and tree shrews based their choices largely on visual information, rats tended to base their choices on past reward history. Furthermore, as the task became more difficult, rats largely disengaged from the visual stimulus, reverting to innate spatial predispositions in order to collect rewards near chance probability. Our findings highlight the limitation of muridae as models for translational research, at least in the area of visually based decision making.

Retino-cortical stimulus frequency-dependent gamma coupling: evidence and functional implications of oscillatory potentials

Long‐range gamma band EEG oscillations mediate information transmission between distant brain regions. Gamma band‐based coupling may not be restricted to cortex‐to‐cortex communication but may include extracortical parts of the visual system. The retinogram and visual event‐related evoked potentials exhibit time‐locked, forward propagating oscillations that are candidates of gamma oscillatory coupling between the retina and the visual cortex. In this study, we tested if this gamma coupling is present as indicated by the coherence of gamma‐range (70–200 Hz) oscillatory potentials (OPs) recorded simultaneously from the retina and the primary visual cortex in freely moving, adult rats. We found significant retino‐cortical OP coherence in a wide range of stimulus duration (0.01–1000 msec), stimulus intensity (800–5000 mcd/mm²), interstimulus interval (10–400 msec), and stimulus frequency (0.25–25 Hz). However, at low stimulus frequencies, the OPs were time‐locked, flickering light at 25 Hz entrained continuous OP coherence (steady‐state response, SSR). Our results suggest that the retina and the visual cortex exhibit oscillatory coupling at high‐gamma frequency with precise time locking and synchronization of information transfer from the retina to the visual cortex, similar to cortico‐cortical gamma coupling. The temporal fusion of retino‐cortical gamma coherence at stimulus rates of theater movies may explain the mechanism of the visual illusion of continuity. How visual perception depends on early transformations of ascending sensory information is incompletely understood. By simultaneous measurement of flash‐evoked potentials in the retina and the visual cortex in awake, freely moving rats, we demonstrate for the first time that time‐locked gamma oscillatory potentials exhibit stable retino‐cortical synchrony across a wide range of stimulus parameters and that the temporal continuity of coherence changes with stimulus frequency according to the expected change in the visual illusion of continuity.

Potential biological and ecological effects of flickering artificial light

Organisms have evolved under stable natural lighting regimes, employing cues from these to govern key ecological processes. However, the extent and density of artificial lighting within the environment has increased recently, causing widespread alteration of these regimes. Indeed, night-time electric lighting is known significantly to disrupt phenology, behaviour, and reproductive success, and thence community composition and ecosystem functioning. Until now, most attention has focussed on effects of the occurrence, timing, and spectral composition of artificial lighting. Little considered is that many types of lamp do not produce a constant stream of light but a series of pulses. This flickering light has been shown to have detrimental effects in humans and other species. Whether a species is likely to be affected will largely be determined by its visual temporal resolution, measured as the critical fusion frequency. That is the frequency at which a series of light pulses are perceived as a constant stream. Here we use the largest collation to date of critical fusion frequencies, across a broad range of taxa, to demonstrate that a significant proportion of species can detect such flicker in widely used lamps. Flickering artificial light thus has marked potential to produce ecological effects that have not previously been considered.

Metabolic rate and body size are linked with perception of temporal information

Body size and metabolic rate both fundamentally constrain how species interact with their environment, and hence ultimately affect their niche. While many mechanisms leading to these constraints have been explored, their effects on the resolution at which temporal information is perceived have been largely overlooked. The visual system acts as a gateway to the dynamic environment and the relative resolution at which organisms are able to acquire and process visual information is likely to restrict their ability to interact with events around them. As both smaller size and higher metabolic rates should facilitate rapid behavioural responses, we hypothesized that these traits would favour perception of temporal change over finer timescales. Using critical flicker fusion frequency, the lowest frequency of flashing at which a flickering light source is perceived as constant, as a measure of the maximum rate of temporal information processing in the visual system, we carried out a phylogenetic comparative analysis of a wide range of vertebrates that supported this hypothesis. Our results have implications for the evolution of signalling systems and predator–prey interactions, and, combined with the strong influence that both body mass and metabolism have on a species' ecological niche, suggest that time perception may constitute an important and overlooked dimension of niche differentiation.

•

Animals vary in their ability to perceive changes in their environment visually.

•

Temporal perception can be quantified using critical flicker fusion (CFF).

•

High CFF indicates an ability to perceive rapid changes in the visual field.

•

We show that high metabolism and small body size are associated with high CFF.

•

We argue that these findings have both ecological and evolutionary implications.

The susceptibility of the retina to photochemical damage from visible light

The photoreceptor/RPE complex must maintain a delicate balance between maximizing the absorption of photons for vision and retinal image quality while simultaneously minimizing the risk of photodamage when exposed to bright light. We review the recent discovery of two new effects of light exposure on the photoreceptor/RPE complex in the context of current thinking about the causes of retinal phototoxicity. These effects are autofluorescence photobleaching in which exposure to bright light reduces lipofuscin autofluorescence and, at higher light levels, RPE disruption in which the pattern of autofluorescence is permanently altered following light exposure. Both effects occur following exposure to visible light at irradiances that were previously thought to be safe. Photopigment, retinoids involved in the visual cycle, and bisretinoids in lipofuscin have been implicated as possible photosensitizers for photochemical damage. The mechanism of RPE disruption may follow either of these paths. On the other hand, autofluorescence photobleaching is likely an indicator of photooxidation of lipofuscin. The permanent changes inherent in RPE disruption might require modification of the light safety standards. AF photobleaching recovers after several hours although the mechanisms by which this occurs are not yet clear. Understanding the mechanisms of phototoxicity is all the more important given the potential for increased susceptibility in the presence of ocular diseases that affect either the visual cycle and/or lipofuscin accumulation. In addition, knowledge of photochemical mechanisms can improve our understanding of some disease processes that may be influenced by light exposure, such as some forms of Leber's congenital amaurosis, and aid in the development of new therapies. Such treatment prior to intentional light exposures, as in ophthalmic examinations or surgeries, could provide an effective preventative strategy.

Short-term (2 to 5 h) dark exposure lowers long-term potentiation (LTP) induction threshold in rat primary visual cortex

Up- and down-regulation of synaptic strength (i.e., long-term potentiation, LTP, long-term depression) is thought to be the primary mechanism mediating experience-dependent plasticity of cortical networks. Recent evidence indicates that the expression of plastic changes at synapses itself is dynamic and regulated, at least in part, by the recent history of synaptic activity, a concept termed metaplasticity. Here, adult, urethane-anesthetized rats were exposed to light or dark conditions for various durations (1, 2, and 5 h) to influence activity levels in the retinal-dorsal lateral geniculate nucleus (dLGN)-primary visual cortex (V1) pathway. Field potentials, recorded in layer IV of V1, were evoked by light flashes to the retina or single pulse electrical stimulation of the dLGN. Brief (60 s) periods of high frequency (50 Hz) retinal light stimulation results in an increase in visual evoked potential (VEP) amplitude in animals exposed to complete darkness for 2 h, while VEP amplitude failed to show potentiation in animals maintained in darkness for shorter periods. Similarly, weak theta burst stimulation of the dLGN failed to induce LTP in animals maintained under continuous light, but elicited robust LTP after 5 h of dark exposure. These data demonstrate that induction thresholds for sensory- and electrically-induced LTP in the retino-geniculo-cortical pathway of adult rats are dynamically regulated by levels of preceding sensory stimulation. Importantly, such metaplastic adjustments of plasticity in V1 can occur over time-scales significantly shorter than previously recognized.

Rod and cone function in coneless mice

Transgenic coneless mice were initially developed to study retinal function in the absence of cones. In coneless mice created by expressing an attenuated diphtheria toxin under the control of flanking sequences from the human L-cone opsin gene, a small number of cones (3-5% of the normal complement) survive in a retina that otherwise appears structurally quite normal. These cones predominantly ( approximately 87% of the total) contain UV-sensitive photopigment. ERG recordings, photoreceptor labeling, and behavioral measurements were conducted on coneless and wild-type mice to better understand how the nature of this alteration in receptor complement impacts vision. Signals from the small residual population of UV cones are readily detected in the flicker ERG where they yield signal amplitudes at saturation that are roughly proportional to the number of surviving cones. Behavioral measurements show that rod-based vision in coneless mice does not differ significantly from that of wild-type mice, nor does their rod system show any evidence of age-related deterioration. Coneless mice are able to make accurate rod-based visual discriminations at light levels well in excess of those required to reach cone threshold in wild-type mice.

The visual input stage of the mammalian circadian pacemaking system: II. The effect of light and drugs on retinal function

Acute light pulses as well as long-term light exposure may not only modulate photoreceptive properties, but also induce reversible or irreversible damage to the retina, depending on exposure conditions. Illuminance levels in laboratory animal colonies and manipulations of lighting regimens in circadian rhythm research can threaten retinal structure and physiology, and may therefore modify zeitgeber input to the central circadian system. Given the opportunity to escape light at any time, the nocturnal rat self-selects a seasonally varying "naturalistic skeleton photoperiod" that protects the eyes from potential damage by nonphysiological light exposures. Both rod rod-segment disk shedding and behavioral circadian phase shifts are elicited by low levels of twilight stimulation. From this vantage point, we hypothesize that certain basic properties of circadian rhythms (e.g., Aschoff's rule and splitting) may reflect modulation of retinal physiology by light. Pharmacological manipulations with or without the addition of lighting strategies have been used to analyze the neurochemistry of circadian timekeeping. Drug modulation of light input at the level of the retina may add to or interact with direct drug modulation of the central circadian pacemaking system.

Behavioral determination of critical flicker fusion in dogs

Steady-state critical flicker-fusion frequencies (CFFs) were determined for four beagle dogs using the psychophysical technique of conditioned suppression. The CFFs obtained demonstrated that the dog can discriminate flicker at much faster rates than has been suggested by ERG data. In addition, dog rods may support the discrimination of flicker at much higher rates than can human rods. An indication of a psychophysical rod-cone break occurred at a luminance level intermediate to those previously reported in ERG CFF studies. This level is similar to that in the cat, but much higher than that in man. The high CFFs provide the first psychophysical evidence of a well-developed functioning cone system in the dog.

Morphology and time-course of defined photochemical lesions in the rabbit retina

The present study demonstrates an experimental set-up to study light injury with defined parameters including retinal irradiance levels and spectral composition of the damaging light. The time-course of acute morphological changes at constant light intensity and increasing exposure durations (from 5-30 minutes) was evaluated, the wavelength of the damaging light being 400-550 nm. Pigment epithelial lesions appeared already after 5 minutes, and rod outer segment membrane disruptions after 15-20 minutes of light exposure. Striking was the observation of disruption and vesiculation of disk membranes at the base of rod outer segments. This "clear zone" was consistently observed beginning after twenty minutes of light exposure. The comparison of morphological changes in pigmented and albinotic eyes revealed no essential differences. This result confirms the observations of other laboratories that pigment epithelial melanin neither protects against nor promotes light damage to a significant extent. Long-term changes after light exposure revealed pigment epithelial lesions and rod outer segment disruptions, followed by macrophage invasion and pigment epithelial proliferation with subsequent loss of photoreceptor cells.